Court On Its Own Motion vs State
- Court
- Delhi High Court
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 21.09.2026
Pronounced on: 18.11.2026
Uploaded on: 18.11.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010292522021
+ CRL.REF. 2/2021
COURT ON ITS OWN MOTION ...Petitioner
Through: Mr. Harsh Prabhakar
( Amicus Curiae ), Ms.
Pallavi Garg, Mr. Yash
Kotak, Mr. Dhruv
Chaudhry, Mr. Shubham
Sourav and Mr. Vijit
Singh, Advs.
versus
STATE ...Respondent
Through: Mr. Aman Usman, APP
with Mr. Manvendra
Yadav, Adv. with SI
Rahul, P.S. Tigri for State.
Mr. Amit Tiwari, CGSC
with Ms. Ayushi
Srivastava, Mr. Arpan
Narwal, Mr. Kushagra
Malik and Mr. Ujjwal
Tyagi, Advs. for UOI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN BHARDWAJ
J U D G M E N T
ARUN BHARDWAJ, J.
1. Reference : In this Criminal Reference under Section
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 1 of 28
395(2) read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (‘hereinafter referred to as ‘Cr.P.C.’), the learned
Metropolitan Magistrate- 04, South District, Saket Courts, New
Delhi has referred the following questions of law for the decision
of this Court:
“Q.1 Would releasing the accused/
foreign national on unconditional bail,
who is apprehended on charge of
overstaying in India after expiry of his
visa, not tantamount to legalizing his
future stay in India without valid visa,
which is otherwise an offence under
section 14 of Foreigners Act, 1946? Can
granting of bail to a foreign national
overshadow the provisions of Foreigners
Act, 1946 and can the bail order be used
by a foreign national as a substitute for
a visa to remain in country?
Q.2 Should the matters of foreign
nationals, who are accused for offence
u/s 14 of Foreigners Act, 1946, and
particularly where accused himself
concedes that his visa has expired before
date of his apprehension, be not treated
differently than other criminal cases?
Q.3 If bail is granted to a foreign
national, can certain conditions be
imposed on such foreign nationals
including to keep them in detention
centre till completion of their trail, so as
to refrain them to evade the process of
justice and not to allow them to remain
the country without having any valid
visa?”
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 2 of 28
Brief facts of the case :
2. The learned Magistrate was seized of the bail application
of a Nigerian national, for the alleged offence under Section 14
of the Foreigners Act, arising out of FIR No. 267/2021 registered
at Police Station Tigri, New Delhi.
3. It was found that the foreign national had come to India in
the year 2016 on a tourist visa for a period of 3 months.
However, he continued living in India even after the expiry of his
visa.
4. It was submitted by the learned counsel appearing for the
foreign national therein, that the foreign national was entitled to
bail and that he would apply for an extension of visa, once he is
granted bail. In furtherance, reliance was placed on the judgment
of this Court in Omokhosio v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) ,
2018 SCC OnLine Del 11966.
5. On the other hand, the learned APP for the State relied on
the judgment of the High Court of Karnataka in Babul Khan v.
State of Karnataka, 2020 SCC OnLine Kar 3438, to contend that
if bail is granted to a foreign national, he should be kept in a
detention centre.
6. The present reference was listed before this Court on
21.09.2021 and Mr. Harish Prabhakar, Advocate, was appointed
as the Amicus Curiae , to assist this Court.
Subsequent developments :
7. Certain subsequent developments, which have taken place
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 3 of 28
since the making of this reference, would show that the questions
which arose in the case pending before the learned Magistrate
stand considered and answered. Three such developments shall
be discussed in the following paragraphs.
8. First development : The first development, since making
of this reference, is that the Foreigners Act, 1946 (hereinafter
referred to as, ‘1946 Act’) has been repealed by the Immigration
and Foreigners Act, 2025 (hereinafter referred to as, ‘2025 Act’).
The Passport (Entry into India) Act, 1920 (34 of 1920), the
Registration of Foreigners Act, 1939 (16 of 1939), and the
Immigration (Carriers’ Liability) Act, 2000 (52 of 2000) have
also been repealed.
9. The law regarding penalty for contravention of the 1946
Act, provided under Section 14 of the 1946 Act, is as under:
“14. Penalty for contravention of
provisions of the Act, etc. —Whoever. —
(a) remains in any area in India for a
period exceeding the period for which
the visa was issued to him;
(b) does any act in violation of the
conditions of the valid visa issued to him
for his entry and stay in India or any
part thereunder;
(c) contravenes the provisions of this Act
or of any order made thereunder or any
direction given in pursuance of this Act
or such order for which no specific
punishment is provided under this Act,
shall be punished with imprisonment for
a term which may extend to five years
and shall also be liable to fine; and if he
has entered into a bond in pursuance of
clause (f) of sub-section (2) of section 3,
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 4 of 28
his bond shall be forfeited, and any
person bound thereby shall pay the
penalty thereof or show cause to the
satisfaction of the convicting Court why
such penalty should not be paid by him.
