Rajesh Ebrahimkutty Majidha Beevi vs Akshay Gupta

Court
Delhi High Court

$~88
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
th
% Date of Decision: 17 November, 2026
# CNR No. DLHC010546442026
+ CRL.REV.P.(NI) 375/2026, CRL.M.A. 35467/2026 & CRL.M.A.
35468/2026

RAJESH EBRAHIMKUTTY MAJIDHA BEEVI AND ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Rahul Sharma, Mr. Himanshu
Sharma, Mr. Chandra Shekhar, Mr.
Kartik Malhotra, Ms. Shreya Mansi
James, Ms. Anika Pande, Mr. Utkarsh
Jaiswal and Mr. Lakshaya Chopra,
Advs.

versus

AKSHAY GUPTA .....Respondent

Through: Mr. Abhishek Varma and Mr. Saurabh
Agarwal, Advs. for R-1 with R-1 in
person

CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MINI PUSHKARNA
MINI PUSHKARNA, J. (Oral):
th
This matter is taken up today as 16 November, 2026, was declared as a
Holiday on account of “Chhath Puja”.
1. The present criminal revision petition has been filed under Section 438
read with Section 442 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
Signature Not Verified
Page 1 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

th
(“BNSS”), assailing the common order dated 09 October, 2026, passed by
the Additional Sessions Judge-06 (South), Saket Courts, New Delhi,
(“Appellate Court”) in CA No. 369/2025 and the other connect matter, only
insofar as the same dismisses the application of the petitioners for adducing
additional evidence in CA No. 369/2025 .
2. It is to be noted that respondent no. 1 instituted a complaint against the
petitioner under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (“NI
th
Act”), alleging dishonour of Cheque No. 251012 dated 25 April, 2017, for
Rs. 20,00,000/- (Twenty Lakhs Only).
3. The aforenoted complaint was allowed and the petitioners were
convicted under Section 138 of the NI Act by the Judicial Magistrate First
Class (“JMFC”) (NI Act)-04, South, Saket, New Delhi, by way of order dated
th
18 July, 2025, passed in CT Cases 8416/2017 .
4. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that the said
th
complaint was premised upon a Return Memo dated 11 July, 2017. He draws
the attention of this Court to Annexure P-7 , appended to the captioned
petition, which shows that the cheque in question was returned vide Return
th
Memo dated 11 July, 2017, recording the reason “ insufficient funds ”. The
said document is reproduced as under:
Signature Not Verified
Page 2 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

5. He submits that the bank statement of petitioner no. 2, as obtained from
Axis Bank, clearly shows that Cheque No. 251012 issued for Rs. 20,00,000/-
th
(Twenty Lakhs Only) was returned only on 27 April, 2017. He further
submits that the cheque in question was returned with the reason noted as
“ Drawers signature differs ”.
6. Thus, he submits that the bank statement of petitioner no. 2 clearly
th
shows that the cheque in question was returned on 27 April, 2017, and not
Signature Not Verified
Page 3 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

th th
on 11 July, 2017, and that there is no mention of any Return Memo of 11
July, 2017, in the said bank statement.
7. The relevant portion of the bank statement of petitioner no. 2, reflecting
the Cheque Return Details, is reproduced hereunder:
“xxx xxx xxx

xxx xxx xxx”
8. By referring to the aforesaid, learned counsel appearing for the
th
petitioners submits that the cheque in question was returned only on 27
th
April, 2017, and the Return Memo dated 27 April, 2017, has not been placed
on record by respondent no. 1 before the Trial Court.
9. Accordingly, he submits that the complaint was filed by respondent no.
th
1 before the Trial Court on the basis of the Return Memo dated 11 July,
th
2017, and not based on the Return Memo dated 27 April, 2017.
10. He also submits that as per the bank account details of petitioner no. 2,
the cheque in question was never presented by respondent no. 1 in July, 2017.
th
11. He, thus, submits that the Return Memo dated 11 July 2017, based on
which the complaint was filed by respondent no. 1, is a forged document.
st
12. He further draws the attention of this Court to the letter dated 01
September, 2026, issued by Axis Bank, and submits that it has been
categorically stated therein that the cheque in question was presented by
Signature Not Verified
Page 4 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

st
respondent no. 1 only once and not twice. The said letter dated 01 September,
2026, issued by Axis Bank, is reproduced as under:


Signature Not Verified
Page 5 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

