STATE OF RAJASTHAN vs MUKESH KUMAR MEENA (APPLICATION ID- 202439498342)

Court
Rajasthan High Court

(1 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JD:47791-DB] [SAW-1186/2026]
Reportable
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JODHPUR
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 1186/2026
CNR: RJHC010771232026 | URN: SAW / 2386U / 2026
1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Its Secretary, Ayurved And
Indian Medicine Department, Government Of Rajasthan,
Secretariat, Jaipur
2. Director, Ayurved Department, Ashok Marg, Lohagal
Road, Savitri College Circle, Ajmer.
3. Additional Director (Admn.), Ayurved Department, Ashok
Marg, Lohagal Road, Savitri College Circle, Ajmer.
4. The Registrar, Dr. Sarvepali Radhakrishnan Rajasthan
Ayurved University, Karwar, Nagaur Road, Jodhpur (Raj.).
5. All India Institute Of Medical Sciences, Jodhpur, Through
Its Director, Basni, Phase-II, Jodhpur.
6. The Superintendent, Mdm Hospital, Associated Hospital To
Dr. S.N. Medical College, Jodhpur.
----Appellants
Versus
Mukesh Kumar Meena (Application Id- 202439498342) S/o
Ramavatar Meena, Aged About 33 Years, (Physically
Handicapped Candidate- Ld), Resident Of Near Talchhi Ki Puliya,
Ward No. 17, Sangod, Tehsil Sangod, District Kota (Raj.)
----Respondent
For Appellant(s) : Mr. N.S. Rajpurohit, AAG
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Yashpal Khileree
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINIT KUMAR MATHUR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE CHANDRA SHEKHAR SHARMA
Order
01/10/2026
Vinit Kumar Mathur, J.
The present appeal has been filed by the State of Rajasthan
after a delay of 112 days and therefore, an application under
Section 5 of the Limitation Act has been filed for condonation of
the said delay.
(Uploaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:15:52 PM)
(Downloaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:33:11 PM)

(2 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JD:47791-DB] [SAW-1186/2026]
2. The application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act is not
opposed by the learned counsel for the respondent.
3. For the reasons mentioned in the application, the same is
allowed. The delay of 112 days caused in filing the present appeal
is condoned.
4. Heard learned counsel for the parties on the appeal itself.
5. The present appeal has been filed against the order dated
29.01.2026 passed by learned Single Bench whereby the writ
petition filed by the petitioner-respondent was allowed and the
appellants had been directed to offer appointment to the
respondent-petitioner on the post of Compounder/Nurse Junior
Grade in Ayurveda Department.
6. Briefly noted the facts of the present appeal are that the
petitioner-respondent was selected for the post of
Compounder/Nurse Junior Grade on and thereafter, the selection
of the petitioner-respondent was cancelled vide order dated
08.09.2025. Against the order of cancellation, he preferred the
writ petition before this Court.
7. The bone of contention before the learned Single Bench was
whether the petitioner is suffering from disability in both legs of
lower limb or the disability is only in one leg. Since, the condition
of appointment was that if a person is having disability to the
extent of 40% or more in one leg, he will be eligible for the post.
The petitioner-respondent submitted a certificate of disablement
to the extent of 50% in the left lower limb. On re-examination by
the appellant authorities, it was found that disability suffered by
the petitioner-respondent is in both the legs and therefore, he was
ineligible for appointment on the post of Compounder/Nurse Junior
(Uploaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:15:52 PM)
(Downloaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:33:11 PM)

(3 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JD:47791-DB] [SAW-1186/2026]
Grade. In pursuance of the submission made before this Court,
the interim orders were passed whereby the respondent-petitioner
was directed to be examined by a Medical Board of All India
Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) at Jodhpur.
8. In pursuance of the directions issued by the learned Single
Bench, the respondent-petitioner was examined on two occasions
by the Medical Board constituted at AIIMS. The reports of the
Medical Board of AIIMS categorically stated that the petitioner-
respondent is suffering from disability to the extent of 70% in the
left lower limb and the right lower limb of the petitioner-
respondent is not having any kind of disability.
9. In view of the reports submitted by the Medical Board of
AIIMS, the learned Single Bench came to the conclusion that the
petitioner-respondent is suffering disability only in the left leg to
the extent of 70% and since he is not having any disability in right
leg, therefore, he fulfills all the requisites qualifications of the
advertisement for the post of Compounder/Nurse Junior Grade.
Therefore, the writ petition was allowed and a direction was issued
to the State for offering him appointment to the post of
Compounder/Nurse Junior Grade.
10. The argument of the learned State Counsel is that the report
of the examination conducted by the State functionaries is final
and therefore, no other report can be relied upon for considering
the disability of the respondent-petitioner in the light of the
observations made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors. vs. Ravindra Kumar Sharma
and Ors. reported in (2016) 4 Supreme Court Cases 791 . The
learned counsel for the State very fairly submits that the reports
(Uploaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:15:52 PM)
(Downloaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:33:11 PM)

