DEBASIS LENKA vs DR. DILLIP KUMAR JENA, SUPERINTENDENT, LEPROSY HOME AND HOSPITAL, NAYABAZAR

Court
Odisha High Court

CONTC/3100/2024
ODHC010296242024
2026:OHC:316

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK

CONTC No.3100 of 2024

CNR No.ODHC010296242024

Debasis Lenka & others Petitioners
….

Mr. Pratik Dash, Advocate

-versus-
Dr. Dillip Kumar Jena,
Superintendent, Leprosy
Home & Hospital, Cuttack

Opposite Party/
….
Contemnor

Mr. Dipankar Acharya, Advocate

CORAM: JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MISHRA



Order No.
ORDER

Date of Hearing:14.08.2026 Date of Order: 20.11.2026
18.





This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.

2. The present Contempt Proceeding has been initiated
under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971,
shortly, ‘the Act, 1971’, for alleged wilful and deliberate
violation of interim order dated 16.04.2024, passed in I.A.
No.5037 of 2024 (arising out of W.P.(C) No.8855 of 2024).
Vide the said order, as an interim measure, this Court
directed the Opposite Party-Contemnor to allow the
Petitioners to supply the dietary articles to Leprosy Home &
Hospital, Cuttack till the next date of listing. Instead of
acting in terms of the said order, the Opposite Party-
Contemnor allowed the Opposite Party No.7 to the writ
petition, i.e., Swarupa Mahasangha to supply the dietary


articles w.e.f. 17.04.2024. Hence, the present Contempt
Proceeding.
3.
A Show Cause Affidavit was filed by the Opposite
Party-Contemnor on 18.08.2025, taking a plea therein that
the Petitioners had been supplying the dietary articles to
the Leprosy Home & Hospital, Cuttack since the year 2020-
21, without initiating any tender process for selection of
supplier for supply of dietary articles to the Leprosy Home
& Hospital, Cuttack. It was also stated in the Show Cause
Affidavit that the selection of SHGs for supply of dietary
articles was already finalized by the selection committee on
12.02.2024 and communicated to the CDMO, Cuttack vide
letter dated 27.03.2024. It was further stated that the
inmates of the Leprosy Home & Hospital, Cuttack made a
protest on 18.01.2024 regarding irregular supply so also
low quality of dietary articles being supplied by the
Petitioners, for which they (Petitioners) were noticed on
02.04.2024 to stop supply of dietary articles to the Leprosy
Home & Hospital, Cuttack after 15 days from the date of
receipt of the said letter, which was extended up to
17.04.2024. Soon after expiry of the said notice period, the
newly selected SHG, i.e., Swarupa Mahasangha, was
engaged to supply cooked food to inmates of the Leprosy
Home & Hospital, Cuttack, as per the provision of the Govt.
Guidelines dated 18.11.2021.
3.1. Though the interim order dated 16.04.2024 was
passed in presence of the learned State Counsel, who was
representing the Opposite Party-Contemnor and after going
through the written instruction imparted by the
Contemnor vide his letter dated 16.04.2024 to the learned
Page 2 of 18

State Counsel, vide which it was confirmed that the
Petitioners were supplying dietary articles till 16.04.2024,
i.e., the date on which interim order was passed, a further
stand was taken in the Show Cause Affidavit that the said
interim order dated 16.04.2024 passed in I.A. No.5037 of
2024 was not within the knowledge of the Opposite Party-
Contemnor till 17.04.2024.
4. However, because of the conduct of the Opposite
Party-Contemnor during hearing of the present contempt
proceeding, so also for flouting of interim order dated
16.04.2024 passed in I.A. No.5037 of 2024 & W.P.(C)
No.8855 of 2024, referring to the earlier orders, this Court
was of prima facie view that such conduct of the Opposite
Party-Contemnor is deliberate, willful and contemptuous.
Accordingly, vide order dated 26.03.2026 the Opposite
Party-Contemnor was asked to show cause as to why he
should not be punished under Section 12 of the Act, 1971.
The said order, being relevant, is reproduced below:
“ORDER
26.03.2026
This matter is taken up through hybrid
mode.
2. Pursuant to order dated 12.03.2026, Dr.
Dillip Kumar Jena, the alleged Contemnor, is
physically present in the Court being accompanied
by Mr. P.T. Ganesh Sahoo, the I.I.C, CRI Police
Station, as this Court, vide the said order,
requested the Deputy Commissioner of Police,
Cuttack to ensure presence of the Opposite Party-
alleged Contemnor today before this Court.
3. As is ascertained from the record, an
Affidavit has been filed by the alleged Contemnor
on 12.03.2026, i.e., the last date, on which a
detailed order was passed for physical presence
of the alleged Contemnor before this Court today
at 2:00 P.M. Paragraph Nos.4 to 6 of the said
order dated 12.03.2026, being relevant, are
reproduced below:-
Page 3 of 18

