SMT. SHAHANA KHATOON vs STATE OF CHHATTISGARH
- Court
- Chhattisgarh High Court
Page 1 of 15
CGHC010230162020 2026:CGHC:47509
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 4169 of 2020
Reserved On : 22 .09.2026
Delivered On : 18.11 .2026
• Smt. Shahana Khatoon W/o Dr. Shahid A. Siddiqui Aged About 34
Years R/o Flat No. 05, Apartment No. A-5, Chouhan Green Valley,
Bhilai, District Durg Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Government Of
Chhattisgarh, Department Of Higher Education, Mantralaya, Mahanadi
Bhawan, Nava Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin Code 492002.
2 - Commissioner Department Of Higher Education, Government Of
Chhattisgarh, Block -3, Indravati Bhawan, Nava Raipur District Raipur
Chhattisgarh Pin Code 492002.
3 - Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission Through Secretary, Shankar
Nagar Road, Bhagat Singh Square, Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin
Code 492001.
4 - Ms. Rajkumari Markam Roll No. 1905200329, PSC Selected Candidate
For The Post Of Sports Officer (Higher Education) C/o O/o Commissioner,
Department Of Higher Education, Government Of Chhattisgarh, Block -3,
Indravati Bhawan, Nava Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin Code
492002.
5 - Ms. Poornima Thakur Roll No. 1905200224, PSC Selected Candidate
For The Post Of Sports Officer (Higher Education) C/o O/o Commissioner,
Department Of Higher Education, Government Of Chhattisgarh, Block -3,
Indravati Bhawan, Nava Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin Code
492002.
6 - Ms. Pooja Sonkar Roll No. 1905200229, PSC Selected Candidate For
The Post Of Sports Officer (Higher Education) C/o O/o Commissioner,
Department Of Higher Education, Government Of Chhattisgarh, Block -3,
BHUMIKA
ANGARE
HIGH COURT OF
CHHATTISGARH
Page 2 of 15
Indrawati Bhawan, Nava Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin Code
492002, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
7 - Ms. Heeramati Sahu Roll No. 1905200152, PSC Selected Candidate
For The Post Of Sports Officer (Higher Education) C/o O/o Commissioner,
Department Of Higher Education, Government Of Chhattisgarh, Block -3,
Indravati Bhawan, Nava Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin Code
492002.
8 - Ms. Bharati Rajak Roll No. 1905200028, PSC Selected Candidate For
The Post Of Sports Officer (Higher Education) C/o O/o Commissioner,
Department Of Higher Education, Government Of Chhattisgarh, Block -3,
Indravati Bhawan, Nava Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh Pin Code
492002.
... Respondents
For Petitioner : Mr. L.C. Patne, Advocate appeared through
Video Conferencing
For State : Mr. Arpit Agrawal, Panel Lawyer
For Res. No. 3 : Mr. Anand Mohan Tiwari, Advocate
For Res. No. 4 to 7 : Mr. Anchal Kumar Matre, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Narendra Kumar Vyas, J.
CAV ORDER
1. The petitioner has filed the present writ petition assailing the select
list dated 18.09.2020 (Annexure P/9), issued by the Chhattisgarh
Public Service Commission (for short “the CGPSC”) by which
respondents No. 4 to 8 have been selected for appointment on the
post of Sports Officer.
2. This Court vide order dated 19.10.2020 has directed the State not to
give effect the appointment of respondents No. 4 to 8 as well as the
petitioner. It has also been directed by this Court that the respondent
State was at liberty to proceed with the appointment procedure with
regard to other selected candidates. The interim order passed by this
Court was challenged before the Hon’ble Division Bench of this
Court by filing Writ Appeal No. 443/2021 and the Hon’ble Division
Page 3 of 15
Bench has directed for early disposal of the matter. Thereafter, this
Court on 11.06.2024 has vacated the interim order and in pursuance
of vacating the appointment order, the petitioners of the other
connected cases bearing WP(S) No. 447/2020, 4466/2020 and
4169/2020 were appointed by the State. Consequently, the private
respondents in those writ petitions were also appointed by the State,
accordingly, this Court has also vacated the interim order passed by
this Court in WP(S) No. 4169/2020 on 17.06.2026 applying the
principle of parity and thereafter the matter was heard finally on
22.09.2026.