(4 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JD:47791-DB] [SAW-1186/2026]
of Medical Board of AIIMS were never challenged and at the time
of deciding the writ petition, no doubt was made on the reports of
the Medical Board of AIIMS. He however, prays that the appeal
may be allowed and the order of learned Single Bench may be
quashed and set aside.
11. Per contra, learned counsel for the petitioner-respondent has
justified the order and submits that as per the terms and
conditions of the advertisement for the post of Compounder/Nurse
Junior Grade, the petitioner-respondent is having a disability of
more than 40% in his left lower limb only and therefore, his
candidature has wrongly been rejected and in the light of reports
of the Medical Board of AIIMS, learned Single Bench has rightly
allowed the writ petition.
12. We have considered the submissions made at Bar and have
gone through the relevant record of the case.
13. The admitted position in the present case is that as per the
conditions of the advertisement for the post of Compounder/Nurse
Junior Grade, the candidates having disability of more than 40%
in one leg are considered eligible for appointment. Although, the
State Government has found the disability of respondent-
petitioner in both the legs, therefore, he was non-suited for the
post. On the directions issued by the learned Single Bench, the
Medical Board constituted by the AIIMS, on two occasions, has
reported as under:-
(Uploaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:15:52 PM)
(Downloaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:33:11 PM)

(5 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JD:47791-DB] [SAW-1186/2026]
Medical Examonation Report by Medical Board
¼esfMdy cksMZ }kjk fpfdRlk ijh{k.k fjiksVZ ½
fnukad % 02@12@2025
lanHkZ %& dk;Zokgd fpfdRlk v/kh{kd] ,El] tks/kiqj dh LohÑfr ls] dk;kZy; vkns”k la[;k
%& v-Hkk-vk-la-@fp-v-dk-@11@2025@530 fnukad 28-11-2025 ds varxZr Jh eqds”k dqekj
eh.kk iq= Jh jkekorkj eh.kk cuke jktLFkku ljdkj ds lca/k esa fnO;kaxrk ijh{k.k djokus
gsrq esfMdy cksMZ dk xBu fd;k x;k gSA ¼;g esfMdy cksMZ dk ekuuh; jktLFkku mPp
U;k;ky; ¼t;iqj csap½ esa nk;j ;kfpdk la[;k ,l-ch- flfoy fjV fifV”ku la-
19573@2025 esa ikfjr vkns”k fnukad 21-11-2025 ds varxZr fd;k x;k gSA½
izkFkhZ dk fooj.k fuEufyf[kr gS%& ;g izekf.kr fd;k tkrk gS fd geus Jh eqds”k dqekj
eh.kk iq= Jh jkekorkj eh.kk] tUefrfFk 20@07@1992 vk;q 33 o’kZ 04 ekg 13 fnu
¼fnukad 02@12@2025 ds vuqlkj½] fyax iq#’k] LFkk;h fuoklh rkyPNh dh iqfy;k ds ikl]
okMZ ua- 17 lkaxksn] rglhy lkaxksn] ftyk dksVk jktLFkku & 325001 ¼vk/kkj la[;k 3419
6276 2788½ dk lko/kkuhiwoZd fpfdRlh; ijh{k.k fd;k gSA
fpfdRlh; ijh{k.k dh frfFk ij ck;kseSfVªd iz.kkyh miyC/k u gksus ds dkj.k vH;FkhZ dh
igpku fpfdRlk cksMZ }kjk vU; oSdfYid lk/kuksa ls lqfuf”pr dh xbZA bl gsrq vH;FkhZ
dh igpku nks fpUgksa ck,a vaxwBs ds fu”kku rFkk layXu QksVksxzkQ ds vk/kkj ij lR;kfir
dh xbZA
igpku ds fu”kku %&
A raised brown, non-hairy mole of size 0.4cm x 0.4cm present
(i)
over left side of face, 2cm away from outer canthus of left eye.
(ii) A flat black non-hairy mole of size 0.1cm x 0.1cm present over
right side of neck, 7cm below right mastoid.
(iii) ck,a vaxwBs ds fu”kku
lgefr i=%&
eSa] Jh eqds”k dqekj eh.kk iq= Jh jkekorkj eh.kk viuh laiw.kZ Lora= ,oa LoSfPNd lgefr
iznku djrk gwa fd ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky; ds vkns”kkuqlkj] esjh fodykaxrk ds ekiu gsrq
esjk ijh{k.k ,El] tks/kiqj ds fpfdRlk cksMZ }kjk fd;k tk,A eSa bl ijh{k.k ls lcaf/kr
lHkh vkSipkfjdrkvksa ,oa izfØ;kvksa dks le>rk gwa ,oa mUgsa Lohdkj djrk gwaA
gLrk{kj
fpfdRlk ijh{k.k fnukad] le; ,oa LFkku %&
fnukad ,oa le; %& 02-12-2025 ¼eaxyokj½
LFkku %& fpfdRlk v/kh{kd dk;kZy;] v-Hkk-vk-la-] tks/kiqj
The disability of the petitioner has been evaluated in accordance
with the guidelines issued in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary,
Part II, Section 3, Sub-Section (ii), No.1272, New Delhi, dated
Thursday, March 14, 2024 / Phalguna 24, 1945 (Saka). The
disability of petitioner is as follows -
Sr.
No.
Disability Affected part of
Diagnosis Disability Percentage
Body
1. Locomotor
Disability
Left Lower Limb
Only
Left Lower Limb
Post-Polio
Residual
Paralysis
70%
(Seventy Percent Only)
(Uploaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:15:52 PM)
(Downloaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:33:11 PM)

