M/S Goodluck India Limited vs Union Of India
- Court
- Supreme Court
Non-Reportable
2026 INSC 821
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
EXTRAORDINARY/CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (C) No.24550 OF 2025
M/s Goodluck India Limited & Anr.
…Petitioners
Versus
Union of India & Ors.
…Respondents
With
Special Leave Petition (C) No.26411 of 2026
And
Civil Appeal No...........of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No. 26336 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No...........of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26592 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No...........of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26914-26915 of 2026 ]
[ @ Diary No. 53310-2025 ]
Civil Appeal Nos..............of 2026
( @Special Leave Petition (C) Nos. 26350-26391/2026 ]
Civil Appeal No...........of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26344 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No...........of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26345 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No...........of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.10125 of 2026 ]
Page 1 of 8
SLP(C) No.24550 of 2025 Etc.
Civil Appeal Nos.................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) Nos.26597-26681 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No.................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26346 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No.................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26337 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal Nos...........of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) Nos.15317-15320 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal Nos..................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) Nos.26686-26687 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No...................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26930 of 2026 ]
[ @ Diary No.18356 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No....................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26343 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No....................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26710 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No.................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26747-26749 of 2026 ]
[ @ Diary No.20839 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal Nos...................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) Nos.19077-19078 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No....................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26339 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No.................of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26341 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No...........of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26858-26864 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No...............of 2026
Page 2 of 8
SLP(C) No.24550 of 2025 Etc.
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26858-26864 of 2026 ]
[ @ Diary No.21412 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No..............of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.23504 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No..............of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26916-26928 of 2026 ]
[ @ Diary No.35275 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No..............of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26929 of 2026 ]
[ @ Diary No.36240 of 2026 ]
Civil Appeal No..............of 2026
[ @ Special Leave Petition (C) No.26878 of 2026 ]
[ @ Diary No.16551 of 2026 ]
O R D E R
Special Leave Petition (C) No.24550 of 2025
And
Special Leave Petition (C) No.26411 of 2026 :
In the above batch, the challenge by the Union of India and the
Department is against the impugned judgment having held the
omission of Rule 96(10) of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST)
Rules, 2017 to be applicable to every pending proceedings as on the
date of its omission. In two SLPs by the assesses, numbered as SLP (C)
No.24550 of 2025 and SLP(C) No.26411 of 2026 the challenge is against
the very vires and validity of Rule 96(10), which the High Court had
refused to consider, since it was applied to all pending proceedings. In
the nature of the orders to be passed by us, the two SLPs referred to
Page 3 of 8
SLP(C) No.24550 of 2025 Etc.
hereinabove are dismissed as infructuous.
2. Leave granted in the rest of the matters.
3. The issue arising is whether sub-rule (10) of Rule 96 as omitted by
Notification No.20/2024 with effect from 08.10.2024 would inure to the
benefit of the assessee in the pending proceedings, wherein there was
a claim of refund of integrated tax paid on goods and services exported
out of India, to be considered without the restriction under sub-rule (10)
being applied. The sub-rule having been omitted, suffice it to notice
that the applicability of refund under Rule 96 was without the rigor of
the person claiming such refund, having received supplies after
availing benefits available by virtue of the notifications specified in
clause (a) or the benefits available under the notifications specified
under clause (b). The sub-rule having been omitted without a saving
clause it applies squarely to all the proceedings pending, is the
contention of the assessees, which was sought to be resisted by the
learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the Union of India.
th
4. Sri S. Dwarakanath, learned ASG took us to the minutes of the 54
th
meeting of the GST Council held on 09 September, 2024 at New Delhi,
fairly conceding that the recommendation is only advisory and it is not
mandatory to accept it. In any event the recommendation reads as
under, insofar as the omission of Rule 96(10) is concerned:
Page 4 of 8
SLP(C) No.24550 of 2025 Etc.
