Gurnam Chand (Now Deceased) Thr His Legal Heirs And Anr vs State Of Haryana Thr. Collector Distt Sirsa And Anr

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court



IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

RFA-550-2024 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026

Gurnam Chand (Deceased) through LRs and another
...Appellant(s)
Versus

State of Haryana and another ...Respondent(s)

And

Sr. Case No. Appellant(s) Respondent(s)
No.
2. RFA-564-2024 (O&M) Lal Chand and another State of Haryana and another
3. RFA-565-2024 (O&M) Maninder Kaur and another State of Haryana and another
4. RFA-568-2024 (O&M) Surjit Rani and others State of Haryana and another
5. RFA-571-2024 (O&M) Surjit Rani and another State of Haryana and another
6. RFA-573-2024 (O&M) Baldev Raj and others State of Haryana and another
7. RFA-578-2024 (O&M) Surjit Rani and others State of Haryana and another
8. RFA-720-2024 (O&M) Chhotu Ram (Deceased) through
LRs and others
State of Haryana and another
9. RFA-721-2024 (O&M) Om Parkash and others State of Haryana and others
10. RFA-722-2024 (O&M) Sunil Kumar and others State of Haryana and another
11. RFA-733-2024 (O&M) Hakam Singh and others State of Haryana and another
12. RFA-734-2024 (O&M) Jasvinder Kaur (Deceased) through
LRs
State of Haryana and another
13. RFA-746-2024 (O&M) Sheela Bai and others State of Haryana and another
14. RFA-816-2024 (O&M) Sukhdev State of Haryana and another
15. RFA-1062-2024 (O&M) Manphool (Deceased) through LRs
and another
State of Haryana and another
16. RFA-1086-2024 (O&M) Mukh Ram (Deceased) through
LRs
State of Haryana and others
17. RFA-1087-2024 (O&M) Savitri alias Savitri Devi State of Haryana and others
18. RFA-1148-2024 (O&M) Savitri Devi and another State of Haryana and others
19. RFA-1157-2024 (O&M) Balram and others State of Haryana and others
20. RFA-163-2023 (O&M) Chandu Ram (Deceased) through
LRs
State of Haryana and others
21. RFA-164-2023 (O&M) Puran (Deceased) through LRs State of Haryana and others
22. RFA-165-2023 (O&M) Krishan State of Haryana and others
23. RFA-166-2023 (O&M) Rohtash and another State of Haryana and others
24. RFA-561-2024 (O&M) Rajinder Kaur State of Haryana and others
25. RFA-572-2024 (O&M) Lakhveer Kaur State of Haryana and others
26. RFA-582-2024 (O&M) Lalit Kumar State of Haryana and others
27. RFA-688-2024 (O&M) Karam Chand State of Haryana and another
28. RFA-693-2024 (O&M) Munni Bai alias Munni Devi
(Deceased) through LRs and others
State of Haryana and others
29. RFA-695-2024 (O&M) Ram Diyal alias Ram Dayal
(Deceased) through LRs
State of Haryana and others
30. RFA-696-2024 (O&M) Sohan Lal and others State of Haryana and others
31. RFA-697-2024 (O&M) Ram Singh State of Haryana and others
32. RFA-701-2024 (O&M) Mahender and another State of Haryana and others
33. RFA-703-2024 (O&M) Mahender Singh State of Haryana and others
34. RFA-704-2024 (O&M) Chhotu Ram and another State of Haryana and others
35. RFA-706-2024 (O&M) Mahender Singh State of Haryana and others
36. RFA-707-2024 (O&M) Savitri Devi @ Savitri and others State of Haryana and others
37. RFA-708-2024 (O&M) Kalu Ram (Deceased) through LRs State of Haryana and others
38. RFA-709-2024 (O&M) Roop Ram (Deceased) through LRs
and others
State of Haryana and others
39. RFA-710-2024 (O&M) Gurdass Ram @ Gurdas and
another
State of Haryana and others
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-2-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

40. RFA-712-2024 (O&M) Nikku Ram @ Nikku State of Haryana and others
41. RFA-713-2024 (O&M) Krishan Lal and others State of Haryana and others
42. RFA-716-2024 (O&M) Moman (Deceased) through LRs State of Haryana and others
43. RFA-740-2024 (O&M) Jitender Kaur State of Haryana and others
44. RFA-744-2024 (O&M) Godavari Devi alias Godawari Devi State of Haryana and others
45. RFA-747-2024 (O&M) Parmeshwari Devi (Deceased)
through LRs
State of Haryana and others
46. RFA-749-2024 (O&M) Brij Lal (Deceased) through LRs
and others
State of Haryana and others
47. RFA-751-2024 (O&M) Om Parkash State of Haryana and others
48. RFA-755-2024 (O&M) Hobni Bai alias Hodi Bai and others State of Haryana and another
49. RFA-978-2024 (O&M) Anita alias Anita Bajaj State of Haryana and others
50. RFA-1076-2024 (O&M) Nasib Kaur alias Nasiv Kaur State of Haryana and another

CORAM:- HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JAGMOHAN BANSAL

Present:- Mr. Paramjit Singh Jammu, Advocate,
Mr. Santosh Kumar Yadav, Advocate,
Mr. Rajinder Partap Singh Jammu, Advocate and
Mr. Jasbir Singh Thind, Advocate
for the appellants in RFA Nos.550, 720, 721, 722, 733, 734,
693, 695, 696, 709, 712, 713, 978, 1148, 1157, 701, 703,
704, 706, 707, 708, 710, 716, 1062, 1086 and 1087 of 2024.