Explanation.— For the purposes of this
section, the expression “visa” shall have
the same meaning as assigned to it under
the Passport (Entry into India) Rules,
1950 made under the Passport (Entry
into India) Act, 1920 (34 of 1920).”
10. The corresponding provision in the 2025 Act, is in Section
23, titled ‘ Penalty for contraventions of other provisions of this
Act ’, and reads as under:
“ 23. Penalty for contraventions of other
provisions of this Act. — Whoever, —
(a) being a foreigner, remains in any
area in India for a period exceeding the
period for which the visa was issued to
him or stays in India without a valid
passport or other valid travel document
in contravention of provisions of section
3 or does any act in violation of the
conditions of the valid visa issued to him
for his entry and stay in India or any
part thereunder;
(b) contravenes any other provisions of
this Act, other than sections 17 and 19,
or of any rule or order made thereunder
or any direction or instruction given in
pursuance of this Act or such order or
direction or instruction for which, no
specific punishment is provided under
this Act,
shall be punishable with an
imprisonment for a term which may
extend to three years or with a fine
which may extend to three lakh rupees or
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 5 of 28
with both. ”
11. Section 25 of the 2025 Act also provides for compounding of
certain offences.
12. Further, in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 7
read with Sections 3 and 11 of the 2025 Act, and in supersession of
the Foreigners Order, 1948, the Foreigners (Protected Areas) Order,
1958, the Foreigners (Restricted Areas) Order, 1963 and the
Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964, the Central Government has
issued the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025.
13. While there is no provision like Section 3(2)(g) of the 1946
Act, empowering the Central Government to make orders providing
for the arrest and detention or confinement of a foreigner,
Paragraph 8(2) of the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025
provides that “ Every State Government and Union territory
Administration shall set up dedicated holding centres or camps for
the purpose of restricting the movement of foreigners, till they are
deported ”.
14. The explanation added to Paragraph 12 of the Immigration
and Foreigners Order, 2025 further explains that the term “illegal
migrant”, for the purposes of the aforesaid paragraph, shall have the
same meaning as assigned to it in Paragraph (b) of Sub-Section (1)
of Section 2 of the Citizenship Act, 1955 (57 of 1955), which is as
under:
“ 2. Interpretation. ―(1) In this Act,
unless the context otherwise requires, ―
xxxx
(b) “illegal migrant” means a foreigner
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 6 of 28
who has entered into India―
(i) without a valid passport or other
travel documents and such other
document or authority as may be
prescribed by or under any law in that
behalf; or
(ii) with a valid passport or other travel
documents and such other document or
authority as may be prescribed by or
under any law in that behalf but remains
therein beyond the permitted period of
time;…”
15. Paragraph 12(4) of the Immigration and Foreigners Order,
2025 provides for the procedure, which shall be followed in the
cases of illegal migrants apprehended within India.
16. Paragraph 12(4)(a) provides that a suspected illegal migrant
shall be imposed with restrictions on movement in a holding centre
or camp, as may be specified by the authorities referred to in sub-
Paragraph (3), in terms of provisions of the Act and rules and
Paragraph 8 of the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025,
pending deportation.
17. Paragraph 16 of the Immigration and Foreigners Order,
2025, provides for constitution of Foreigners Tribunals, to
determine whether a person is or is not a foreigner within the
meaning of the 2025 Act.
18. As per Section 2(f) of the 2025 Act, “foreigner” means a
person who is not a citizen of India.
19. Second development : The second development, during
the pendency of the present reference, is that the Ministry of
Home Affairs has issued a Circular, bearing No.25022/40/2021-
F.I, dated 10.12.2025, containing the Standard Operating
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 7 of 28
Procedure (hereinafter referred to as, ‘SOP’) for processing visa
cases of foreign nationals who are involved in criminal cases and
are granted bail and whose presence is required in India to attend
the court proceedings or where an application has been filed
under Section 360 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita,
2023 (hereinafter referred to as, ‘BNSS’) for withdrawal from
prosecution.
