SMT.PARWATI W/O PARTAPPA vs SHIVANNA S/O BASANNA AND ORS
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 200264 OF 2016 (PAR)
BETWEEN:
SMT. PARWATI W/O PARTAPPA,
(D/O BASANNA),
AGE: 48 YRS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. HANCHATE CHAWL,
OPP: RAILWAY STATION,
CHIITTAPUR, TQ: CHITTAPUR-585211
…APPELLANT
(BY SMT. SHARADA R. PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. SHIVANNA S/O BASANNA,
AGE:57 YRS, OCC: AGRICULTURE.
2. SHANTAPPA S/O BASANNA,
AGE: 54 YRS, OCC: AGRICULTURE.
3. SHIVASHARANAPPA S/O BASANNA,
AGE:51 YRS, OCC: AGRICULTURE.
4. SIDDAPPA S/O BASANNA,
AGE:44 YRS, OCC: AGRICULTURE.
5. BHIMBAI W/O BASANNA,
AGE:76 YRS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
ALL ARE R/O: ALLOLLI, TQ: CHITTAPUR-585211.
Digitally signed
by B NAGAVENI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
6. DRAKSHAYANI W/O SIDDAPPA,
(D/O BASANNA),
AGE:46 YRS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. GACCHI BOWDI, YADGIR,
TQ. & DIST. YADGIR-585203
…RESPONDENTS
(R1 SERVED AND R6 SERVED;
V/O DTD.29.05.2024 NOTICE TO R2 TO R5 HELD SUFFICIENT)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC,
PRAYING TO ALLOW THE SECOND APPEAL BY CONFIRMING
THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE PASSED IN O.S.NO.37/2010
DATED 30.04.14 BY CIVIL JUDGE CHITTAPUR, AND
CONSEQUENTLY DISMISS THE MODIFIED JUDGMENT AND
DECREE PASSED IN RA. NO.15/2014 DATED 25.7.16 BY SR.
CIVIL JUDGE CHITTAPUR.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
ORAL JUDGMENT
1. This regular second appeal is filed by the appellant
challenging the judgment and decree dated
25.07.2016 passed in R.A. No.15 of 2014 by the
learned Senior Civil Village, Chittapur (for short, ‘ the
First Appellate Court ’) wherein the First Appellate
Court has modified the judgment and preliminary
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
decree dated 30.04.2014 passed in O.S. No.37 of
2010 by the learned Civil Judge, Chittapur (for short,
‘ the Trial Court ’).
2. For the sake of convenience, parties are based on
their ranking before the Trial Court: The appellant
was the plaintiff and respondents were the
defendants.
3. The plaintiff filed a suit for partition and separate
possession. The plaintiff and defendants are the
children of Basanna and Bhimabai i.e., defendant
No.5. Basanna died in 1999 leaving behind the
plaintiff and defendants. It is contended that the suit
schedule properties are the ancestral and joint family
properties of the plaintiff and defendants and the
plaintiff and defendants are the members of a Hindu
Undivided Joint Family and no partition is effected.
The plaintiff demanded for a partition and separate
possession, however, the defendants refused to
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
effect a partition. Hence, a cause of action arose for
the plaintiff to file a suit for partition and separate
possession.
4. Defendant Nos.1 to 5 filed a written statement partly
admitting the description of the suit schedule
properties and it is contended that the plaintiff has
not included all the immoveable properties of their
family in the suit and admitted some of the
properties are the ancestral properties and
specifically the following properties:
“(i) House bearing Gram Panchayat No.1-83
and 1-85;
(ii) House bearing Gram Panchayat No.12-35;
(iii) House bearing Gram Panchayat No.1-84;
(iv) Land Sy.No.57/2 measuring 6 acres 16
guntas;
(v) Land Sy.No.58/2 measuring 6 acres 10
guntas;
(vi) Land Sy.No.138/1 measuring 6 acres 12
guntas;
(vii) Land Sy.No.280/2 measuring 25 guntas;
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
(ix) Land Sy.No.57/1 measuring 6 acres 39
guntas;
(xii) Land Sy.No.427 measuring 15 acres 05
guntas”
5. It is also contended that defendant No.1 had
purchased the land bearing Sy.No.85/e and
defendant No.4 and purchased the land bearing
Sy.No.97/a. The suit schedule properties Sl.Nos.8,
10 and 11 are the self-acquired properties of
defendant Nos.1, 3 and 4 and hence, prays to
dismiss the suit.
6. The defendants also sought a counter-claim
contending that the plaintiff has suppressed the real
facts and filed a false suit and hence, prays to decree
the counter-claim in respect of the ancestral
properties.
