TOLENTINE WAHLANG AND ANR. vs THE STATE OF MEGHALAYA AND 6 ORS.

Court
High Court of Meghalaya

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
MLHC010013562023
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 383 of 2023
Reserved on : 04.06.2026
Pronounced on : 17.11.2026
Uploaded on : 17.11.2026
Whether the operative part or full judgment is pronounced : Full Judgment

1.Shri Tolentine Wahlang
S/o (L) Nestor Lyngdoh,
R/o Nonglynkien Village, Maharam Syiemship,
South West Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.

2. Shri Haspingwel Kharhari,
S/o (L) Stickshon Marngar,
R/o Mawtiehbah Village, Raid Saw Symper,
South West Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
… Petitioner(s)
Versus

1.State of Meghalaya represented by
The Chief Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Shillong.

2. The Secretary/Deputy Secretary/Under Secretary/Joint Secretary
To the Government of Meghalaya,
District Council Affairs Department, Shillong.

3. The Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council,
Represented by the Secretary to the Executive Committee,
East Khasi Hills District, Shillong.

4. The Chief Executive Member,
Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council, Shillong

5. The Deputy Chief Executive Member,
Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council, Shillong
1 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB

6. Chairman/Secretary,
Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council, Shillong

7. The Executive Member, In-charge Law,
Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council
…. Respondent(s)


Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge


Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv.

For the Respondent(s) : Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA (For R 1&2)
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Khyriem, Adv. (For R 3-7)

i) Whether approved for reporting in Yes/No
Law journals etc:

ii) Whether approved for publication Yes/No
in press:
Per. H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge:
JUDGMENT:

1. The main challenge in the instant writ petition, is to the vires
of The Khasi Hills Autonomous District (Nomination and Election of the
Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam) (Amendment) Act,
2019 , which was passed by the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council on
25.07.2019, which received the assent of the Governor on 15.09.2023, and
published in the Gazette of Meghalaya Extra Ordinary Issue dated
2 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
26.09.2023. The challenge is on the ground that the said amendment Act,
was enacted in violation of the mandatory legislative process and custom.

2. The Principal Act of 2006, was enacted under the law-making
power of Paragraph-3 of the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution of India and
the assent of the Governor received under Paragraph-3(3) read with the
Assam and Meghalaya Autonomous Districts (Constitution of District
Councils) Rules, 1951 (hereinafter known as the Rules of 1951). This
enactment of 2006, was as per substantive law and mandatory legislative
procedure. The Amendment of 2019, as contended by the petitioners is that
the same was passed without proper consultation, in violation of established
procedure and further that, the respondents relied solely on the Bill passed
by the District Council on 25.07.2019, which however was not tabled before
the House for reconsideration and as per their assertion, suffers from serious
procedural defects, being in violation of Rule 93 of The Assam and
Meghalaya Autonomous Districts (Constitution of District Councils),
Rules 1951, and as such is liable to be declared ultra vires.

3. Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. T.
Dkhar, learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that in pursuance to
Rule 73(2) of The Assam and Meghalaya Autonomous Districts
(Constitution of District Councils), Rules 1951 , the Amendment Bill of
2019, was introduced without seeking the opinion of the Dorbar Hima,
3 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
which is against the enactment of the Original 2006 Act. The Amendment
Bill of 2019 was proposed to be introduced he submits, in the Council
Session by a Notification dated 22.07.2019, issued by the Deputy CEM
KHADC, and the amendment sought by the Bill were firstly, after Section-
1 Sub-section (2) of the Principal Act of 2006, a proviso was to be inserted
that in Raid Saw Symper, the Act would apply only to matters of Village
administration and not to land administration, and secondly after Section-2,
after Clause-j, a proviso was to be inserted that in Raid Saw Symper, the
Myntri shall also be known as Rangbah Shnong (Headman), and finally a
proviso to Section-8 after Sub-section-(3), was to be inserted fixing a
3(three) year term of office for the Myntri or Headman and prescribing the
procedure for election to that post. The learned Senior counsel contends that
the amendment itself is untenable as the post of Myntri within the Maharam
Syiemship, is not equivalent to Rangbah Shnong (Headman) and that the
Original Act of 2006 made no such distinction and did not contemplate a
situation where a Myntri would be demoted to the status of Headman, as has
been done in the Amendment Act of 2019 for Raid Saw Symper.