Mr. Lupil Gupta, Advocate,
Mr. Varun Aggarwal, Advocate and
Mr. Akash Khurcha, Advocate
for the appellant in RFA No.740 of 2024.

Mr. P.K. Ganga, Advocate
for the appellant in RFA Nos.688, 755 and 1076 of 2024.

Ms. Kajal Verma, Advocate for
Mr. Ashok Kumar Verma, Advocate
for the appellant in RFA Nos.744, 747 and 749 of 2024.

Mr. J.S. Thind, Advocate,
Mr. Balsher Singh, Advocate,
Ms. Tudhjot Kaur Sidhu, Advocate
Mr. Inderpreet Singh, Advocate
for the appellant in RFA Nos.550, 564, 565, 568, 571, 573,
578 and 746 of 2024.

Mr. Arpandeep Narula, Advocate,
Mr. Vrishketu, Advocate,
Mr. Kartik Kataria, Advocate,
Mr. Piyush Mittal, Advocate,
Ms. Anjali Pathak, Advocate and
Mr. Nitesh Gautam, Advocate
for the appellants
in RFA Nos.163, 164, 165 and 166 of 2023.

Mr. Abhinash Jain, Addl. A.G., Haryana.

PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-3-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

JAGMOHAN BANSAL, J.


1. These appeals under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (for short ‘1894 Act’) are directed against awards dated 27.03.2024
and 28.03.2024 passed by the Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Authority-cum-Additional District Judge, Sirsa (hereinafter called as
‘Authority’). The landowners are seeking enhancement of the amount of
compensation.

2. By this common order, appeals emanating from Section 4
notifications dated 04.11.2011 and 19.02.2013 are hereby adjudicated.
For the sake of brevity and convenience, facts are borrowed
from RFA-550-2024 which relates to Section 4 notification dated
19.02.2013.

3. Tabulated details of the assessment qua both notifications
made till date read as: -
Date of notification under Section 4 19.02.2013 04.11.2011
Date of notification under Section 6 26.08.2013 23.10.2012
Purpose of acquisition Construction of Ratta
Construction of
Khera Kharif Channel in
Naiwala Kharif
Channel in village
village Chamal
Nanuana
Location Village Chamal
Villages:
Tehsil & District Sirsa
Kussar, Fatehpuria and
Nanuana
Tehsil & District Sirsa
Area (Total) 202 Kanal 18 Marla 25.63 Acre
Date of Collector Award (LAC) 10.01.2014 10.09.2014 (Kussar)
07.10.2014 (Nanuana)
10.01.2014
(Fatehpuria)
₹
Market value as per LAC ( per acre) 22,30,000/- 14,00,000/-
Date of Reference Court (RC) Award 27.03.2024 28.03.2024
₹
Market value as per RC ( per acre) 27,87,500/- 35,00,000/-
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-4-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters


4. The State Government issued notification dated 19.02.2013
under Section 4 of the 1894 Act for the acquisition of 202 Kanal 18 Marla
land situated in Village Chamal, Tehsil & District Sirsa with intent to
construct Ratta Khera Kharif Channel. The said notification was followed
by notification dated 26.08.2013 issued under Section 6 of 1894 Act.

5. The Land Acquisition Collector (for short ‘Collector’) vide
Award dated 10.01.2014 determined compensation payable to the
landowners. Market value of the acquired land was determined @
₹
22,30,000/- per acre. Landowners were held entitled to solatium and
other statutory benefits. Feeling dis-satisfied from the aforesaid award,
landowners preferred petitions before the Collector which were referred
to the Court under Section 18 of the 1894 Act.

6. The Reference Court while appreciating evidence led by both
sides, by impugned award adjudicated reference petitions. The Reference
Court by award dated 27.03.2024 has assessed market value of the
₹
acquired land @ 27,87,500/- per acre.

7. This is second round of litigation. On the earlier occasion
landowners approached this Court by way of RFA-1313-2018 which was
decided vide order dated 07.09.2022 whereby matter was remitted back to
the Authority for fresh adjudication as per provisions of the Right to Fair
Compensation & Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013 (for short ‘2013 Act’). The Authority vide order
₹
dated 27.03.2024 has assessed compensation @ 27,87,500/-. The
₹
Authority has found market value 22,30,000/- per acre and applied
multiplier of 1.25. The Authority has further awarded solatium @ 100%
and additional amount @ 12% per annum.
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-5-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters


8. Learned counsel for the landowners submit that the Authority
has not determined market price as per parameters laid down by the
Supreme Court in multiple cases. The Authority was supposed to consider
highest available sale deeds. The State issued notification under Section 4
of 1894 Act on 19.02.2013 and award under Section 11 could not be
passed prior to 01.01.2014, thus, as per Section 24(1)(a), the assessment
was required to be made as per provisions of the 2013 Act. As per Section
24 read with Section 26, ‘ 01.01.2014 ’ is required to be considered as date
of notification and market value needs to be assessed accordingly. The
Authority should consider sale deeds of 2010, 2011 and 2012 i.e. 3 years
preceding the date of deemed notification. The Authority may not
consider sale deeds executed during 2013 because ‘ 01.01.2014 ’ is
considered as deemed date of notification under Section 11 of 2013 Act
read with Section 4 of 1894 Act. The landowners are entitled to 12% per
annum addition as provided under Section 30(2) read with 69(3) of 2013
Act besides solatium as provided under Section 30(3). The Authority has
wrongly applied multiplier of 1.25. It should be 1.5.

