M/S RAJASTHAN PATRIKA PVT LTD vs STATE AND ANR
- Court
- Rajasthan High Court
[2026:RJ-JP:40230]
HIGH Court OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous (Petition) No. 1537/2005
CNR: RJHC020210432005 | URN: CRLMP / 2860U / 2005
1. M/s Rajasthan Patrika Pvt Ltd, Itrana Road, Industrial Area,
Alwar, Dist. Alwar
2. Gulab Kothari, Editor, Rajasthan Patrika Pvt. Ltd, Kesargarh,
Jaipur
3. Milap Kothari, Advisor, Rajasthan Patrika Pvt. Ltd, Kesargarh,
Jaipur (Deleted)
----Petitioners
Versus
1. The State of Rajasthan, through PP
2. Kailash Chand son of Ganesh Lal adopted son of Kanhaiyaa
Lal, resident of Laxmangarh, Tehsil Laxmangarh, Dist. Alwar
----Respondents
For Petitioner : Mr. V.R. Bajwa, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Savita Nathawat,
Mr. Mahesh Vijay and
Mr. Manish K. Sharma
For Respondent
For Complainant
:
:
Mr. Vijay Singh Yadav, PP
Mr. Ram Babu Sharma
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK KUMAR JAIN
Order
REPORTABLE
01/10/2026
1. The instant criminal miscellaneous petition has been
preferred under Section 482 of CrPC by the petitioners aggrieved
from order dated 11th November 2005 in Criminal Revision
No.86/2004 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Lakshmangarh, District Alwar, whereby the revisional Court has
affirmed the order of cognizance dated 7th April 2004 in criminal
complaint case No. 7/2003 passed by learned Additional Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Lakshmangarh, District Alwar, wherein an order
of cognizance has been passed against ten accused, including
present petitioners under Sections 500, 501 and 502 of IPC.
2. During pendency of miscellaneous petition, petitioner No.3-
Milap Kothari has expired, thus his name has been deleted on 1st
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(2 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
September 2021. Now we are considering this petition on behalf of
petitioners No.1 and 2.
3. Learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the
petitioners would submitted that non-petitioner No. 2 has filed a
criminal complaint on 21st August 2003 against ten persons
alleging inter alia that he is a lawyer and practicing at Laxmangarh
and the accused, who were annoyed and having animosity due to
his success in advocacy, has distributed pamphlets and organised a
demonstration with intent to injure his reputation. He also
submitted that on basis of distribution of pamphlet and said
incident, the complaint has been filed wherein clearly mentioned
that the pamphlets were distributed by other accused persons and
same was printed at Surya Printers but present petitioners have no
role in said incident of demonstration and distribution of
pamphlets. He further submitted that making allegation in para
No. 9 of complaint that the accused Nos.1 to 4 with intent to
circulate the details mentioned in the pamphlets have published a
news article with intention to injure and cause damage the
reputation of complainant. He submitted that in the entire
complaint nowhere it has been mentioned that how these
petitioners have played any role in publication and distribution of
pamphlets, as the petitioners have nothing to do with any of the
acts committed by other accused and also with the Surya printing
press, which published the pamphlets. He also submitted that in
the entire complaint nowhere any kind of specific role and
involvement of these petitioners were mentioned and further, after
registration of complaint in the statements under Section 200 and
202 of CrPC nowhere it has been mentioned that any of the
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(3 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
petitioners have any role in printing, drafting or intentional
publication in the news article. He also referred the statement of
complainant recorded under Section 200 of CrPC and submitted
that as per complainant, a loudspeaker was engaged by other
accused in distribution of the pamphlets. He also submitted that
there were sloganeering by some of the individuals and people
have also gathered wherein speeches were made, but none of
them have any proximity with petitioners. He also submitted that
the evidence of complainant clearly suggest that it was a local
incident which has actually occurred and explained by complainant
and his witnesses, but have nothing to do with present petitioners.
