Employees State Insurance Corporation vs Sri Lakshmi Srinivasa Jute Mills Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
- Court
- National Company Law Appellate Tribunal
NATIONAL COMPANY LAW APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
25.09.2026
Present: JUSTICE N. SESHASAYEE, MEMBER (JUDICIAL)
JATINDRANATH SWAIN, MEMBER (TECHNICAL)
Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (Ins) No.410/2022
(IA Nos.1005 & 1060/2022)
In the matter of:
Employees State Insurance Corporation,
Sub-Regional Office,
R.R. House, Door No.45-57-21/1,
Beside SBI Saligramapuram Branch,
Main Road, Akkayyapalem,
Vishakhapatnam, 530024,
Rep. by N.S. Sujeendranath, SSO,
ESIC, Chennai. … Appellant
Vs
M/s. Sri Lakshmi Srinivasa Jute Mills Private Limited,
Registered Office at Bobbili Road,
Rajam, Srikakulam District - 532 124. ... Respondent No.1
Shri. Maligi Madhusudhana Reddy,
Resolution Professional of
M/s. Sri Lakshmi Srinivasa Jute Mills Private Limited,
Registered Office at MMR Lion Corp.,
th
4 Floor, HSR Eden, Road No.2, Banjara Hills,
Hyderabad - 500 034. ... Respondent No.2
M/s. Agrigo Trading Private Limited,
Old No.23/2, New No.20,
Mylai Ranganathan Street,
T Nagar, Chennai-600 017. ... Respondent No.3
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 1 of 16
Present :
For Appellant : Mr. SP. Srinivasan, Advocate
For Respondents : Mr. Avinash Krishnan Ravi, Advocate for R1 & R3
Mr. NP. Vijaykumar, Advocate for R2
JUDGMENT
(Hybrid Mode)
[Per: Jatindranath Swain, Member (Technical)]
1. The instant appeal has been preferred by the Appellant, ESI Corporation
Ltd., against the approval of the resolution plan by the Ld. NCLT passed in IA
No. 183 of 2022 in CP(IB) No.73/9/AMR/2020 vide the impugned order dated
in dated 01.09.2022.
Brief Facts:
2. The Corporate Debtor M/s. Sri Lakshmi Srinivasa Jute Mills Private
Limited has 4 units under the ESI Act. Prior to commencement of the CIRP,
the Corporate Debtor had incurred substantial statutory liabilities towards
contributions payable under the Employees’ State Insurance Act, 1948 (“ESI
Act”) for the period 2012 -2018. On the basis of the monthly contribution
returns and statutory assessment notices, a cumulative amount of
Rs.13,38,30,616/- was due and payable to the Employees’ State Insurance
Corporation (“ESIC”) herein the appellant by the corporate debtor.
3. On 16.03.2022, the Corporate Debtor M/s. Sri Lakshmi Srinivasa Jute
Mills Private Limited was admitted into CIRP by Ld. NCLT, Amaravati in CP(IB)
st
No.73/9/AMR/2020, and Shri Maligi Madhusudhana Reddy, herein the 1
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 2 of 16
respondent, was appointed as the Interim Resolution Professional (“IRP”). The
IRP made a public announcement on 17.03.2022, inviting claims from the
creditors of the Corporate Debtor.
4. In response thereto, on 07.04.2022, the Appellant submitted its claim
in Form-B before the IRP, claiming Rs.13,38,30,616/- as an Operational
Creditor towards the statutory ESI contributions due from the Corporate
st
Debtor. The 1 meeting of the CoC held on 18.04.2022 wherein the
appointment of the IRP as the Resolution Professional (“RP”) was approved
with 100% voting share.
nd
5. The 2 CoC meeting was scheduled on 17.05.2022 and an email was
sent on 14.05.2022 (Saturday) to the claimants. The Appellant was unable to
attend the said meeting due to the absence of concerned official and,
consequently, by an email dated 19.05.2022 the appellant requested the RP
to keep the appellant informed of all future meetings and proceedings of the
CoC.
6. Meanwhile, on 24.05.2022, the RP issued a public announcement in
Form-G, inviting Expressions of Interest from prospective resolution
applicants. Pursuant thereto, nine prospective resolution applicants
submitted their responses, and on 18.06.2022, the RP issued the final list of
eligible prospective resolution applicants, which included M/s. Agrigo Trading
rd
Private Limited, the 3 Respondent herein.
7. During the CIRP, the Appellant Corporation initiated steps for recovery
of its statutory dues and the Recovery Officer of ESIC issued attachment
notices dated 29.06.2022 in respect of the properties of the Corporate Debtor.