13. In response, learned Additional Public Prosecutor (“APP”) appearing
for the State submits that the State is only a pro forma party in the present
case, as this is a private dispute between the petitioners and respondent no.
1/complainant.
14. Learned counsel appearing for respondent no. 1 submits that the Trial
Court has taken note of the fact that the cheque in question was presented
twice. However, proof of the previous presentation of the cheque was not
placed before the Trial Court.
th
15. He further submits that the subsequent Return Memo dated 11 July,
2017, was duly placed by respondent no. 1 before the Trial Court.
16. This Court has heard the submissions made by learned counsels
appearing for the parties and has perused the material on record.
17. This Court notes the submission made by learned counsel appearing for
the petitioners that the complaint filed by respondent no. 1 was based on the
th
Return Memo dated 11 July 2017, recording the reason for return as
“ Insufficient funds ”, which is contrary to the Cheque Return Details recorded
in the bank statement placed on record by the petitioners ( Annexure-7 ). In
support of the same, the petitioners have also placed on record documents to
th
show that no such cheque was presented to the bank on 11 July, 2017.
18. At the outset, it is noted that Section 432 of the BNSS, corresponding
to Section 391 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (“CrPC”), permits
the Appellate Court to take on record additional material to ensure complete
and effective adjudication of the pending appeal.
19. In this regard, it is pertinent to note the observations made by the
Supreme Court in Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh and Another Versus State of
Gujarat and Others, (2004) 4 SCC 158 , which read as under:
Signature Not Verified
Page 6 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

“xxx xxx xxx

36. The principles of rule of law and due process are closely
linked with human rights protection. Such rights can be
protected effectively when a citizen has recourse to the courts
of law. It has to be unmistakably understood that a trial which
is primarily aimed at ascertaining the truth has to be fair to all
concerned. There can be no analytical, all-comprehensive or
exhaustive definition of the concept of a fair trial, and it may
have to be determined in seemingly infinite variety of actual
situations with the ultimate object in mind viz. whether
something that was done or said either before or at the trial
deprived the quality of fairness to a degree where a
miscarriage of justice has resulted. It will not be correct to say
that it is only the accused who must be fairly dealt with. That
would be turning a Nelson’s eye to the needs of the society at
large and the victims or their family members and relatives.
Each one has an inbuilt right to be dealt with fairly in a
criminal trial. Denial of a fair trial is as much injustice to the
accused as is to the victim and the society. Fair trial obviously
would mean a trial before an impartial judge, a fair
prosecutor and atmosphere of judicial calm. Fair trial means
a trial in which bias or prejudice for or against the accused,
the witnesses, or the cause which is being tried is eliminated.
If the witnesses get threatened or are forced to give false
evidence that also would not result in a fair trial. The failure
to hear material witnesses is certainly denial of fair trial.
xxx xxx xxx
38. A criminal trial is a judicial examination of the issues in the
case and its purpose is to arrive at a judgment on an issue as
to a fact or relevant facts which may lead to the discovery of
the fact issue and obtain proof of such facts at which the
prosecution and the accused have arrived by their pleadings;
the controlling question being the guilt or innocence of the
accused. Since the object is to mete out justice and to convict
the guilty and protect the innocent, the trial should be a search
for the truth and not a bout over technicalities, and must be
conducted under such rules as will protect the innocent, and
punish the guilty. The proof of charge which has to be beyond
reasonable doubt must depend upon judicial evaluation of the
totality of the evidence, oral and circumstantial, and not by an
isolated scrutiny.
Signature Not Verified
Page 7 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

xxx xxx xxx
47. Section 391 of the Code is another salutary provision
which clothes the courts with the power to effectively decide
an appeal. Though Section 386 envisages the normal and
ordinary manner and method of disposal of an appeal, yet it
does not and cannot be said to exhaustively enumerate the
modes by which alone the court can deal with an appeal.
Section 391 is one such exception to the ordinary rule and if
the appellate court considers additional evidence to be
necessary, the provisions in Section 386 and Section 391 have
to be harmoniously considered to enable the appeal to be
considered and disposed of also in the light of the additional
evidence as well. For this purpose it is open to the appellate
court to call for further evidence before the appeal is disposed
of. The appellate court can direct the taking up of further
evidence in support of the prosecution; a fortiori it is open to
the court to direct that the accused persons may also be given
a chance of adducing further evidence. Section 391 is in the
nature of an exception to the general rule and the powers
under it must also be exercised with great care, especially on
behalf of the prosecution lest the admission of additional
evidence for the prosecution operates in a manner prejudicial
to the defence of the accused. The primary object of Section
391 is the prevention of a guilty man’s escape through some
careless or ignorant proceedings before a court or vindication
of an innocent person wrongfully accused. Where the court
through some carelessness or ignorance has omitted to record
the circumstances essential to elucidation of truth, the
exercise of powers under Section 391 is desirable.

