Naresh Kumar Gupta & Anr. vs State Nct Of Delhi And Anr
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~108&109
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 19.11.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010235462025
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025, CRL.M.A. 12558/2025
+
(108) NARESH KUMAR GUPTA & ANR. .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Manav Vohra, Ms. Kavita
Nailwal, Advs.
versus
STATE NCT OF DELHI AND ANR .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Naresh Kumar Chahar (APP)
Mr. Utkarsh (APP) along with Mr.
Abhiraj Singh, Adv. for R2
SI Chetan (P.S. Pashim Vihar West)
#
CNR No. DLHC010878342025
+
CRL.REV.P. 449/2025, CRL.M.A. 33163/2025
(109) NARESH KUMAR GUPTA & ANR. .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Manav Vohra, Ms. Kavita
Nailwal, Advs.
versus
STATE NCT OF DELHI AND ANR .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Naresh Kumar Chahar (APP)
Mr. Utkarsh (APP) along with Mr.
Abhiraj Singh, Adv. for R2
SI Chetan (P.S. Pashim Vihar West).
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN DATTA
SACHIN DATTA, J. (ORAL)
1. These petitions arise out of a Criminal Case (Cr. Case) No. 9213/2020,
pending before ld. Judicial Magistrate First Class-08, West District, Tis
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 1 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52
Hazari Courts, Delhi. The petitioners herein are Naresh Kumar Gupta
(petitioner no. 1) and his Sole Proprietorship Firm, namely, M/s Masters
Medical Equipment (petitioner no. 2). Respondent no.2 is the District
Appropriate Authority (West), appointed under the Pre-Conception and
Pre-Natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994
(hereinafter “ PCPNDT Act ”).
2. The factual background is that the District Inspection & Monitoring
Committee of PC & PNDT Cell (West), with prior approval of DDA/DM
(West), along with SDM, Punjabi Bagh, and District Nodal Officer, PC &
PNDT Cell (West), inspected the alleged address of petitioner no. 2. Upon
such inspection, the aforesaid inspecting authorities seized several documents
and consequently found that petitioner no. 2 has engaged in unauthorised
sale/distribution/dealing of MRI and other medical equipment, without
mandatory registration. The same was communicated by SDM, Punjabi Bagh,
Delhi, to the SHO, Mianwali Nagar. Consequently, FIR No. 323/2017, dated
14.07.2017, was registered at P.S. Mianwali Nagar, Outer District, Delhi,
under Section 25 of the PCPNDT Act. Thereafter, a chargesheet was filed, by
way of which Section 23 of the PCPNDT Act was added.
3. On 29.11.2024, the Appropriate Authority filed a complaint under
Section 28 of the PCPNDT Act read with Section 200 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter “ CrPC ”), alleging violation of Circular No.
F.No. 9(10)65/PNDT/DFW/14/4308.
4. By the order dated 11.03.2025 in Criminal Case (Cr. Case) No.
9213/2020 (impugned in CRL.M.C. 2812/2025), took cognisance of the
aforesaid complaint in the following manner:
“ In the present case cognizance was taken by Ld. Predecessor of this
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 2 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52
Court on 27.10.2022. The cognizance was taken after filing of police
charge-sheet. Thereafter the matter was listed for arguments on
charge.
Later on, complaint has been filed on behalf of the
department. The trial should have proceeded on the basis of
complaint case rather than police case. It is settled law that
cognizance is taken of the facts, circumstances and ingredients of
the offence. It is immaterial whether the cognizance is taken upon
police report, complaint or on the knowledge of the Magistrate.
Since, cognizance has already been taken by the Ld. Predecessor,
this court deem it appropriate that the present proceedings be
continued as a complaint case.
”
(emphasis supplied)
5. Vide order dated 10.09.2025 in Crl. Case 9213/2020, the matter was put
up for framing of charges. Subsequently thereto, the trial Court, by order
dated 16.09.2025, framed charges under Sections 25/26 read with Section 3B
of the PCPNDT Act. Both these orders are assailed in CRL.M.C. 449/2025.
6. It is the sole contention of the petitioner that cognisance on a police
report is barred by Section 28 of the PCPNDT Act, and that the complaint of
the Authorised Authority was never considered on its own merits.