“ 4. Mr. Dash, learned Counsel for
the Petitioners further submits, the
Opposite Party/ alleged Contemnor is
in the habit of defying the orders
passed by this Court. Earlier also,
vide order dated 13.05.2024, a
direction was given to file Show
Cause Affidavit within a period of
four weeks w.e.f. 13.05.2024 and
thereafter, vide order dated
28.07.2025, further two weeks’ time
was granted to the Opposite
Party/alleged Contemnor to file the
Show Cause Affidavit. Instead of
filing the Show Cause Affidavit within
two weeks w.e.f 28.07.2025, Show
Cause Affidavit was filed just one
day before listing of the matter, i.e.,
on 18.08.2025. Neither any
application was filed for acceptance
of Show Cause filed beyond the
extended period, nor the Opposite
Party remained present in the Court
in terms of order dated 28.07.2025.
Such conduct of the Opposite
Party/alleged Contemnor is further
contemptuous and in complete
disregard to the orders passed by
this Court from time to time.
5. A query being made as to
the reason of absence of the
Opposite Party / alleged
Contemnor, Mr. Mishra, learned
ASC, who is assisting Mr. Nayak,
learned AGA submits, since the
Opposite Party did not file his
Response within the extended
period, despite repeated request
and instruction to the Opposite
Party / alleged Contemnor to
ensure his presence today before
this Court, he did not bother to
act in terms of such
instruction/request.

6. Hence, this Court is of prima
facie view that such conduct of the
Opposite Party/ alleged Contemnor is
contemptuous. The Opposite Party
namely, Dr. Dillip Kumar Jena is
Page 4 of 18

directed to remain physically present
th
before this Court on 26 March, 2026
at 2:00 P.M.”

(Emphasis supplied)

4. A repeated query being made as to when he
last came to this Court, the alleged Contemnor did
not answer to such query. However, the Affidavit
dated 12.03.2026 was confronted to Dr. Dillip
Kumar Jena, the alleged Contemnor in the Court.
After going through the same, he admitted that
the signature appearing in the said Affidavit
dated 12.03.2026 belongs to him. However, the
alleged Contemnor states that he never came to
this Court on 12.03.2026 to swear the said
Affidavit. He further states before this Court that
on 12.03.2026 being an off day for him, he was at
his residence, which is situated at Meria Bazar,
Cuttack, nearer to this Court.
5. Further, as is revealed from the Affidavit
filed by the Opposite Party-alleged Contemnor
dated 12.03.2026, he has admitted that though
the interim order was passed by this Court on
16.04.2024, since letter had already been issued
in favour of the Self Help Group to provide diet
w.e.f 15.04.2024, the concerned SHG was
permitted to supply diet w.e.f 17.04.2024 and the
Petitioners were allowed to supply diet till
16.04.2024. Paragraph nos. 7 & 8 of the said
Affidavit, being relevant, are reproduced below:-

7. That in reply to para 8 of the
“
Rejoinder Affidavit, it is humbly
submitted that no such tender
process has not been done for the
year 2021-22, 2022-23, 2023-24.
Hence the petitioner was allowed
to supply diet till 16.04.2024 . The
present petitioner was selected
during the tender process for the
financial year 2020-21. But
pursuant to the Government
Guideline, proceeding of meeting was
held on 12.02.2024 and accordingly
letter was issued to the Swasurpa
Mahasangha (Self Help Group) vide
letter No.02.04.2024 (under
Annexure-E) to supply diet w.e.f.
15.04.2024.
Page 5 of 18


