Shrinivas Ganesh Kulkarni vs Savitribai Phule Pune University Through The Registrar And Ors

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM010298852024

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
JYOTI
RAJESH
MANE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Digitally signed by
JYOTI RAJESH
MANE
Date: 2026.09.11
19:49:07 +0530
WRIT PETITION NO. 14168 OF 2024
Shrinivas Ganesh Kulkarni
Age-60 years, Occu- Retired
R/a. S.No.39/A/213, Amrut Nagar
Room No.12, Building NO.3, Sinhgad Road
Manik Baug, Pune – 411041. ...Petitioner
Versus

1)Savitribai Phule Pune University
Through The Registrar Ganeshkhind,
Pune - 411 007.
2) The Principal Secretary,
Dept. of Higher and Technical Education,
Mantralaya, Mumbai.
3) Director of Higher Education, Maharashtra State,
having Office at 3, B.J. Road, Central Building
Pune - 411 001.
(E.mail: [email protected])
4) Joint Director of Higher Education Pune Region,
Pune having Office at 17, Dr. Ambedkar Road,
Pune Division, Pune - 411 001. ...Respondents
_______
Mr. Vaibhav Kulkarni a/w Mr. Prathamesh Deshpande & Ms.Disha Rathod,
for the Petitioner.
Mr. Rajendra Anbhule (through V.C.) a/w Ms.Vaibhavi Shelar,
for Respondent No.1.
Mr. P. P. Kakade, Addl.G.P. a/w Ms.Priyanka B. Chavan, AGP,
for Respondent-State.
_______
CORAM: G. S. KULKARNI &
AARTI SATHE , JJ.

RESERVED ON: 28 JULY 2026
PRONOUNCED ON: 11 SEPTEMBER 2026
Page 1 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
JUDGMENT (Per : Aarti Sathe, J.):-
1. This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is
filed praying for the following substantive reliefs:-
a) That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or
any other appropriate Writ direction or order under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 quashing and setting aside the letter dated
17.04.2023 issued by the Respondent No. 1 showing recovery against the
Petitioner & further direct the Respondent No. 1 to pay all the post retiral
benefits to the Petitioner with immediate effect.
b) That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or
any other appropriate Writ direction or order under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 directing the Respondent No. 1 to award the
benefit of Assured Career Progression Scheme from June 2017 and direct
payment of arrears with appropriate interest.
c) That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or
any other appropriate Writ direction or order under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 directing the Respondent No. 1 to implement
th
the 7 Pay Commission qua the Petitioner w.e.f. 01.01.2016 based on the
existing pay scale i.e. 9300-34800 with Grade Pay of Rs. 5300 (after
awarding the benefit of ACPS - 24 years continuous service).
d) That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or
any other appropriate Writ direction or order under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 directing the Respondent No. 1 to pay the
accumulated earned leave encashment benefit to the Petitioner as per the
rules.
e) That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or
any other appropriate Writ direction or order under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 directing the Respondent No. 1 to pay the
interest accrued on the Provident Fund retained by the University to the
Petitioner asper the rules.
2. The Petitioner, being a Class-III employee of Respondent No. 1-
th
University, has challenged the legality of the notice dated 17 April 2023
issued by Respondent No. 1-University seeking to recover from the
Petitioner an amount of Rs. 39,94,343/- on the ground that the same
amounted to excess payment. The Petitioner is seeking further direction to
th
release his gratuity, earned leave encashment, the arrears of the 7 Pay
Page 2 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
Commission dues under the Assured Career Progression Scheme, and
accrued interest on Provident Fund which is due to him. The recovery of the
aforesaid amount, according to the Petitioner, is an arbitrary action taken by
Respondent No. 1-University, and more particularly post-retirement of the
Petitioner, the same cannot be made from the Petitioner.
