Amandip Singh vs Gramin Bank And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
202
CWP-14112-2020
Date of Decision : 13.11.2026
Amandip Singh …..Petitioner
Versus
Gramin Bank Regional Office, Kapurthala and others ....Respondents
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE NAMIT KUMAR
Present : Mr. J.S. Dadwal, Advocate for the petitioner.
Ms. Preeti Grover, Advocate with
Mr. Mukul Chauhan, Advocate and
Mr. Saurav Verma, Advocate for the respondents.

NAMIT KUMAR, J. (ORAL)
1. The petitioner has filed the instant petition under Articles
226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, seeking issuance of a writ of
mandamus directing the respondents to consider the case of the
petitioner for compassionate appointment on any suitable post as per his
qualification, on account of death of his father in harness.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner's father, namely, Sh. Massa Singh, who was serving as Branch
Manager in the Gramin Bank, Village Saidpur, District Amritsar,
unfortunately died in harness on 20.11.1990, leaving behind his widow
and a minor son (the present petitioner). Upon his death, family pension
was sanctioned in favour of the petitioner's mother. However, in the year
2003, the petitioner's mother contracted a second marriage. He further
submits that at the time of his father's demise, the petitioner was merely
three years of age. The petitioner completed his secondary education in
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 2
the year 2005 and thereafter pursued an Art and Craft Course, which he
completed in the year 2007. Upon completion of his studies, the petitioner
approached the respondents seeking compassionate appointment and
submitted various representations dated 07.07.2020, 10.08.2020 and
17.08.2020 (Annexure P-2). However, no response has been received from
the respondents to the aforesaid representations till date.
3. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents, while
referring to the averments made in the written statement filed on behalf
of the respondents, submits that the case of the petitioner is liable to be
dismissed on the ground of delay and laches, as the father of the
petitioner died on 20.11.1990 and the petitioner attained majority in the
year 2005, whereas he approached the respondent-Bank seeking
compassionate appointment only in the year 2020, i.e., after an
inordinate and unexplained delay of 15 years.
4. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
5. Admittedly, the petitioner's father died in harness on
20.11.1990, when the petitioner was merely three years old. The
petitioner attained the age of majority in the year 2005, however, he
approached the respondent-Bank seeking compassionate appointment
only in the year 2020 by submitting his first representation dated
07.07.2020.
6. The very object of the scheme of compassionate
appointment presupposes that the request must be made within the time
stipulated, or at the very least, within the reasonable period. In the
present case, a period of more than 15 years has passed from the date
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 3
the petitioner attained majority, i.e., in the year 2005. As per settled law,
appointment on compassionate basis cannot be claimed as a matter of
right. Such belated claims defeat the purpose of compassionate
appointment and cannot be entertained. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has
consistently held that the stale and delayed applications for
compassionate appointment are liable to be rejected and cannot be
directed to be considered as a matter of right. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court in The Chief Commissioner, Central Excise and Customs,
Lucknow and others Vs. Prabhat Singh : 2013(2) S.C.T. 58 , while
considering the similar issue, has held as under: -
“13. Most importantly, the High Court did not take into
consideration one of the most significant reasons depicted in
the orders passed by the appellants (dated 5.1.2006 and
22.5.2008), namely, that under the OM dated 5.5.2003
appointment on compassionate ground was permissible
within a period of three years from the date of death of the
concerned employee in harness. Vijay Bahadur Singh, the
father of Prabhat Singh had died on 2.3.1996. The
candidature of Prabhat Singh, for appointment on
compassionate ground, under the OM dated 5.5.2003
could have been considered only till 1.3.1999. Thereafter,
Prabhat Singh was rendered ineligible for appointment on
compassionate ground. Pointedly, on aforesaid ground the
Review Committee constituted by the appellants to
consider the claims of dependents of employees who had
died in harness, vide an order dated 21.9.2007, had
excluded the names of persons including Prabhat Singh,
from the list of pending cases for appointment on
compassionate ground, because they could no longer be
appointed on compassionate ground, since more than three
years had expired after the death of the concerned bread
winner in harness. Had the High Court or the Tribunals
applied their mind to the aforesaid pre-condition for
eligibility for appointment on compassionate ground, none
of the directions issued by the High Court or the Tribunals
would have been issued. Such directions could have been
issued only when the party approaching the Tribunal or the
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 4
High Court had established a prima facie case, by
demonstrating fulfillment of the terms and conditions
stipulated in rules/regulations/policy instructions/office
memoranda, relevant for such consideration. Had the
aforesaid simple exercise been carried out, it would not
have been necessary to examine the matter again and
again. In the instant case, on a simple issue of
compassionate appointment, there have been repeated
rounds of litigation, the first time before the CAT-
Allahabad Bench, then before the CAT-Lucknow Bench,
and thereafter, before the High Court. From the High
Court the matter has now been carried to this Court. If
only the pre-requisite eligibility of Prabhat Singh for
appointment on compassionate ground had been examined,
it would not have been necessary to examine the matter
again, and yet again. The instant observations have been
recorded only to demonstrate how judicial time at different
levels has been wasted by entertaining a frivolous
litigation. Surely, because Prabhat Singh had approached
a judicial forum nine years after the death of his father,
whereas, appointment on compassionate ground is
permissible only within three years of the death of the
bread winner, the matter deserved to have been rejected at
the stage of first entertainment.
