SAMIRAN BERA AND ORS vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Court
Calcutta High Court

Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present : The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
&
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi

W.P.L.R.T. No. 80 of 2026
On the death of petitioner no. 1 namely
Dipak Ranjan Bera
represented by his legal heirs
Samiran Bera and Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal and Ors.
For the petitioners : Mr. J. C. Das,
Mr. Binoy Kumar Das, Advs.
For the respondent no. 7 : Mr. Uttam Kumar Bhattacharyya, Adv.
For the State : Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharjee,
Senior Standing Counsel,
Ms. Mary Datta,
Ms. Sneha Chatterjee, Advs.
Heard on : November 19, 2026.
Judgment on : November 19, 2026.

Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya , J. :

2
1.
The present challenge has been preferred against an order
passed by the learned Tribunal, whereby the learned Tribunal set
aside the order of the Appellate Authority and remanded the appeal
preferred by the petitioners for being taken up for hearing after a
reference by a coordinate Bench of this Court is answered.
2. The brief facts are that one Bankim Chandra Bera, the
predecessor-in-interest of the present petitioners, was recorded as
the raiyat in respect of the subject plot, both in the RS Records as
well as in the LR Records of Rights. Nowhere in the said
documents was there any reference to any bargadar cultivating the
land.
3.
Subsequently, the petitioners sought conversion, upon which an
order was passed for conversion of the said land to bastu. A portion
of the land comprises of bastu and the other a pond. At none of the
above stages was any objection raised by the present respondent
no. 7 claiming his bargadarship in respect of the subject land.
4. Subsequently, on an allegation that the respondent no. 7 was
trying to disturb the possession of the petitioners, the petitioners
obtained an order under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, in which proceeding reports were filed by the Revenue

3
Inspector and the Sub-inspector, both of which indicated that the
respondent no. 7 was not in occupation of the subject plots.
5.
The said developments took place in the year 2014.
Subsequently, the respondent no. 7 applied for being recorded as a
bargadar in respect of the subject plot. The Revenue Officer, on the
strength of certain purported letters written by the respondent no. 7
to the petitioners in the year 2016, seeking receipts for alleged
delivery of share of produce, as well as a further report, wherefrom
it transpired that a portion of the land was being cultivated, came to
the conclusion that the respondent no. 7 was a bargadar in respect
of the subject plot.
6.
The said order was challenged before the Appellate Authority
which affirmed the same, challenging which the Tribunal was
moved by the petitioners.
7. Learned counsel for the writ petitioners places reliance on
coordinate Bench judgments in the matters of Shambhunath Nath
Ghosh vs. State of West Bengal , reported at 2014 (4)
CHN(Cal)146 , and Sibani Giri vs. State of West Bengal , reported at
2013 (1) CHN (Cal) 70 , as well as the judgment of a learned Single
Judge of this Court in the matter of Samejan Bewa vs. Revenue
Officer, Lalgola and Ors. , reported at 1986 (1) CLJ 161 , for the

4
proposition that in order to establish Bargadarship, apart from
cultivation of the land in question, receipts in respect of delivery of
share of produce by the bargadar to the raiyat are mandatorily
required to be produced.
8. It is submitted that in such view of the matter, the learned
Tribunal erred in law in relegating the matter to the Appellate
Authority instead of setting aside the orders of the Revenue Officer
and the Appellate Authority, as well as in directing a fresh enquiry to
be held.
9.
Learned counsel for the private respondent no. 7 submits that
the relationship between the respondent no. 7 and petitioners was
all along cordial, due to which no receipt was sought, although the
respondent no. 7 all along delivered the share of crops to the
petitioners.
10. It is submitted that the Revenue Officer was justified in recording
the respondent no. 7 as a bargadar in view of the report filed by the
Revenue Officer, clearly indicating that a portion of the land was
actually being cultivated.
11. Learned Senior Standing Counsel cites an unreported
coordinate Bench judgment dated December 24, 2019 in the matter
of Balaram Layek (Tiwari) vs. The State of West Bengal and Ors.

