Mithilesh Kumar Pathak vs Union Of India

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 1219
REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4411 OF 2011

MITHILESH KUMAR PATHAK …APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ORS. …RESPONDENT(S)

J U D G M E N T

SATISH CHANDRA SHARMA, J.

1. The present appeal arises out of the judgment and order
dated 05.05.2010 passed by the High Court of Judicature at
Patna ( hereinafter referred to as the “High Court” ) in Letters
Patent Appeal No. 921 of 2007, whereby the Division Bench set
aside the order dated 13.04.2007 passed by the learned Single
Judge in CWJC No. 5308 of 2004 and restored the order dated
29.03.2001 removing the Appellant from service as a Constable
in the Central Reserve Police Force ( hereinafter referred to as
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
RAHUL KUMAR
Date: 2026.11.16
18:13:08 IST
Reason:
the “CRPF” ).
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 1 of 10

2. The facts necessary for adjudication of the present appeal
are as follows:
th
2.1 The Appellant, posted with the 54 Battalion, CRPF, at
Anantnag, Jammu and Kashmir, was granted casual leave from
21.09.2000 to 12.10.2000 on the ground of his wife’s illness.
He was supposed to rejoin duty on 13.10.2000, but failed to do
so. The Company Commander sent two registered letters dated
26.10.2000 and 08.11.2000 directing the Appellant to report for
duty. However, he failed to respond to the letters and finally
reported for duty on 19.01.2001, thereby overstaying the
sanctioned leave by 99 days.
2.2 By an application dated 22.01.2001 addressed to the
Commandant, the Appellant explained that he had himself
fallen ill on 09.10.2000 while at his village in District Munger,
Bihar, and had undergone treatment for infective hepatitis under
Dr. S.N. Singh, a Medical Officer attached to Sadar Hospital,
Banka. He relied upon medical prescriptions, pathological
reports, receipts for purchase of medicines and a certificate
declaring him fit for duty on 13.01.2001. He further stated that
his illness, the absence of postal facilities in his village and his
wife’s inability to read or write had prevented him from
responding to the letters.
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 2 of 10

2.3 A memorandum of charges dated 25.01.2001 was issued
to the Appellant alleging firstly, unauthorised absence for 99
days and, secondly, disobedience of orders in not responding to
the two letters. The Appellant pleaded not guilty and produced
twelve documents in support of his case, including medical
certificates, pathological reports, etc. The Enquiry Officer, in
his report dated 17.03.2001, held both charges proved. The
medical documents were disbelieved principally because they
did not bear an indoor or outdoor patient number, the treatment
appeared to have been obtained privately, and the prescriptions
and medicine bills appeared to have been written with the same
pen. On this basis, the Enquiry Officer inferred that the
documents had been prepared on the same day and were
fabricated. Acting on the report, the Commandant, by order
dated 29.03.2001, imposed the penalty of ‘Removal from
Service’ on the Appellant with effect from the afternoon of
31.03.2001.
2.4 The departmental appeal and revision preferred by the
Appellant were rejected vide orders dated 11.01.2002 and
26.03.2004, respectively. During this period, the Appellant had
also approached the High Court in CWJC No. 8712 of 2001 and
CWJC No. 3333 of 2002.
2.5 Thereafter, the Appellant filed CWJC No. 5308 of 2004.
The learned Single Judge, by order dated 13.04.2007, allowed
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 3 of 10

the writ petition. It was held that the fact of overstay was
admitted and that the only question was whether the Appellant
had furnished a sufficient explanation for it. The learned Single
Judge found that the reasons given for rejecting the medical
documents rested on conjectures and surmises, and that the
reason given by the enquiry officer to disbelieve the absence or
overstayal of the Appellant for the period in question was not
based on sound reasoning. Accordingly, the orders of the
disciplinary, appellate and revisional authorities were quashed
and the Respondents were directed to accept the Appellant’s
joining.
3. Aggrieved thereby, the Respondents preferred Letters
Patent Appeal No. 921 of 2007. By the impugned judgment and
order dated 05.05.2010, the Division Bench allowed the appeal,
holding that the learned Single Judge had exceeded the limits of
judicial review by reappreciating the evidence as an appellate
authority. The Division Bench upheld the rejection of the
medical evidence and reasoned that, once the absence was held
to be unauthorised, the plea of illness failed and the charge of
insubordination stood established. It further held that past
conduct was relevant to the quantum of punishment and
emphasised the need to maintain discipline in a uniformed force
deployed in a sensitive area. The order of removal was
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 4 of 10

consequently restored. Aggrieved thereby, the Appellant has
approached this Court.
4. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellant
submitted that the learned Single Judge had rightly interfered
with findings which were founded on conjecture. It was
contended that the medical documents could not have been
treated as fabricated merely by reference to the pen or ink used,
or the absence of a hospital registration number, without
examining the treating doctor or otherwise verifying the
documents. It was further submitted that the earlier periods of
overstay had already been dealt with and could not justify
rejection of the explanation furnished in the present
proceedings. Learned counsel also urged that the penalty of
removal was disproportionate and that the procedure adopted in
the enquiry did not comply with Rule 27(c)(4) of the CRPF
Rules, 1955, concerning the opportunity to submit a written
statement and lead evidence in defence.
5. Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondents submitted that the Appellant, despite being a
member of a disciplined force posted in a sensitive area,
remained absent for 99 days without permission and failed to
comply with two directions to report for duty. It was contended
that the medical documents were procured to justify the
overstay and that the Appellant’s earlier absences demonstrated
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 5 of 10