14. We are constrained to record that even
compassionate appointments are regulated by norms.
Where such norms have been laid down, the same have to
be strictly followed. Where claims for appointment on
compassionate ground, exceed, the available vacancies
(which can be filled up by way of compassionate
appointment), a selection process has to be adopted by the
competent authority. The said process, necessarily has to
be fair, and based on a comparative compassion gradient
of eligible candidates, or on some such like criterion
having a nexus to the object sought to be achieved. In
other words, where there are two candidates but only one
vacancy is available, there should be a clear, transparent
and objective criterion to determine which of the two
should be chosen. In the absence of a prescribed criteria, a
fair selection process has to be followed, so that, the
exercise carried out in choosing one of the two candidates
against a solitary available vacancy, can be shown to be
based on reason, fair-play and non arbitrariness.
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 5
15. The very object of making provision for appointment
on compassionate ground, is to provide succor to a family
dependent on a Government employee, who has
unfortunately died in harness. On such death, the family
suddenly finds itself in dire straits, on account of the
absence of its sole bread winner. Delay in seeking such a
claim, is an ante thesis, for the purpose for which
compassionate appointment was conceived. Delay in
raising such a claim, is contradictory to the object sought
to be achieved. The instant controversy reveals that even
though Vijay Bahadur Singh, the father of the applicant
(Prabhat Singh) seeking appointment on compassionate
ground had died on 2.3.1996, Prabhat Singh sought
judicial redress, for the first time, by approaching the CAT-
Allahabad Bench in 2005. By such time, there was no
surviving right for appointment on compassionate ground
under the OM dated 5.5.2003. As already noticed above,
appointment on compassionate ground under the OM
dated 5.5.2003 is permissible within three years of the
death of the bread winner in harness. By now, sixteen years
have passed by, and as such, there can be no surviving
claim for compassionate appointment.
16. Courts and Tribunals should not fall prey to any
sympathy syndrome, so as to issue directions for
compassionate appointments, without reference to the
prescribed norms. Courts are not supposed to carry Santa
Claus's big bag on Christmas eve, to disburse the gift of
compassionate appointment, to all those who seek a court's
intervention. Courts and Tribunals must understand, that
every such act of sympathy, compassion and discretion,
wherein directions are issued for appointment on
compassionate ground, could deprive a really needy family
requiring financial support, and thereby, push into penury
a truly indigent, destitute and impoverish family.
Discretion is therefore ruled out. So are, misplaced
sympathy and compassion.”
7. Further the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jagdish Prasad Vs.
State of Bihar : 1996 (1) SCC 301 has held as under: -
"3. …..The very object of appointment of a dependent of
the deceased employee who died in harness is to relieve
unexpected immediate hardship and distress caused to the
family by sudden demise of the earning member of the
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 6
family. Since the death occurred way back in 1971, in
which year the appellant was four years old, it cannot be
said that he is entitled to be appointed after he attained
majority long thereafter. In other words, if that contention
is accepted, it amounts to another mode of recruitment of
the dependent of a deceased Government servant which
cannot be encouraged, de hors the recruitment rules."
