N.KARTHIK vs THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT
- Court
- Madras High Court
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 17-11-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE G. JAYACHANDRAN
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE E.MANOHARAN
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
CNR:{HCMA011774302025}
and
C.M.P.No.20717 of 2025
N.Karthik,
S/O. C.S.Nair,
Venkatsamudram Post,
Papireddipatti Taluk,
… Appellant
Dharmapuri District -636905.
Vs.
1. The Principal Secretary To The Government,
Higher Education(B1) Department,
Secretariat,
Chennai -600 009.
2.The Member Secretary,
Tamil Nadu State Council For Higher Education,
Lady Willingdon College Campus,
Kamarajar Salai,
Chennai -600 005.
3.The Secretary,
The Tamil Nadu Pubic Service
Commission, TNPSC Road,
V.O.C.Nagar, Park Town,
Chennai -600 003.
4.The Principal Secretary,
Tourism, Culture And Religious Endowments Department,
Government Secretariat, Fort St. George,
Chennai, Tamil Nadu -600 009.
Page Nos.1/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
5.The Director of Tourism
Directorate Of Tourism,
Tamil Nadu Tourism Complex,
No. 2, Wallajah Road,
Chennai-600 002.
… Respondents
Prayer: Writ Appeal has been filed under Clause 15 of Letters Patent, to set
aside the order dated 24.06.2025 made in W.P.No.13022 of 2024.
For Appellant: Mr.U.Karunakaran
For Respondents: Mr.K.Sathish,
Additional Government Pleader,
for R1 & R2.
Abrar Md.Abdullah,
Standing Counsel, for R3
J U D G M E N T
(Order of the Court was made by G.Jayachandran, J.)
The appellant herein is a graduate holding an M.A., (English), as one of
the subjects in the second Semester with Tourism Principles and Practices. That
apart, under Part- B, one of the subjects is Computing Skills (Basic) and
Computing Skills (Advanced). When the TNPSC called for application for the
post of Tourism Officer vide Notification No.11/2017 dated 09.05.2017, the
appellant applied, being fully qualified for the post as prescribed under the
notification. However, his candidature was rejected on the ground that though
M.A. (English) degree with Tourism as one of the subjects satisfied as per the
educational qualification prescribed, the Computing Skills (Advanced) paper is
not offered by University of Madras was not equivalent to the certificate course
Page Nos.2/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
in Computer on Office Automation (COA) offered by the Directorate of
Technical Education.
2. According to the appellant, the syllabus for Computing Skills (Basic)
and Computing Skills (Advanced) offered by the University of Madras as one of
the subjects in the Post Graduate course, is far more advanced course than the
syllabus prescribed for the certificate course conducted for a duration of six
months. With this contention, when the petitioner approached the High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution, the Learned Single Judge has gone into
the facts of the case and dismissed the writ petition, holding that the Court
cannot substitute its view regarding equivalency.
3. On being aggrieved by the above order of dismissal, the present appeal
is filed.
4. The Learned Counsel appearing for the appellant reiterated his stand,
stating that the Computing Skills (Basic) and Computing Skills (Advanced)
papers is more updated, practical/laboratory-based training compared to the
certificate course in Computer on Office Automation (COA) offered by the
Directorate of Technical Education. He further contended that merely for want
of the duration of the practical training in Computer operations and the marks
Page Nos.3/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
scored in the practical examination, the appellant's candidature cannot be
rejected on the ground that he does not possess an equivalency certificate. We
have no doubt about the principle that judicial review cannot be extended to test
the opinion of the Equivalence Committee. However, it is a case where a
candidate possesses a Post Graduate degree with Tourism and Computer Skills
as one of the subjects, besides, the syllabus also indicates that the said course
covers Linguistic Training and Comparative study of other languages like
French and Hindi, apart from English Literature. The opinion of the experts,
namely the Equivalence Committee, was found to be incomplete. Therefore,
this Court has directed to file a status report by the Member Secretary, Tamil
Nadu State Council for Higher Education, which is the competent authority to
award equivalency certificates.
5. The Equivalence Committee, consisting of three members which
includes the Head of the Department of the Computer Science at the University
of Madras has opined that the Computing Skills (Basic) and (Advanced)
undergone by the appellant are not equivalent to the certificate course in
Computer on Office Automation offered by the Directorate of Technical
Education.
Page Nos.4/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
6. On perusal of the experts report, we find that the comparison of the
course offered by the University of Madras for Post Graduate M.A. (English)
and the subject offered for the certificate course by the Directorate of Technical
Education reveals the following similarity percentages:
Computer Hardware, Software and Office Systems: 50% similarity
Computer on Office Automation Package: 70% similarity
Database Administration and Internet: 60% similarity.
7. As far as the practical is concerned, the observation of the Expert is as
below:
5. Practical: Detailed syllabus is
attached.
Number of hours for practical:
81 hours Practical Examination
conducted for 100 marks.
No detailed syllabus is
provided.
Number of hours for practical
is not specified.
10 marks per semester is
included in the internal
marks.
Total 20 marks.