7. Section 28 of the PCPNDT Act reads as follows:
“ 28.
(1)
Cognizance of Offences:
No court shall take cognizance of an offence under this Act
except on a complaint made by
(a) the Appropriate Authority concerned, or any officer authorised
in this behalf by the Central Government or State Government, as
the case may be, or the Appropriate Authority; or
(b) a person who has given notice of not less than 1[fifteen days] in
the manner prescribed, to the Appropriate Authority, of the alleged
offence and of his intention to make a complaint to the court.
Explanation.-- For the purpose of this clause, "person" includes a
social organisation.
(2) No court other than that of a Metropolitan Magistrate or a
Judicial Magistrate of the first class shall try any offence punishable
under this Act.
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 3 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52
(3) Where a complaint has been made under clause (b) of
sub-section (1), the court may, on demand by such person, direct the
Appropriate Authority to make available copies of the relevant
records in its possession to such person. ”
(emphasis supplied)
8. This Court finds merit in the aforesaid contention of the ld. counsel for
the petitioner; the same is in consonance with the decision of the Supreme
Court in State of U.P. v. Brij Pal Singh , 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1673 . The
relevant observations therein are as under:
“ 6.4.
Section 28 prohibits taking of cognizance by a court except in
two scenarios, (a) The AA or the AO of the Central, State
Government or AA shall make the complaint to the Court; (b) on a
complaint by any person, not less than fifteen days' notice to the
AA of his intention to make the complaint.
*
10.3. One submission of the Union of India was that Section 28 of
the Act only restricted the Court's power to take cognizance and
nothing else. But the question that we put to ourselves is what would
be the logical conclusion of the investigation carried out by the
police? Once it undertakes an investigation, the police have two
options available to it. One, is to file a closure report, if it finds that
no offence is made out, or two, to file a chargesheet upon the
completion of the investigation. A chargesheet obviously is filed
before a Court. To what end though? The Court cannot take
cognizance thereof due to the mandatory jurisdictional bar under
Section 28, and, as such, the effort made by the police would result
in being nugatory in the eyes of law. Can such an interpretation be
countenanced in law? Certainly not. Regarding Section 28, we
may further observe that it also provides for a ‘person’ to make a
complaint, with notice to the AA of such complaint and of the
intent to make a complaint before the court. So, it provides two
methods for a complaint to be made under Section 28(1)(a) & (b),
and in both scenarios the AA is indispensable. Still further, it is
provided in the Explanation to Section 28 that a ‘person’, within its
meaning, includes a social organisation. The legislature has taken
care to explain the meaning of a person as being inclusive of only a
social organisation, and in all other scenarios a ‘person’ has to be
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 4 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52
understood in its general meaning. In other words, it may be that a
police official, in his private capacity, can make a complaint to the
court or to the AA by following the requisite procedure but the
police as an institution have not been covered within the meaning
of ‘person’. Given that, outside its ordinary meaning, a person may
include entities such as companies or individuals, but however in the
Act, only social organisations have been expressly included within
its meaning. We, therefore, find force in the submission that the
language of Section 28 impacts jurisdiction and is prohibitory
.
*
11. … Question 1 - Whether, for offences under the PC & PNDT Act,
the registration of FIR at the police station is permissible, merely
because the offences under the PC & PNDT Act have been made
cognizable and non-bailable?
Answer 1 - The language of the statute, more particularly Sections
27 and 28 of the Act when read together, in light of the other
provisions and the socially beneficial nature of the Act as also the
requirement of sensitivity along with medical and technical
know-how, indicates that the police are not meant to be the
investigators for the purpose of this Act. This is further made clear
by the fact that an FIR once registered cannot be taken to its
logical conclusion as per the procedures of this Act. The restriction
applies only to offences under this Act and does not restrict the
police's power to investigate or prosecute independent offences
disclosed under substantive criminal law (IPC/BNS)
Question 2 - Whether the police investigation is permissible for the
offences under the PC & PNDT Act? And who can investigate the
complaints, received for violation of the provisions of the PC &
PNDT Act?
.