4. Learned Senior Advocate would further submitted that the
local correspondent who were not on regular role of petitioner No.1
has sent a news article and the newspaper has published the same
without any interpolation in the news. He also submitted that the
complainant has alleged that there was a conspiracy but there is
no evidence about meeting of minds between the petitioners and
other accused who have acted against the complainant. He further
referred the publication dated 7th April 2004 in another newspaper
Dainik Bhaskar and submitted that on basis of said news article,
the news published in newspaper owned by the petitioner No.1
cannot be termed as false or malicious campaign published with
intent to defame the complainant. He also submitted that the
complainant has failed to mention the essential ingredient of the
offence either in his complaint or in his evidence, and once the
ingredients are not available then the order passed by the trial
Court is contrary to the records. He also submitted that neither of
the petitioner belong to local area Laxmangarh or District Alwar
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(4 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
nor other accused No. 5 to 10 have any connection with these
petitioners. He also referred the news article and submitted that
even accused No. 5 Subhash Tiwari was a private correspondent
and he is working in capacity of independent correspondent. He
also submitted that neither is there evidence of conspiracy nor of
abetment, therefore, the petitioners cannot held responsible for
any of the act as mentioned in the complaint filed by the
complainant.
5. Learned Senior Advocate has further referred the order of
cognizance dated 7th April 2004 passed by the trial Court and
submitted that the cognizance has been taken on the basis of
publication of pamphlets, announcement on loudspeakers (Public
address system), which were made to injure and cause harm to
the reputation of the complainant. He also submitted that how the
news article has damaged the reputation of complainant was
neither discussed by the trial Court nor same is basis of order of
cognizance. He also submitted that in the entire cognizance order
the facts were mentioned in the complainant and the evidence of
the complainant has been referred but there is no reason to
demonstrate how an offence is made out. He further referred the
order and submitted that the pamphlets and the news articles are
two different aspects but same were mixed together and on basis
of said conclusion, a conclusion was drawn that these petitioners
have conspired to malign and defame the complainant. He also
submitted that the order passed without considering legal position
indicate that it was a non-application of mind. He also referred the
order of revisional Court and submitted that revisional Court,
without considering the legality of the order passed by the trial
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(5 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
Court has dismissed the criminal revision in summary manner,
which is again a non-application of mind. He also submitted that
neither in the order of trial Court nor in the revisional Court the
ingredients of defamation were discussed and there is not a
whisper to demonstrate that the petitioners have committed an
offence of defamation, therefore, the order of cognizance and also
order of revisional Court are contrary to settled proposition of law
and deserves to be quashed.
6. Learned Senior Advocate has further referred judgment in
case of Rajaram Sharma versus The State of Uttar Pradesh
and Anr.: 2024 LiveLaw (SC) 41 and submitted that under
Section 482 of CrPC it is incumbent upon this Hon'ble Court to
consider question whether the allegations would constitute an
offence alleged against the petitioners. He also placed reliance
upon judgment in case of Sachin Garg versus State of UP and
Anr. : 2024 INSC 72 and submitted that it is duty of the
Magistrate to record satisfaction, and without recording satisfaction
a process cannot be issued as issuance of process is a serious
issue. He has further placed reliance upon judgments in case of
Jawaharlal Darda and Ors. Vs. Manoharrao Ganpatrao
Kapsikar and Ors.:MANU/SC/0251/1998, Prabhu Chawla
and Ors. versus A.U. Sheriff :MANU/KA/0078/1994, Sanjay
Upadhya Vs. Anand Dubey : 2024 INSC 66 , and M/s Iveco
Magirus Brandschutztechnik GMBH Vs. Nirmal Kishore
Bhartiay and Anr. 2023 LiveLaw (SC) 860 , and submitted that
unless the evidence constitute an offence, the petitioners cannot
be held responsible for committing any offence.
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(6 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
7. Aforesaid contentions were opposed by learned counsel
appearing on behalf of non-petitioner/complainant and learned
Public Prosecutor.
8. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the complainant
submitted that in para Nos. 10, 12 and 13 of complaint the specific
allegations were made against these petitioners, and same are
sufficient to constitute an offence and take cognizance, by the trial
court. He also submitted that para No. 3 of the cognizance order
described the evidence with role and involvement of these
petitioners in publication of news article, which resulted into harm
to reputation of complainant in the eye of society. He also
submitted that if any news article is published in any newspaper,
then it is obligatory upon the publisher and editor to verify the
news article before publication and if they have published a false
and malicious article with intention to defame anyone, then they
are responsible for committing an offence of defamation. He also
submitted that the complainant has filed a complaint mentioning
specific role of these petitioners, and after recording the evidence
the trial Court has taken cognizance, which is in accordance with
legal provisions. He further submitted that one of the lady about
whom the complainant was named and defamed has not given any
statement against the complainant, and there is no material to
show that the complainant was ever blamed or criticized by said
female Sukhwanti and the publication of pamphlet and subsequent
news in daily newspaper Rajasthan Patrika amounts to defamation.
