ANIL GUPTA vs UNION OF INDIA

Court
Calcutta High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE

PRESENT:

THE HON’BLE JUSTICE TIRTHANKAR GHOSH

C.R.M. (NDPS) 1295 of 2026
Anil Gupta
-vs.-
Union of India

For the Petitioner : Mr. Sourav Chatterjee, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Antarikhya Basu, Adv.,
Ms. Madhumita Basak, Adv.,
Ms. Mayanakshi Saha, Adv.


For the DRI Authority : Mr. Nadeem Sulaiman, Adv.,
Mr. Tapan Bhanja, Adv.
Mr. Gourab Karmakar, Adv.,

Reserved on : 28.09.2026

Judgment on : 17.11.2026
Tirthankar Ghosh, J:-
Petitioner has prayed for bail in connection with the order dated
19.05.2026 passed by the Learned Additional District and Sessions
th
Judge, 8 Court Barasat, in connection with Case No.
N-275/2025 arising out of DRI Case No. DRI/KZU/NDPS/ENQ-
106/2025 under Section 8 (c)/21 (c)/29 of the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1958, wherein the Learned Special
Court was pleased to reject the prayer for bail of the petitioner.
Learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner submitted

2

that the petitioner is the licensee of Green Inn Restaurant-Cum-
Bar, located at 10F, B.T. Road, North 24 Parganas, West Bengal
and his wife, Smt. Nitu Gupta, is the licensee of Cossipore F.L. Off
Shop. Petitioner has maintained his business operations
continuously and lawfully for a long period of time, as evidenced by
the successive annual renewals of their respective excise licenses.
Petitioner is not involved in any illicit activities and manages his
legitimate business in full compliance with the West Bengal Excise
Act, 1909. According to the petitioner on 04.12.2025, at about 3:00
p.m., suddenly, officers of the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence
(DRI), along with a Gazetted Officer and four Intelligence Officers,
accompanied by two independent panchas, arrived at the
petitioner’s shop, namely, Cossipore F.L. Off Shop, under the garb
of searching Koushik Bera. When petitioner questioned the search
of Koushik Bera, who is an employee of Cossipore F.L. Off Shop,
the DRI officers, immediately at about 3:15 p.m., upon entering
the shop premises, arbitrarily tagged the petitioner along with
Koushik Bera, treating him as an associate without any legal basis,
and apprehended him on mere suspicion.
Thereafter, the officers of the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence
(DRI) forcibly took the petitioner, along with the co-accused,
namely, Koushik Bera, and two other independent witnesses,
approximately 8 to 10 kilometres away from his shop at Cossipore,
to the commercial warehouse of VRL Logistics at Agarpara Jute Mill

3

premises. At the warehouse, while under severe custodial duress,
physical intimidation and threat of immediate arrest, the petitioner
was forced to initiate a UPI transaction of Rs . 2,222/- from Account
No. 50200049888076, registered in the name of M/S Cossipore F.L.
Off Shop to VRL Logistics on the pretext of receiving a consignment
so as to falsely establish a financial connection. The officers
subsequently received the consignment under such false pretext.
The said transaction was entirely non-voluntary, extorted and
staged by the officers. Immediately thereafter, on the evening of
04.12.2025, the officers forced the petitioner and Koushik Bera into
their vehicles and took them to the DRI office at New Town,
Kolkata, at about 5:00 p.m., where they were illegally detained and
subsequently shown as arrested in the early morning of 05.12.2025
at about 01:10 a.m. Strikingly, throughout these high-handed
actions at the warehouse and during transit on 04.12.2025, the
investigating officers failed to secure any independent local witness
to the alleged recovery and relied solely upon their own arranged
witnesses in violation of the procedural safeguards under Section
103(4) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
Furthermore, there was an absolute lack of contemporaneous on
spot videography of the search, recovery and seizure proceedings
at the warehouse on 04.12.2025 and 05.12.2025. This complete
omission violates the standard operating procedures and
mandatory directives laid down by this Hon’ble Court in CRM
(NDPS) 492 of 2022 (Kalu Sk @ Kuran v. State of West Bengal) with