4. The Bill it is submitted, was passed by the respondent No. 3,
and notified on 02.08.2019, whereafter written objections was filed by the
Maharam Syiemship before the Governor not to assent to the same. The said
objections he submits was forwarded to the respondent No. 2, by letter dated
4 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
10.09.2019, who then formally informed the District Council (respondent
No. 3) about the objections to the proposed Bill vide letter dated 17.10.2019.
After a lapse of some time he submits, the respondent No. 2 vide letter dated
15.02.2021, then communicated to the respondent No. 3 that the Bill having
not received the assent of the Governor, the same be reconsidered in light of
the written objections filed by Maharam Syiemship. Clarification was also
sought he submits, by the respondent No. 2 on the term “land regulation” as
provided in the Amendment Bill of 2019 under Section 1(2), to which the
respondent No. 3 replied that the same was a technical error and should be
read as “land administration” instead of “land regulation”. The learned
Senior counsel has then highlighted that the respondent No. 2 i.e. District
Council Affairs Department, had communicated a crucial fact, vide letter
dated 25.08.2023, to the Law Department with the observation that Clause-
2 of the 2019 Bill may be omitted, as the Principal Act of 2006, was strictly
intended to provide the procedure for the nomination and election of
Traditional Heads and the day to day administration of the village, but not
for land administration, and also that Clause-3, which sought to equate the
Myntri to a Rangbah Shnong (Headman) also needed to be omitted. Heavy
emphasis has been laid by the learned Senior counsel on the aspect that when
the Governor returned the Bill, it was a formal Act under the law, and not
just a simply administrative exchange, which entailed and demanded that the
5 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
Bill should have gone back to the full Council to be voted upon. The
Executive Committee he contends, cannot become the author of a law by
deciding on its own to effect amendment.

5. It is then argued that despite the written objections by the office
of the Hima of Maharam and the Law Department’s recommendations, the
respondents acted arbitrarily by firstly, finalizing the Act without any further
consultation with the traditional authorities, and also without abiding by the
prescribed legislative process. Learned Senior counsel has also pointed out
that major gaps had occurred in the legislative process and further, that a Bill
which was initially passed by the Council on 25.07.2019, received the
Governor’s assent only on 15.09.2023, after more than 4(four) years had
elapsed. It has been further asserted that the manner of passing the
Amendment of 2023, was selective, inasmuch as, while Clause-2 was
omitted as suggested, it failed to comply with the Law Department’s
recommendations also to omit Clause-3. This entire process he submits,
suffers from serious procedural defects, inasmuch as, the established
procedure demands that a returned Bill must be tabled again before the
Council for fresh discussion and approval, which however the respondents
bypassed by relying solely on the earlier vote of 2019, and failed to re-table
the modified Bill, which therefore renders the Amendment Act invalid and
ultra vires. In this context, reference has been made to Rule-93 of the Rules
6 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
of 1951, and it is submitted that according to this Rule, in the reconsideration
of Bills, returned by the Governor, the Chairman of the House is required to
put the Governor’s recommendations before the Council for discussion and
vote in the same manner as a new Bill.

6. In support of his contentions, the learned Senior counsel had
relied upon the following judgments: -

i)
AIR (1960) SC 232 Para 47, 61, 78 & 79 – Art 304 (b)
Atiabari Tea Co. Ltd Vrs State of Assam & Ors.


ii) 1992 Supl. 2 SCC 651 Para 63, 65, 69, 73-75 & 186
Hillohan vrs Zachillhu & Ors.


iii) (2016) 5 SCC 1 Para 856, 857, 860-863
Supreme Court Advocates on Record & Anr. vrs. Union of India


iv) (1987) 1 SCC 378 Para 8-9
Dr. D.C. Wadhwa & Ors. vrs State of Bihar


v) (2002) 8 SCC 182 Para 29
Kaiser-I- Hind Pvt. Ltd. & Anr vrs. National Textile Corporation
(Maharashtra North) Ltd. & Ors.


vi) (2025) 8 SCC 1 Para 378 & 381
State of Tamil Nadu vrs. Governor of Tamil Nadu & Anr.


