SAURABH GUPTA vs ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
COMMERCIAL APPELLATE DIVISION
ORIGINAL SIDE
AD-COM 9 of 2026
SAURABH GUPTA
Versus
ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED AND ORS.
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Debangsu Basak
-And-
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta
For the Appellant : Mr. Krishnaraj Thaker, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Suchismita Ghosh, Adv.
Mr. Abir Lal Singh, Adv.
Ms. A. Banerjee, Adv.
Mr. Malay Seal, Adv.
Mr. Rohan Thakur, Adv.
For the Respondent No. 1 : Mr. Avinash Kankani, Adv.
Mr. Aurin Chakraborty, Adv.
Ms. Shree Chatterjee, Adv.
For the Respondent No. 2 : Mr. Sayantan Bose, Adv.
Ms. Pooja Chakraborty, Adv.
Ms. Arti Bhattacharyya, Adv.
HEARING CONCLUDED ON : 17.11.2026
JUDGMENT DELIVERED ON : 20.11.2026
UPLOADED ON : 20.11.2026
AJAY KUMAR GUPTA, J.:-
1. The instant appeal, at the behest of the appellant/plaintiff, is
directed against the judgment and decree dated August 6, 2026
passed by the learned Single Bench in CS-COM/91/2024 (Old No.
2
CS/11/2018) [Saurabh Gupta Vs. Royal Sundaram General
Insurance Company Limited & Anr.].
2. By the said judgment, the suit was dismissed, and it was declared
that the appellant is not entitled to any claim or relief as prayed for.
3. The sum and substance of the appellant’s case is that the appellant
is carrying on a sole proprietorship business in the name and style
of M/s Gupta Infotech within the jurisdiction of this Court and
carrying on business of manufacturing compact fluorescent lamp
and allied products. The respondent no. 1 is an insurance company
and respondent no. 2 is a bank.
4. As per the need of the appellant, the respondent no. 2 always
rendered credit facilities to the appellant for financial assistance in
its business. The appellant insured his plants, machinery and
stocks in process, raw materials and finished goods, including goods
for which customs duty had been paid, with the respondent no. 1 in
2013 against fire and burglary. The policy was renewed from time to
time upon payment of premiums. The last policy was renewed from
04.09.2015 to 03.09.2016 bearing Policy number
YB00013052000102. The sum insured was Rs. 14,50,00,000/-. The
premium was Rs. 1,93,285/- for the said sum insured.
5. Accidentally, on 08.06.2016, a fire occurred in the office of the
appellant at location-1 SDF (G) Building, SEZ, 24 Pgs. (South), West
3
Bengal at about 10.20 hrs. Ultimately, the fire damaged the
appellant’s entire stock, raw materials and goods, resulting in severe
loss and damage. The appellant lodged a complaint at Ramnagar
Police Station, Falta, intimating about the incident of fire.
6. The appellant assessed his loss and damage to the tune of Rs.
10,74,79,736/- and, accordingly, lodged a claim with the respondent
no. 1 being claim no. YB1040. Respondent No. 1 appointed a
surveyor to conduct the statutory survey required for settlement of
the claim. The appellant furnished the said surveyors with all the
necessary documents, and the surveyors of Respondent no. 1
assessed the appellant’s loss to the extent of Rs. 1,94,46,960/-. Two
survey reports, one original and the other supplementary, both
dated 12.05.2017, are on record. The appellant also assessed his
loss and damage by his own auditor. The auditor’s report dated
29.03.2017 assessed the appellant’s loss at Rs. 10,74,79,736/- as
aforesaid.
7. On 20.06.2017, a draft copy of a purported settlement agreement
was handed over to the appellant from the local office of the
respondent no. 1, and the appellant was also asked to contact the
respondent no. 1 at the Chennai office.
8. The appellant, along with his representative, visited the Chennai
office of the respondent no. 1 and, as per the appellant, he was
4
practically forced and induced to sign the settlement agreement for
payment of Rs. 1,94,46,960/- with further assurance that payment
of the balance amount would be dealt with favourably.
