Rajat Kumar And Ors Etc Etc vs S D Adarash Jain Kanya Maha Vidyalaya Sadhaura And Anr Etc Etc

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 648
REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NOS.19552-19553 OF 2017

RAJAT KUMAR AND OTHERS APPELLANTS


VERSUS

S D ADARSH JAIN KANYA MAHA RESPONDENTS
VIDYALAYA SADHAURA AND OTHERS


J U D G M E N T

ATUL S. CHANDURKAR, J
1. The appellants are the legal heirs of the original plaintiff-
Om Parkash. The original plaintiff filed Civil Suit No.426 of
1996 against the respondents-original defendants seeking
mandatory injunction for removal of alleged illegal
encroachment in the form of a wall constructed by them on
the common open space beyond the plaintiff’s house. He
further sought permanent injunction seeking to restrain the
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
LOKESH ARORA
Date: 2026.06.19
14:26:19 IST
Reason:
defendants from raising any further construction thereon. The

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 1 of 10

Trial Court on 06.02.2006 decreed the suit and directed the
defendants to remove the encroachment committed by raising
the said walls. It also restrained them from raising any further
construction over the said walls.
Regular Civil Appeal No.137 of 2006 preferred by the
defendants was dismissed on 05.09.2007 and the decree
passed by the Trial Court was upheld.
The defendants being aggrieved preferred Regular
Second Appeal No.364 of 2008 before the Punjab and Haryana
1
High Court . By the judgment dated 25.11.2011, the High
Court disposed the Second Appeal with a direction to the
defendants to pay an amount of ₹ 10,000/- with interest
@ 12% per annum being half the amount of expenditure
incurred on construction of the walls in question. It further
held that on making such payment, the wall would be treated
as ‘common’ between the parties. The legal heirs of the
plaintiff challenged the reversal of the decree before this
Court, reference to which would be made a bit later.

1
For short, ‘the High Court’

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 2 of 10

2. The original plaintiff also filed another Civil Suit being
CS No.148 of 2000 against the same defendants, this time
with a prayer for mandatory injunction for removal of lintel of
the school building that had been erected by the defendants
on the wall of the plaintiff’s house. The Trial Court by its
judgment dated 08.11.2004 decreed the said suit and directed
the defendants to remove the lintel of the school building from
the said wall. The defendants were also restrained from
putting any lintel on any wall of the plaintiff’s house.
Being aggrieved, the plaintiff preferred Regular Civil
Appeal No.143 of 2004 which came to be dismissed by the
first Appellate Court on 05.09.2007. Being aggrieved, the
defendants preferred Regular Second Appeal No.363 of 2008
before the High Court. The Second Appeal was decided on
25.11.2011 and a similar decree directing the defendants to
pay an amount of ₹ 7,000/- being half of the amount spent on
construction of the wall with interest @ 12% per annum was
passed. It was further directed that on making such payment,
the wall would be treated as ‘common’ between the parties.

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 3 of 10

3. The legal heirs of the original plaintiff being aggrieved by
the reversal of the aforesaid decrees by the High Court filed
appeals before this Court. By order dated 13.09.2013 passed
in Civil Appeal Nos.8203 of 2013 and 8281 of 2013, it was
held that the modification of the decrees by the High Court
without entering into the merits of the controversy was
impermissible. No substantial questions of law had been
framed while deciding the Second Appeals. On these counts,
the judgments delivered in the Second Appeals by the High
Court were set aside and the proceedings were remanded for
fresh consideration in accordance with law.
4. On remand, the High Court was of the view that the
construction of the wall had been raised long back. There was
no valuation report on record and the claim alleged to be put
forth by the plaintiff had not been proved. By observing that
the other party could be compensated in terms of money that
could be assessed by a valuer and with a view to do justice
between the parties, it directed the Executing Court to assess
the value of the construction. The defendants were
accordingly directed to deposit such amount in the Executing

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 4 of 10

Court to be paid to the legal heirs of the plaintiff. With these
directions, the decree passed by the Trial Court as affirmed
by the first Appellate Court came to be set aside.
The legal heirs of the original plaintiff are aggrieved by
the reversal of the said decrees and have, thus, preferred the
present appeals.
5. Despite service, there has been no appearance on behalf
of the respondents since 23.04.2019. After hearing
Ms. Sangeeta Kumar, learned counsel for the appellants and
on perusal of the record, we are of the view that the High Court
committed an error in reversing the decrees passed by the
Trial Court and affirmed by the first Appellate Court on
irrelevant considerations. We say so for the following reasons:
a) The initial suit filed by the original plaintiff was
essentially for a decree for mandatory injunction seeking
removal of the alleged encroachment undertaken at the
behest of the defendants on the common open space beyond
the construction of the plaintiff. According to the original
plaintiff, such construction interfered with the right of the
plaintiff to enjoy air and light through the ventilators as well

