Uttar Pradesh Subordinate Service Selection Commission vs Ashok Yadav
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 991
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Civil Appeal No(s). /2026
@ SLP (C) No(s).12895/2026
UTTAR PRADESH SUBORDINATE SERVICE SELECTION COMMISSION
…..Appellant
VERSUS
ASHOK YADAV & ORS.
...Respondent(s)
O R D E R
1. Leave granted.
2. Heard learned counsel for the parties.
3. This appeal impugns judgment and order of the
1
Division Bench of the High Court dated 20.03.2026
rendered in Civil Misc. Review Application No.
224/2021 which sought review of order dated
20.01.2021 passed in Special Appeal Defective
No.1186 of 2020.
FACTS
Signature Not Verified
4. A brief narration of facts is necessary to
Digitally signed by
CHETAN ARORA
Date: 2026.09.15
18:14:24 IST
Reason:
1
1 The High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
1
understand the issue that has arisen for our
consideration in this appeal.
5. The appellant i.e., The Uttar Pradesh Subordinate
2
Service Selection Commission , on 18.01.2016
published an advertisement inviting applications
for appointment on 3133 posts of Village
Development Officer. As per selection procedure, a
written test comprising objective type questions-
answers was held on 05.06.2016. Provisional answer-
key was published on 09.06.2016. After considering
objections a revised answer-key was published on
30.06.2016. Based on the revised answer-key, on
18.07.2018, the result was declared. In between,
few candidates, who had their own individual
grievances, filed writ petitions before a Single
Judge Bench of the High Court wherein certain
directions were issued. In consequence, a
supplementary result was published on 26.06.2020.
6. Though, in between various writ petitions came to
be filed before the High Court, the issue that
falls for our consideration in this appeal
2
2 The Commission
2
emanates from Writ A No.10221 of 2019, which shall
hereinafter be referred to as the subject writ
petition. The subject writ petition was filed
before the learned Single Judge of the High Court
for a direction to the Commission to allot one
mark to the writ petitioner (i.e., the respondent
3
herein) for his answer to the following question :
In Hindi:
“68. ?
ननमन म स ककन सस समसललत नहह ह
(A) -
वसबरनसमस बसबर
(B) -
शसहजहसहनसमस मसहममदतसनहर
(e) -
हसमसयहनसमस हसमसयह
(D) - - - "
तसजसक ए जहसहगगरग जहसहगगर
In English:
“68. Which of the following pairs
is incorrect?
(A) Baburnama – Babur
(B) Shahjahannama - Mohd. Taahir
(C) Humayunnama – Humayun
(D) Tuzuk-e-Jahangiri - Jahangir”
7. The Commission in its answer-key had selected
option ‘B’ as the correct answer whereas the writ
petitioner had opted for option ‘C”.
8. The writ petitioner’s contention was that option
‘C’ is the correct answer in as much as
Humayunnama was not authored by Humayun but by
3
3 To have a clear understanding of the question, its Hindi as well as English version, as found in the
question Booklet, have been reproduced.
3
Gulbadan Begum.
9. The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ
petition on the ground of laches upon being
informed that several such writ petitions were
dismissed on laches. While dismissing the writ
petition the learned Single Judge also cited a
decision of this Court in U.P. Public Service
Commission through its Chairman V. Rahul Singh and
4
Another wherein it has been held that
constitutional courts must exercise restraint in
such matters and should be reluctant to entertain
a plea challenging the correctness of key answers.
10. Aggrieved by the order of learned Single Judge,
the respondent preferred an intra court appeal
before the Division Bench of the High Court. The
Division Bench vide order dated 20.01.2021
dismissed the appeal by relying on few decisions
of this Court.
11. Upon dismissal of the intra court appeal, a review
petition was filed, which came to be allowed by
the impugned order holding that the writ
4
4 (2018) 7 SCC 254
4
petitioner was entitled to one mark for selecting
option ‘C’, which was the correct answer as per
the report dated 10.08.2020. In consequence, the
intra court appeal was allowed, the order of the
learned Single Judge was set aside, and a
direction was issued to the Commission to declare
the result of the review petitioner and make
recommendation accordingly, and the State
Government was directed to issue appointment.
12. While allowing the review petition, the High Court
opined that the expert report dated 10.08.2020 was
not placed either before the learned Single Judge
or before the Division Bench earlier even though
it was relevant and had a bearing on the decision
of the matter. It held that the expert report
dated 10.08.2020 indicated that both option ‘B’
and ‘C’ could be correct depending upon the
perception of the reader.
