Shirya @ Shree Ganesh Waghmare vs State Of Maharashtra And Ors
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM010272542026
1 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
Gokhale
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 2856 OF 2026
Shirya @ Shree Ganesh Waghmare ..Petitioner
Versus
The State of Maharashtra & Ors. ..Respondents
__________
Mr. Prasad Avhad i/b. Kuldeep Nikam for Petitioner.
Ms. M. H. Mhatre, APP for State/Respondent.
__________
CORAM : SARANG V. KOTWAL &
RANJITSINHA RAJA BHONSALE, JJ.
DATE : 18 NOVEMBER 2026
JUDGMENT : (PER RANJITSINHA RAJA BHONSALE, J.)
1. By the present petition, the Petitioner seeks to challenge
the Detention Order dated 23.01.2026 and also the Committal
Order directing the detention of the Petitioner in Amravati Central
Prison, Amravati. The Detention Order has been passed by the
Respondent No.3.
2. Heard Mr. Prasad Avhad, learned counsel for the
Petitioner and Ms. M. H. Mhatre, learned APP for the State.
3. Mr. Prasad Avhad, learned counsel appearing for the
Digitally
signed by
VINOD
BHASKAR
GOKHALE
Date:
2026.11.21
14:28:21
+0530
VINOD
BHASKAR
GOKHALE
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
2 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
Petitioner, though, has raised various grounds in the Petition, he
has restricted his arguments to only one ground i.e. perusal of
paragraphs-2 and 8 of the grounds of detention would create a
confusion in the mind of the Petitioner, in as much as, the material
relied upon by the Detaining Authority to arrive at his subjective
satisfaction is contrary and, therefore, crucial right of the
Petitioner to make an effective representation was adversely
affected.
4. Ms. M. H. Mhatre, learned APP appearing for the State
would submit that the Detaining Authority has relied only upon
the offence mentioned in paragraph-5.1 of the grounds of
detention and two ‘in-camera’ statements mentioned in
paragraphs-6.1 and 6.2 to arrive at his subjective satisfaction. The
past offences and the preventive action referred to in the grounds
of detention are only for the purpose of stating the past history
and antecedents of the Petitioner.
5. We have considered the submissions made by learned
counsel for both the parties. The perusal of grounds of detention
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
3 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
would indicate that, the Detaining Authority has described the
Petitioner as a weapon-wielding dangerous recidivist of violent
nature, indulging in criminal activities that foster terror in the
society. The Detaining Authority has concluded that the Petitioner
has become a perpetual danger to the lives and properties of the
people residing in and around the jurisdiction of Haveli and Uttam
Nagar police station in Pune city. It is observed that the Petitioner
along with his accomplices, moved around armed with deadly
weapons such as sword, koyta in the aforementioned areas and
did not hesitate to use the same while committing the act of terror.
It is observed that the Petitioner and his accomplices engaged in
violent criminal activities and have became a virtual terror on
account of his criminal activities.
6. The Detaining Authority, after narrating the aforesaid
facts, in Paragraph-2 concluded that, thus, the Petitioner is a
‘dangerous person’ as defined under section 2(b-1) of the MPDA
Act and that the criminal activities of the Petitioner are prejudicial
to the maintenance of public order.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
4 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
7. In paragraph-3 of the grounds of detention, the
Detaining Authority has listed the past offences and preventive
actions taken against the Petitioner. Paragraph-3.1 contains a
tabular form showing the past offences registered with Uttam
Nagar and Haveli police station. There are in all seven offences
referred in the said paragraph, which pertain to the period from
23.01.2021 to 25.06.2025. In paragraph-3.2 of the grounds of
detention, the Detaining Authority has recorded the preventive
actions which were initiated against the Petitioner with an object
to deter the Petitioner from committing further crime. There is a
Chapter Case No.1 of 2020 registered with Uttam Nagar police
station, U/s.107 of the Cr.P.C. In the said case, the Petitioner, on
09.01.2020 executed a bond of Rs.10,000/- with one surety for
one year before the Special Executive Magistrate, Kothrud
Division, Pune City. The second Chapter case bearing Case No.118
of 2023 is registered at Uttam Nagar Police station, U/s.107(a)(e)
(g) of the Cr.P.C.. In this case, on 15.04.2023, the Petitioner had
executed a bond of Rs.50,000/- with one surety for two years
before the Special Executive Magistrate, Kothrud Division, Pune
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
5 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
City. It is further observed that, even the preventive actions had no
deterrent effect on the Petitioner and he continued to commit
serious offences.
8. In paragraph-5 of the grounds of detention, the
Detaining Authority has relied on C.R.No.130 of 2025 registered
with Uttam Nagar police station, on 22.10.2025. The said offence
was registered under sections 115(2), 352 and 3(5) of the BNS,
U/s.4(25) of the Arms Act, U/s.37(1)/135 of the Maharashtra
Police Act and U/s.7 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act. The
prosecution alleged that, on 22.10.2025, the complainant and his
friend were walking to offer prayers at Jilani Masjid, Kondhave
Dhawade, Pune. When they came to the public road in front of
Bismilla Biryani House, the Petitioner and one Chetan who were
known to the complainant, came on a motorcycle. The Petitioner
asked Rehan Ansari as to where he would get good Biryani. The
complainant asked the Petitioner as to what type of Biryani he
wanted. At that time, the Petitioner started arguing with the
complainant, after which the Petitioner threatened and abused the
complainant. The Petitioner removed a sharp weapon from his
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
6 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
waist, waived in the air and created terror. Looking at the act of
the Petitioner, the shopkeepers closed their shops, other people ran
home in fear. The complainant has filed complaint against the
Petitioner which is relied upon by the Detaining Authority. In the
said offence, the Petitioner was arrested on 23.10.2025 and was
granted bail on 07.11.2025.