3. The brief facts as reflected from the record are that:
(a) The respondent No. 3/CGPSC issued an advertisement No.
5/2019 on 06.03.2019 for appointment of 61 posts of Sports
Officer and 56 posts of Librarian in the Higher Education
Department. The reservation wise vacancy position as published
in the advertisement is as under:
l-
Ø-
in dk
dqy fjfDr;ksa dh oxZokj
dqy fjfDr;ksa dh oxZokj
dqy fjfDr;ksa dh esa ls
;ksx dqy
;ksx
osru eSfVªDl
uke
la[;k
la[;k esa ls dsoy
NRRkhlx<+ ds Lfkkuh;
fuoklh efgykvksa ds fy,
fu%’kDrtuksa ds fy,
vkjf{kr in
vkjf{kr in
vuk- v-tk- v-t-
v-fi-
o-
vuk- v-tk- v-t-
v-fi-
o-
tk-
tk-
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
1 xazFkiky
2(OA,OI,OAI,B,LV,HH)
25
1(OA,OI,OAI,B,LV,HH)
31
56 osru eSfVªDl
vdknfed
ysoy&10 ¼osru
cSaM #
15800&39100 $
,-th-ih- 6000½
cSdykWx
2 ØhM+k
vf/kdkjh
40
21
61
cSdykWx
dqy in%& 117
(b) The petitioner being qualified and having been cleared CGTET
Examination in Physical Education applied for the post of Sports
Page 4 of 15
Officer in UR-Female category and appeared in the written
examination conducted by the CGPSC on 26.11.2019 as well as
participated in the interview conducted and secured 147.9701
marks by securing place at Serial No. 65 in the final merit list
whereas respondents No. 4 to 8 who were OBC category and
placed at Sr. No. 7, 9, 21, 28 & 13 respectively in the final merit
list by securing 213.8344, 211.7936, 200.6305, 188.3247 &
207.6712 marks respectively and got selected against the post
reserved for UR-Female candidates by migrating from reserved
category to unreserved category ignoring that the reservation for
women candidates in the State of Chhattisgarh, is horizontal and
compartmental in nature as contemplated under the
Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Special Provision for Appointment of
Women) Rules, 1997 (for short “Rules of 1997”), as such the
selection list so far as respondents No. 4 to 8 is dehors the
Rules and liable to be quashed by this Court. Hence this petition.
4. Respondent No. 3/CGPSC has filed its return mainly contending that
the entire selection process was conducted strictly in accordance
with the Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission Rules of
Procedure, 2014, as amended on 08.03.2017 and according to the
Rules 7, 10, 11 and 17 of the said Rules, the reserved-category
candidates could be considered against unreserved vacancies on
the basis of merit on satisfying the minimum qualifying standard
prescribed for the Unreserved category. It has been further
contended that reservation for women is horizontal and
compartmental wise and there is no separate sub-category. It has
Page 5 of 15
been further contended that there is no express bar under the Rules
or the advertisement against SC/ST/OBC candidates being
considered for unreserved posts and that respondent Nos. 4 to 8
were selected on the basis of their merit in accordance with the
applicable Rules and also stated that the cut-off marks were
205.7121 for Unreserved candidates and 87.4672 for Reserved
candidates. It has been further contended that there is legal
impediment with regard to maintainability of the writ petition because
if the petition is allowed the select list will be adversely affected
without hearing the affected parties, as such it has been prayed for
dismissal of the writ petition due to non-joinder of necessary party,
alternatively it has been prayed that the petitioner be directed to
implead all the candidates who have been selected as party to the
case.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the
respondent/CGPSC has failed to apply the principle of horizontal
and compartmental reservation prescribed under Rule 3(1) of the
Rules of 1997 as under the aforesaid Rules, 33% reservation for
female candidates is horizontal and compartmental, requiring
separate reservation for female candidates in each vertical category,
namely, General, SC, ST and OBC as Explanation to Rule 3(1)
clarifies that such reservation shall operate in each of these
categories. He would further submit that the Rules, framed in
exercise of the powers under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution of India, have overriding effect over other service rules
