Ku. Senehi Rathore vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

1
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
A T G W A L I O R

BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE G. S. AHLUWALIA
&
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE ANURADHA SHUKLA

th
ON THE 19 OF NOVEMBER, 2026

WRIT PETITION No. 46584 of 2026

CNR No.: MPHC030313712026

KU. SENEHI RATHORE
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS


Appearance:
Shri M.P.S.Raghuvanshi, Senior Advocate with Shri Mohd. Amir
Khan, Advocate for appellant.
Shri G.K.Agarwal, Govt. Advocate for State.
Shri Dinesh Singh Tomar, Advocate for respondent No.3.

ORDER

Per : Justice Gurpal Singh Ahluwalia
This petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, has
been filed seeking the following reliefs:-
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

2
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

“(i) That, the impugned action on the part of respondents be
held to be illegal and unjustified.
(ii) That, the respondent No.2 and 3 be directed to adjust Rs.2
Lakhs registration fee deposited by the petitioner at the time of
appearing in Mop-up round, as against the admission fee and
accordingly the respondents may be directed to complete
admission process and to permit the petitioner to prosecute
studies of BDS first year course in the respondent No.3 college
after completing all the formalities, which are required under
the law to be completed for granting admission in the said
course.
(iii) That, other relief which is just and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the case may also be granted.”
2. It is submitted by counsel for petitioner that she had qualified
NEET Examination 2026. She had applied as a general category candidate
and secured All India Rank 584036. After the result of NEET
Examination 2026 was declared, the State of MP through DME got
conducted general counseling for the purposes of granting admission in
respondent No. 3 and other dental colleges. The first and second
counseling were conducted and ultimately in mop-up round, petitioner
was held eligible to appear in online counseling. She was required to
deposit Rs.2,00,000/- for her appearance in mop-up round. Petitioner
deposited the same. Thereafter, petitioner was offered a seat for BDS first
year course in respondent No. 3/College. Petitioner accepted the same and
consequently, allotment letter (Provisional) (Mop-Up round:open) was
issued to the petitioner and thereafter on 12/10/2026, petitioner went to
respondent No. 3/College along with all her original educational
certificates and documents. The college verified the same and online
updated the same. Petitioner was also directed by the representative of
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

3
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

respondent No. 3/College to deposit the remaining fee of Rs.35,000/- as a
general category candidate, which was also done by the petitioner on
12/10/2026. Petitioner had also deposited the hostel fee as she was in need
of hostel. Once petitioner's documents were verified and uploaded on the
portal, the registration fee of Rs. 2,00,000/- was deposited by the
petitioner at the time of participation in mop-up round, and the remaining
deficit fee of Rs. 35,000/- was deposited on 12/10/2026, then nothing
more was required to be done by the petitioner. Thereafter, it was the duty
of respondent No. 3/College to show that complete requisite fee has been
deposited and the said seat should have been shown to be occupied by the
petitioner on the portal. However, on account of lapses on the part of
respondent No. 3, the seat allotted to petitioner was shown to be vacant on
the portal. This occurred because the registration fee was not adjusted
against admission fee due to fault on the part of respondent Nos. 2 and 3,
and the portal handled and supervised by respondent No. 2 was still
showing the seat of BDS to be vacant. By showing the seat vacant,
petitioner has been deprived of her right to get admission and prosecute
her higher studies in BDS course.
3. Respondent No. 3 filed its return. The verification of original
documents and the deposit of the requisite deficit fee on 12/10/2026 was
accepted by the college. However, it was mentioned that, "…due to the
aforesaid technical fault, the fee receipt could not be generated, and
consequently, the petitioner was denied admission and deprived of her
valuable opportunity to pursue her studies in the BDS course." It is
further submitted that respondent No. 3, vide its letter dated 27/10/2026,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