9. Per contra , learned State counsel submits that as per
Explanation 1 to Section 26(1), the Authority is required to consider
average of 3 years preceding the year in which the acquisition is
proposed. In the present case, acquisition was proposed on 19.02.2013 by
way of notification under Section 4 of 1894 Act, thus, sale deeds of 2013
cannot be considered. The landowners cannot claim benefit of 12%
addition for the period from February’ 2013 to January’ 2014 if they are
extended benefit of 100% solatium and 01.01.2014 is considered as
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-6-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

deemed date of notification under Section 4 of 1894 Act. The Authority
was supposed to consider average of sale price prevailing during 2010,
2011 and 2012.

10. Heard the arguments and perused the record.

11. Learned counsel for the parties are ad idem that delay in
filing or re-filing any appeal which is part of present bunch may be
condoned. Accordingly, delay, if any, in any case, stands condoned.

12. All the arguments raised by both sides have been recorded in
the presence of counsel for the parties. They have not raised any other
argument.

13. A perusal of the impugned award reveals that the Authority
has determined market price as per parameters laid down under Sections
26 to 30 of 2013 Act. The Authority has concluded that previous awards
as per Explanation 3 of Section 26(1) cannot be relied upon. Sale
deed Ex. P-10 which was executed in 2013 cannot be considered as per
Explanation 1 of Section 26. The Authority has further rejected sale deeds
Ex. R-1 and R-2 produced by the State. These deeds were executed
during 2012. The Authority has finally concluded that the parties have
failed to lead any evidence worth consideration with aforesaid findings,

market price determined by the Collector has been upheld.
The Authority has granted benefit of 1.25 multiplier. The
Authority has noticed notification dated 23.01.2018 whereby State
Government, as per Section 26(2) read with First Schedule of the 2013
Act, has notified multiplier factor.

PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-7-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters



14. This Court is of considered opinion that Authority
constituted under Section 51 of the 2013 Act is bound to adjudicate
matters in accordance with mandate of Sections 26 to 30 as well as 69.
The Authority constituted under Section 51 does not fall within definition
of ‘ Court ’. It is not bound to follow procedure prescribed under Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short ‘ CPC ’). As per Section 60(1), it is vested
with specific powers which are vested in Court under CPC. An Authority
constituted under an enactment does not carry inherent powers as are
vested in Courts. It is bound to follow provisions of the statute under
which it is constituted. Section 69(1) provides that the Authority while
determining amount of compensation shall take into consideration
whether the Collector has followed the parameters set out under Sections

26 to 30. Section 69 reads as:
“ 69. Determination of award by Authority. –
(1) In determining the amount of compensation to be
awarded for land acquired including the Rehabilitation
and Resettlement entitlements, the Authority shall take into
consideration whether the Collector has followed the
parameters set out under section 26 to section 30 and the
provisions under Chapter V of this Act.
(2) In addition to the market value of the land, as above
provided, the Authority shall in every case award an
amount calculated at the rate of twelve per cent. per
annum on such market value for the period commencing
on and from the date of the publication of the preliminary
notification under section 11 in respect of such land to the
date of the award of the Collector or the date of taking
possession of the land, whichever is earlier.
Explanation. - In computing the period referred to in this
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-8-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

sub-section, any period or periods during which the
proceedings for the acquisition of the land were held up on
account of any stay or injunction by the order of any Court
shall be excluded.
(3) In addition to the market value of the land as above
provided, the Authority shall in every case award a
solatium of one hundred per cent. over the total
compensation amount.”
[Emphasis Supplied]

9. The Authority may or may not agree with the market price
determined by the Collector as per parameters set out under Sections 26
to 30, however, it is bound to ascertain at the first instance whether the
Collector has followed parameters set out under Sections 26 to 30. In the
case in hand, the Authority has attempted to follow parameters laid down
under Sections 26 to 30. Sections 26, 30 and First Schedule to 2013 Act
are relevant for the adjudication of the present appeals. The same are
reproduced below:
“ 26. Determination of market value of land by Collector .
–
(1) The Collector shall adopt the following criteria in
assessing and determining the market value of the land,
namely:-
(a) the market value, if any, specified in the Indian
Stamp Act, 1899 (2 of 1899) for the registration of
sale deeds or agreements to sell, as the case may
be, in the area, where the land is situated; or
(b) the average sale price for similar type of land
situated in the nearest village or nearest vicinity
area; or
(c) consented amount of compensation as agreed
upon under sub-section (2) of section 2 in case of
acquisition of lands for private companies or for
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-9-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

public private partnership projects, whichever is
higher:
Provided that the date for determination of market value
shall be the date on which the notification has been issued
under section 11.
Explanation 1. - The average sale price referred to in
clause (b) shall be determined taking into account the sale
deeds or the agreements to sell registered for similar type
of area in the near village or near vicinity area during
immediately preceding three years of the year in which
such acquisition of land is proposed to be made.
Explanation 2. - For determining the average sale price
referred to in Explanation 1, one-half of the total number
of sale deeds or the agreements to sell in which the highest
sale price has been mentioned shall be taken into account.
Explanation 3. - While determining the market value
under this section and the average sale price referred to in
Explanation 1 or Explanation 2, any price paid as
compensation for land acquired under the provisions of
this Act on an earlier occasion in the district shall not be
taken into consideration.
Explanation 4. - While determining the market value
under this section and the average sale price referred to in
Explanation 1 or Explanation 2, any price paid, which in
the opinion of the Collector is not indicative of actual
prevailing market value may be discounted for the
purposes of calculating market value.
(2) The market value calculated as per sub-section (1)
shall be multiplied by a factor to be specified in the First
Schedule.
(3) Where the market value under sub-section (1) or sub-
section (2) cannot be determined for the reason that-
(a) the land is situated in such area where the
transactions in land are restricted by or under any
other law for the time being in force in that area;
or
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-10-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