by virtue of the non-obstinate clause contained in Rule 3(1). He
Page 6 of 15
would further submit that reservation in favour of women is a special
'horizontal reservation' referable to Article 15(3) of the Constitution of
India and is distinct from 'vertical reservation' under Article 16(4) and
the use of the expression 'General' instead of 'Unreserved' in the
Explanation to Rule 3(1) manifests the legislative intention to treat
General Category women as a separate class, entitled to 33%
reservation at par with female candidates belonging to SC, ST and
OBC categories. Consequently, the reservation is category-specific,
and adjustment of reserved-category female candidates against
posts earmarked for General Category Female (URF) candidates is
impermissible. He would further submit that respondent Nos. 4 to 8
belonged to reserved categories and had obtained the requisite
eligibility/qualification by availing the benefit of relaxed standards
applicable to their respective reserved categories.
6. He would further submit that the candidates who had obtained
eligibility or qualification by availing the benefit of relaxed standards
applicable to reserved categories could not thereafter be migrated or
adjusted against the UR-Female category, as their selection was not
based upon the standards applicable to candidates competing in the
Unreserved category. He would further submit that respondent No.
3-CGPSC has illegally adjusted female candidates belonging to
SC/ST/OBC categories against the posts earmarked for URF
candidates, thereby exceeding the prescribed percentage of
horizontal and compartmental reservation in the respective reserved
categories. As a result, private respondents No. 4 to 8, belonging to
reserved categories, have been selected against URF posts,
Page 7 of 15
depriving the petitioner, who stood at Serial No. 3 in the order of
merit under the URF category, of her rightful place in the main select
list and would pray for setting aside the impugned select list and
allow the instant writ petition.
7. To substantiate his submission, he would refer to the judgments
rendered by the Hon'ble the Supreme Court in case of Indra
Sawhney Vs. Union of India & Others reported in 1992 Supp. (3)
SCC 217, Anil Kumar Gupta and Others Vs. State of U.P. &
Others reported in (1995) 5 SCC 173, Rajesh Kumar Daria Vs.
Rajasthan Public Service Commission and others reported in
(2007) 8 SCC 785, Uttaranchal Public Service Commission Vs.
Mamta Bisht reported in (2010) 12 SCC 204 & Deepa E.V. Vs.
Union of India & Others reported in (2017) 12 SCC 680 .
8. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent No.3/ CGPSC
opposing the submissions made by learned counsel for the petitioner
would submit that the impugned select list has been prepared in
accordance with the applicable recruitment rules and the settled
principles governing horizontal and vertical reservation. He would
further submit that horizontal reservation for women is required to be
adjusted within the respective vertical categories in accordance with
the prescribed procedure and that eligible female candidates
belonging to reserved categories cannot be denied consideration
against unreserved female posts merely on the ground of their social
category, unless they have availed any impermissible relaxation in
the selection process. He would further submit that the selection of
respondent Nos. 4 to 8 have been made in accordance with the
Page 8 of 15
applicable rules and merit position, and that the petitioner has failed
to establish any illegality or violation of the reservation policy in
preparation of the impugned select list and would pray for dismissal
of the writ petition.
9. Learned counsel for private respondents has adopted the
submission made by the learned counsel for the State and supports
the stand taken by the State and would pray for dismissal of the writ
petition.
10. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents placed on record with utmost satisfaction.
11. From the submissions made by the parties, the point emerged for
determination is:
“Whether the migration of OBC female candidates to General
women category under the Chhattisgarh Civil Services
(Special Provision for Appointment of Women) Rules, 1997 is
permissible or not.”