13. The said expert report dated 10.08.2020, which was
considered by the High Court while passing the
impugned order, is reproduced below:
“Opinion of the Subject Expert
5
regarding the question of the
written examination conducted by
the Uttar Pradesh Subordinate
Services Selection Commission,
Lucknow.
Question- Which of the following is
not correctly matched?
(a) Baburnama – Babur
(b) Shahjahan Nama - Mohammad Tahir
(c) Humayun Nama – Humayun
(d) Tuzuk-e-Jahangiri – Jahangir
We have gone through the question on
the above. If we go by the logic of
Book and Author pair, the correct
answer to the above question is C.
Because Humayun Nama was not written
by Humayun but it was written by
Gulbadan Begum.
However, if we go by the logic of Book
and its description about Whom, the
correct answer to the above question
is B. Because Baburnama talks about
Babur and Humayun nama talks about
Humayun and Tuzuk-e-Jahangiri talks
about Jahangir, but Shahjahan nama
does not talk about Mohammad Tahir, it
talks about Shahjahan.
10.8.2020
Sd/-
Dr. Alok Kumar
DSMNR University
Lucknow
Sd/-
Prof. S. Victor Babu
B. B. Ambedkar University
Lucknow”
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
14. Assailing the impugned judgment of the High Court,
on behalf of the appellant it is submitted that
the Expert Report relied by the High Court is
6
equivocal. It does not say that option ‘C’ is the
correct answer. It simply says that if pairing is
to be done by authorship, then option ‘C’ would be
the correct answer because Humayunnama is not
written by Humayun, but if pairing is done on the
basis of subject i.e., the book/ scripture relates
to whom, option ‘B’ would be the correct answer.
It was argued that the question does not spell out
that pairing had to be on authorship, therefore,
authorship cannot be used as a parameter to find
out the incorrect pair. It has also been submitted
that in absence of authorship as a parameter for
pairing, the answer to the question i.e., pairing
can be done either phonetically or subject-wise
i.e., to whom the book relates to. If it is paired
phonetically, option ‘B’ is the only option where
the two do not phonetically match; and if pairing
is done subject-wise, then too, option ‘B’ is the
only correct option. To illustrate, the learned
counsel for the appellant submitted that
‘Baburnama’ is about Babur, ‘Humayunnama’ is about
7
Humayun and ‘Tuzuk-e-Jahangiri’ is about Jahangir
whereas Shahjahannama is not about Mohammad Tahir;
therefore, if pairing is done subject-wise option
‘B’ is the only combination which does not match.
Hence, option ‘B’ was the only correct option.
Phonetically also option ‘B’ is the only correct
answer. Thus, when authorship was not the
parameter on which pairing had to be done, option
‘C’ cannot be considered as the correct answer.
15. Additionally, it is submitted, the writ court
ought not to have interfered with the decision of
the Commission, particularly when its decision was
neither arbitrary nor perverse. More so, when the
writ petition came to be filed much after
declaration of the result. In these circumstances,
it is urged, the impugned order of the High Court
is liable to be set aside.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENTS
16. Per contra, on behalf of the respondents as well
as intervenors whose matters are pending before
the High Court, it has been submitted that the
8
question paper had three Parts, namely, General
Hindi, General Intelligence Test and General
Knowledge. The first part comprising questions 1
to 30 relates to General Hindi; the second part
comprising questions 31 to 50 relates to General
Intelligence Test; and the third part comprising
questions 51 to 80 relates to General Knowledge.
The subject question falls in the third part which
relates to General Knowledge. Therefore, the
question had to be understood in that context
whereas the underlying rationale for picking up
option ‘B’ does not correlate with General
Knowledge, rather it relates to General
Intelligence or logic. Therefore, the very basis
on which option ‘B” was selected by the Commission
as the correct answer is faulty. It has been
submitted that having information about authorship
of a known book or scripture is part of General
Knowledge and, therefore, when all other options
match with the name of author, only option ‘C’
stands out as Humayunnama’s author is not Humayun
9
but Gulbadan Begum. Consequently, the High Court
was justified in awarding one mark for the said
option. In the alternative, it is submitted, if
there was no parameter for pairing, the same could
be both subject-wise and author-wise, giving rise
to two correct answers, namely, option ‘B’ and
option ‘C’. In such circumstances, marks would
have to be awarded for both and, therefore, the
impugned order calls for no interference as marks
have been awarded to both. In this context,
reliance was placed on a decision of this Court in
Siddhi Sandeep Ladda vs. Consortium of National
5
Law Universities and Anr. to canvass that though
Courts are generally reluctant to interfere in
such matters for lack of expertise, however, when
the academicians themselves act in a manner that
adversely affects the career aspirations of lakhs
of students, the Court’s hands are not tied, and
it may interfere to do complete justice.