8. A Division Bench of this Court in Bijender Singh Vs.
State of Haryana : 1999(3) SCT 98 has held as under: -
"20. One of the principles which is clearly discernible
from the various judicial precedents referred to above, is
that the minor dependent of deceased employee cannot
claim appointment as of right on his/her attaining majority
and unless the rules or the administrative instructions
which regulate ex gratia employment/compassionate
appointment provide for consideration of the claim of such
dependent after he/she becomes major, the Court cannot
issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the public
employer to appoint such dependent after lapse of many
years. It is also consistent view of the Courts that long time
gap between the date of the death of the employee and the
date of submission of application by an eligible dependent
is sufficient to draw an inference that the family of the
deceased was not in dire need of assistance in the form of
ex-gratia employment/compassionate appointment."
9. This Court while considering similar issue in Tinku Vs.
State of Haryana and others : 2021(4) SCT 18 has held as under: -
“8. It is well settled that appointment to public office is
required to be made by strictly adhering to the mandatory
requirement of the Constitution. Compassionate
appointment is an exception to the general rule. Provision
has been made in order to help the bereaving family
immediately, who has lost its bread earner, to tide over the
immediate crisis. Compassionate appointment is not a
right but a concession. A government/public employment
is not a hereditary office. Such provision has been made to
provide immediate succor to the dependents of the
deceased. Moreover, it is also well settled that the
compassionate appointment cannot be claimed as a matter
of right especially after a passage of time. Reference in
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 7
this regard can be made to the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana
(1994) 4 SCC 138 .
10. On the basis of case laws decided earlier, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in The State of West Bengal Vs. Debabrata Tiwari and
others : 2025(5) SCC 712 has laid down certain guidelines for
compassionate appointment and observed as under: -
“7.2. On consideration of the aforesaid decisions of this
Court, the following principles emerge:
i. That a provision for compassionate
appointment makes a departure from the general
provisions providing for appointment to a post by
following a particular procedure of recruitment.
Since such a provision enables appointment being
made without following the said procedure, it is in
the nature of an exception to the general provisions
and must be resorted to only in order to achieve the
stated objectives, i.e., to enable the family of the
deceased to get over the sudden financial crisis.
ii. Appointment on compassionate grounds is not
a source of recruitment. The reason for making such
a benevolent scheme by the State or the public sector
undertaking is to see that the dependants of the
deceased are not deprived of the means of
livelihood. It only enables the family of the deceased
to get over the sudden financial crisis.
iii. Compassionate appointment is not a vested
right which can be exercised at any time in future.
Compassionate employment cannot be claimed or
offered after a lapse of time and after the crisis is
over .
iv. That compassionate appointment should be
provided immediately to redeem the family in
distress. It is improper to keep such a case pending
for years.
v. In determining as to whether the family is in
financial crisis, all relevant aspects must be borne in
mind including the income of the family, its
liabilities, the terminal benefits if any, received by
the family, the age, dependency and marital status of
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 8
its members, together with the income from any
other source.
7.3. The object underlying a provision for grant of
compassionate employment is to enable the family of the
deceased employee to tide over the sudden crisis due to the
death of the bread-earner which has left the family in
penury and without any means of livelihood. Out of pure
humanitarian consideration and having regard to the fact
that unless some source of livelihood is provided, the
family would not be in a position to make both ends meet, a
provision is made for giving gainful appointment to one of
the dependants of the deceased who may be eligible for
such appointment. Having regard to such an object, it
would be of no avail to grant compassionate appointment
to the dependants of the deceased employee, after the crisis
which arose on account of death of a bread-winner, has
been overcome. Thus, there is also a compelling need to
act with a sense of immediacy in matters concerning
compassionate appointment because on failure to do so,
the object of the scheme of compassionate would be
frustrated. Where a long lapse of time has occurred since
the date of death of the deceased employee, the sense of
immediacy for seeking compassionate appointment would
cease to exist and thus lose its significance and this would
be a relevant circumstance which must weigh with the
authorities in determining as to whether a case for the
grant of compassionate appointment has been made out for
consideration.
