Kushagra Mittal Minor & Anr. vs National Testing Agency & Ors.

Court
Delhi High Court

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment Reserved on: 13.08.2026
% Judgment Delivered on: 18.08.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010373612026
+ LPA 632/2026, CM APPL. 53779/2026, CM APPL. 53780/2026 &
CM APPL. 53781/2026
KUSHAGRA MITTAL MINOR & ANR. .....Appellants
Versus
NATIONAL TESTING AGENCY & ORS. .....Respondents
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Appellants : Mr. Nitiin Soni, Ms. Puja B. Soni &
Mr. Deepjyot Singh, Advocates.
For the Respondents : Mr. Sanjay Khanna, Standing
Counsel with Ms. Pragya Bhushan,
Ms. Jaya Choudhary, Ms. Meemansa
Dixit, Mr. Naman Dwivedi & Mr.
Saurabh Pandey, Advocates for
Respondent No.1/NTA.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
JUDGMENT
TEJAS KARIA, J.
INTRODUCTION
1. This is an intra court Appeal filed by the Appellants against the
judgment dated 11.08.2026 (“ Impugned Judgment ”) passed by the learned
LPA 632/2026 Page 1 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

Single Judge in W.P.(C) 10274/2026 (“ Writ Petition ”) whereby the learned
Single Judge dismissed the Writ Petition filed by the Appellants.
FACTUAL MATRIX:
2. The factual matrix leading to the filing of the present Appeal is as under:
2.1. Appellant No. 1 appeared in the National Eligibility- cum -Entrance
Test-Undergraduate, 2026 (“ NEET-UG 2026 ”), conducted by
Respondent No. 1, the National Testing Agency (“ NTA ”), on
21.06.2026.
2.2. NEET-UG 2026 contained Question No. 150 in the Biology Section
(“ Q150 ”), which read as follows:
“ 150. Which of the following statements about the reabsorption
process in Henle’s loop are correct?
(a) The descending limb of Henle’s loop is permeable to water but
almost impermeable to electrolytes.
(b) Urine gets concentrated in Henle’s loop.
(c) Reabsorption of Na+ and water takes place in Henle’s loop.
(d) Active or passive transport of electrolytes occurs in the ascending
limb of Henle’s loop.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
(1) (b), (c) and (d) only
(2) (a), (b) and (c) only
(3) (a), (b) and (d) only
(4) (a) and (b) only ”
2.3. The NTA published the provisional answer key for NEET-UG 2026 on
25.06.2026 (“ Provisional Answer Key ”), which provided Option No.
3 to Q150 (“ Option No. 3 ”) as the correct answer. However, Appellant
No. 1 had selected Option No. 2 as the answer to Q150.
LPA 632/2026 Page 2 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

2.4. Appellant No. 1 challenged the answer to Q150 as indicated in the
Provisional Answer Key. In support, Appellant No. 1 placed reliance
on relevant scientific material, the prescribed material of the National
Council of Educational Research and Training (“ NCERT ”), and
standard medical textbooks, to demonstrate the correctness of the
answer selected by Appellant No. 1.
2.5. Thereafter, the NTA released the final answer key (“ Final Answer
Key ”), retaining the answer indicated in the Provisional Answer Key
in respect of Q150. The result of NEET-UG 2026 was declared on
16.07.2026 (“ Result ”), wherein Appellant No. 1 secured 695 out of 720
marks and obtained All India Rank 65.
2.6. Being aggrieved by the Result, the Appellants filed the Writ Petition,
in which the NTA filed a counter affidavit dated 07.08.2026 (“ Counter
Affidavit ”), stating that the objections received had been placed before,
and considered by the subject experts.
2.7. Vide the Impugned Judgment, the learned Single Judge disposed of the
Writ Petition, inter alia , observing that the onus was upon the
Appellants to establish that there was a manifest error in the opinion
adopted by the subject experts, and that the Appellants had failed to
discharge the said onus.
2.8. Being aggrieved by the Impugned Judgment, the Appellants have
preferred the present Appeal.
LPA 632/2026 Page 3 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANTS
3. The learned Counsel for the Appellants made the following
submissions:
3.1. Appellant No. 1 is a meritorious student, who had initially appeared in
the NEET-UG Examination held on 03.05.2025 and, as per the
provisional answer key released in respect thereof, was likely to secure
a perfect score of 720 out of 720. However, the said examination was
subsequently cancelled, whereafter the NTA conducted a fresh
examination, NEET-UG 2026.
3.2. The learned Single Judge failed to appreciate the central and objective
defect in Q150 as Option No. 3 wrongly provides that Statements (a),
(b) and (d) are correct and by necessary implication, treats Statement
(c) as incorrect. Once Statement (c) is shown to be scientifically
correct, Option No. 3 cannot, either logically or scientifically, continue
to be regarded as the correct answer. If all four statements are
scientifically correct, none of the options provided by the NTA, each
of which employs the expression “ only ”, accurately represents the
complete set of scientifically correct statements.
3.3. The opinion given by Dr. Yogesh Singh, Professor, Department of
Physiology, AIIMS Rishikesh (“ Dr. Singh ”) in respect of the answer
to Q150 states that all Statements are correct.
LPA 632/2026 Page 4 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