5
[W.P.L.R.T 89 of 2019] , where the coordinate Bench referred
certain questions for being resolved by a larger Bench, which are as
follows:-
“1. Whether, in view of section 21-D of the West Bengal Land
Reforms Act, 1955 ordaining that the names of bargadars in
respect of every raiyat shall be entered in the record-of-rights in the
manner as prescribed, could the requirement of producing receipt
proving delivery of share of produce by a bargadar upon cultivation
of the land of the raiyat be read into the procedure prescribed by
the West Bengal Land Reforms Rules,1965 although the same
requirement manifestly does not form part of such Rules?
2. Whether, in view of the provisions contained in Rule 14-1 of the
West Bengal Land Reforms Rules, 1965, any procedure other than
that statutorily prescribed can be directed to be followed for
entering the name of a cultivator as bargadar in the record-of-rights
under Section 21-D of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955? If
yes, to what extent?
3. Whether, delivery of share of produce evidenced by receipt of
acknowledgment issued by the raiyat [which is a requirement of
section 16(3) of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955 and is
not traceable in rule 14-I of the West Bengal Land Reforms Rules,

6
1965] could be the sole consideration, or at all a consideration, or
one of the considerations, for determining the claim of a cultivator
seeking to have his name entered in the record-of-rights as a
bargadar under section 21-D of the said Act of 1955 particularly
when section 2(2) thereof, while defining a bargadar, only refers to
the system of cultivation on a particular condition but does not go
further to include a provision similar to section 16(3) in rule 14-I?
4. Whether, having regard to the statutory presumption in section
21-B of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955 and the policy of
the State as declared by section 1A of the West Bengal Land
Reforms Act, 1955 and clauses (b) and (c) of Article 39 of the
Constitution, any ambiguity in interpreting the statutory provisions
should be resolved in favour of the person claiming to be a
bargadar?
5. Whether, the provisions in rule 14-I of the West Bengal Land
Reforms Rules, 1965 having passed sub-silentio in the decision of
the Division Bench of this Court reported in 2009 (2) CHN 830
(Sambhunath Ghosh & Anr. vs. The State of West Bengal & Ors.)
as well as the decisions reported in (2018) 4 CHN 539 (Bholanath
Pal v. Gobindo Bag & ors.), (2013) 1 CHN 70 (Sibani Giri v. State of
West Bengal), (2001) 1 CHN 588 (Panchu Gopal Das v. State of

7
West Bengal & ors.), (2000) 2 CLJ 209 (Kartick Bagdi & ors. v. Sri
Bidyut Kumar Ray & ors.) and AIR 1997 Calcutta 151 (Smt. Sari
Mahanti v. Ghauiram Mahata), the same have interpreted the law
on the subject correctly?”
12. It is contended by learned Senior Standing Counsel that in view
of the said reference, the Tribunal reverted the matter back to the
Appellate Authority.
13. Upon a careful consideration of the judgment in Balaram Layek
(Tiwari) vs. The State of West Bengal and Ors. , we find that the
scope of the reference centres around whether it is mandatory to
produce receipt proving delivery of share of produce for the purpose
of recording a person’s name as bargadar within the contemplation
of Rule 14-I of the west Bengal Land Reforms Rules, 1965, in the
light of Section 21D of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955.
14. With utmost respect, the provisions of the statute are clear.
15. Section 2(2) of the 1955 Act defines a bargadar to mean a
person who under the system generally known as adhi, barga or
bhag cultivates the land of another person on condition of delivering
a share of the produce of such land to that person and includes a
person who under the system generally known as kisani or any
other description cultivates the land of another person on condition

8
of receiving a share of the produce of such land from that person .
[ Emphasis supplied]
16.
Thus, it is crystal clear from the definition of bargadar in the
1955 Act that the two essential ingredients of bargadarship are,
cultivation of the land directly by the Bargadar, as well as delivery of
share of produce by the bargadar to the raiyat.
17. The self-same position is reiterated in Section 16 of the 1955
Act. In Section 16, it has been stipulated that the bargadar shall
tender within the prescribed period, to the person whose land he
cultivates, the share of produce due to such person.
18.
Under sub-section (3) thereof, where any share of produce
tendered under sub-section (2) is accepted by the person whose
land is cultivated by the bargadar, each party shall give to the other
a receipt, in such form as may be prescribed, for the quantity of the
produce received by him.
19. Under sub-section (4) of Section 16, if the person whose land is
cultivated by the bargadar refuses to accept the share of the
produce tendered to him by the bargadar or to give a receipt
therefor, the bargadar may deposit within the prescribed period
such share with such officer or authority as may be prescribed and
such deposit shall discharge the bargadar from his obligation to