7. On behalf of the respondents Nos. 3 to 7, the main contesting
respondents, Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. S.
Khyriem, learned counsel has submitted that a challenge to the vires, can
only be maintained if there is a lack of legislative competence, or if the law
violates the fundamental rights, neither of which he contends has been
pleaded by the petitioners, and that further ‘lack of consultation’ is not a
7 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
valid ground for assailing the constitutional validity of an Act. Para-3 and
Para-3(1)(g) of the Sixth Schedule he submits, has vested the District
Council with the power to make laws regarding appointment and succession
of Chiefs and Headmen, and that this power has been exercised to which the
Amendment, received the assent of the Governor. He further submits that
the power to enact a law inherently includes the power to amend it. It has
been further advanced that the present matter, is not a case of return by the
Governor, and the same is evident from the letter dated 25.08.2023, annexed
to the writ petition, wherein it has been categorically stated the observations
contained were made by the Law Department of the Government of
Meghalaya. As such, he contends as the Governor had not returned the Bill
with a message requiring reconsideration on specific points, there was no
necessity to place the returned Bill before the floor of the House for
reconsideration. It is further submitted that under Rule-93 of the Rules of
1951, a Bill must be returned by the Governor with a specific message to
warrant a formal reconsideration by the House, which is not so in the instant
case as the return originated from the Law Department of the Government
of Meghalaya. It is also contended that the District Council’s legislative
powers are subservient to the observations of the State Government, and
though the Executive Committee chose to consider the Law Department’s
8 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
recommendations, the same was a matter of discretion and does not
invalidate legislative process.

8. In response to the challenge that the Amendment Act was never
placed before the House for consideration, the learned Senior counsel
submits that the Amendment Bill was placed before the House on
25.07.2019 during the Summer Session (23.07.2019 to 25.07.2019) and was
passed by a voice vote on the same day. Further submission is that the
observations acted upon, were merely regarding typographical or clerical
errors and that the recommendation from the District Council Affairs
Department or the Law Department is not binding on the District Council.
The action of the Executive Committee in addressing these minor points he
submits, does not constitute an encroachment on the legislative domain. The
learned Senior counsel by referring to Articles 122 and 212 of the
Constitution of India, has argued that Courts should not enquire into the
validity of legislative proceedings based on procedural irregularities and that
to exercise the powers under Article-226, the petitioners must demonstrate
substantive illegality. In the instant case, he asserts the changes made such
as correcting the term ‘Regulation’ to ‘Land Administration’ were purely
clerical intended to correct an inadvertent omission, and as such no illegality
exists. Learned Senior counsel has then placed a letter dated 01.09.2023,
addressed to the respondent No. 2, to show the factum of incorporation of
9 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
the amendment being made under Rule-92(1) of the Rules of 1951, and re-
submitted to the respondent No. 2, for necessary action, and concludes his
submissions by submitting that the Bill being duly signed, having received
the Governor’s assent, and published in the official Gazette is a valid Act,
and prays that this Court should not set aside the same over mere cosmetic
procedural issues.

9. In support of his case, the learned Senior counsel has relied upon the
following judgment: -

i) Raja Ram Pal v. Hon’ble Speaker, Lok Sabha
(2007) 3 SCC 184 Para-360


10. On behalf of the respondents Nos. 1 & 2, Mr. A. Kumar, learned
AG assisted by Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, learned GA has supported the
submissions of the learned Senior counsel for the respondents Nos. 3 to 7,
and has added that there is a presumption of validity and constitutionality of
an enactment and that the law regarding the vires of an Act, is well settled
and further that the same can be challenged only on two grounds i.e. lack of
legislative competence and violation of fundamental rights.
The learned AG has also placed the following judgment In Re:
Assent, Withholding or Reservation of Bills by the Governor and the
President of India [2026 1 SCC 1] , and submits that to preserve
constitutional elasticity, the framers deliberately excluded rigid timelines
from Articles 111 and 200. Further it is submitted that at Para-56 of the
10 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
judgment, it has been pointed that Article 163 itself points towards a set of
various functions under the Constitution which are required to be done in the
exclusive discretion of the Governor, and that the decision of the Governor
in his discretion shall be final, and the validity of anything done shall not be
called in question on the grounds that he ought or ought not to have acted in
his discretion.