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 5 of 10

as obstructed the passing of water through the common path.
It found that the defendants could not prove any right, title or
interest on the land on which they had erected the wall. The
decree was, thus, passed to remove the wall illegally erected
by them. In the other suit, the Trial Court found that the
defendants had put up a lintel of the school building on the
wall of the plaintiff’s house illegally. A decree directing
removal of the same and restraining the defendants from
doing so in the future was passed. Both these decrees were
upheld by the first Appellate Court. There was no prayer
whatsoever made by the original plaintiff seeking any
damages or compensation from the defendants for the
encroachment committed by them. In absence of any such
relief sought by the original plaintiff, the decree passed in his
favour could not have been set aside by the High Court by
compelling his legal heirs to accept compensation that was
directed to be assessed by a valuer. The legal heirs of the
plaintiff did not consent for such course to be followed. The
High Court, therefore, could not have undertaken such
exercise of seeking to compensate one party at the cost of the
other without any prayer being made in that regard.

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 6 of 10

b) The High Court by the impugned judgment reversed the
decree for mandatory injunction for removal of encroachment
passed by the Trial Court which was upheld by the first
Appellate Court. It, however, directed the Executing Court to
assess the value of the offending wall put up by the
defendants so as to compensate the plaintiff in terms of
money. Once the decrees passed by the Trial Court in favour
of the plaintiff were set aside, there would be no occasion for
the Executing Court to proceed with the execution
proceedings since there would be no decree holding the field
for being executed. In such a situation, directing the
Executing Court to assess the value of the wall in question
would be requiring it to undertake an exercise not supported
by any decree whatsoever. Indeed, the course adopted by the
High Court does not find support under Order XXI of the Code
2
of Civil Procedure, 1908 .
c) The High Court ought to have been mindful of the fact
that a similar exercise undertaken by it earlier while deciding
the respective Second Appeals and directing the payment of

2
For short, ‘the Code’

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 7 of 10

compensation to the original plaintiff was set aside by this
Court. The High Court, on remand however again committed
the same error, this time by directing the Executing Court to
undertake valuation of the wall in question so as to
compensate the legal heirs of the plaintiff in monetary terms.
There being no prayer made by the original plaintiff in the suit
for grant of any compensation nor any consent having been
offered by the legal heirs of the plaintiff in that regard, the
High Court could not have imposed such a direction on them,
especially when there was a decree operating in their favour.
d) The impugned order of the High Court proceeds on a
factually wrong premise that the Trial Court in Civil Suit
No.426 of 1996 had recorded a finding that the wall in
question was a common wall. No such finding was recorded
by the Trial Court. In fact, a decree for removal of the offending
wall came to be passed by the Trial Court. Further, though
the High Court has referred to three questions in the
impugned judgment and has stated that the defendants urged
the Court to frame the said questions as ‘substantial
questions of law’, the impugned order does not indicate that

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 8 of 10

the said questions were treated as substantial questions of
law. However, the order concludes by observing that the
substantial questions were answered in favour of the
defendants and the decree passed in favour of the original
plaintiff was set aside. It is, thus, clear that without an
available question of law for consideration and also by making
out a new prayer, the decrees passed in favour of the original
plaintiff have been set aside. The legal heirs of the plaintiff
have been required to accept monetary relief for which a
prayer was never made. Such course has resulted in
miscarriage of justice.
6. For all the aforesaid reasons, we find the judgment of the
High Court to be unsustainable. Accordingly, the common
judgment dated 02.05.2016 passed in RSA No.363 of 2008
and 364 of 2008 by the High Court is set aside. Since the
appeals have not been adjudicated on merits, there is no
option but to request the High Court to re-consider both the
appeals in accordance with Section 100 of the Code and
decide the same on their own merits. Considering the fact that

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 9 of 10

the Second Appeals are of the year 2008, we request the High
Court to consider the same expeditiously.
7. The Civil Appeals are allowed in aforesaid terms with no
order as to costs.

………..……………………..J.
[ S.V.N. BHATTI ]



….…..………………………..J.
[ ATUL S. CHANDURKAR ]

NEW DELHI,
JUNE 19, 2026.

Civil Appeal Nos.19552-19553 of 2017 Page 10 of 10