LAXMI NARAYAN PANDA vs STATE OF ODISHA
- Court
- Odisha High Court
WP(C)/2605/2022
ODHC010056912022
2026:OHC:315
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C). No. 2605 of 2022
CNR No. ODHC010056912022
(An application under Articles 226 and 227 of Constitution
of India)
AFR Laxmi Narayan Panda ....... Petitioner
- Versus-
State of Odisha & Others ....... Opposite Parties
_______________________________________________________
For Petitioner : Mr. D. Mohapatra, Sr. Advocate, with
Mr. A. Dash, Advocate
For Opp. Parties : Mr. S.N. Patnaik,
[Additional Government Advocate]
Mr. S. Dash, Advocate [For O.P No.5]
CORAM:
MR.JUSTICE SASHIKANTA MISHRA
JUDGMENT
20.11.2026
SASHIKANTA MISHRA, J. The petitioner seeks to challenge the
order dated 30.09.2021 passed by the Tahasildar, Banapur,
in Misc. Case No. 1 of 2021, whereby his application seeking
correction of the ROR in respect of the case land, on the
basis of the pre-existing Settlement ROR was rejected. The
1 17
Page of
petitioner also seeks a direction to the opposite parties to
correct the computerized ROR available in the Bhulekh
portal in conformity with the ROR prepared by the
Settlement Authority, on the ground that the discrepancy in
the computerized record arose during the process of
computerisation and does not reflect the entries in the
original settlement record.
2. The facts of the case, briefly stated, are that the
land in question comprises Khata No. 79, Plot Nos. 14, 16
and 18, situated in Mouza-Cheunkasahi, Thana-Banapur,
District-Khurda, covering a total area of Ac.1.485. The
petitioner claims that, in the Settlement ROR prepared in
the year 1962, the land was recorded in the name of
Kapileswar Dev, Marfat Ladukishore Bhopa and Others, with
the petitioner's father, Bhagabat Panda, recorded as a raiyat
in respect of the land. According to the petitioner, the land
was originally held under a service tenure and following the
proceedings in OLR Case No.40 of 1972 under Section 4(9)
of the OLR Act, the rent payable in respect of the land was
converted from kind to cash, while the status of his
2 17
Page of
predecessor as a raiyat continued. It is further stated that
the settlement entries and the order passed in the OLR
proceeding attained finality and were never set aside or
modified by any competent authority. During the process of
computerisation of the land records and their incorporation
in the Bhulekh portal, the entries in the tenancy column of
the computerized ROR came to be altered, resulting in the
name of the deity being reflected in place of the entries
appearing in the original Settlement ROR. Aggrieved by the
discrepancy, the petitioner approached the revenue
authorities seeking correction of the computerized ROR in
conformity with the original settlement record. He also
pursued the matter under the RTI Act, pursuant to which an
enquiry was conducted by the Director, Land Records and
Survey. The petitioner relies on the enquiry report and the
subsequent communications issued by the revenue
authorities, including the communications dated 21.09.2019
and 29.09.2020, indicating that the discrepancy in the
computerized record required correction. The petitioner had
earlier approached this Court in W.P.(C) No.32517 of 2020,
3 17
Page of
whereby this Court by order dated 08.01.2021 disposed of
the writ petition with a direction to the Tahasildar to take
necessary steps in the matter in the light of the enquiry
report and the communications referred to therein, as
expeditiously as possible, without expressing any opinion on
the merits of the petitioner's claim. Pursuant thereto, the
Tahasildar registered Misc. Case No.1 of 2021 and after
consideration of the matter, passed order dated 30.09.2021
rejecting the petitioner's claim. Said order is impugned in
the present writ petition.
3. Counter affidavit has been filed by Tahalsildar,
Banapur stating that the impugned order was passed in
compliance with the direction issued in W.P.(C) No.32517 of
2020. It is stated that, under the original Settlement ROR,
the deity and its Marfatdars were recorded in the tenant
column of Khewat No.2, while the Government was recorded
in the Zamindar column of Khewat No.1, and the petitioner's
father, Bhagabat Panda, was recorded in subsidiary Khata
No.79 as an under-raiyat under the deity. It is stated that
OLR Case No.40 of 1972 only converted rent from kind to
4 17
Page of
cash without conferring any raiyati rights on the petitioner's
father or the petitioner and under-raiyati rights are neither
heritable nor transferable. It is also stated that the entry of
the deceased father's name in the ROR was erroneous and
liable to be deleted. Reliance is also placed on the pending
proceeding in O.A. No.66 of 2017 before the Commissioner
of Endowments under Section 19 of the Odisha Hindu
Religious Endowments Act, 1951, to dispute the petitioner's
claim over the case land.