7.4. As noted above, the sine qua non for entertaining a
claim for compassionate appointment is that the family of
the deceased employee would be unable to make two ends
meet without one of the dependants of the deceased
employee being employed on compassionate grounds. The
financial condition of the family of the deceased, at the
time of the death of the deceased, is the primary
consideration that ought to guide the authorities' decision
in the matter.
7.5. Considering the second question referred to above,
in the first instance, regarding whether applications for
compassionate appointment could be considered after a
delay of several years, we are of the view that, in a case
where, for reasons of prolonged delay, either on the part of
the applicant in claiming compassionate appointment or
the authorities in deciding such claim, the sense of
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 9
immediacy is diluted and lost. Further, the financial
circumstances of the family of the deceased, may have
changed, for the better, since the time of the death of the
government employee. In such circumstances, Courts or
other relevant authorities are to be guided by the fact that
for such prolonged period of delay, the family of the
deceased was able to sustain themselves, most probably by
availing gainful employment from some other source.
Granting compassionate appointment in such a case, as
noted by this Court in Hakim Singh would amount to
treating a claim for compassionate appointment as though
it were a matter of inheritance based on a line of
succession which is contrary to the Constitution. Since
compassionate appointment is not a vested right and the
same is relative to the financial condition and hardship
faced by the dependents of the deceased government
employee as a consequence of his death, a claim for
compassionate appointment may not be entertained after
lapse of a considerable period of time since the death of
the government employee.”
11. A Coordinate Bench of this Court in CWP No.37554 of
2025 titled as ‘Gurbhinder Singh Vs. State of Punjab and others’
decided on 23.12.2025 : 2025 NCPHHC 177771 has held as under :-
“5. The legal principles governing compassionate
appointments are well-settled and have been consistently
reiterated by the Supreme Court. It is trite that
compassionate appointment is not a right, but a concession
granted to the family of a deceased employee to tide over
sudden financial crisis arising out of the death of the sole
breadwinner. The object is to provide immediate relief, not
to provide employment as a matter of course or opening a
backdoor entry into employment.
6. A Two Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Uttaranchal Jal Sansthan v. Laxmi Devi (2009) 11 SCC
453 held that,“ Since rules relating to compassionate
appointment permit a sidedoor entry, the same have to be
given strict interpretation” . Further reliance may be
placed on another Two Judge Bench of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in SAIL v. Madhusudan Das (2008) 15
SCC 560 observed that, “Compassionate appointment is a
concession and not a right and the criteria laid down in the
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 10
Rules must be satisfied by all aspirants.” It has been
crystallized by the Hon’ble Apex Court that compassionate
appointments must be made strictly in adherence to the
policy, to the extent that in Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan
v. Dharmendra Sharma (2007) 8 SCC 148 the Hon’ble
Apex Court stated that the courts cannot compel the
employer to make appointments on compassionate ground
contrary to its policy.
7. Moreover recently, a Two-Judge Bench of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Canara Bank v. Ajithkumar G.K.
2025 INSC 184 , the Supreme Court reiterated the necessity
of strict adherence to the policy and emphasized that the
financial condition of the family, availability of other
means of sustenance, and existence of genuine indigence
are critical factors. The Court held that where the family is
not in immediate financial distress, the very basis for
compassionate appointment ceases to exist.
8. Further, the Hon’ble Apex Court in State Bank of
India v. Somvir Singh 2007 (4) SCC 778 , held that the
terminal benefits, investments, monthly family income
including the family pension and income of family from
other sources, viz. agricultural land were rightly taken
into consideration by the authority to decide whether the
family is living in penury . The Hon’ble Apex Court
through a catena of judgments has observed that:
Financial condition of the family of the deceased
employee, allegedly in distress or penury, has to be
evaluated or else the object of the scheme would stand
defeated inasmuch as in such an eventuality, any and
every dependent of an employee dying in harness would
claim employment as if public employment is heritable,
reliance in this regard may be placed on Union of India v.
Shashank Goswami (2012) 11 SCC 307, Union Bank of
India v. M. T. Latheesh (2006) 7 SCC 350, National
Hydroelectric Power Corporation v. Nank Chand (2004)
12 SCC 487 and Punjab National Bank v. Ashwini Kumar
Taneja (2004) 7 SCC 265 .