8. That so far as reply to para 9 and
10 of the Rejoinder Affidavit, the
present deponent has no comments to
offer. However, much prior to
interim order dated 16.04.2024, letter
has already been issued to the Self
Help Group to provide diet w.e.f.
15.04.2024 and accordingly, the
Self Help Group concerned, has
supplied diet w.e.f. 17.04.2024 as
the petitioner was allowed to
supply diet till 16.04.2024 .”

(Emphasis supplied)

6. Admittedly, no application was filed by the
alleged Contemnor seeking variance of the order
dated 16.04.2024 passed by this Court in I.A.
5037 of 2024 on the plea, as has been taken in
the Reply to the Rejoinder Affidavit filed by the
Petitioner. Rather, before passing the order dated
16.04.2024, vide order dated 15.04.2024, a query
was made by this Court with the Petitioners’
Counsel as to who is supplying the diets as on
15.04.2024.That apart, learned State Counsel
was also directed to take instruction as to
whether the Opposite Party No.7 (Self Help Group)
has already started supplying the hospital diet to
the Leprosy Home and Hospital, Cuttack,
pursuant to its selection by the District Social
Welfare Officer, Cuttack vide order dated
20.02.2024, so also Memo dated 27.03.2024 of
the C.D.M.O., Cuttack.
7. Relevant paragraphs of Order No.1 dated
15.04.2024 and Order No.2 dated 16.04.2024
passed in W.P.(C) No.8855 of 2024 and I.A.
No.5037 of 2024 are reproduced below:-
“ ORDER
15.04.2024
5. Learned Counsel for the
Petitioners submits, the impugned
letter dated 02.04.2024 under
Annexure-6 has been issued by the
authority concerned when the Code of
Conduct is in vogue.
6. A query being made, learned
Counsel for the Petitioners submits,
as per the instruction received, the
Petitioner Nos.2 and 3 are supplying
Page 6 of 18

Bred, OMFED Milk, Goat Meat,
Chicken, fish, egg, vegetable, Jeera,
Dry Chilli, Haladi Powder, Mustard
Oil and so far as Petitioner No.1, he is
supplying rice, refine Oil, Jeera and
Haladi etc., as detailed in the
performance sheet dated 28.03.2023,
as at Annexure-3 series, and the
Petitioner No.1 supplied rice last on
12.04.2023.
7. Since the learned Counsel for
the Petitioners presses for staying
operation of letter dated 02.04.2024,
as at Annexure-6, a query being
made by this Court, the learned
Counsel for the Petitioners is unable
to apprise as to who is, at present,
supplying the perishable items, as
detailed above.
8. Learned A.S.C. for the State
Opposite Party Nos.1 and 3 to 6 is
directed to take instruction as to
whether the Opposite Party No.7
(Self Help Group) has already
started supplying the hospital
diet to the Leprosy Home and
Hospital, Cuttack, pursuant to its
selection by the District Social Welfare
Officer, Cuttack vide its order dated
20.02.2024 so also Memo dated
27.03.2024 of the C.D.M.O., Cuttack.
9. Learned A.S.C. for the
State-Opposite Party Nos.1 and 3
to 6 is also directed to take
instruction urgently as to the
present status of supplying diet
articles, including perishable
articles, to the Leprosy Home and
Hospital, Cuttack, as detailed
above so also legality of the order
dated 02.04.2024 issued during
operation of Code of Conduct .
10. Matter be listed tomorrow
(16.04.2024) under the same
heading.”
(Emphasis supplied)

“ ORDER
16.04.2024
W.P.(C) No.8855 of 2024 &
Page 7 of 18

I.A. No.5037 of 2024
4. Pursuant to order dated 15.04.2024,
learned Counsel for the Petitioners files
Affidavits sworn by the Petitioners after
handing over copies of the same to the learned
Counsel for the State indicating therein that
they are in the process of supplying the food
articles as detailed in the said Affidavits. The
said Affidavits are taken on record.
5. Learned State Counsel files photocopy of
letter No.294 dated 16.04.2024 of the
Superintendent, Leprosy Home & Hospital,
Cuttack, addressed to Mr. D.K. Behera,
learned Additional Standing Counsel for the
State regarding supply of dietary articles to
inmates and patients of Leprosy Home &
Hospital, Cuttack, the contents of which is
extracted below.