Not comparable is the
detailed syllabus is
not specified as per
syllabus for column
(3). Hence, based on
the marks it is
considered as 20%
DOS and Windows Not specified 20%
MS-Word and MS-Excel Not specified 20%
MS-Access and Internet Not specified 20%
nd
In the status report filed by the 2 respondent which was called for to
clarify this issue, the Member Secretary, Tamil Nadu State Council of Higher
Education, Chennai, has stated as below:
Page Nos.5/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
“ 3. I respectfully submit that the remark made by
the Chairperson stating that the "No detailed syllabus was
provided" was not intended to convey that the respondent
had failed to furnish detailed syllabus. The said remark
arose solely from the fact that, although the syllabus
supplied by the University of Madras contained a
practical component, the practical portions were not
elaborated or detailed in a manner comparable to the
practical-oriented structure of the Certificate Course in
Office Automation. Thus, the remark pertains only to the
absence of detailed practical content In the syllabus
issued by the University and not to any non-submission of
material by the respondent.
4. I respectfully submit that the appellant has
sought to misconstrue this internal academic observation
to allege non-furnishing of the practical syllabus. The
allegation is wholly untenable. The records would clearly
demonstrate that the syllabus, in full, was provided and
placed before the Expert Committee, and Experts
observation was only with respect to the nature and extent
of the practical content contained therein.
5. I respectfully submit that the Practical syllabus
pertaining to the Certificate Course in Computing on
Office Automation offered by the Directorate of Technical
Education prescribes 81 hours of Practical sessions and
provides 100 marks for Practical Examination. It is
further submitted that, as per the scheme of valuation and
pattern of question paper, the course consists of Theory
for 100 marks and Practical for 100 marks, aggregating
Page Nos.6/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
to 200 marks. Further, the Candidate has to complete a
minimum of 120 hrs. of training.
However, the University of Madras has not
specified the number of hours allotted for Practical
sessions per semester. The University has stipulated that
Part A (Theory - Written) carries 40 marks and Part B
(Practical - Using Computers) carries 40 marks, with a
combined duration of three hours for both components;
Both Part A and Part B are evaluated together, and
consolidated marks are awarded. Thus, this is treated as a
single examination and not as separate Theory and
Practical examinations. It is further submitted that this
combined examination is conducted prior to the
commencement of the end-semester examinations for
other core and elective courses.
6. I respectfully submit that the Certificate Course
in Computer on Office Automation, offered by the
Directorate of Technical Education, is a stand-alone
course, whereas the Soft Skills course offered by the
University of Madras forms an integral part of the Post-
Graduate Programme, conducted along with core and
elective courses. Hence, the structure, duration, and
evaluation pattern of both courses are not comparable.”
8. From the status report read with the report of the experts, indicates that
for want of particulars regarding the number of hours allotted for practical
sessions per semester by the University of Madras as well as for want of
Page Nos.7/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
separate marks for practicals, being the criteria has influenced the Committee
that the two papers, namely, Computing Skills (Basic) and Computer Skills
(Advanced) offered by Madras University cannot be equated with the certificate
course in Computer on Office Automation (COA) offered by the Directorate of
Technical Education.
9. If there is any ambiguity regarding the nature of the practical training
offered by the University of Madras, the appropriate course should have been to
call for information from the concerned University regarding the duration
prescribed for the practical papers. Being a two-year course with the subjects
spread over two semesters each of six months, the experts, for want of breakup
details regarding the hours of practical training and marks scored, alone had
reject the equivalency sought by the appellant. Further, material ought to have
been collected by the Committee, particularly when the Committee is satisfied
with the fact that the subjects taught to the appellant in his M.A. (English)
course with Tourism and Computer Skills as ancillary subjects are more than
50% similar to the subjects taught to the candidates in the certificate course in
Computer on Office Automation.
10. Therefore, we set aside the Expert Committee report dated 23.03.2022
nd
and direct the 2 respondent/Member Secretary, Tamil Nadu State Council of
Page Nos.8/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
Higher Education, Chennai, to constitute a fresh committee including a
representative from the University of Madras who has taught the M.A. (English)
course with Computer Skills as one of the subjects, being one of the members
and to reconsider the equivalency within a period of two months from today.
Based on the opinion of the experts, necessary orders shall be passed by the
other respondents if the appellant satisfies the qualification prescribed.
11. With the above directions, this Writ Appeal is allowed. There shall be
no order as to costs. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
(Dr. G.JAYACHANDRAN, J.) & (E.MANOHARAN, J.)
17-11-2026
Index :Yes/No.
Neutral Citation :Yes/No.
Speaking/Non-speaking order
bsm
To,
1. The Principal Secretary To The Government,
Higher Education(B1) Department,
Secretariat,
Chennai -600 009.
2.The Member Secretary,
Tamil Nadu State Council For Higher Education,
Lady Willingdon College Campus,
Kamarajar Salai,
Chennai -600 005.
Page Nos.9/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
3.The Secretary,
The Tamil Nadu Pubic Service Commission,
TNPSC Road, V.O.C.Nagar, Park Town,
Chennai -600 003.
4.The Principal Secretary,
Tourism, Culture And Religious Endowments Department,
Government Secretariat, Fort St. George,
Chennai, Tamil Nadu -600 009.
5.The Director of Tourism,
Directorate of Tourism,
Tamil Nadu Tourism Complex,
No. 2, Wallajah Road,
Chennai-600 002.
Page Nos.10/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
Dr. G.JAYACHANDRAN, J.
AND
E.MANOHARAN, J.
bsm
W.A.No.2594 of 2025
and
C.M.P.No.20717 of 2025
17-11-2026
Page Nos.11/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 19/11/2026 04:22:22 pm )