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 3 of 16
The RP, however, by communication dated 30.06.2022, brought to the notice
of the Appellant that the moratorium under Section 14 of the IBC was
declared against the corporate debtor and so the Appellant withdrew the
attachment notices.
8. Subsequently, M/s. Agrigo Trading Private Limited submitted its
Resolution Plan on 22.07.2022. The said Resolution Plan was thereafter
th
placed before the CoC, and in the 4 meeting of the CoC held on 30.07.2022,
the plan was approved through e-voting with 100% voting share. The
Resolution Plan was thereafter placed before the Adjudicating Authority for
approval.
9. By order dated 01.09.2022, passed in IA No. 183 of 2022 in CP(IB)
No.73/9/AMR/2020, the Ld. NCLT, Amaravati Bench approved the
Resolution Plan submitted by M/s. Agrigo Trading Private Limited, involving
a total sum of Rs. 21,51,65,246/-.
10. Pursuant to approval of the Resolution Plan, the RP, by an email dated
13.09.2022, informed the Appellant that its admitted claim of
Rs.13,38,30,616/- had been treated under the Resolution Plan as
Government Dues/Operational Creditor dues, against which only 1%,
amounting to Rs. 13,38,306/-, had been allowed under the plan.
11. Aggrieved by the treatment of its statutory claim and the admission of
only 1% of its admitted dues under the approved Resolution Plan, the
Appellant preferred the present appeal.
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 4 of 16
Submissions of the Appellant:
12. The learned Counsel appearing for the Appellant submits that ESIC had
submitted claim of Rs.13,38,30,616/- towards statutory contributions
payable under the Employees’ State Insurance Act, 1948 (“ESI Act”). However,
the Resolution Professional communicated that only 1% of the admitted claim,
amounting to Rs.13,38,306/-, would be paid under the Resolution Plan by
treating the claim as ordinary Government dues/dues of an Operational
Creditor.
13. Learned Counsel submits that the ESI contributions are statutory
contributions intended for the benefit of employees/workmen and are
required to be deposited into the Employees’ State Insurance Fund in terms
of the ESI Act and the Appellant Corporation does not acquire any beneficial
ownership therein. It is therefore contended that such amounts cannot be
treated in the same manner as an ordinary operational debt.
14. Learned Counsel accordingly submits that unpaid ESI contributions
constitute amounts held by the Corporate Debtor in the nature of third-party
funds/trust monies and, therefore, do not form part of the assets of the
Corporate Debtor available for distribution. Under Section 36(4)(a)(i) of the
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“IBC”) assets owned by a third party
but in possession of the Corporate Debtor, including assets held in trust for
the benefit of third parties are excluded from the liquidation estate.
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 5 of 16
15. On this basis, it is contended that the statutory ESI contributions are
required to be excluded from the liquidation estate and cannot be subjected
to the distribution mechanism contemplated under Section 53 of the IBC.
16. Learned Counsel further submits that the fact that ESIC submitted its
claim in Form-B, being the prescribed form for filing a claim as an Operational
Creditor, cannot alter the substantive character of the statutory dues. It is
contended that the filing of a claim in the prescribed form is a procedural
compliance and it cannot override the substantive rights available to ESIC
under the ESI Act and the IBC.
17. It is further contended that Section 94 of the ESI Act confers statutory
priority upon ESI contributions. According to the Appellant, such statutory
protection demonstrates that ESI contributions cannot be treated as ordinary
Government dues for the purposes of distribution under the Resolution Plan.
18. In the alternative, learned Counsel submits that, even if the ESI dues
are not to be excluded from the liquidation estate under Section 36(4)(a)(i) of
the IBC, they ought to be treated as workmen’s dues under Section 53(1)(a)
and/or Section 53(1)(b) of the IBC, having regard to the purpose for which the
contributions are collected and the beneficiaries for whom the said statutory
fund is maintained.
19. The Appellant also raises a grievance with regard to the conduct of the
CIRP proceedings. It is submitted that ESIC had specifically requested the
Resolution Professional, after 17.05.2022, to keep it informed regarding the
meetings of the Committee of Creditors and the further proceedings in relation
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 6 of 16
to the Resolution Plan. According to the Appellant, despite the said request,
ESIC was not kept informed of the subsequent CoC meetings and the
consideration and approval of the Resolution Plan.
20. Learned Counsel submits that the aforesaid circumstances assume
significance because the Resolution Plan ultimately provided for payment of
only 1% of ESIC’s admitted statutory dues, and ESIC was allegedly not
afforded an effective opportunity to place its objections before the CoC at the
relevant stage.