(b) the registered sale deeds or agreements to sell
as mentioned in clause (a) of sub-section (1) for
similar land are not available for the immediately
preceding three years; or
(c) the market value has not been specified under
the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 (2 of 1899) by the
appropriate authority, the State Government
concerned shall specify the floor price or minimum
price per unit area of the said land based on the
price calculated in the manner specified in sub-
section (1) in respect of similar types of land
situated in the immediate adjoining areas.”
Provided that in a case where the Requiring Body offers
its shares to the owners of the lands (whose lands have
been acquired) as a part compensation, for acquisition of
land, such shares in no case shall exceed twenty-five per
cent. of the value so calculated under sub-section (1) or
sub-section (2) or sub-section (3) as the case may be:
Provided further that the Requiring Body shall in no case
compel any owner of the land (whose land has been
acquired) to take its shares, the value of which is
deductible in the value of the land calculated under sub-
section (1):
Provided also that the Collector shall, before initiation of
any land acquisition proceedings in any area, take all
necessary steps to revise and update the market value of
the land on the basis of the prevalent market rate in that
area.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
“ 30. Award of solatium . - (1) The Collector having
determined the total compensation to be paid, shall, to
arrive at the final award, impose a "Solatium" amount
equivalent to one hundred per cent. of the compensation
amount.
Explanation. - For the removal of doubts it is hereby
declared that solatium amount shall be in addition to the
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-11-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

compensation payable to any person whose land has been
acquired.
(2) The Collector shall issue individual awards detailing
the particulars of compensation payable and the details of
payment of the compensation as specified in the First
Schedule.
(3) In addition to the market value of the land provided
under section 26, the Collector shall, in every case, award
an amount calculated at the rate of twelve per cent. per
annum on such market value for the period commencing
on and from the date of the publication of the notification
of the Social Impact Assessment study under sub-section
(2) of section 4, in respect of such land, till the date of the
award of the Collector or the date of taking possession of
the land, whichever is earlier.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
“THE FIRST SCHEDULE
[See section 30 (2)]
COMPENSATION FOR LAND OWNERS
The following components shall constitute the minimum
compensation package to be given to those whose land is
acquired and to tenants referred to in clause (c) of section
3 in a proportion to be decided by the appropriate
Government.
Serial Component of
No. compensation
package in
respect of
land acquired
Manner of
determination of
value
Date of
determination
of value
under the Act
(1) (2) (3) (4)
1. Marker value
of land
To be determined
as provided
under section 26.

2. Factor by
which the
market value
is to be
multiplied in
the case of
rural areas.
1.00 (One) to 2.00 (Two) based
on the distance of project from
urban area, as may be notified by
the appropriate Government.
3. Factor by 1 (One).
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-12-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

which the
market value
is to be
multiplied in
the case of
urban areas
4. Value of assets
attached to
land or
building
To be determined
as provided
under section 29.

5. Solatium Equivalent to one
hundred per cent
of the market
value of land
mentioned
against serial
number I
multiplied by the
factor specified
against serial
number 2 for
rural areas or
serial number 3
for urban areas
plus value of
assets attached to
land or building
against serial
number 4 under
column (2).

6. Final award Market value of
in rural areas land mentioned
against serial
number I
multiplied by the
factor specified
against serial
number 2 plus
value of assets
attached to land
or building
mentioned
against serial
number 4 under
column (2) plus
solatium
mentioned
against serial
number 5 under
column (2).

Market value of
land mentioned
against serial

7. Final award
in urban areas
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-13-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

number I
multiplied by the
factor specified
against serial
number 3 plus
value of assets
attached to land
or building
mentioned
against serial
number 4 under
column (2) plus
solatium
mentioned
against serial
number 5 under
column (2).
8. Other
component, if
any, to be
included

Note. - The date on which values mentioned under column
(2) are determined should be indicated under column (4)
against each serial number.”

[Emphasis Supplied]

10. Section 26 provides mode and manner of determination of
market price. Section 26 is deviation from Section 23 of 1894 Act. Under
Section 23 of 1894 Act, parameters were not prescribed to determine
market price. Section 26 is evolution of 2013 Act. As per Section 26, the
Collector has to determine circle rate, if any, specified for the registration
of sale deeds. He has to further ascertain average sale price for similar
type of land situated in the nearest village or nearest vicinity area. He is
further required to ascertain consented amount of compensation, if any.
Explanations 1 & 2 have prescribed procedure to determine average sale
price under Section 26(1)(b). Highest of three i.e. (i) collector rate
prescribed for stamp duty, (ii) average sale price and (iii) consented
amount of compensation is considered as market value of the land.
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-14-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

