EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED THROUGH ITS GENERAL MANAGER SHRI AJAY KUMAR SHARMA vs UNION OF INDIA THROUGH ITS SECRETARY MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND EMPLOYMENT
- Court
- Jharkhand High Court
2026:JHHC:32929
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(L) No. 6682 of 2023
Eastern Coalfields Limited, Pandaveswar Area, PO & PS-
Pandaveswar, Dist.- West Burdwan, PIN- 713346, through its General
Manager Shri Ajay Kumar Sharma, aged about 59 years, S/o
Bhagwan Das Sharma, R/o - Quarter No. D-11, Jhanjra, Officers
Colony, Jhanjhra, PO- Laudoha, Dist.- West Burdwan, West Bengal,
PIN – 713383. … … Petitioner
Versus
1. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Labour and
Employment, Shashtri Bhawan, New Delhi, P.O. Shastri Bhawan,
P.S.- Parliament Street, District-New Delhi, PIN-110001
2. Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central), Hazaribagh and In
Charge ALC(C), Dhanbad - I in the Office of the Deputy Chief
Labour Commissioner (Central), 'Shramev Jayate Bhawan', PO
Jagjivan Nagar, PS-Saraidhela, Dist. - Dhanbad, PIN-826003.
3. The Secretary, Rashtriya Colliery Mazdoor Congress, Water Board
Colony, Hari Mandir Road, Hirapur, Dhanbad, PO, PS & Dist.-
Dhanbad, PIN – 826001 … … Respondents
---
CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
---
For the Petitioner : Mr. Anoop Kr. Mehta, Advocate
: Mr. Shubham Malviya, Advocate
For the Resp. Nos. 1 & 2 : Ms. Bakshi Vibha, Advocate
For the Resp. No. 3 : Mr. Ranjan Kr. Singh, Advocate
: Mr. Niranjan Singh, Advocate
---
C.A.V. On 30.06.2026 Pronounced on 18.11.2026
1. This writ petition has been filed for the following reliefs:
“ i) Issue an appropriate writ in the nature of Certiorari or
any other appropriate writ for Quashing the Reasoned Order
No. 2(3)/2007-E-6 dated 14.07.2023 (Annexure-8) passed by
the Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central) Hazaribagh -
I/C, Dhanbad-I, the Respondent No. 2 purported to have been
passed in compliance of the orders and directions passed by
this Hon'ble Court vide its Order dated 17.05.2023 in WPL
No. 4004 of 2009 directing the Petitioner to implement the
Award dated 29.08.2006 passed by the Central Government
Industrial Tribunal No. 1, Dhanbad (hereinafter referred to as
CGIT No. 1, Dhanbad) in Reference No. 137 of 1991.
ii) Issue an appropriate writ/order/direction commanding
upon the Respondents, more particularly the Respondent No. 3
not to direct the Petitioner to implement the Award dated
1
2026:JHHC:32929
29.08.2006 in Ref No. 137/1991 of the Central Government
Industrial Tribunal No. 1, Dhanbad as the Respondent No. 3
has failed to submit Pro Forma within 60 days from the date
of publication of Award and the Presiding Officer, CGIT No.
1, Dhanbad also made it crystal clear that in no case the said
period will be extended beyond 60 days and the case of the
concerned workman will not be considered, and therefore the
Award dated 29.08.2006 passed in Ref No. 137/1991 by the
Central Government Industrial Tribunal No. 1, Dhanbad has
become inoperative.
iii) Issue any other writ, order or direction as Your Lordships
may appear just and proper for doing conscionable justice to
the petitioner.”
2. Arguments of the petitioner
a. The award as contained in annexure 1 in favour of the
concerned workmen represented through the respondent no.3
has attained finality and the dispute relates to implementation of
the award.
b. Learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to annexure- 7
which is a judgment passed by this Court in W.P.(L) No. 4004
of 2009 and has submitted that the impugned order has been
passed pursuant to the said judgment.
c. An award was passed with respect to 397 persons and the award
is dated 29.08.2006 passed in Reference Case No. 137 of 1991
with certain directions mentioned therein. The learned counsel
has placed paragraph no. 7 of the award and has submitted that
the award itself indicated that the parties were to act strictly in
terms of the time-frame mentioned therein and certain
documents/information were required to be furnished by the
concerned workmen.
d. The award was not challenged by any person. However, in
connection with implementation of the award, a show-cause
notice dated 24/29.07.2009 was issued by the concerned
respondent directing the present petitioner to implement the
order and a notice under section 29 of the Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947 was issued.
