Nitish Kumar vs State Of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home Lko. And 2 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
LUCKNOW
WRIT - A No. - 7813 of 2026
Nitish Kumar
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Home Lko. and 2 others
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Akash Tiwari, Arpit Dwivedi,
Shashank Shukla
Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C.,
Reserved on: 01.10.2026
Delivered on 19.11.2026
Court No. - 12
HON'BLE RAJEEV SINGH, J.
1. Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Sandeep Sharma,
learned Additional Chief Standing Counsel for the State.
2. This petition has been filed with the following prayer:-
“Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari, thereby
quashing the final list of shortlisted candidates issued on 17.07.2026,
as contained in Annexure No. 1 to this writ petition, in the interest of
justice.”
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that in
consonance with the advertisement dated 12.12.2023, another
notification was issued on 03.01.2024, clarifying the relaxations in the
prescribed age limit. The petitioner applied for the post of Constable
being sportsman in cross-country sports, as he fulfilled the eligibility
criteria prescribed for the same. The application form was submitted by
2
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
paying the requisite fee. Thereafter, document verification was
scheduled from 27.03.2026 to 28.03.2026. Following the verification
process, the event of trial for the cross-country sports was scheduled, and
a list of 120 candidates, whose documents had been verified, was issued.
Subsequently, the result for the cross-country sports was declared. Upon
perusal of the final list, the petitioner noticed that Indrajeet, whose name
appeared at Serial No. 8 of the list and his Roll No. 10003504, had been
included in the final list. Further, Ravi Kumar Pal, whose name appeared
at Serial No. 4 of the provisional list of shortlisted candidates for the
cross-country sports, whose Roll No. was 10002222, as his name was
not in the list of candidates called for the initial scrutiny and verification
of documents.
3.1. It has further been submitted that the name of the petitioner is at
Serial No. 13 in the provisional select list. Ravi Kumar Pal, Ashish
Kumar Patel, and Rohan Kumar were permitted to participate in the trial
held on 28.03.2026, even though their names did not appear in the list of
candidates called for document verification. Ravi Kumar Pal's name
appeared in the provisional select list. The action of the respondent
authorities in permitting the aforesaid three candidates to participate in
the trial was arbitrary and illegal. Accordingly, the impugned result is
liable to be set aside.
4. Learned State Counsel, while opposing the prayer of the
petitioner, has submitted that as per the provisions of the Uttar Pradesh
Police (Kushal Khiladiyon Ki Bharti Evam Bina Paari Padonnati)
Niyamavali, 2021, the advertisement in question was issued for
appointment of the constables under the sports quota of sportsmen of
different sports. As per para 9.13 of U.P. Police Recruitment and
Promotion Board’s Nirdesh Pustika, if a candidate fails to enclose any
document at the time of submitting the application form but produces the
relevant document before the authority at the time of document
verification, the document that was not submitted along with the
application form shall also be considered, and the matter shall be
proceeded with accordingly.
3
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
4.1. It has further been submitted that Ms. Ankita Singh, Additional
Superintendent of Police, Uttar Pradesh Police Recruitment and
Promotion Board, informed that after scrutiny, a list of 120 candidates
was published on the Board's website. Along with the said list, a notice
was issued stating that if any candidate, whose name had not been
considered due to non supply of document, could submit a
representation, he/she can do so within a period of three days from the
date of the notice assigning the reasons. Thereafter, ten applications were
received by the committee. Upon examination of those applications, the
names of the candidates were included in the list of candidates calling to
participate in the trials in their respective sports.
However, neither the representations submitted by the candidates nor the
orders passed thereon have been placed before this Court by the
respondent authorities.
