THE STATE OF KARNATAKA vs VITHAL S/O. DHIRENDRARAO BEEDI
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18636
RSA No. 5559 of 2013
CNR: KAHC020102842013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD
TH
DATED THIS THE 13 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE RAJESHWARI N.HEGDE
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 5559 OF 2013
BETWEEN:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
R/BY ITS EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
MRBCC DIV.NO.1
NARAGUND DIST: GADAG-582103.
2. KARNATAKA NEERAVARI NIGAM LTD. (KNNL)
R/BY ITS EXECUTIE ENGINEER,
MRBCC DN. NO. 1,
NARAGUND, DIST: GADAG.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI S.M. TONNE, ADVOCATE.)
AND:
1. SRI VITHAL S/O. DHIRENDRARAO BEEDI
AGE: 49 YEARS, OCC: SERVICE,
R/O. SHIVAPPANAKATTI,
RAJENDRA NAGAR, HAVERI-581110.
2. SRI B. CHANNAPPA
AGE: MAJOR,
OCC: RETD. EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
R/O. OLD PETH, BIRUR (AGO-3)
CHIKKAMAGALUR DIST.-577117.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI K.ANAND KUMAR, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
NOTICE TO R1 IS HELD SUFFICIENT.)
ROHAN
HADIMANI
T
Digitally signed by ROHAN
HADIMANI T
Location: HIGH COURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
Date: 2026.11.19 16:49:51
+0530
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18636
RSA No. 5559 of 2013
CNR: KAHC020102842013
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL IS FILED UNDER
SECTION 100 OF THE CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE, 1908,
PRAYING TO ALLOW THIS APPEAL AND SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 17.01.2013, PASSED IN
R.A.NO.56/2009, ON THE FILE OF THE PRESIDING OFFICER,
FAST TRACK COURT AT GADAG, FILED AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 19.04.2008, DISMISSING THE
SUIT IN O.S.NO.242/2003 PASSED BY THE LEARNED
ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.) COURT, GADAG AND
DECREE THE SUIT WITH COSTS THROUGHOUT IN FAVOUR OF
THE PLAINTIFFS AND ETC.,.
THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE RAJESHWARI N.HEGDE
ORAL JUDGMENT
Heard the learned counsel Sri S.M.Tonne, for the
appellant.
2. Perused the memorandum of appeal, the
grounds urged therein and the judgment and decree
passed by both the Courts.
3. This appeal is filed assailing the judgment dated
17.01.2013, passed in R.A.No.56/2009 by the Presiding
Officer, Fast Track Court, Gadag (‘First Appellate Court’,
for short), confirming the judgment dated 19.04.2008,
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18636
RSA No. 5559 of 2013
CNR: KAHC020102842013
passed by the Additional Civil Judge (Sr.Dn.), Gadag (‘trial
Court’, for short) in O.S.No.242/2003, dismissing the suit
of the plaintiffs filed for recovery of damages.
4. For convenience, parties are referred as
plaintiffs and defendants as referred before the trial Court.
5. Facts of the case in brief are that, the plaintiffs
filed a suit in O.S.No.242/2003 before the trial Court
seeking recovery of ₹1,01,838-94 from defendant No.1
and ₹33,946-25 from defendant No.2 by way of damages
with future interest at 18% per annum along with costs.
6. It is contended that the plaintiffs KNNL is
created and wholly owned by the Govt. of Karnataka and
registered company of the Government. The successor in
interest of the properties transferred to it by the
Government and initiated the recovery proceedings
against the defendants for the loss caused by them, during
the service tenure of the father of defendant No.1 late
Sri Dhirendra Laxmanrao Beedi and defendant No.2 while
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18636
RSA No. 5559 of 2013
CNR: KAHC020102842013
being posted at MRBCC Division No.1, Naragund, as Store
Superintendent and the Executive Engineer, respectively.
7. It is contended by the plaintiffs that, the
defendants committed illegalities, irregularities and acted
in gross negligence resulting in shortage of store material.
The Chief Engineer, Irrigation North, Belagavi, in his
enquiry held defendants guilty of having caused shortage
of articles worth of ₹1,35,784-99, of which defendant No.1
was held liable for the loss of 75% and defendant No.2
was held liable for loss of 25%.
8. After filing the suit, the defendants entered
appearance and they have denied the contents of the
plaint and also denied their liability. It is their contention
that, there was no shortage of store material during their
tenure and the KAT allowed their application and set aside
the charges levelled against them. Therefore, the
defendants prayed for dismissal of the suit.