20. The said SOP is reproduced as under:
“ Standard Operating Procedure (SOP)
to be followed for processing visa cases
of foreign nationals who are involved in
criminal cases & granted bail and
whose presence is required in India to
attend the court proceedings, or where
an application has been filed under
section 360 of BNSS, 2023 for
withdrawal from prosecution
1. Normally, any foreigner who is
involved in criminal activities is to be
deported from the country forthwith.
However, in cases where an offence has
been registered against the foreigner
under the relevant provisions of the law
for the time being in force, the foreigner
can be deported only after completion of
the legal proceedings or completion of
the sentence, as the case may be.
Ministry of Home Affairs has separately
circulated a model SOP for withdrawal
from prosecution in cases filed against
foreigners under section 360 of
Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita,
2023 (46 of 2023) so as to facilitate their
early deportation from the country vide
MHA’s letter no. 25022/34/2024-F.I
(Part-I) dated 25.11.2025.
Notwithstanding the above, the presence
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 8 of 28
of the foreigner against whom an offence
has been registered would be required in
India during investigation / trial or till
the consent of the Trial Court concerned
is obtained for withdrawal from
prosecution under section 360 of BNSS,
2023. Such a foreigner may require a
visa for his/ her stay in the country. This
is also necessary so as to keep a record
of such foreigners and for tracking their
movements. This SOP deals with the
procedure to be followed in processing
visa cases of such foreigners.
2. Following types of cases shall be
covered by this SOP:-
(i) Cases where the foreigner is on bail
and case is under trial
(ii) Cases where the FIR has been
registered against the foreigner for his
involvement in serious offences and case
is under investigation
(iii) Cases where an application has
been filed under section 360 of BNSS,
2023 for withdrawal from prosecution
(iv) Cases where the prosecuting agency
(Central or State/UT) has filed appeal
against orders of Trial / Acquittal court
(v) Cases where the Hon'ble Supreme
Court/High Court/ Trial Court
specifically orders for grant of visa to
the foreign national to stay in India for
completion of legal proceedings
(vi) Cases of following categories of
dependents of the foreign national who
is under trial: -
(a) A minor child to a single parent
(b) A critically-ill patient under medical
treatment
(c) Old parent(s)
3. At the time of being charge-
sheeted or prosecuted, if the foreign
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 9 of 28
national is holding any type of valid
visa, the same shall be cancelled by the
FRRO/ FRO concerned with immediate
effect, in terms of the provisions in the
Visa Manual. All activities, which were
permitted under the cancelled visa, shall
be prohibited from the date of
cancellation of the visa.
4. In all cases covered by para 2
above, FRRO concerned may grant X-
Misc. Visa as indicated below, with the
prior approval of the Bureau of
Immigration: -
(i) In all cases covered in para 2 above
[other than clauses (iv) & (vi)], X-Misc.
Visa may be granted initially for a
period of six months or till the
completion of the legal proceedings or
till the consent of the Trial Court
concerned is obtained for withdrawal
from prosecution against the foreign
national, whichever is earlier.
(ii) In cases covered by clause (iv) of
para 2 above, X-Misc. Visa may be
granted for a period of six months or till
the final orders of the Appellate Court
on the appeal or deportation of the
foreigner, whichever is earlier.
(iii) In cases covered by clause (vi) of
para 2 above, X-Misc. Visa may be
granted for a period of six months or till
the completion of the legal proceedings
against the foreign national under trial
or till the consent of the Trial Court
concerned is obtained for withdrawal
from prosecution against the said
foreign national, whichever is earlier.
(iv) In respect of cases covered by
clauses (i) to (v) of para 2 above, X-
Misc. Visa shall be granted with the
endorsement "Permitted to stay for
Court purpose". The passport/
Certificate of Registration of the foreign
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 10 of 28
national concerned shall be endorsed
accordingly.
(v) In respect of cases covered by clause
(vi) of para 2 above, X-Misc. Visa may
be issued with endorsement "Dependent
of the foreigner permitted to stay for
Court purpose". The passport/
Certificate of Registration of the said
foreign national shall be endorsed
accordingly.
(vi) In case there is a requirement of
extension of visa, especially in cases
covered by clause (i) in para 2 above, X-
Misc. Visa may be further extended by
FRRO concerned for multiples of six
months depending upon the progress of
the case subject to production of court
orders, and ensuring that the foreign
national is attending the Court and not
deliberately delaying the trial. It may
also be ensured that the foreigner gets
his visa extended regularly, as and when
required, until the case is disposed of.
(vii) A processing fee of Rs 10,000/-
shall be levied irrespective of the
nationality, for granting/ every extension
of such X-Misc. Visa.