3.4. In view of the above, there existed an alternative academic view, which
affirmatively and demonstrably established the scientific correctness
of Statement (c). The observation in the Impugned Judgment that the
Appellants’ case rested upon “ inferences / logical deductions and
applications ” is, therefore, contrary to the material placed on record
and to the principles laid down in Kanpur University v. Samir Gupta ,
(1983) 4 SCC 309, Om Prakash Verma v. National Testing Agency ,
(2024) 1 HCC (Del) 115, and Shivraj Sharma v. Consortium of
National Law Universities & Ors. , 2025 SCC OnLine Del 2589, which
recognise that a Court is not required to adopt an entirely hands-off
approach and may test a disputed key answer against standard and
prescribed textbooks.
3.5. The requirement under the Information Bulletin (“ Information
Bulletin ”) to choose “ the correct answer or the most appropriate
answer ” cannot authorise the NTA to treat as correct an option that
expressly excludes a scientifically correct statement. The issue before
the learned Single Judge was not whether Option No. 3 was marginally
more appropriate than Option No. 2 to Q150. However, the issue was
whether Option No. 3 could be regarded as scientifically correct at all
when the use of the word “ only ” necessarily treats Statement (c) as
incorrect, despite authoritative scientific material establishing the contrary.
3.6. The learned Single Judge, vide the Impugned Judgment, erred in
adopting an approach under which the availability and extent of
LPA 632/2026 Page 5 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

judicial scrutiny would depend upon whether the subject matter of the
dispute falls within the personal or professional expertise of the Court.
Such an approach creates an arbitrary and constitutionally
impermissible distinction between similarly situated litigants. The
constitutional protection guaranteed under Article 14 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 (“ Constitution ”), cannot vary according to
the academic discipline to which the dispute pertains, nor can access
to effective judicial review depend upon the personal subject-matter
expertise of the Judge.
3.7. Reliance was placed on Sumit Kumar v. High Court of Delhi , 2016
SCC OnLine Del 2818, Anjali Goswami v. Registrar General, Delhi
High Court , 2019 SCC OnLine Del 7132, Rishabh Duggal v.
Registrar General, Delhi High Court , 2024 SCC OnLine Del 1916,
and The Commissioner of Police and Anr. v. Amit Gulia and Ors. ,
Neutral Citation- 2026:DHC:1760-DB, to submit that where an
objective question admits of more than one correct or equally
appropriate answer, or where the options fail properly to accommodate
the correct answer, a candidate cannot be prejudiced merely because
the examining authority intended another answer to be treated as the
most appropriate one.
3.8. Once the learned Single Judge observed that, owing to “ limited
knowledge ”, the learned Single Judge was “ not in a position to analyse
the material provided by the petitioner ”, the learned Single Judge
LPA 632/2026 Page 6 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

could not thereafter have concluded that the very material relied upon
by the Appellants was insufficient to establish an error in the NTA’s
answer and involved merely “ inferences/logical deductions ”.
3.9. In the Writ Petition, the learned Single Judge was not called upon to
substitute a judicial opinion on Biology for the opinion of subject
experts. The limited prayer was that, if upon consideration of the
scientific material placed on record the learned Single Judge was
unable to determine the scientific issue for want of subject expertise,
the disputed question could be referred to an independent expert body
for its opinion. However, the learned Single Judge accorded
determinative weight to the NTA’s assertion that Appellant No. 1’s
objection had been considered by its subject experts, although the
correctness of that very expert determination constituted the subject
matter of challenge in the Writ Petition.
3.10. The learned Single Judge erred in distinguishing Vanshika Yadav v.
Union of India , (2024) 10 SCC 641, merely on the ground that the
NTA had, in that case, accepted two options as correct, and Shaureen
Shamik Ambatkar v. Union of India , 2024 SCC OnLine Bom 4577,
merely by reference to the nature of the defects alleged therein. The
said authorities were relied upon by the Appellants to submit that
where a challenge to an answer key turns upon a specialised scientific
determination beyond the Court’s expertise, the Court may seek the
opinion of independent subject experts. Whether the examining
LPA 632/2026 Page 7 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