9. It was also promised that the claim settlement amount would be
remitted via bank transfer to the appellant’s account. The appellant
signed the settlement agreement on 23.06.2017. According to the
appellant, the settlement agreement was executed based on
misrepresentation and undue influence by the respondent no. 1’s
representative. Since respondent no. 1 was the appellant’s insurer, it
was, through its employees, in a position to dominate the appellant’s
will.
10. After returning from Chennai, the appellant was compelled to lodge a
complaint on June 27, 2017 at Ramnagar police station in Kolkata
against such force and undue influence imposed upon the appellant
as same is void/voidable as against the appellant and immediately
instituted a suit against the respondent no. 1, inter alia , praying for
decree of declaration, permanent injunction, recovery of money and
other reliefs.
11. The settlement claim amount of the appellant amounting to Rs.
1,94,46,960/- was remitted by the respondent no. 1 to the bank
account of the appellant maintained with the respondent no. 2
within the jurisdiction of this Court. It was informed that the
5
facilities granted to the appellant were suo-motu reduced by the
respondent no. 2 and the amount of Rs. 1,94,46,960/- was adjusted
against the credit facility.
12. The suit was contested by the respondent no. 1 as well as
respondent No. 2 by filing written statements, thereby denying and
disputing all the contentions of the appellant save and except the
matter of record and further controverted the allegations as levelled
against them.
13. Altogether the Learned Single Judge framed 13 issues on the basis
of pleadings of the parties. Out of those, Issue nos. 1, 2, and 3 are as
regards the jurisdiction, maintainability and cause of action, decided
in favour of the appellant. Issue nos. 4 and 5 are with regard to the
validity of the subsisting insurance policy between the appellant and
respondent no. 1 and whether the appellant’s goods were damaged
by fire or whether the fire was attributable to any negligence or fault
of the appellant. These two issues are also decided in favour of the
appellant. Issue no. 10 is whether a relationship of Principal-agent
between the respondents was also decided in favour of the appellant.
14. The remaining issues were thoroughly assessed and discussed by
the learned Single Judge based on the evidence laid by the parties,
and finally it was concluded that the appellant failed to prove that
the settlement agreement was the outcome of force or undue
6
influence. The view of the Single Bench was very clear that the claim
of the appellant regarding respondent no. 1’s representative, who
assured him to pay the gross loss value, was neither pleaded nor
brought on record by evidence. Neither the name of the
representative nor the representative of the respondent No. 1 was
brought on record to satisfy the court with regard to the allegation of
imposing force or undue influence upon the appellant prior to
putting his signature on every page of the written settlement
agreement on June 23, 2017.
15. No documentary evidence was presented to prove or establish that
the respondent no. 1, at any point of time, assured the appellant to
settle the claim by an amount higher than the survey report. The
respondent no. 1 fully relied upon the surveyor’s report, which was
exhibited by the appellant after receiving the draft settlement
agreement [Ext. D1(2)] and final agreement [Ext. B]. The settlement
agreement has been finally discussed and signed by the parties for
full and final settlement, and payment, accordingly, made by the
respondent no.1, therefore, the learned Single Judge finally
dismissed the claim and relief sought for by the appellant.
16. Mr. Thaker, learned Sr. Counsel representing the appellant,
vehemently submitted and argued on several points. Firstly, the
surveyor’s reports dated May 12, 2017, claiming to be based on their
7
best knowledge and experience, were all along denied and refuted by
the appellant. The depreciation of materials and/or goods has been
deducted from the gross value of the goods are not permissible and
unsustainable in law although the surveyor has accepted that the
entire goods were damaged due to fire and assessed a tentatively
lower value of Rs. 9,68,75,785.44/- than the actual value assessed
by the appellant’s auditor to the tune of Rs. 10,74,79,736/-.
17. Secondly, the agreement is void/voidable since the signature
obtained in the settlement agreement in Chennai at the office of the
Respondent No.1 was the outcome of force and undue influence; the
same may be declared as void or voidable in accordance with law
and not binding upon the appellant.
18. Thirdly, the learned Single Bench wrongly relied upon the document
in connection with submission of no objection certificate of the
Commissioner of Customs and the banks for clearance to obtain the
said payment of Rs. 1,94,46,960/- without presentation during
proceedings in evidence is contrary to law and unsustainable in law.