“The Law Committee observed that operation of rule 96(10)
is leading to unnecessary complications without any intended
benefit being served and therefore recommended that rule
96(10), rule 89(4A) & rule 89(4B) of the CGST Rules, 2017 may
be omitted with prospective effect and that consequential
amendments in clause (b) of sub-rule (4B) of rule 86, clause
B, clause C and clause E of sub-rule (4) of rule 89 and
Explanation (a) to sub-rule (5) of rule 89 of CGST Rules may
be made.”
The emphasis on the recommendation is to persuade us to apply
it prospectively only, as the Council visualised it, in so far as its
application is concerned.
5. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents on the
other hand, relies on Kolhapur Canesugar Works Ltd v. Union of
1
India . Therein the question raised was the refund demanded under
Rule 10A of the Central Excise Rules, 1944, which though prevalent at
the time of issuance of show cause notice, before the final order was
passed, it stood omitted. The newly brought in rule did not have
provision for enforcing such refund. It was argued for the Department
that the introduction of Section 11A, created a fiction by virtue of which
proceedings under Rule 10 are deemed to be proceedings under Rule
11A of the Act. The trite principle in common law that the effect of
repealing a statute or deleting a provision, is to obliterate it from the
1
(2000) 2 SCC 536
Page 5 of 8
SLP(C) No.24550 of 2025 Etc.
statute book, as completely as if it had never existed was highlighted
by this Court. An exemption, as engrafted by the provisions of Section
6 of the General Clauses Act; though Section 6 was held to be not
applicable in the given circumstances of omission of a rule, should have
been incorporated as a saving clause to facilitate continuance of
pending proceedings despite the omission, failing which all actions
would come to a stop when the omission is given effect. It was held so
under paragraph 36
“36. In the case in hand Rule 10 or Rule 10-A is neither a
"Central Act" nor a "regulation" as defined in the Act. It may
be a Rule under Section 3(51) of the Act. Section 6 is
applicable where any Central Act or regulation made after
commencement of the General Clauses Act repeals any
enactment. It is not applicable in the case of omission of a
"rule".
6. It was held by the Constitution Bench that if on omission of a rule,
there was a provision for continuance of the proceedings already
initiated or if by incorporation of a provision in the statute there was a
legal device adopted, creating a fiction by virtue of which proceedings
under the omitted rule could be continued; only then proceedings
initiated under the omitted rule could be continued.
7. The Constitution Bench decision applies squarely in the above
case. We may also observe that even going by the recommendations
Page 6 of 8
SLP(C) No.24550 of 2025 Etc.
as extracted hereinabove, sub-rule (10) of Rule 96 was omitted because
it was ‘ leading to unnecessary complications without any intended benefit
being served’ (sic) . As fairly submitted by the learned ASG the
legislature has not brought in any saving clause or a sunset clause,
when sub-rule (10) of Rule 96 was omitted. The recommendation that
the omission should be prospective is also advisory in nature and does
not bind the rule making authority. The intention to omit the rule without
any saving clause was to bring to an end, the unnecessary
complications once and for all and the intention cannot be to keep alive
the unnecessary complications insofar as the pending proceedings are
concerned.
8. We find no good reason to interfere with the well-reasoned
judgment of the High Court. We are told that there are many
proceedings pending before the various High Courts and conflicting
decisions have also been passed. We hope that such proceedings
would get closure with this judgment.
9. The Registry is directed to send a copy of this order to all the High
Courts. The Registry of the High Courts will ensure that the cases
relating to the subject issue of omission of Rule 96(10) would be placed
before the Courts having roster, after taking appropriate orders from
the Hon’ble Chief Justice of the respective High Courts, expeditiously
Page 7 of 8
SLP(C) No.24550 of 2025 Etc.
to bring quietus in the subject litigation.
10. The appeals are dismissed.
11. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
…..……….…….……….……. J.
(J.B. PARDIWALA)
….……….…….……….……. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)
NEW DELHI
AUGUST 06, 2026.
Page 8 of 8
SLP(C) No.24550 of 2025 Etc.