“Sir,
With reference to your Letter
No. subject cited above. I am to
state that till today the dietary
articles to Superintendent L.H.H.
Cuttack were supplied by Pvt.
Contractors through tender for the
year 2020-21 but the tender process,
could not be possible due to some
avoidable circumstances the
contractors were allowed to give
the dietary articles till today.
That is on 16.04.2024 but as Govt.
pleased to declare to WSHG to supply
diet to inmates & patients to Leprosy
Home & Hospital, Cuttack. After
selection of Swrupa Mahasangha
Cuttack City-1 by DSWO Cuttack &
CDM & PHO Cuttack is directed the
under singed supply of diet to patient
& inmates to LHH Cuttack. The under
singed discussed with Swrupa
Mahasangha & directed them to
supply the dietary articles as per
Govt. norm to LHH Cuttack and
Swarupa Mahasangha started
preliminary (wrongly typed as
prilmenry) process to supply the Diet
tomorrow.
Page 8 of 18

This kind information &
necessary action.”
(Emphasis supplied)
6. At this stage, learned Counsel for the
State/Opposite Parties, drawing attention of
this Court to the instruction for enforcement of
Model Code of Conduct issued by the Election
Commission of India as at Annexure-5 series
submits, the Model Code of Conduct came into
effect on and from 16.03.2024, whereas the
tender process for awarding the work of
supply of dietary articles in favour of the
S.H.G namely, Swarupa Mahasangha,
Cuttack was finalized much before the said
date, pursuant to which the impugned letter
dated 02.04.2024 was issued by the
Superintendent, Leprosy Home & Hospital,
Cuttack to the present Petitioners advising
them to stop supply of dietary articles w.e.f.
14.04.2024.
7. Learned Counsel for the State, drawing
attention of this Court to the Instruction at
Serial No.2, which is based on Election
Commission’s letter dated 09.03.2004,
further submits, as per the Model Code of
Conduct, the work which has already been
started from the ground may be continued, no
fresh work shall be started till the completion
of elections and tenders are not to be finalized
during the period of elections. Since in the
present case the tender was finalized much
before the Code of Conduct came into effect,
there was no illegality in issuance of the
impugned communication dated 02.04.2024
advising the Petitioners to stop supply of
dietary articles w.e.f. 14.04.2024. However, in
view of the specific allegation made in Para-12
of the Writ Petition that the tender process
was only finalized on 27.03.2024, which is
admittedly after the Code of Conduct came to
effect from 16.03.2024, a further query being
made by this Court as to whether the issuance
of work order also includes under the purview
of finalization of the tender process and
whether any work order has been issued in
favour of the S.H.G. namely, Swarupa
Mahasangha, Cuttack before the Code of
Conduct came into force, learned Counsel for
Page 9 of 18