4
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

had already apprised the Director, Medical Education Department, of the
circumstances resulting in the denial of admission to petitioner,
particularly the non-generation of fee receipt/admission slip during the
mop-up round, despite petitioner having completed the requisite
admission formalities. It was submitted that aforesaid communication was
made much prior to filing of instant petition, which clearly demonstrates
the bonafide conduct and genuine concern of respondent No. 3 towards
petitioner's academic interest. Thus, it is clear that according to
respondent No. 3, petitioner had completed all her responsibilities on
12/10/2026, and the fee receipt could not be generated on account of
technical glitch in the online payment system.
4. Respondents No. 1 and 2 had initially filed a short reply and
claimed that if any mistake is committed by any college Authority, then as
per schedule which was issued after mop-up round, the college
Authorities were bound to inform any mistake which was committed at
any time on or before stray vacancy round concluded on 25/10/2026.
Respondent No. 3 did not communicate its mistake in respect of non-
issuance of admission slip in favor of petitioner on or before 25/10/2026.
Therefore, one seat was showing vacant in MP-DME online counseling
portal. Now, the seat has been allotted to another candidate, and another
candidate has also taken admission on 16/11/2026 along with an affidavit
in respect of giving her undertaking. In the aforesaid affidavit, the newly
selected candidate has submitted on oath that her admission is subject to
the outcome of decision by Hon'ble High Court in WP No. 46584/2026;
Ku. Senehi Rathore Vs. State of MP and others , i.e., the present petition. It
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

5
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

is further mentioned that before granting admission to the subsequent
successful candidate i.e. Ms. Aastha Dulani, private respondent No. 3
forwarded mail to respondent No. 2 on 13/11/2026 for providing
clarification in respect of granting admission on vacant seat. After
receiving the mail, respondent No. 2 forwarded their reply through mail
dated 13/11/2026 to respondent No. 3/college and advised to take an
affidavit from subsequently successful candidate i.e. Ms. Aastha Dulani. It
is submitted that on account of non-issuance of admission slip, a vacant
seat was showing on portal, and therefore, respondents No. 1 and 2 have
allotted respondent No. 3/college to subsequently successful candidate,
namely Ms. Aastha Dulani.
5. Thereafter, additional return has been filed by respondent Nos. 1
and 2 vide document No. 19449/2026. It is mentioned that petitioner
appeared in third mop-up round of counseling. As per schedule of third
mop-up round of counseling, the date of reporting at allotted medical/
dental college in person for documents verification and admission was
from 11/10/2026 to 14/10/2026, which was extended up to 16/10/2026.
Although in the present case, due to non-issuance of admission slip as per
Clause 10(5) of Act of 2007 by private respondent No. 3, the seat was
showing vacant on the portal. After the conclusion of admission process
in third mop-up round of counseling on 16/10/2026, total three seats were
showing vacant, including this seat. Therefore, this seat was carried
forward by respondent No. 2 for fourth stray vacancy round counseling.
The fourth stray vacancy round counseling was conducted on 25/10/2026.
The fifth special stray vacancy round counseling was conducted as per
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

6
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

schedule, and last date of admission was 16/11/2026 and in this special
stray vacancy round counseling, the vacant seat of private respondent No.
3 college has been filled. Now, no seat is available. It was submitted that
the glitch, if any, has been committed by respondent No. 3 in respect of
non-issuance of admission slip in favor of petitioner. Furthermore,
respondent No. 3 should have informed respondent No. 2 on or before
16/10/2026 i.e. last date of admission, but that was not done, and they
forwarded mail for the first time on 27/10/2026 and by that time, the
process of last fourth stray vacancy round counseling was already
completed. Therefore, it is clear that there is no mistake on the part of
respondent No. 2.
6. Heard, learned counsel for the parties.
7. It is clear from the additional return filed vide document No.
19449/2026, that respondent No. 2 has filled up the vacant seat after fifth
special stray vacancy round and admittedly, the department/respondent
No. 2 had already received information about the glitch much prior to
holding of fifth special stray vacancy round. According to the petitioner,
the last date for admission is 28/11/2026. Thus, it is clear that the
admission process has not come to an end, and only the various
interlocutory stages of different rounds of counseling have come to an
end. One thing is clear that there was no error on the part of petitioner,
and she completed all her responsibilities on 12/10/2026.
8. The Supreme Court in the case of S. Krishna Sradha v. State of
A.P., reported in (2020) 17 SCC 465 has held as under:
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