(viii) The foreign national shall not have
any right under X-Misc. Visa granted for
stay in India for court purpose. No other
activities, such as employment, business,
tourism etc., shall be allowed on such X-
Misc. Visa.
5. In the case of any foreign national
who is staying in India on a dependent
visa to a foreign national who is charge-
sheeted or prosecuted [other than those
covered by clause (vi) of para 2 above],
the dependent visa shall also be
cancelled and the dependent(s) shall be
issued Exit Permission/ Leave India
Notice, as the case may be.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 11 of 28
6. Foreign nationals involved in
petty offences which are usually
punishable with nominal fine or shorter
term of imprisonment may be deported
to their native country immediately after
completion of the sentence or after
paying the penalty. In case any such
foreigner expresses his/her inability to
pay the penalty, he/she may be deported
forthwith and he/she may be blacklisted
under appropriate category as per the
prevailing Black list guidelines of MHA.
7. On completion of the trial or on
receipt of final orders of the Appellate
Court on the appeal or receipt of consent
of the Trial Court concerned for
withdrawal from prosecution the X-Misc.
Visa shall be cancelled forthwith.
Necessary action shall be taken
immediately to issue Leave India Notice
(LIN) or deportation, except in those
cases where the foreign national has
been sentenced to undergo
imprisonment. In cases where the
foreign national has been sentenced to
undergo imprisonment, necessary action
will be taken to issue Leave India Notice
(LIN) or deportation after completion of
the sentence. After the exit/ deportation
of the foreign national, he/she may be
blacklisted under appropriate category
as per the prevailing Black list
guidelines of MHA.
8. The Law Enforcement Agency
shall ensure that cases involving foreign
nationals are fast tracked and must try to
ensure that the case is completed before
the expiry of the X-Misc. Visa, so that
the requirement of the foreigner for stay
in India is not prolonged due to reasons
of court cases.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 12 of 28
9. The bail granted by Hon'ble
Court may be with certain conditions
including the place of stay and police
reporting at regular intervals etc. Civil
Authority/Distt. SP/FRO are
empowered under Para 7(2)(f) of the
Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025
to impose restriction on movements of a
foreign national. If the investigation
authority or State Govt. wants, they can
request the Hon'ble Court to get the
condition, as envisaged under Section
7(2)(f) of the Immigration and
Foreigners Act, 2025, incorporated in
the court order itself considering the
gravity of offence committed by the
foreigner, chances of evading court
trials by absconding from India by using
different means etc.”
(emphasis supplied)
21. This Court, in its order dated 24.03.2026, noted that the
said Circular does not clarify if a foreign national who, inter alia ,
is being prosecuted for the offence under Section 14 of the 1946
Act and/or under Section 23 of the 2025 Act, shall also be
eligible for grant of an X-Misc. Visa.
22. The Foreigners Regional Registration Office (hereinafter
referred to as, ‘FRRO’) then filed an affidavit dated 17.07.2026,
wherein it was clarified that a foreign national, who, inter alia , is
being prosecuted for the offence under Section 14 of the 1946
Act and/or under Section 23 of the 2025 Act, shall not be eligible
for the grant of an X-Misc. Visa. It was then suggested by the
FRRO that for such foreign nationals involved in the offences
under the 1946 Act or under the 2025 Act, another option in the
form of compounding of offence is available under Section 25 of
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 13 of 28
the 2025 Act. The foreign nationals fulfilling the eligibility
conditions, as mentioned in the 2025 Act, can pay the requisite
penalty amount and get the offence compounded.
23. Section 25 of the 2025 Act reads as under:
“25. Compounding of certain
offences.—
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained
in the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023, any offence punishable
under sections 21, 23 or section 24
whether committed by an individual or a
company or an organisation or any
officer or employee or a representative
thereof, may, either before the institution
of prosecution or during trial, be
compounded by such officers or
authorities and for such sums as the
Central Government may, by
notification, specify in this behalf:
Provided that the sum so specified shall
not, in any case, exceed the maximum
amount of the fine which may be
imposed under sections 21 or 23 for the
offence so compounded.
(2) Nothing contained in sub-section (1)
shall apply to an offence committed, by
an individual or a company or an
organisation or any officer or employee
or representative thereof within a period
of three years from the date on which a
similar offence committed by it or him
was compounded under this section.
(3) Every officer or authority referred to
in sub-section (1) shall exercise the
powers to compound an offence, subject
to the directions, control and supervision
of the Central Government.
(4) Where any offence is compounded
before the institution of any prosecution
or before commencement of trial, no
prosecution shall be instituted in relation
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 14 of 28
to such offence, against the offender in
relation to whom the offence is so
compounded.