2
2026:JHHC:32929
e. The aforesaid notice was challenged before this Court in
W.P.(L) No. 4004 of 2009. Considering the fact that there was
a dispute as to whether the parties had acted in terms of the
award or not, the declaration sought for in the writ petition that
the award dated 29.08.2006 passed in Reference Case No. 137
of 1991 was inoperative and could not be implemented, was not
granted by this Court. However, the dispute was yet to be
considered as to whether the parties had acted in terms of the
award dated 29.08.2006.
f. In aforesaid circumstances, the writ petition was disposed of
directing the Assistant Labour Commissioner, Central
Dhanbad-I to consider the show-cause reply filed by the
petitioner as back as on 08.08.2009 and pass appropriate order
after granting opportunity of hearing to the parties. The show-
cause reply has been placed on record at Annexure- 5.
g. The learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
pursuant to the order passed in the earlier writ petition, the
impugned order has been passed.
h. The learned counsel has placed the award passed earlier as
contained in annexure-1 to the writ petition and submits that
strict timeline was given to submit the documents by the
concerned workmen and the required documents to be filed
were also mentioned.
i. The learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that so far
as the compliance of the direction regarding timeline for filing
the documents by the respondent in terms of the aforesaid
award (annexure-1) is concerned, the same may not be of much
relevance as there is at best a gap of one day even as per the
impugned order. The respondent no. 3 claims to have filed the
documents on 06.12.2006 and the petitioner claims that the
document by way of a chart was filed on 07.12.2006. The
authority has accepted the filing of the said document to be
within time.
3
2026:JHHC:32929
However, the learned counsel submits that as per the award
(annexure-1) itself, the documents as mentioned and indicated
in the award were required to be filed by each workman. This
part of the award (annexure-1) was not complied by the
respondent no.3/ the concerned workmen inasmuch as, what
was filed was only a chart giving certain entry in the columns
with respect to each workman as Annexure- 6 to the writ
petition and the documents mentioned as enclosure to annexure-
6 were not filed. He submits that the directions contained in the
award (annexure-1) was not complied and therefore, the Award
dated 29.08.2006 (annexure-1) passed in Ref No. 137/1991 by
the Central Government Industrial Tribunal No. 1, Dhanbad has
become inoperative.
j. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that when the
aforesaid point was raised before this Court on an earlier date
that except the chart, no documents mentioned in the covering
letter were actually filed, this Court passed an order dated
17.10.2024 wherein it has been recorded that the learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent – Union had
submitted that since it was mentioned that the chart was filed
along with the supporting documents, he shall seek instruction
and file supporting documents and photographs of each and
every workman before this Court which were already filed
along with the chart annexed with the writ petition as annexure-
6 and the matter was adjourned for filing the affidavit.
k. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that now the
respondents have filed the affidavit enclosing certain documents
in connection with 156 workmen only out of 397 workmen,
although in the covering letter as contained in annexure-6 they
claimed that the documents in connection with all the 397
workmen were furnished.
l. During the course of arguments and upon going through the
documents which have been filed by the respondent no.3, it has
been pointed out that at page no. 39 of the affidavit, the date of
4
2026:JHHC:32929
document is 03.09.2008 which is much after the
06.12.2006/07.12.2006 [ the date of filing the document] and at
page no. 94, 146, 195, 199 and 343 it has been mentioned as
under:
“Certified to be true copy
Sd/-
(3/04/19)
Authorized by Presiding Officer,
Central Government Industrial Tribunal
(No.1) Dhanbad”
m. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the enclosures
which are claimed to have been filed with respect to 397
workmen along with the chart as contained in Annexure- 6
have not been brought on record in spite of grant of opportunity
and alleged documents in connection with 156 workmen have
only been filed and many of the documents as mentioned above
itself reveal that they could not have been filed way back in the
year, 2006.
n. The learned counsel submits that the order passed by this Court
on 17.10.2024, wherein the respondent- Union was granted time
to file supporting documents and photographs of each and every
workman before this Court, has not been complied and thus, the
respondent-Union has not been able to demonstrate before this
Court that the documents were filed along with the chart as
contained in annexure-6 to the writ petition. The learned
counsel submits that since the documents were not filed along
with the chart, therefore, the directions as contained in the
award passed by the learned tribunal was not complied by the
respondent no.3- Union and therefore, there is no question of
violation of the award on the part of the petitioner which has
been rendered inoperative and hence no direction could have
been issued by the impugned order to implement the award and
consequently, subsequent order as contained in Annexure 9 is
also bad in law.
o. The learned counsel for the petitioner has further submitted that
otherwise also so far as the impugned order is concerned, the
5
2026:JHHC:32929
authority was not only required to decide the timeline, but was
also required to consider as to whether the documents in terms
of the award have been filed or not. He submits that the
authority has only considered the timeline and has recorded a
finding that it may be taken as to have been filed within time,
but the authority has not examined any of the documents. He
has submitted that since no documents were filed along with the
chart, there was no occasion for the authority to decide the
same. The learned counsel submits that the impugned order
dated 14.07.2023 is fit to be set-aside and since the respondent-
Union has not complied the award, the respondent authority
could not have directed the petitioner to implement the award
(annexure-1) dated 29.08.2006.