3. Briefly the facts are as follows:
i. The Petitioner joined the services of Respondent No. 1-
University on the post of “Data Entry Operator” as per instructions of
th
Respondent No. 1-University on job-work basis on 7 June 1993.
nd
Thereafter, on 22 July 1993, the Petitioner was issued an official
appointment order for the post of “Data Entry Operator” in the pay scale
1200-30-1560-EB-40-2040.
ii. The Petitioner was given temporary appointment in Respondent
nd
No. 1-University as a Data Entry Operator on 22 July 1993 as stated
th
aforesaid. On 26 September 1994, a fresh appointment letter was issued to
the Petitioner, by which the Petitioner was appointed to the post of Data
nd
Entry Operator on permanent basis. On 22 August 1995, since the
Petitioner was already in the service of Respondent No. 1-University, it also
protected his basic pay, and a pay protection letter was issued to the
th
Petitioner of even date. Thereafter, on 10 December 1998, a Government
Notification was issued by the Finance Department of the State of
Maharashtra, in which the pay scale of Rs. 9300-34800 with a grade pay of
Page 3 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
Rs. 4300 had been provided to the position of the Data Entry Operator.
th
Thereafter, again on 4 February 1999, through a Government Notification,
th
the post of Data Entry Operator was included in the 5 Pay scale and
accordingly the pay band of the Petitioner was determined between 4000-
100-6000.
iii. On 13 January 2001, Respondent No.1 issued a letter to the
Petitioner intimating him of his confirmation on the said post with effect
th
from 7 June 1995.
th
iv. Thereafter, on 27 June 2001, a letter was issued by the
Department of Higher and Technical Education, which showed that the pay
scale of Rs 9300-34800 with a grade pay of Rs. 4300 had been provided to
the position of the Data Entry Operator at North Maharashtra University,
th
Jalgaon. A resolution dated 5 August 2005 was passed by the Management
of Respondent No. 1-University, through which the employees appointed
from the university funds were to be given salary at par with the employees
th
working on the sanctioned post of the Government. Further, on 17 October
2006, Respondent No. 1-University, by a letter of even date, awarded the
benefits of the Time Bound Promotion Scheme to the Petitioner with effect
th
from 7 June 2005, after completion of 12 years service in Respondent No.
1-University. It is the Petitioner’s contention that the Petitioner was also
supposed to receive the second benefit of the Assured Career Progression
Page 4 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
Scheme (scheme of promotion/next pay band), but the same was not given to
the Petitioner, and the said benefit was there, up to the date of his retirement.
th
v. On 30 January 2019, a Gazette Notification was issued by the
Finance Department of the State of Maharashtra, which showed the pay scale
for the position of Data Entry Operator under the Maharashtra Public State
Commission (MPSC) as Rs.9300-34800 with grade of Rs. 4300.
vi. The Petitioner retired from the service of Respondent No. 1-
st
University on 31 December 2022 due to superannuation. After his
retirement, the Petitioner was also supposed to receive benefits such as
gratuity, earned leave encashment, and interest due on Provident Fund. It is
the contention of the Petitioner that, however, the said amount was not paid
to him. Therefore, in respect thereof, the Petitioner enquired/approached
Respondent No. 1-University, to provide him with a clarification regarding
the same.
th
vii. On 17 April 2023, Respondent No. 1-University issued a letter
to the Petitioner and informed him that there was an error in his pay fixation
th
as per the 6 Pay Commission, and therefore, there is a recovery to the tune
of Rs. 39,94,343/- from him. The letter also stated that Respondent No. 1-
University would take suitable action for the said recovery. The Petitioner
thereafter was informed verbally that he would not be paid gratuity and
earned leave encashment unless he repaid the aforesaid amount, which was
given to him as excess payment. Respondent No. 1-University also issued to
Page 5 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
th
the Petitioner a pay revision chart showing that his pay scale under the 6
Pay Commission ought to have been Rs.5200-20200 with grade pay of Rs.
2400 instead of Rs. 9300-34800 with grade of pay of Rs. 4300.
th st
viii. Between 8 May 2023 and 21 August 2023, the Petitioner
addressed number of letters to Respondent No. 1-University and submitted
that he had never demanded any pay scale, and that his salary was fixed by
Respondent No. 1-University, and now since he had retired, it would not be
possible for him to return the said amount which Respondent No. 1-
University had claimed had been paid in excess towards the salary. He further
requested Respondent No. 1-University to release the dues which had not
been paid to him yet. However, Respondent No. 1-University has not replied
to any of the aforesaid letters of the Petitioner, and it is the Petitioner’s
contention that the said amount still remains unpaid.
ix. As the Petitioner had not received any reply from Respondent
th
No. 1-University, the Petitioner once again issued a reminder letter on 11
September 2023 with a copy to the Governor of Maharashtra/ Chancellor of
Respondent No. 1-University, Minister of Higher and Technical Education
Department and the Secretary of Higher Education, Pune to the effect that
the retiral dues of the Petitioner be returned to him. It is the Petitioner’s
st
contention that he has retired from his services from 31 December 2022,
but except his Provident Fund, he has not received any of his post-retiral
Page 6 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
th
benefits such as gratuity, earned leave encashment, arrears of 7 Pay
Commission, and accrued interest of Provident Fund amount.
x. It is in the backdrop of the aforesaid facts that we proceed to
th
decide the present petition, as to whether the letter dated 17 April 2023
issued by Respondent No. 1-University to the Petitioner seeking to recover
an amount of Rs. 39,94,343/- as excess payment of salary, which was paid to
him allegedly by mistake, is a correct position which has been taken by
Respondent No. 1-University.
