Lalita Devi @ Lila Devi vs The Union of India

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.15109 of 2024
CNR No. BRHC010985822024
======================================================
Bajo Das Son of Late Soni Das Resident of Village- Mainak Tola, Ward No.
9, Post and Police Station- Mokama, District- Patna.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The Union of India through the Pr. Commissioner, Customs (Preventive)
Commissionerate, Central Revenue Building, Birchand Patel Path, Patna.
2. The Pr. Commissioner, Customs (Preventive) Commissionerate, Central
Revenue Building, Birchand Patel Path, Patna.
3. The Additional Commissioner (P and V), Customs (Preventive) Headquarter,
Central Revenue Building, Birchand Patel Path, Patna.
4. The Assistant Commissioner, Customs (P) Division, Motihari, District- East
Champaran.
5. The Deputy Commissioner, Customs (P) Division, Motihari, District- East
Champaran.
6. The Superintendent, Customs (P) Division, Motihari, District- East
Champaran.
7. The Superintendent (Tech), Customs (P) Division, Motihari, District- East
Champaran.
8. Kumari Reema Lahri Daughter of Hari Narayan Jigyasu Resident of Village-
Kutubpur Saidpur, Police Station- Bidupur, Circle- Hajipur, District-
Vaishali.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Manoj Kumar, Advocate
Mr.Pranjal Shandilya, Advocate
Mr.Chandra Shekhar Tiwary, Advocate
For the Custom : Mr.Anshuman Singh, Advocate
For the Respondent/s : Additional Solicitor General
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PURNENDU SINGH
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 19-11-2026
Heard learned counsels for the parties.
2. The petitioners in paragraph no. 1 of the present
writ petition have sought inter alia following relief(s), which is
reproduced hereinafter:-

Patna High Court CWJC No.15109 of 2024 dt.19-11-2026
2/10
(i) For issuance of writ in the nature of certiorari
quashing the decision contained in File No. 11 (25)
06/Pen/2010/1963 dated 10.07.2024 taken by the
Committee and communicated under the signature of
the Assistant Commissioner, Custom (P) Division,
Motihari whereby the family pension has been given to
the Respondent No.8 only. (Annexure-P/12).
(ii) For directing the authority concerned to issue
family pension to the petitioner as she is the nominee in
the service record of her deceased son and not the
Respondent No.8 who is a government servant and is
maintaining herself and her child after separation in
the year 2006 itself.
(iii) For direction to the respondent concerned to make
payment of the other admissible dues as decided by the
Committee in File No. II (25) 06/Pen/2010/1963 dated
10.07.2024 in equal share except the pension.”
3. The petitioners are aggrieved by the order
passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Customs (P), Division,
Motihari (respondent no. 4), as contained in File No. II (25)
06/Pen/2010/1963 dated 10.07.2024 ( Annexure P/12 to the writ
petition), whereby the claim concerning the retiral benefits of
the legal representatives of the deceased employee, namely, Late
Sunil Kumar, who died on 01.03.2010, has been decided.
4. The original petitioner, Lalita Devi @ Lila
Devi, being the mother of the deceased employee, had filed the
present writ petition and upon her demise, her husband, namely,
Bajo Das, was substituted in her place vide order dated
20.08.2026.

Patna High Court CWJC No.15109 of 2024 dt.19-11-2026
3/10
5. The basic question raised by learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner is that the order dated
10.07.2024 is vitiated on account of the fact that the respondent
no. 4 [The Assistant Commissioner of Customs (P), Division,
Motihari], vide communication dated 27.06.2024, had fixed
30.07.2024 as the date for verification and hearing before the
Committee, enabling the respective parties, particularly
respondent no. 8 (Kumari Reema Lahri), who claims to be the
legally wedded wife of the deceased employee, to produce the
requisite documents in support of their respective claims. It is
contended that, before the petitioner could place her claim for
receiving the retiral benefits, the respondent no. 4 proceeded to
unilaterally decide the matter on 10.07.2024 and the same was
communicated to the petitioner. On these grounds, learned
counsel seeks interference with the order dated 10.07.2024
passed by the respondent no.4.
6. Per contra , Mr. Anshuman Singh, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the Customs Department,
referring to Annexure P/11 to the writ petition submitted that on
27.06.2024, the petitioner had appeared before the respondent
no. 4 and placed the relevant records in support of her claim and
taking into consideration the fact that respondent no. 8 (Kumari

