Loveleen Dhaliwal And Others vs Sdmcum Land Acquisition Collector, Rupnagarand Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court



206 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH


RFA-2262-2017 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 13.11.2026


Loveleen Dhaliwal and others
...Appellant(s)

Versus


SDM-Cum-Land Acquisition Collector, Rupnagar and others


...Respondent(s)
And


Sr. Case Number Appellant(s) Respondent(s)
No.
2. RFA-2481-2019 (O&M) Tej Pal Singh and The Sub Divisional Magistrate-
another Cum-Land Acquisition Collector,
Rupnagar and others
3. RFA-1955-2017 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Ram Sahai and others
4. RFA-1956-2017 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Swaranjit Kaur
5. RFA-2072-2017 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Charanjit Kaur
6. RFA-2721-2016 (O&M) Jagjit Kaur The Land Acquisition Collector and
another
7. RFA-2722-2016 (O&M) Mangat Ram The Land Acquisition Collector and
another
8. RFA-2759-2016 (O&M) Sucha Singh
(deceased) through
LRs
State of Punjab and another
9. RFA-2845-2017 (O&M) State of Punjab and
another
Sunita Singla @ Sunita Rani and
others
10. RFA-2874-2017 (O&M) State of Punjab and
another.
Sucha Singh (Deceased) through
LRs
11. RFA-2875-2017 (O&M) Land Acquisition
Collector and
another
Jagjit Kaur
12. RFA-2876-2017 (O&M) State of Punjab and
another
Raman Goyal and others
13. RFA-3254-2016 (O&M) Gurnam Kaur State of Punjab and others
14. RFA-320-2017 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Mohan Singh and others
15. RFA-3296-2018 (O&M) Land Acquisition

Collector Cum SDM
Ropar and others
Gram Panchayat of Village
Abheypur Beli
16. RFA-3692-2017 (O&M) Kulwant Singh and

another
Land Acquisition Collector,
Rupnagar and another
17. RFA-3693-2017(O&M) Randhir Singh Sub Divisional Magistrate Cum
LAC, Rupnagar and others
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-2-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

18. RFA-3694-2017 (O&M) Harnek Singh and
others
Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and another
19. RFA-3695-2017 (O&M) Surinder Singh and

another
Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and another
20. RFA-3983-2016 (O&M) Ram Sahai and The Sub Divisional Magistrate-
others -Cum Land Acquisition Collector,
Rupnagar and others
21. RFA-4631-2017 (O&M) Navinder Singh Sub Divisional Magistrate-Cum -

Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
22. RFA-151-2017 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Sada Ram and others
23. RFA-152-2017 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Nathi Singh and others
24. RFA-4708-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Gurdip Singh and others
25. RFA-4709-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Sant Singh and another
26. RFA-4711-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Chuhar Singh and another
27. RFA-4712-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Om Parkash and others
28. RFA-4713-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Sukhdev Singh and another
29. RFA-4714-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Hazura Singh and others
30. RFA-4715-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Amit Jindal and others
31. RFA-4716-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Nirmal Singh and others
32. RFA-4717-2016 (O&M)
with XOBJR-75-CI-2018
State of Punjab and
others
Mohan Singh and others
33. RFA-4718-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Ram Sahai and others
34. RFA-4880-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Dharam Pal and another
35. RFA-4881-2016 (O&M) State of Punjab and
others
Balbir Singh and others
36. RFA-5235-2015 (O&M) Sada Ram and The Sub Divisional Magistrate-
others Cum-Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
37. RFA-5236-2015 (O&M) Nirmal Singh
(Deceased) through
LRs and others
The Sub Divisional Magistrate-
Cum-Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
38. RFA-5237-2015 (O&M) Dharam Pal The Sub Divisional Magistrate-
Cum-Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
39. RFA-5238-2015 (O&M) Amit Jindal and The Sub Divisional Magistrate-
others Cum-Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
40. RFA-5239-2015 (O&M) Sukhdev Singh and The Sub Divisional Magistrate-
another Cum-Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
41. RFA-5240-2015 (O&M) Balbir Singh and The Sub Divisional Magistrate-
others Cum-Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
42. RFA-5241-2015 (O&M) Om Parkash and The Sub Divisional Magistrate-
others Cum-Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-3-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

43. RFA-5319-2017 (O&M) Bhupinder Singh The Sub Divisional Magistrate-

and others Cum -Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
44. RFA-5320-2017 (O&M) Narinder Singh

(deceased) through
LRs and others
Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and another
45. RFA-5321-2017 (O&M) Raj Kumar and

another
Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and another
46. RFA-5322-2017 (O&M) Piara Singh

(deceased) through
LRs and others
Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and another
47. RFA-6559-2015 (O&M) Mohan Singh and
others
State of Punjab and others
48. RFA-6560-2015 (O&M) Gurdeep Singh and
others
State of Punjab and others
49. RFA-6562-2015 (O&M) Nathi Singh and
others
State of Punjab and others
50. RFA-799-2017 (O&M) Charanjit Kaur State of Punjab and others
51. RFA-800-2017 (O&M) Kishan Singh State of Punjab and others
52. RFA-4618-2015 (O&M) Hazura Singh and The Sub Divisional Magistrate
others Cum Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
53. RFA-6561-2015 (O&M) Sant Singh and
another
State of Punjab and others
54. RFA-4541-2015 (O&M) Ram Sahai and The Sub Divisional Magistrate
others Cum Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others
55. RFA-4540-2015 (O&M) Chuhar Singh and The Sub Divisional Magistrate
another Cum Land Acquisition Collector
Rupnagar and others


CORAM:- HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JAGMOHAN BANSAL

Present:- Mr. J.S. Bhatia, Advocate
for the appellant(s)-landowners
in RFA No.2262 of 2017.