19. Learned senior counsel has further drawn the attention of this Court
to the answer as well as evidence of P.W. 1, particularly question no.
279 to demonstrate that the first survey report did not itself contain
a justification for the assessment made, and that a supplementary
report became necessary. It is pointed out that, in answer to the said
8
question, the surveyor admitted that the supplementary report was
prepared after a joint meeting between the proprietor and the head
office officials of respondent no. 1, held in the surveyor’s presence.
The surveyor further admitted that the insurer, thereafter, advised
him to look into the post-fire transactions, and that the
supplementary report was submitted on that observation. Learned
senior counsel submits that the assessment of Rs. 1,94,46,960/-
was, thus, shaped at the instance of the insurer and was not an
independent, objective assessment.
20. Therefore, it is submitted that the judgment and decree passed by
the Commercial Court is based on surmises and conjectures and is
liable to be set aside, and the prayer made by the appellant in the
suit may be allowed.
21. Learned senior counsel has placed reliance on a decision passed in
the case of National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Boghara
1
Polyfab Private Limited to fortify his submission that if the
settlement agreement is based on fraud, coercion or undue
influence, the same ought not to be given effect and should be
declared as void and not binding upon the appellant.
22. Conversely, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent
no. 1 vociferously opposed the prayer of the appellant and submitted
1
(2009) 1 SCC 267
9
that the appellant was well aware that the claim amount was
reduced to Rs. 1,94,46,960/- after considering various relevant
factors by the surveyor. Thereafter, several discussions were held
between the parties. After due deliberation, they agreed to a
settlement at the final amount assessed by the surveyor on the basis
of the two reports. The draft settlement agreement was
remitted/sent to him, and he was asked to contact the
representative of respondent no. 1 at the Chennai office of
respondent no. 1. The appellant, along with the representative,
arrived at the Chennai office for execution after going through the
terms and conditions mentioned therein. Therefore, the question of
misrepresentation, force or undue influence, as alleged, does not
arise. The settlement agreement had been signed in the head office
of the respondent no. 1 in the presence of two witnesses.
23. The allegation made by the appellant is out and out false and
concocted, subsequently, for illegal motive or gain by lodging a
complaint in Kolkata, albeit the agreement was executed at Chennai.
At best, even for the sake of argument, he could have lodged a
complaint before the jurisdictional police station at Chennai, but
that was not done. A written complaint was lodged baselessly before
Ramnagar police station at Kolkata four (4) days after signing the
settlement agreement, i.e., after remitting the settled amount as per
10
the terms of the agreement into the bank. Furthermore, the
appellant failed to prove the allegations either through oral
testimony or documentary evidence in connection.
24. Even during examination of witnesses, PW 1 all along narrated that
the respondent no. 1’s representative assured him to pay gross loss
value. However, such facts were not pleaded in the pleadings nor
substantiated in evidence who was the actual representative of the
respondent no. 1. Therefore, the Single Judge did not rely upon any
of the allegations made by the appellant, and finally, the Single
Judge rightly dismissed the suit; as such, the instant appeal is liable
to be dismissed with costs.
25. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the bank also submitted and
admitted that the amount as aforesaid was remitted to the bank
account of the appellant and the said amount was adjusted against
credit facilities given to the appellant. Nothing more is required to be
submitted from the side of the said bank. The bank’s role is limited
to accepting money if someone remits any amount into the account
of any customer, and the same can be adjusted with the credit
facility, if found necessary. Therefore, no illegality arises from such
action of the bank.
26. Learned counsel appearing for the bank has submitted that, the
bank had acted as an agent of the respondent No. 1 so far as the
11
contract of insurance is concerned. In such context, therefore, he
submits that, the bank cannot be held to be jointly and/or severally
liable with the respondent No. 1 so far as the claim on account of
insurance is concerned in view of Section 230 of the Contract Act,
1872.