Explanation 1 provides that average sale price shall be determined taking
into account sale deeds executed during three years immediately
preceding the year of proposed acquisition. It means sale deeds registered
during the year of proposed acquisition cannot be considered. Supreme
Court in Madhya Pradesh Road Development Corporation v. Vincent
Daniel and others, 2025 (7) SCC 798 has held that transactions older
than three years would be excluded. Paragraph 23 of the judgment read
as:
“23. Explanation 1 states that the determination of the
average sale price under Clause (b) must be based on sale
deeds or agreements to sell registered for similar type of
lands in the same vicinity, during the immediately
preceding three years from the year in which acquisition
was proposed. Thus, transactions older than three years
would be excluded. Explanation 2 states that to determine
the average sale price under Explanation 1, one-half of
the total sale deeds or agreements to sell in which the
highest sale price is mentioned, shall be taken into
account. This also implies that there should be multiple
deeds available for reference. Singular deals may not
supply adequate and reliable data. Explanation 3 states
that while determining the market value under Section 26
and the average sale price referred to in Explanation 1 or
2, the price paid as compensation for land acquired under
the provisions of this Act on an earlier occasion in the
district, shall not be taken into consideration. Thus,
referring to compensation paid for an earlier acquisition
in the concerned district is expressly barred.”
[Emphasis Supplied]

11. In the case in hand, Section 4 notification was issued on
19.02.2013. Award under Section 11 of 1894 Act was passed on
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-15-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

10.01.2014. It is apt to notice here that Collector failed to pass award by
31.12.2013, thus, provisions of 2013 Act became applicable qua
determination of amount of compensation. There are divergent opinions
of this Court with respect to cut-off date in the aforesaid situation. In
State of Haryana and another v. Rajbir and another, 2022 Law Finder
(P&H) 2363 , this Court has considered that date of notification would be
cut-off date though market price is determined as per 2013 Act. In
Krishan Singh and others v. State of Punjab and others, 2024 (3) RCR
(Civil) 57 , a different opinion has been formed by this Court. In the said
case, it has been held that 01.01.2014 is cut-off date where award could
not be passed by 31.12.2013. In aforesaid judgments, expression
‘ immediately preceding 3 years of the year in which such acquisition of
land is proposed to be made ’ has not been considered. As per proviso to
Section 26(1), market value needs to be considered on the date of
notification issued under Section 11, however, mode and manner has
been prescribed in Explanations 1 & 2. Explanation 1 categorically
provides that sale deeds of the year in which acquisition is proposed
should be excluded. As conceded by both sides, on being confronted with
provisions of Sections 4 to 9 of 2013 Act, acquisition is proposed in the
year in which notification under Section 4 of 2013 Act is issued. In view
of mandate of Explanation 1, it is hereby held that for calculating average
market price, sale deeds of 3 years preceding the year of proposed
acquisition are required to be considered.
12. Expression ‘ year ’ has not been defined in 2013 Act, thus,
General Clauses Act, 1897 needs to be considered. As per Section 3(66)
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-16-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

of the said Act, ‘ year ’ means British Calendar year. British Calendar year
st st
is sprawled from 1 January to 31 December. In a particular case,
notification under Section 4 may be issued in the month of January and in
another case in the month of November-December. There would be
drastic difference between both the notifications with respect to year to be
excluded. The Legislature has not defined expression ‘ year ’ in 2013 Act
and Courts cannot add or subtract any word or expression from the
statutory provisions. The Courts are bound to read provisions as such
unless and until plain reading makes the provisions otiose or unworkable.
This Court, in the present case, does not find such a situation, thus, is of
the opinion that year would not be counted as 12 months or 365 days. It
would be counted as Calendar year and even financial year cannot be
considered. The Authority in the impugned award has wrongly excluded
sale deeds executed during 365 days prior to the notification under
Section 4 of 1894 Act.
The aforesaid aspect may be examined from another angle.
Under 1894 Act, sale deeds executed close to the Section 4 notification
were preferred than older or subsequent. Under 2013 Act, date for
determination of market value is date of notification under Section 11,
however, as per Explanation 1 to Section 26, average sale price of 3 years
preceding the year in which acquisition is proposed are considered. As
per 2013 Act, acquisition is proposed under Section 4. Section 11
notification which is pari materia with notification under Section 4 of
1894 Act is issued after completion of Social Impact Assessment Study
and acceptance of report by the Government. As agreed by both sides,
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-17-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

year in which notification under Section 4 for the Social Impact
Assessment Study is issued, is the year of proposed acquisition. There is
gap of 12-15 months between the notifications issued under Sections 4
and 11, thus, possibility of execution of collusive sale deeds is minimized
and there is no harm if expression ‘ year ’ is read in the manner as defined
under General Clauses Act, 1897 instead of equating to 12 months or 365
days.

