Mukhtiar Singh vs Rajinder Singh & Ors.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
114 Date of decision :16.11.2026
114(1) FAO No.5223 of 2002 (O&M)
RAJINDER SINGH AND ORS. …APPELLANTS
VERSUS
RAKESH KUMAR AND ORS. ...RESPONDENTS
114(2) FAO No.1010 of 2003 (O&M)
MUKHTIAR SINGH …APPELLANT
VERSUS
RAJINDER SINGH & ORS. ...RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Mr. J.S. Bhandohal, Advocate and
Ms. Manveer Kaur, Advocate
for appellants in FAO-5223-2002.
Mr. Jitender K. Sehrawat, Advocate
for respondent No.5 in FAO No.5223 of 2002.
Mr. R.C. Gupta, Advocate
for respondent No.11 in both the appeals.
*
PARMOD GOYAL, J. (ORAL)
FAO No. 5223 of 2002 has been preferred by appellants-
claimants seeking enhancement in compensation awarded vide award dated
06.08.2002 passed by learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kapurthala
(hereinafter referred to as ‘ Tribunal ’), whereby they were awarded total
compensation of Rs.2,30,400/- on account of untimely death of Sukhdev
Singh (hereinafter referred to as ‘ deceased ’) in motor vehicular accident
dated 24.05.1997 allegedly caused due to rash and negligent driving of
respondent-driver while driving Tempo bearing registration No.PB-06-2112
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -2-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
(hereinafter referred to as ‘ tempo ’).
2. On the other hand FAO No.1010 of 2003 has been preferred by
appellant-owner of bus bearing registration No.PB-02B-9916 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘ bus ’) being aggrieved by impugned award dated 06.08.2002,
whereby he was held liable to pay compensation awarded by learned
Tribunal to claimants.
FAO No.1010 of 2003
3. It is the case of appellants-claimants that deceased and his wife
i.e. claimant No.2 had boarded bus bearing registration No.PB-02-B-9916,
which was proceeding from Amritsar towards Dera Baba Vadhbag Singh via
Subhanpur –Tanda –Dasuya. That deceased and his wife were to go to Dera
Baba Vadhbag Singh and when the bus reached on Tanda Dasuya road, it
was found that two buses and a truck were going ahead of the bus in which
deceased and his wife were travelling. The driver of the bus had tried to
overtake the truck going ahead and while overtaking, he found that tempo
bearing registration No.PB-06-A-2112 was coming from opposite side. It
was asserted that their bus was being plied by respondent-driver at high
speed and while overtaking the bus lost its balance and struck against the
tempo coming from opposite side and thereafter against the wall of the
petrol pump on the roadside. That three persons had died on the spot,
whereas several others had become unconscious and had suffered grievous
injuries. It was claimed that claimant No.2 had suffered minor injuries and
the deceased was taken to Primary Health Center, Tanda Urmur, where he
was declared dead. It was also claimed that accident was also witnessed by
Nirmal Singh and others. Accordingly, compensation was sought from
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -3-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
respondents.
4. Drivers and owners of both the vehicles including Insurance
Company of tempo were impleaded as respondents. Admittedly, bus was not
having any insurance policy and it was being plied without insurance policy.
5. Appellant-owner of bus, however, had challenged manner of
occurrence stated by claimants by claiming that it was the tempo which was
coming at high speed and had lost its balance and in order to avoid the
accident, the driver of bus had taken turn, resultantly, bus and tempo had
collided and thereafter, bus had struck against the wall of petrol pump. It
was claimed that accident had taken place on account of rash and negligent
driving on the part of driver of tempo.