4. Learned counsel Mr. Vaibhav Kulkarni, along with Mr.
Prathamaesh Deshpande and Ms. Disha Rathod appeared on behalf of the
Petitioner, Mr. Rajendra Anbhule along with Ms. Vaibhavi Shelar appeared
for Respondent No. 1-University, and Mr. P.P. Kakade Addl. GP along with
Ms. Priyanka B. Chavan AGP appeared on behalf of the State.
5. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner, at the very outset, has
submitted that the facts of the present case are squarely covered by the
decision of the Supreme Court in the case of State of Punjab and others v/s.
1
Rafiq Masih and Ors. , wherein it has been held that insofar as Class-III and
Class-IV employees are concerned, even where the payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer in excess of their entitlement, yet in
those cases recoveries by the employers from such employees would be
impermissible in law. He has further submitted that a Co-ordinate bench of
1 2015(4) SCC 334
Page 7 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
this Court in the case of Anil Pralhad Dhande v/s The State of Maharashtra
2
and Ors. has followed the view taken by the Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih
(supra), and in view thereof, the present matter also, on similar facts, stands
covered by the aforesaid decisions. He has further submitted that in the
present case also the Petitioner was also a Class III employee, and applying
the principles as enunciated in the case of Rafiq Masih (supra), Respondent
No. 1-University would not be correct in recovering the post-retiral benefits
from the Petitioner.
6. It is the contention of learned Counsel for the Petitioner that the
st
Petitioner had already retired from his services on 31 December 2022, and
Respondent No. 1-University had not paid him any of the post-retiral
benefits, except his provident fund. The services of the Petitioner are non-
pensionable, and his post-retiral benefits are the only source of income which
the Petitioner has, and Respondent No. 1-University by seeking the alleged
excess amount of Rs. 39,94,343/-, has, in that sense, trampled upon the
Petitioner’s only source of income. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner
submits that in fact, the Petitioner had addressed several letters to
Respondent No. 1-University, but till date, there has been no reply from
Respondent No. 1-University in respect of the alleged erroneous and excess
payment which Respondent No. 1-University contends has been made to the
Petitioner.
2 Writ Petition No. 13029 of 2022
Page 8 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
7. Per contra , learned counsel for Respondent No. 1-University Mr
Anbhule seeks to place reliance on the affidavit-in-reply filed by Dr. Prasad
Vishnu Kulkarni on behalf of Respondent No. 1-University to contend that
the action taken by Respondent No. 1-University showing recovery against
the Petitioner was the correct action. He has sought to place reliance on the
nd
fact that on 22 July 1993, the Petitioner came to be appointed on the post
of Data Entry Operator, Class-III on a temporary basis, and he joined the
University on the said date. Thereafter, as per advertisement No.
st
149/151/1993 and subsequent interview held on 1 September 1994, the
th
Petitioner by letter from Respondent No. 1-University dated 26 September
1994 came to be appointed on the post of Data Entry Operator, Class-III
under the university fund on the pay band of Rs. 1200-30-1560-EB-40-240.
th
Thereafter, a Government Notification dated 4 February 1999 was issued,
th
wherein the post of Data Entry Operator was included in the 5 Pay Scale,
and the pay band of the Petitioner was 4000-100-6000. The Petitioner came
th
to be confirmed by letter dated 7 June 1995 on the post of Data Entry
Operator created from the university funds, and a Time Bound Promotion
th
was given to the Petitioner on 7 June 2005. He also submitted that the
appointment of the Petitioner was from the funds of Respondent No. 1-
th
University, and as per Resolution No. M:158-05 dated 5 August 2005
passed by the management of Respondent No. 1-University, the employees
appointed from the university funds were to be given salary at par with the
employees working on the sanctioned post of the Government. Thereafter,
Page 9 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
th th
by the Government Notification dated 7 October 2009, the 6 Pay
Commission came be to be implemented in Respondent No. 1-University,
and in the said notification, for the post of Data Entry Operator at serial
number 134, the pay band was fixed at PB-2,9300-34800 with Grade Pay
Rs. 4300. He therefore contended that since the appointment of the
th
Petitioner was made on pay band of Rs. 1200-30-1560-EB-40-240 by 5
Pay scale, PB Rs. 4000-100-6000 was given to the Petitioner. In view of that,
th
as per the 6 Pay Commission, the PB 15200-20200 grade pay 2400 was
required to be given to the Petitioner, but by mistake PB-2,9300-34800
Grade Pay 4300 was made applicable to the Petitioner, and in view thereof,
the excess salary of Rs. 37,085,83/- was paid to the Petitioner, which
Respondent No. 1-University has now sought to recover from the Petitioner.