13. In the case in hand, notification was issued under 1894 Act,
thus, there was no question of notification under Section 4 of 2013 Act.
As per Section 24 of 2013 Act, compensation has to be determined as per
2013 Act because award was not passed prior to 01.01.2014 i.e. date of
implementation of 2013 Act. Under 1894 Act, no Social Impact
Assessment Study was made and straightaway notification under Section
4 used to be issued. To implement provisions of the 2013 Act, with
respect to Section 4 notification issued under 1894 Act, it is inevitable as
well as practicable to consider year of Section 4 notification as year in
which acquisition is proposed. Accordingly, sale deeds of 2013 need to
be excluded for the purpose of determination of market value as per
Section 26 of 2013 Act. Sale deeds executed during 2010, 2011 & 2012
must be considered to calculate average market price.
14. If as contended by landowners, sale deeds of year of
proposed acquisition are not ignored, unscrupulous ones may exploit the
situation and cause irreparable loss to the State exchequer. Under 1894
Act, sale deeds close to the date of notification under Section 4 were
preferred. Under 1894 Act, there was no concept of Social Impact
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-18-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

Assessment Study whereas under 2013 Act it is mandatory to conduct
Social Impact Assessment Study. The appropriate Government is
required to join stakeholders including landowners. This is a time-
consuming process and normally starts 12-15 months prior to the
notification under Section 11 of 2013 Act (Section 4 of 1894 Act is pari
materia to Section 11 of 2013 Act). People with oblique motive would
execute sale deeds as soon as process of Social Impact Assessment study
would commence. This Court while adjudicating appeals filed by
landowners as well as State has noticed that landowners, to claim
maximum compensation, execute one or two collusive sale deeds. Due to
lack of proper assistance and required inquiry on the part of Revenue
Officers, reliance is placed upon highest sale price. To avoid this
situation, the Legislature has mandated that sale deeds of the year in
which acquisition is proposed shall be excluded from the data to be
considered. If applying judgments under 1894 Act, sale deeds executed
close to the notification under Section 11 of 2013 Act are considered, the
assessed market value would be multifold than actual market value
contemplated under Section 26, thus, it is inevitable to ignore sale deeds
executed during the year in which acquisition is proposed.
15. First Schedule of 2013 Act envisages different components
of the compensation. Its Column No.3 titled as ‘ Manner of determination
of value ’ provides for market value of the land as determined under
Section 26 and Column No.4 provides for ‘ Date of determination of
value ’. It is apt to notice here that as per proviso to Section 26, date of
notification under Section 11 is date of determination of market value of
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-19-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

the land whereas date of determination of damages, caused to the
landowners on account of acquisition of their land, would be date of
taking possession. Proviso to Section 26(1) provides that date of
notification under Section 11 would be date of determination of market
value for the land. Explanations prescribe mode and manner of
determination of value. Legislature as per its wisdom has decided to
exclude sale deeds executed during the year in which acquisition is
proposed. Consideration of sale deeds executed during the year of
proposed acquisition or thereafter would be contrary to the statutory
provisions e.g. if notification under Section 4 is issued in 2014 and
notification under Section 11 is issued in 2015, neither sale deeds of 2014
nor of 2015 can be considered because 2014 is the year of proposed
acquisition. The Legislature has prescribed mechanism to determine
market value and if value is determined applying parameters laid down
under 1894 Act, it may amount to unjust enrichment to the landowners
because under the old Act there was no provision of multiplier factor,
solatium was 30% instead of 100%.
16. Ordinarily market price of a particular piece of land, may be
urban area, increases maximum by 10-15% per annum. In case of
agricultural land, there is slow and steady growth in the value. Any
exorbitant or exceptional increase in the market value does not represent
correct value. Exceptional increase in the value should be ignored.
Keeping in mind these facts, the Legislature has mandated to ignore sale
deeds of the year in which acquisition is proposed. If applying judgments
delivered under 1894 Act, the market value is determined under Section
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-20-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

26 of 2013 Act, it would be contrary to the scheme of 2013 Act and
disregard of mandate of Section 26. The Courts are bound by plain
language of the Act. Intention may be scrutinized where plain language is
not clear. In the case of Section 26, plain reading is supporting policy and
intention of the Legislature, thus, there is no occasion to make any other
interpretation. It may also amount to addition/deletion of words in
Section 26 which is impermissible in law.
17. As per above quoted Sections read with Section 69, the
Collector as well as authority at the first instance is required to determine
market price as per parameters laid down in Section 26. As per
explanation 4, the Collector while determining market value or average
sale price referred to in Explanation 1 or 2 may take corrective measures.
He may reduce or enhance the market price. The Supreme Court in
Vincent Daniel (supra) has held that the Collector may reduce as well as
enhance the market price. The Supreme Court has further clarified that
expression ‘ and ’ used in Explanation 4 should be read as ‘ or ’ and the
Collector may consider theory of deduction, principle of belting,
advantages or disadvantages attached to the acquired land. This Court is
of the opinion that market price determined under Section 26 may not be
ipso facto accepted, however, Collector as well as Authority, at the first
instance, is bound to determine market price as per parameters laid down
under Section 26. Relevant extracts of the judgment read as: -
“24. Explanation 4 requires specific attention, as it
brings the element of discretion while computing the
market value under Section 26(1) to the forefront.
Explanation 4 is divided into two parts. The first part
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-21-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

refers to sub-section (1) to Section 26 - the higher value
determined as per Clauses (a), (b) and (c) of Section 26(1)
of the Acquisition Act, 2013. The second part is specific to
the average sale price referred to in Clause (b) to Section
26(1) read with Explanations 1 and 2. In either case,
where the Collector is of the opinion that the value/price
computed by applying these provisions is not indicative of
the actual prevailing market value, they may discount or
enhance it to arrive at the accurate market value.
25. Explanation 4 uses the word "and" in conjoining the
values referred to in the two parts of the Explanation. This
is done to expand the scope of application of the
Collector's discretion to the entire provision, as is also
evident from the phrase "while determining the market
value under this section". The discretion should not be
interpreted as restricting the discretion to only the average
sale price under Explanations 1 and 2. The two parts must
be given a disjunctive reading, attracting the application
of Explanation 4 when either of the values does not reflect
the actual market value. Thus, though the word "and" is
used to connect the two parts, it should be read as "or" to
effectuate the legislative intent.
26. This interpretation is also supported by the use of
the same phrase in both Explanations 3 and 4. The first
part of Explanation 3, which refers to determining the
market value under this Section, will apply with equal
vigour to both Clauses (b) and (c) of Section 26(1) of the
Acquisition Act, 2013. The latter part of Explanation 3 - as
in the case of Explanation 4, which refers to Explanations
1 and 2 - will specifically apply to Clause (b).
27. Under Explanation 4, the formation of the Collector's
opinion and any discounting or enhancing of the value
must be supported by recorded reasons. At this stage, if the
Collector chooses to make adjustments to the market value
under Explanation 4, the theory of deduction, the principle
of belting and other material factors will also be taken
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-22-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