He also submitted that the news article has been published without
confirmation, as the entire news article is itself defamatory, which
has impacted and affected the legal practice of the complainant
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(7 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
and it has injured the reputation of complainant, who is a
practicing lawyer. He also submitted that at the stage of
cognizance, the Court has required to see only a prima facie case,
and when a prima facie case is available, then the trial Court is
required to take cognizance.
9. Learned counsel for the complainant has further placed
reliance upon judgment in case of Chilakamarthi
Venkateshwarlu and Anr. Vs. State of Andhara Pradesh and
Anr: Criminal Appeal No. 1082 of 2019 , and submitted that
under Section 482 of CrPC it is not permissible for the Court to act
as if it were a trial Court. The Court is only to be prima facie
satisfied about existence of sufficient ground for proceeding
against the accused and for limited purpose the Court can evaluate
materials and documents and it cannot appreciate the evidence.
He also referred same judgment published in news portal
"LiveLaw".
10. Learned counsel for the complainant has further placed
reliance upon judgment in case of Gambhirsinh R. Dekare Vs.
Falgunbhai Chimanbhai Patel and Anr.: 2013, Crl. L.J. 1757
(SC) , and submitted that the editor is responsible for contents of
newspaper in view of Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867, as
every matter is within control of editor and he is responsible
person. He referred judgment in case of Bhushan Kumar and
Anr. Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) & Anr. :2012 Crl.L.J. 2286
(SC) , and submitted that under Section 190 a Magistrate has to be
satisfied whether there exists a sufficient ground for proceeding,
and not, whether there is sufficient ground for conviction. He also
placed reliance upon judgment in case of Nupur Talwar versus
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(8 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
CBI: AIR 2012 SC 1921 , and submitted that for issuance of
process under Section 204 of CrPC the trial Court is required to be
satisfied from the material on record, and it has nothing to do with
the defence of any person as same is not subject matter to be
considered by the trial Court or the revisional Court at the stage of
cognizance.
11. Heard learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of
petitioners, learned counsel for the complainant and learned Public
Prosecutor. Perused the material placed on record along with
judgments as referred by learned counsel for the parties.
12. The brief facts of the case are that non-petitioner No.2-
complainant has filed a criminal complaint on 21st August 2003
against ten persons alleging certain acts about to organization of a
campaign, distribution of pamphlet and further sloganeering by
public address system (loud speaker) and further publication in
daily newspaper "Rajasthan Patrika", resulted in defamation to the
complainant. The complainant has also annexed a news article
published in another newspaper "Dainik Bhaskar" to show that a
demonstration organized by Kisan Sabha was a malicious
campaign. The statement of complainant was recorded under
Section 200 of CrPC whereas statement of other witnesses Om
Prakash, Laxminarayan, Virendra were also recorded under Section
202 of CrPC. Total 23 documents were submitted by the
complainant, and on the basis of said material, the trial Court has
taken cognizance against all ten accused named in complaint
under Sections 500, 501 and 502 of IPC. The present petitioners
have filed a criminal revision, which was decided by learned
Additional Sessions Judge, Laxmangarh on 11th November 2005
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(9 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
and same was dismissed. Now the current criminal misc. petition is
filed under Section 482of CrPC.
13. The present petitioner No.1 is a newspaper company,
whereas petitioner No.2 is an Editor-in-Chief of the newspaper
"Rajasthan Patrika".
14. Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India confers a right to
freedom of speech and expression to all citizens, whereas Article
19(2) allows the State to make laws that impose reasonable
restrictions on the exercise of the right conferred by the said sub-
clause in the interests of the sovereignty and integrity of India, the
security of the State, friendly relations with Foreign States, public
order, decency or morality or in relation to contempt of Court,
defamation or incitement to an offence.