th
He further submitted that while applying the 6 Pay Commission, the
Petitioner had given an undertaking to the effect that if any excess payment
may be found to be made as a result of incorrect fixation of pay for any excess
payment detected in light of discrepancies noticed subsequently, he would
refund the said amount to the Government either by adjustment for future
payment, or otherwise. The relevant paragraphs of affidavit filed by Dr.
Prasad are reproduced below:-
5. I say that by letter dated 22/07/1993 issued by the respondent University
the petitioner came to be appointed on the post of Date Entry Operator
(Class-3) on temporary basis and he joined the service of the respondent
University. As per Advertisement No. 149/151/1993 and subsequent
interview held on 01/09/1994, the petitioner by letter dated 26/06/1994
came to be appointed on the post of Date Entry Operator (Class 3) under the
University fund on the pay band of 1200-30-1560-EB-40-240.
Page 10 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
6. I say that as per the Government Notification dated 04/02/1999, the post
of Data Entry Operator was included in Fifth Pay Scale and the Pay band of
Petitioner was 4000-100-6000. The petitioner came to be confirmed by
letter dated 07/06/1995 on the post of Data Entry Operator, created from
University fund. Time bound promotion was also given to the petitioner on
07/06/2005.
7. I say that the appointment of the petitioner was from the funds of the
University. As per the Resolution No. M:158/05, dated 05/08/2005 passed
by the Management of the Respondent University, the employees appointed
from the University funds are given salary in par with the employees working
on sanctioned post of the Government.
8. I say that as per Government Notification dated 07/10/2009, the Sixth
Pay Commission came to be implemented in the respondent University. In
the said Notification, at serial no.134 the post of Data Entry Operation is
given pay band of PB-2, 9300-34800 Grade Pay 4300.
9. I say that as the appointment of the petitioner was made on the pay band
of 1200-30-1560-EB-40-240, by Fifth Pay Scale (04/02/1999) the Pay band
of 4000-100-6000 was given to the petitioner. In view of this, as per Sixth
pay Commission, PB-1, 5200-20200 Grade Pay 2400 was required to be
given to the petitioner. But, by mistake PB-2, 9300-34800 Grade Pay 4300
is made applicable to the petitioner. It is seen that, while applying the Sixth
Pay Commission to the petitioner, the pay scale of PB-2, 9300-34800 Grade
Pay 4300 has been given wrongly to the petitioner. As a result of this, by way
of salary, an amount of Rs. 37,85,083/- has been paid in excess to the
petitioner.
10. I say that while applying Sixth pay Commission to the Petitioner, the
Petitioner has given undertaking to the effect that any excess payment that
may be found to have been made as a result of incorrect fixation of pay for
any excess payment detected in the light of discrepancies noticed
subsequently Will be refunded by him to the government either by
adjustment against future payments due to him or otherwise.The copy of the
undertaking given by the petitioner is annexed to the affidavit at "Exhibit-A".