9. In the present case, a perusal of the impugned
minutes of meeting dated NIL (Annexure P-9) reveals that
the respondent/Corporation examined the pending cases of
compassionate appointment in detail and recorded the
following findings:-
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 11
"After examining in detail the 7 pending cases
available on page 1 to 3, it has been found that in
these 7 cases, the wife/husband of the deceased
employee is in government/non-government service
and is earning at the time of death of the deceased
employee and these cases have not been found
eligible as per the above instructions issued by the
Punjab Government for providing jobs to the heirs
of the deceased employee on compassionate
grounds. Apart from this, regarding case mentioned
at Sr. No. 3, applicant has submitted a copy of the
Will executed by his father. According to which his
father has recorded in the Will that if anything
happens to him during his service, then his daughter
Jatwinder Kaur will be entitled to receive all his
funds and he will also apply for the deduction of
nomination of his wife from his funds and if any
other benefits are received from the department
apart from the salary, then his son Gurbinder Singh
will be entitled to receive it. After examining the
Will, the committee found that this Will was
registered on 23.07.2020 after the death of the
deceased employee Mr. Paramjit Singh, which is
baseless because at the time this Will was registered,
the testator had died. Apart from this, as per the
records of the department, the pensionary benefits of
the employee such as GP fund etc. have been paid to
the wife of the deceased employee. In view of which,
since this case is covered in the category of spouse
working cases, this case should be disposed of as
this case is not eligible for providing job on
compassionate grounds. Therefore, the committee
recommends the cancellation of these 7 cases."
10. From the perusal of the record, it is evident that the
mother of the petitioner, namely Sarabjeet Kaur, was
employed in the Punjab School Education Board at the
time of the death of Sh. Paramjit Singh i.e. 26.10.2019.
Although she retired subsequently on 31.05.2021, the fact
remains that she was a breadwinner for the family at the
crucial time of the employee's death. Furthermore, she is
now a recipient of pensionary benefits in addition to the
terminal benefits already disbursed to her.
11. These factors are directly related to determining
whether the family is in such penury that compassionate
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 12
appointment is warranted. The authority is entitled to
satisfy itself that the claimant is genuinely dependent and
the family has no other sufficient means of support. The
fact that the spouse was working and earning at the time of
death and continues to have financial stability through
pension, fundamentally negates the claim of "financial
destitution."
12. It is pertinent to note that compassionate
appointment is intended to meet an immediate financial
crisis, whereas in the present case the claim has been
pursued after a considerable lapse of time from the date of
death of the employee. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Canara Bank’s case (supra) and other decisions has
cautioned against granting compassionate appointment
after a long lapse of time as the immediacy of the crisis is
lost.
13. The aim of compassionate appointment is not to
open a backdoor entry into employment or to treat public
employment as heritable right but to help the dependents in
times of immediate need as the breadwinner passes away.
Given the gainful employment of the petitioner's mother at
the time of death and the subsequent receipt of retirement
and pensionary benefits, the family cannot be deemed to be
in a state of financial crisis that warrants this exceptional
concession.”
12. The Rajasthan High Court in Smt. Parwati Devi and
another v. Director, (G) & Nodal Officer (PG), Ministry of Mines,
Geology Survey of India and others : 2022 SCC Online Raj 410 ,
relying upon the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed
as under: -
“14. It has also been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
the case of "Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. & Ors.
v. Nirval Singh, reported in (2019) 6 SCC 774" that delay
in pursuing claim/approaching court would mitigate
against claim for compassionate appointment as very
objective of providing immediate amelioration to family
would stand extinguished.