into account. The reason for this is two-fold. First,
because the calculation of accurate market value is not an
exact science, and therefore the Collector must be mindful
of the unique factors which affect the valuation of a piece
of land. Secondly, apart from Clause (b) to Section 26(1),
the mandatory procedure of computation under the other
two Clauses, (a) and (c), does not take into account these
theories and factors, which may result in inaccuracy.
Though not determinative in the facts of the present case,
a contrary interpretation may cause injustice to the
landowners in many situations.”
[Emphasis Supplied]

17.1 In the present case, the Collector did not assess market price
as per provisions of Section 26. The Authority was bereft of complete
data of sale deeds executed during 2010, 2011 & 2012. The landowners
as well as State produced very few sale deeds, consequently, the
Authority passed impugned order as per available data. This Court is of
the considered opinion that it is pious duty of the Collector to consider
complete available data of sale deeds and registered agreements to sell.
Neither the Collector considered complete data nor submitted before the
Authority. In such circumstances, this Court vide order dated 18.08.2026
directed the Collector to prepare a chart disclosing transaction value as
well as value per acre of all the sale deeds which were executed during
2009 to 2012. The Collector prepared its report dated 25.09.2026 which
was taken on record vide order dated 30.09.2026. Copy of aforesaid
report is available with the counsel for the landowners.
18. Reduction or addition in the market price assessed as per
Section 26 may be made, however, subject to recording of reasons. The
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-23-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

reasons recorded by Collector as well as Authority shall be subject to
judicial scrutiny under Section 74 of the 2013 Act.
19. For determining average price, similar type of land situated
in the nearest village should be considered. In Section 26(1)(b),
expression ‘ nearest village or nearest vicinity area’ has been used.
Market price for the land of nearest village can be considered if sale
deeds of the village in question are not available. Expression ‘ nearest
vicinity area’ used in aforesaid Section cannot be ignored. In any case,
Section 26(1)(b) cannot be interpreted in such a manner that sale price for
the land of the adjacent/nearest village is considered despite availability
of sale price for the land of the same village. Not only every village is an
independent village but also every locality carries its own value. In the
same village and even on the same road two pieces of land may fetch
different market price. The Authority should consider sale price for land
situated in the nearest vicinity area. If sale deeds of nearest vicinity area
are not available, sale deeds of the nearest village may be considered. It
must also be kept in mind that similar type of land can be considered e.g.
agricultural land of a village cannot be compared with residential or
industrial or commercial land. Similarly, land abutting the National
Highway or State Highway cannot be compared with land situated at a far
away place from the National Highway. Thus, as per statutory provisions,
sale price of the land of nearest vicinity area has to be considered and
there is no occasion to consider sale deeds of other areas. Purpose of
determination of market price under 2013 Act is to determine fair
compensation and not to determine compensation as maximum as
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-24-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

possible. If on one hand, there are land losers, it cannot be ignored that on
the other hand there is taxpayers’ money. Balance needs to be
maintained.
20. Section 30(2) provides that Collector shall issue individual
awards detailing the particulars of compensation payable and details of
payment of the compensation as specified in the First Schedule. Section
30(3) provides that in addition to the market value of the land provided
under Section 26, the Collector shall assess addition @ 12% per annum.
Section 69(2) also provides that in every case, the Authority shall award
additional amount @ 12% per annum in addition to market value. At the
cost of repetition, Sections 30(3) and 69(2) are reproduced as below:-
Section 30(3): In addition to the market value of the
land provided under section 26, the Collector shall, in
every case, award an amount calculated at the rate of
twelve per cent. per annum on such market value for the
period commencing on and from the date of the
publication of the notification of the Social Impact
Assessment study under sub-section (2) of section 4, in
respect of such land, till the date of the award of the
Collector or the date of taking possession of the land,
whichever is earlier.
Section 69(2): In addition to the market value of the
land, as above provided, the Authority shall in every case
award an amount calculated at the rate of twelve per cent.
per annum on such market value for the period
commencing on and from the date of the publication of the
preliminary notification under section 11 in respect of
such land to the date of the award of the Collector or the
date of taking possession of the land, whichever is earlier.
Explanation. - In computing the period referred to in this
sub-section, any period or periods during which the
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-25-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

proceedings for the acquisition of the land were held up on
account of any stay or injunction by the order of any Court
shall be excluded.”