11. Heard learned counsel for the parties.

12. On hearing the learned counsel for the parties, this Court notes

that the main issue that has arisen for consideration, is whether procedure as
established under law i.e. the Rules of 1951, more particularly Rule 92 (2)
and Rule 93 have been followed when the Governor’s assent was obtained,
and whether, the deviation of such procedure would render the statute illegal,
ab initio/ultra vires. Other issues that have arisen is whether this Court has
the power to exercise its jurisdiction on the law-making power of the
legislature and whether assent given by the Governor, when the Bill is not
placed before the House would render it invalid.

13. The sequence of events as has been discussed and narrated
above, would show that the Principal Act of the Khasi Hill Autonomous
District (Nomination and Election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors
of Hima Maharam, 2006, received the Governor’s assent and was published
on 19.12.2006. On 25.07.2019, the KHADC passed the Amendment Bill of
11 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
2019, and the same rested without any further progress or process, till
15.02.2021, when the respondent No. 2 (District Council Affairs
Department) requested the respondent No. 3, (KHADC Executive
Committee) to reconsider the amendment due to certain objections by the
Syiemship of Maharam. The respondent No. 3, then clarified the term ‘Land
Regulation’ to mean ‘land administration’ whereafter on 25.08.2023, the
Law Department of the State of Meghalaya formally advised the omission
of Clause-2 and Clause-3, as the Principal Act of 2006 was not intended for
‘Land Administration’. The Amendment Act then received the Governor’s
assent on 15.09.2023, and was published on 26.09.2023, and while Clause-
2 was omitted, the controversial Clauses 3 & 4, were retained. Apart from
the assertion that the Amended Act constitutes a substantive violation of
traditional customs, such as by reducing the traditional post of Myntri to the
status of Rangbah Shnong (Headman) of Raid Saw Symper, a distinction
that was not recognized under the original legislation of 2006, the main
challenge however, is that the legislative procedure was violated, inasmuch
as, after the Governor returned the Bill, for reconsideration, it was never re-
tabled before the House for discussion or a vote.

14. At this juncture, as the matter involves a Bill which was
returned for reconsideration, it would be relevant to reproduce hereinbelow
12 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
Rule 92 (2) and more pertinently Rule 93 of the Assam and Meghalaya
Autonomous Districts (Constitution of District Councils) Rules, 1951.
“92 (2) After the Bill has been signed by the Chairman, the
Secretary shall send an authenticated copy to each of the
following:


(i) To the Executive Committee for information;


(ii) To the Governor for information through the
Secretary, District Council Affairs Department,
Government of Meghalaya, if the Bill does not require
the approval of the Governor being not so specified in
any of the provisions of the Sixth Schedule; or


(iii) To the Governor for approval thereof if it is required
under any provision in the Sixth Schedule to the
Constitution of India.

“Reconsideration of Bills returned by the Governor

93. When a Bill which has been passed is submitted as in Rule
92 (2) (iii) and is returned by the Governor with a message to
the District Council for reconsideration the point or points
referred for re-consideration or the amendments
recommended shall be put before the Council by the
Chairman, and shall be discussed and voted upon in the same
manner as amendments to a Bill and it shall be presented
again to the Governor for his assent.”


15. A bare perusal of Rule 93, would show that the mandatory
legislative procedure stipulated by this Rule is that when a Bill which has
been passed, is returned by the Governor, with a message to the District
Council for reconsideration or amendments recommended, the same shall be
put before the Council by the Chairman to be discussed and voted upon, and
then it shall be presented again to the Governor for his assent. In the instant
13 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
case it is seen after the Bill of 2019, did not receive the assent of the
Governor, what followed was that a clarification was sought by the
respondent No. 2, whereafter it was also revealed that the Law Department
had also given their inputs and advice as noted earlier. The basic fact that
emerges from these events, is that the Governor had returned the Bill on
25.08.2023, which constitutes a formal act as contemplated under Rule 93.
This to the mind of the Court cannot be understood or taken to be a routine
internal administrative exchange as sought to be made out by the
respondents Nos. 3 to 7, that the Bill had not been returned by the Governor,
but by the Law Department, which therefore, would not warrant the placing
of the same before the House. In this scenario therefore, from a plain
understanding of Rule 93, and as it had been informed by the respondent No.
2 to the respondent No. 3, vide letter dated 15.02.2021, (Annexure-8) that
the Bill had not received the assent of the Governor, the amendments
thereafter sought to be inserted by the Amendment Act of 2019, would in
the view of this Court necessarily entail the placing of the same before the
House for discussion and vote.