3. Arguments of the Respondent no.3
i. Learned counsel for the respondent no.3- Union has referred to
internal page no. 4 of the impugned award at page 107 and has
submitted that it was agreed and accepted by both the parties
that the documents were submitted by Union on 07.12.2006. He
submits that once it was accepted that the documents were
submitted on 07.12.2006, there is no occasion for the petitioner
to argue that the documents accompanying the letter dated
06.12.2006 filed on 07.12.2006 were not filed.
ii. Learned counsel for the respondent no. 3 – Union has further
referred to paragraph 15 of the writ petition to submit that a
reference has been made by the petitioner themselves that in the
earlier writ petition in paragraph 12 of the counter-affidavit, the
respondent Union stated that the list of workmen was submitted
on 06.12.2006.
iii. The learned counsel for the respondent no.3 has also submitted
that so far as time limit for filing the documents pursuant to the
award (Annexure-1) is concerned, the documents have been
held to be filed within time and such finding does not call for
any interference.
6
2026:JHHC:32929
iv. However, during the course of argument, the learned counsel
for the respondent no.3 has not been able to explain as to why
the respondent no.3 has not been able to submit the
documents which were said to have been enclosed along with
the list of workmen in spite of specific order passed by this
Court on 17.10.2024. He is further not able to explain as to
why certain documents in connection with only 156 workmen
have been submitted before this court out of 397 workmen.
The learned counsel has further not been able to explain as to
how many of the documents sought to be produced in terms of
the order of this Court, contain the date of 2008/2019 which
the said respondent no.3 claim to have been filed with the
petitioner way back in the year 2006.
4. Rejoinder of the petitioner.
In response, the learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that the respondent no.3-Union was required to file the
documents in terms of observations at internal page no. 6 of the
award (annexure-1) read with the directions contained at the
end of paragraph 7 of the award (annexure-1). The directions
having not been complied, the award (annexure-1) has been
rendered unenforceable.
Findings of this court.
5. The entire dispute revolves around implementation of award
dated 29.08.2006 passed in Reference Case No. 137 of 1991. This writ
nd
petition is the 2 round of litigation before this High Court. Earlier,
the petitioner had moved this Court in W.P.(L) No. 4004 of 2009
which was decided vide order dated 17.05.2023. The sponsoring union
was representing 397 persons as per the schedule to the terms of
reference with respect to 5 collieries which were nationalized and
taken over on 28.05.1974 under Coal Mines Nationalisation Act and
were running under the management of the petitioner – company.
6. It was the case of the sponsoring union in the Reference Case
No. 137 of 1991 that as a result of takeover, there was complete
failure of law and order and taking advantage of the situation, the
7
2026:JHHC:32929
management left out the genuine workmen who were working on the
roll of the concerned company on the date of take over and some new
persons were inducted as workmen in the five collieries. Initially, they
had approached Calcutta High Court and also before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court and ultimately the dispute was referred to the learned
Tribunal vide order dated 26.11.1991 numbered as Reference Case
No. 137 of 1991.
7. The terms of reference was as under:
“Whether the demand of the workmen of Jorekuri, Palesthali,
Beldanga, Kasta, Pariharpur Collieries of M/S. Eastern Coalfield
Ltd., Sanctoria, P.O. Disergarh (Burdwan) that the workmen
named in the Annexure should be reinstated with all benefits of
back wages and continuity of service from 28.5.74 when their
services were stopped by the management, is justified? If so, to
what relief are the workmen concerned entitled?”
8. The learned tribunal entered into the core question involved in
the case i.e., whether the concerned persons were the genuine
workmen of the erstwhile owner on the date of nationalization and
observed that the same was definitely a question which required a lot
of investigation. The learned tribunal further observed that in terms of
reference, only names of 397 persons had been mentioned, their
parentage had not been mentioned nor their age or the permanent
home address had been mentioned. The learned tribunal also observed
that in order to verify the genuineness, form-B register of erstwhile
owner was required to be perused and the information as to whether
they were members of provident fund was also required to be probed
into, but neither party had brought on record the said documents. The
concerned persons had filed certificates from erstwhile owner which
were marked Exhibit- W-1 to W-5 series to prove that they were
workmen of erstwhile owner on the date of takeover of five collieries,
but the genuineness of the certificates was required to be verified vis-
à-vis Form -B register of erstwhile owner and provident fund record
and also from the voter list of the locality of those collieries for the
relevant year.