4

CRM (NDPS) 493 of 2022 (Kabir Sk. v. State of West Bengal).
According to the learned Advocate, the prosecution’s case suffers
from fatal legal infirmity, as no on-the-spot search list, recovery
memo or seizure list was prepared either at the shop premises or at
the VRL Logistics warehouse at the Agarpara Jute Mill premises.
Instead, the petitioner and the co-accused were forcibly taken
directly to the DRI office at New Town, Kolkata, where the officers
subsequently manufactured and drew up a combined
consolidated Inventory-cum-Seizure list at their desks. It is a
settled principle of law that seizure and inventory are distinct and
separate procedures which cannot be merged into a single
document, and the preparation of such a combined list post-facto
at the agency’s office, rather than at the place of recovery,
constitutes a gross violation of the mandatory provision of the
NDPS Act, thereby completely vitiating the evidentiary foundation of
the prosecution’s case. Lastly, the alleged DRI search was carried
out on 04.12.2025. However, when this search record is placed
against the DRI’s own formal complaint, which asserts that the
intelligence was received and developed only on the morning of
05.12.2025, it presents an absolute physical and temporal
impossibility. This reveals that the search story is completely
fabricated and back dated and shows that the DRI officers drew up
these records at their desks prior to any actual interception or raid
being carried out.

5

Learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner has argued the
case on two points, which are absence of videography of the search
and seizure at the place of occurrence and involvement of stock witnesses
by the DRI at the time of the search and seizure.
It was submitted on behalf of the petitioner that the standard operating
procedure of DRI during search operation reflects that the same should
commence prior to entry at the premises by the DRI search team and the
audio-video recording should be continuous. The SOP emphasizes that the
camera must continuously follow the search team. Surprisingly, the first
production petition dated 05.12.2025 reflects that a Hyundai i20 car was
intercepted and a person driving the vehicle, namely Md. Rajesh on
questioning admitted that cough syrup bottles were kept at the boot space
of the vehicle. Md. Rajesh divulged that such cough syrup bottles were
handed over to him by one Koushik Bera. A set of other officers along with
two independent witnesses subsequently apprehended Koushik Bera and
on reaching Cossipore F.L. Off Shop they intercepted Koushik Bera and
Anil Gupta (the petitioner herein). The first production petition do not
disclose with regard to any videography being conducted throughout the
process of search and seizure. However, the prayer reflects that the
prosecution intended to deposit the memory cards containing
reconstructed audio-video recordings of the recovery proceedings.
The petition of complaint filed by the DRI discloses that the DRI officers
along with Koushik Bera, Anil Gupta and two other independent witnesses
had been to godown of VRL Logistics inside Agarpara Jute mill and

6

another 1,000 bottles of cough syrup were recovered therefrom. The
petitioner was compelled to pay a sum of Rs . 2,222/- in favour of VRL
Logistics at the behest of DRI officers. It was claimed by the DRI that the
entire search and seizure procedure was recorded in audio-video mode
and stored in memory cards. However, the memory card numbers
mentioned in the petition of complaint do not tally with the number of the
memory cards mentioned in the prayer of the first production petition.
It was pointed out that the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the DRI
disclosed that videography of search and seizure was conducted only at
the office of DRI which bolsters the contention of the petitioner that no
videography was conducted from inception and the same was done at the
office of the DRI. Such piecemeal videography is per se illegal and dilutes
the authenticity of the prosecution case.
In order to fortify his argument, learned advocate for the petitioner
referred to series of judgements relating to videography of search and
seizure.
Relying upon Mithun Das & Anr. -versus- State of West Bengal, CRM
petitioner submitted that the Hon’ble High Court was
(NDPS) 144 of 2026
pleased to hold that it is the bounden duty of this court to ensure that the
directions given are fully complied with. In the said case, the seizure was
not video-graphed as such after expressing its opinion that procedures are
laid down to ensure safe-guards for fulfilling the constitutional mandates
and non-compliance of the same is a serious breach, the court was
pleased to grant bail to the accused. Similar views were expressed by the