15. In case of Subramanian Swamy versus Union of India,
Ministry of Law and Ors. reported in (2016) 7 SCC 221 ,
Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that "freedom of speech and
expression is a highly treasured value under the Constitution". It
was further held that notwithstanding the expansive, and sweeping
ambit of freedom of speech, as all rights, right to freedom of
speech and expression is not absolute and is subject to imposition
of reasonable restrictions. The reputation of a person is an integral
part of life, guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of
India, as reputation of anyone cannot be allowed to be crucified at
the altar of the other’s right of free speech. While considering
constitutional validity of Sections 499 and 500 of IPC, has
differentiated a defamatory attack from criticism, dissent by
speaker by speaking for tolerance for criticism, dissent and
discordance but professed no tolerance to defamatory attack.
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(10 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
16. In case of Arnab Ranjan Goswami versus Union of India
and Ors. : (2020) 14 SCC 51 , Hon'ble Supreme Court has
observed that in the interest of ensuring the fair administration of
criminal justice, the order which we intend to pass should present
a balance between the governing principles to ensure that the
criminal process does not assume the character of a vexatious
exercise by the institution of multifarious complaints. There is a
need for the law to protect journalistic freedom within the ambit of
Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India.
17. In case of Vinod Dua versus Union of India and Ors.
reported in AIR 2021 SC 3239 , while considering Section 88 of
IPC observed that before a medical professional is prosecuted for
negligence in criminal law, some threshold requirements ought to
be satisfied, otherwise an unwarranted prosecution may not only
result in great prejudice to concerned medical professional, but
would not still a sense of confidence in medical professional for
discharging their duties.
18. In case of Vinod Dua versus Union of India and Ors.
(supra), Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as under:-
“45. The other offending provision referred to in the
FIR is Section 501 of the IPC which is printing or
engraving a matter which is defamatory to any person.
As a matter of fact, the cognizance with respect to an
offence punishable under Chapter XXI of the IPC
(Section 501 of the IPC is part of said Chapter) can be
taken by a Court only upon a complaint made by the
person aggrieved. Without going into such
technicalities, in our view, there is nothing defamatory
in the statements made by the petitioner. Further, the
statements of the petitioner would be covered by the
second and third exceptions to Section 499 of the IPC.
In some of the cases decided by this Court, for
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(11 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
example, in Jawaharlal Darda and Others vs.
Manoharrao Ganpatrao Kapsikar and Another, (1998) 4
SCC 112, Rajendra Kumar Sitaram Pande and Others
vs. Uttam and Another, (1999) 3 SCC 134, Vivek
Goenka and Others vs. Y.R. Patil, (2000) 9 SCC 87 and
S. Khushboo vs. Kanniammal and Another, (2010)5
SCC 600 relying on exceptions to Section 499 of the
IPC, the criminal proceeding initiated against the
accused were quashed. Thus, the instant proceedings,
in so far as Section 501 IPC is concerned, also deserve
to be quashed.”
19. In case of Muhammad Abdulla Khan versus Prakash K.
reported in 2017 INSC 1168 , while considering an appeal in a
matter relating to cognizance of offense punishable under Sections
500, 501 and 502 of IPC, has referred judgment in case of K.M.
Mathew Vs. K.A. Abraham: (2002) 6 SCC 670 and Sections
499 of IPC and observed as under about the essential ingredient
for offense as under:
11. An analysis of the above reveals that to constitute
an offence of defamation it requires a person to make
some imputation concerning any other person;
(i) Such imputation must be made either
(a) With intention, or
(b) Knowledge, or
(c) Having a reason to believe
that such an imputation will harm the reputation of the
person against whom the imputation is made.
(ii) Imputation could be, by
(a) Words, either spoken or written, or
(b) By making signs, or
(c) Visible representations
(iii) Imputation could be either made or published.
The difference between making of an imputation and
publishing the same is:
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(12 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
If ‘X’ tells ‘Y’ that ‘Y’ is a criminal – ‘X’ makes an
imputation.
If ‘X’ tells ‘Z’ that ‘Y’ is a criminal – ‘X’ publishes the
imputation.