9. Consequently, the learned tribunal was of the view that a
screening committee should be constituted to examine all these
8
2026:JHHC:32929
aspects and there should be a representative of the sponsoring union
and a nominee of the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central) of the
concerned area to examine the genuineness of the concerned persons
and also to find out if they were workmen on the roll of the erstwhile
owner of the respective collieries. It was also observed that since the
dispute was going on from 28.05.1974 and many of the concerned
persons might have crossed the age limit of 60 years and many of
them might not be available for some reasons or the other, therefore,
screening committee was required. Further, the learned tribunal
formulated a formula for screening of the concerned persons as
mentioned in the award itself whereby all the concerned persons were
to submit a proforma containing their name, parentage, age, permanent
address, a recent photograph and any proof in support of their being
workmen in the erstwhile colliery in the Personnel Department of the
area of the colliery through sponsoring union within 60 days from the
date of publication of the award. It was stipulated that in no case the
period would extend beyond 60 days and if this was not complied by one
or the other concerned person, their case would not be considered. It was
only upon filing of such proforma by all the concerned persons, the
management was to constitute a screening committee and include a
nominee of Regional Labour Commissioner (Central) of the concerned
area to be present in the screening committee along with one office
bearer of the sponsoring union and genuineness of the concerned
persons having worked with the erstwhile owner was to be examined.
Thereafter, the screening committee was to publish a list of genuine
persons. Such genuine persons so scrutinized were to be entitled for
employment with continuity of service and 25% back-wages within 30
days from the publication of the list. It was also mentioned that if the
management failed to follow the timeline, then it would be presumed
that all the concerned persons whose names find place in the list of
order of reference are the genuine workmen and they would be
entitled for reinstatement with continuity of service w.e.f. 25.08.1974
and 25% back wages.
Paragraph 7 of the award is quoted as under:
9
2026:JHHC:32929
“Now the question is whether the concerned persons were the
genuine workmen of erstwhile owner on the date of
nationalization is definitely a question which requires a lot of
investigation. In the term of reference there is only the names of
397 persons. Their parentage has not been mentioned, nor
there is mention of their age or the permanent home address.
Therefore, a lot of exercise is required to be done for the
identification of genuine workmen to find out whether any of the
persons mentioned in the list, were the workmen of the
erstwhile owner. For this purpose Form ‘B’ Register of
erstwhile owner is required to be perused. The information
regarding their being member of Provident Fund will also be
required to be probe into, but neither party has brought on
record the documents. The concerned persons, however, have
filed certificates from the erstwhile owners which have been
marked Exts. W-1 to W-5 series to prove that they were
workmen of erstwhile owner on the date of take over of the
aforesaid five collieries/coal mines. The genuineness of the
certificates granted by the erstwhile owner is also to be verified
vis-à-vis Form ‘B’ Register of erstwhile owner and the
provident fund record and also from the voter list of the locality
of those collieries for the relevant year.
Therefore, in such circumstances of this case I think
that there should be a Screening Committee to examine all
these aspects of this case in which there should be a
representative of the sponsoring union and a nominee of the
Regional Labour Commissioner (Central) of the concerned
area to examine the genuineness of the concerned persons and
also to find out if they were workmen on the roll of the erstwhile
owner of the respective collieries. Furthermore, the dispute
regarding the employment is going on right from 28.5.74 and
many of the concerned persons might have crossed the age limit
of 60 years and many of them might not be available for some
reason or other. Therefore, in that view of the matter also a
Screening is required. Therefore, I formulate a formula for the
screening of the concerned persons to find out whether any of
them were the workmen of erstwhile owner in any of the
collieries mentioned in the reference order on the date of
takeover or just before the date of take over. These formula will
be as follows:
(i) All the concerned persons will submit a proforma
containing their names, parentage, age, permanent
address, a recent photograph and any proof in support of
their being workmen in the erstwhile colliery in the
Personnel Department of the area of the colliery through
the sponsoring union within 60 days from the date of
10
2026:JHHC:32929
publication of the award. In no case the period will be
extended beyond 60 days i.e. if some one fails to file such
format alongwith proof within 60 days through their
sponsoring union then his case will not be considered on
any later date.
