Purusottam vs State Of M.P.
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
1 WP-4996-2009
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
th
ON THE 18 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No. 4996 of 2009
CNR No.: MPHC030177972009
PURUSOTTAM AND OTHERS
Versus
STATE OF M.P. AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Ashwini Johri - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Dharmendra Nayak -Govt. Advocate for the State.
None for the respondent No.5.
ORDER
The present petition, under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of
India, has been filed by the petitioner seeking following reliefs:-
"(i) That, the order dt. 02-06-2009 (Annexure P/1)
passed by the Commissioner, Chambal Division, Morena in
revision no. 42/2002-03 be set aside.
(ii) That, the order dt. 04-06-2001 passed by the
Collector, Bhind and the order of allotment of land bearing
survey no.473 measuring 0.45 hector situated at village
Chowki, Teh. & Distt. Bhind, (M.P.) in favour of petitioners
be upheld.
(iii) That, the other relief doing justice including cost
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PAWAN KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
3:42:39 PM
2 WP-4996-2009
be ordered."
The present petition, under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of
India, has been filed by the petitioners challenging the order dated
02.06.2009 (Annexure P/1) passed by the Commissioner, Chambal Division,
Morena, in Revision No.42/2002-03, whereby the revision preferred by
respondents No.5 to 8 has been allowed and the orders passed by the
Collector, Bhind, as well as the Naib Tehsildar, Circle Pipri, in respect of
settlement of land bearing Survey No.473, area 0.45 hectare, situated at
Village Chowki, Tehsil and District Bhind, in favour of the petitioners, have
been set aside.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioners, being poor
agriculturists and residents of Village Chowki, applied for settlement of the
Government land bearing Survey No.473, area 0.45 hectare, situated at
Village Chowki, pursuant to a public notice issued by the Naib Tehsildar,
Circle Pipri. The said public notice was issued on 26.07.2000 inviting
objections from the general public by 24.08.2000. It is the case of the
petitioners that the notice was duly published and pasted on the notice board
of the Tehsil Office and wide publicity was given in the village.
After registration of the proceedings, the statements of the applicants
were recorded and the report of the Patwari was obtained. Since no objection
was received within the prescribed period, the Naib Tehsildar, Circle Pipri,
vide order dated 29.09.2000, passed in Case No.32/99-2000/A-19, ordered
settlement of the aforesaid land in favour of the petitioners upon payment of
premium of Rs.1,170/-. Consequently, the necessary certificate conferring
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PAWAN KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
3:42:39 PM
3 WP-4996-2009
Bhumiswami rights was also issued in their favour.
Subsequently, the Collector, District Bhind, initiated suo motu
revisional proceedings against the aforesaid order of settlement and
registered Revision No.55/2000-01. After issuing notice to the petitioners
and considering their reply, the Collector, vide order dated 04.06.2001,
dismissed the suo motu revision, holding that no illegality had been
committed in the settlement of the disputed land in favour of the petitioners.
While arriving at the aforesaid conclusion, the Collector also considered the
relevant Khasra entries for Samvat 2052 to 2056.
Thereafter, respondents No.5 to 8 preferred Revision No.42/2002-03
before the Commissioner, Chambal Division, Morena, challenging the order
passed by the Collector. The Commissioner, vide impugned order dated
02.06.2009, allowed the revision and set aside the earlier orders passed by
the Collector and the Naib Tehsildar, thereby disturbing the settlement made
in favour of the petitioners. Being aggrieved, the petitioners have preferred
the present petition.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the impugned order
passed by the Commissioner is without jurisdiction and contrary to the
provisions of the Revenue Book Circular. It is contended that the land in
question was settled in favour of the petitioners by the Naib Tehsildar after
following the prescribed procedure and after issuance of a public notice
inviting objections. The Collector, after exercising suo motu revisional
jurisdiction and examining the relevant revenue records, had already
dismissed the revision vide order dated 04.06.2001. Thereafter, a second
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PAWAN KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
3:42:39 PM
4 WP-4996-2009
revision against the order passed by the Collector was not maintainable
before the Commissioner.
It is further submitted that respondents No.5 to 8 were neither parties
to the original settlement proceedings nor had they raised any objection
pursuant to the public notice issued by the Naib Tehsildar. They had no locus
to challenge the settlement made in favour of the petitioners. It is also
contended that the Commissioner has passed the impugned order without
properly appreciating the jurisdictional provisions contained in Clause 30 of
the Revenue Book Circular and without assigning cogent reasons for
interfering with the findings recorded by the Collector. Thus, the impugned
order deserves to be set aside.
Per contra, learned Government Advocate appearing for the
respondents/State opposed the submissions made on behalf of the petitioners
and prayed for dismissal of the present petition.
Heard.
The controversy involved in the present petition primarily relates to
the jurisdiction of the Collector to exercise suo motu revisional powers under
Clause 30 of the Revenue Book Circular on 04.06.2001 and the
consequential jurisdiction of the Commissioner to entertain a revision against
the order passed by the Collector in such proceedings.
