RAKESH CHOUHAN vs STATE OF HP AND OTHERS
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
CWP No.5637 of 2026
th
Decided on 09 September 2026
Rakesh Chouhan
…Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…Respondents
Coram
High Court of H.P.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge
1
Whether approved for reporting? Yes
For the petitioner : Mr. Ashwani K. Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondents : Mr. Pushpinder Jaswal, Additional
Advocate General, for
respondents No.1 to 4.
: Mr. Kunal Thakur, Advocate, vice
Mr. Ajay Chauhan, Advocate, for
respondent No.5.
: Mr. Neeraj Sharma, Advocate, for
respondent No.6.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge (Oral )
By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for the following reliefs:-
“i. That the impugned act of the respondent
authorities of altering/fabricating with the population
census of 2011 taken as base for preparing reservation
roster for local body Elections of NP Shahpur to be held
in 2026 be declared illegal and hence, be quashed and
set aside.
ii. Further the reservation roster prepared by the
respondent authorities on the basis of
fabricated/manipulated population census of 2011 for
NP Shahpur to be commenced in the year 2026 be also
declared illegal and hence, be quashed and set aside.
::: Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 11:38:27 :::CIS
2
iii. Writ of mandamus be issued by directing the
respondent authorities to prepare the fresh reservation
roster for NP Shahpur strictly in accordance with actual
census of 2011.”
2. The gist of the grievance of the petitioner is that, for
High Court of H.P.
the purpose of holding elections for Nagar Panchayat/Municipal
Council, Shahpur, as it then was in the year 2021, the census
of the year 2011 was relied upon.
3. According to the petitioner, in terms of the 2011
census, as the population of Scheduled Caste was maximum in
Ward No. 2, i.e., Hara Ward, the same should have been
reserved for Scheduled Caste when elections were held for
Nagar Panchayat Shahpur in the year 2020-21. However,
erroneously Ward No. 3, Jhular was reserved for Scheduled
Caste category. Now, when the process stood initiated again for
holding elections, at the time of filing of the writ petition, for the
now Municipal Council, Shahpur, despite the fact that Hara
should have been reserved for the Scheduled Caste category
in the year 2021, Hara ward is being reserved for Scheduled
Caste (Women), which act of the respondents, according to the
petitioner, is bad in law.
::: Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 11:38:27 :::CIS
3
High Court of H.P.
4. Mr. Ashwani Sharma, learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the petitioner belongs to the
unreserved category and as a result of the reservation of his
ward, i.e., Ward No. 2 (Hara), he has been denied the
opportunity to contest the election. He submits that on this
count, the present petition deserves to be allowed, in terms of
the prayer made in the writ petition.
5. On the other hand, learned Additional Advocate
General referred to the reply filed on behalf of the respondents
and submitted that the present writ petition is completely
misconceived. He submitted that the elections of Nagar
Panchayat, Shahpur in the year 2020 were conducted on the
basis of the Census of the year 2011 by taking the base year to
be 2010 and the elections of Municipal Council, Shahpur held
in the year 2026 were also on the basis of the Census of 2011,
but the base year was 2025. He submitted that the reservation
of the Wards was strictly done as per the population of the
categories of various castes and thus, the contention of the
petitioner that the respondents have wrongly applied the
::: Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 11:38:27 :::CIS
4
Census of 2011 or there is some wrong doing in the reservation
High Court of H.P.
of the Wards is completely incorrect. He argued that reservation
roster has been correctly applied.
6. In rebuttal, Mr. Ashwani Sharma, learned counsel
for the petitioner has reiterated that the reservation of the
Wards has been done in a totally illegal manner and as the
petitioner has been denied his right to contest election, he has
the locus to maintain this writ petition.
7. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and
we have also carefully gone through the averments made in the
pleadings as also the documents appended therewith.
8. It is not in dispute that in the year 2020, when the
elections were held for Nagar Panchayat, Shahpur, the same
was on the basis of the 2011 census. It is also a matter of
record that for the purpose of the said elections, the Wards of
Nagar Panchayat Shahpur, as it then was, were reserved as
under:-
Ward No. 1 : Siholpuri (General Women)
Ward No. 2 : Hara (General Women)
Ward No. 3 : Jhular (Scheduled Caste Men)
Ward No. 4 : Shahpur (Scheduled Tribe Men)
::: Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 11:38:27 :::CIS
5
Ward No. 5 : Chandroon (General Women)
High Court of H.P.