7

Court in Sonal Barman & Ors. v. State of West Bengal, CRM (NDPS) 318 of
2025 and Shakti Nath Bhowmik @ Sakti Nath Bhowmik & Ors., CRM (NDPS)
602 of 2025 . Attention of the Court was drawn to Samit Mandal –versus-
State of West Bengal , CRM (NDPS) 1444 of 2023 .
Reference was made to reported judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
in
Shafhi Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2018) 5 SCC 311
relation to the suggestions of videography, which may be an effective tool
in investigation.
Emphasis was laid on the fact that the State as well as the Central
Government Agencies were directed to undertake training programs for
creating awareness relating to videography of recovery proceedings.
On an assessment of the search and seizure conducted in the case, it
was observed by the Hon’ble High Court that there was palpable violation
on the part of the investigating agency, as no videography of the seizure of
narcotics from the petitioner was done in the said place. There were no
independent witnesses, as such, the petitioner was released on bail.
In the case of Jahiruddin Sk. V. The State of West Bengal, CRA (DB) 217
of 2024, the attention of this court was drawn by the petitioner to the
observations of the Division Bench, wherein reliance was placed upon
Kalu Sk. v. State of W.B., reported in 2022 SCC OnLine Cal 4556 and it was
observed that smart phones are carried by the investigating officers,
which makes them easier to videograph the entire process of the search
and seizure or at least photographs of the said process using their phone.

8

However, in spite of the same being available, the investigating agency
having not done the same and there were no independent witnesses to
support the prosecution case, benefit was extended to the appellant
therein.
Learned advocate thereafter submitted that the Hon’ble High Court
primarily relied upon Shafhi Mohammad (supra), as well as the guidelines
laid down in Kalu Sk. v. State of W.B., reported in CRM (NDPS) 492 of 2022
and CRM (NDPS) 493 of 2022 to assert the importance of videography and
the same not being done, it was held that the search and seizure was
infructuous.
Attention of this Court was drawn by the petitioner to the judgment of
the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in Gaurang Jitendra Khair v. Narcotics
Control Bureau & Anr., (Criminal Bail Application No. 3506 of 2022) , and it
was emphasized that relying upon the judgments of Kalu Sk. @ Kuran
(supra) and Kabir Sekh (supra), and taking into account the observations
in Shafhi Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2018) 5 SCC 311, the
petitioner was released on bail, holding that there were reasonable
grounds to believe him not guilty of the offence for the purposes of Section
37 of the NDPS Act.
Petitioner also referred to the judgment of the Delhi High Court, being
Bail Application No. 1022 of 2026, (Arinze Hillary Ali v. State of Delhi) and
submitted that in a similar set of circumstances, wherein there was
absence of photography and videography and no independent witnesses
were present during seizure, the accused was granted the benefit of doubt

9

at the stage of bail. Learned advocate stressed on the observations made
in the judgment, particularly where the recovery of contraband is
supported only by official witnesses and no videography of the search and
seizure was done in presence of independent witnesses a doubt is cast on
the recovery of contraband unless the same is justified by cogent reasons.
It was specifically held in the judgment that the aforesaid grounds are
relevant factors while considering the bail application as the same casts
shadow over the very fulcrum of the case.
Petitioner also relied upon Sarfaraj v. State (NCT of Delhi), reported in
2026 SCC OnLine Del 3737, and submitted that the reasoning assigned in
the earlier judgment with regard to the absence of photography or
videography and independent witnesses was relied upon and the accused
was released on bail.
On the issue relating to the witnesses relied upon by the DRI in the
course of search and seizure it was submitted that the four so-called
independent witnesses relied upon by the DRI in the petition of complaint
are Abhijit Mondal (CSW-20), Ranjit Barui (CSW-21), Dilip Haldar (CSW-
22) and Pobitra Biswas (CSW-23). According to the petitioner, these four
witnesses are stock witnesses of the DRI, as they have been cited as
witnesses in a number of criminal prosecutions/investigations conducted
by the DRI. In order to illustrate the same, petitioner relied upon the
following list of cases:
(i) DRI/KZU/NDPS/ENQ-39/2026 – wherein Dilip Halder and Ranjit Barui
were cited as independent witnesses.

10

(ii) DRI/KZU/NDPS/ENQ-80/2025 – wherein Dilip Halder, Abhijit Mandal
and Ranjit Barui were cited as independent witnesses.

The DRI did not deny in respect of the seizure lists which were referred in
respect of the aforesaid two criminal cases.
Petitioner argued that the witnesses cited are projected as independent
witnesses, but in reality they are stock witnesses/panchas of search and
seizure in NDPS cases, who are relied upon to curtail the liberty of
individuals by invoking the stringent provisions of the NDPS Act.
It was also brought to the notice of the Court that although ‘Md. Rajesh’
name is typed on each of the inventory-cum-seizure lists, his signature does
not appear on the said documents.
The petitioner, therefore, relied upon the celebrated judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in ,
Prem Chand (Paniwala) v. Union of India
reported in (1981) 1 SCC 639 and submitted that the Hon’ble Apex Court
expressed serious concern with regard to an investigating agency using
stock witnesses and held that there may be difficulties in detection and
proof and strain upon the police in tracking down criminals; however,
fundamental rights are fundamental and personal liberty cannot be placed
at the mercy of the police.
The Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Kashmir Singh v. Narcotics Control
Bureau . (Bail Application No. 2314 of 2026), relying upon the decision in
Prem Chand (supra), granted bail.