(5) Where the compounding of an
offence is made after the institution of
prosecution or during trial, such
compounding shall be brought by the
authority specified for such
compounding in writing, to the notice of
the court in which the prosecution or
trial is pending and on such notice of the
compounding of offences being given,
the individual or the company or the
organisation or any officer or employee
in relation to whom the offence is so
compounded shall be discharged.
(6) For the purposes of this section, any
second or subsequent offence committed
after the expiry of a period of three years
from the date on which the offence was
previously compounded, shall be deemed
to be a first offence.”
24. At this stage, it is pertinent to note a few judgments which
have been referred by Mr. Harsh Prabhakar, Advocate ( Amicus
Curiae ).
25. The learned Amicus Curiae has referred to the judgment
of the Supreme Court in Louis De Raedt v. Union of India and
Others , (1991) 3 SCC 554; of this Court in Lambert Kroger v.
Enforcement Directorate , (2000) SCC Online Del 208; and H.B.
Chaturvedi v. C.B.I ., (2010) SCC Online Del 2155; and of the
High Court of Allahabad in Sagynbek Toktobolotov and Ors. v.
State of U.P ., 2020 SCC OnLine All 754.
26. A reading of these judgments shows that it has been
observed that a foreign national is protected by Article 21 of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 15 of 28
Constitution of India for his life and liberty. The law does not
authorise or permit any discrimination between a foreign national
and an Indian national in the matter of grant of bail. What is
permissible is that, considering the facts and circumstances of
each case, the court may impose different conditions to ensure
that the accused, who is a foreign national, will be available for
facing the trial. An application for bail, therefore, cannot be
rejected solely on the ground that the applicant is a foreign
national.
27. Reference is also made by the learned Amicus Curiae to
the judgment in Mr. Junia Erastus Mayemba v. The Bureau of
Immigration , 2017:KHC:10760, wherein the High Court of
Karnataka at Bengaluru was of the view that in a case where the
accused has overstayed, in violation of the law, such accused is
to be penalised and if he is to suffer imprisonment, his overstay
would only be extended further. Any such proceedings taken
against him would necessarily be at the cost of the State
exchequer. The Court opined therein that as the justice
dispensation system of this country is also over-loaded therefore,
there is no need to add more cases of such kind. It was opined
that it would be in the interest of all, particularly the State
exchequer, to ensure that the accused, in such cases, leaves the
country at the earliest. The FRRO was, accordingly, directed to
issue an exit permit to the petitioner therein, without insisting
upon the petitioner facing action for violation of rules and
regulations, as already alleged. It was further directed that the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 16 of 28
criminal case pending against the petitioner therein should also
be dropped, provided that it is ensured that on issuance of such
exit permit, he is escorted by the airport police till he is subjected
to security check and proceeded on his onward journey to his
country.
28. The learned Amicus Curiae has also referred to
Tshibambula Jennifer Kabantobelu v. State of Karnataka ,
2018:KHC:8276, decided by High Court of Karnataka. The
petitioner therein, a Congo national, was facing trial for the
offence under Section 14 of the 1946 Act and Clause 7(2) of the
Foreigners Order, 1948. The petitioner had approached the
FRRO for grant of exit permit to return to her country and after
considering her representation, the FRRO had imposed a penalty
of ₹10,400/- for overstaying in the territory of India, which was
duly paid. Thereafter, she had purchased an air ticket and
submitted before the FRRO for grant of exit permit to leave the
country (India) and an exit permit was granted. But when she
was about to travel from Mumbai to Brussels, the immigration
authorities at Mumbai Airport detained her, took her into custody
and later remanded her to judicial custody. As no other case was
pending against the petitioner therein, the High Court of
Karnataka observed that permitting the petitioner to continue to
stay in the country would only be legalising the overstay and
would not serve any purpose. Therefore, the proceedings pending
against the petitioner were quashed and she was acquitted of the
alleged offence, with the direction to the petitioner to exit the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 17 of 28
country within two weeks. The authorities were directed to
provide her exit permit and the Look Out Circular issued against
her was directed to be withdrawn.
29. In the case of Mr. Freddy Tshimanga Kanyama v. The
Bureau of Immigration & Ors. , 2016 SCC OnLine Kar 3874,
referred by learned Amicus Curiae , the petitioner therein was
prosecuted for the offence under Section 14 of the 1946 Act. It
was held therein:
“Since the object of the Act and Rules
are to deter foreigners from over-staying
in India and if the petitioner for one
reason or other did not obtain extension
of visa from 2013, the petitioner being
prosecuted and remaining in India
would run counter-productive. It is best
to get him rid of India at the earliest.”
