Surinder Pal Singh vs Sulakhan Singh And Ors
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
FAO-3801-2002
Judgment reserved on :05.11.2026
Judgment pronounced on 19.11.2026
SURINDER PAL SINGH . .. APPELLANT
VERSUS
SULAKHAN SINGH AND ORS ...RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Mr. Sudhir Paruthi, Advocate
for the appellant.
Mr. Vinod Chaudhri, Advocate
for respondent No. 6.
PARMOD GOYAL, J.
1. Present appeal has been preferred by appellant-claimant Surinder
Pal Singh for enhancement of compensation of Rs.72,971/- awarded to him vide
impugned award dated 06.02.2002 passed by learned Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Jalandhar (hereinafter referred to as ‘Tribunal’) on account of injuries
suffered by him in motor vehicular accident dated 27.09.1999 allegedly caused
by rash and negligent driving of respondent-driver while driving bus bearing
registration No.PB-06-1050 (hereinafter referred to as ‘offending vehicle’).
2. Since in the present appeal the only issue raised by the appellants-
claimants is with regard to the quantum of compensation and no appeal or cross-
objection has been preferred by any of the respondents to challenge findings of
learned Tribunal as regards to rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:58
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
FAO-3801-2002 -2-
driven by respondent-driver, therefore, the detailed facts regarding the manner
of accident are not being noticed herein for the sake of brevity.
3. In the present case, learned Tribunal had awarded the following
compensation to appellant-claimant:
Medicines expenses Rs.12,176/-
Treatment charges Rs.35,415/-
Compensation on account
of expenses incurred on
purchasing arm sling etc.
Rs.380/-
Pain and sufferings Rs.5,000/-
Permanent disability Rs.20,000/-
Total Rs.72,971/-
4. Learned counsel for appellant-claimant has sought enhancement in
compensation on the following grounds that :
● Learned Tribunal had erred in not granting compensation on
the basis of functional disability (as permanent disability is
20%);
● Learned Tribunal has erred in not taking the income of
appellant-claimant as was pleaded by the appellant-claimant;
● Future prospects were not added while determining loss of
earning capacity. Future prospects to the extent 25% of
monthly income needs to be added as appellant-claimant was
49 years of age at the time of accident.
● Multiplier was not applied by learned Tribunal;
● Compensation for loss of future prospects and future
amenities, for loss of income during treatment and for future
medical expenses has not been granted to which appellant-
claimant is entitled to; and
● Enhancement of compensation for medical expenses & other
expenses and pain and sufferings is warranted being
insufficient in view of nature of injuries, nature of treatment
and period of hospitalization.
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:58
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
FAO-3801-2002 -3-
5. Learned counsel for the appellant-claimant had claimed that on
account of accident appellant-claimant had suffered multiple injuries including
fractures. It was asserted that after the accident he was taken to Guru Teg
Bahadur Hospital and thereafter shifted to D.M College and Hospital, Ludhiana,
where he remained admitted from 27.09.1996 till 14.10.1996. During his
admission in hospital, he was operated upon. Appellant-claimant also claimed
to have incurred expenses of Rs.1,00,000/- on his treatment.
6. In order to prove nature of injury, nature of treatment and extent of
disability, appellant-claimant had examined Dr. H.L Mehmi, Orthopaedic
Surgeon, Civil hospital, Kapurthala as PW1 who had duly stated that the
appellant-claimant had suffered fracture on his right arm and elbow joint. PW-1
had stated that the appellant-claimant had suffered permanent disability to the
extent of 20% on account of fracture of right arm and proved the disability
certificate of appellant-claimant as Ex.P1. Appellant-claimant also placed on
record cash memos amounting to Rs.12,206/-with regards to the purchase of
medicine vide Ex.P6 to Ex.P54. He had also produced medical treatment receipt
issued by DMC, hospital, Ludhiana as Ex.PX. Manoj Kumar, Record keeper,
DMC Hospital, Ludhiana while appearing as PW-2 proved the discharge
certificate as Ex.P-2.
7. From the nature of injuries stated by PW1 and PW2 and extent of
disability found by board of doctors, it is clearly established that appellant-
claimant had suffered grievous injuries resulting into permanent disability
compromising his earning capacity to a great deal. The functional disability
therefore has to be determined keeping in view extent of permanent disability
along with nature of job which injured-appellant-claimant was performing prior
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:58
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
FAO-3801-2002 -4-
to the accident.