the State prays for further time to take
instruction and file Counter Affidavit.
8. Though in the impugned communication
dated 02.04.2024, as at Annexure-6, the
Petitioners were instructed to stop supply of
dietary articles to the Leprosy Home &
Hospital, Cuttack w.e.f. 14.04.2024, as per
the communication dated 16.04.2024, as
extracted above, admittedly they are
supplying the dietary articles as on date and
supply of the dietary articles to the Leprosy
Home & Hospital, Cuttack cannot be stalled
unless and until some alternative arrangement
is made.
9. In view of the specific allegations made in
the Writ Petition by the Petitioners as to
issuance of the impugned communication
during operation of the Code of Conduct and
finalization of the tender process during
operation of the Code of Conduct, this Court
is inclined to pass an order as an interim,
to allow the Petitioners to supply the
dietary articles to Leprosy Home &
Hospital, Cuttack as before, till the next
date
.”
(Emphasis supplied)
8. The said interim order was passed on
16.04.2024, based on the Affidavit filed by the
Petitioners so also instruction imparted vide letter
No.294 dated 16.04.2024 by the Superintendent,
Leprosy Home & Hospital, Cuttack to the Office of
learned Advocate General, and it was well within
the knowledge of the State Counsel regarding
such interim order . Admittedly, the S.H.G namely,
Swarupa Mahasangha, Cuttack was permitted by
the alleged Contemnor for supply of diets w.e.f.
17.04.2024, which is after the interim order
passed by this Court dated 16.04.2024. That
apart, the alleged Contemnor neither acted in
terms of the order passed by this Court on
26.02.2026 in the present proceeding, nor
remained present before this Court on
12.03.2026, despite repeated request made by
the learned State Counsel, which was recorded
vide order dated 12.03.2026, extracted above .
9. That apart, this Court is unable to
appreciate as to how an Affidavit could be filed
by the alleged Contemnor on 12.03.2026
Page 10 of 18

remaining at his home, when it is not his case
that the Notary Public went to his home for
swearing the affidavit.
10. Hence, this Court is of prima facie view that
the conduct of the Opposite Party-alleged
Contemnor amounts to willful flouting of order
dated 16.04.2024 passed by this Court in I.A.
No.5037 of 2024 & W.P.(C) No.8855 of 2024. That
apart, the conduct of the Opposite Party-alleged
Contemnor in not acting in terms of order dated
26.02.2026, so also not appearing before this
Court on 12.03.2026, despite request being made
by the learned State Counsel, even though he was
available on the said date at his residence, which
is nearer to this Court, is further contemptuous.
11. Accordingly, the Opposite Party-alleged
Contemnor is directed to file Show Cause as to
why he shall not be punished under Section 12 of
the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 for wilful
flouting of order dated 16.04.2024 passed in
W.P.(C) No.8855 of 2024 & I.A. No.5037 of 2024,
so also order dated 26.02.2026 passed in this
Case, within two weeks hence after serving copy
thereof on the learned Counsel for the Petitioners.
12. At this stage learned Additional Standing
Counsel for the State submits, since the Opposite
Party-alleged Contemnor is not acting in terms of
the instructions imparted by the State Counsel
and that apart, as this Court has taken a prima
facie view that the conduct of the Opposite Party-
alleged Contemnor is contemptuous, the State is
no more going to defend the Opposite Party in this
contempt proceeding. If he so desires, he himself,
either in person or by engaging a lawyer, has to
participate in the present proceeding to defend his
case.
13. Hence, Office is directed to communicate a
copy of this order urgently to the Opposite Party-
alleged Contemnor in order to enable him to file
Show Cause, as directed above.
14. Personal appearance of the Opposite Party-
alleged Contemnor is dispensed with for the time
being.
rd
15. The matter be listed on 23 April, 2026.”


(Emphasis supplied)

5. On being so ordered, the Opposite Party-Contemnor
filed a Show Cause Affidavit on 14.05.2026, indicating
Page 11 of 18

therein that he is conscious that the said interim order
dated 16.04.2024 was binding upon him and compliance of
the said order of this Court is not a matter of discretion,
but of solemn legal and constitutional obligation. Further,
it has been stated in the said Show Cause Affidavit that
non-compliance of the said interim order was not actuated
by any deliberate, wilful, or contumacious intent to disobey
or disrespect the powers of this Court. The same was due
to oversightness and various other unavoidable reasons. It
has also been contended in the said Show Cause Affidavit
that the Contemnor tenders his most sincere, unqualified
and unconditional apology to the Court for the failure to
comply with the interim order dated 16.04.2024. It has also
been stated in the Show Cause Affidavit that the
Contemnor is deeply remorseful and acknowledges that
such conduct is liable for punishment. But, the Contemnor
pleads before this Court to take a lenient view in the matter
considering the surrounding factors. It has also been stated
in the Show Cause Affidavit that the Contemnor has
highest regards to the orders passed by this Court and
would never violate the order and it has been undertaken
that he shall abide by and comply with all future orders
and directions issued by this Court in letter and spirit.
Such default shall not recur in any manner whatsoever and
the Contemnor is fully aware of the consequences of any
further non-compliance and gives his undertaking in all
sincerity. Accordingly, it has been prayed to forgive the
Contemnor and drop the Contempt proceeding.
6. The record indicates that Swarupa Mahasangha was
permitted to commence the supply from 17.04.2024. The
Page 12 of 18