21. In support of the aforesaid submissions, learned Counsel for the
Appellant places reliance upon various decisions dealing with statutory
employee-benefit contributions and their treatment under the IBC. Reliance
is first placed upon Nurani Subramanian Suryanarayanan, Liquidator of
M/s. Care IT Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. Employees State Insurance
Corporation , wherein the Appellant submits that this Tribunal considered
the treatment of statutory contributions under the ESI Act and held that such
amounts fall within the exclusion contemplated under Section 36(4)(a)(i) of
the IBC, being amounts held for the benefit of third parties.
22. The appellant also placed reliance on the following cases:
• Para 45 of Tourism Finance Corporation of India Pvt. Ltd. V. Rainbow
Papers Ltd. & Ors., [CA(AT)(Ins) No.354, 364, 404 & 1001/2019
NCLAT Delhi] / State Tax Officer V. Rainbow Papers Ltd. [2022 SCC
Online SC 1162]
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 7 of 16
• Para 71,72 & 76 of Jet Aircraft Maintenance Engineers Welfare
Association V. Ashish Chhawchharia, Resolution Professional of Jet
Airways (India) Ltd. & Ors. ,
• Para 23 and 24 of State Bank of India V. Moser Baer Karamchari
Union & Anr. [2019 SCC Online NCLAT 447]
• [2020 SCC online
Para 17 of Savan Godiwala V. Apalla Siva Kumar
NCLAT 191]
• Para 19 of Sunil Kumar Jain & Ors. V. Sundaresh Bhatt & Anr. ,
reported in (2022) 7 SCC 540
In all these judgements, dues in the nature of employee contributions
and meant for employee welfare have been accorded priority and given the
status of third-party asset as per Section 36(4)(a)(i) of the IBC.
23. Based on the above submission the appellant seeks the following relief:
‘a) To set aside the Impugned Order passed passed in IA(IBC)
183/2022 in CP(13) No. 73/9/AMR/2020 dated 01.09.2022,
by National Company Law Tribunal, Amaravati Bench at
Mangalagiri allowing IA by approving the Resolution Plan
annexed to the application preferred by Resolution
Professional in favour of the Successful Resolution Applicant,
b) To direct the 2nd Respondent Resolution Professional to
consider the claims of the Appellants not under Operational
Creditors (Government dues) instead to consider under
36(4)(a)(i) Of IBC, 2016 or in the alternative under
Operational Creditors (workmen dues and Employees). c) To
hold that the appellants dues under Section 36(4)(a)(i) of
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 8 of 16
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 or in the alternative
under Operational Creditors (workmen dues and Employees).
d) To direct the RP/2nd Respondent to re-determine and
reassess the dues of various creditors, after priority being
given to appellant under Section Of IBC, 2016 or in the
alternative treating ESIC dues as workmen dues and settle
the dues of Appellant on priority basis.
e) Pass such further or other orders as may be deemed fit and
proper in the interests of justice.’
Submissions of the Respondent:
st
24. The learned Counsel appearing for the 1 Respondent/Corporate
rd
Debtor and the 3 Respondent/Successful Resolution Applicant submits
that:
25. Since the Appellant submitted its claim in Form B, the Appellant has
rightly been treated as an unsecured Operational Creditor under the
provisions of the IBC. If the Appellant wanted to claim a status other than
that of an Operational Creditor, it was incumbent upon the Appellant to
submit its claim in Form F, applicable to “Other Creditors”. Having elected to
submit its claim in Form B, the Appellant cannot subsequently seek to alter
the nature or classification of its claim and contend that it ought to be treated
otherwise.
26. According to the Respondents, the specific exclusion contemplated
under Section 36(4)(a)(iii) relates to provident fund, pension fund and gratuity
fund. It is contended that ESI contributions are distinct in nature and
constitute insurance contributions under the Employees’ State Insurance Act,
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 9 of 16
1948 (“ESI Act”), and cannot be equated with provident fund, pension or
gratuity funds specifically referred to in the said provision. According, to the
Respondents, ESIC’s claim constitutes a statutory monetary claim against the
Corporate Debtor and forms part of the liabilities to be dealt with under the
insolvency process.
27. The Respondents contend that, ESIC did not, at the relevant stage,
assert that the amounts claimed were third-party assets falling outside the
liquidation estate, and that if ESIC intended to contend that the amounts
were assets held in trust for a third party and therefore outside the
distribution matrix, it ought to have asserted such a position before the
Resolution Professional at the appropriate stage.
