THE STATE OF KARNATAKA vs SMT.VINODA SHEDTHY

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU


TH
DATED THIS THE 4 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1138 OF 2016

BETWEEN:

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY THE ASSISTANT
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
KUNDAPURA SUB DIVISION,
REPRESENTED BY SPP,
BANGALORE - 560 001.
…APPELLANT







(BY SRI. K. NAGESHWARAPPA, HCGP)

AND:

1. SMT. VINODA SHEDTHY
W/O CHANDRA,
R/O ANGADIBETTU, KORAVADY,
KUMBHASHI VILLAGE,
KUNDAPURA TALUK
UDUPI DISTRICT - 576 201.

2. MANJU K
S/O KOTI
AGED 38 YEARS
R/O ANGADIBETTU, KORAVADI,
KUMBHASHI VILLAGE, KUNDAPURA TALUK,
UDUPI DISTRICT - 576 201.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. K. PRASANNA SHETTY, ADVOCATE)



Digitally signed by
LAKSHMINARAYAN N
Location: High Court
of Karnataka

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016



THIS CRL.A. IS FILED U/S.378(1) AND (3) OF CR.P.C
PRAYING TO GRANT LEAVE TO FILE AN APPEAL AGAINST THE
JUDGEMENT AND ORDER DATED 10.03.2016 PASSED IN
SPL.C.NO.1/2011 ON THE FILE OF PRL. SESSIONS/SPL. JUDGE,
UDUPI DIST., UDUPI, ACQUITTING THE RESPONDENT FOR THE
OFFENCE P/U/S 341, 323 OF IPC AND SEC. 3(1)(x) OF SC/ST
(POA) ACT.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA

ORAL JUDGMENT
The police report has not been issued with regard to
the defacto complainant.

2. Learned HCGP seeks time to serve notice. Since
the State has preferred this appeal, it is the duty of the
State to serve notice on the victim. However, the State
has not complied with the order of this Court.

3. The State has preferred this appeal against the
judgment of acquittal passed by the Principal Sessions

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016



Judge/Special Judge, Udupi, in Special Case No. 1/2011
dated 10.03.2016.

4. The brief facts leading to this appeal are:
The Assistant Superintendent of Police, Kundapura
Sub-Division, has alleged, on behalf of the prosecution,
that on 10-11-2010 at about 6.30 p.m., the accused
wrongfully restrained PW.2 Manju from proceeding ahead
on his bicycle along with PW.4 Subramanya by stopping
his bicycle and pushing the same while they were going on
the mud road near the house of the accused. When PW.2
Manju stated that he does not know when the accused
questioned with regard to the teasing of her daughter in
connection with the electric pole, the accused assaulted
him with his hand and abused him as "
ೕನು ಕೂ ಾಳ
ನನ ಮಗ ೆ
," referring to his caste in a public place,
ೕೇನು ೇಳ
ವದು
knowing fully well that he belongs to a Scheduled Caste.
Thus, the accused has committed the alleged offence.

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016




5. After filing charge sheet, accused was secured
before the trial Court and was enlarged on bail. On hearing
the charges, the trial Court framed the charges against the
accused for the alleged commission of offences; the same
was read over and explained to the accused. The accused
pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

6. To prove the guilt of the accused, 9 witnesses
were examined as PW1 to PW9. 8 documents were marked
as Exhibits P1 to P8. No material objects were marked on
behalf of the prosecution. On closure of the prosecution
evidence, the statement under Section 313 of the CrPC
was recorded. The accused totally denied the evidence of
the prosecution witnesses. However, he did not choose to
lead any defence evidence on his behalf. Exhibits D1 to D9
were marked during the course of cross-examination of
the prosecution witnesses. Having heard the arguments
on both sides, the trial Court acquitted the accused.

7. Being aggrieved by the judgment of acquittal,
the State has preferred this appeal. The learned HCGP,

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016



Sri.K.Nageshwarappa, submits that the impugned
judgment and order of acquittal recorded by the trial Court
are opposed to law, facts, the probabilities of the case,
and the evidence on record. The learned Sessions Judge
has not properly appreciated the evidence of PW2, the
victim, the evidence of PW1, the doctor, and wound
certificate Exhibit P12. The learned Sessions Judge also
failed to appreciate the evidence of PW5, who is a material
witness to the case of the prosecution. The trial Court has
failed to appreciate the evidence on record in accordance
with law and facts, and accordingly, he sought to allow
this appeal.

8. The learned counsel for the respondent submits
that the trial Court has properly appreciated the evidence
on record in accordance with law and facts, and sought
dismissal of the appeal.

9. Having heard the arguments on both sides, the
following points arise for my consideration:

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016



i. Whether the State has made out grounds to interfere
with the impugned judgment of acquittal?
ii. What order?