27. Heard the submissions and arguments advanced by the learned
counsels for the respective parties and, after careful perusal of the
materials made available on record as well as the judgment relied
upon by the appellant, this Court notes that the maximum issues
are decided in favour of the appellant as there are undisputed facts
that the appellant had insured the Plant & Machinery, stock-in-
process including raw materials, finished goods as well as customs
duty paid goods with the respondent No. 1 and paid insurance
premium. Further, a fire occurred in the office of the appellant at
location-1 SDF (G) Building, SEZ, 24 Pgs. (South), West Bengal on
08.06.2016 at about 10.20 hrs. There are also no disputes about the
quantity of materials and/or goods lost and damaged due to the fire.
The policy was valid on the date of incident of fire i.e. on 08.06.2016.
28. The crux of the case wholly rests on the issue whether the
settlement agreement was executed on the ground of allegation of
misrepresentation, force, undue influence or otherwise? To prove
such contention of the appellant, the appellant requires to suffice
12
with sufficient oral testimony and documentary evidence, but the
appellant could not prove the same by any evidence, either oral or
documentary evidence. The trial court has rightly assessed the whole
evidence carefully and finally rendered judgment narrating the
grounds in negative in the operative portion. This Court also concurs
with the same.
st
29. The surveyor’s 1 report was disagreed with by the appellant, but
subsequently, the supplementary survey report also indicated a
similar amount of loss and damages. The surveyor’s report was
based on various factors such as site inspection, incident leading to
fire, cause of fire, reason for damages to properties insured, fire
brigade report, police report, newspaper report, claim lodged on
third party, about claim of the appellant and finally assessed the
loss of stock viz. Raw material stock, packing materials stock, PCB
Components, CFL Components and finished stock. The surveyor
also assessed the difference of claim after physical verification after
the incident. The respondent no. 1 was stuck with the amount
assessed by the surveyor’s twin reports, as the insurance company
had to rely upon the survey reports based on the aforesaid overall
assessment. An experienced surveyor has been appointed for the
purpose of assessing the loss and damages of the appellant based on
various factors. The said amount was already indicated to the
13
appellant, and after deliberation and discussion, the appellant
agreed to the said amount of Rs. 1,94,46,960/- and in view of such
agreement, a draft agreement was sent/handed over. After being
satisfied, the appellant went to the head office of the respondent no.
1 in Chennai, and after arrival, the appellant agreed with the terms
and conditions as stipulated in the agreement. That settlement
amount was contemplated in the draft settlement agreement that
was made known to the appellant before reaching Chennai. After
reaching Chennai, the agreement was signed between the parties,
knowing each and every terms and conditions of the settlement
agreement. Even after signing the said settlement agreement at
Chennai, he could have lodged the complaint before the
jurisdictional police station at Chennai, if he had been forced or
pressured under undue influence, but he did not lodge the same,
knowing the fact that the cause of action arose therein. Upon
arriving at Kolkata, he lodged the complaint at Ramnagar PS after
four (4) days.
30. The settlement agreement, signed between the appellant and the
respondent No. 1, has been witnessed by two persons. One of the
witnesses to the settlement is a person of the appellant. The
settlement agreement, therefore, had been signed by the appellant in
presence of his representative who also witnessed such agreement.
14
31. On a query from this Bench, learned senior counsel for the appellant
was unable to state the present status of the complaint lodged at
Ramnagar Police Station on 27.06.2017. No material has been
placed on record to show that the complaint led to any investigation,
report or proceeding. In any event, the mere lodging of a complaint is
not proof of the allegations made in it. The appellant was required to
establish force and undue influence by evidence in the suit, and the
complaint does not supply that proof. The dispute arises out of a
written settlement agreement executed after deliberation, in the
presence of two witnesses, and at best discloses a civil dispute
between the parties.
32. The learned Single Judge rejected all his contentions that once the
settlement agreement was signed by and between the parties and the
signatures were put on it in the presence of witnesses, without
proving the same was obtained by coercion, undue influence, force
or threat, the same cannot be declared void or voidable.