(ii) The management of M/s E.C. Ltd. will constitute a
Screening Committee and they will include a nominee of
the R.L.C. (Central) of the concerned area to be present in
the Screening Committee alongwith one office-bearer of
the sponsoring union within 30 days from the last date of
filing of the format mentioned above. Thereafter the
Screening Committee will make sitting and decide the
genuineness of the concerned persons for having been the
workmen of the erstwhile owner. After examination of the
claims of the concerned persons who will produce their
claim format mentioned above within 30 days from the
date of formation of the Screening Committee the
Screening Committee will publish a list of genuine
persons, if any, duly authenticated by the representative of
the R.L.C.(C) of the concerned area also.”
10. The award attained finality and was followed by notification
publishing the award. The notification was served upon the Central
Government vide communication dated 08.09.2006. The award was
published vide notification dated 07.10.2006. The notification is
contained in Annexure-2.
11. As per paragraph 19 of the writ petition, the 60 days expired on
06.12.2006 and the workmen did not comply with the terms of
furnishing documents within time. A letter dated 14.10.2006 was
served upon the petitioner enclosing a copy of the award and a request
was made to initiate the required steps for implementation process. It
is the case of the petitioner that the said letter was issued without
submitting format containing details and particulars of the concerned
workmen.
Thereafter, the petitioner was served with notice dated 10.07.2008
(Annexure-4) issued by the Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central)
Dhanbad-I wherein it has been mentioned that they were informed by
the Union that the Union had already submitted required proforma in
respect of 397 workmen vide letter dated 14.10.2006 and a copy of the
same was also enclosed and the petitioner was called upon to explain
11
2026:JHHC:32929
as to why legal action be not taken against the management for non-
implementation of the award under section 29 read with section 32 of
the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
12. In response to the aforesaid, the petitioner issued letter dated
08.08.2009 and categorically stated that the Union/the concerned
workmen did not abide by the directions as contained in award dated
29.08.2006, neither in terms of timeline nor in terms of content. It was
their specific stand that the allegation by the Union that they actually
submitted the proforma of 397 workmen on 14.10.2006 was
absolutely incorrect, inasmuch as, the Union only forwarded copy of
the award along with their letter dated 14.10.2006 and submitted the
th
proforma as late as on 07 December, 2006 as admitted by the Union
in their representation to the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central)
Dhanbad-I dated 20.03.2007 (Annexure-A-3).
13. The petitioner has also brought on record a letter dated
06.12.2006 issued to the personnel manager of Personnel Department
of Eastern Coalfields Limited by National Colliery Mazdoor Sangh
and in the said letter, the sponsoring union mentioned that under the
direction of the tribunal, they were submitting the list of 397 workmen
who were the employees of erstwhile owners of five collieries. It was
also mentioned that with the direction of the tribunal they were
submitting the list in the office within 60 days and were also enclosing
a copy of the award. The letter is a typed one and in the bottom of the
said letter, the enclosures are mentioned as:
“1. Photocopy of the Award
2. Names sheets along with all required documents/certificates
verified by one Branch Secretary Shri B.D. Khan, Asst. Sect. Kadir
Khan and vice president Shri Jayanti Singh.”
14. The petitioner has enclosed the chart said to have been
submitted by the concerned workmen and at the top of the chart, it has
been mentioned as follows:
“List of Workman of Jorekuri Colliery, Beldanga Colliery, Kasta
Colliery, Parihar Pur Colliery and Palasthali Colliery under the
Pandveshwar Aera of Eastern Coalfield Limited with their Home
address, Designation, date of appointment etc. alongwith
supporting documents. Central Govt. Industrial Tribunal No.I,
Dhanbad with reference are 653 award dated 29-8-06 on the
12
2026:JHHC:32929
reference no. 137/91 of the Govt. order No.
20012(52)/83/III(A)I.R.(Coal-I), New Delhi, Dated 26-11-1991.”
15. It was at this stage, the petitioner filed a writ petition being
W.P.(L) No. 4004 of 2009 for the following reliefs:
“For a declaration that the award dated
29.08.2006 passed in reference case No. 137 of
1991 is inoperative and cannot be implemented.
AND
A further writ to quash the show cause notice
dated 24/29.07.2009 issued by the concerned
respondents directing the petitioner the
implemented the said award and further writ
directing the concerned respondents not to take
in coercive steps pursuant to the notice dated
24/29.07.2009 issued to the petitioner.
AND
During the pendency of this writ application no
coercive steps should be taken against the
petitioner or their employees.”
