DR. VIJAY PRASAD B., vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD

TH
DATED THIS THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL

WRIT PETITION NO.101707 OF 2021 (S-RES)

BETWEEN:
1. DR. VIJAY PRASAD B.,
AGE 39 YEARS, OCC. ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR,
DEPARTMENT OF CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY,
DHARWAD INSTITUTE OF MENTAL HEALTH AND
NEAURO SCIENCE, BELAGAVI ROAD DHARWAD.

2. SRI SUSHEELKUMAR S/O VEERAPPA RONAD
AGE 37 YEARS, OCC. LECTURER IN PSYCHIATRIC,
DEPARTMENT OF CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY,
DHARWAD INSTITUTE OF MENTAL HEALTH AND,
NEAURO SCIENCE , BELAGAVI ROAD DHARWAD.
…PETITIONERS















(BY SRI. H.M. DHARIGOND, ADVOCATE)

AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY TO DEPARTMENT,
HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE SERVICE,
VIDHANA SOUDHA, BANGALURU-560001.

2. THE DIRECTOR,
DHARWAD INSTITUTE OF MENTAL HEALTH,
AND NEAURO SCIENCE BELAGAVI ROAD,
DHARWAD-580008.
…RESPONDENTS


Digitally signed
by SAROJA
HANGARAKI
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad
Bench


(BY SRI PRASHANTH V. MOGALI, HCGP FOR R1;
SRI SUNIL S. DESAI, ADVOCATE FOR R2)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT IN THE
NATURE OF CERTIORARI TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED OFFICE
INTIMATION LETTER DATED 11.12.2020 ISSUED BY THE SECOND
RESPONDENT UNDER NO.DIMHNS/STAFF/149/2020-21 VIDE
ANNEXURE-R AND ETC.

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


THIS WP COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING IN ‘B’ GROUP,
THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL

ORAL ORDER


1. Petitioner No.1 was appointed as Assistant Professor in
Clinical Psychology in the Department of Psychiatry by
respondent No.2-Dharwad Institute of Mental Health and
Neauro Sciences, Belagavi Road, Dharwad vide Official
Memorandum dated 01.08.2011 with a pay scale of
Rs.15,200-25,650/- and allowance as per AICTE with
effect from the date of his joining the institute.

2. Similarly, petitioner No.2 was appointed to the post of
Lecturer (Department of Psychiatric Nursing) vide
communication dated 08.02.2012 produced at
Annexure-D.

3. The present petition is filed being aggrieved by the
Office Intimation Letter dated 11.12.2020 issued by
respondent No.2 to the petitioners stating that
petitioners were appointed to their respective posts on

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


the State Government pay scale and reference to
allowance as per AICTE was an error. Therefore the
request of the petitioners to extend the pay scale of
AICTE has been declined.

4. Learned counsel for the petitioners taking this Court
through the records namely Annexure-A which is a
Government Order dated 16.12.2011 submit that the
posts referred to therein have been brought within the
purview of pay scale as per AICTE with effect from
01.04.2011. Referring to document at Annexure-G dated
11.04.2012, he points out that post of Assistant
Professor in Psychology as well as Lecturer in Psychiatric
Nursing has been brought within the purview of
AICTE/UGC Pay Scale which is held by the petitioners.
He also refers to another similar communication dated
22.05.2012 issued by respondent No.2 submits that,
respondent No.2 himself had confirmed permission
having been accorded by the Government vide its
endorsement dated 09.05.2012 for extension of AICTE

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


pay scale to all the employees employed by respondent
No.2, which includes the petitioners herein. He then
refers to a communication dated 14.12.2020 produced
at Annexure-Q3 addressed by the Principal Secretary to
Government, Medical Education Department to
respondent No.2 and submits that there is a reference to
the Government Order dated 04.05.2020 in the said
letter intimating that the Government has directed
extension of AICTE Pay Scale to all the cadres of
teaching staff.

5. Thus, he submits that, in the light of these many
documents and repeated Government Orders,
respondent No.2 could not have issued document at
Annexure-A taking a complete ‘U’ turn of its own
correspondence, hence seeks for allowing of the petition.

6. Shri Sunil S. Desai learned counsel appearing for
respondent No.2 referring to statement of objection
submits that, the petitioners were appointed to the
respective posts with the State Government pay scale

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


and not the pay scale of AICTE. In this regard he refers
to the Government proceedings dated 18.12.2010
produced at Annexure-R1 to the Statement of Objections
and points out that, the pay scale to the post of
Assistant Professor was fixed at Rs.15,200-25,650/-. So
also to the post of Lecturer, Psychiatric Nursing, which is
Rs.14,050-25,050/-. He then refers to Annexure-R2,
which is Regulation i.e., Minimum Qualification for
Teachers in Medical Institutions Regulations, 1998
th
(Amended upto 8 June 2017) issued by the Medical
Council of India and referring to Table-1 of the said
document providing for 45 subjects enumerated
thereunder, that there is no mention of the posts
occupied by the petitioners in the said list. He then
refers to the contents of Annexure-B2 and C1, which are
the documents evidencing appointment of petitioner
Nos.1 and 2 respectively to the respective posts and
points out the pay scale mentioned therein and submits
the pay scale mentioned therein are the one which are
referred to at Annexure-R1 which is the State

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


Government Approved Pay Scale. He submits reference
bona fide
to allowance “as per AICTE” Pay Scale, is a
mistake which is what has been stated in the impugned
communication. Adverting to the contents of document
at Annexure-H issued by respondent No.2 referring to
Government endorsement dated 09.05.2012, he submits
that there is no such endorsement issued by the State
Government according permission to extend AICTE Pay
Scale benefits to the petitioners and that the very
communication at Annexure-H is unauthorized. He
however fairly submits that, if either the petitioners or
respondent No.1-State issues express orders to extend
the AICTE benefit to the petitioners, respondent No.2
would comply with the same.