The essence of publication in the context of Section
499 is the communication of defamatory imputation
to persons other than the persons against whom
the imputation is made.
12. Committing any act which constitutes defamation
under Section 499 IPC is punishable offence under
Section 500 IPC. Printing or engraving any defamatory
material is altogether a different offence under Section
501 IPC. Offering for sale or selling any such printed
or engraved defamatory material is yet another
distinct offence under Section 502 IPC.
20. Further held that in the context of the fact of the case in
hand, it must be established that the matter printed and offered
for sale is defamatory within the meaning of expression under
Section 499 of IPC. If so proved, the next step would be to
examine the question whether the accused committed the act
which constitute an offense of which he is charged with the
requisite intention or knowledge etc. to make his act culpable.
Answer to the question depends upon the facts, if the respondent
is the person who either made or published the defamatory
imputation, he would be liable for punishment under Section 500
of IPC.
21. In case of Sachin Dua versus Union of India and Ors.
(supra), after considering several judgments including M/s
Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. versus State of
Maharashtra and others reported in (2021) 19 SCC 401 ,
State of Haryana and others versus Bhajan Lal and others
reported in 1992 SCC (Criminal) 426 and R.P. Kapoor versus
State of Punjab: AIR 1960 SC 862 , Hon'ble Supreme Court has
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(13 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
observed that at the stage of issuing summons, the Magistrate
only needs to be satisfied with a prima facie case for taking
cognizance. The duty of the Magistrate is also to be satisfied
whether there is a sufficient ground for proceedings, as has been
held in case of Jagdish Ram versus State of Rajasthan and
another reported in (2004) 4 SCC 432 . While referring the
judgment in case of M/s. Pepsi Foods Ltd. & Anr. v. Special
Judicial Magistrate & Ors. : reported in (1998) 5 SCC 749 ,
Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed that the Magistrate's order
issuing summons records the background of the case in a rather
longest details but reflects his satisfaction in cryptic manner. At the
stage of issue of summons, detailed reasoning is not necessary.
22. In case of Ravindranatha Bajpe vs. Mangalore Special
Economic Zone Ltd. and others etc. : Criminal Appeal No.
1047-1048/2021 dated 27.09.2021 , Hon'ble Supreme Court
has observed that issuance of summons of process by any Court is
a serious matter and unless there are specific allegations and the
role attributed to each accused has been explained the Magistrate
ought not to issue the process.
23. In case of Rajaram Sharma versus The State of Uttar
Pradesh and Anr. (supra), it was held that it is incumbent upon
the High Court to consider the question under Section 482 of CrPC
whether the allegation would constitute offense against the
present accused.
24. In case of Jawaharlal Darda and Ors. Vs. Manoharrao
Ganpatrao Kapsikar and Ors. , (supra), after considering the
Sections 499, 500, 501 and 502 of IPC regarding news item
published in newspaper, has observed that if the accused bona
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(14 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
fidely believing the true version and published in good faith, then it
cannot be said that the accused intend to harm the reputation of
the complainant.
25. In case of Prabhu Chawla and Ors. versus A.U. Sheriff
(supra), it was observed that the Court shall not order issuance of
process in routine manner for any offense in absence of positive
averment against the persons.
26. In case of Sanjay Upadhya Vs. Anand Dubey (supra),
while considering fundamental rights of freedom of speech and
expression enshrined under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of
India, it was referred the observation that the publication in
question did not warrant prosecution of the accused appellant for
the offense punishable under Section 500 of IPC. Hon'ble Supreme
Court has expressed the view that news article in question was
published in good faith in exercise of fundamental right of freedom
of speech and expression.
27. In case of M/s Iveco Magirus Brandschutztechnik GMBH
Vs. Nirmal Kishore Bhartiay and Anr. (supra), it was held that
the Magistrate can dismiss the defamation complaint by applying
the exceptions under Section 499 of IPC, even before issuing
summons to accused.
28. At the stage of issue of process in a complaint of defamation,
the Magistrate has to form opinion based on allegation made in the
complaint and other material as to whether sufficient ground for
proceeding exists, as distinguished from sufficient ground for
conviction. The issue of process under Section 204 read with
Section 200 of CrPC does not ipso facto stand vitiated for non
consideration of exceptions to Section 499 of IPC unless it is
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(15 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
convincingly demonstrated before the High Court that even on
basis of complaint and materials, the Magistrate had before him
and without there being nothing more, the facts alleged do not
prima facie make out the offense of defamation.
