Ashok Kumar vs Shri Bhagwan Transport Co & Ors.

Court
Delhi High Court

$~51
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
th
% Date of decision: 04 November 2026

# CNR No. DLHC010041662026
+ CM(M) 311/2026 & CM APPL. 8265-8266/2026
ASHOK KUMAR .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Sudhir Naagar, Mr. Akhil
Gusain, Advocates.
versus

SHRI BHAGWAN TRANSPORT CO & ORS. .....Respondents
Through: Ms. Prabhsahay Kaur, Advocate
( Amicus Curiae ) with Mr. Soumit
Ganguli, Advocate.

CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT

ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1. This petition has been filed by the petitioner/plaintiff assailing
th th
impugned orders dated 11 July 2025 and 10 October 2025, passed by the
District Judge- 02, North District, Rohini Courts, New Delhi [‘ Trial
Court ’] in CS DJ No. 621/2018 , whereby the petitioner/plaintiff was
directed to file his PAN Card, considering that an amount of Rs.
49,00,000/- had been paid in cash to the respondent/defendant no.1, as per
the plaint [‘ impugned orders ’].
2. This direction had been passed in view of compliance with the
decision of the Supreme Court in RBANMS Educational Institution v. B.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 1 of 12

Gunashekar & Anr. , 2025 INSC 490.
3. Mr. Naagar , counsel for petitioner, at the outset, stated that the said
judgement makes it clear that the Court was concerned with the violation of
Section 269ST of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which was introduced in 2017
through an amendment, in order to curb black money. On this basis, he
contends that since the transaction had taken place in 2015,
petitioner/plaintiff would not be covered under the said direction.
4. This Court appointed Ms. Prabhsahay Kaur , Advocate, as Amicus
Curiae , to assist the Court on the legal issue involved.
5. Ms. Prabhsahay Kaur , Amicus Curiae , apprised the Court of the
broad aspects of the issues raised by petitioner/plaintiff while assailing the
impugned order.
6. The crux of the matter is that a suit was filed by petitioner/plaintiff
for recovery of Rs.35,67,000/-. During the course of final arguments, the
Trial Court directed the petitioner/plaintiff to file a copy of his PAN card,
considering that, as per the plaint, an amount of Rs.49,00,000/- had been
paid in cash to respondent/defendant no.1.
7. Amicus Curiae pointed out the following aspects:
(i) As per the plaint, various amounts were provided by
petitioner/plaintiff to defendants/respondents over a period of
time, from 2012 onwards, as friendly loans. The initial
amounts were in round figures; however, as is evident from
paragraph 8 of the plaint, the amounts paid from December
2012 onwards were specific amounts, such as Rs.23,47,216/-,
followed by Rs.63,712/- and so on.
(ii) On the face of it, the money does not appear to be provided
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 2 of 12

towards stock loans or friendly loans, and instead appears to
have been paid towards certain transactions, that may have
occurred between the parties, in respect of which cash
payments were made.
(iii) Specifically in order to curb proliferation of such cash
transactions above a certain value, the Supreme Court in
RBANMS Educational Institution ( supra ), issued certain
directions vide paragraph 18.1 of the said judgment. The
Supreme Court, essentially, directed the Courts to inform the
Income Tax Department, in cases where suits were filed with
claims that more than Rs.2,00,000/- was being paid in cash
towards any transaction. At that time, the Supreme Court
relied upon the extant provisions of the Income Tax Act viz .
Section 269ST of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [‘ the Act ’].
(iv) Section 269SS of the Act, also prohibits transactions of
Rs.20,000/- or more in cash, particularly in respect of loans or
deposits exceeding the said threshold.
(v) Therefore, considering that the transactions, as stated in the
plaint, occurred at the time when Section 269SS was
applicable, Ld. Amicus Curiae contends that it was incumbent
upon the Trial Court to comply with the directions of the
Supreme Court. She submits that the directions of the Supreme
Court could not be read in isolation from a particular provision
which came on the statute book in 2017, since the purpose was
to ensure that information regarding transactions, made
outside the formal channels of payment, was to be provided.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 3 of 12