7. Learned Additional Government Advocate on the other
hand submits that, though there is a reference to certain
endorsement dated 09.05.2012 in the document at
Annexure-H, it needs to be ascertained whether such
communication/endorsement dated 09.05.2012 has ever

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


been issued. He submits that if such endorsement/order
is passed, appropriate instruction/direction be issued to
the respondent No.2.

8. Heard and perused the records.

9. Though the Official Memorandum dated 01.08.2011
produced at Annexure-B2 as well as the communication
dated 01.08.2011 produced at Annexure-C1, which are
the documents evidencing appointment of the petitioners
to the posts of Assistant Professor in Clinical Psychology
and Lecturer in Psychiatric Nursing respectively, the Pay
Scale mentioned therein which is Rs.15,200-25,650/-
and Rs.14,050-25,050/- respectively are referable to the
Pay Scale mentioned in Annexure-R1 to the Statement
of Objections. Annexure-R1 is the Government Order
dated 18.12.2010 sanctioning 10 posts to respondent
No.2 with the State Government Approved Pay Scale.
Thus, the pay scale referred to in Annexure-R1 has been
specifically mentioned in the documents at Annexures-
B2 and C1 and the said appointments have been

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


accepted by the petitioners without any demur. Issue
seems to have cropped up with the further reference in
the said orders to the effect that “allowance as per
AICTE Pay Scale with effect from the date of his/her
joining duty at this institute”. When the pay scale is
specifically referred to the State Government approved
pay scale, what was the need to mention “allowance as
per AICTE” is not clear.

10. Nonetheless correspondences have ensued at the
instance of the petitioners who have been demanding
their pay scale to be fixed as per AICTE Pay Scale.
Document at Annexure-H dated 22.05.2012 issued by
respondent No.2, though refers to Government Order
dated 18.12.2010 (produced by respondent No.2 at
Annexure-R1), further proceeds to indicate that the
principal Secretary to the Government, Department of
Medical Education by endorsement dated 09.05.2012
had granted permission to extend AICTE Pay Scale to all
the employees.

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021



11. On a query by this Court about the availability of such
endorsement dated 09.05.2012 learned counsel for the
petitioners pleads ignorance and submits it is for the
State Government to bring the same on record. While
learned counsel for respondent No.2 submits that no
such order ever has been passed. Learned Additional
Government Advocate on the other hand submits that
such order has to be traced. It is this elusive
endorsement dated 09.05.2012 has kept this pot boiling
till date, constraining the petitioners to make relentless
representations and to approach this Court more than
two occasions. If such an endorsement was ever issued,
Government need not have to shy away from bringing
the same on record and to extend the benefit to the
petitioners if they so deserve.

12. Though respondent No.2 has now sought to distance
itself from the communication at Annexure-H and has
now seek to reiterate the stand of petitioners having
been appointed to the respective posts based on the

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


State Government Approved Pay Scale by issuing the
impugned communication dated 11.12.2020, the fact
remains respondent No.1-State has to make it stand
clear whether or not any such endorsement dated
09.05.2012 referred to at Annexure-H was ever issued.

13. At this juncture learned counsel for the petitioners also
brings to the notice of this Court a Government
Communication dated 02.12.2020, which finds reference
in the impugned communication at Annexure-R, in terms
of which, it appears AICTE pay scale has been extended
to the teaching staff. However learned counsel for
respondent No.2 hastened to add such extension is only
to the teaching staff, who are enumerated in the
regulation issued by the Medical Council of India
produced at Annexure-R2.

14. Be that as it is. It is for the respondent No.1-State
Government to come clear as to whether or not the
AICTE pay scale has been extended to the petitioners in
terms of the endorsement dated 09.05.2012 as referred

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


to at Annexure-H. Unless and until the respondent No.1
makes it stand clear, respondent No.2 cannot be
directed to extend the AICTE Pay Scale and as such a
direction would be one without prior order by the
Government.

15. In that view of the matter, the following;
ORDER

(i) The writ petition is partly allowed.

(ii) Impugned communication at Annexure-R
is quashed .

(iii) Respondent No.1-State Government is
directed to verify if it has already passed
any order and issued endorsement dated
09.05.2012 as referred to in unnumbered
paragraph No.4 at page No.2 of
Annexure-H extending AICTE Pay Scale to
the petitioners.

(iv) Respondent No.1-State shall also verify
the intent and purpose of Annexure-A as
well as the communication dated
02.12.2020 referred to at Reference No.8

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18394
WP No. 101707 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020166602021


of the impugned Communication produced
at Annexure-R; and shall pass appropriate
orders and communicate the same to the
petitioners within an outer limit of 90
days from the date of receipt of certified
copy of this order.

Sd/-
(M.G.S. KAMAL)
JUDGE



EM, CT:VP
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 37