Answer 2 - Section 17(4) of the Act, while describing the functions
of the AA, clearly states that investigating the complaints is its
responsibility. Rule 18A(3)(iv), which has statutory force, also
requires that recourse to the police be avoided “as far as possible”.
It necessarily has to be concluded, therefore, that the police cannot
be the main investigating authority. At best, the police may play a
supplemental role, as and when required by the AA under its
supervision
Question 3 - Whether on the chargesheet submitted after the
investigation by the police, the competent magistrate can take
cognizance of the offence under the PC & PNDT Act?
.
Answer 3 - Section 28 of the Act envisions a complete statutory
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 5 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52
embargo on the taking of cognizance except in situations and
scenarios provided thereunder. The answer has to be clear. The
competent Magistrate shall not be able to take cognizance upon the
filing of a chargesheet
. ”
(emphasis supplied)
9. To the same effect, a Coordinate Bench of this Court in Manoj Krishan
Ahuja v. State (NCT of Delhi) , 2023 SCC OnLine Del 2303 , inter alia ,
observed as under:
“ 30.
Thus, it is clear from a bare reading of Section 28 of
PC&PNDT Act that there exists a bar on Courts as far as taking
cognizance of an offence under the Act is concerned, and the same
can only be taken in accordance with Section 28 of the Act.
*
32. Having discussed the procedure contemplated under Section 28
of the Act in the preceding discussion, this Court notes that the
manner in which the cognizance was taken by the learned Trial
Court upon a chargesheet is not the procedure envisaged under the
PC&PNDT Act. In the present case, the complaint had to be filed
by the concerned Appropriate Authority before the learned Trial
Court as a complaint under Section 200 Cr. P.C. Since the
cognizance has been taken on the chargesheet filed under Section
173 of Cr. P.C., it is clearly in the teeth of the bar under Section 28
of this Act which bars cognizance except upon receipt of complaint
in the manner provided therein.
It is also the sine qua non for taking
cognizance that the said Appropriate Authority or the person so
authorised should be validly appointed. ”
(emphasis supplied)
10. In light of the settled position of law that cognisance cannot be taken on
the basis of a police report/chargesheet invoking only the offences under the
PCPNDT Act, the order dated 27.10.2022 (referenced in the impugned order,
dated 11.03.2025), by way of which cognisance was taken on a chargesheet,
is bad in law and therefore, quashed. Therefore, the question which remains
before this Court is whether a subsequent complaint by the Authorised
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 6 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52
Authority can cure the defect of taking cognisance on the basis of the
chargesheet.
11. This Court, in Manoj Krishan Ahuja (supra) , in addition to stating that
cognisance taken on a police report/chargesheet is contrary to the bar under
Section 28 of the PCPNDT Act, also held that a subsequent complaint filed by
the Appropriate Authority would not validate such a cognisance order. The
relevant observations to this effect in the said judgment are as under:
“ 35. In the considered opinion of this Court, since Section 28 of the
Act expressly prohibits taking of cognizance by the Courts in
absence of a complaint made by Appropriate Authority or any other
person authorised on its behalf, the complaint filed subsequently
and registered and pending adjudication as per law under the Act
cannot come to the rescue of the prosecution, more so since it will
amount to prosecuting the same persons for same offences by two
procedures prescribed under law i.e. by way of filing of a
complaint case which was mandatory under this Act and on the
basis of cognizance taken of a chargesheet which is prohibited
under the Act.
”
(emphasis supplied)
12. It is noticed that another Coordinate Bench of this Court, in Uravashi
Fakay v. State (NCT of Delhi) , 2023 SCC OnLine Del 8091 , set aside the
cognisance taken on a chargesheet/police report, after not only rejecting the
view that the defect was curable by a later complaint but also by holding that a
police report and complaint cannot be clubbed together under Sections 202
and 210 of the CrPC. The relevant observations therein are as under:
“ 62. In view of the above and the express provisions of law, the
observation made by the learned ASJ in the impugned order dated
02.07.2014 that the aforesaid order dated 11.01.2013 was a curable
defect which has been rectified by the complaint filed by
respondent no. 2 which was pending in the same Court, is not
sustainable in law. The order dated 11.01.2013 taking cognizance
is set aside and the petitioners are discharged in the said
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 7 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52
chargesheet
. At the same time, it is observed that registration of an
FIR and subsequent investigation was not barred under the
provisions of the Act. In Manoj Krishan Ahuja (supra), it was further
held as under: …
*
68. In view of the above, for the purposes of proceedings under
Section 210 of the CrPC, so far as clubbing of police report and
complaint is concerned, cognizance of an offence of a report under
Section 173 of the CrPC is mandatory. Section 210(2) of the CrPC
clearly stipulates that the Magistrate shall try together the
complaint case and the case arising out of the police report only if
the cognizance had been taken by the learned Magistrate on such
report. In the present case as pointed out hereinabove, the
cognizance could not have been taken in view of the Section
28(1)(a) of the PCPNDT Act and, in absence of any cognizance the
clubbing of the police report and the complaint is not permissible
under Section 210 of the CrPC
.