8. It is an admitted position that the transaction in this case related to a
loan of Rs.49,00,000/- being paid by the petitioner/plaintiff to
respondents/defendant nos. 1 and 2 in cash, on different dates up till
September 2015. Considering that the transactions in question took place
prior to 2017, one of the issues before the Court was whether the said
transaction would have to be reported to the jurisdictional tax authorities in
view of the decision of the Supreme Court in RBANMS Educational
Institution ( supra ), wherein the Supreme Court dealt with the violation of
Section 269ST of the Act, introduced in 2017.
9. What is now clear, to this Court, is that prior to the introduction of
Section 269ST of the Act by the Finance Act, 2017, another provision i.e.
Section 269SS, had already been inserted by the Finance Act, 1984, with
st
effect from 01 April 1984. Section 269SS was made operative in respect
st
of loans and deposits taken or accepted on or after 01 July 1984. Initially,
the monetary threshold prescribed was Rs.10,000/- , which was
st
subsequently enhanced to Rs.20,000/- with effect from 01 April 1989. For
ease of reference Sections 269SS and 269ST have been reproduced
hereinbelow:
“ 269SS. Mode of taking or accepting certain loans,
deposits and specified sum .—No person shall, after the
th
30 day of June, 1984, take or accept from any other
person (herein referred to as the depositor), any loan or
deposit or any specified sum, otherwise than by an
account payee cheque or account payee bank draft or use
of electronic clearing system through a bank account or
through such other electronic mode as may be
prescribed, if,—
(a) the amount of such loan or deposit or specified sum
or the aggregate amount of such loan, deposit and
specified sum; or
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 4 of 12

(b) on the date of taking or accepting such loan or
deposit or specified sum, any loan or deposit or
specified sum taken or accepted earlier by such person
from the depositor is remaining unpaid (whether
repayment has fallen due or not), the amount or the
aggregate amount remaining unpaid; or
(c) the amount or the aggregate amount referred to in
clause (a) together with the amount or the aggregate
amount referred to in clause (b), is twenty thousand
rupees or more:
Provided that the provisions of this section shall not
apply to any loan or deposit or specified sum taken or
accepted from, or any loan or deposit or specified sum
taken or accepted by,—
(a) the Government;
(b) any banking company, post office savings bank or
co-operative bank;
(c) any corporation established by a Central, State or
Provincial Act;
(d) any Government company as defined in clause (45)
of Section 2 of the Companies Act, 2013 (18 of 2013);
(e) such other institution, association or body or class
of institutions, associations or bodies which the
Central Government may, for reasons to be recorded
in writing, notify in this behalf in the Official Gazette:
Provided further that the provisions of this section shall
not apply to any loan or deposit or specified sum, where
the person from whom the loan or deposit or specified
sum is taken or accepted and the person by whom the
loan or deposit or specified sum is taken or accepted, are
both having agricultural income and neither of them has
any income chargeable to tax under this Act.
Provided also that the provisions of this section shall
have effect, as if for the words “twenty thousand rupees”,
the words “two lakh rupees” had been substituted in the
case of any deposit or loan where,—
(a) such deposit is accepted by a primary agricultural
credit society or a primary co-operative agricultural
and rural development bank from its member; or
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 5 of 12

(b) such loan is taken from a primary agricultural
credit society or a primary co-operative agricultural
and rural development bank by its member.]
Explanation.— For the purposes of this section,—
(i) “banking company” means a company to which the
provisions of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (10 of
1949) applies and includes any bank or banking
institution referred to in Section 51 of that Act;
(ii) “co-operative bank”, “primary agricultural credit
society” and “primary co-operative agricultural and
rural development bank” shall have the meanings
respectively assigned to them in the Explanation to
sub-section (4) of Section 80-P;
(iii) “loan or deposit” means loan or deposit of
money;
(iv) “specified sum” means any sum of money
receivable, whether as advance or otherwise, in
relation to transfer of an immovable property, whether
or not the transfer takes place.
269ST. Mode of undertaking transactions .—No person
shall receive an amount of two lakh rupees or more—
(a) in aggregate from a person in a day; or
(b) in respect of a single transaction; or
(c) in respect of transactions relating to one event or
occasion from a person, otherwise than by an account
payee cheque or an account payee bank draft or use of
electronic clearing system through a bank account or
through such other electronic mode as may be
prescribed:
Provided that the provisions of this section shall not
apply to—
(i) any receipt by—
(a) Government;
(b) any banking company, post office savings bank
or co-operative bank;
(ii) transactions of the nature referred to in Section
269-SS;
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 6 of 12