28. The Respondents further submit that the ESI Act does not create any
statutory first charge over the properties of the Corporate Debtor in favour of
ESIC. It is further submitted that, in any event, the provisions of the IBC, by
virtue of Section 238, have overriding effect over provisions of other Acts.
29. Ld. Counsel for the Respondent submits that the Resolution Plan has
nevertheless dealt with the claim of ESIC in accordance with the statutory
framework. It is contended that the amount proposed to be paid to ESIC under
the Resolution Plan is higher than the amount that would have been payable
to it in the event of liquidation. Thus, according to the Respondents, the
requirements of Section 30(2)(b) read with Section 53(1)(e) of the IBC have
been duly complied with.
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 10 of 16
30. It is further submitted that an Operational Creditor does not have the
same rights of participation in the decision-making process of the CoC which
are available to Financial Creditors. Reliance is placed upon the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Swiss Ribbons Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Union of
India , reported in (2019) 4 SCC 17 , to contend that the differential treatment
between Financial Creditors and Operational Creditors under the IBC has
been recognised as constitutionally valid.
31. Reliance is placed upon Beacon Trusteeship Ltd. v. Jayesh
Sanghrajka & Ors. , to contend that the statutory framework does not
guarantee payment of the entire value of a creditor’s security or claim under
a Resolution Plan merely because such amount may have been claimed by
the creditor.
32. Further reliance placed on:
• State Tax Officer (1) V. Rainbow Papers Limited [Civil Appeal Nos.
1661 and 2568 of 2020]
• Paschimanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. V. Raman Ispat Private
Limited and Ors. [CA (AT) (Ins) No. 639 of 2018]
• Sanjay Kumar Agarwal and Ors. V. State Tax Officer (1) and Ors.
[Review Petition (Civil) No. 1620 of 2023 in Civil Appeal No. 1661
of 2020]
• Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes LGSTO V. Alok
Kailash Saksena and Ors. [CA (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 302/2023 and
IA No.968/2023]
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 11 of 16
• Commissioner of State Tax Department V. Ramchandra Dallaram
Chaudhary Liquidator of Anil Ltd . [CA (AT) (Ins) No.34 of 2024,
I.A. Nos. 105, 106 and 990 of 2024]
• Regional Director, ESIC V. George Samuel Liquidator of Shreem
Spa & Resorts Ltd. [IA/8(AHM)2022 in CP(IB) 550 of 2018 (NCLT
Ahmedabad)]
• Mr. Vinod Agrawal Resolution Professional of M/s. Mayfair
Leisures Limited [IA/542(AHM)/2022 in CP (IB) 213 of 2018
(NCLT Ahmedabad)]
• Ashwini Fal Dessai and Ors. V. Anneel Saraogi and Ors .
[Cont.A/01(MB)/2022 in C.P.(IB)-2119(MB)/2019 (NCLT
Mumbai)]
• Bangalore Turf Club Ltd. and Ors. V. Regional Director, Employees
State Insurance Corporation and Ors. [Civil Appeal Nos. 2416 of
2003]
33. It is further submitted that the Resolution Plan has already been
approved and has proceeded towards implementation. According to the
Respondents, the first tranche of amounts contemplated under the Resolution
th th
Plan has already been disbursed to the creditors on 25 and 26 October
2022. The Respondents therefore contend that substantial equities have
arisen in favour of the Successful Resolution Applicant and other
stakeholders and that the approved Resolution Plan ought not to be reopened
at this stage on the basis of a claim which ESIC had itself submitted and
pursued as an Operational Creditor.
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 12 of 16
Findings:
34. We have considered the submissions advanced by the learned Counsel
for the parties and perused the material available on record. The principal
question which arises for consideration is whether the ESI contributions
payable by the Corporate Debtor, including the amounts deducted from the
wages of the employees and required to be remitted to the Employees’ State
Insurance Corporation, can be treated merely as an ordinary operational debt
forming part of the liquidation estate, or whether such amounts are required
to be excluded from the liquidation estate by virtue of Section 36(4)(a)(i) of the
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
35. The issue is no longer res integra. The controversy stands squarely
covered by the decision of this Appellate Tribunal in Nurani Subramanian
Suryanarayanan, Liquidator of M/s. Care IT Solutions Pvt. Ltd. V.
Employees State Insurance Corporation & Ors. , TA (AT) No. 212/2021,
CA (AT) (Ins) No. 116/2020 , decided on 18.07.2024. In the said decision,
this Tribunal considered the interplay between Section 40(4) of the Employees’
State Insurance Act, 1948 and Section 36(4)(a)(i) of the I&B Code and held
that the ESI amounts contributed by the employer as well as the employee,
lying with the Corporate Debtor, are held in trust and consequently fall within
the exclusion contained in Section 36(4)(a)(i) of the I&B Code. The amounts
so held cannot, therefore, form part of the liquidation estate available for
distribution under Section 53 of the Code.