29. In case of Gambhirsinh R. Dekare Vs. Falgunbhai
Chimanbhai Patel and Anr. (supra), it was observed that the
newspaper content is within control of editor and he has to be held
responsible for news published in newspaper. After considering
Sections 1, 5 and 7 of the Press and Registration of Books Act,
1867, it was observed that the presumption is a rebuttable
presumption and it would be deemed a sufficient evidence unless
the contrary is proved. It was also observed that the allegation of
the complainant was that as per instruction of accused, the news
was published and the publication was within their knowledge,
therefore, truthfulness or otherwise cannot be gone into at the
stage of cognizance.
30. In case of Bhushan Kumar and Anr. Vs. State (NCT of
Delhi) & Anr. (supra), it was held that under Section 190 of CrPC
only application of judicial mind to the averment in complaint that
constitute offense has to be seen and a petition to quash
summoning order is maintainable under Section 482 of CrPC.
31. In case of Nupur Talwar versus CBI (supra) while
considering Section 204 CrPC it was observed that the order
issuing process need not be reasoned and absence of reasons does
not vitiate order.
32. In case of Chilakamarthi Venkateshwarlu and Anr. Vs.
State of Andhara Pradesh and Anr (supra), while considering
the provision under Section 482 of CrPC, it was observed that in
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(16 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
exercise of jurisdiction under Section 482 of CrPC, it is not
permissible for the Court to act as it were a trial Court and the
Court is only to be prima facie satisfied about existence of
sufficient ground for proceedings against the accused and for
limited purpose can evaluate material and documents on record.
33. Instant case is relating to present petitioner is confined to
defamation by publication of a news article and after the
publication of news article, a complaint has been filed by the
complainant.
34. Section 499 of IPC defines defamation and the essential
ingredient to constitute an offense has been referred by us, which
clearly indicate that when a person making some imputation
concerning any other person either with intention or knowledge or
having a reason to believe by words either spoken or written or
making signs or visible representation or made or published then it
is a defamation. In order to constitute an offense, there has to be
essential elements which includes intention or knowledge or having
reason to believe on part of the accused.
35. In the instant case, a complaint has been filed by
complainant against ten persons including both the petitioners.
The petitioners No.1 is a company, but no specific reference is
made in the complaint about the management of the company.
Otherwise also, a company which owns the newspaper does not
itself liable for defamation as in order to establish the role and
involvement of a company, it is necessary to establish that the
Board of Directors or the management of the company was having
intention or knowledge or reason to believe about the news article,
which was published to harm the reputation of other person.
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(17 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
36. In the entire complaint from Para No.1 to 8 nothing has been
mentioned against the petitioners, but in Para No.9 it has been
mentioned that the pamphlet which was distributed in an assembly
was published in newspaper by accused No.1 to 4 (including
present petitioners) in their daily newspaper Rajasthan Patrika,
“Alwar edition”. It was held that said news article was published
without any basis and it has been published by the correspondent
because the complainant is a counsel for opposite party. In Para
No.10 nothing has been mentioned against the petitioners. In Para
No.11 name of "Rajasthan Patrika" has been mentioned but with
reference that Sukhvanti has not made any allegation complainant.
In Para No.12 nothing has been mentioned against the petitioners
but in Para No.13 it was mentioned that the pamphlets were
distributed with announcement on loudspeaker across the market
and news article has been published. The Para No.14 mentioned a
fact that the incident is of Laxmangarh and newspaper was
published and sold in Laxmangarh.
37. A bare reading of complaint from Para No.1 to 14 clearly
indicate that neither specific role of present petitioners were
mentioned nor any statement about their involvement in
conspiracy with other accused No.5 to 10 was made. It means no
specific attribution about the role of these petitioners were
mentioned by complainant in his entire complaint.