17. We have accorded due consideration to the rival
submissions and have perused the materials
5
5 [2025] 7 S.C.R. 55:2025 INSC 714:2025 SCC OnLine SC 1144
10
available on record including the impugned
judgment in review as well as the judgment
whereby, earlier, the intra court appeal was
dismissed.
ISSUE
18. Upon consideration of the rival submissions, the
following issue arises for our consideration:
“Whether the High Court was justified
in interfering with Commission’s
decision to pick Option ‘B’ as the
only correct answer to the concerned
question?”
ANALYSIS
19. Before we address the aforesaid issue, it would be
useful to examine the scope of judicial review in
adjudging the correctness of a key answer selected
and published by the examining body holding a
public examination.
6
20. In Ran Vijay Singh v. State of U.P. this Court
after considering earlier decisions culled out
legal principles delineating the scope of judicial
review while examining a challenge to the
correctness of the key answer(s) and seeking re-
6
6 (2018) 2 SCC 357
11
evaluation of the answer script. The relevant
paragraphs of the said judgment are extracted
below:
“30.2. If a statute, Rule or
Regulation governing an
examination does not permit re-
evaluation or scrutiny of an
answer sheet (as distinct from
prohibiting it) then the court
may permit re-evaluation or
scrutiny only if it is
demonstrated very clearly,
without any “inferential process
of reasoning or by a process of
rationalization” and only in
rare or exceptional cases that a
material error has been
committed;
30.3. The court should not at
all re-evaluate or scrutinize
the answer sheets of a candidate
- it has no expertise in the
matter and academic matters are
best left to academics;
30.4. The court should presume
the correctness of the key
answers and proceed on that
assumption; and
30.5 In the event of a doubt,
the benefit should go to the
examination authority rather
than to the candidate.”
(Emphasis supplied)
After holding as above, this Court added a note of
12
caution for the courts while entertaining such
matters and highlighted the adverse consequences
of over interference with the examination results.
Relevant observations in that regard are as under:
“31. On our part we may add that
sympathy or compassion does not
play any role in the matter of
directing or not directing re-
evaluation of an answer sheet.
If an error is committed by the
examination authority, the
complete body of candidates
suffers. The entire examination
process does not deserve to be
derailed only because some
candidates are disappointed or
dissatisfied or perceive some
injustice having been caused to
them by an erroneous question or
an erroneous answer. All
candidates suffer equally,
though some might suffer more
but that cannot be helped since
mathematical precision is not
always possible. This Court has
shown one way out of an impasse
-exclude the suspect or
offending question.
32. It is rather unfortunate
that despite several decisions
of this Court, some of which
have been discussed above, there
is interference by the courts in
the result of examinations. This
places the examination
authorities in an unenviable
position where they are under
13
scrutiny and not the candidates.
Additionally, a massive and
sometimes prolonged examination
exercise concludes with an air
of uncertainty. While there is
no doubt that candidates put in
a tremendous effort in preparing
for an examination, it must not
be forgotten that even the
examination authorities put in
equally great efforts to
successfully conduct an
examination. The enormity of the
task might reveal some lapse at
a later stage, but the court
must consider the internal
checks and balances put in place
by the examination authorities
before interfering with the
efforts put in by the candidates
who have successfully
participated in the examination
and the examination authorities.
The present appeals are a
classic example of the
consequence of such interference
where there is no finality to
the result of the examinations
even after a lapse of eight
years. Apart from the
examination authorities even the
candidates are left wondering
about the certainty or otherwise
of the result of the examination
- whether they have passed or
not; whether the result will be
approved or disapproved by the
court; whether they will get
admission in a college or
university or not; and whether
they will get recruited or not.
This unsatisfactory situation
14
does not work to anybody's
advantage, and such a state of
uncertainty results in confusion
being worse confounded. The
overall and larger impact of all
this is that public interest
suffers.”