30. The petitioner therein was directed to catch the next flight
to his country after 8 days, with the direction that if he remains in
India beyond one hour of his flight time, he shall be arrested and
kept in prison till the case is over.
31. In the case of Farhan Hussain v. State & Ors., 2020 SCC
OnLine Kar 1194, also referred by learned Amicus Curiae , the
petitioners therein were tried for the offence under Section 14 of
the 1946 Act. It was directed that the FRRO shall provide an exit
permit to the petitioners and ensure their exit from the country
forthwith, if their presence is not required in any other case, and
subject to paying of fine as may be levied by the competent
authority.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 18 of 28
32. Third development : The third development since making
of this reference is that in the case of Efrance Namatende v.
State , Bail Application 2214/2022 dated 09.01.2023, a judgment
passed by a learned Single Judge of this Court, the condition in
the bail order passed in the case of the petitioner therein, who
was being prosecuted under Section 14 of the 1946 Act, that she
shall remain in an observation home till she is granted a valid
visa for India, was quashed observing that for a violation of
Section 14 of the 1946 Act, there is no requirement that the
applicant is to be confined to an observation home.
33. In the case of Emechere Maduabuchkwu v. State NCT of
Delhi & Anr ., 2023:DHC:3872, a learned Single Judge of this
Court was dealing with a case in which the petitioner therein was
being tried for the offence under Sections 33/38/58 of the Delhi
Excise Act, 2009 and Section 14 of the 1946 Act. He was granted
bail by the learned Magistrate with a condition to keep him in a
detention centre till the conclusion of the trial. The learned ASJ,
subsequently, on an application, admitted the petitioner on bail
and directed for his release from the detention centre, however,
he was still not released from the said detention centre. It was
held by this Court that granting such foreigners a special
permit/visa/travel document would not legitimize their earlier
offence of having overstayed in violation of the provisions of the
1946 Act, but would in fact ensure that they are not confined in a
detention centre at state expense, but instead are restricted to a
place on conditions as may be prescribed and furnish
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 19 of 28
bond/sureties to ensure compliance of such conditions. This
would ensure a judicious balance between recognizing liberty
and a human right and ensuring the presence of foreign nationals
for the purpose of trial and being subject to
restrictions/regulations/conditions. It was further held that a
Court or Magistrates or a Sessions Court cannot, as part of
enlarging foreign national on bail, also direct the said person to
be sent to a detention centre since the court is not competent to
pass such a direction when granting bail. Detention centres are
not for judicial custody but a place where a foreign national is
detained on an executive order and is the prerogative of the
competent authority under the 1946 Act. The Court was of the
view that there are other possibilities under the 1946 Act which
can be considered by the FRRO, that is, keeping such a person at
a particular place (not necessarily a detention centre), imposing
restrictions on his movements (like restricting him to an area),
regulating his conduct and association with persons reporting
requirements to an authority. The order passed by the FRRO
retaining the petitioner in a detention centre was, accordingly, set
aside subject to the conditions mentioned therein.
34. Further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Frank
Vitus v. Narcotics Control Bureau & Ors. , 2025 SCC OnLine
SC 30, observed that:
“2. Under Section 3 of the Act, there is a
power vested in the Central Government
to issue an order making provisions
either generally or concerning any
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 20 of 28
particular foreigner or class of
foreigners of prohibiting, regulating or
restricting the entry of foreigners into
India or their departure therefrom or
their presence or continued presence.
Under clause (g) of Section 3(2), a
power has been conferred on the Central
Government to issue an order directing
that a foreigner shall be arrested or
detained or confined.”
35. It was further held that under the Foreigners Order, 1948
the appropriate civil authority can impose various restrictions on
movements of a foreigner. It was also observed that under
Paragraph 11 and other relevant paragraphs of the said order,
various restrictions can be imposed on a foreigner while he is in
India. The said power was opined to be wholly independent of
the power to grant bail. It was held that notwithstanding the bail
granted by a criminal court, the power to arrest and detain a
foreigner can be exercised, provided the Central Government
makes an order in terms of Clause (g) of Section 3(2) of the 1946
Act.