8. Learned Counsel for the Respondents also relied upon the
additional affidavit-in-reply filed by Dr. Prasad Vishnu Kulkarni, wherein in
it was once again reiterated that the payment of excess salary was made
erroneously to the Petitioner, and in fact, the Petitioner had misled the Court
by citing the schedule indicating the designation of Data Entry Operator
(Grade I-Bioinformatics) with regard to the existing and revised pay scale of
th
the Maharashtra Government Notification dated 7 October 2009. He
Page 11 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
submitted that in fact, the Petitioner’s designation is of Data Entry Operator
th
(Grade-III) at serial No. 252 of the Government Notification dated 7
October 2009, wherein the existing pay scale of Rs. 4000-6000 and revised
pay structure Rs. 5200-20200 with Grade Pay 2400 is what is payable to the
Petitioner. He therefore submitted that the Petitioner has deliberately
concealed/suppressed the facts by not attaching the complete Government
th
Notification dated 7 October 2009, and therefore the petition is liable to be
dismissed and does not deserve any consideration. The relevant paragraphs
th
of the additional affidavit dated 11 December 2024 are reproduced below:-
5. I say that by letter dated 22/07/1993 issued by the respondent University
the petitioner came to be appointed on the post of Date Entry Operator
(Class-3) on temporary basis and he joined the service of the respondent
University. As per Advertisement No. 149/151/1993 and subsequent
interview held on 01/09/1994, the petitioner by letter dated 26/06/1994.
came to be appointed on the post of Date Entry Operator (Class 3) under the
University fund on the pay band of 1200-30-1560-EB-40-240. 7" October,
2009
6. I say that the Petitioner has vehemently misled the Honourable Court by
citing the schedule indicating the scale for the Designation of Data Entry
Operator (Grade I - Bioinformatics) with regard to the existing and revised
pay structure in serial no. 134 of the Maharashtra Government Notification
of 7" October, 2009.
7. I say that the Petitioner's designation is of Data Entry Operator (Grade -
III of the serial no 252 of the Maharashtra Government Notification of T'
October, 2009 where it mentions the existing Pay scale 4000 - 6000 and
revised pay structure 5200 - 20200 Grade Pay 2400 to which the Petitioner
th
belongs. The copy of the Government notification dated 7 October, 2009 is
annexed to this Affidavit as Exhibit A
8. I say that, inadvertently and by mistake PB- 2, 9300 - 34800Grade Pay
4300 was made applicable to the Petitioner to which he doesn't belong.
th
9. I say that, as per the Government Notification of 7 October, 2009 issued
by Government of Maharashtra the Data entry Operator varies from
Department to department and also the pay scale differs at the Respondent
University hence the pay scale of the Petitioner is different from the pay scale
of the Data Operator (Bioinformatics)
Page 12 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
10. I say that the Petitioner deliberately concealed/ suppressed the facts by
not attaching the complete Maharashtra Government Notification of 7"
October, 2009 disclosing the schedules..
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
9. We have heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the
papers and proceedings with their assistance. At the very outset, this Court
has passed several orders in the present petition, and in one of the said orders
it has been categorically recorded by the Co-ordinate bench of this Court
that, they were of the prima facie view that the facts of the present case are
covered by the decision of the Supreme Court in Syed Abdul Qadir v/s State
3
of Bihar and others and in the case of Rafiq Masih (supra). The Co-ordinate
bench of this Court also directed the Respondent No. 1-University to deposit
the entire retiral dues of the Petitioner in this Court, including gratuity
th
amount on or before 14 November 2024, pending the final disposal of the
th
aforesaid Petition by order dated 16 October 2024. Pursuant to the
aforesaid order, Respondent No. 1-University had deposited Demand Draft
th
(DD) No. 187828 dated 11 November 2024 amounting to Rs. 7,36,164/-
drawn from Bank of Maharashtra, Pune University Campus Branch and DD
th
No. 187829 dated 11 November 2024 amounting to Rs. 3,16,387/- drawn
from Bank of Maharashtra, Pune University Campus Branch with this Court.
th
The relevant order of the Co-ordinate bench of this Court dated 16 October
2024 is reproduced below:-
1. The Petitioner was working in Class III category as a Data Entry
Operator. He joined service on 7" June, 1993. During his service tenure, he
was found to be entitled for the pay commission recommendations and
3 2009(3) SCC 475
Page 13 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
accordingly, he was extended the monetary benefits as per the Sixth Pay
th
Commission recommendations from 7 October, 2009. He superannuated
on 31" December, 2022.
2. Since the retiral benefits have not been paid to him approached the
Employer University for release of the benefits. It thereafter that the Deputy
Registrar addressed a letter dated 17" April, 2023, to the Petitioner,
informing him that the benefits he was receiving from 1" January, 2006 were
accidentally paid though he was not entitled to it and a recovery of Rs.
39,94,343/- is to be made from the Petitioner's retiral dues.
3. Prima facie, the law laid down in Syed Abdul Qadir vs. State of Bihar
and others, 2009 (3) SCC 475 and State of Punjab and other vs. Rafiq Mash
(White Washer) etc., (2015) 4 SCC 334 = AIR 2015 SC 696, would be
applicable.