16. The aforesaid writ petition being W.P.(L) No. 4004 of 2009
was essentially seeking a declaration that the award dated 29.08.2006
passed in Reference Case No. 137 of 1991 was inoperative and could
not be implemented and the petitioner had also prayed for a writ to
quash the show-cause notice dated 24/29.07.2009 issued by the
concerned respondent directing the petitioner to implement the award.
17. It was the specific case of the sponsoring union in the earlier
writ petition, who filed a counter-affidavit, that a letter dated
14.10.2006 for implementation of the award was submitted and on
06.12.2006 they submitted the list of workmen with the required
details which was duly received in the office of the petitioner on
06.12.2006. It was submitted on behalf of the sponsoring union that
the claim was lodged within the stipulated time from the date of
publication of the award. A reference was made by the learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner in the earlier writ petition
to annexure- 4 of the said writ petition which was issued by an
Advocate namely, B.N. Singh, who claimed to be the office bearer of
13
2026:JHHC:32929
the Union and in paragraph 5 of the representation dated 18.11.2006,
the said Advocate had informed that till date, no existent workmen
and no real dependent of non-existing workmen had turned up before
him in terms of the award to get his name sponsored for employment
etc. The petitioner also disputed the date of submission of documents
by the sponsoring union and stated that no supporting document was
filed by the sponsoring union.
18. After having recorded the aforesaid submissions, this Court
disposed of the said writ petition in the following terms:
“9. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties and
considering the facts and circumstances of this case, this court
finds that the award dated 29.08.2006, having strict time line, was
published on 07.10.2006. From the arguments of the parties it
appears that there is a dispute as to whether the respondent No. 2
had taken steps in terms of the award or not. It further appears
that the respondent Ministry of Labour, Government of India had
issued a letter dated 24/29.07.2009 asking the petitioner to show
cause as to why legal action under Section 29 read with Section 32
of the Industrial Disputes Act be not taken for non-implementation
of the award to which the petitioner had filed a reply as contained
in Annexure-11 stating that the direction issued by the learned
Tribunal upon the respondent union has not been complied.
10. It appears that in the meantime, interim order dated
10.12.2009 was passed by this court and the respondents have not
proceeded further regarding the show cause issued to the
petitioner during the pendency of this case.
11. Considering the dispute as to whether the respondent No. 2
had complied with the time line as prescribed in the award or not,
this court finds that the petitioner has filed his show cause to the
notice dated 24/29.07.2009 and therefore an appropriate order is
required to be passed by the Authority upon considering the reply
to show cause filed by the petitioner. Since the rights of the
respondent No. 2 is involved in the present case, therefore the
respondent No. 2 is also required to be heard while disposal of the
show cause reply filed by the petitioner.
12. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, when there is
a dispute as to whether the parties have acted in terms of the
award or not, this court is of the considered view that no
declaration as prayed for by the petitioner can be made by this
court at this stage as to whether the award dated 29.08.2006,
passed in Reference Case No. 137 of 1991, is inoperative or not
14
2026:JHHC:32929
and whether it can be implemented or not. However, the reply to
the show cause submitted by the petitioner is certainly required to
be taken care of and appropriate order is required to be passed.
13. Accordingly, this writ petition is disposed of directing the
Assistant Labour Commissioner, Central Dhanbad-I to consider
the show cause reply filed by the petitioner as back as on
08.08.2009 and pass an appropriate order after granting an
opportunity of hearing to the petitioner as well as to the
respondent No. 2. The petitioner as well as respondent No. 2 shall
appear before the respondent No. 3 on 13.06.2023 at 11.00 a.m.
Upon their appearance, the respondent No. 3 shall consider the
show cause reply filed by the petitioner and also the points to be
raised by the respondent No. 2 before the said Authority and pass
a reasoned order after granting an opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner as well as respondent No. 2. The respondent No. 3 shall
pass a reasoned order within a period of one month from the date
of receipt of the representation and communicate the same to the
petitioner as well as respondent no.2 at their respective address to
be provided to the respondent no.3.”
19. Pursuant to the order passed by this Court, the concerned
authority namely, Assistant Labour Commissioner, (Central)
Dhanbad-I passed the impugned order dated 14.07.2023.
20. The concerned authority recorded that on 19.06.2023, the
representative of the management had appeared and the stand of the
management was reiterated again by the representative of the
management on the date of hearing on 19.06.2023 and has also
recorded that it was agreed and accepted by both the parties that the
documents were submitted by the Union on 07.12.2006. After having
recorded as aforesaid, the authority posed a moot question as follows:
“The moot question is, which is the correct date of publication of
award for the purpose of reckoning of the period of 60 days from
the date of publication of award as stipulated by the CGIT
Dhanbad-I?”