36. In the case of Aizaz Kilicheva @ Aziza @ Maya v. State
NCT of Delhi , 2025:DHC:294, the question before the learned
Single Judge of this Court was whether, while considering the
bail petition filed by a foreign national, it is permissible for this
Court to also direct the State authorities to grant visa to such a
person, to enable the foreign national to continue to reside in the
country and participate in the pending criminal proceedings. It
was held that a foreign national, charged under Section 14 or
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 21 of 28
14A of the 1946 Act, is to be tried for contravention of those
provisions committed in the past and may be released from
judicial custody on bail, while facing those charges; but the same
person may be placed in executive detention by the Central
Government towards enforcement of the provisions of Section 14
and 14A of the 1946 Act for the future period . It was further held
that it is not necessary that once released on bail, the petitioner
would be escorted straight to a detention centre/restriction centre,
because Section 3 of the 1946 Act gives several options to the
Central Government to adopt different measures for different
persons, such as requiring the person to reside at a particular
place (not necessarily a detention centre/restriction centre) or
imposing other restrictions on movements within India.
37. In the recent judgment of the Supreme Court in Union of
India v. Chidiebere Kingsley Nawchara & Ors ., 2026 INSC 870,
while considering the issue regarding grant of bail to foreign
nationals and the conditions that can be imposed thereupon, the
Court opined that merely because an accused/convict is a
foreigner, his right to bail cannot be circumscribed. The Court
held as under:
“13.4 The Delhi High Court in Lambert
Kroger v. Enforcement Directorate
while dealing with the bail application of
a German national accused under the
Foreign Exchange Regulation Act 1973,
which undoubtedly is a special statute,
referred to the oft-repeated saying of
bail is the rule and jail is the exception,
and as such released him on bail subject
to the conditions that his passport shall
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 22 of 28
be deposited; he shall not leave the NCT
of Delhi; and that he would report to the
Enforcement Officer, every Monday at
11 am.
13.5 From the above judgments as also
others, inter alia, Sartori Livio v. The
State (Delhi Admin) ; Haroub Slaum
Sleyoum v. Shri Abdul Qadir the
following principles emerge:
(i) Foreign nationals are entitled to
protection under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India;
(ii) The State has power as the sovereign
to regulate, restrict and expel foreign
nationals;
(iii) Merely because an accused/convict
is a foreigner, the right to bail cannot be
circumscribed. It is permissible to
impose special conditions on them while
keeping in view the right to privacy and
personal liberty under Article 21.
(iv) The conditions of bail must be
reasonable, proportionate and capable
of compliance.”
38. After noticing the aforesaid three developments, now this
Court will answer the questions raise in this reference.
39. Question No.1 raised in the reference is again reproduced,
as under:
“Q.1: Would releasing the
accused/foreign national on
unconditional bail, who is apprehended
on charge of overstaying in India after
expiry of his visa, not tantamount to
legalizing his future stay in India without
valid visa, which is otherwise an offence
under Section 14 of Foreigners Act,
1946? Can granting of bail to a foreign
national overshadow the provisions of
Foreigners Act, 1946 and can the bail
order be used by a foreign national as a
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 23 of 28
substitute for a visa to remain in
country?”
40. A foreign national who is charged under Section 14 or
Section 14A of the 1946 Act (or Section 23 of the 2025 Act) is to
be tried for the contravention of those provisions committed in
the past . Therefore, while dealing with the bail application of
such an accused, the Court is considering contravention of
provisions of the 1946 Act (or contravention of provisions of the
2025 Act) committed in the past .
41. While ordinarily, granting bail in every offence, every
court considers the possibility of the accused repeating the same
offence, if released on bail. However, for enforcing the
provisions of Section 14 or Section 14A of the 1946 Act (or
Section 23 of the 2025 Act) for the future period , it is for the
Central Government to adopt different options given under
Section 3 of the 1946 Act/Paragraph 11 and other paragraphs of
the Foreigners Order, 1948 (or Section 7 of the 2025 Act/
Paragraph 8 and other paragraphs of the Immigration and
Foreigners Order, 2025) and adopt different measures for
different persons, such as requiring the person to reside at a
particular place (not necessarily arresting and detaining or
confining in a detention centre/restriction centre) or imposing
other restrictions on movement within India. The said power is
wholly independent of the power to grant bail and can be
exercised by the Central Government, notwithstanding the bail
granted by a criminal Court. It is reiterated that there is a ‘ vast
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 24 of 28
menu of options ’ [as noted by the learned Single Judge in the
case of Emechere Maduabuchkwu (supra)] available for the
FRRO to apply, such as requiring the accused to be at a particular
place (not necessarily a detention centre), imposing restrictions
on his movements (like restricting him to an area), regulating his
conduct and association with persons; reporting requirements to
an authority which may be more in consonance with the rights
under Article 21 of the Constitution than a summary ‘ plain
vanilla order ’ [borrowed again from the order passed by the
learned Single Judge in the case of Emechere Maduabuchkwu
(supra)] of continuing in the detention centre.