(Emphasis supplied)
21. Following the decision in Ran Vijay Singh (supra) ,
in U.P. Public Service Commission v. Rahul Singh
(supra), this Court held:
“12. The law is well settled
that the onus is on the
candidate to not only
demonstrate that the key answer
is incorrect but also that it is
a glaring mistake which is
totally apparent and no
inferential process or reasoning
is required to show that the key
answer is wrong. The
constitutional courts must
exercise great restraint in such
matters and should be reluctant
to entertain a plea challenging
the correctness of the key
answers. …”
22. The legal position that emerges from the aforesaid
decision(s) is that a challenge to the correctness
of answer key must be entertained only where the
mistake is so glaring and apparent that no
inferential process or reasoning is required to
15
show that the mistake exists. Besides, while
considering a challenge to the correctness of a
question or an answer, the court must bear in mind
that there is a presumption about the correctness
of the question/ answer, and the onus is on the
candidate to demonstrate that it is incorrect.
Further, in the event of a mere doubt about the
correctness of the question or the answer, the
benefit should go to the examining body and not to
the candidate. However, where it is demonstrated
that the question itself is incorrect, or there
could be two correct answers to the question when
only one is to be chosen from the options
provided, the Court may interfere and order
exclusion of the suspect or offending question
from evaluation. In a situation where the question
is correct and is admissible to only one answer
and that answer is amongst the options provided
but is not the one chosen by the examining body,
the Court may direct the examining body to award
marks only for the correct answer and revise the
16
result accordingly. While entertaining a petition
in such matters, courts must be strict in
condoning laches, if any, having regard to the
ensuing consequences. Besides, the court may
reject a challenge if the procedure prescribed to
raise objection(s) to the question/ answer, within
a specified time frame, is not followed.
23. Having noticed the law on the point, we shall now
consider whether the answer selected by the
Commission to the concerned question suffered from
a glaring mistake.
24. At this stage, it would be pertinent to note that
the concerned question did not spell out the
parameter/ principle basis which the incorrect
pair had to be selected from the available
options. Absent any parameter/ principle for
pairing, a commonsense approach of pairing the
book with the subject i.e., the person about whom
the book was, is what has been adopted by the
Commission in selecting the answer. Such an
approach cannot by any stretch of imagination be
17
considered arbitrary or irrational. Therefore, in
the context of the question concerned, option ‘B’
is one answer which cannot be called patently
erroneous.
25. The Expert Report relied upon by the High Court is
not categorical in saying that Option ‘C’ is the
only correct answer. What it says is that if one
adopts the logic of authorship of the scripture,
option ‘C’ would be the correct answer i.e.,
pairing based on authorship; and if logic adopted
is subject-wise i.e., on whom the book is written,
option ‘B’ would be the right answer. Thus, the
Expert Report does not say that option ‘B’, chosen
by the Commission, is an incorrect answer.
26. Admittedly, the question concerned is silent about
the basis of pairing, therefore, a commonsense
approach leads us to Option ‘B’, which is the
answer chosen by the examining body.
27. The writ petitioner is facing problem because he
applied inferential logic to read into the
question ‘authorship of the book’ as the guiding
principle to select an incorrect pair, when no
18
such principle or parameter is decipherable from a
plain reading of the question. Thus, the writ
petitioner committed an assumptive mistake which
cannot be attributed to the question or the
examining body.
28. Writ petitioner’s assumption that pairing is based
on authorship is what has let him down. It is
possible that if he had not known that Humayun is
not the author of Humayunnama, he may not have
opted for option ’C’. Therefore, one may feel that
the writ petitioner is being punished for having
knowledge about a historical fact. But that is not
the ground to test the correctness of the question
or the answer while exercising the power of
judicial review. The test is whether the mistake
is so glaring that no inferential process or
reasoning is required to show that it is there.
Here, authorship was not the basis on which
pairing was asked for, therefore, commonsense
approach could have resulted in the correct
choice. The writ petitioner on his own assumed
19
that pairing had to be on authorship. But for that
the examining body cannot be blamed.