12. To appreciate this point emerged for determination, it is expedient for
this Court to extract the relevant provisions of Rules of 1997, which
reads as under:
“ Rule 3. Reservation of posts for women .
Notwithstanding anything contained in any service Rules,
there shall be reserved thirty percent of all posts in the
service under the State in favour of women at the stage of
direct recruitment and the said reservation shall be horizontal
and compartment-wise.
Explanation.- For the purposes of this rule "horizontal and
compartment-wise reservation" means reservation in each
category, namely, Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes,
Other Backward Classes and General.”
13. The submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner that
as per the Rules of 1997 only horizontal and compartment-wise
Page 9 of 15
reservation is permissible which means reservation in each category,
namely, Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward
Classes and General and there is no provision for vertical
reservation, as such migration of OBC candidates to General
candidate is not permissible is being considered by this Court now.
14. From perusal of Rules of 1997, it is quite vivid that in case a woman
candidate is selected, she would be adjusted against the appropriate
social category which she belongs to (SC/ST/OBC/OC). However,
there is no rule, or direction which prohibits the adjustment of
socially reserved categories of women in the general category or
“open category”. The Rules of 1997 further provides that even after
providing for this horizontal reservation, the percentage of
reservation in favour of the backward class of citizens remain the
same. This is how, these reservations are worked and there is no
reason to continue that procedure.
15. The issue with regard to Horizontal and Vertical reservation has
come up for consideration before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case
of Saurav Yadav and Others vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and
Others reported in 2021 (4) SCC 542, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has held as under:
“57. As is apparent from a plain reading of the above
government order, the only stipulation with respect to
treatment of horizontal reservation for women, is that in case
a woman candidate is selected, she would be adjusted
against the appropriate social category she belongs to
(SC/ST/OBC/OC). However, there is no rule, or direction
which prohibits the adjustment of socially reserved
categories of women in the general category or “open
category”. The first indication of this is in Indira Sawhney 16
where B.P. Jeevan Reddy, J stated as follows:
Page 10 of 15
“8.12 “Horizontal reservations cut across the vertical
reservations - what is called interlocking reservations.
To be more precise, suppose 3% of the vacancies are
reserved in favour of physically handicapped persons;
this would be a reservation relatable to clause (1) of
Article 16 (1). The persons selected against this quota
will be placed in the appropriate category; if he
belongs to SC category he will be placed in that quota
by making necessary adjustments; similarly, if he
belongs to open competition (OC) category, he will be
placed in that category by making necessary
adjustments. Even after providing for these horizontal
reservations, the percentage of reservations in favour
of backward class of citizens remains - and should
remain - the same. This is how these reservations are
worked out in several States and there is no reason
not to continue that procedure."
58. This rule was affirmed and applied in Anil Kumar Gupta v
State of UP1, Swati Gupta v State of UP and Jitendra Kumar
Singh v State of UP and Rajesh Kumar Daria v Rajasthan
Public Service Commission. The manner of filling the
horizontal reservation category and the vertical, social
categories, was explained in Rajesh Kumar Daria (supra) in
the following terms:
“Social reservations in favour of SC, ST and OBC
under Article 16 (4) are 'vertical reservations'. Special
reservations in favour of physically handicapped,
women etc., under Articles 16(1) or 15(3) Indira
Sawhney v Union of India 1992 Supp (3) SCC 766, @
para 812 (SCC Reports)] 1995 (5) SCC 173 1995 (2)
SCC 560 2010 (3) SCC 119 2007 (8) SCC 785 are
'horizontal reservations'. Where a vertical reservation is
made in favour of a backward class under Article 16
(4), the candidates belonging to such backward class,
may compete for non-reserved posts and if they are
appointed to the non-reserved posts on their own merit,
their numbers will not be counted against the quota
reserved for the respective backward class. Therefore,
if the number of SC candidates, who by their own merit,
get selected to open competition vacancies, equals or
even exceeds the percentage of posts reserved for SC
candidates, it cannot be said the reservation quota for
SCs has been filled. The entire reservation quota will
be intact and available in addition to those selected
under Open Competition category. [Vide Indira
Sawhney, R. K. Sabharwal vs. State of Punjab, Union
of India v Virpal Singh Chauvan and Ritesh R. Shah v
Page 11 of 15
Dr. Y.L Yamul. But the aforesaid principle applicable to
vertical (social) reservations will not apply to horizontal
(special) reservations. Where a special reservation for
women is provided within the social reservation for
Scheduled Castes, the proper procedure is first to fill
up the quota for scheduled castes in order of merit and
then find out the number of candidates among them
who belong to the special reservation group of
'Scheduled Castes-Women'. If the number of women in
such list is equal to or more than the number of special
reservation quota, then there is no need for further
selection towards the special reservation quota. Only if
there is any shortfall, the requisite number of scheduled
caste women shall have to be taken by deleting the
corresponding number of candidates from the bottom
of the list relating to Scheduled Castes. To this extent,
horizontal (special) reservation differs from vertical
(social) reservation. Thus women selected on merit
within the vertical reservation quota will be counted
against the horizontal reservation for women.”