38. Pursuant to said complaint the statement of complainant
were recorded under Section 200 of CrPC wherein he mentioned
the name of Subhash Tiwari as journalist and agent of Rajasthan
Patrika but he has not mentioned any role of these petitioners in
deliberate or malicious publication of the news article. In the entire
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(18 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
evidence, not a single word about conspiracy between present
petitioners and Subhash Tiwari. The complainant has mentioned a
fact that the Rajasthan Patrika came to know from publication in
"Dainik Bhaskar" that the agitations and display of anger in
demonstration was a conspiracy of opposite party to the litigation.
In the statement, a fact was mentioned that editor, distributor,
publisher and journalist were aware that the news and agitation
was a conspiracy. There is not a single word by name against these
petitioners in the entire evidence of complainant. The supporting
evidence of Om Prakash Kuteta only stated about distribution of
pamphlets and announcement from loudspeakers. Identical
evidence was given by Lakshmi Narayan. The third witness
Virendra Kumar has read the pamphlet printed from Surya
Printers, which does not belong to these petitioners, and he also
mentioned about a news article published in Rajasthan Patrika and
he stated that it was published by Subhash Tiwari. The statements
of these three witnesses recorded under Section 202 of CrPC do
not indicate involvement of any of the petitioners.
39. The trial Court after considering the complaint and statement
has observed that the pamphlet and newspaper was published by
editor and advisor who are accused No. 2 and 3 (Gulab Kothari and
Milap Kothari). The trial Court has observed that the accused No.4
Vijay Bhandari was publisher and Subhash Tiwari was local
correspondent whereas pamphlet was published by accused No.6
Surya Printers, whose proprietor was the accused No.7 Prem
Kumar. The trial Court has also observed that accused No.9 Abhay
Singh and accused No.10 are President and Secretary of Kisan
Sabha. The trial Court without recording evidence of Sukhvanti has
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(19 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
observed that the complainant has not committed any cheating
with Sukhvanti and the pamphlet has been published and a news
was published to defame complainant. The trial Court has further
drawn a conclusion that the pamphlet was published and
announcement was made from local loudspeaker, by accused
persons, and Ultimately, the order of cognizance was passed
under Sections 500, 501, 502 of CrPC.
40. The observation by the trial Court clearly reflect that only on
basis of statement of complainant, the order of cognizance was
passed, and in the entire cognizance order nowhere it has been
mentioned that how it injured and harm to the reputation of
complainant. Nowhere it has been mentioned that these petitioners
have conspired either with Sukhvanti or accused Nos.9 and 10 at
the time of publication of news article. Similarly, there is no
evidence about connect in between the petitioners and publication
of pamphlet and distribution of pamphlet with announcement by
the loudspeaker. There is no evidence to show that these
petitioners ever visited and gathered at Laxmangarh and
participated in distribution or announcement process.
41. These petitioners have filed a criminal revision before learned
Additional Sessions Judge and by a cryptic order dated 11.11.2005
the criminal revision was dismissed, which indicate that even the
legality of the order impugned was not tested by learned
Revisional Court as it was beyond the scope under Section 397 of
CrPC to examine the legality of the order. It clearly indicate that
the order passed by the revisional Court is clearly non-application
of mind.
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(20 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
42. In the instant case, not a single whisper has been made
against three petitioners in the entire complaint except the fact
that petitioner No.2 is an editor of newspaper. There is nothing on
record about petitioner No.1, in particular, the management and
day-to-day affairs of newspaper, so as to demonstrate the role of
petitioner No.1 in order to constitute an offence under Sections
500, 501 and 502 of IPC. There is nothing on record to show that
these petitioners have ever conspired with any or all of the other
accused Nos.5 to 10 in publication or demonstration in any
manner.
43. The law of defamation under Section 499 of IPC provides
following exceptions:-
(i) Any statement made about someone, if it is true and for the
public good does not amount to defamation;
(ii) Any statement made about the conduct of a public servant in
the discharge of their duties are exempted from defamation,
provided they are in good faith;
(iii) The conduct of an individual who voluntarily participated in
public affairs or controversies; as fair criticism is permissible.