42. Therefore, the grant of bail to a foreign national accused
under Section 14 of the 1946 Act (or the corresponding Section
23 of the 2025 Act) does not, by itself, tantamount to legalising
his continued stay in India or operate as a substitute for a valid
visa. So far as his continued stay in India in future is concerned,
that is for the Central Government to examine under Section 3 of
the 1946 Act/Paragraph 11 and other paragraphs of the
Foreigners Order, 1948/Section 7 of the 2025 Act/Paragraphs 8
and other paragraphs of the Immigration and Foreigners Order,
2025.
43. The Court is empowered to grant bail and to impose
conditions while granting bail. The grant of bail cannot, by itself,
be treated as conferring any right on the foreign national to
remain in India without a valid visa and, therefore, cannot
overshadow the provisions of the 1946 Act or the 2025 Act.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 25 of 28
44. Question No.2 raised in the reference is again reproduced
below:
“Q.2: Should the matters of foreign
nationals, who are accused for offence
u/s 14 of Foreigners Act, 1946, and
particularly where accused himself
concedes that his visa has expired before
date of his apprehension, be not treated
differently than other criminal cases?”
45. The answer to this question is No.
46. While dealing with the matters involving foreign nationals
who are accused of the offence under Section 14 of the 1946 Act,
and particularly where the accused himself concedes that his visa
has expired before the date of his apprehension, such matters are
not to be treated differently than other criminal cases, as a foreign
national charged under Section 14 or 14A of the 1946 Act is to
be tried for the contravention of those provisions committed in
the past and may be released from judicial custody on bail,
subject to such conditions as the court may deem appropriate, but
certainly not the condition to detain him in a detention centre till
the pendency of the trial. In so far as the future period is
concerned, the same is the subject matter to be considered by the
Central Government under Section 3 of the 1946 Act read with
Paragraph 11 and other paragraphs of the Foreigners Order, 1948
(or Section 7 of the 2025 Act read with Paragraph 8 and other
paragraphs of the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025).
47. The 2025 Act also has a provision in the form of Section
25, dealing with “compounding of certain offences”.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 26 of 28
48. The stand of the FRRO, Union of India in their affidavit
dated 17.07.2026 is also that foreign nationals involved in
offences under the 1946 Act or under the 2025 Act have an
option for compounding the offences under Section 25 of the
2025 Act. The foreign nationals fulfilling the eligibility as
mentioned in the statute can pay the requisite penalty amount and
get the offence compounded. The SOP also provides that in case
any such foreigner expresses his/her inability to pay the penalty,
he/she may be deported forthwith and he/she may be blacklisted
under appropriate category as per the prevailing Black list
guidelines of the Ministry of Home Affairs.
49. This is in tune with the directions of Karnataka High Court
as well as Kerala High Court in the case Junia Erastus
Mayemba (supra), Tshibambula Jennifer Kabantobelu (supra),
Mr. Freddy Tshimanga Kanyama ( supra ) and Farhan Hussain
(supra). Once these options are exercised, there may not be any
need for granting any bail to such a foreign national.
50. Question No.3 raised in the reference is as under:
“Q.3 If bail is granted to a foreign
national, can certain conditions be
imposed on such foreign nationals
including to keep them in detention
centre till completion of their trail, so as
to refrain them to evade the process of
justice and not to allow them to remain
the country without having any valid
visa?”
51. Bail may be granted to a foreign national subject to
reasonable conditions, including regarding the place of residence,
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 27 of 28
restriction on movement, and periodic reporting, having regard to
the gravity of the offence and the risk of the accused evading
trial. However, a direction imposing a condition wherein the
foreign national is restricted to a detention centre would frustrate
the very order of bail and hence, cannot be imposed. Such a
power can be exercised by the Central Government by an order
under Section 3(2)(g) of the 1946 Act, or under Paragraph 8 of
the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025.
52. The Criminal Reference is answered, accordingly, and
disposed of.
53. We express our gratitude to Mr. Harsh Prabhakar, the
learned Amicus Curiae, for rendering assistance to us in
answering the questions referred.
54. A copy of this order be sent to the learned Metropolitan
Magistrate- 04, South District, Saket Courts, New
Delhi/Successor Court.
ARUN BHARDWAJ, J
NAVIN CHAWLA, J
NOVEMBER 18, 2026/akr/ps
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:KAMALDEEP
KAUR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
14:59
CRL.REF. 2/2021 Page 28 of 28