59. The features of vertical reservations are:
59.1 They cannot be filled by the open category, or
categories of candidates other than those specified and
have to be filled by candidates of the concerned social
category only (SC/ST/OBC);
59.2 Mobility (‘migration’) from the reserved (specified
category) to the unreserved (open category) slot is
possible, based on meritorious performance;
59.3 In case of migration from reserved to open
category, the vacancy in the reserved category should
be filled by another person from the same specified
category, lower in rank,
59.4 If the vacancies cannot be filled by the specified
categories due to shortfall of candidates, the vacancies
are to be ‘carried forward’ or dealt with appropriately by
rules.
60. Horizontal reservations on the other hand, by their
nature, are not inviolate pools or carved in stone. They
are premised on their overlaps and are ‘interlocking’
reservations 21. As a sequel, they are to be calculated
concurrently and along with the inviolate ‘vertical’ (or
“social”) reservation quotas, by application of the
various steps laid out with clarity in paragraph 11 of
Page 12 of 15
Justice Lalit’s judgement. They cannot be carried
forward. The first rule that applies to filling horizontal
reservation quotas is one of adjustment, i.e. examining
whether on merit any of the horizontal categories are
adjusted in the merit list in the open category, and then,
in the quota for such horizontal category within the
particular specified/social reservation.”
16. Since there is no prohibition in the rule, or direction which prohibits
the adjustment of socially reserved categories of women in the
general category or “open category”, the migration of merit OBC
candidate to General candidate is legal and justified. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in case of Sadhana Singh Dangi & Others vs.
Pinki Asati & Others reported in 2022 (12) SCC 401 has examined
the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Special Provisions for
Appointment of Women) Rules, 1997 and has held that while
applying horizontal reservation, merit must be precedent and
meritorious reserved category candidate securing higher marks must
be considered against open category and held as under:
“22. It is true that the leading judgment in Saurav Yadav
(supra) considered the matter from a general plane but
the concurring judgment authored by S. Ravindra Bhat, J.
did additionally consider the issue from the perspective of
absence of any statutory Rules in the field. It is also true
that in the instant case, there are Rules occupying the
field and the case would be a fortiori, but we need not
enter into that arena as, in our view, the general
propositions laid down in Saurav Yadav (supra) by
themselves are sufficient to take care of the controversy
which has arisen in the instant matters.
23. The law laid down in Saurav Yadav is very clear that
even while applying horizontal reservation, the merit must
be given precedence and that if the candidates who
belong to SCs, STs and OBCs have secured higher
marks or are more meritorious, they must be considered
against the seats meant for unreserved candidates.”