7. The plaintiff filed a written statement to the counter-
claim of defendant Nos.1 to 5 and denied that the
plaintiff has suppressed the material facts and other
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
immoveable properties. It is contended that the said
lands being the Government lands and were
nominally allotted in the name of the plaintiff and
stated that the said land bearing Survey Nos.190 and
198 not being the joint family properties of the
plaintiff and defendants and they are not the subject
matter of the suit and hence, not subject to partition.
8. The Trial Court, based on the rival pleadings of the
parties, framed the following issues:
“(i) Whether the plaintiff proves that,
the suit schedule properties are the
joint family properties of plaintiff
and defendants?
(ii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to
partition and separate possession of
th
her 7/49 share each in the suit
properties by metes and bounds?
(iii) Whether the defendant Nos.1 to 5
prove that, the suit is bad for non-
inclusion of all the joint properties
of plaintiff and defendants?
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
(iv) Whether the defendant Nos.1 to 5
prove that, the suit schedule Item
No. at Sl.Nos.9, 10, 11 and 13 are
exclusive properties of defendant
Nos.1 to 3 and 4?
(v) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to
the relief sought for?
(vi) What Order or Decree?”
9. The plaintiff, to substantiate her case examined
herself as PW1, examined one witness as PW2 and
marked 75 documents as Exhibits P1 to P75.
10. Defendant No.1 examined himself as DW1, examined
2 witnesses as DWs-2 and 3 and marked 5
documents as Exhibits D1 to D5.
11. The Trial Court, after recording the evidence, hearing
both sides and assessing the verbal and
documentary evidence, answered Issue Nos.1, 2 and
5 in affirmative; Issue Nos.3 and 4 in Negative; and
Issue No.6, as per final order. The suit of the plaintiff
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
was decreed with costs and it is ordered and
declared that the plaintiff is entitled to partition and
th
separate possession of her 7/49 share in all the suit
schedule properties and Sl. Nos.1 to 13 shown in the
schedule annexed to the plaint and the counter-claim
filed by the defendants for a relief of partition and
separate possession of suit counter-claim properties
was dismissed by judgment dated 30.04.2014.
12. The defendants aggrieved by the judgment and
preliminary decree passed in O.S. No.37 of 2010
preferred an appeal in R.A. No.15 of 2014 on the file
of learned Senior Civil Judge, Chittapur.
13. the First Appellate Court, after hearing the learned
counsel for the parties, framed the following points
for consideration:
“1. Whether the appellants/defendants
prove that, the judgment and decree
passed in O.S.No.37/2010 on the file
of Civil Judge, Chittapur dated
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
30.04.2014 is perverse, capricious and
is not sustainable in law?
2. What Order or Decree?”
14. The First Appellate Court, after re-appreciating the
entire evidence on record, allowed the appeal in part
and modified the judgment and preliminary decree
passed in O.S. No.37 of 2010 and held that
th th
defendant Nos.1 to 4 are entitled for 1/5 + 1/7
share in the suit properties and the plaintiff is
th
entitled for 1/7 share in the share of the deceased
Basanna. Defendant Nos.5 and 6 are entitled for
th
1/7 share in the share of deceased Basanna, by
judgment dated 25.07.2016.
15. The plaintiff, aggrieved by the judgment passed in
R.A No.15 of 2014, filed this regular second appeal.
16. Notice was issued to the respondents. Despite
service of notice, the respondents remained
unrepresented.
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
17. Heard the arguments of the learned counsel for the
plaintiff.
18. Learned counsel for the plaintiff submits that the suit
schedule properties are the ancestral and joint family
properties of the plaintiff and defendants. She
submits that the plaintiff being the daughter, she is a
coparcener by virtue of amendment to Section 6 of
the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005.
Learned counsel for the plaintiff submits that
defendant No.5 is no more alive. The daughters are
treated on par with the son and entitled for an equal
share.
19. To buttress her arguments, she has placed reliance
on the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the
1
case of Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma .
Hence, she submits that the judgment passed by the
1
AIR 2020 SC 3717
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
First Appellate Court modifying the shares is contrary
to the proposition laid down by the Hon'ble Apex
Court in the case of Vineeta Sharma (supra).
20. Learned counsel for the plaintiff submits that
defendant No.5 is no more alive and quantum of
share to be modified. Hence, on these grounds, she
prays to allow the appeal.
21. This Court, by order dated 04.06.2024 admitted the
appeal to consider the following substantial questions
of law:
(i) Whether the First Appellate Court
was justified in granting the
share to the plaintiff in the
share of the father holding that
the father died in the year 1999
and the plaintiff/daughter
would be entitled for a share in
the property of the father?