xx xx xx xx xx
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 13
16. In the case of "State of J & K & Ors. v. Sajad Ahmed
Mir reported in (2006) 5 SCC 766" , the Hon'ble Supreme
Court has considered the delay and laches in case of
appointment on compassionate ground. By dismissing the
claim for appointment on compassionate ground, which
was made after a period of four and a half years of the
death of the deceased employee, it was held that the
appointment on compassionate ground is an exception to
the general rule. An appointment to public offices should
be made on the basis of competitive merits. It was further
observed that once it is proved that inspite of the death of
the breadwinner, the family survived and the substantial
period is over, there is no need to make appointment on
compassionate ground, at the cost of interests of several
others ignoring the mandate of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
xx xx xx xx xx
21. In the present case also, as already indicated above,
the petitioners approached the Tribunal after a lapse of
almost 13 years from the date of death of the employee
concerned. The observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the case of P. Venkatesh (supra) are squarely
applicable with the facts of the instant case. For the sake
of convenience, the relevant observations made by the
Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of P. Venkatesh (supra) are
as under:
"The primary difficulty in accepting the line of
submissions, which weighed with the High Court,
and were reiterated on behalf of the respondents, in
these proceedings, is simply this; Compassionate
appointment, it is well settled, is intended to enable
the family of a deceased employee to tide over the
crisis which is caused as a result of the death of an
employee, while in harness. The essence of the claim
lies in the immediacy of the need. If the facts of the
present case are seen, it is evident that even the first
recourse to the Central Administrative Tribunal was
in 2007, nearly 11 years after the death of the
employee. In the meantime, the first set of
representations had been rejected on 3 January
1997. The Tribunal, unfortunately, passed a
succession of orders calling upon the appellants to
consider and then re-consider the representations
for compassionate appointment. After the Union
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 14
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting rejected
the representation on 13 November 2007, it was only
in 2010 that the Tribunal was moved again, with the
same result. These successive orders of Tribunal for
re-consideration of the representation cannot
obliterate the effect of the initial delay in moving the
Tribunal for compassionate appointment over a
decade after the death of the deceased employee.
This 'dispose of the representation' mantra is
increasingly permeating the judicial process in the
High Courts and the Tribunals. Such orders may
make for a quick or easy disposal of cases in
overburdened adjudicated institutions. But, they do
not service to the cause of justice. The litigant is
back again before the Court, as they case shows,
having incurred attendant costs and suffered delays
of the legal process. This would have been obviated
by calling for a counter in the first instance, thereby
resulting in finality to the dispute. By the time, the
High Court issued its direction on 9 August 2016,
nearly twenty one years had elapsed since the date
of the death of the employee....…"
xx xx xx xx xx
24. Looking to the material available on the record, and
after applying the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex
Court in the judgments referred in foregoing paras, we are
of the considered opinion that the contentions put forward
by the counsel for the petitioners, do not carry any merit,
as the subsequent representations were made after a
decade. Thus, this Court is not able to accept the claim of
the petitioners for compassionate appointment after a
great lapse of 17 years. Thus, the impugned order dated
19.08.2021 passed by the Tribunal warrants no
interference by this Court.”
13. In the present case, the petitioner's father died in harness on
20.11.1990, when the petitioner was merely three years old. The
petitioner attained the age of majority in the year 2005 and therefore,
could have approached the respondents seeking compassionate
appointment upon attaining majority. However, instead of doing so, the
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document

CWP-14112-2020 15
petitioner remained silent for a period of more than 15 years thereafter
and submitted his first representation to the respondent seeking
appointment on compassionate grounds only on 07.07.2020. The
position of law is well settled that appointment on compassionate basis
is not an alternate source of recruitment nor does the consideration for
such employment is a vested right, which can be exercised at any time
in future. The object of such appointment is to mitigate the financial
hardship faced by the family immediately following the death of the
employee and not to provide employment after the lapse of several
years, when the immediate crises has ceased to exist. Merely because
the petitioner was minor at the time of the death of his father would not
entitle him to seek compassionate appointment after an inordinate and
unexplained delay of several years upon attaining majority. The
petitioner has also failed to furnish any satisfactory explanation for not
approaching the respondents within a reasonable period after attaining
majority.
14. For the reasons stated hereinabove and keeping in view the
settled position of law, this Court finds no ground to entertain the
petitioner’s claim for compassionate appointment at this belated stage.
The present writ petition is accordingly dismissed on the ground of
delay and laches, with no order as to costs.
(NAMIT KUMAR)
13.11.2026 JUDGE
Kothiyal
Whether Speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No
VINOD KOTHIYAL
2026.11.18 09:50
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document