*
72. The provisions of Section 202 of the CrPC as stated
hereinabove clearly applies to a complaint case and the police
report filed in the present case was not in pursunce to an order
passed under Section 202 of the CrPC in the complaint case filed
on behalf of respondent no. 2. It is also pertinent to observe that
provision of clubbing a police report and complaint has been
provided for under Section 210 of CrPC and not under Section 202
of the CrPC.
The learned ASJ and the learned CMM erred in law by
clubbing the police report and complaint case under the provision of
Section 202 of the CrPC. At this juncture, reference is made to Nazir
Ahmad and The King-Emperor, 1936 SCC OnLine PC 41, wherein
the Privy Council was dealing with a case where the appellant was
convicted on the strength of a confession said to have been made by
him to a Magistrate under the provisions of Section 164 of the CrPC.
Oral evidence of the said alleged confession was given by the
learned Magistrate but the same was not recorded by him, as
required under Section 164 of the CrPC. While dealing with the
aforesaid situation, the Privy Council observed and held as under …
*
74. In view of the above, the findings of the learned ASJ that the
police report filed under Section 173 of the CrPC could be treated
as inquiry report under Section 202 of the CrPC and also that the
police report and the complaint could be clubbed together under
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 8 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52
”
the said Section are not sustainable in law and set aside.
(emphasis supplied)
13. In the circumstances,the impugned order dated 11.03.2025 cannot
survive the scrutiny of law.The cognisance, even in the complaint case, was
taken on the basis of the police charge sheet, and the trial Court proceeded to
treat the mode of cognisance as “ immaterial ”. This same ignores the statutory
bar prescribed under Section 28 of the PCPNDT Act and the dicta laid down
in the aforesaid decisions of this Court. In the present case, the later complaint
of the Appropriate Authority cannot cure the disregard of the statutory bar at
the time of taking cognisance, as the defect goes to the root of the jurisdiction.
Accordingly, the impugned order is set aside.
14. Considering that the impugned orders, dated 10.09.2025 and
16.09.2025, concerning the framing of charges, flow from and rest on the
impugned order dated 11.03.2025, these orders fall with the impugned order
dated 11.03.2025 as well.
15. In the circumstances, the present petitions are allowed, and the
impugned orders (dated 11.03.2025, 10.09.2025, and 16.09.2025) are set
aside. The learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, West District, Tis Hazari
Courts, Delhi, shall consider the complaint, dated 29.11.2024, afresh as a
complaint under Section 28 of the PNPCDT Act, in accordance with law. A
suitable decision on cognisance shall be taken on the basis of the said
complaint. It may be noted that in Uravashi Fakay (supra) , as well ( vide
paragraphs 79 and 80), the complaint case was directed to be considered on its
own merits, after quashing of the order taking cognisance on the chargesheet.
16. Accordingly, the petitions are allowed in the above terms. Pending
application/s also stand disposed of.
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 9 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52
17. The petitioners seek to urge certain legal lacunae in the complaint filed
by the Authorised Authority. It shall be open to the petitioner to take all these
pleas before the concerned Court, which shall consider them in accordance
with law. This Court has not expressed any opinion as regards thereto.
SACHIN DATTA, J
NOVEMBER 19, 2026/ uk/vk
Signature Not Verified
CRL.M.C. 2812/2025and connected matter Page 10 of 10
Digitally Signed
By:ABHISHEK THAKUR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
12:36:52