6. Respondent-driver and owner of tempo had also contested the
claim petition and claimed that it was bus owned by appellant-owner, which
was at fault as while overtaking another truck in a rash and negligent
manner, the bus had struck against the tempo. It was asserted by respondent-
driver and owner of tempo that the said tempo started from M/s. Diamond
Agro Industrial Mirthal on Pathankot-Jalandhar road after loading
Vanaspati/refined oil and was going to village Lalru via Jalandhar. That at
about 03:00 p.m., when tempo reached near petrol pump Tanda Bye-pass,
three buses and one truck were seen coming from the opposite side. Two
buses crossed the truck at very high speed and seeing this, respondent-driver
of tempo had taken his tempo on Katcha path on his left side. In the
meanwhile, driver of third bus bearing registration No.PB-02B-9916 while
overtaking the truck at high speed lost its control over the vehicle and struck
against the tempo which was parked on the katcha portion and thereafter
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -4-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
against the boundary wall of petrol pump. Respondent-driver and owner of
tempo also claimed to have lodged FIR against driver of the bus.
7. Following issues were framed from the pleadings of the
parties:-
i. Whether the petitioners are dependants of Sukhdev
Singh deceased ? OPP
ii. Whether Sukhdev Singh died in the accident which
has been caused by driving the offending vehicle
rashly and negligently by respondent No.1?OPP
iii. Whether the respondent No.1 was having a valid
driving licence ? OPR
iv. Whether the petitioners are entitled to compensation,
if so, to what extent and from whom? OPP
v. Relief.
8. In order to prove manner of accident, claimants had relied upon
evidence of AW2-Nirmal Singh as well as FIR (Ex3). The driver of bus had
not dared to step into the witness box, whereas driver of tempo, who was
impleaded as respondent No.1 before the Tribunal, had duly appeared as
RW1 and reiterated manner of accident as was stated by him in his written
statement. Claimants had also examined AW3 Naib Chand, Criminal
Ahlmad, who had produced the records of trial conducted by Criminal
Courts arisen from FIR (Ex.A3), which was lodged by none else but
respondent No.1-driver of tempo.
9. It is pertinent to note that learned Tribunal, after appreciating
manner of accident as stated by AW2, had noted that it was driver of bus
owned by appellant-owner who was convicted by criminal Court in trial
arising out of FIR (Ex.A3) lodged against driver of bus who was rash and
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -5-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
negligent. Learned Tribunal had taken into consideration testimony of RW1-
driver of tempo, wherein he had clearly stated that accident was result of
rash and negligent driving of driver who was driving the bus, and had found
that it was driver of bus who was responsible for causing the accident and
accordingly had held respondent-driver and owner of bus solely liable to pay
compensation as bus was not insured at the time of accident.
10. Learned counsel for appellant-owner has argued that learned
Tribunal had erred in not taking into consideration evidence of AW2 who
had stated that accident was result of rash and negligent driving on the part
of tempo. He also submits that once the witness of claimants stated the
manner of accident, learned Tribunal ought to have accepted the same and
could not have relied upon evidence of RW1 and contents of FIR (Ex.A3) to
record liability on the part of appellant-owner of bus.
11. On face of it, arguments on behalf of learned counsel for
appellant-owner of bus appears to be attractive. However, on close scrutiny,
it goes to show that learned Tribunal had correctly not relied upon evidence
of AW2, regarding rash and negligent driving on the part of tempo, rather
had taken in consideration the totality of circumstances, especially manner
of occurrence as was stated in claim petition, manner of occurrence as was
stated in FIR (Ex.A3), manner of accident as was stated by RW1 i.e. driver
of tempo and fact that it was driver of bus who was held liable for causing
the accident and convicted in the trial by criminal Court. If all these facts are
taken collectively, it appears that evidence of AW2 has correctly not been
accepted by learned Tribunal in totality of circumstances. In fact, evidence
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -6-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
of AW2 is an effort by claimants to get compensation from Insurance
Company.