authority has itself acknowledged competing correct answers, or
continues to defend its answer key, has no bearing on the power of the
Court to obtain such independent assistance.
3.11. The principle of judicial deference to academic experts cannot be
elevated into an irrebuttable presumption in favour of experts engaged
by the examining authority itself, particularly where authoritative
scientific material to the contrary is placed before the Court. Reliance
was placed on Aditya Singh (Minor) v. Consortium of National Law
Universities , 2024 SCC OnLine Del 9040, to submit that prior
consideration by experts or oversight committees does not create an
absolute bar to judicial review where an answer is demonstrated to be
erroneous.
3.12. The NTA, neither at the stage of deciding Appellant No. 1’s objection
nor in the Counter Affidavit, provided any scientific analysis, reasoned
opinion, minutes, expert report, or other material addressing Appellant
No. 1’s specific objection or explaining why Statement (c) was
incorrect. Significantly, no scientific material was placed by the NTA
before the learned Single Judge to demonstrate that Statement (c),
namely, “ Reabsorption of Na+ and water takes place in Henle’s loop ”,
was scientifically incorrect.
3.13. The Appellants do not seek re-evaluation or re-checking of Appellant
No. 1’s answer sheet. The challenge in the present case is confined to
the legality and scientific correctness of the Final Answer Key.
LPA 632/2026 Page 8 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

Further, any apprehension regarding the possible effect of correction
of the Final Answer Key upon other candidates who appeared in
NEET-UG 2026 cannot constitute a ground to perpetuate an erroneous
answer to Q150, as the Court retains the power to mould relief
appropriately so as to correct an erroneous evaluation while protecting
similarly situated candidates from prejudice.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT NO. 1
4. Learned Counsel for Respondent No. 1 made the following
submissions:
4.1. The challenges to the Provisional Answer Key received from all
candidates, including the Objection raised by the Appellants, were
placed before a panel of eminent subject experts drawn from
premier institutions of national repute, including the Indian
Institutes of Technology and premier Central Universities, for their
consideration and resolution.
4.2. The Final Answer Key was thereafter prepared in accordance with
the opinion and recommendations of the respective panel of subject
experts and pursuant to their review and settlement of the challenges
placed before them, the Result was declared. It was further
submitted that a perusal of the extract from the NCERT textbook
relied upon by the Appellants would also indicate that the answers
to Q150 are debatable.
LPA 632/2026 Page 9 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

4.3. With respect to the expert opinion furnished by Dr. Singh, the
opinion of a single expert cannot be equated with the considered
opinion of multiple experts who framed the question and the
corresponding answers, evaluated the Provisional Answer Key,
considered the challenges received, and thereafter evaluated the
Final Answer Key.
4.4. The Respondents further submitted that 19,99,895 candidates
appeared in NEET-UG 2026, out of whom 11,21,185 candidates
qualified, and that Appellant No. 1 is the only candidate, who has
challenged the answer to Q150. By allowing the present challenge,
it would open the floodgates to similar challenges to the Final
Answer Key and would disrupt the entire admission process.
4.5. Reliance was placed upon the judgment of this Court in National
Board of Examination v. Association of MD Physicians , Neutral
Citation: 2022:DHC:2971-DB, to submit that the answer key must
be presumed to be correct unless it is demonstrated to be wrong, and
that it ought not to be held to be incorrect by an inferential process
of reasoning or by a process of rationalisation. Therefore, the error,
if any, must be clearly demonstrated.
4.6. The Information Bulletin expressly requires a candidate to choose
“ the correct answer or the most appropriate answer ”. Reliance was
also placed upon Ran Vijay Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh , AIR
LPA 632/2026 Page 10 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

2018 SC 52, to submit that the Court ought to presume the
correctness of the key answers and proceed on that basis, and that,
in the event of any doubt, the benefit must be given to the
examination authority rather than to the candidate.
4.7. In view of the aforesaid submissions, it was contended that no
interference with the Final Answer Key published by the NTA is
warranted.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
5. Heard the learned Counsel for the Parties and perused the material
placed on record.
6. The principal contention raised by the Appellants is that Statement (c)
in Q150, namely, “ Reabsorption of Na+ and water takes place in Henle’s
loop ”, is scientifically correct and, therefore, Option No. 3, which comprises
Statements “ (a), (b) and (d) only ”, could not have been treated as the correct
answer. Further, if all four statements are scientifically correct, none of the
options offered by the NTA, all of which use the expression “ only ”, correctly
represents the complete set of scientifically correct statements.
7. The Appellants contend that the material relied upon by the Appellants,
including the prescribed NCERT material, standard medical textbooks and
the opinion of Dr. Singh, clearly demonstrate the correctness of Statement (c)
in Q150. Accordingly, it was submitted on behalf of the Appellants that the
learned Single Judge ought to have examined the material in support of the
LPA 632/2026 Page 11 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