Contemnor’s affidavit dated 12.03.2026 states, in
substance, that the Petitioners were permitted to supply
diet only until 16.04.2024 and that the SHG thereafter
supplied the dietary articles. The contemporaneous letter
dated 16.04.2024 sent by the Contemnor to the State
Counsel, the presence of State Counsel when the interim
order was passed, and the subsequent conduct recorded in
the order-sheets, including order dated 26.03.2026, have
also been considered.
7. Section 2(b) of the Act, 1971 requires wilful
disobedience. In view of the principles in Ashok Paper
Kamgar Union v. Dharam Godha : (2003) 11 SCC 1 , and
Niaz Mohammad v. State of Haryana : (1994) 6 SCC
332 , the Court must be satisfied not merely that the order
was not complied with, but that the disobedience was
intentional and not the result of a genuine inability or
compelling circumstance. The order dated 16.04.2024 was
clear as to the interim arrangement. If the Contemnor
considered the prior selection of the SHG or the
administrative communication to be inconsistent with the
Court’s direction, he was required to seek clarification or
modification and could not unilaterally act contrary to the
subsisting order.
8. Respect should always be shown to the Court. If any
party is aggrieved by an order, which in its opinion, is
wrong or against the rules or implementation is neither
practicable nor feasible, it should approach the Court
immediately seeking modification/clarification or vacation
of the interim order or challenge the said order before the
appropriate forum.
Page 13 of 18

9. Further, apology is an act of regret. Unless apology is
offered at the earliest opportunity and in good grace and
the apology is shown of penitence, is liable to be rejected. If
the apology is offered at the time when the Contemnor
finds that the Court is going to impose punishment, it
ceases to be an apology and becomes an act of cringing
coward.
10. Though, vide Show Case Affidavit dated. 18.08.2025,
initially the Contemnor pleaded not guilty and apart from
justifying his action to be correct, took a stand that he had
no knowledge about the interim order of stay dated
16.04.2024, but in his subsequent Show Cause Affidavit
dated 14.05.2026, which was filed by him pursuant to a
detailed order dated 26.03.2026 extracted above, he
pleaded guilty and has begged unconditional apology.
11. Having considered the Show-Cause Affidavits dated
18.08.2025 and 14.05.2026, the material on record and
the submissions of learned Counsel for the parties, this
Court finds that the Contemnor had knowledge about the
interim order dated 16.04.2024, was in a position to
comply with it, and intentionally permitted the SHG to
supply the dietary articles from 17.04.2024, instead of
continuing the arrangement, as directed by this Court. The
explanation of oversight and unavoidable reasons does not,
on the material established, satisfactorily explain the
departure from the express judicial direction. The Court
accordingly records a finding of wilful disobedience
constituting civil contempt within Section 2(b) of the Act,
1971.

Page 14 of 18

11.1. That apart, vide order dated 13.05.2024, a direction
was given to the Opposite Party-Contemnor to file Show
Cause Affidavit within a period of four weeks w.e.f.
13.05.2024. Thereafter, vide order dated 28.07.2025,
again further two weeks’ time was granted to the Opposite
Party-Contemnor to file the Show Cause Affidavit. Instead
of filing the Show Cause Affidavit within two weeks w.e.f
28.07.2025, Show Cause Affidavit was filed just one day
before listing of the matter, i.e., on 18.08.2025. Neither any
application was filed for acceptance of Show Cause
Affidavit filed beyond the extended period, nor the Opposite
Party-Contemnor remained present in the Court in terms of
order dated 28.07.2025. That apart, the Opposite Party-
Contemnor neither acted in terms of the order passed by
this Court on 26.02.2026, nor remained present before this
Court on 12.03.2026, despite repeated request made by the
learned State Counsel, which was recorded vide order
dated 12.03.2026.
11.2. A query being made as to the reason of absence of
the Opposite Party-Contemnor, learned State Counsel
submitted that, as the Opposite Party did not file his
Response within the extended period, despite repeated
request and instruction to the Opposite Party-Contemnor
to ensure his presence before this Court on 12.03.2026, he
did not bother to act in terms of such instruction/request.
Though the Contemnor allegedly sweared the Show Cause
Affidavit on 12.03.2026 before the Notary Public and was
also available in his residence at Meria Bazar, Kataka,
which is nearer to this Court, but did not bother to appear
before this Court despite repeated request made by the
Page 15 of 18