(6 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JD:47791-DB] [SAW-1186/2026]
The Medical Board opinion that:- On the basis of detailed
clinical examination, physical assessment, and review of the
above-mentioned investigation reports, we, the members of the
Medical Board, are of the opinion that Sh. Mukesh Kumar Meena
S/o Ramavtar Meena is suffering from a permanent physical
disability i.e. Locomotor Disability of 70% (Seventy Percent only)
in left lower limb and there is no disability on right lower limb, in
accordance with the guidelines issued by the Government of India.
nd
Dated: 2 December, 2025
MkW- furs”k euksgj xksUukM+s MkWa- lanhi dqekj
lnL;& esfMdy cksMZ lnL;& esfMdy cksMZ
vfrfjDr vkpk;Z uSfrd fpfdRlk ,oa lg vkpk;Z] vfLFk jksx foHkkx
iquokZl foHkkx
MkW- #fp xxZ MkWa- jk?kosUnz flag “ks[kkor
la;kstd &esfMdy cksMZ v/;{k& esfMdy cksMZ
mi&fpfdRlk v/kh{kd] vfrfjDr vkpk;Z]
vLirky iz”kklu foHkkx U;k;kf;d fpfdRlk ,oa fo’k foKku foHkkx
Re-Disability Examination Report by Medical Board
¼esfMdy cksMZ }kjk iqu% fnO;kaxrk ijh{k.k fjiksVZ½
fnukad %& 28@12@2025
lanHkZ %&
1- ekuuh; jktLFkku mPp U;k;ky; ¼t;iqj csap½ esa nk;j ;kfpdk la[;k ,l-ch- flfoy
fjV fifV”ku la- 19573@2025 esa ikfjr vkns”k fnukad 21-11-2025
2- dk;Zokgd fpfdRlk v/kh{kd] v-Hkk-vk-la- tks/kiqj ds i=kad la[;k v-Hkk-vk-la-@dk-
fp-v-@12@2025@543 fnukad 04@12@2025
3- ekuuh; jktLFkku mPp U;k;ky; ¼t;iqj csap½ esa nk;j ;kfpdk la[;k ,l-ch-
flfoy fjV fifV”ku la- 19573@2025 esa ikfjr vkns”k fnukad 16-12-2025
4- dk;Zokgd fpfdRlk v/kh{kd] ,El] tks/kiqj dh LohÑfr ls] dk;kZy; vkns”k la[;k
v-Hkk-vk-la-@fp-v-dk-@12@2025@598 fnukad 22-12-2025 ,oa dk;kZy; vkns”k la[;k v-
Hkk-vk-la-@fp-v-dk-@12@2025@602 fnukad 23@12@2025
izkFkhZ dk fooj.k fuEufyf[kr gS%& ;g izekf.kr fd;k tkrk gS fd geus Jh eqds”k dqekj
eh.kk] iq= Jh jkekorkj eh.kk tUefrfFk 20-07-1992 vk;q 33 o’kZ 04 ekg 13 fnu ¼fnukad
02-12-2025 ds vuqlkj½] fyax iq#’k] LFkk;h fuoklh rkyPNh dh iqfy;k ds ikl] okMZ ua- 17
lkaxksn] rglhy lkaxksn] ftyk dksVk jktLFkku & 325001 ¼vk/kkj la[;k 3419 6276 2788½
dk lko/kkuhiwoZd iqu% fnO;kaxrk ijh{k.k fd;k gSA
(Uploaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:15:52 PM)
(Downloaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:33:11 PM)