repeated disregard of discipline. The Respondents relied upon
earlier periods of overstay of 71 days in 1994 and 175 days in
1999. It was further submitted that adequate opportunity had
been afforded to the Appellant during the enquiry and that the
learned Single Judge had impermissibly substituted his own
assessment of the evidence for that of the departmental
authorities.
6. We have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties
and perused the material placed on record.
7. The principal question which arises for consideration is
whether the Division Bench was justified in setting aside the
order of the learned Single Judge and restoring the penalty of
removal from service.
8. The limits of judicial review in disciplinary matters are
well settled. In State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. v. S. Sree
Rama Rao , 1963 SCC OnLine SC 6, wherein this Court held
that:
“ 7. … The High Court may undoubtedly interfere
where the departmental authorities have held the
proceedings against the delinquent in a manner
inconsistent with the rules of natural justice or in
violation of the statutory rules prescribing the
mode of enquiry or where the authorities have
disabled themselves from reaching a fair decision
by some considerations extraneous to the evidence
and the merits of the case or by allowing
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 6 of 10

themselves to be influenced by irrelevant
considerations or where the conclusion on the very
face of it is so wholly arbitrary and capricious that
no reasonable person could ever have arrived at
that conclusion, or on similar grounds. But the
departmental authorities are, if the enquiry is
otherwise properly held, the sole judges of facts
and if there be some legal evidence on which their
findings can be based, the adequacy or reliability
of that evidence is not a matter which can be
permitted to be canvassed before the High Court in
a proceeding for a writ under Article 226 of the
Constitution .”

9. Similar principle was reiterated in B.C. Chaturvedi v.
Union of India & Ors. , (1995) 6 SCC 749, wherein this Court
further observed that:
“ 18. A review of the above legal position would
establish that the disciplinary authority, and on
appeal the appellate authority, being fact-finding
authorities have exclusive power to consider the
evidence with a view to maintain discipline. They
are invested with the discretion to impose
appropriate punishment keeping in view the
magnitude or gravity of the misconduct. The High
Court/Tribunal, while exercising the power of
judicial review, cannot normally substitute its own
conclusion on penalty and impose some other
penalty. If the punishment imposed by the
disciplinary authority or the appellate authority
shocks the conscience of the High Court/Tribunal,
it would appropriately mould the relief, either
directing the disciplinary/appellate authority to
reconsider the penalty imposed, or to shorten the
litigation, it may itself, in exceptional and rare
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 7 of 10

cases, impose appropriate punishment with cogent
reasons in support thereof .”

10. Tested on the aforesaid principles, we are of the
considered view that the Division Bench erroneously set aside
the order passed by the Single Judge. Absence from duty
without prior permission may constitute unauthorised absence;
however, unauthorised absence and wilful absence are not
necessarily synonymous. The circumstances in which an
employee remained absent, the explanation furnished, and the
material supporting that explanation must be considered before
determining the nature and gravity of the misconduct. Illness or
other circumstances beyond an employee’s control may be
relevant to that determination, though they do not, by
themselves, automatically excuse the entire period of absence.
11. In the present case, the Appellant’s explanation was that
he had suffered from infective hepatitis and had undergone
treatment during the period of his absence. In support of this
explanation, he produced a series of documents, including
medical prescriptions, pathological reports, receipts relating to
the purchase of medicines and a certificate declaring him fit to
resume duty. The Enquiry Officer disregarded the said
documents, inter alia , on the ground that certain entries
appeared to have been made with the same pen and that the
documents did not bear an outpatient department number. On
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 8 of 10

the basis of these circumstances, the Enquiry Officer questioned
the authenticity of the documents and proceeded to disbelieve
the explanation furnished by the Appellant. No verification
from the treating doctor, the medical establishment or the
pharmacy supported that inference. Similarity in the writing or
ink, without material connecting it to fabrication, could not
reasonably sustain the conclusion drawn in the present case.
12. The absence of an indoor or outdoor patient number, and
the circumstance that the doctor appeared to have treated the
Appellant privately while affixing his official seal to the fitness
certificate, could call for clarification. These features did not,
by themselves, establish either that no treatment had been
received or that the documents were forged. The learned Single
Judge, therefore, rightly held that the rejection of the medical
documents rested on conjectures and surmises.
13. Furthermore, the punishment given to the Appellant
ought to have been proportionate to the magnitude and gravity
of the misconduct. We are conscious that the Appellant was a
member of a disciplined force posted in a sensitive area, and
that compliance with orders and timely reporting for duty are
essential obligations of such service. However, the punishment
imposed must satisfy the requirement of proportionality. In the
present case, the punishment of removal from service for over-
staying the period of 99 days is unduly harsh considering the
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 9 of 10

relevant circumstances. Even after taking into account the
earlier periods of overstay and the Appellant’s failure to
maintain communication, we are satisfied that the penalty of
removal from service, in these particular circumstances, is
grossly disproportionate in the facts of this case.
14. In the result, the appeal is allowed. The impugned
judgment and order dated 05.05.2010 passed by the High Court
in Letters Patent Appeal No. 921 of 2007 is set aside, and the
order dated 13.04.2007 passed by the learned Single Judge in
CWJC No. 5308 of 2004 is restored. The respondents are
directed to reinstate the appellant with immediate effect with a
direction to pay him 50% of the back wages for the period he
was removed from service till his reinstatement. He will be
entitled for all other consequential benefits.
15. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed
of.

.…………….…………………………………J.
[SATISH CHANDRA SHARMA]

..………………………………………………J.
[NONGMEIKAPAM KOTISWAR SINGH]

New Delhi
November 16, 2026
C. A. No. 4411 of 2011 Page 10 of 10