12. Admittedly, bus was not insured and in order to get
compensation from Insurance Company, AW2 had claimed that it was
tempo, which had caused the accident. However, from perusal of evidence, it
is clearly made out that presence of AW2 itself was doubtful at the time of
accident nor his statement goes to show that he had taken any ticket of the
bus. AW2 had also not given any statement before the police nor was
witness in the criminal case which was lodged on the statement of
respondent-driver of tempo. In fact, AW2 himself had clearly stated that
accident had taken place when driver of the bus was making effort to
overtake the truck. Even if the evidence of AW2 is taken to consideration, it
also points out towards rash and negligent driving solely on the part of
driver of the bus as it was duty of bus owned by appellant-owner to be
careful at the time of overtaking another vehicle. The fact that bus had struck
vehicle coming from opposite direction which was on its correct side goes to
show that it was driver of the bus who was at fault. Moreover, the evidence
of RW1, author of FIR upon which driver of bus was convicted had gone
unrebutted and driver of the bus had not dared to step into the witness box
and contradict manner of accident as was stated by RW1.
13. In present case, there is no dispute as regards the accident and
involvement of both the vehicles. Therefore, even after concluding that
evidence of AW2 is not trustworthy, the manner of occurrence can be found
out from the pleadings as well as evidence led by both the sides. In present
case, the manner of accident as was stated in FIR as well as claim petition
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -7-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
appears to be trustworthy and evidence of AW2 is an attempt to help
appellant-owner to avoid his liability as he had not got his vehicle insured
despite mandate of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. Therefore, I do not find any
error in the conclusion drawn by learned Tribunal.
14. Accordingly, appeal ( FAO No.1010 of 2003 ) preferred by
appellant-owner of bus qua issue No.1 is dismissed.
FAO No.5223 of 2002
15. Present appeal has been preferred by appellants-claimants
seeking enhancement of compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal. In
the present case, learned Tribunal had awarded the following compensation
to appellant-claimants:
Income Rs.2,400/-per month
Deduction 1/3rd
Multiplier 12
Loss of dependency Rs.2,30,400/-
(Rs.1,600/- X 12 X12)
Total compensation
Rs.2,30,400/-
awarded
16. Learned counsel for the appellants-claimants has sought
enhancement of compensation on the following grounds:
●
That the learned Tribunal has erred in not assessing the
income of the deceased as pleaded and proved by the
claimants.
●
That the learned Tribunal has failed to apply the correct
multiplier, as per age of deceased.
●
That the deduction towards the personal and living expenses
of the deceased is excessive and contrary to the settled
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -8-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
principles of law.
●
That no addition towards future prospects has been made
while calculating the loss of dependency. Future prospects
ought to have been added, as per age of deceased.
●
That the learned Tribunal has also failed to award just and
appropriate compensation under the conventional heads,
namely funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of spousal
and parental consortium, in accordance with the law laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
17. It is the case of appellants-claimants that deceased was earning
Rs.20,000/- by running a dairy farm consisting of 15 to 20 buffaloes. It was
also claimed that deceased was owner of agricultural land which he was
cultivating and was earning some amount from said agricultural activities.
However, except for oral assertions, no proof as regards to existence of dairy
and income from dairy had been produced by appellants-claimants. Rajinder
Singh-appellant-claimant No.1 who is son of deceased could not show
ownership of any buffalo in the name of deceased. He also admitted that the
land is still under their cultivation and they are earning from the land owned
by the deceased. Reliance had also been placed by appellants-claimants on
Jamabandis (Ex.A4 and Ex.A5), which show that deceased was owner of
land measuring 40 kanals and 15 marlas, approximately 05 acres, which was
inherited by his wife and was under self-cultivation of deceased. Ex.A5 on
the other hand shows that another piece of land that is 8065/42526 share of
the total of 132 kanals and 12 marlas was also owned by deceased but was in
possession of others as same was cultivated by other persons and not by
deceased. Keeping in view the fact that agricultural land continued to give
SUNIL CHANDER
income to the dependents of the deceased, the income of deceased from
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -9-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
agricultural activities has to be taken equivalent to managerial skills put in
by deceased in looking after his land which included land which was under
self-cultivation as well as land with the tenants.