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18636
RSA No. 5559 of 2013
CNR: KAHC020102842013
9. The trial Court after framing the issues recorded
the evidence of the witnesses. On behalf of the plaintiffs,
plaintiff No.2 got examined as PW1 and got marked
documents as Ex.P1 to P11. On behalf of defendants,
defendants No.1 and 2 were examined as DW1 and DW2
and got marked the documents as Ex.D1 and D2. The trial
Court after appreciation of the evidence on record,
proceeded to dismiss the suit of the plaintiffs, vide
impugned judgment dated 19.04.2008.
10. The plaintiffs being aggrieved by the impugned
judgment, filed appeal before the First Appellate Court in
R.A.No.56/2009. The First Appellate Court after
re-appreciation of the evidence on record, dismissed the
appeal confirming the judgment of the trial Court, vide
impugned judgment dated 17.01.2013.
11. Being aggrieved by the impugned judgment of
both the Courts, the appellants/plaintiffs have preferred
the present regular second appeal on the following:
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18636
RSA No. 5559 of 2013
CNR: KAHC020102842013
GROUNDS
a) Both the Courts have not properly
appreciated the evidence on record and both
the Courts have committed illegality in
dismissing the suit of the plaintiffs.
b) It is contended that because of the
negligent act of father of defendant No.1 and
defendant No.1 herein who is the legal heir and
defendant No.2 being the executive engineer of
the division, both have neglected in execution
of their work and thereby caused loss, which is
not properly appreciated by both the Courts.
c) Hence the appellants contended that,
both the Courts have committed error and
thereby the present second appeal is filed to
decide the substantial questions of law,
whether both the Courts have not properly
appreciated the evidence on record and
erroneously dismissed the suit because the KAT
has exonerated the charges against defendants
No.1 and 2 and on that basis the suit of the
plaintiffs was dismissed, which is also
erroneous.
12. Upon hearing the learned counsel for the
appellants and after perusal of the impugned judgment of
both the Courts, in the judgment the trial Court has
appreciated the evidence on record placed by both the
parties and at paragraph No.16 assigned reasons that,
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18636
RSA No. 5559 of 2013
CNR: KAHC020102842013
PW1 and PW2 both have admitted in their evidence that,
at the time of taking charge by defendant No.1 whether
defendant No.1 took all the documents pertaining to the
charge list and further, both PW1 and PW2 have also
admitted that, they have not periodically checked the
stock and they have also not get audited periodically.
Further in paragraphs No.27 and 28 also the trial Court
has appreciated the evidence on record and has rightly
come to the conclusion that the plaintiffs have failed to
prove their case. Accordingly, the suit was dismissed.
13. Even the First Appellate Court has also
re-appreciated the evidence on record and has come to
the conclusion that, the trial Court has rightly appreciated
the evidence and proceeded to dismiss the suit. In
paragraph No.20 of the First Appellate Court order it is
observed that, the enquiry officer who has made enquiry
and fixed charges against defendants No.1 and 2 to pay
the tune of 75% and 25% respectively in respect of
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18636
RSA No. 5559 of 2013
CNR: KAHC020102842013
damages caused to plaintiffs No.1 and 2 has been quashed
by order dated 30.07.1996 in Application No.5687/1995
by the KAT, Bengaluru and the said order has not been
challenged by the plaintiffs and it has attained finality,
even on the basis of the said order, the First Appellate
Court has dismissed the appeal confirming the judgment
of the trial Court.
14. On a careful consideration of the material on
record, this court is of the opinion that, the grounds urged
by the appellant do not give rise to any substantial
question of law warranting admission of the appeal under
section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The
findings recorded by both the Courts are based on
appreciation of the pleadings and evidence on record. No
perversity, illegality or error of law warranting interference
by the Court is made out. In the absence of any
substantial question of law, this Court is not intended to
admit the appeal.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18636
RSA No. 5559 of 2013
CNR: KAHC020102842013
15. Accordingly, the Regular Second Appeal is
dismissed
at the stage of admission.
16. In view of disposal of the appeal, pending
interlocutory applications, if any, stand disposed of as they
do not survive for consideration.
17. No order as to costs.
Sd/-
(RAJESHWARI N.HEGDE)
JUDGE
MRK
CT-CMU
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 21