9
deliver the share of the produce to the person whose land he
cultivates.
20.
Thus, the Act clearly obliges the bargadar to deliver the share
of the produce to the person whose land he cultivates, and further
stipulates the paradigm of exchange of receipts by the bargadar as
well as the person whose land he cultivates.
21. Hence, there cannot be any manner of doubt that, to establish
bargadarship, not only cultivation but also delivery of share of
produce has to be established. The Act specifically provides for the
modality to be adopted by the bargadar if share of produce is
refused to be accepted, in which case, to establish bargadarship, in
discharge of the obligation of the bargadar to deliver the share of
produce, the latter has to deposit such share of produce with the
appropriate authority.
22. Moreover, under sub-section (3) of Section 16, it is the mutual
obligation of both the bargadar as well as the person whose land is
being cultivated to give to each other a receipt.
23. In the present case, the respondent no. 7 never produced any
document as contemplated under Section 16 (3) to show that any
receipt was either given by the landowner or by the bargadar/

10
respondent no. 7 himself which, under normal circumstances, was
to be under the custody of the bargadar.
24.
Secondly, throughout the relevant period, at least up to the year
2014, at various stages, the names of the predecessor-in-interest of
the petitioners, and thereafter the petitioners, were recorded as
raiyats in the RS Records of Rights as well as the LR Records of
Rights, without any whisper of the existence of any bargadar.
25. Moreover, it is well-settled that a land cannot be converted
within the contemplation of Section 4C of the 1955 Act unless the
bargadarship, if any, in respect of the said land is terminated.
Hence, the conversion order in favour of the petitioners, per se ,
indicates that there was no bargadar at the relevant point of time on
the subject plot.
26. The aforesaid narrative clearly belies the claim of the
respondent no. 7 that he has been cultivating the land for the last
30 to 35 years.
27. Secondly, the respondent no. 7 took a plea that he is cultivating
about 38 decimals of land, whereas the last report of the Revenue
Officer indicates that 21 decimals of land is being cultivated and the
rest of the land is in the nature of bastu and pond.

11
28.
However, at all earlier stages, several reports were filed by
different officers, all of which clearly indicated that there was no
cultivation being done by the respondent no. 7.
29. The respondent no. 7, having failed to take recourse to sub-
sections (3) and/or (4) of Section 16 of the 1955 Act, and/or to take
any objection to the conversion order in favour of the petitioners, as
well as by desisting from seeking any correction of the Records of
Rights all along by recording his bargadarship, is clearly barred by
estoppel from claiming bargadarship at this belated stage.
30.
In spite of the judgment of reference which is placed before us,
we, with utmost respect, are of the opinion that the same primarily
pertains to the necessity of actually producing a receipt of delivery
of share of produce for the limited purpose of recording a person as
bargadar within the West Bengal Land Reforms Rules, 1965. It is
trite law that Rules cannot override the parent provisions of the
statute under which the Rules are framed. Hence, such reference
does not make any difference to the otherwise well-settled position,
as borne out by Section 2(2) and Section 16 of the 1955 Act and
repeatedly held and reiterated in Shambhunath Nath Ghosh , Sibani
Giri as well as Samejan Bewa by coordinate Benches and learned
Single Judges of this Court, that the delivery of share of produce is

12
a mandatory ingredient of bargadarship, which the respondent no. 7
has miserably failed to establish in the present case. Mere writing of
letters as an afterthought only in the year 2016, without taking
recourse to Section 16 and/or producing any receipt as
contemplated under Section 16(3) of the 1955 Act, is utterly
insufficient to establish the self-proclaimed bargadarship of the
respondent no. 7. Moreover, regarding cultivation as well, we do not
find any convincing material, particularly in the teeth of the earlier
reports which all along indicated that there was no such cultivation
done by the respondent no. 7 on the subject plots.
31.
Thus, neither of the two essential ingredients of bargadarship,
being cultivation and delivery of share of produce, has been
established by the respondent no. 7.
32. In such view of the matter, this Court is of the opinion that the
learned Tribunal erred in law and in facts in merely remanding the
matter to the Appellate Authority instead of setting aside the orders
of the Appellate Authority and the Revenue Officer whereby the
respondent no. 7 was held to be a bargadar.
33. Accordingly, W.P.L.R.T. 80 of 2026 is hereby allowed on
contest, thereby setting aside the impugned judgment dated
February 17, 2026 passed by the First Bench, West Bengal Land

13
Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal in OA 1466 of 2017 (LRTT), as well
as setting aside the orders of the Appellate Authority and the
Revenue Officer, whereby the respondent no. 7 was declared/held
to be a bargadar. Any act, if undertaken consequent / pursuant to
the aforesaid orders which have been set aside by us, hereby stand
revoked and annulled.
34. There will be no order as to costs.
35. Urgent photostat certified copies of this judgment, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all requisite
formalities.
I agree. ( Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J .)
( Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J .)
AD- 12
Ct No.16
(SSS)