36. The aforesaid principle has subsequently been reaffirmed by principal
bench of this Appellate Tribunal in its judgement dated 24.09.2005 in
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 13 of 16
Regional Director, ESI Corporation v. Manish Kumar Bhagat,
Liquidator, Gupta Dyeing & Printing Mills Pvt. Ltd. , Comp. App. (AT) (Ins)
No. 301 of 2024 . In that case also, the ESI Corporation’s claim had been
admitted by the Liquidator as an operational creditor. The Respondents
therein raised substantially the same objection that the claim had been dealt
with under the I&B Code and that ESI dues did not enjoy any special status.
The Tribunal, however, held that the controversy was squarely covered by
Nurani Subramanian (supra) and allowed the appeal, setting aside the
impugned order.
37. In the present case, the Appellant’s claim relates to statutory ESI
contributions payable under the ESI Act. The mere fact that the Appellant
submitted its claim in Form B and that the claim was consequently described
as an Operational Creditor claim cannot alter the substantive character of the
amount in question. The form prescribed for submission of a claim is
procedural in nature and cannot have the effect of converting an amount
which is statutorily required to be held for the benefit of the employees into
an asset beneficially belonging to the Corporate Debtor.
38. Consequently, the contention of the Respondents that, having
submitted the claim in Form B, the Appellant is estopped from asserting the
benefit of Section 36(4)(a)(i) cannot be accepted.
39. The contention that Section 36(4)(a)(iii) specifically mentions provident
fund, pension fund and gratuity fund and does not expressly mention ESI
contributions also does not advance the case of the Respondents. The
Appellant’s claim under consideration is not being excluded merely by analogy
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 14 of 16
with provident fund, pension fund or gratuity fund. The exclusion flows from
the independent operation of Section 36(4)(a)(i), when the statutory character
of the ESI contribution is examined in the light of Section 40(4) of the ESI Act,
1948, as explained in Nurani Subramanian and reaffirmed in Regional
Director, ESI Corporation v. Manish Kumar Bhagat .
40. We are, therefore, unable to accept the Respondents’ submission that
the Appellant’s claim was liable to be dealt with as an ordinary unsecured
operational debt merely because it was filed in Form B. The ESI contributions,
being amounts held by the Corporate Debtor in trust for the beneficiaries
contemplated under the ESI Act, will not constitute part of the assets of the
Corporate Debtor and hence cannot be subjected to distribution under the
waterfall mechanism contained in Section 53 of the I&B Code.
41. The same principle necessarily governs the treatment of such dues in
the present proceedings. The Resolution Plan could not have treated the
amounts dues to ESIC, which stood outside the estate of the Corporate
Debtor, as an ordinary Government/Operational Creditor claim, so as to
provide for payment of only a fraction thereof under the plan on the footing
that the entire claim will have to be paid in accordance with the waterfall
mechanism under Section 53 of the IBC.
42. In the present case, the question is as to how to treat the claim of ESIC
under the Resolution Plan. Once the ESI contributions are held to be amounts
entrusted for the statutory purpose contemplated under the ESI Act and
consequently excluded under Section 36(4)(a)(i), they cannot be treated as an
ordinary operational debt merely because the claim has been filed in Form B.
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 15 of 16
Therefore, the treatment of the said amount in the approved Resolution Plan
requires reconsideration.
43. For the foregoing reasons, the appeal deserves to be allowed. The
Impugned Order dated 01.09.2022 passed by the National Company Law
Tribunal, Amaravati Bench in IA No. 183 of 2022 in CP(IB) No.
73/9/AMR/2020, insofar as it approves the Resolution Plan treating the
Appellant’s ESI contributions as ordinary Government/Operational Creditor
dues and provides for payment of only 1% thereof, is set aside to that extent.
44. The Resolution Professional/Successful Resolution Applicant shall give
effect to the present order in respect of the ESI contributions which fall within
the scope of Section 40(4) of the ESI Act, 1948 read with Section 36(4)(a)(i) of
the I&B Code. The exact amount, if any, qualifying for such exclusion shall
be determined on the basis of the statutory records and the contribution
period in accordance with law.
45. The appeal is accordingly allowed in the aforesaid terms. Pending
Interlocutory Applications, if any, stand disposed of.
[Justice N. Seshasayee]
Member (Judicial)
[Jatindranath Swain]
Member (Technical)
AR/MS/AK
Comp App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 410/2022 Page 16 of 16