4. Issue notice to the Respondents, returnable on 21st November, 2024.
The learned Advocate Mr. Anbhule waives service of notice on behalf of
Respondent No.1. The learned AGP waives service of notice on behalf of
Respondent Nos. 2 to 4.
5. The learned Advocate for Respondent No.1- University desires to file an
affidavit-in -reply. Let such affidavit in reply be filed, on or before 13"
November, 2024.
6. In the meanwhile, considering the law laid down in Syed Abdul Qadir
and Rafig Mash (White Washer) (supra), the University would deposit the
entire retiral dues of the Petitioner in this Court, including gratuity amount,
on or before, 14th November, 2024.
10. Considering the facts of the present case, and also the orders
passed by the Co-ordinate bench of this Court as reproduced above, and on
perusal of the decision of the Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih (supra), we are
of the considered view that the facts in the present case get squarely covered
by the decision in Rafiq Masih (supra). We come to this conclusion
considering that the Petitioner in the present case was also a Class III
employee, and insofar as the contention of Respondent No. 1-University is
concerned, that the Petitioner had given an undertaking during the
th
application of the 6 Pay Commission that he would refund the amount to
the Respondent No. 1-University in the event there were any discrepancies
or mistakes while calculating the said amount, the same would not come in
Page 14 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
the way of the Petitioner’s case, inasmuch as the decision in case of Rafiq
Masih (supra) categorically lays down the law that insofar as recovery from
employees belonging to Class III and Class IV service is concerned, the same
is impermissible in law, and even if it has been mistakenly been made by the
employees. Considering the clear position of law as set out in the case of
Rafiq Masih (supra), we do not see as to how the facts of the present case can
be differentiated and the guidelines as laid down by the Supreme Court in
Rafiq Masih (supra) would not be applicable to the present case. The relevant
paragraphs of the decision of Rafiq Masih (supra) are reproduced below:-
7. Having examined a number of judgments rendered by this Court, we are of
the view, that orders passed by the employer seeking recovery of monetary
benefits wrongly extended to the employees, can only be interfered with, in
cases where such recovery would result in a hardship of a nature, which would
far outweigh, the equitable balance of the employer's right to recover. In other
words, interference would be called for, only in such cases where, it would be
iniquitous to recover the payment made. In order to ascertain the parameters
of the above consideration, and the test to be applied, reference needs to be
made to situations when this Court exempted employees from such recovery,
even in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution of
India. Repeated exercise of such power, "for doing complete justice in any
cause" would establish that the recovery being effected was iniquitous, and
therefore, arbitrary. And accordingly, the interference at the hands of this
Court.
8. As between two parties, if a determination is rendered in favour of the
party, which is the weaker of the two, without any serious detriment to the
other (which is truly a welfare State), the issue resolved would be in
consonance with the concept of justice, which is assured to the citizens of
India, even in the Preamble of the Constitution of India. The right to recover
being pursued by the employer, will have to be compared, with the effect of
the recovery on the employee concerned. If the effect of the recovery from the
employee concerned would be, more unfair, more wrongful, more improper,
and more unwarranted, than the corresponding right of the employer to
recover the amount, then it would be iniquitous and arbitrary, to effect the
recovery. In such a situation, the employee's right would outbalance, and
therefore eclipse, the right of the employer to recover.
9. The doctrine of equality is a dynamic and evolving concept having many
dimensions. The embodiment of the doctrine of equality can be found in
Articles 14 to 18 contained in Part Ill of the Constitution of India, dealing
with "fundamental rights". These articles of the Constitution, besides assuring
Page 15 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
equality before the law and equal protection of the laws, also disallow
discrimination with the object of achieving equality, in matters of
employment; abolish untouchability, to upgrade the social status of an
ostracised section of the society; and extinguish titles, to scale down the status
of a section of the society, with such appellations. The embodiment of the
doctrine of equality, can also be found in Articles 38, 39, 39-A, 43 and 46
contained in Part IV of the Constitution of India, dealing with the "directive
principles of State policy". These articles of the Constitution of India contain
a mandate to the State requiring it to assure a social order providing justice—
social, economic and political, by inter alia minimising monetary inequalities,
and by securing the right to adequate means of livelihood, and by providing
for adequate wages so as to ensure, an appropriate standard of life, and by
promoting economic interests of the weaker sections.