(iii) such other persons or class of persons or receipts,
which the Central Government may, by notification in
the Official Gazette, specify.
Explanation.— For the purposes of this section,—
(a) “banking company” shall have the same meaning
as assigned to it in clause (i) of the Explanation to
Section 269-SS;
(b) “co-operative bank” shall have the same meaning
as assigned to it in clause (ii) of the Explanation to
Section 269-SS. ”
10. The legislative competence to enact Section 269SS was upheld by
the Supreme Court in Assistant Director of Inspection (Investigation) v.
A.B. Shanthi , (2002) 6 SCC 259, wherein the Supreme Court indicated that
the objective behind the said provision is to “ curb the menace ” of
unaccounted money. Relevant paragraphs from A.B. Shanthi ( supra ) are
extracted hereinbelow for ready reference:
“ 8. The contention of the appellant's counsel has no
force. The object of introducing Section 269-SS is to
ensure that a taxpayer is not allowed to give false
explanation for his unaccounted money, or if he has given
some false entries in his accounts, he shall not escape by
giving false explanation for the same. During search and
seizures, unaccounted money is unearthed and the
taxpayer would usually give the explanation that he had
borrowed or received deposits from his relatives or
friends and it is easy for the so-called lender also to
manipulate his records later to suit the plea of the
taxpayer. The main object of Section 269-SS was to curb
this menace. As regards the tax legislations, it is a policy
matter, and it is for Parliament to decide in which
manner the legislation should be made. Of course, it
should stand the test of constitutional validity.
xxx
10. The above dictum applies in full force as regards the
present case. The object sought to be achieved was to
eradicate the evil practice of making of false entries in
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 7 of 12

the account books and later giving explanation for the
same. To a great extent, the problem could be solved by
the impugned provision.
(emphasis added)
11. Furthermore, keeping in mind the underlying principle forming the
basis of the decision in RBANMS Educational Institution ( supra ), various
Courts have also reported transactions undertaken prior to 2017 to the
jurisdictional tax authorities. In this regard, attention was drawn by the
Amicus Curiae to the decision of the High Court of Madras in R.V.
Venkateshan v. Sanjay , 2026 SCC OnLine Mad 5000, wherein the suit for
recovery of money was based on a promissory note executed in respect of a
loan of Rs.80,00,000/- , advanced in cash in 2016. Taking note of the fact
that the transaction occurred prior to 2017, the Madras High Court

observed as under:
“ 9. In the case on hand, as per the plaint averment, the
plaintiff said to have paid Rs 80,00,000 in cash to the
defendants on 21-6-2016. Though the amount said to
have been paid prior to coming into force of Section 269
ST of Income Tax Act, such a huge transaction by the
plaintiff should have been reflected in his income tax
return. If it is not duly mentioned in its income tax
returns, certainly, the transaction should be viewed with
suspicion. Whether the transaction which has not been
brought into the book or a black money transaction can
be a subject matter of the suit and whether the Court
can lend its helping hand to recover money based on
such transaction are all matters to be decided at the
time of final disposal of the suit. Therefore, I do not
want to express any opinion on the said aspect. If
ultimately the plaintiff is able to prove the payment of Rs
80,00,000 by cash to the defendants, certainly it should
be brought to the notice of the income tax Department
for setting law into motion.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 8 of 12

10. The Supreme Court, in the above mentioned decisions
with the noble object of abolishing black money
transaction, issued general guidelines to Courts in India
to intimate such kind of heavy cash transaction to the
jurisdictional Income Tax Authorities. Though the present
suit transaction had taken place prior to introduction of
Section 269ST of the Income Tax Act, even in the absence
of said provisions, this kind of heavy cash transaction
requires consideration by the income tax Department.
Therefore, I do not want to interfere with the order
passed by the trial court directing the Ministerial Officer
of the Court to intimate the suit transaction to the income
tax Department by forwarding the copies of the plaint
documents.
(emphasis added)
12. Similarly, in Nishant Creations Pvt. Ltd. v. Prasad Buildcon Pvt.
th
Ltd. , CS(OS) 1887/2015, order dated 18 March 2026, the Court was
dealing with an amount of Rs. 2,60,00,0000/- , out of which Rs.
2,00,00,000/- was paid in June 2011 and Rs.1.25 crores , out of the said
Rs.2,00,00,000/- was paid in cash towards an agreement to sell. The Court
thereby directed the Registrar General of this Court to forward the case for
information and necessary action to the Principal Chief Commissioner,
Income Tax Department, New Delhi, along with a copy of a suit and the
documents annexed thereto.
13. Accordingly, the opinion of this Court would resonate with the
opinion previously put forward by the Coordinate Bench of this Court as
well as by the Madras High Court, for the reason that the objective of the
Supreme Court in RBANMS Educational Institution ( supra ) was to ensure
reporting of cash transactions to the Income Tax Authorities in order to
curb the menace of unaccounted money/black money.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 9 of 12