7
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

12. However, the question is with respect to a student, a
meritorious candidate for no fault of his/her has been denied
admission illegally and who has pursued his/her legal rights
expeditiously without delay is entitled to any relief of
admission more particularly in the courses like MBBS the relief
of compensation as held by this Court in Asha [ Asha v. Pt. B.D.
Sharma University of Health Sciences , (2012) 7 SCC 389 : 4
SCEC 611] ? The aforesaid question is required to be
considered only to the cases where ( i ) no fault is attributable to
the candidate; ( ii ) the candidate has pursued her rights and legal
remedies expeditiously and without delay; ( iii ) where there is
fault on the part of the authorities and apparent breach of rules
and regulations; and ( iv ) candidate is found to be more
meritorious than the last candidate who has been given
admission.
12.1. At the outset, it is required to be noted that the question is
with respect to a student/candidate seeking admission in the
medical course more particularly in MBBS course. For a
student/candidate seeking admission in professional courses
more particularly the medical course each year is very
important and precious. Similarly, getting admission in medical
course itself is very important in the life of a candidate/student
and even a dream of man. In light of the above, the question for
consideration is whether compensation for a meritorious
candidate, who has been denied the admission illegally and
arbitrarily having approached the court in time can be said to be
just and equitable relief?
12.2. The right to equal and fair treatment is a component of
Article 14 of the Constitution. As held by this Court in Asha
[ Asha v. Pt. B.D. Sharma University of Health Sciences , (2012)
7 SCC 389 : 4 SCEC 611] that a transparent and fair procedure
is the duty of every legal authority connected with admissions.
In such cases, denial of fair treatment to the candidate would
not only violate his/her right under Article 14 but would
seriously jeopardise his/her right under Articles 19 and 21 of
the Constitution of India. A natural corollary of declaring that
an administrative act more particularly the denial of admission
illegally and for no fault of a candidate/student violates
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

8
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

principles of Article 14 is that the citizen injured must be put
back to his/her original position. In that sense, the primary
relief is restitutionary. As observed hereinabove, for a
meritorious student seeking admission in medical course is very
important in the life of student/candidate and denial of
admission to a meritorious candidate though for no fault of
his/her violates his/her fundamental rights. Compensation could
be an additional remedy but not a substitute for restitutionary
remedies. In case of medical admissions, even the restitutionary
remedy of providing a seat in the subsequent year would lead to
loss of one full academic year to a meritorious candidate, which
cannot be compensated in real terms. Thus compensation for
loss of year could be provided, but denial of admissions to a
meritorious candidate cannot be compensated in monetary
terms. Thus denial of admission in medical course to a
meritorious candidate for no fault of his/her and though he/she
has approached the Court in time and despite the same not
granting any just and equitable relief, would be denial of
justice. Therefore, the question is what relief the Court can
grant by which right to equal and fair treatment to a candidate is
protected and at the same time neither there is injustice to other
candidate/student and even compromising with the quality
education. Therefore, a balance is required to be struck.
However, at the same time it can safely be said that the view
taken by this Court in Jasmine Kaur [ State (UT of Chandigarh)
v. Jasmine Kaur , (2014) 10 SCC 521 : 6 SCEC 745] that the
only relief which can be granted to such a candidate would be
the compensation only is not good law and cannot be accepted.
Even granting a relief to such a candidate/student in the next
academic year and to accommodate him/her in the next year
and in the sanctioned intake may even affect the right of some
other candidate/student seeking admission in the next academic
year and that too for no fault of his/her. Therefore we are of the
view that in the exceptional and in the rarest of rare cases and in
case where all the conditions stipulated in para 33.3 in Jasmine
Kaur [ State (UT of Chandigarh) v. Jasmine Kaur , (2014) 10
SCC 521 : 6 SCEC 745] are satisfied, the Court can grant
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

9
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

exceptional relief to the candidate of granting admission even
after the cut-off date is over.
13. In light of the discussion/observations made hereinabove, a
meritorious candidate/student who has been denied an
admission in MBBS course illegally or irrationally by the
authorities for no fault of his/her and who has approached the
Court in time and so as to see that such a meritorious candidate
may not have to suffer for no fault of his/her, we answer the
reference as under:
13.1. That in a case where candidate/student has approached the
court at the earliest and without any delay and that the question
is with respect to the admission in medical course all the efforts
shall be made by the court concerned to dispose of the
proceedings by giving priority and at the earliest.
13.2. Under exceptional circumstances, if the court finds that
there is no fault attributable to the candidate and the candidate
has pursued his/her legal right expeditiously without any delay
and there is fault only on the part of the authorities and/or there
is apparent breach of rules and regulations as well as related
principles in the process of grant of admission which would
violate the right of equality and equal treatment to the
competing candidates and if the time schedule prescribed —
30th September, is over, to do the complete justice, the Court
under exceptional circumstances and in rarest of rare cases
direct the admission in the same year by directing to increase
the seats, however, it should not be more than one or two seats
and such admissions can be ordered within reasonable time i.e.
within one month from 30th September i.e. cut-off date and
under no circumstances, the Court shall order any admission in
the same year beyond 30th October. However, it is observed
that such relief can be granted only in exceptional
circumstances and in the rarest of rare cases. In case of such an
eventuality, the Court may also pass an order cancelling the
admission given to a candidate who is at the bottom of the merit
list of the category who, if the admission would have been
given to a more meritorious candidate who has been denied
admission illegally, would not have got the admission, if the
Court deems it fit and proper, however, after giving an
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