21. With respect to the date of publication of the award and
compliance with the timeline, as prescribed in the award, the authority
observed as under:
“If it is consider that the date of submission of documents by the
union was on 7/12/2006, the period taken by the union to submit
proforma to the management is 61 days. Therefore, the union is
stating in their support that though the notification is published by
th
the Authority on 7 October, 2006 (Saturday), the same should
15
2026:JHHC:32929
have been received on Monday or thereafter to justify the delay of
one day on their part.”
22. With respect to the aforesaid, the authority further held as
under:
“In view of the above order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court as well
as provision of the ID Act 1947 I am of the opinion that the stand
of the management is not acceptable in calculating the limitation
for implementation of award of 60 days from the date 08/09/2006
as it was only the date of receipt of award by the Ministry of
Labour & Employment, New Delhi from the CGIT Dhanbad-I.”
23. The learned authority ultimately recorded that the show-cause
notice reply dated 08.08.2009 from the management has been
considered as per the direction of the High Court. The operative
portion of the impugned order is quoted as under:
"The period specified for 60 days submission of document by the
claimant, the intention of CGIT prompt expedite procedure of
screening the application. It does not mean restriction impose on
operation of award"
"The Show Cause notice reply dated 08.08.2009 from the
management have been considered, as per direction of the Hon'ble
High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi and in the light of the above,
the management of M/s Eastern Coalfields Limited is hereby
advised to implement the award in Ref.No.137/91 dated
29.08.2006 of CGIT, Dhanbad-I in letter and spirit".
24. It is apparent from the earlier order passed by this court while
remanding the matter through W.P.(L) No. 4004 of 2009 that there
was a serious dispute as to whether the documents were submitted in
terms of the award.
25. This Court is of the considered view that the authority was
required to consider not only whether the documents were filed within
time as per the Award, but also whether the concerned workmen had
complied with the directions contained in the award. This Court finds
that the authority while passing the impugned order has simply
recorded that the timeline was followed, but has not examined the
other aspects of the matter and proceeded by observing that it was
agreed and accepted by both the parties that documents were
submitted by the union on 07.12.2006. The authority did not examine
16
2026:JHHC:32929
as to whether the documents were submitted in terms of the award or
not and whether the required proforma were submitted or not.
This Court also finds that in the entire impugned order, there is no
discussion of the stand taken by the petitioner in its show-cause reply
dated 08.08.2009 wherein a plea was raised that the directions issued
by the tribunal in the award were not followed in terms of timeline
and also in letter and spirit and the impugned order only considered
the timeline but has not considered as to whether the documents were
filed in terms of the award and to what extent.
Consequently, this Court passed an order dated 17.10.2024 which is
quoted as under:
“Heard the learned counsels for the parties.
2. The learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
pursuant to the award dated 29.08.2006 passed in Reference Case
No.137 of 1991, the respondent-Union had only submitted the list
of the workmen total 397 in number, who were claiming that they
were ex-employees of the colliery way back in the year 1971. He
submits that although at the top of page no.55, it has been stated
that the chart was being submitted along with the supporting
documents, but no supporting documents, photographs etc. were
submitted.
3. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-
Union has submitted that since it has been mentioned that the
chart was filed along with the supporting documents, he shall seek
instruction and file supporting documents and photographs of each
and every workman before this Court which were already filed
along with the chart annexed with the writ petition.
4. Let the affidavit be filed by 18.12.2024.
5. The affidavit of the Union should clearly indicate as to whether
these documents were filed along with the chart or not.
6. Post this case on 19.12.2024 in the supplementary cause list.
7. Interim order dated 03.07.2024 passed earlier is directed to
continue till 19.12.2024.”
26. Pursuant to the said order, the respondent no. 3 has filed a reply
vide supplementary counter-affidavit dated 20.12.2024. The
respondent no. 3 has specifically stated in paragraph 5 of its affidavit
that documents of 156 workmen only were filed along with chart
which was being filed along with the supplementary counter-affidavit.
It has also been stated that in the case of some of the workmen, their
letter issued by the management of the erstwhile colliery was lost due
17
2026:JHHC:32929
to which Sanha/FIR was also enclosed. Paragraphs 5 and 6 of the
supplementary counter-affidavit are quoted as under:
“5. That, as such documents of 156 workmen were filed along
with the chart which are also being filed here with this
supplementary affidavit.
Photocopies of Voter Card along
with photographs and the letters
issued by the management of
erstwhile colliery are being
annexed and marked as Annexure
1/Supp Series to this affidavit.