18. Learned Tribunal had taken the income of deceased to be
Rs.2400/- on the basis of minimum wages, which in the present case cannot
be sustained in view of Jamabandis (Ex.A4 and Ex.A5), from which it is
clearly made out that deceased was self-cultivating about five acres of land
and was looking after three to four acres land which was under tenants.
Therefore, keeping in view managerial skills and average income being
earned from an acre of land in State of Punjab in the year 1997, the income
of deceased is taken as Rs.4,000 /- per month towards his managerial
contribution in agricultural activities.
19. The deceased was stated to be 42 years old, therefore addition
of 25% towards future prospects has to be made in view of judgment passed
by Hon’ble Supreme Court in National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs.
Pranay Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16) SCC 680. In view of age of deceased to
be 42 years, multiplier of ‘14’ would be applicable as per judgment passed
by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi
Transport Corporation & Anr. , 2009(6) SCC 121. Similarly, deduction
towards personal expenses has to be made on the basis of number of
dependents which are six in present case i.e. wife and five children.
Accordingly, deduction to the extent of 1/4th shall be applicable.
20. The loss of dependency, therefore, has to be determined by
taking monthly income of deceased to be Rs.4,000/-, by adding future
prospects to the extent of 25% , by applying multiplier of ‘ 14 ’ and by
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -10-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
making deduction of 1/4th towards personal expenses.
21. Apart from compensation for loss of dependency, appellants-
claimants shall also be entitled to Rs . 15,000 /- towards funeral expenses and
Rs . 15,000 /- towards loss of estate . Appellant-claimant No.1 shall be entitled
to compensation of Rs . 40,000 /- towards loss of spousal consortium .
Appellants-claimants No.2 to 6 shall be entitled to compensation of
Rs . 40,000 /- each towards loss of parental consortium . It is however made
clear that in case Hon’ble Supreme Court answers the reference regarding
quantum of compensation under conventional heads made in Hasina
Yasmin & Ors. Vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd. , 2025 SCC Online SC
2919 in favour of appellants-claimants, appellant-claimants shall be free to
seek said amount by moving appropriate application in this regard.
22. Reworked compensation payable to appellants-claimants is as
under:-
Income Rs.4,000/- Rs.4,000/-
per month per month
Future prospects 25% Rs.5,000/-
(4,000+1000)
Deduction 1/4th Rs.3,750/-
(5,000 – 1250)
Multiplier 14 14
Total loss of Rs.3,750X12X14 Rs. 6,30,000/-
dependency
Loss of estate Rs.15,000/-
Funeral expenses Rs.15,000/-
Loss of spousal
consortium to
appellant-claimant
No.1
Rs.40,000/-
Loss of parental
consortium to
appellants-claimants
No.2 to 6
Rs.40,000/-X 5 Rs.2,00,000/-
Total compensation Rs.2,30,400/-
awarded by the
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO No.5223 of 2002 -11-
FAO No.1010 of 2003
Tribunal
Total compensation Rs.9,00,000/-
awarded in appeal
Enhanced Rs. 9,00,000/-
compensation (awarded in appeal)
-
Rs.2,30,400/-
(awarded by
Tribunal)
Rs.6,69,600/-
23. Appellants-claimants shall be entitled to enhanced
compensation (except for conventional heads i.e. loss of consortium, funeral
expenses, loss of estate) along with 7.5% interest from the date of filing of
claim petition till realization of entire amount. Interest on enhanced
compensation under conventional heads shall be payable from August 2017
onwards till realization. Apportionment and liability to pay compensation
shall be as per award.
24. Appeal bearing FAO No.5223 of 2002 is allowed in above
terms and appeal bearing FAO No.1010 of 2003 preferred by appellant-
owner of offending bus is dismissed.
25. Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of. Photocopy of
this order be placed on the files of connected cases.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
JUDGE
16.11.2026
Sunil Chander
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.18 15:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document