9. In paragraph-6 of the grounds of detention, the
Detaining Authority has relied on two ‘in-camera’ statements of
Witness ‘A’ and Witness ‘B’. The statement of Witness ‘A’ referred to
the incident dated 07.10.2025, wherein, the witness was serving
paan to the customers at his paan stall. It is alleged that, the
Petitioner along with his two companions came in front of the stall
on a motorcycle. One of his companions took three cigarettes from
the witness without making any payment. The complainant-
witness asked for money. The Petitioner took out koyta from his
waist and threatened the Petitioner. At that time, the people
waiting at the paan stall ran away. The Petitioner threatened the
witness and forcibly took out Rs.1100/- from the witness’s trouser
pocket. The witness was assaulted. The Petitioner damaged the
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
7 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
paan stall with Koyta and broke two chocolate jars.
10. The next statement of Witness ‘B’ pertains to the incident
dated 15.10.2025. While the witness was going home on his
motorcycle, the Petitioner and his companion suddenly came on
the motorcycle and stopped the witness by putting their
motorcycle across in the middle of the road. The witness got
scared and started to move forward. At that time, the Petitioner
got down from his vehicle and pulled the witness’s vehicle and
knocked it down. The witness got scared and shouted for help, but
no one stopped. At that moment, the Petitioner checked the
witness’s bag, but he found nothing in it. Then the Petitioner
checked the witness’s pocket and forcibly took out Rs.2400/- from
it. After giving a punch in the stomach of witness, the Petitioner
left from there.
11. In Paragraph-8, the Detaining Authority has specifically
stated that, it has relied upon the material mentioned in
paragraphs-5.1 and 6.1 & 6.2 of the grounds of detention to arrive
at its subjective satisfaction that the Petitioner is a dangerous
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
8 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
person as defined U/s.2(b-1) of the MPDA Act, and that the
criminal activities of the Petitioner are prejudicial to the
maintenance of public order.
12. On conjoint reading the paragraphs-2 and 8 of the
grounds of detention, we are of the considered opinion that the
same creates a confusion. In paragraph-2 the Detaining Authority
has specifically concluded that, the Petitioner is a ‘dangerous
person’ based on his past criminal activities and the offences. In
paragraph-8 it is stated that, reliance is placed only on the material
mentioned in paragraphs-5 and 6. In our view, this would
definitely create confusion in the mind of the Petitioner and affect
his rights to make an effective representation. The Petitioner while
making a representation, would not be able to clearly know
whether he has to deal with the past offences and/or preventive
actions mentioned in paragraph-3.1 and 3.2 or whether he has to
deal only with the material relied on the paragraphs-5.1 and 6.1 &
6.2 or both. In our opinion, this adversely affects the Petitioner’s
right to make an effective representation.
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
9 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
13. We note that, the references made in paragraph-2 are
not casual or passing reference made to the past offences or
preventive actions nor can the contents be termed or referred to as
only an introductory preamble. The Detaining Authority has
clearly concluded that the past offences and actions of the
Petitioner made him a ‘dangerous person’.
14. Perusal of the contents of paragraphs 2 and 8 of the
Grounds of Detention, clearly creates a confusion as to the basis
and material on which the Detaining Authority has arrived at its
subjective satisfaction. Considering the Grounds of Detention in
their entirety, we are of the considered view that, the contents of
paragraphs 2 and 8 clearly created confusion in the mind of the
detenue and it is not clear on which material the Detaining
Authority has relied upon to reach its subjective satisfaction. This,
confusion and lack of clarity, in our considered view directly affects
the right of the detenue to make an effective representation. It
appears that, the detaining authority has also relied upon the past
instances as well as the instances referred to in paragraphs 2 and 3
of the Grounds of Detention, and still proceeded to state that it
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
10 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
relied only on the instances mentioned in paragraph 5 and 6 of the
Grounds of Detention. In our opinion, this has prejudiced the right
of the Petitioner to make an effective representation. One cannot
lose sight of the fact that Preventive Detention action is a summary
action and the Detention is without trial. One of the safeguards
available to the Detenue is his right of making a representation as
provided under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India. The said
safeguard, should be effectively, completely and meaningfully
provided to the Detenue. The right to make a representation
includes a right to make a complete, effective and meaningful
representation. It is necessary that, the facts and material on which
the subjective satisfaction is arrived at should be clear, present and
not stale grounds nor based on acts/misconduct which can be
effectively and completely addressed by the normal law of the
land. In view of the afore stated peculiar facts of this case, we are
of the considered view that the Detention Order cannot be
sustained and is liable to be quashed and set-aside.
15. Hence, the following order:
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
11 of 11 305-wp-2856-26
O R D E R
i) Rule is made absolute in terms of prayer clause
(b); which reads as follows:
“(b) This Hon’ble Court be pleased to quash
and set aside the impugned detention order
dated 23/01/2026 passed by Respondent No.2
as vicious and malicious, non-est void ab
initio .”
ii) The Petitioner be released from detention
forthwith, if not required in any other case.
iii) The Petition is accordingly disposed of.
(RANJITSINHA RAJA BHONSALE, J.) (SARANG V. KOTWAL, J.)
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 14:40:24
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)