Patna High Court CWJC No.15109 of 2024 dt.19-11-2026
4/10
Reema Lahri) had submitted an application expressing her
inability to appear in the proceedings on account of illness of
her children, who were suffering from diarrhea, the respondent
no. 4, in order to ensure that she should not be unheard,
adjourned the matter and fixed 30.07.2024 as the next date of
hearing. He further submitted that it is not a case where the
petitioner was denied an opportunity of hearing, rather, it is an
admitted position that the petitioner appeared on 27.06.2024 and
placed all relevant documents in support of her claim including
the genealogical table and the succession certificate. Learned
counsel further clarifies that the information as contained in
Annexure P/2 to the writ petition shows that no document or
record was available with the Department establishing
respondent no. 8 as the legally wedded wife of the deceased
employee. The respondent no. 8 has two biological children
from her matrimonial relationship with the deceased employee
and their entitlement has duly been considered by the
respondent no. 4 in accordance with law.
7. In the aforesaid background, learned counsel
submitted that there is no infirmity in the order passed by the
respondent no. 4, as contained in Annexure P/12 to the writ
petition.

Patna High Court CWJC No.15109 of 2024 dt.19-11-2026
5/10
8. The issue which arises for consideration is
whether a party, who could not be heard on account of a genuine
reason ought to be afforded an opportunity of hearing before
any decision affecting the respective claims is taken ? It is
evident from letter dated 27.6.2024 ( Annexure P/11 to the writ
petition ) that the respondent no. 4, after recording the
appearance of the petitioner and receipt of her documents, had
fixed 30.07.2024 for further proceedings, awaiting the report of
the Committee. This Court finds that before the report of the
Committee could be submitted, the respondent no. 4, vide order
dated 10.07.2024, proceeded to decide the claims of the
respective parties including the petitioner.
9. In this regard, it would be apposite to refer to
the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in K.I. Shephard v.
Union of India , reported in (1987) 4 SCC 431 , wherein the
Apex Court, while considering the applicability of the principles
of natural justice to administrative decisions involving adverse
civil consequences, held that even an administrative authority is
required to act fairly and afford an effective opportunity of
hearing to a person whose rights or interests are likely to be
adversely affected by its decision. The Apex Court further
emphasised that the requirement of fairness in administrative

Patna High Court CWJC No.15109 of 2024 dt.19-11-2026
6/10
action is an integral part of the principles of natural justice and
that a decision affecting the livelihood or financial interests of
an individual cannot ordinarily be taken without affording him
an opportunity. The observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in paragraphs 12, 13 and 15 of the aforesaid judgment are
reproduced hereinafter:-
“ 12. Mullan in Fairness: The New Natural
Justice has stated:
“Natural justice co-exists with, or reflected, a
wider principle of fairness in decision-making and that all
judicial and administrative decision-making and that all
judicial and administrative decision-makers had a duty to
act fairly.”
In the case of State of Orissa v. Dr (Ms)
Binapani Dei [AIR 1967 SC 1269 : (1967) 2 SCR 625 :
(1967) 2 LLJ 266] this Court observed:
“It is true that the order is administrative in
character, but even an administrative order which involves
civil consequences as already stated, must be made
consistently with the rules of natural justice after
informing the first respondent of the case of the State, the
evidence in support thereof and after giving an
opportunity to the first respondent of being heard and
meeting or explaining the evidence. No such steps were
admittedly taken: the High Court was, in our judgment,
right in setting aside the order of the State. ”
(emphasis supplied)
In A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India [(1969) 2
SCC 262 : (1970) 1 SCR 457] a Constitution Bench quoted
with approval the observations of Lord Parker in Re: (H) K
(an infant) [(1969) 3 SCC 84 : (1970) 2 SCR 600 : 38 FJR
1] . Hegde, J. speaking for the Court stated: (SCC p. 272,
para 20)
“Very soon thereafter a third rule was
envisaged and that is that quasi-judicial enquiries must be
held in good faith, without bias and not arbitrarily or
unreasonably. But in the course of years many more
subsidiary rules came to be added to the rules of natural
justice. Till very recently it was the opinion of the courts
that unless the authority concerned was required by the law