Ward No. 6 : Gorda (General Women)
Ward No. 7 : Manjhair (General)
9. The petitioner, at the relevant time, did not agitate
the reservation of the Wards for the categories mentioned
hereinabove in the mode and manner in which they were
reserved and elections were held for Nagar Panchayat,
Shahpur.
10. It is now, when the elections were due again in the
year 2026, that the petitioner approached this Court by way of
this writ petition in the month of April 2026, raising the issues
flagged therein.
11. A perusal Annexure R-3/6 and Annexure R-3/7,
appended with the reply of respondent No.3 demonstrate that
the reservation roster of Nagar Panchayat, Shahpur in first term
for the elections held in the year 2020 was determined as per
Annexure R-3/7 and elections were held in the year 2026 in
terms of Annexure R-3/6. This is so mentioned in Para-8 of the
reply filed by respondent No. 3.
12. A perusal of Annexure R-3/6 demonstrates that
therein the total Scheduled Caste population of village Hara is
::: Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 11:38:27 :::CIS
6
mentioned as 25.63% and that of village Jhular is mentioned as
High Court of H.P.
21.42%. Now, these two Wards have the maximum population
of Scheduled Caste amongst all the seven Wards.
13. Similarly, a perusal of Annexure R-3/7 demonstrates
that in terms thereof, the Scheduled Caste population of Hara
therein was mentioned as 15.23% and that of Jhular was
mentioned as 21.42%. In terms of Annexure R-3/7 also, at the
relevant time, these two Wards were having the maximum
number of Scheduled Caste population.
14. In terms of Annexure R-3/6 and R-3/7, on both the
occasion, the reservation of the Ward for Scheduled Caste
category has been done of the Ward, which is reflected to be
having maximum number of Scheduled Caste population.
15. The genesis of determining whether these figures
are correct or not is not the subject matter of dispute before us,
because, these figures stand spelled out in the reply and no
rejoinder thereto has been filed by the petitioner and we have
no reason to disbelieve what has been submitted on behalf of
the State, because, per se , there is no allegation of any mala
fide against anyone to convince us that this has been purposely
::: Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 11:38:27 :::CIS
7
done to subvert the right of the petitioner.
High Court of H.P.
16. The above demonstrates that both in the elections
of 2020 as also 2026, the reservation of the Ward for
Scheduled Caste category, may be for a lady candidate or
otherwise, was based on the percentage of the said category in
the Ward concerned. Either way, as the petitioner happens to
be a candidate belonging to General category, he could not
have contested the election from the said Ward.
17. Therefore, we are of the considered view that no
relief as prayed for in this writ petition can be granted to the
petitioner.
18. The petitioner has not been able to substantiate, as
has been alleged in the writ petition, that the authorities have
fabricated the population census of 2011 or that even the
reservation roster stands prepared on the basis of fabricated/
manipulated population census of 2011.
19. In light of the fact that both Hara Ward as well as
Jhular Ward were having the maximum population of
Scheduled Caste residents and as in the year 2020,
Jhular Ward was reserved for Scheduled Caste category,
::: Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 11:38:27 :::CIS
8
the reservation of Hara Ward in the 2026 election for the said
High Court of H.P.
category cannot be interfered with by holding the same to be
bad in law.
20. In light of the above observations and more so the
fact that now elections have already been held for Municipal
Council, Shahpur, we do not see any reason to intervene or
interfere with the results in the mode and manner the petitioner
wishes the Court to do so, therefore, the petition is being
dismissed. No order as to costs.
21. However, before parting with the judgment, we may
observe that in light of the fact that the determination of roster
is also determinative of the fact as to who is included and who
is excluded from contesting the election, as has been
suggested by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
respondents are called upon to ensure that there is sufficient
transparency in the matter, so that the mode and manner in
which the Wards are determined for the purpose of reservation
can be easily ascertained by one and all, so that the same
leaves no room for any speculation etc. How this can be
ensured is for the respondents to determine.
::: Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 11:38:27 :::CIS
9
22. With these observations, the petition stands
High Court of H.P.
disposed of, so also pending miscellaneous application, if any.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
(Yogesh Jaswal)
Judge
September 09, 2026
(Vinod)
::: Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 11:38:27 :::CIS