(ii) Whether the judgment and
decree of the First Appellate
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
Court warrants interference in
the light of amended provisions
of Section 6 of the Hindu
Succession (Amendment) Act,
2005 and in the light of the
judgment of the Apex Court in
the case of Vineeta Sharma v.
Rakesh Sharma and others
reported in (2020) 9 SCC 1?
22. Both substantial questions of law are interlinked and
hence, they are taken together for common
discussion in order to avoid the repetition of facts.
Reg. Substantial Questions of Law Nos.1 and 2 :
23. There is no dispute in regard to the relationship
between the parties to the suit. The plaintiff filed a
suit for partition and separate possession in regard to
the suit schedule properties contending that the suit
schedule properties are the ancestral and joint family
properties of the plaintiff and defendants. The
plaintiff and defendants are the members of a Hindu
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
Undivided Joint Family and no partition is effected
between the plaintiff and the defendants.
24. The defendants have filed a written statement
making a counter-claim contending that the plaintiff
has not included all the properties in the suit
schedule and also made a counter-claim in respect to
the properties annexed to the written statement.
25. The plaintiff examined herself as PW1 and she has
re-iterated the plaint averments in the examination-
in-chief and in order to prove that the suit schedule
properties are the ancestral and joint family
properties of the plaintiff and defendants, produced
the documents Exhibits P1 to P75.
26. The plaintiff also examined one Gulinath as PW2,
who has deposed that the plaintiff and defendants
are the members of the Hindu Undivided Family and
there is no partition effected between the plaintiff
and defendants.
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
27. Defendant No.1 was examined as DW1 and he
reiterated the written statement averment in the
examination-in-chief and deposed that Item Nos.1, 8
and 10 are the self-acquired properties of defendant
No.1. They are not amenable for partition and has
deposed that the plaintiff has suppressed that other
properties are also amenable for partition and the
said properties were not included in the suit schedule
and in order to prove that Item Nos.1, 8 and 10 are
purchased by him, produced the certified copy of the
sale deed is marked as Exhibit D1; RTC extracts are
marked as Exhibits D2 to D4; Exhibit D5 is the
mutation extract.
28. From the perusal of the record, it is clear that there
is no dispute in regard to relationship between the
parties to the suit and the nature of the suit schedule
properties. The Trial Court has recorded its finding
that the plaintiff and defendants are the members of
the Hindu Joint family and the suit schedule
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
properties are the ancestral and joint family
properties of the plaintiff and defendants and held
that the counter-claim made by the defendants is
dismissed on the ground that the said properties are
the self-acquired properties of the plaintiff.
29. The Trial Court declared that the plaintiff is entitled
th
for 7/49 share in all the suit schedule properties
and dismissed the counter-claim for the relief of
partition and separate possession of suit counter-
claim property.
30. The defendants aggrieved by the judgment and
preliminary decree passed in O.S. No.37 of 2010 filed
an appeal in R.A. No.15 of 2014. The First Appellate
Court modified the judgment and decree passed by
the Trial Court and recorded its finding that the
original propositus passed away prior to the Hindu
Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 and hence, the
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
daughters are not entitled for an equal share. They
are not treated as coparceners in the year 1999.
31. The said observation of the First Appellate Court is
contrary to the proposition laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of Vineeta Sharma ( supra )
wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court held that irrespective
of whether the father is alive or not, as on the date
of amendment, the daughters born after 1956 are
treated as coparceners.
32. Thus, the impugned judgment passed by the First
Appellate Court is in violation of Section 6 of the
Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 and also
contrary to the proposition laid down by the Hon'ble
Apex Court in the case of Vineeta Sharma (supra) .
33. To the said extent, the impugned judgment passed
by the First Appellate Court needs to be set aside.
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
34. In view of the above discussion, I answer substantial
question of law No.1 in Negative and substantial
question of law No.2 in the affirmative.
35. In view of the above discussion, I proceed to pass
the following order:
ORDER
(i) The regular second appeal is
allowed .
(ii) The judgment dated 25.07.2016
passed in R.A. No.15 of 2014 by
the First Appellate Court is set
aside .
(iii) The judgment and preliminary
decree dated 30.04.2014
passed in O.S. No.37 of 2010
passed by the Trial Court is
modified .
th
(iv) The plaintiff is entitled for 1/6
share in all the suit schedule
properties i.e., Sl. Nos.1 to 13.
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12249
RSA No. 200264 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030036642016
(v) Pending IAs, if any, stand
disposed of.
(vi) Registry is directed to draw the
preliminary decree accordingly.
Sd/-
(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE
RK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 9
Ct:pk