14. In any event, since the transaction in question is a ‘ loan ’, it would, in
any case, fall within the purview of Section 269SS, which was in existence
even prior to 2017.
15. Accordingly, in the opinion of this Court, the reporting directed by
th
the Trial Court, vide order dated 11 July 2025, is appropriate, except in
respect of one issue. The Trial Court has also directed the
petitioner/plaintiff to file a copy of his PAN Card. The subsequent
application moved by the petitioner/plaintiff, prayed for a recall of this
particular direction. However, while rejecting the plea for recall vide order
th
dated 10 December 2025, the Trial Court, in paragraph 9 , stated that the
Permanent Account Number [‘ PAN ’] of the petitioner/plaintiff was also
required to be sent and that there was no ground to recall the said order.
16. To this extent, the Trial Court may not be correct, particularly since
the Supreme Court in RBANMS Educational Institution ( supra ) has not
issued any specific direction for disclosure of plaintiff’s PAN card.
17. In this context, Amicus Curiae pointed out that the PAN card
contains personal identifying particulars, including the holder's name, PAN,
date of birth, photograph and signature and, where applicable, the father's
name. The particulars are also encoded in the QR code which facilitate
verification of the holder's identity. Even though the PAN No. serves as an
important identifier, particularly for financial information ecosystem, if the
same comes into the possession of an unauthorized person, it may be
misused, thereby exposing the PAN holder.
18. Therefore, this direction requiring disclosure of the
petitioner/plaintiffs’ PAN is neither in accordance with the decision of the
Supreme Court in RBANMS Educational Institution ( supra ) nor per
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 10 of 12

Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India , (2017) 10 SCC 1,
wherein the nine-judge Bench of the Supreme Court recognised
information privacy as a facet of the fundamental right to privacy.
19. Support in this regard may also be drawn from the decision of this
Court in Nishant Creations ( supra ), wherein the Coordinate Bench of this
Court merely directed the Registrar General of this Court to forward ‘ the
case ” for information and necessary action “ along with the copy of the suit
and the documents annexed thereto ”. In R.V. Venkateshan ( supra ) as well,
the Madras High Court dealt with the plea of the defendant pleading for the
PAN number of petitioner to be revealed as well as the direction issued by
the Trial Court to that effect. The Madras High Court rejected the said plea
and thereby held as under:
“11. As far as the direction issued by the trial Court to
reveal the PAN number of the petitioner is concerned, in
the guideline issued by the Apex Court in the
above-mentioned case, no such direction is given and the
petitioner cannot be compelled to reveal his PAN number
to the respondents. Therefore, the direction issued by the
trial Court to the petitioner to reveal his PAN number to
the respondents is set aside and that portion of the
impugned order is modified. The direction issued by the
trial Court forward the copy of the plaint and the plaint
documents to the jurisdictional Income Tax Authority is
confirmed. ”
(emphasis added)

20. The direction issued by the Madras High Court was therefore to
“ forward the copy of the plaint along with documents to the Jurisdictional
Income Tax Authority ”.
21. In yet another matter before this Court, namely, Birmala Projects
Pvt. Ltd. v. Ashwani Ahluwalia , 2025 SCC OnLine Del 6784, this Court
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 11 of 12

directed the Registry to send the entire paper book of the concerned case to
the Jurisdictional Income Tax Authority to enable it to take appropriate
steps in accordance with the directions of the Supreme Court in RBANMS
Educational Institution ( supra ).
22. In light of the above, the impugned order is set aside to the extent
that it requires the petitioner/plaintiff to disclose his PAN Card. However,
it is hereby directed that a copy of the suit along with the other relevant
documents shall be duly sent to the Jurisdictional Tax Authority/Principal
Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi, in line with what has been opined
hereinabove.

23. The petition is partly allowed to the extent as stated above.
24. We express our deep appreciation for Ms. Prabhsahay Kaur ,
Advocate, Amicus Curiae , who has traversed various nuances relating to
the matter before us in great detail and precision.
25. Needless to state that the t rial may proceed in accordance with law,
considering that the direction herein is merely for the purpose of supplying
necessary information to the jurisdictional tax authorities and ought not to
serve as an impediment in the proceedings before the Trial Court.
26. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion relating
to the merits of the matter and therefore, the suit before the Trial Court
shall be decided on its own merits.
27. This petition stands disposed of with above directions.
28. Order be uploaded on the website of this Court.

(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
NOVEMBER 04, 2026/sm /ya
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:17.11.2026
16:43:47

CM(M) 311/2026 Page 12 of 12