Patna High Court CWJC No.15109 of 2024 dt.19-11-2026
7/10
under which it functioned to act judicially there was no
room for the application of the rules of natural justice. The
validity of that limitation is now questioned. If the purpose
of the rules of natural justice is to prevent miscarriage of
justice one fails to see why those rules should be made
inapplicable to administrative enquiries. Oftentimes it is not
easy to draw the line that demarcates administrative
enquiries from quasi-judicial enquiries. Enquiries which
were considered administrative at one time are now being
considered as quasi-judicial in character. Arriving at a just
decision is the aim of both quasi-judicial enquiries as well
as administrative enquiries. An unjust decision in an
administrative enquiry may have more far-reaching effect
than a decision in a quasi-judicial enquiry.”
These observations in A.K. Kraipak case
[(1969) 2 SCC 262 : (1970) 1 SCR 457] were followed by
another Constitution Bench of this Court in Chandra
Bhavan Boarding and Lodging, Bangalore v. State of
Mysore [(1969) 3 SCC 84 : (1970) 2 SCR 600 : 38 FJR 1] .
In Swadeshi Cotton Mills v. Union of India [(1981) 1 SCC
664 : AIR 1981 SC 818 : (1981) 2 SCR 533 : (1981) 51
Com Cas 210] a three Judge Bench of this Court examined
this aspect of natural justice. Sarkaria, J. who spoke for the
court, stated: (SCC pp. 683-84, para 28)
“During the last two decades, the concept of
natural justice has made great strides in the realm of
administrative law. Before the epoch-making decision of the
House of Lords in Ridge v. Baldwin [1964 AC 40 : (1963) 2
All ER 66 (HL)] it was generally thought that the rules of
natural justice apply only to judicial or quasi-judicial
proceedings; and for the purpose, whenever a breach of the
rule of natural justice was alleged, courts in England used
to ascertain whether the impugned action was taken by the
statutory authority or tribunal in the exercise of its
administrative or quasi-judicial power. In India also, this
was the position before the decision dated February 7,
1967, of this Court in Dr Binapani Dei case [AIR 1967 SC
1269 : (1967) 2 SCR 625 : (1967) 2 LLJ 266] ; wherein it
was held that even an administrative order or decision in
matters involving civil consequences, has to be made
consistently with the rules of natural justice. This supposed
distinction between quasi-judicial and administrative
decisions, which was perceptibly mitigated in Binapani Dei
case [AIR 1967 SC 1269 : (1967) 2 SCR 625 : (1967) 2 LLJ
266] was further rubbed out to a vanishing point in A.K.
Kraipak v. Union of India [(1969) 2 SCC 262 : (1970) 1
SCR 457] . . . .”
On the basis of these authorities it must be
held that even when a State agency acts administratively,
rules of natural justice would apply. As stated, natural