16. As held in the case of Kihoto Hillohan vrs Zachillhu & Ors.
(supra), at Para-53, the criterion for determining the validity of a law is the
competence of the law-making authority, which would depend on the ambit
of the legislative power, and the limitations imposed therein, as also
14 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
limitations on the mode of exercise of this power. In Para-186 thereof, the
entire Tenth Schedule was found to be constitutionally invalid in the absence
of prior ratification in accordance with the proviso to Clause-2 of Article
368. In the case of Supreme Court Advocates on Record & Anr. vrs. Union
of India (supra) , at Paras-856 and 857 and 860 to 863, it has also been held
that if procedure is not followed, then the law to that extent will have no
effect, and that a law can be challenged, if it is enacted without following
the procedure laid down in the Constitution. Further this judgment, has also
held that proceedings that are substantively illegal or unconstitutional as
opposed to irregular, are not protected from judicial scrutiny by Article 122
(1) of the Constitution. In the case of Kaiser-I- Hind Pvt. Ltd. & Anr vrs.
National Textile Corporation (supra), the Supreme Court held that granting
of assent under Article 254(2), is not an exercise of legislative power of the
President as contemplated under Article 123, but is part of legislative
procedure, and whether procedure prescribed by the Constitution before
enacting the law is followed or not, can always be looked into by the Court.
These landmark cases in the considered view of the Court in the facts of the
instant case, wherein the specific requirement as laid down in Rule-93 of the
Rules of 1951, has not been adhered to, would surely open the impugned
procedure to judicial scrutiny. The authorities relied upon by the
respondents, which are general in nature and centering around arbitrariness,
15 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
Article-14 and the questioning of validity on the Bill duly signed, cannot
defeat the legislative requirement of Rule 93, for not placing the Bill before
the House when the facts clearly show that the Bill had been returned for
reconsideration.

17. Another aspect which was brought on record by an additional
affidavit by the respondents Nos. 3 to 7, as directed by the order of this Court
vide order dated 05.06.2025, also would show that the respondent No. 3, by
letter dated 01.09.2023, addressed to the respondent No. 2, had stated therein
that the Executive Committee had agreed to the observations made by the
Law Department of the Government of Meghalaya, and had incorporated
same as provided under Rule 92 (1) of the Rules of 1951, and the same was
resubmitted. This letter in the opinion of this Court, clearly establishes the
fact that the substantial amendments which were made, were not merely
clerical as contended by the respondents Nos. 3 to 7, were never placed
before the Chairman of the House for discussion or vote, which is a clear
transgression of the executive into the legislative domain of the Council.

18. As such, in consideration of the entire facts and circumstances
therefore, and in reiteration of the observations and findings made
hereinabove, The Khasi Hills Autonomous District (Nomination and
Election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam)
(Amendment) Act, 2019, (Passed by the Khasi Hills Autonomous District
16 17
Page of

2026:MLHC:1297-DB
th th
Council on the 25 July, 2019) (Received the assent of the Governor on 15
September, 2023) (Published in the Gazette of Meghalaya Extraordinary
th
issued dated 26 September, 2023) is hereby declared as ultra vires on the
ground of a fatal departure from the mandatory legislative procedure
prescribed by Rule 93 of the Rules of 1951.

19. The writ petition is accordingly allowed and disposed of.


(B. Bhattacharjee) (H.S. Thangkhiew)
JUDGE JUDGE



Meghalaya
17.11.2026
“ V. Lyndem- AR-PS ”
17 17
Page of

VALENTINO LYNDEM
Digitally signed by:
Signed On: 17-11-2026 17:28:38 IST
Verified