As per above quoted Section 30(3), 12% per annum addition
has to be calculated for the period commencing from the date of
publication of notification under Section 4(2) till the date of award or
date of taking possession whichever is earlier. As per Section 69(2), 12%
per annum addition has to be calculated from the date of publication of
notification under Section 11 to the date of award of the Collector or date
of taking possession of the land whichever is earlier. There seems
contradiction between the aforesaid sub-sections. As per Section 30(3),
liability of additional compensation commences from the date of
notification under Section 4(2) whereas it commences from the date of
notification under Section 11 as per Section 69(2). In the case in hand,
there was no notification under Section 4(2) of 2013 Act, thus, date of
notification i.e. 19.02.2013 issued under Section 4 of 1894 Act is the
relevant date. The landowners have claimed that 01.01.2014 should be
treated as deemed date of notification under Section 4 of 1894 Act read
with Section 11 of 2013 Act. If 01.01.2014 is considered as deemed date
of notification under Section 11 of 2013 Act, the landowners would not
be entitled to additional compensation for the period commencing from
19.02.2013 to 31.12.2013. On being confronted with this fact, learned
counsel for the landowners pleaded that they may not be denied benefit of
additional compensation for the aforesaid period because it would be a
substantial loss. This Court has held hereinabove that average sale price
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-26-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

of 2010, 2011 & 2012 has to be considered, thus, there is no rhyme or
reason to deny landowners 12% per annum addition for the period
commencing from 19.02.2013 i.e. date of notification under Section 4 till
31.12.2013. It is made clear that their entitlement to additional
compensation @ 12% per annum is undisputed for the period from
01.01.2014 to 10.01.2014 i.e. date of Collector’s award. Authority in the
impugned award has granted and rightly so additional compensation
@ 12% per annum from the date of notification under Section 4.
21. As held by this Court vide order dated 13.10.2026 passed in
a bunch of appeals including Amarjit Kaur v . State of Punjab and
another, RFA No.1785 of 2023 , 50% sale deeds of three years in which
highest sale price has been disclosed shall be selected for counting
average market value. It is irrespective of number of the year. The
selected sale deeds may be of one year or more years out of total
available data of three years e.g. if sale deeds of 2010, 2011 and 2012 are
considered, 50% deciphered highest sale deeds may be of only 2010 or
2011 or 2012 or in combination of these years.
22. The Collector, as per directions of this Court, has submitted
data of sale deeds executed during 2009, 2010, 2011 & 2012. As returned
hereinabove, sale deeds executed in 2009 need to be excluded. The
Collector has produced data with respect to sale deeds of residential as
well as agricultural land. The acquired land was agricultural land, thus,
sale deeds of only agricultural land can be considered. As held
hereinabove, the Collector/Authority must consider average sale price of
sale deeds executed during 2010, 2011 and 2012. In this backdrop, there
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-27-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

is need to consider location of the land comprised in the exemplar sale
deeds.
23. As per landowners, multiplier of 1.5 instead of 1.25 is
required to be applied. The Authority has not calculated distance of the
acquired land from the Urban area as per 2018 Notification read with
Rules framed by the State Government. This Court finds that this aspect
needs to be re-considered.
24. There is no evidence contrary to the findings recorded by the
Authority qua severance charges, thus, findings qua severance charges
are hereby upheld.
25. At this stage, learned counsel for the parties plead that matter
may be remanded to the Authority to re-calculate market value as per
data of aforesaid years. They need to verify genuineness of the data
submitted by the State. They may also find sale deeds in support of their
claim. This Court finds substance in their submissions because
appellants-landowners need to be granted opportunity to lead evidence in
the light of findings returned hereinabove.
26. In the wake of above discussion and findings, all the appeals
are hereby allowed by way of remand. Matter is remanded back to the
Authority to pass fresh orders keeping in mind:

i) Notification under Section 4 of 1894 Act was issued
on 19.02.2013 and as per Explanation 1 of Section 26 of
2013 Act, 3 years preceding the year in which acquisition
was proposed, would be 2010, 2011 and 2012;
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-28-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters


ii) Sale deeds of the nearest vicinity area and in case of
non-availability of such deeds, sale deeds of nearest
village shall be considered;

iii) 50% of the aforesaid sale deeds in which the
highest sale price has been mentioned shall be
considered;

iv) Explanation 4 of Section 26 of 2013 Act while
finalizing the market value would be considered;

v) Landowners would be entitled to 12% per annum
addition as per Section 30(3) read with Section 69(2) of
2013 Act for the period commencing from the date of
notification under Section 4 to the date of award passed
by the Collector.
27. Few appeals relate to Section 4 notification dated
04.11.2011. In case of aforesaid notification, sale deeds of 2008, 2009
and 2010 shall be considered. The landowners would be entitled to 12%
addition from 04.11.2011 to the date of award passed by the Collector.
The Collector has furnished before this Court sale deeds of
2009-2012. He would furnish statement of sale deeds executed during
2008 besides data of 2009-2010 which is already submitted before this
Court. The aforesaid data would be relating to the agricultural land. The
landowners would be free to point out sale deeds executed during
aforesaid years, however, not included in the data furnished by the
Collector.
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-29-
RFA-550-2024 (O&M) and other connected matters

28. It is hereby clarified that the landowners would not be
required to refund already paid compensation, however, it would be
subject to final order passed by the Authority. The parties, at the first
instance, shall appear before the Authority on 15.12.2026 and thereafter,
as directed by the Authority. The Collector shall produce before the
Authority data as submitted before this Court besides data as mentioned
in previous paragraph.
29. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.

(JAGMOHAN BANSAL)
JUDGE
16.11.2026
Prince Chawla


Whether Speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No


PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.18 12:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document