8. In present case, appellant-claimant had claimed to be aged 49 years
at the time of accident and working as an agriculturist. He claimed that he was
earning Rs.15,000/- per month. It is further claimed that appellant-claimant was
cultivating 10 acres of land on which a paddy crop, valued at Rs.70,000/- was
standing, however on account of accident, the said crop could not be harvested.
Appellant-claimant also asserted that on account of accident, he was unable to
drive the tractor and he had therefore employed a driver namely Jassa, at a
monthly salary of Rs.1,000/-. In order to prove the assertions regarding the
ownership of tractor no material/evidence/driving licence was placed on record
to show that the appellant-claimant owned a tractor. No material/evidence
regarding the ownership of agricultural land in shape of revenue record was
placed on record to prove the pleaded income and vocation of the appellant.
However, it is clearly made out that appellant-claimant who was abled body
person must be earning his livelihood. Therefore, the nature and extent of
permanent disability in view of injury of right arm and elbow joint would lead
to loss of future earning capacity and accordingly functional disability is taken
as 20%. In absence of any material/reliable to conclude income of injured, same
is taken as Rs.1,749/- per month i.e. minimum wages payable to unskilled
worker in the year 1999. Appellant-claimant was stated to be aged 49 years at
the time of accident to which there is no rebuttal. Therefore, future prospects to
the extent of 25% for the purposes of determining loss of earning capacity also
needs to be added in view of judgment passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in
National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16)
SCC 680. Multiplier of ‘13’ shall be applicable as per the age of injured in view
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:58
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
FAO-3801-2002 -5-
of judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors.
Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. , 2009(6) SCC 121.
9. Accordingly, loss of earning capacity payable to appellant-claimant
has to be determined by taking functional disability equivalent to 20% after
taking monthly income of the injured to be Rs.1,749/- , by adding future
prospects to the extent of 25% and by applying multiplier of ‘13’ .
10. Appellant-claimant was granted compensation of Rs.5,000/- for
pain and sufferings , which keeping in view nature of injuries, nature of
treatment, permanent disability, period of hospitalization is totally insufficient
and same is accordingly enhanced to Rs . 50,000 /-. Since appellant-claimant had
suffered permanent disability to the extent of 20%, he would have been deprived
of future amenities of life as well as future prospects of life, therefore, he shall
be entitled to compensation for loss of future prospects including marriage
prospects and future amenities of life which is quantified at Rs.75,000/- .
Appellant-claimant is also entitled to consolidated compensation of Rs.55,000/-
for medical expenses, transportation, special diet and attendant charges .
Appellant-claimant must have also suffered loss of income for the time he was
under treatment and keeping in view period of hospitalization and nature of
injuries, it is made out that appellant-claimant must have remained out of work
for at least 04 months. Accordingly, compensation for loss of income during
treatment is assessed as Rs . 6,996/- (Rs.1,749/- X 4). Since, appellant-claimant
had not placed any material regarding need to incur future medical treatment,
therefore, appellant-claimant is not entitled to any compensation under the head
future medical expenses.
11. Re-worked compensation payable to appellant-claimant is as
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:58
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
FAO-3801-2002 -6-
under:-
Income Rs.1,749/-
Rs.1,749/-
per month
Future prospects 25%
(Rs.1,749/- + 437)
per month
Rs.2,186/-
20% Permanent
disability
20% of Rs.2,186/- Rs.437
Multiplier 13 13
Total loss of earning
capacity
Rs.437/- X 13 X 12 Rs.68,172/-
Loss of income
during treatment
Rs.1,749/- X 4 Rs.6,996/-
Compensation for
medical expenses,
transportation,
special diet and
attendant charges
Rs.47,971/-
(by Tribunal for medical
expenses)
Rs.55,000/-
Compensation for Rs.5,000/- Rs.50,000/-
pain and sufferings (by Tribunal)
Compensation for
loss of future
prospects and future
amenities of life
Rs.75,000/-
Total compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs.72,971/-
Total compensation
awarded in appeal
Rs.2,55,168/-
Enhanced Rs.2,55,168/-
compensation (awarded in appeal) -
Rs.72,971/-
(awarded by Tribunal)
Rs.1,82,197/-
12. Appellant-claimant shall also be entitled to interest over enhanced
amount to the extent of 7.5% from the date of filing of claim petition till its
realization. The liability of respondents to pay compensation shall be as per
award.
13. Present appeal is allowed in above terms.
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:58
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
FAO-3801-2002 -7-
14. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand(s) disposed
of accordingly.
19.11.2026 (PARMOD GOYAL)
manoj JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes
Whether reportable Yes/No
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:58
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document