10. My answers to the above points are as under:
i. Negative.
ii. As per the final order.
Regarding Point No.1:

11. I have examined the materials placed before
this Court. To prove the guilt of the accused, prosecution
has examined 9 witnesses as PW1 to 9. PW.1 is the doctor
who examined PW.2 Manju and issued wound certificate
Ex.P1 and also intimated to the police by sending Ex.P2
MLC intimation. PW.2 is Manju and he is the complainant
and the injured. PW.3 is Tahsildar who issued Ex.P4 Caste
Certificate of PW.2 Manju and accused. PW.4 is
Subramanya is an eyewitness to the incident and he has

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016



shown spot to the police. PW.5 is Manjunath Hathwar who
came to the spot after the incident and took PW.2 Manju
on his bike and dropped him to Kumbashi. PW.6-
Raghavendra is panch to Ex.P5 spot mahazar. PW.7 is
W.P.C. who carried Ex.P7 F.I.R. and Ex.P3 complaint and
handed over the same to the Special Judge. PW.8 is the
Head Constable who received Ex.P2 MLC intimation from
Taluk Government Hospital, Kumbashi and who went to
the hospital and recorded the statement of PW.2 Manju
who was admitted in the hospital and thereafter, came
back to the police station and registered the case on the
basis of Ex.P3 Statement of PW.2 Manju. PW.9 is the
A.S.P. who is the Investigating Officer.

12. On careful examination of the entire evidence
on record the trial Court has observed in paragraphs
No.14 to 16 are as under:
"14. PW.2 has deposed that accused abused touching
his caste and insulted him in public place and it
annoyed him. PW 2 in the cross-examination has
stated before him that he was annoyed as the
accused abused touching his caste but police have

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016



not mentioned the same in his statement and he has
not asked the police why they have not mentioned
the same in his statement. Ex.P3 is the statement of
PW.2. There is no mention of the same in it. PW.9
A.S.P. who is the Investigating Officer who has
recorded the statement of PW.2 has stated in the
cross-examination that PW.2 has not stated before
him that he has been annoyed. Therefore, the said
aspect deposed by PW.2 is an improvement.
15. PW.2 has stated in the cross-examination that he
was having facial acquaintance with the accused.
PW.2 in the cross-examination has admitted the
suggestion that accused Vinoda Shedthi had filed
complaint against him and Ganesh in Women Police
Station on 28-08-2010 and he has given undertaking
not to indulge in criminal act against Vinoda Shedthi
and her daughter in Women Police Station. Exs.D1 to
D4 are the said copies of NC acknowledgement
petition, statement of Manju, statement of Ganesh
and endorsement dated:28-08-2010. The very said
documents go to show that he is well acquainted
with the accused. Even though PW.2 is well
acquainted with the accused, he has stated in the
cross-examination that he was having facial
acquaintance with the accused. The very said
documents Exs.D1 to D5 go to show that earlier
there was quarrel between PW 2 and the accused
and the police have warned PW.2. The very said
aspect goes to show that there was enmity between
PW.2 Manju and accused Vinoda Shedthi.
16. PW.2 has deposed that at the time of incident his
mobile, cash and golden chain cut, fell on the ground
and he does not know what happened to the said
articles and cash. PW.2 in the cross-examination has
stated that he has stated before the police about the
mobile number. weight of golden chain and cash. But
the same is not mentioned in the statement Ex.P3
statement of PW.2. N PW.2 has stated in the cross-
examination that he did not get back his mobile

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016



phone, golden chain and cash and he has asked the
police to get back his mobile phone, golden chain
and cash. PW.2 has further stated that he has not
taken any legal action for getting mobile phone,
golden chain and cash. PW.4 has deposed that at the
time of incident, golden chain, mobile and cash of
Manju fell on the ground. PW.4 in the cross-
examination has stated that he did not collect mobile
phone, cash and golden chain fell on the road and he
does not know total cash fell on the road. PW.5 has
deposed that he came to the spot after the incident
and PW.2 has narrated about the incident before
him. PW.5 has stated in the cross-examination that
there was no articles fallen on the road except cycle
when he went there. PW.4 has stated that after 5-10
minutes Manjunath Hathwar came on his bike and he
enquired PW.4 has stated in the cross-about the
matter. examination that Manju and Hathwar went
first and thereafter, he went and he does not know
whether said articles were on the road when Hathwar
came there. He does not know whether Manju told
Hathwar about his articles fell on the road. The said
evidence goes to show that even after PWs.2 and 5
went away from the spot, PW.4 remained on the spot
but he is not aware about what happened to the
mobile, cash and golden chain fell on the spot. PW.2
has stated in the cross-examination that no others
came to the spot at the time of incident. The very
said aspect goes to show that PWs.2 and 4 are
deposing falsely that mobile phone, cash and golden
chain of PW.2 fell on the spot at the time of
incident."

13. On re-appreciation/ re-examination and
reconsideration of the entire evidence on record, I do not
find any factual or legal error committed by the trial Court.
Hence, I answer Point No.1: in the 'Negative'.

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61405
CRL.A No. 1138 of 2016


CNR: KAHC010519602016



Regarding Point No.2: For the aforesaid reasons and
discussions, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
dismissed.
Appeal is


Sd/-
(G BASAVARAJA)
JUDGE

TIN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 13