objections raised by the Appellants to Q150 or, alternatively, obtained an
independent expert opinion.
8. There can be no cavil with the proposition that judicial review of an
answer key is not altogether excluded merely because the answer has been
considered by subject experts. However, the error alleged must be manifest
and palpable and so evident that no reasonable body of persons well versed in
the particular subject would regard the answer as correct. It is settled law that
an answer key should be assumed to be correct unless it is proved to be wrong
and that it should not be held to be wrong by an inferential process of
reasoning or by a process of rationalisation. The burden of establishing such
an error, in the facts of the present case, is, therefore, upon the Appellants.
9. The Appellants have sought to discharge the said burden by relying
upon the prescribed NCERT material, standard medical textbooks and the
opinion of Dr. Singh. The material relied upon by the Appellants, however, is
required to be considered in the context of the law governing judicial
interference with an answer key.
10. The opinion of Dr. Singh states that all the Statements (a), (b), (c) and
(d) are correct. Therefore, the said opinion does not help the Appellants as it
makes all the answers to Q150 incorrect rather than saying that Option No. 2
selected by Appellant No. 1 was the correct answer.
11. The learned Counsel for the Appellants has also contended that the
NTA has not furnished any scientific analysis, reasoned opinion, minutes,
LPA 632/2026 Page 12 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

expert report or other material dealing with the specific objection raised by
the Appellants and explaining that Statement (c) was incorrect.
12. The said submission, in our view, does not alter the position in the
present case. The Appellants’ objection was placed before subject experts,
and the Final Answer Key was prepared after considering the same. It is
settled law that in academic matters, when no mala fides have been alleged
against the experts constituted to prepare Final Answer Key, the Courts must
leave the decisions to the academicians and experts. Evidently, in the present
case, the Appellants have not alleged any mala fides against the subject
experts. In matters of judicial review which involve examination of academic
content and award of marks, the evaluation of merits should be left to the
expertise of academics.
13. The Appellants have failed to demonstrate that a material error has been
committed in the answer prescribed by the NTA to Q150. The presumption,
therefore, operates in favour of the correctness of the Final Answer Key and
the opinion of the subject experts, and the benefit of any doubt must
accordingly go to the examination authority.
14. The Appellants submitted that the expression “ only ” in Option No. 3
proceeds on the basis that Statement (c) is incorrect and, if it found that
Statement (c) is scientifically correct, Option No. 3 would necessarily be
incorrect. However, the Appellants have failed to establish the correctness of
Statement (c) without an inferential process of reasoning or by a process of
LPA 632/2026 Page 13 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

rationalisation. The material relied upon by the Appellants requires an
inference, logical deduction and reasoning to arrive at the conclusion that
Statement (c) is correct.
15. Consequently, the submission based upon the expression “ only ” in
Option No. 3 cannot, by itself, establish that the answer prescribed by the
NTA to Q150 in the Final Answer Key is manifestly and palpably erroneous.
16. As regards the constitution of an independent expert committee, the
same is a matter of judicial discretion. In the precedents relied upon by learned
Counsel for the Appellants, such discretion was exercised having regard to
the facts and circumstances obtaining in those cases. In the present case,
however, the Appellants have failed to demonstrate a manifest and palpable
error in the answer prescribed by the NTA in the Final Answer Key, and the
conclusion sought to be established by them requires an inferential process of
reasoning and rationalisation. The objection had already been considered by
the panel of subject experts constituted by the NTA. The facts and
circumstances of the present case are, therefore, materially distinguishable
and do not warrant the exercise of such discretion.
17. In our considered view, the restraint exercised by the learned Single
Judge in declining judicial intervention in the examination process was
appropriate, having regard to the nature of the challenge raised by the
Appellants and the limited scope of judicial interference in academic matters,
LPA 632/2026 Page 14 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46

particularly where the answer in question had already been examined by
subject experts.
18. Accordingly, the Appellants have failed to discharge the burden of
demonstrating a manifest and palpable error in the answer prescribed by the
NTA to Q150 in the Final Answer Key and do not satisfy the threshold
warranting interference with the Final Answer Key evaluated by the subject
experts. We, therefore, find no infirmity with the conclusion of Impugned
Judgement declining to interfere with the Result.
19. For the aforesaid reasons, we do not find any merit in the present
Appeal. The present Appeal is, accordingly, dismissed. Pending applications,
if any, also stand disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.
TEJAS KARIA, J
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
AUGUST 18, 2026
HK
LPA 632/2026 Page 15 of 15
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
Signing Date:18.08.2026
17:09:46