11

The Hon’ble Delhi High Court, in Amarjit Singh v. DRI , reported in 2009
SCC OnLine Del 1684 , once again granted bail on the ground, inter alia, of
planting stock witnesses.
Learned advocate for the petitioner finally submitted that the aforesaid
discrepancies are not mere irregularities but glaring illegality which entitles
the petitioner to be released on bail.
Mr. Suleman, learned advocate appearing for the DRI, submitted that on
04.12.2025, an information was received that a Hyundai i20 car bearing
Registration No. WB 02 AC 0140 was proceeding along Jessore Road and
carrying contraband, i.e., Eskuf cough syrup, whose sale, purchase and
transport are prohibited under the NDPS Act. A team of officers of DRI
reached at Bira on Jessore Road at about 13:45 hours and intercepted the
Hyundai i20 vehicle parked near the roadside at Bira. A person was
available at the car, who disclosed his identity as Md. Rajesh. On enquiry,
he admitted that bottles of Eskuf cough syrup were available and kept at
the boot space of the vehicle. He was offered an option in writing relating to
his search when he opted to be searched before a Gazetted Officer and also
requested that such search be conducted at a different place for safety and
security reasons. A notice under Section 67 of the NDPS Act was served,
requiring him to appear at the office of DRI, Kolkata Zonal Unit. On further
enquiry, Md. Rajesh divulged that the bottles of Eskuf cough syrup which
were available in the vehicle was handed over to him by Koushik Bera. On
the instructions of Koushik Bera, the Eskuf cough syrup bottles were to be
handed over to different recipients at Panchpota near Bangaon for onward

12

supply to Bangladesh. He also informed that Koushik Bera would be
available at Cossipore F.L. Off Shop at Cossipore.
On receipt of the said information, DRI officers along with independent
witnesses proceeded towards Cossipore F.L. Off Shop and on being
identified they intercepted Koushik Bera and Anil Gupta. On repeated
questioning, Koushik Bera admitted that the consignment had been handed
over by him to Md. Rajesh on the instructions of Anil Gupta. On further
interrogation both the accused persons informed that another consignment
of Eskuf cough syrup was lying at the godown of VRL Logistics at Agarpara
and the consignee therein was named as M/s Ray Computer and
Electronics. A search conducted resulted in the recovery of ten cartons/
boxes from VRL Logistics at Agarpara. Both the accused persons were
served with notices and they were brought at the office of the DRI. The
recovery from the Hyundai i20 vehicle was 42 cartons/boxes wherein 1,042
bottles of Eskuf cough syrup was recovered and ten cartons/ boxes were
recovered from the godown of VRL Logistics at Agarpara which contained
1,000 bottles of cough syrup, aggregating to a recovery of 2,042 bottles of
Eskuf cough syrup.
It was submitted that at the place of recovery at Agarpara, as many
people started gathering and they became curious and inquisitive, so after
intimating the persons detained for security reasons the recovered
contraband were brought to the office of DRI, seized and videography of the
same were done. The memory card of audio-video recordings and their
hash values thereof were generated by a forensic expert.

13

In order to ascertain the further complicity of Md. Rajesh, Koushik Bera
and Anil Gupta, their further statements were recorded, particularly with
regard to the illicit smuggling of cough syrup into Bangladesh and on
reasonable belief of their conspiracy to obtain the 2,042 bottles of seized
cough syrup they were arrested on 05.12.2025 for violation of the provisions
of the NDPS Act.
It was further submitted that in the course of investigation Koushik Bera
divulged that consignment had been booked from Delhi with M/s ATC
Logistics Solution Private Limited in the name of M/s Ray Computer and
Electronics. Information was sent to the transporter in respect of the said
consignment and on 11.12.2025 it was informed through e-mail by the
transporter that the said consignment has reached Kolkata and has been
kept at the godown located at Kaliprasanna Sinha Road, Kolkata. A team of
officers on 12.12.2025 reached the said address and on examination of the
consignment found 14 packets from which 1,400 bottles of cough syrup/
codeine mixture, each of 100 ml was available. The staff of the transporter
further informed that another consignment of M/s Ray Computer and
Electronics had been kept at the godown. The said consignment was
examined and another 1,000 bottles of codeine cough syrup were recovered.
Total 2,400 bottles were recovered and whole of the process of search and
seizure was photographed/audio-videographed at the place of seizure.
Investigation revealed that the accused persons booked such consignments
in the names of M/s Ray Computer and Electronics and M/s Bablani
Brothers and area in-charge of VRL Logistics confirmed that the