10. In view of the aforestated constitutional mandate, equity and good
conscience in the matter of livelihood of the people of this country has to be
the basis of all governmental actions. An action of the State, ordering a
recovery from an employee, would be in order, so long as it is not rendered
iniquitous to the extent that the action of recovery would be more unfair,
more wrongful, more improper, and more unwarranted, than the
corresponding right of the employer, to recover the amount. Or in other
words, till such time as the recovery would have a harsh and arbitrary effect
on the employee, it would be permissible in law. Orders passed in given
situations repeatedly, even in exercise of the power vested in this Court under
Article 142 of the Constitution of India, will disclose the parameters of the
realm of an action of recovery (of an excess amount paid to an employee)
which would breach the obligations of the State, to citizens of this country,
and render the action arbitrary, and therefore, violative of the mandate
contained in Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
…
18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship which would
govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have mistakenly
been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as a ready reference,
summarise the following few situations, wherein recoveries by the employers,
would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and Class IV service
(or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees who are due to
retire within one year, of the order of recovery
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment has been made
for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been required to
discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even though
he should have rightfully been required to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the conclusion, that recovery
if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such
Page 16 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of the employer's right
to recover.
10. We are also in agreement with the submission made on behalf of
the learned Counsel for the Petitioner that the Co-ordinate bench of this
Court in the case of Anil Pralhad Dhande (supra) has also applied the
principles/guidelines as set out in the Rafiq Masih (supra) to hold that any
retiral benefits which are sought to be taken from a Class III employee cannot
be taken, inasmuch as the Petitioner therein, fell in the categories (i) and (ii)
of the guidelines as laid down in the case of Rafiq Masih (supra). The
relevant paragraphs of the order of the Co-ordinate bench of this Court in
the case Anil Pralhad Dhande (supra) are reproduced below:-
4. Learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the Petitioner retired as Class-
III/Group ‘C’ employee and the recovery order is issued after his retirement and
therefore, the same is directly in contravention of law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of State of Punjab and others v/s. Rafiq Masih (White
Washer) and Ors. 1 . He submitted that this Judgment is recently followed by this
Hon’ble Court in a Group of petitions under its order dated 27 March 2023 passed
in Writ Petition No. 14575 of 2018 and others. Relying on the said judgment, the
Petitioner prayed for quashing and setting aside the impugned orders.
5. The learned counsel for the Respondent/Zilla Parishad relying on the Reply
Affidavit filed by the Zilla Parishad, contended that the Petitioner has given
undertaking and consent to the office of the Zilla Parishad that he is liable to pay
back any excess amount of pension if paid to him and therefore has no case.
Respondent / Zilla Parishad has justified the impugned orders relying on judgment
of High court of Punjab and Haryana and Ors. v/s. Jagdev Singh 2 .
6. We have considered rival submissions. The Respondent/Zilla Parishad has not
disputed that the Petitioner is a Class-III employee and that the first impugned
order is passed after his retirement. In that view of the matter, the present case is
squarely covered by the Judgment of Rafiq Masih (supra). The Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the said case has laid down following parameters.
“"18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship which would govern
employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have mistakenly been made by
the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the
decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as a ready reference, summarise the
following few situations, wherein recoveries by the employers, would be
impermissible in law:
Page 17 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-IlI and Class-IV service (or Group
C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due to retire within
one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess payment has been made for a
period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been required to
discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even though he
should have rightfully been required to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the conclusion, that recovery if
made from the employees, would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of the employers right to
recovery.”
7. The Petitioner squarely falls in categories (i) and (ii) above. It is important to
note that in the Jagdev Singh’s case (supra), the judgment relied by the
Respondent/Zilla Parishad, the recovery was claimed from Class-I officer who was
a Judicial Officer to whom, revised pay scale was granted after he furnished an
undertaking and the recovery was initiated. The present case is clearly
distinguishable on the ground that, the Petitioner is Class-III employee and not
Class-I employee undisputedly. Also, it is not disputed before us that in earlier
pension payment order dated 13 June 2019, there was no reference to excess
amount recoverable from the Petitioner. This order is produced on record.
th
11. We are also of the view that the letter dated 17 April 2023 in the
present case seeking to recover the alleged excess amount from the Petitioner
st
has been issued post the retirement of the Petitioner, i.e., on 31 December
2022. This, to our mind, also strengthens the case of the Petitioner that an
amount which has already been paid to the Petitioner cannot now be
recovered from the Petitioner on the ground of a mistake on the part of the
employer. Further, it is not disputed before us that the Petitioner is a Class III
employee, and hence the decisions in Rafiq Masih (supra) and Anil Pralhad
Dhande (supra) would completely cover the facts of the present case. Even
otherwise for recovery of such amounts even a civil suit was hopelessly time
barred.