33. Before signing, the appellant was fully aware that the amount had
been assessed by the surveyor. The same amount was reflected in
the draft settlement agreement as well as in the final agreement,
which was signed on every page by the parties in the presence of two
witnesses. A party who has executed a written settlement is bound
by it, and cannot resile from it merely by asserting that his signature
15
was obtained by force or undue influence, or by a party in a
dominant position. It is open to him to avoid the agreement only if
he establishes the vitiating circumstance. The appellant did not
examine any of the witnesses who were present when he signed
every page, to show that he had signed under protest or without
consent. This Court is conscious that a written instrument may be
avoided if it was obtained by fraud, coercion or undue influence. The
appellant, however, has failed to prove any of them, and the
settlement therefore binds him.
34. The appellant’s challenge to the surveyor’s reports on the quantum
of loss, including the deduction of depreciation, does not arise for
consideration. The dispute as to quantum was resolved by the
written settlement agreement dated 23.06.2017, which, as held
above, was voluntarily executed and binds the appellant. So long as
the settlement stands, the assessment made by the surveyor cannot
be re-opened.
35. Even for the sake of argument, if it is assumed that the learned
Single Bench wrongly relied upon the document in connection with
submission of no objection of Commissioner of Customs and the
banks for clearance to obtain the said payment of Rs. 1,94,46,960/-
without presentation in evidence, it also does not aid the appellant’s
allegation and contention to succeed his case, when the entire case
16
rests on consent , settlement and admitted written settlement
agreement dated June 23, 2017 (Ext B).
36. Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant has
relied upon the decision in National Insurance Company Limited
v. Boghara Polyfab Private Limited (Supra) . It lays down that a
settlement or discharge voucher must be validly and voluntarily
executed. If the party who executed it alleges fraud, coercion or
undue influence and is able to establish it, the discharge is rendered
void and cannot be acted upon, and the position is the same before a
Civil Court. The proposition is sound, but it is conditional on proof.
The decision itself directs that a Civil Court shall examine the
evidence and, if it finds no fraud, coercion or undue influence,
accept the voucher as a discharge and reject the claim without
examining the merits. Here the suit has been tried and the question
is one of proofs. A draft agreement was furnished on 20.06.2017,
three days before execution, for the very amount assessed by the
surveyor and already known to the appellant. The agreement was
signed on every page before two witnesses, none of whom was
examined by the appellant. The representative, said to have exerted
influence, was never identified, and the assurance of a higher
payment was neither pleaded nor proved, so the allegation of being
“practically forced and induced” remains bare. The alleged
17
assurance that the balance would be “dealt with favourably” is, in
any event, an expression of hope and not a misrepresentation of fact
or an act of coercion.
37. The answer to question no. 279 does not assist the appellant either.
It concerns the assessment of quantum, which preceded the survey
reports of 12.05.2017 and the execution at Chennai by more than
five weeks. It shows that the supplementary report was submitted at
the plaintiff’s own request after his proprietor met the insurer’s head
office officials in a joint meeting and put forward his own contention,
which is the conduct of a party negotiating and not of one whose will
was overborne. Nor does it suggest that the assessment was shaped
at the insurer’s instance. The appellant, therefore, failed to establish
the vitiating circumstance, and, therefore, the aforesaid decision
does not advance his case.
38. The respondent No. 2 has acted as an agent of the respondent No. 1,
the insurance company, so far as the contract of insurance is
concerned. Under Section 230 of the Contract Act, 1872 the
respondent No. 2, therefore, cannot be sued. Respondent No. 2 has
acted as the agent of the disclosed principal that is the respondent
No. 1. The appellant, therefore, could not have sought a decree
emanating out of the contract of insurance as against the
respondent No. 2 as sought to be done.
18
39. Under the above facts and circumstances, this Court does not find
any valid or cogent reasons to interfere with the impugned judgment
passed by the learned Single Judge. The appeal, thus fails.
Consequentially, the impugned judgment calls for no interference.
40. Accordingly, AD-COM 9 of 2026 is dismissed .
41. Connected application, if any, is also thus disposed of.
42. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
43. Urgent certified copy of this order, if applied for be supplied to the
parties upon usual undertakings.
(AJAY KUMAR GUPTA , J.)
44. I agree .
(DEBANGSU BASAK, J.)
PA