4. Counter affidavit has also been filed by the
private Opposite Party No. 5, Marfatdars supporting the
stand taken by the Tahasildar. The private Opposite Party
also refers to the earlier revenue proceedings concerning
correction of the ROR, the withdrawal and disposal of the
earlier writ petitions, and the pending proceeding in O.A.
No.66 of 2017 before the Commissioner of Endowments,
seeking permission to alienate the deity's property.
5. Rejoinder affidavits have been filed by the
petitioner in reply to the counter affidavits of the Tahasildar
and the private Opposite Party No.5, stating that the
5 17
Page of
impugned order is without jurisdiction, as the Tahasildar
initiated and adjudicated the Misc. Case without referring to
any provision of law. It is stated that the direction issued by
this Court in W.P.(C) No.32517 of 2020 required correction
of the computerized ROR in conformity with the original
Settlement ROR, in the light of the enquiry report and the
subsequent communications of the revenue authorities, and
did not authorise adjudication of rights over the case land.
The petitioner disputes the description of his father as an
under-raiyat and also states that his predecessor was a
raiyat/tenure-holder paying Sanja . It is also stated that the
order passed in OLR Case No.40 of 1972 attained finality
and the pending proceeding under the Odisha Hindu
Religious Endowments Act cannot defeat the petitioner's
claim or justify alteration of the existing settlement entries.
6. Heard Mr. D. Mohapatra, learned Senior
Counsel, with Mr. A. Dash, learned counsel for the
Petitioner; Mr. S. Das, learned counsel for Opposite Party
No.5 and Mr. S.N. Patnaik, learned Additional Government
Advocate for the State.
6 17
Page of
7. Mr. Mohaptra would argue that the grievance of
the petitioner is confined to correction of the computerized
ROR in conformity with the original Settlement ROR of 1962
and does not involve adjudication of any fresh claim of title
or tenancy. He submits that the entries in the original
Settlement ROR, read with the order passed in OLR Case
No.40 of 1972, clearly shows the status of the petitioner's
predecessor as a raiyat in respect of the case land. Said
entries and the order having attained finality, the Tahasildar
had no authority, in a proceeding initiated for correction of
the computerized ROR, to reopen or unsettle the same. He
also argues that this Court, in W.P.(C) No.32517 of 2020,
had directed the Tahasildar to take necessary steps in the
light of the enquiry report and the subsequent
communications of the revenue authorities, which had
identified the discrepancy in the computerized record.
Instead of examining the limited issue of such discrepancy
and taking corrective steps, the Tahasildar proceeded to
adjudicate the rival claims over the land and reject the
7 17
Page of
petitioner's application on grounds beyond the scope of the
proceeding.
8. Per contra, Mr. Patnaik, learned Additional
Government Advocate submits that the impugned order was
passed by the Tahasildar after examining the original
Settlement ROR and the revenue records. He argues that the
petitioner's father was recorded only as an under-raiyat
under the deity and the order passed in OLR Case No.40 of
1972 only converted the rent payable in kind into cash,
without conferring any raiyati rights upon him. He also
submits that the Tahasildar was justified in declining the
correction sought, as the petitioner cannot claim any right
on the basis of the entry relating to his deceased father.
9. Mr. Dash, supports the submissions made by
Mr. Patnaik. He also submits that the petitioner's father was
only an under-raiyat under the deity and such a status did
not confer any heritable or transferable right on the
petitioner. He submits that the petitioner cannot seek
correction of the ROR so as to claim rights over the deity's
property, particularly when the earlier revenue proceedings
8 17
Page of
had not accepted his claim and the proceeding concerning
alienation of the deity's property is pending before the
Commissioner of Endowments.
10. Having heard the parties at length and on going
through the materials on record, this Court, at the outset,
would like to notice certain facts which are not in dispute
between the parties with regard to the original Settlement
ROR published in the year 1962. The Tahasildar, in the
impugned order, has himself recorded that Khata No.79 is a
subsidiary khata under Khata No.78. While the deity, Shree
Kapileswar Dev, through its Marfatdars, is recorded in the
tenant column of Khewat No.2 of Khata No.78, the name of
Bhagabat Panda, father of the petitioner, finds place in the
subsidiary Khata No.79 as a tenant under the deity, which
the Tahasildar has described as an under-raiyat or sub-
tenant.