Page 18 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
12. Insofar as the reliance by learned Counsel on behalf of the
Respondent No. 1-University on the case of High Court of Punjab and
4
Haryana v. Jagdev Singh is concerned, the same is distinguishable from the
facts of the present case, inasmuch, as in the said case the recovery was
claimed from a Class I officer, who was a judicial officer, and to whom a
revised pay scale was granted after he furnished an undertaking and recovery
was initiated. In the facts of the present case, it is an undisputed fact that the
Petitioner is a Class III employee and not a Class I employee, and therefore,
the decision in Jagdev Singh (supra) as sought to be relied on by learned
Counsel for Respondent No. 1-University would not be applicable to the
facts of the present case. Insofar as the case of Mandeep Singh Kohli and
5
Others v. Union of India is concerned, the same is distinguishable from the
facts of the present case, inasmuch as the Petitioners therein had themselves
challenged the classification of Data Entry Operators under the pay scale of
Rs. 11500-1500 before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT),
subsequent to which the CAT had directed the Respondents therein to
examine whether similarly situated employees had been granted a higher pay
scale on the basis of any order of a Court. Pursuant to the same, the
Respondents had provided the Petitioners with the pay scale of Rs. 1350-
2200, after taking undertakings from each Petitioner that if they were found
disentitled for the pay scale in the future, the dues thereof could be recovered
from their pay and allowances, including retiral benefits. The undertakings
4 (2016) 14 SCC 267
5 2021 (1) Mh.L.J. 370
Page 19 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
were therefore taken in view of the pendency of the issue of the pay scale
applicable to the Petitioners therein. Thereafter, an order was passed by the
Supreme Court, through which the Petitioners were held disentitled for the
higher pay scale. However, in the present case, the Petitioner was paid salary
under the pay scale of Rs. 9300-34800 with Grade Pay of Rs. 4300 merely
due to an alleged mistake by the Respondent Authorities. Further, in the case
of Mandeep Singh Kohli (supra), the Petitioners therein were held disentitled
for the higher pay scale after a period of merely 20 months, whereas in the
present case the Petitioner was informed that he was disentitled for the pay
scale of Rs. 9300-34800 with Grade Pay of Rs. 4300 only after his
st
retirement on 31 December 2022, after a lapse of considerable amount of
time.
13. Considering the aforesaid factual and legal backdrop, we are of
the opinion that it would be illegal and arbitrary to recover the amount of
Rs.39,94,343/- from the Petitioner’s retiral benefits, more so when the
Petitioner is a Class III employee. In view thereof, we are of the view that this
Writ Petition deserves to succeed, and the illegal recovery made by
Respondent No. 1-University deserves to be set aside. We therefore pass the
following order which will meet the ends of justice:-
ORDER
th
i) Letter/notice dated 17 April 2023 issued to the
Petitioner by Respondent No. 1-University is hereby quashed
and set aside to the extent it directs recovery from the Petitioner.
Page 20 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11

15-WP 14168-24.DOC
The amount, if recovered from the Petitioner under the
th
letter/notice dated 17 April 2023, be refunded to the Petitioner
within a period of three months from the date of uploading of
this order.
ii) Respondent No. 1-University is directed to pay to the
Petitioner all the post-retiral benefits, including the benefits of
the Assured Career Progression Scheme from June 2017, along
with arrears and appropriate interest, and further, pay the
accumulated leave encashment and the interest accrued on the
Provident Fund to the Petitioner.
iii) Respondent No. 1-University is directed to implement
th st
the 7 Pay Commission qua the Petitioner w.e.f. 1 June 2016,
based on existing pay scale, i.e., Rs. 9300-34800 with Grade Pay
Rs. 4300 (after awarding the benefits of Assured Career
Progression Scheme-24 years’ continuous service).
iv) These directions be complied by Respondent No.1-
University within a period of three months from the date of
uploading of this order.
v) Rule is made absolute in the above terms. Writ Petition is
disposed of. No costs.
( AARTI SATHE , J.) (G. S. KULKARNI, J.)
Page 21 of 21
Mane
Uploaded on - 11/09/2026 Downloaded on - 11/09/2026 20:02:11
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)