(7 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JD:47791-DB] [SAW-1186/2026]
fpfdRlk ijh{k.k fnukad] le; ,oa LFkku %&
fnukad ,oa le; %& 26-12-2025 ¼”kqØokj½ ,oa 30-12-2025 ¼lkseokj½
LFkku %& fpfdRlk v/kh{kd dk;kZy;] v-Hkk-vk-la-] tks/kiqj
The disability of the petitioner has beenevaluated in accordance
with the guidelines issued in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary,
Part II, Section 3, Sub-Section (ii), No.1272, New Delhi, dated
Thursday, March 14, 2024 / Phalguna 24, 1945 (Saka). The
disability of petitioner is as follows -
Sr.
No.
Disability Affected part of
Diagnosis Disability
Percentage
Body
1. Locomotor
Disability
Left Lower Limb
Only
Left Lower Limb Post-
Polio Residual Paralysis
70%
(Seventy Percent
Only)
The Medical Board opinion that:- On the basis of detailed
clinical examination, physical assessment, and review of the
above-mentioned investigation reports, we, the members of the
Medical Board, are of the opinion that Sh. Mukesh Kumar Meena
S/o Ramavtar Meena is suffering from a permanent physical
disability i.e. Locomotor Disability of 70% (Seventy Percent only)
in left lower limb and there is no disability on right lower limb, in
accordance with the guidelines issued by the Government of India.
th
Dated: 12 January, 2026
MkWa- jfo xkSM+
lnL;& esfMdy cksMZ
vfr- vkpk;Z ,oa foHkkxk/;{k
HkkSfrd fpfdRlk ,oa iquokZl
MkW- jkts”k dqekj jtuh”k
MkW- foHkksj Vkd
la;kstd& esfMdy cksMZ
lnL; & esfMdy cksMZ
lgk;d vkpk;Z
vfLFk jksx foHkkx
mi&fpfdRlk v/kh{kd
foHkkx
MkW- ruqt dapu
v/;{k& esfMdy cksMZ
vkpk;Z ,oa foHkkxk/;{k
U;k;kf;d fpfdRlk ,oa fo’k foKku foHkkx
14. The Medical Board’s reports clearly reflect that the disability
of the petitioner-respondent exists only in the left leg to the
extent of 70% and he does not suffer from any disability in the
right leg. Since there is no challenge to the reports of the Medical
Board of AIIMS and the same are not found to be false or
fabricated, we find that the learned Single Bench has rightly taken
into consideration those reports and has rightly ordered that the
(Uploaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:15:52 PM)
(Downloaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:33:11 PM)

(8 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JD:47791-DB] [SAW-1186/2026]
candidature of the petitioner should be considered favorably by
giving directions to appoint him on the post of Compounder/Nurse
Junior Grade, more particularly, when the respondent-petitioner
has cleared the selection process undertaken by the Department.
15. The judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the
State is not applicable in the peculiar facts and circumstances of
the present case.
16. Therefore, the present appeal is devoid of force and the
same is dismissed.
(CHANDRA SHEKHAR SHARMA),J (VINIT KUMAR MATHUR),J
155/Twinkle Singh
(Uploaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:15:52 PM)
(Downloaded on 03/10/2026 at 02:33:11 PM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)