At this stage, it would be appropriate to refer to the provisions of
Clause 30 of the Revenue Book Circular. A perusal of the said provision, as
reproduced and considered by this Court in Writ Petition No.3868 of 2006
(Vishnu Kumar and Others v. Satyanarayan Sharma and Others), decided on
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PAWAN KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
3:42:39 PM
5 WP-4996-2009
10.04.2023, makes it evident that sub-Clauses (4), (5) and (6) of Clause 30
were deleted by amendment dated 09.02.1984 and it was only sub-clause 6
which provided for suo-moto powers to the Collector. The provision
conferring suo motu revisional powers upon the State Government,
Commissioner and Collector was reintroduced only vide amendment dated
02.05.2003.
In the aforesaid decision, this Court, after considering the scheme of
Clause 30 of the Revenue Book Circular, categorically held that on the date
of passing of the order by the Collector, i.e. 23.01.2003, the Collector was
not vested with suo motu revisional powers, as the relevant provision had not
been reintroduced till then. It was further held that where the original order
of allotment was passed by the Tehsildar or Naib Tehsildar, the statutory
remedy of appeal was available before the Sub-Divisional Officer and that
the Commissioner could not had entertained a revision against an order
passed by the Collector in proceedings which were themselves without
jurisdiction.
Applying the aforesaid legal position to the facts of the present case, it
would be evident that the original order of settlement was passed by the Naib
Tehsildar, Circle Pipri, on 29.09.2000. The Collector thereafter initiated suo
motu revisional proceedings and passed the order dated 04.06.2001.
Admittedly, on the said date, the provision conferring suo motu revisional
powers upon the Collector under Clause 30(6) of the Revenue Book Circular
had already been deleted and had not been reintroduced.
Consequently, the Collector was not vested with jurisdiction to
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PAWAN KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
3:42:39 PM
6 WP-4996-2009
exercise suo motu revisional powers under the aforesaid provision on
04.06.2001. The order passed by the Collector in such proceedings,
therefore, cannot be treated as an order passed in a valid exercise of suo
motu revisional jurisdiction. Once the very foundation of the proceedings
before the Collector was without jurisdiction, the order passed therein could
not have furnished a valid basis for invoking further revisional jurisdiction
before the Commissioner.
It is also pertinent to observe that under Clause 30 of the Revenue
Book Circular, an appeal against an order of allotment passed by the
Tehsildar or Naib Tehsildar is provided before the Sub-Divisional Officer,
therefore, the Commissioner could not assume revisional jurisdiction merely
because the Collector had passed an order in proceedings initiated by him
without the requisite jurisdiction. The respondents, therefore, could not have
invoked the revisional jurisdiction of the Commissioner against such an
order of the Collector.
The aforesaid controversy is squarely covered by the decision of this
Court in Writ Petition No.3868 of 2006 (Vishnu Kumar and Others v.
Satyanarayan Sharma and Others), decided on 10.04.2023, wherein, under
identical circumstances, this Court held that when the Collector had exercised
suo motu revisional powers without there being any enabling provision under
Clause 30 of the Revenue Book Circular, the order passed by the Collector
could not have been challenged further before the Commissioner and the
Commissioner had no occasion to pass any order in respect of such
proceedings.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PAWAN KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
3:42:39 PM
7 WP-4996-2009
So far as the allegations raised by respondent No.5 in the return
regarding her earlier rights over the disputed land, non-publication of notice
and alleged irregularities in the settlement proceedings are concerned, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the impugned order passed by the
Commissioner cannot be sustained on those grounds without first
establishing the jurisdiction of the authority to entertain the revision itself.
The question of jurisdiction goes to the root of the matter and must
necessarily be examined before entering into the merits of the controversy.
Once the Commissioner lacked jurisdiction to entertain the revision arising
out of the order passed by the Collector in the aforesaid proceedings, the
impugned order cannot be sustained.
It is, however, made clear that the order dated 04.06.2001 passed by
the Collector is not being affirmed as a valid exercise of suo motu revisional
jurisdiction. The consequence of the aforesaid legal position is that the
impugned order passed by the Commissioner cannot operate to disturb the
original order of settlement dated 29.09.2000 passed by the Naib Tehsildar in
favour of the petitioners. The said settlement order, having not been lawfully
set aside in the proceedings impugned herein, shall remain undisturbed by
virtue of this order.
Accordingly, the present petition is allowed. The impugned order
dated 02.06.2009 (Annexure P/1) passed by the Commissioner, Chambal
Division, Morena, in Revision No.42/2002-03 is hereby set aside.
Consequently, the order of settlement dated 29.09.2000 passed by the Naib
Tehsildar, Circle Pipri, in favour of the petitioners shall remain undisturbed.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PAWAN KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
3:42:39 PM
8 WP-4996-2009
It is clarified that this Court has not adjudicated upon the rival claims
of title or possession raised by respondent No.5 in respect of the disputed
land on their independent merits. The parties shall be at liberty to avail such
remedy as may be available to them in accordance with law, if so advised.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, the petition stands
allowed and disposed of.
No order as to costs.
(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
pwn*
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PAWAN KUMAR
Signing time: 11/20/2026
3:42:39 PM