10
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

opportunity of hearing to a student whose admission is sought
to be cancelled.
13.3. In case the Court is of the opinion that no relief of
admission can be granted to such a candidate in the very
academic year and wherever it finds that the action of the
authorities has been arbitrary and in breach of the rules and
regulations or the prospectus affecting the rights of the students
and that a candidate is found to be meritorious and such
candidate/student has approached the court at the earliest and
without any delay, the court can mould the relief and direct the
admission to be granted to such a candidate in the next
academic year by issuing appropriate directions by directing to
increase in the number of seats as may be considered
appropriate in the case and in case of such an eventuality and if
it is found that the management was at fault and wrongly denied
the admission to the meritorious candidate, in that case, the
Court may direct to reduce the number of seats in the
management quota of that year, meaning thereby the
student/students who was/were denied admission illegally to be
accommodated in the next academic year out of the seats
allotted in the management quota.
13.4. Grant of the compensation could be an additional remedy
but not a substitute for restitutional remedies. Therefore, in an
appropriate case the Court may award the compensation to such
a meritorious candidate who for no fault of his/her has to lose
one full academic year and who could not be granted any relief
of admission in the same academic year.
13.5. It is clarified that the aforesaid directions pertain to
admission in MBBS course only and we have not dealt with
postgraduate medical course.
9. If the facts and circumstances of the case are considered, then it is
clear that petitioner had completed all her formalities, including
verification of original documents and deposit of fee much before the
expiry date i.e. 16/10/2026. It is on account of fault on the part of the
college that admission slip was not issued. Although the college had
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

11
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

already informed respondent No. 2 about its mistake in not issuing the
admission slip on 27/10/2026, still respondent No. 2 filled up the vacancy
after fifth special stray vacancy round, which took place much after the
receipt of the information. Undisputedly, the last date for admission is
28/11/2026. Therefore, not only respondent No. 3 had failed to discharge
its duty in time, but at the same time, respondent No. 2 also failed to take
note of the fact that the candidate has already fulfilled all her liabilities
and on account of failure on the part of respondent No. 3 admission slip
could not be issued and therefore one of the vacant entries which was
being reflected on the portal was erroneous, and still decided to allot the
seat to Ms. Aastha Dulani. However, respondents have taken an affidavit
from Ms. Aastha Dulani, which reads as under:
"My admission is subject to the outcome of decision by
Hon'ble High Court in WP No. 46584/2026 Ku. Senehi Rathore
V/s. state of MP".
10. Under these circumstances, in view of the undertaking given by Ms.
Aastha Dulani, this Court is of considered opinion that this Court can
direct for giving admission to the petitioner in the BDS course.
11. Therefore, in the light of judgment passed by Supreme Court in the
case of S. Krishna Sradha (supra), coupled with the fact that the last date
for admission has not expired and no extension is required, it is directed
that petitioner shall be granted admission to the BDS course to be
prosecuted by her in respondent No. 3/college, and in view of the
undertaking given by Ms. Aastha Dulani, respondents/Authorities are free
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:35094

12
W.P. No. 46584 of 2026

to take a decision as to whether she can be adjusted or she has to be
denied admission in BDS course.
12. Let the admission be granted to petitioner positively by 25th of
November 2026 i.e. much prior to the last date of admissions.
13. With aforesaid directions, petition is disposed of.

(G. S. AHLUWALIA) (ANURADHA SHUKLA)
JUDGE JUDGE


(and)
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANAND
SHRIVASTAVA
Signing time: 21-11-2026
12:13:09