(iv) Publishing a true and accurate report of judicial proceedings
is not a defamatory statement;
(v) Any statement regarding the merits of a case, a judgment or
the conduct of a witness, if made in good faith, are protected;
(vi) Any fair criticism of any literary, artistic, or other public
performance does not constitute an offence of defamation;
(vii) Any authority to censure its subordinate for misconduct or
inefficiency, but within scope of their professional relation and in
good faith is not defamation;
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(21 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
(viii) Any accusation in good faith to an authorized person is not a
defamatory statement;
(ix) A imputation made to protect one's own interest or the
interest of others, if done in good faith, is also exempted from the
offence of defamation.
(x) Any statement made to make aware the public against
potential harm are not defamatory, provided they are made in
good faith.
44. The exceptions for the defamation are provided to ensure
that the statement must serve a public purpose and be made with
honest intention in good faith. A public servant is accountable for
their official action and their work and performance is subject to
scrutiny by public and media. The purpose of exemption is to
ensure fair criticism of the persons involved in public life and
ensure transparency or foster trust and accountability in the
system. Any analysis or constructive criticism in responsible
manner also does not fall in the act of defamation. Any advice,
good or bad, but in good faith about anyone, including any
consumer product, also falls in above exemption and it does not
constitute an offence.
45. Having considered the legal position, I am of the considered
view that neither in the entire complaint nor in any evidence, any
whisper of allegation is made against any of the petitioners, which
was made with intention to cause harm to the reputation of
complainant. In case of M/s. Pepsi Foods Ltd. & Anr. v. Special
Judicial Magistrate & Ors. (supra) Hon'ble Supreme Court has
considered Section 204 of CrPC and held that without being
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(22 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
satisfied about the availability of ingredients to constitute an
offence, a process cannot be issued in routine manner.
46. Here in this case, the entire order of the trial Court indicate
that the trial Court has connected these petitioners with
publication of pamphlet, demonstration by Kisan Sabha, and
further speeches or announcement on loudspeakers (public
address system) though there is nothing on record to show that
these petitioners have any meeting of mind with any other
persons, arrayed as an accused No.5 to 10. Thus, the issuance of
process by the trial Court is just an abuse to the extent that the
trial Court without taking note of any justification or narration
about the role of these petitioners has passed an order of
cognizance, against petitioners.
47. In case of Pradeep Kumar Kesarwani versus the State of
Uttar Pradesh another reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC
1947 , Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that it is duty of the
Court in case where an accused seeks quashing of an FIR or
proceedings on the ground that such proceedings are manifestly
perverse or frivolous, vexatious or instituted with an ulterior
motive for wreaking vengeance was delineated, is required to be
quashed. It was held that summoning any person on the basis of
frivolous or vexatious complaint is something very serious and it
would tarnish the image of the person against whom false,
frivolous and vexatious allegations are levelled.
48. In case of Sujoy Ghosh vs The State of Jharkhand
reported in 2026 INSC 267 , Hon'ble Supreme Court, while
considering the scope of Section 482 of CrPC and Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, has observed that the Court need not restrict
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
(23 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:40230] [CRLMP-1537/2005]
itself only to the stage of a case but is empowered to take into
account the overall circumstances leading to the
initiation/registration of the case as well as the materials collected
in the course of investigation. Summoning of accused in a criminal
case is a serious matter and criminal law cannot set into motion as
a matter of course.
49. Having considered the entire material as referred
hereinabove, the summoning process initiated by the learned trial
Court is just an abuse of process of law and without any evidence
or assigning the role and involvement of the petitioners, an order
of cognizance and summoning order has been passed against the
petitioners, which is contrary to settled law, therefore, in absence
of essential ingredient to constitute an offence of defamation, a
cognizance order cannot be passed by the trial Court, particularly
when it relates to fundamental right of freedom of speech and
expression, as it undermines the freedom of press in a democracy
like ours. Thus, we have no option except to quash the
proceedings instituted at behest of complainant respondent No.2.
50. In view of discussion made hereinabove, criminal
miscellaneous petition under Section 482 of CrPC is hereby allowed
and the order dated 7th April 2004 in complaint case No.7/2003
and order dated 11th November 2005 in Criminal Revision
No.86/2004 are hereby set aside and the proceedings pending
against the petitioners is hereby quashed.
51. Miscellaneous application, if any, also stands disposed.
(ASHOK KUMAR JAIN),J
104/MR
(Uploaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:29:40 PM)
(Downloaded on 06/10/2026 at 07:39:55 PM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)