29. Misreading a question, or reading something into a
question, often results in a wrong answer. Very
often questions are framed to confuse a candidate
so that only an alert mind picks up the requisite
nuances of a question for rendering a proper
answer. The examinee / candidate cannot say that
the question ought to have been drafted like this
or that. Therefore, while considering whether the
question or answer is correct, the Court must only
consider whether the question or answer as it
stands is correct or not and not what it ought to
have been. If the question and its answer, as they
stand, do not suffer from a glaring mistake, the
Court cannot hold that it should be read and
understood as something else than what it actually
is only because, in the opinion of the Court, it
would have made more sense.
30. From the discussion above, what is clear is that
neither the question concerned is incorrect nor
20
option ‘B’ chosen by the Commission is incorrect.
In such circumstances, the question and its answer
was not amenable to judicial review. The High
Court clearly overstepped its jurisdiction in
interfering with the same, that too, in the review
jurisdiction.
31. The argument on behalf of the respondents that the
concerned question fell in that Part of the
Question Paper which related to General Knowledge,
therefore only authorship could have formed the
basis of pairing, is based on assumption. A
question is to be understood as it stands and not
what it ought to have been. We have already
noticed above that judicial review of the
correctness of a question or an answer is
permissible only where the mistake is so glaring
and apparent that one could notice the mistake
without use of any inferential process or
reasoning. Hence, we do not find force in the said
submission.
32. Having regard to the discussion above, we are of
21
the view that the Commission did not commit any
such glaring or apparent mistake in picking up
option ‘B’ as the correct answer for the concerned
question. The High Court, while acting on the
Expert Report, overlooked that the Expert Report
had only indicated a possible answer if the
question had been perceived as one relating
authorship of the Book. The said Expert Report did
not fault the question. Rather, it pointed out
that if matching had to be subject-wise i.e., as
to whom the Book was about, option ‘B’ was the
correct answer. Thus, the report does not in
certain terms declare option ‘B’ as the incorrect
answer. Moreover, authorship was not the
underlying principle for finding out the incorrect
pair. Thus, neither the question nor its answer is
patently incorrect. In such circumstances, there
was no occasion for the High Court to interfere
with the decision of the Commission, that too, in
the review jurisdiction.
33. Consequently, the appeal is allowed. The impugned
22
order is set aside. Writ A No.10221 of 2019 filed
by the respondent before the High Court is hereby
dismissed.
34. All pending application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.
………………………………………..J
[MANOJ MISRA]
………………………………………..J
[VIJAY BISHNOI]
New Delhi;
September 09, 2026
23
ITEM NO.8 COURT NO.10 SECTION XI
S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A
RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s). 12895/2026
[Arising out of impugned final judgment and order dated 20-03-2026
in CMRA No. 224/2021 passed by the High Court of Judicature at
Allahabad]
UTTAR PRADESH SUBORDINATE SERVICE SELECTION COMMISSIONPetitioner(s)
VERSUS
ASHOK YADAV & ORS. Respondent(s)
[FOR FINAL DISPOSAL]
IA No. 172288/2026 - EXEMPTION FROM FILING O.T.
IA No. 107477/2026 - EXEMPTION FROM FILING O.T.
Date : 09-09-2026 This matter was called on for hearing today.
CORAM :
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ MISRA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAY BISHNOI
For Petitioner(s) :
Mr. P.s. Patwalia, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Talha Abdul Rahman, AOR
Mr. Sudhanshu Tewari, Adv.
Ms. Deveshi Chand, Adv.
Mr. Faizan Ahmed, Adv.
Ms. Vibha Swaminathan, Adv.
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Sudhir Kumar Saxena, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Himanshu Raghave, Adv.
Mr. Umesh Dubey, AOR
Mr. Aviral Saxena, Adv.
Mr. Harsh Srivastava, Adv.
Mr. Abhinav Sharma, Adv.
Mr. Shivansh Rajput, Adv.
Mr. Fardeen Khan, Adv.
Mr. Raman Chugh, Adv.
Mr. Namit Saxena, AOR
24
Mr. M R Shamshad, Adv.
Mr. Shashank Singh, AOR
Mr. Sanjay Kumar, Adv.
Mr. Arijit Sarkar, Adv.
Ms. Prapti Shrivastava, Adv.
Ms. Sweety Gautam, Adv.
Mr. Varun Singh, Adv.
UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following
O R D E R
1. Leave granted.
2. The appeal is allowed in terms of the Reportable
signed order placed on the file.
3. All pending application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.
(CHETAN ARORA) (SAPNA BANSAL)
ASTT. REGISTRAR-cum-PS COURT MASTER (NSH)
25