6. That, in case of some of the workmen their letter issued by the
management of the erstwhile colliery was lost due to which
Sanha/F.I.R. have been enclosed.”
27. Through the supplementary counter-affidavit, the concerned
union has admitted before this Court that they had filed documents
only with respect to 156 workmen along with chart. Further, in the
impugned order it has been recorded that on the date of hearing on
19.06.2023 it was agreed and accepted by both the parties that the
documents were submitted by the Union on 07.12.2006 and the date of
submission of documents has been accepted to be within the period
prescribed by the tribunal. The concerned authority (Respondent no.2)
also considered that at best there was a default of 1 day and this was
accepted to be within time on account of intervening weekend.
However, the learned authority (Respondent no.2) has not considered
as to whether the documents submitted were in terms and in
consonance with the directions issued by the tribunal in award passed
in Reference Case No. 137 of 1991 which was under implementation.
28. Considering the nature of controversy and upon being given an
opportunity to place on record the documents submitted by the Union,
the documents with respect to only 156 out of 397 workmen have
been produced through supplementary counter affidavit. It has also
been recorded in the order dated 30.06.2026 that the respondent no. 3
was not able to explain as to how, many of the documents which were
subsequently issued, could have been filed way back in 2006 and as to
why certain documents in connection with only 156 workmen have
been submitted before this court out of 397 workmen. The observation
in the order dated 30.06.2026 is quoted as under: -
18
2026:JHHC:32929
“ 4. However, during the course of argument, the learned counsel
for the respondent no.3 has not been able to explain as to why
the respondent no.3 has not been able to submit the documents
which were said to have been enclosed along with the list of
workmen in spite of specific order passed by this Court on
17.10.2024. He is further not able to explain as to why certain
documents in connection with only 156 workmen have been
submitted before this court out of 397 workmen. The learned
counsel has further not been able to explain as to how many of
the documents sought to be produced by the order of this Court,
contain the date of 2008/2019 which the said respondent claim to
have been filed with the petitioner way back in the year 2006.”
29. It is just to put on record that the respondent -union has not
annexed even one proforma in terms of the award (Annexure-1) along
with their supplementary counter-affidavit although as per impugned
order it was agreed between the parties that documents were submitted
by the Union on 07.12.2006. Further, the respondent union has
admitted that they had submitted the documents only with respect to
156 workmen. However, the respondent no.2 having not examined as
to whether the documents filed even with respect to 156 out of 397
workmen were in terms of the award or not and whether required
proforma were also filed or not in terms of the award with respect to
156 workmen, this court refrains from examining this aspect of the
matter for the first time in writ jurisdiction. The needful is required to
be done by the learned authority (Respondent no.2) before proceeding
further to implement the award.
30. In aforesaid circumstances, the impugned order rejecting the
show cause reply filed by the petitioner, being incomplete in aforesaid
aspects of the matter as to whether the documents filed by the Union
were in consonance with the directions issued by the award under
implementation, cannot be sustained in law except to the extent that
filing of certain documents on 07.12.2006 has been rightly taken as
having been filed within time. However, it remains to be examined as
to whether the documents filed with respect to 156 workmen out of
397 workmen were as per the directions passed in the award.
31. Accordingly, the respondent no.2 is directed to examine the
matter regarding each of 156 workmen, whose documents were said to
19
2026:JHHC:32929
have been filed on 07.12.2006, in the light of the directions issued in
the award under implementation and in case the directions contained
in the award are found not to have been complied by the union/
concerned workmen, no relief can be granted to one or the other
workman in the matter of implementation of the award as the award
itself would be rendered unimplementable when seen in the light of
the directions contained in the award itself.
32. The office is directed to forward a copy of the supplementary
counter affidavit dated 20.12.2024 (filed on 14.01.2025) filed by the
Union (Respondent no.3) along with its annexures to the concerned
authority (Respondent no.2) for his perusal and needful.
33. The petitioner and the respondent no. 3 shall appear before the
th
respondent no.2 on 14 of December, 2026 at 11.00 a.m. and the
respondent no.2 is directed to pass a reasoned order after giving an
opportunity of hearing to the parties in the light of the aforesaid
discussions within a period of 1 month thereafter and communicate
the order to the parties through speed post.
34. This writ petition is disposed of with the aforesaid observations
and directions.
35. Pending interlocutory application, if any, is dismissed as not
pressed.
36. Let this order be communicated to the concerned authority
(Respondent no.2) through ‘FAX/email’.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Date of Judgment: 18.11.2026
Pankaj
Date of Uploading: 18.11.2026
20