Iqbal Singh vs State Of Punjab & Ors
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
1
CWP-14284-2013 (O&M) &
COCP-434-2022
208
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CWP-14284-2013 (O&M)
Date of Decision : 18.11.2026
IQBAL SINGH .....Petitioner
VERSUS
STATE OF PUNJAB & OTHERS ....Respondents
COCP-434-2022
IQBAL SINGH
.....Petitioner
VERSUS
Dr. AVNISH KUMAR ....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KULDEEP TIWARI
Present : Mr. D.S.Patwalia, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Rishu Bajaj, Advocate,
for the petitioner/applicant.
Mr. Sahil R. Bakshi, AAG, Punjab
KULDEEP TIWARI, J.(Oral)
CWP-14284-2013 (O&M)
1. The petitioner has approached this Court through the instant
petition, filed under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India, for
issuance of mandamus upon the respondents to re-designate him as
Senior Lecturer (Physiology) (now re-designated as Assistant Professor
Physiology), and to place him to a pay scale meant for Senior Lecturer
(now re-designated as Assistant Professor) w.e.f. 14.11.2006.
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.21 14:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2
CWP-14284-2013 (O&M) &
COCP-434-2022
2. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner, at the outset,
placed reliance upon instructions issued by the State Government on the
26.08.1991 (Annexure P-5), whereby the sanctions was accorded for 15
posts of Lecturers in medical specialities in three medical colleges in the
State, as Senior Lecturers and placed them in the scale of Rs.3,000–5,000
with immediate effect, subject to the condition that only those doctors
who possess post-graduation qualifications in their specialities will be
designated as Senior Lecturers. The said re-designation is subject to the
restrictions that the persons who were re-designated as Senior Lecturer on
account of possessing post-graduation in the speciality will not claim any
seniority over and above the Lecturers who is senior to them.
3. He further submits that the notification ( supra ) was duly
relied upon while confirming re-designation to one of the co-employees,
i.e., Dr. Aditya Jain, who is working in the Physiology Department in
which the petitioner is working, vide order dated the 11.06.2015.
4. He next submits that the Director, Research and Medical
Education, Punjab, Chandigarh, had recommended the re-designation of
the petitioner, and thereafter, no decision was taken. Thus fetching
grievances from such indolent and lackadaisical approach of the
respondents, the petitioner has to knock the door of this Court by
invoking its writ jurisdiction.
5. Per contra , learned State counsel, vociferously, opposes the
claim of the petitioner and submits that it is not a case of re-designation.
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.21 14:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
3
CWP-14284-2013 (O&M) &
COCP-434-2022
The service conditions of the petitioner are governed by Punjab Medical
Education State Service (Class-II) Rules, 1979 (for short 'Rules of 1979'),
and only the service which comprises the posts shown in Appendix-B,
can be recognized in view of Rule 4 thereof.
6. He further submits that the proviso attached to Rule 4 of the
Rules of 1979, has no effect upon the inherent power of the government
to add or reduce the number of such posts or create new posts with
different designation and scale of pay, whether permanently or
temporarily. The said Rule 4 of ibid Rules, is extracted hereinafter:
“4. Number and character of posts- The Service shall
comprise the posts shown in Appendix 'B':
Provided that nothing in these rules shall affect
the inherent right of Government to add to or reduce the
number of such posts or create new posts with different
designations and scales of pay, whether permanently or
temporarily.”
7. He thereupon referred to Appendix-B attached with the
aforesaid rule to submit that in the Department of Physiology, the only
category mentioned is that of Lecturers and not that of Senior Lecturers.
The relevant of Appendix-B is extracted hereinafter:
Sr. No. Name of Deptt. Name of Category Name of sanctioned posts
1. XX XX XX XX XX
2. Physiology Lecturer 3 11 14
3. XX XX XX XX XX
8. He further submits that the aforesaid rule(s) recognizes the
distinction between Lecturer and Senior Lecturer, as in some departments
the entry-level post is that of a Senior Lecturer, and they have a different
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.21 14:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
4
CWP-14284-2013 (O&M) &
COCP-434-2022
pay scale as prescribed in the rules itself. He then make a reference to
Rule 9 which prescribes the qualifications, and Appendix-C attached with
Rule 9 to submit that the different qualification has been prescribed for
Senior Lecturers and Lecturers. Therefore, the said rule(s) does not
recognize any concept of re-designation from Lecturers to Senior
Lecturers.
9. He also referred to the pay scale prescribed in Appendix-D
attached with Rule 13 to submit that there is a different pay scale meant
for Lecturers and a higher pay scale is meant for Senior Lecturers.
10. This Court has considered the legal submission as made by
learned State counsel.
11. There is no dispute with regard to the Rules of 1979, which
recognizes distinction between Lecturers and Senior Lecturers. However,
the State Government through instructions dated the 26.08.1991, in order
to encourage the doctors who possessed or acquired post-graduation
qualification to redesignate them as Senior Lecturers, de hors to the
Rules of 1979, and also confer the pay scale which is meant for Senior
Lecturers, but with a rider that merely re-designation as Senior Lecturers
would not confirm any right to claim any seniority over and above the
Lecturers who are senior to them. Even the said instructions were
meticulously followed by extending relief to the similarly situated
employee, Dr. Aditya Jain, who is working in the Department of
Physiology, and this is sufficient for this Court to reject the legal
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.21 14:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
5
CWP-14284-2013 (O&M) &
COCP-434-2022
argument as raised by learned State counsel that there is no post of Senior
Lecturer in the Department of Physiology. Not only that, there is a
specific recommendation by the Director concerned, considering the
precedent and the Instructions of 1991. Despite that, no plausible reason
is coming forth, as to why, discriminatory treatment has been meted out to
the present petitioner, that too, while referring to the rule books.
Therefore, the instant petition, at this stage, is disposed of with a
direction to respondent no.1, who shall take a final decision in the case of
the present petitioner, specifically keeping in view the observations made
hereinabove; the similar relief having been extended to one of the co-
employees, namely, Dr. Aditya Jain; and the recommendations of the
Director concerned, vide Annexure P-16 and P-17, by passing a reasoned
and speaking order, after affording an opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner.
12. The aforesaid exercise shall be carried out within six weeks
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
13. Needless to say that in case, the petitioner still fetches
grievance from the speaking order, he shall be at liberty to take
appropriate remedy, as per law.
COCP-434-2022
14. The instant contempt petition also stands disposed of
accordingly, in view of the observations made hereinabove.
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.21 14:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
CWP-14284-2013 (O&M) &
COCP-434-2022
15. All pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of
accordingly.
A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of the
connected case.
(KULDEEP TIWARI)
November 18, 2026 JUDGE
dharamvir
Whether speaking/reasoned. : Yes
Whether Reportable. : Yes
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.21 14:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document