14

consignments were received by Koushik Bera by furnishing his identity
proof and signature. Further, the mobile number available in the invoice
was used by Koushik Bera.
Analysis of call detail records reflected that Anil Gupta frequently
exchanged calls with Koushik Bera. The mobile number of Koushik Bera
also reflected several text messages exchanged with M/s ATC Logistics
Solution Private Limited and M/s VRL Logistics. Anil Gupta was also in
regular contact with Dilip Gupta, who used to send consignments from
Delhi. Koushik Bera was also in regular contact with Md. Rajesh and in the
morning of 04.12.2025 three calls were exchanged between them. The CDR
of Md. Rajesh also reflected the mobile numbers of persons relating to
recipients of the contraband. The WhatsApp chats of Anil Gupta with
Koushik Bera reflected the forwarding of consignor’s copy in the name of
M/s Ray Computer and Electronics.
It was submitted that the CDR and WhatsApp messages of the three
accused persons would reflect a chain of circumstances including the
consignor copies, bank transactions and invoices.
It was emphasized that there were cogent reasons for not photographing
or audio-video recording of the seizure dated 04.12.2025, however, the
seizure dated 12.12.2025 was videographed and photographed. As such, the
issue of citing seizure list witnesses who are alleged to be stock witnesses
are irrelevant as there are other clinching evidence which make out a
watertight case against the petitioner and do not make out any

15

circumstances to overcome the bar of Section 37 of the NDPS Act. As such,
the prayer for bail of the petitioner should be rejected.
I have taken into account the submissions of the respective parties and
on an assessment of the same I find that the petitioner’s main concern is
that no videography was done at the time of seizure and that stock
witnesses have been relied upon in order to justify such seizure by the
prosecution.
On an assessment of the documents relied upon by the DRI/
Prosecution it is reflected that on two dates seizures were effected, firstly
on 04.12.2025 and secondly on 12.12.2025. In respect of the seizure on
04.12.2025 prosecution assigned their reasons that the local people
assembled and became curious as such for security reasons the seized
materials were brought to the office of DRI and inventory along with
videography was done. So far as seizure on 12.12.2025 is concerned
photographs of the contraband were taken at the godown of ATL Logistics
along with audio video recording of such search and seizure. To that
effect DRI/ Prosecution has enclosed the relevant documents in their
supplementary affidavit-in-opposition.
In this case the argument advanced on behalf of the petitioner is that
no videography of search and seizure was effected at the place of seizure,
the documents relied upon by the prosecution before this Court,
particularly the second seizure dated 12.12.2025 do demolish such
factual issue raised by the petitioner. So far as the first seizure is
concerned reasons have been assigned by the prosecution for their

16

inability to videograph at the place of seizure.
The issue relating to videography assumes importance as in cases
under the NDPS, Act the legitimacy relating to recovery of the contraband
is the foundation and plinth of prosecution case and possibility of false
implication can be ruled out. Taking into account the materials placed in
this case by the prosecution at this stage the issue of false implication,
particularly nexus of the petitioner with the chain of events including
recovery cannot be ruled out. Consequently, the issue relating to same
set of witnesses being cited in other cases by the DRI/Prosecution do not
dilute the rigors of Section 37 of the NDPS.
Petitioner proceeded with the arguments that no videography of search
and seizure of contraband in this case was done, as such the judgments
relied upon by the petitioner has no applicability so far as the
prosecution case is concerned because of the factual assertions, which
are not only contrary but also are diametrically opposite to the
documentary evidences/materials placed by the prosecution before this
Court.
Accordingly, the application for bail of the petitioner in C.R.M. (NDPS)
1295 of 2026 is dismissed .
Pending applications, if any, are consequently disposed of.
All parties shall act on the server copy of this judgment duly
downloaded from the official website of this Court.

17

Urgent Xerox certified photocopy of this judgment, if applied for, be
given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.

(Tirthankar Ghosh, J.)