17. Again the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Chhaya and Others
vs. State of Maharashtra and Another reported in 2026 INSC 277
Page 13 of 15
has allowed migration of category to open/unreserved category on
merits even if there is reservation in qualifying examination as the
relaxation in qualifying examination affects eligibility and does not
prevent reserved category migration to open category on merit
unless recruitment rules expressly prohibited such migration. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:
“32. The appellants who admittedly are more meritorious
than the last selected candidate under the general
category, cannot be excluded from consideration under
the general category, in the absence of any express
prohibition in the Recruitment Rules/notification. The
relaxation in qualifying criteria only affects eligibility and
not merit and migration is permissible in the absence of
any prohibition. The decisions of this Court in Pradeep
Kumar (supra), Union of India & Ors. v. Sajib Roy
(supra) and Union of India v. G. Kiran & Ors. (supra)
have no application to the obtaining factual matrix of
these appeals, whereas, decisions of this Court in
Jitendra Kumar Singh (supra) and Vikas Sankhala
(supra) apply to the facts of these appeals. The
appellants are entitled to migrate to general category.
CONCLUSION
33. For the foregoing reasons, impugned judgment dated
14.02.2025, is quashed and set aside. The respondents
shall include in the merit list, those appellants who have
secured marks higher than the last selected candidate in
the general category.”
18. Again the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Airport Authority of
India & Ors. vs. Sham Krishna B & Ors. reported in 2026 LiveLaw
(SC) 83 has held as under:
"32. The issue in respect of migration of reserved
category candidates who has not availed any concession
or relaxation has been considered in detailed by this
Court in Rajasthan High Court & Anr. v. Rajat Yadav &
Ors. in Civil Appeal No. 14112 of 2024 decided on
19.12.2025, wherein this Court after taking into account
all the judgments on the subject has held that a candidate
belonging to reserve category who has scored higher
marks than the cut off marks for the General Category
candidates has to be treated as having qualified against
an open unreserved vacant post.
Page 14 of 15
33. In the considered opinion of this Court, the
controversy involved in the present case is no longer res
integra. It is now a settled proposition of law that a
candidate belonging to reserve category who has scored
marks higher than the cut off marks for the General
Category is to be treated as having qualified against an
open or unreserved vacant post. In the present case, no
concession or relaxation was extended to the reserve
category candidates who have been appointed on their
own merit against the posts meant for the General
Category candidates as they have scored more marks
than the General Category candidates in the selection
process. The facts of the case further makes it clear that
all the vacancies notified for unreserved category i.e. 122
posts were filled up based upon the marks scored by
candidates in the process of selection on their own merit
and, therefore, the Appellant Authority were justified in
migrating the candidates belonging to reserve category to
the unreserved list on the basis of their own merit as they
have scored higher marks than the General category
candidates.
34. This Court is of the considered opinion that the
judgment delivered by the learned Single Judge as well
as the Division Bench of the Kerala High Court deserves
to be set aside and are accordingly set aside and the
question of directing appointment of Respondent No. 1
i.e. Sham Krishna B. or any other person belonging to
unreserved category does not arise as all vacancies
notified under the unreserved category have been filled
strictly in accordance with the merit list prepared by the
Appellant Authority.”
19. Further submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that as
per the Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission Rules for
Procedure, 2014, the female reservation will be governed by the
Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Special Provision for Appointment of
Women) Rules, 1997 and due to horizontal and compartment-wise
reservation for female candidates all female categories of any
category shall be included in the process of shortlist after being
considered as a part of relevant category and there will be no
separate female category of sub-category, as such the OBC
candidates cannot be migrated to General category, is misconceived
Page 15 of 15
and deserves to be rejected as the reservation to the women is
governed by the Rules of 1997 which does not prohibit migration.
Accordingly, the submission is rejected.
20. Considering the Rules of 1997, which does not prohibit migration of
the reserved category to open category, also considering the law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and also considering the fact
that the respondents No. 4 to 8 have secured more marks than the
petitioner, the respondents No. 1 to 3 have not committed any
illegality in including them in the list of selected candidates and
subsequent appointment, as such the writ petition is liable to be
dismissed and accordingly, it is dismissed.
Sd/-
(Narendra Kumar Vyas)
Judge
Bhumika