11. Such being the factual position, this Court
would now like to discuss the law laid down by the Full
Bench of this Court in the case of Daitary Swain V.
9 17
Page of
1
Kartika Swain and others , wherein the Court considered
the status of a Sikimi tenant, being a form of sub-tenant or
under-raiyat, and whether Sikimi rights in respect of
agricultural land are heritable and transferable. On
consideration of the provisions of the OLR Act, particularly
Section 4(1)(i), as amended by Orissa Act 29 of 1976, the
Bench held that a Sikimi tenant is recognised as a sub-
tenant or under-raiyat and by virtue of the amendment, the
expression ‘and their successors-in-interest’ extends the
benefit of the provision to the successors-in-interest of such
sub-tenants or under-raiyats. It was accordingly held that
Sikimi rights in respect of agricultural land are heritable and
transferable. The Bench also clarified that the heritability
and transferability of the Sikimi interest do not depend on
the tenant having first obtained a declaration of raiyati
status under sub-Sections (5) to (8) of Section 4 of the OLR
Act. Such declaration may enlarge the nature of the interest
by recognising the person as a raiyat; its absence, however,
does not, by itself, extinguish the underlying Sikimi tenancy
1
O.J.C. No.13720 of 1997
10 17
Page of
or the right of succession thereto. The Bench, also, overruled
the contrary observations in the cases of Natabara Pandey
2
V. Sri Sri Tareswar Dev and others and Subal
3
Baliarsingh V. Chanchala Bewa and another to the
extent they held that Sikimi tenancy was neither heritable
nor transferable.
12. Now, coming to the facts of the present case, it
is not disputed that Khata No.79 is a subsidiary khata
under Khata No.78 and the Tahasildar himself has
described the interest of the petitioner's father as that of an
under-raiyat. The Tahasildar, however, has held that, under
the provisions of the OLR Act, under-raiyati rights in respect
of agricultural land are neither heritable nor transferable.
Such a proposition, being contrary to the law laid down in
Daitary Swain (Supra) , cannot be accepted.
13. However, the principal question which remains
to be addressed is that, although the petitioner's father was
recorded as an under-raiyat, he was never declared a raiyat
under the provisions of the OLR Act and, therefore, the
2
O.J.C. No.4349 of 1994
3
Vol.95 (2003) CLT 438
11 17
Page of
petitioner cannot claim any right by way of succession
through him.
14. Before proceeding further, it would be
appropriate to refer to clause (i) of sub-section (1) of Section
4 of the OLR Act, as it originally stood and as it came to be
amended from time to time. The relevant provisions read as
follows:-
“(i) Persons who are immediately before the
commencement of this Act in personal cultivation of
any land and recorded as sub-tenants or under-
raiyats in respect of such land in the record-of-rights
under any law in force in any part of the state.”
(as originally stood)
“(i) Subject to the provisions of sub-sections (5) to (8)
persons who are immediately before the
commencement of this Act in personal cultivation of
any land and recorded as sub-tenants or under-
raiyats in respect of such land in the record-of-rights
under any law in force in any part of the State.”
(as stood after amendment by Orissa Act 13 of
1965)
“(i) Subject to the provisions of Sub-sections (5) to (8)
persons who are in personal cultivation of any land
and recorded as sub-tenants or under-raiyats in
respect of such land in the record-of-rights under any
law in force in any part of the State and their
successions-in-interest.
[emphasis added]
Provided that nothing in this clause shall apply to
persons who are recorded as sub-tenants or under
raiyats after the 30th day of September, 1965 or to
their successor-in-interest if the land in respect of
which they have been so recorded belongs to a person
under disability or to a privileged raiyat.”