learned State Counsel. The same was duly recorded vide
order dated 12.03.2026. Accordingly, this Court had to
make a request to the Deputy Commissioner of Police,
Kataka vide order dated 12.03.2026 to ensure Contemnor’s
presence before the Court on 26.03.2026, on which date
the Contemnor finally appeared before this Court, being
produced by the I.I.C, CRI Police Station.
12. Hence, this Court is further satisfied that, for the
reasons recorded hereinbefore, and having regard to the
practical consequences flowing from the substitution of a
different supplier immediately after the interim direction
was issued, the conduct of the Contemnor is of such a
nature as to substantially interfere, or tend substantially to
interfere, with the due course of justice, within the
meaning of Section 13(a) of the Act, 1971.
13. The Contemnor has tendered an unconditional
apology and sought a lenient view. Section 12(1) of the Act,
1971 permits the Court to discharge the Contemnor or
remit punishment on an apology to its satisfaction, and its
explanation requires a bona fide apology to be considered
on its merits. As per the settled position of law, the Court
has to assess the apology in the context of the timing of its
tendering, the explanation offered, the Contemnor’s
conduct and the degree of acknowledgment of the breach.
14. Having considered the materials on record and the
explanation offered by the Contemnor, this Court is
satisfied that the disobedience of the order dated
16.04.2024 was conscious, wilful and deliberate, and is not
attributable to any bona fide misunderstanding or inability
to comply. The said conduct, as well as subsequent
Page 16 of 18

conducts of the Contemnor during pendency of the
contempt proceeding, as detailed in order dated
26.03.2026, vide which the Contemnor was asked to show
cause, therefore, constitutes civil contempt within the
meaning of Section 2(b) of the Act, 1971. Such conduct
cannot be countenanced, as it strikes at the efficacy of
judicial orders and the rule of law.
15. In the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court
is further satisfied that an order merely imposing a fine
would not meet the ends of justice and that detention in a
civil prison is warranted. Though Section 12(3) of the Act,
1971 mandates maximum six months civil imprisonment,
keeping in view the admitted fact on record that the
Contemnor is a Class-I officer under the pay role of State
Government and is a doctor, taking a lenient view, and
bearing in mind the circumstances placed before the Court,
this Court directs, in exercise of power under Section 12(3)
of the said Act, 1971, that the Contemnor shall be detained
in a civil prison for a period of 1(one) day. In addition, the
Contemnor, who is a Government employee, shall pay costs
from his own pocket quantified at Rs.20,000/- (Rupees
twenty thousand only), which shall be deposited with the
Orissa High Court Advocates’ Welfare Fund within a period
of four weeks hence. The Contemnor shall place the proof
of such deposit on record within the aforesaid period.
16. The Registry shall ensure that the operative
directions, the amount of costs, and the commitment
warrant in conformity with the provisions enshrined in
Chapter XVII of the Rules of The High Court of Orissa,
1948 and applicable law. The Petitioner is to deposit
Page 17 of 18

Rs.500/- with the Registry within a week hence towards
subsistence allowance to be paid to the Contemnor, in
terms of Sub Rule (C) of Rule 19, under Chapter XVII, of
the Rules of The High Court of Orissa,1948.

17. The Contempt Petition is disposed of in the above
terms.





Kanhu
(S. K. MISHRA)
JUDGE

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: KANHU BEHERA
Designation: JUNIOR STENOGRAPHER
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack.
Date: 20-Nov-2026 17:50:51
Page 18 of 18