4.2. It has next been submitted that on an earlier occasion, the
aforesaid officer also admitted before this Court that the said notification
permitting candidates to submit representations was issued on
03.11.2025. A total of ten candidates submitted representations along
with their sports certificates. Out of these, seven candidates were
permitted to participate in the trials, while the representations of the
remaining three candidates were rejected on the ground that their
documents did not meet the prescribed requirements. The aforesaid
seven candidates were permitted to participate in the trials conducted on
28.03.2026. The officer further admitted that Ravi Kumar Pal, along
with two other candidates, namely, Ashish Kumar Patel and Rohan
Kumar, submitted representations along with their certificates on
27.03.2026, beyond the period prescribed in the notice dated 03.11.2025;
despite the expiry of the prescribed period, they were permitted to
participate in the trials. Ravi Kumar Pal was subsequently declared
successful.
4
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
4.3. It has also been submitted that the petitioner is at serial no.13 and
only 12 posts are lying in the stream for which the petitioner applied.
Therefore, no interference is required.
5. Considering the submissions advanced by learned counsel for the
parties and going through the contents of the petition, relevant
photocopy of the record provided by the official, as well as other
relevant documents, it is evident that the advertisement was issued on
12.12.2023 and the petitioner applied against 12 posts for cross-country
sports. Thereafter, some relaxation in age was also prescribed vide
notification dated 03.01.2024. After scrutiny, the record reveals that a
total of 306 candidates had applied for recruitment. In the list prepared
by the Board containing details of the applications received, the name of
the petitioner appears at Serial No. 228, whereas the names of Indrajeet
and Ravi Kumar Pal appear at Serial Nos. 151 and 245, respectively, as
highlighted by the officer. Thereafter, on 03.11.2025, a notice was issued
by Additional Secretary of the Board stating that three days’ time was
granted for submissions of relevant documents if these were not
enclosed with application form by giving reasons and after three days,
no representation will be considered.
5.1. The contents of the letter dated 03.11.2025 are as under:-
5
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
5.2. Thereafter, upon expiry of the aforesaid period of three days, the
Board prepared a list of 120 eligible candidates, in which the name of
the petitioner is shown at Serial No. 113. However, the names of Ravi
Kumar Pal, Ashish Kumar Patel, and Rohan Kumar did not find place in
the said list. Subsequently, another list comprising 126 eligible
candidates was prepared by the authorities.
5.3. The contents of list of 306 candidates are as under:-
6
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
7
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
8
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
5.4. The contents of list of 120 candidates are as under:-
9
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
10
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
11
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
12
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
5.5. The contents of list of 126 candidates are as under:-
13
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
14
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
15
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
5.6. It is evident that the names of Indrajeet, Ravi Kumar Pal, and
Ashish Kumar Patel appeared in the said list of 126 candidates. It is
pertinent to note that after the expiry of the period stipulated in the
notice dated 03.11.2025, a list of 120 eligible candidates had already
been prepared and published. However, the authorities subsequently
included the names of certain additional candidates in another list
comprising 126 eligible candidates without disclosing the reasons for
doing so.
5.7. Apparently, despite clear directions, no order has been placed, by
which other six persons including Indrajeet, Ravi Kumar Pal, Ashish
Kumar Patel were allowed to participate in the trials.
6. In view of the observations made above, this Court finds that six
additional candidates namely Ganesh Kumar Bind, Indra Jeet, Ashish
Kumar, Rohan Kumar, Ravi Kumar Pal, and Ashish Kumar Patel, were
permitted to participate in the trials illegaly without following the
prescribed procedure and their claims were considered contrary to the
notice dated 03.11.2025. Therefore, the list of persons, who were not in
the list of 120 candidates, which was prepared after completion of period
as per notice dated 03.11.2025, is non est .
16
WRIA No. - 7813 of 2026
7. The Chairman, U.P. Police Recruitment and Promotion Board is
directed to finalize the selection process on the basis of aforesaid list of
120 candidates which was published in pursuance of the notice dated
03.11.2025. In case the petitioner is found suitable, the exercise in
relation to the appointment be completed within a period of six weeks by
passing a reasoned and speaking order.
8. In view of above, the present petition is allowed .
(Rajeev Singh,J.)
November 19, 2026
Arpan
Digitally signed by :-
ARPAN
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
Lucknow Bench