(as stood after amendment by Orissa Act 29 of
1976)
12 17
Page of
15. In order to understand the matter better, the
relevant provisions of Orissa Act 29 of 1976, which amended
Section-4 (1)(i) of the ‘OLR Act’ may also be referred to. The
same reads as follows:-
“3. In Section 4 of the principal Act,- (a) in sub-section (1),-
(i) X X X (ii) in clause (i) – (1) the words “immediately
before the commencement of this Act” shall be and shall
be deemed always to have been deleted; (2) the words
“and their successors-in-interest” shall be and shall be
deemed always to have been added at the end;”
16. A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions
would make it clear that, by virtue of the amendment
brought about by Orissa Act 29 of 1976, the words
‘immediately before the commencement of this Act’ were
deleted and the expression ‘and their successors-in-interest’
was added to clause (i) of sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the
OLR Act. The expression ‘successors-in-interest’ takes
within its fold the heirs as well as transferees of persons
covered by the provision. It, therefore, recognises the
succession and transfer of the interest of sub-tenants or
under-raiyats falling within the provision. The Full Bench in
Daitary Swain (Supra) has interpreted the amendment and
held that the interest of a Sikimi tenant in agricultural land
13 17
Page of
is heritable and transferable. Thus, the absence of a
declaration of raiyati status cannot, by itself, be a ground to
hold that the underlying interest of a person covered by the
provision stood extinguished or that his successors-in-
interest cannot claim through him.
17. It has been strongly argued by Mr. Patnaik and
Mr. Dash that, since the petitioner's father had filed an
application under Section 4(9) of the OLR Act for conversion
of rent in kind into cash, it cannot be said that he was ever
declared a raiyat. In order to examine this contention, this
Court would like to refer to the decision rendered in the case
4
of Smt. Sarala Kumari Rath V. Khati Rout and others ,
wherein this Court held that even if a sub-tenant or under-
raiyat had not obtained a declaration of his status as a
raiyat under Section 4 of the OLR Act, the underlying right
of such sub-tenant or under-raiyat in respect of the land in
question would not, for that reason alone, stand
extinguished. The declaration provided under sub-sections
(5) to (8) of Section 4 would enlarge the nature of the interest
4
2000 (II) OLR 363
14 17
Page of
by recognising the person as a raiyat in accordance with the
statutory provisions. In the present case, admittedly, the
petitioner's father had not obtained any declaration of raiyati
status, and the proceeding initiated by him under Section
4(9) of the OLR Act was confined to conversion of rent in
kind into cash. However, in view of the law subsequently
explained by the Full Bench in the case of Daitary Swain
(Supra) , even in the absence of a declaration of raiyati
status, the interest of a sub-tenant or under-raiyat, is
capable of being inherited and transferred in respect of
agricultural land as well as against homestead land.
18. Having discussed the matter as above, this
Court is of the considered view that the impugned order
cannot be sustained in law. The Tahasildar, while examining
the petitioner's application seeking correction of the
computerized ROR, was required to consider the entries
appearing in the original Settlement ROR of 1962, the order
passed in OLR Case No.40 of 1972 and the enquiry report
submitted by the Director, Land Records and Survey,
together with the subsequent communications issued by the
15 17
Page of
revenue authorities. The Tahasildar, however, rejected the
petitioner's claim substantially on the ground that the
interest of an under-raiyat was neither heritable nor
transferable and the petitioner's father had not been
declared a raiyat under the provisions of the OLR Act. Such
approach, it is stated at the cost of repetition, is contrary to
the law laid down by the Full Bench in the case of Daitary
Swain (Supra). The absence of a declaration of raiyati
status under sub-sections (5) to (8) of Section 4 of the OLR
Act, by itself, does not extinguish the interest of an under-
raiyat or preclude succession thereto.
19. For the foregoing reasons and in view of the
settled legal position discussed hereinabove, this Court is of
the considered view that the impugned order dated
30.09.2021 passed by the Tahasildar, Banapur, in Misc.
Case No.1 of 2021 cannot be sustained and is hereby set
aside. The opposite parties are directed to take necessary
steps to correct the computerized ROR available in the
Bhulekh portal in conformity with the original Settlement
16 17
Page of
ROR of 1962, particularly with regard to the entry relating to
Bhagabat Panda in subsidiary Khata No.79.
20. It is made clear that the correction directed
herein shall be confined to bringing the computerized ROR
in conformity with the original Settlement ROR and shall not
be construed as a declaration of absolute ownership or as an
adjudication of any independent proprietary rights of the
petitioner over the case land.
21. The Writ Petition is accordingly allowed.
…..……….…………….
(Sashikanta Mishra)
Judge
High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
th
20 November, 2026, Puspanjali Ghadai, Jr. Stenographer
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: PUSPANJALI GHADAI
Designation: JUNIOR STENOGRAPHER
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack.
Date: 20-Nov-2026 15:01:29
17 17
Page of