Patna High Court CWJC No.15109 of 2024 dt.19-11-2026
8/10
justice generally requires that persons liable to be directly
affected by proposed administrative acts, decisions or
proceedings be given adequate notice of what is proposed
so that they may be in a position (a) to make
representations on their own behalf; (b) or to appear at a
hearing or enquiry (if one is held); and (c) effectively to
prepare their own case and to answer the case (if any) they
have to meet.
13. Natural justice has various facets and
acting fairly is one of them. RBI which monitored the three
amalgamations was required to act fairly in the facts of the
case. The situation necessitated a participatory enquiry in
regard to the excluded employees. Since the decision to
exclude them from service under the transferee banks is
grounded upon a set of facts the correctness whereof they
deny, if an opportunity to know the allegations and to have
their say had been afforded, they could have no grievance
on this score. The action deprives them of their livelihood
and brings adverse civil consequences and could obviously
not be taken on the ipse dixit of RBI officers without
verification of facts. It is quite possible that a manoeuvring
officer of the banking company adversely disposed of
towards a particular employee of such bank could make a
report against such employee and have him excluded from
further service under the transferee bank. The possibility of
exclusion on the basis of some mistake such as to identity
cannot also be ruled out. There is all the more
apprehension of this type as the process has to be
completed quickly and very often the records of a large
number of employees have to be scrutinised. We are of the
view that rules of natural justice apply to administrative
action and in the instant cases the decision to exclude a
section of the employees without complying with
requirements of natural justice was bad.
15. Fair play is a part of the public policy
and is a guarantee for justice to citizens. In our system of
Rule of Law every social agency conferred with power is
required to act fairly so that social action would be just and
there would be furtherance of the well-being of citizens. The
rules of natural justice have developed with the growth of
civilisation and the content thereof is often considered as a
proper measure of the level of civilisation and Rule of Law
prevailing in the community. Man within the social frame
has struggled for centuries to bring into the community the
concept of fairness and it has taken scores of years for the
rules of natural justice to conceptually enter into the field of
social activities. We do not think in the facts of the case
there is any justification to hold that rules of natural justice
have been ousted by necessary implication on account of
the time frame. On the other hand we are of the view that
the time limited by statute provides scope for an opportunity

Patna High Court CWJC No.15109 of 2024 dt.19-11-2026
9/10
to be extended to the intended excluded employees before
the scheme is finalised so that a hearing commensurate to
the situation is afforded before a section of the employees is
thrown out of employment.”
10. Having considered the disputed question
relating to the alleged separation of respondent no. 8 from the
deceased employee, which has neither been specifically pleaded
in the writ petition nor supported by any material evidence, I do
not find any substance in the contention advanced by learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner. However, the
order dated 10.07.2024 cannot be sustained, having regard to the
fact that the claims of the respective parties were decided
without affording an effective opportunity of hearing to the
parties. The matter concerns the determination of the entitlement
of the respective legal representatives of the deceased employee,
including his two children and respondent no. 8, who claims to
be his wife.
11. It is a well settled principle of law that a post-
decisional hearing will not be sufficient to decide the claim of
the respective parties. In that view, the order dated 10.07.2024
is unsustainable and is, accordingly, set aside.
12. The Committee, so constituted for the purpose,
is directed to forthwith submit its report after affording due
opportunity of hearing to all the respective parties, including the

Patna High Court CWJC No.15109 of 2024 dt.19-11-2026
10/10
present petitioner, Bajo Das, who has been substituted in place
of the original petitioner. Upon receipt of the report, the
competent authority shall consider the claims of the respective
parties and shall take conscious decision strictly in accordance
with law.
13. The respective parties shall be at liberty to
produce all relevant documents and other evidence in support of
their respective claims before the Committee.
14. Till a final decision is taken by the competent
authority, no payment shall be released in favour of any of the
parties. In the event any payment has already been made, the
same shall be subject to the final decision to be taken by the
competent authority.
15. The present writ petition accordingly stands
disposed of.

(Purnendu Singh, J)
chn/-
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE NA
Date of Pronouncement NA
Uploading Date 21.11.2026
Transmission Date NA