48. The legislative intent in enacting Section 391 appears to
be the empowerment of the appellate court to see that justice
is done between the prosecutor and the persons prosecuted
and if the appellate court finds that certain evidence is
necessary in order to enable it to give a correct and proper
finding, it would be justified in taking action under Section
391.

49. There is no restriction in the wording of Section 391 either
as to the nature of the evidence or that it is to be taken for the
prosecution only or that the provisions of the section are only
to be invoked when formal proof for the prosecution is
Signature Not Verified
Page 8 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

necessary. If the appellate court thinks that it is necessary in
the interest of justice to take additional evidence, it shall do so.
There is nothing in the provision limiting it to cases where there
has been merely some formal defect. The matter is one of
discretion of the appellate court. As reiterated supra, the ends
of justice are not satisfied only when the accused in a criminal
case is acquitted. The community acting through the State and
the Public Prosecutor is also entitled to justice. The cause of
the community deserves equal treatment at the hands of the
court in the discharge of its judicial functions.

50. In Rambhau v. State of Maharashtra [(2001) 4 SCC 759 :
2001 SCC (Cri) 812] it was held that the object of Section 391
is not to fill in lacuna, but to subserve the ends of justice. The
court has to keep these salutary principles in view. Though
wide discretion is conferred on the court, the same has to be
exercised judicially and the legislature had put the safety valve
by requiring recording of reasons.
xxx xxx xxx
55. The courts, at the expense of repetition we may state, exist
for doing justice to the persons who are affected. The trial/first
appellate courts cannot get swayed by abstract technicalities
and close their eyes to factors which need to be positively
probed and noticed. The court is not merely to act as a tape
recorder recording evidence, overlooking the object of trial
i.e. to get at the truth. It cannot be oblivious to the active role
to be played for which there is not only ample scope, but
sufficient powers conferred under the Code. It has a greater
duty and responsibility i.e. to render justice, in a case where
the role of the prosecuting agency itself is put in issue and is
said to be hand in glove with the accused, parading a mock
fight and making a mockery of the criminal justice
administration itself.

xxx xxx xxx”
(Emphasis Supplied)
20. Accordingly, considering the facts and circumstances of the present
case as brought forth before this Court and in order to meet the ends of justice,
this Court is of the view that the petitioners ought to be allowed to lead
additional evidence before the Appellate Court.
Signature Not Verified
Page 9 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

21. However, considering that the petitioners have already been convicted
for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the NI Act, and to balance the
equities, this Court directs the petitioners to deposit a sum of Rs. 20,00,000/-
(Twenty Lakhs Only) before the Appellate Court, within a period of two
weeks, from today.
22. Subject to the petitioners depositing the sum of Rs. 20,00,000/-
(Twenty Lakhs Only) before the Appellate Court, within a period of two
weeks from today, the petitioners herein shall be permitted to lead additional
th
evidence with respect to the Return Memo dated 11 July, 2017, the bank
statement of petitioner no. 1 showing the return of the cheque in question only
th st
on 27 April, 2017, and the letter dated 01 September, 2026, issued by Axis
Bank.
23. The aforesaid additional evidence shall be produced by the petitioners
before the Appellate Court expeditiously, and the examination of the
additional witness(es) shall be completed preferably within a period of two
months, from today.
24. This Court further directs that no adjournment shall be taken by any
party.
25. Needless to state that when fresh evidence is produced by the
petitioners, learned counsel appearing for respondent no. 1/complainant shall
be granted full opportunity to cross-examine.
26. Since the petitioners are being granted an opportunity to lead additional
evidence, a similar opportunity to lead additional evidence in rebuttal shall, if
need be, be granted to respondent no. 1/complainant by the Appellate Court.
27. With the aforesaid directions, the present petition is accordingly
disposed of.
Signature Not Verified
Page 10 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50

28. The pending applications also stand disposed of.


MINI PUSHKARNA, J
NOVEMBER 17, 2026/KR
Signature Not Verified
Page 11 of 11

Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
Signing Date:21.11.2026
10:07:50