Mr. Vijay Lath, Advocate for the landowners
in RFA Nos.65600, 6559, 5235, 5237, 5238, 5241, 4540,
4541, 4618, 6562, 6561, 5240 & 5239 of 2015;
in RFA Nos.2759, 4717, 3254 & 3983 of 2016;
in RFA Nos.799, 800, 5319, 5322, 5321, 3693, 4631, 5320,
3692, 3695 & 3694 of 2017; XOBJR-75-CI-2018;
RFA No.2481 of 2019.

Mr. Pritam Singh Saini, Advocate,
Mr. Deepak Singh Saini, Advocate and
Ms. Rajdeep Kaur, Advocate
for the appellants
in RFAs No.2721 and 2722 of 2016 .

Mr. Puru Jarewal, DAG Punjab with SDM, Rupnagar.

PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-4-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

JAGMOHAN BANSAL, J.


1. These appeals under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (for short ‘1894 Act’) are directed against different awards passed
by learned Additional District Judge, Rupnagar (hereinafter called as
‘Reference Court’). The landowners are seeking enhancement of the
amount of compensation whereas the State is claiming otherwise.

2. As common issues are involved in the captioned appeals,
with the consent of both sides, the same are hereby disposed of by this
common order. For the sake of brevity and convenience, facts are
borrowed from RFA- 2262 of 2017.

3. Tabulated details of the assessment made by Collector read
as: -
Date of notification under Section 4 03.03.2010
Date of notification under Section 6 30.07.2010
Purpose of acquisition Construction of Ropar bye-pass
Location Village – Shampura, Abheypur Beli and
Arazi Ropar
Tehsil & District – Rupnagar
Area (Total) Shampura- 157K-36M
Abheypur Beli- 9K-15M
Arazi Ropar- 23K-14M
Date of Collector’s Award (LAC) 07.02.2011
Market value as per LAC ( ₹ per acre) Shampura- 1,50,00,000/- for category A
60,00,000/- for category B
45,00,000/- for category C
Abheypur Beli and Arazi Ropar-
40,00,000/-


PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-5-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters


4. The Reference Court has determined different market values
vide different awards qua different pieces of land. Details thereof read as:

Village Shampura

Sr. No. Date of Award of
Market Value as per Reference
Reference Court
Court ( ₹ per acre)
1. 08.11.2016 1.65 crore
2. 29.04.2015 1.5 crore
3. 04.08.2015 1.5 crore
4. 05.11.2015 1.5 crore
5. 14.12.2015 1.5 crore
6. 15.03.2016 1.5 crore
7. 29.03.2016 1.5 crore
8. 18.01.2016 1.5 crore

Village Abheypur Beli

Sr. No. Date of Award of
Market Value as per Reference
Reference Court
Court (
₹ per acre)
1. 11.10.2017 1.65 crore

Village Arazi Ropar

Sr. No. Date of Award of Market Value as per Reference
Reference Court Court ( ₹ per acre)
1. 09.02.2016 63,52,500/-
2. 07.03.2017 63,52,500/-


5. The State Government issued notification dated 03.03.2010
under Section 4 of the 1894 Act for the acquisition of 55.93 Acres land
situated in a villages of District Rupnagar. The aforesaid acquisition
included acquisition of 157K-36M, 9K-15M and 23K-14M land situated
in Village Shampura, Abheypur Beli and Arazi Ropar respectively.
Acquisition was proposed with intent to construct Rupnagar bye-pass.
The said notification was followed by notification dated 30.07.2010
issued under Section 6 of 1894 Act.
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-6-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters


6. The Land Acquisition Collector (for short ‘Collector’) vide
Award dated 07.02.2011, in terms of provisions of 1894 Act, determined
compensation payable to the landowners. Market value of the acquired
land was determined @ ₹ 40,00,000/- per acre for village Abheypur Beli
& Arazi Ropar and ₹ 1,50,00,000/- per acre for category A, ₹ 60,00,000/-
for category B and ₹ 45,00,000/- per acre for category C for village
Shampura. Landowners were held entitled to solatium and other statutory
benefits. Feeling dis-satisfied from the aforesaid award, landowners
preferred petitions before the Collector which were referred to the Court
under Section 18 of the 1894 Act.

7. The Reference Court while appreciating evidence led by both
sides, by impugned award adjudicated reference petitions. The Reference
Court by impugned awards has enhanced market value of the acquired
land then assessed by the Collector.

8. Learned counsel for the landowners submit that the
respondent-State by notification dated 03.03.2010 acquired 55.93 Acres
land situated in nine villages. The land was acquired to construct bye-pass
road. Acquisition started from village Paprala and passed through 08
more villages. A bridge was constructed over Sutlej River to connect
State of Punjab with State of Jammu & Kashmir. This Court vide order
dated 02.02.2026 passed in RFA No.3719 of 2018 titled as ‘ Darshan
Singh and others Versus State of Punjab’ and order dated 25.09.2026
passed in RFA No.3133 of 2016 titled as ‘ Bhag Singh Versus The Sub
Divisional Magistrate-Cum-LAC, Rupnagar and others’ has determined
market value @ ₹ 1,09,68,450/- per acre. The aforesaid value has been
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-7-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

determined with respect to 06 villages i.e. Paprala , Chhoti Railon ,
Rasoolpur, Bari Haveli, Badi Railon, Gurdaspura. There was no question
to make discrimination between land of the same village. Hon’ble
Supreme Court time and again including in recent judgment titled as
‘ Surender Ahuja and another Versus State of Punjab and another’,
2026(4) RCR (Civil) 417 has held that in case of linear acquisition unless
and until there are exceptional circumstances, uniform rate for the entire
land should be determined. The Reference Court applying aforesaid
principles has determined market value of the entire piece of land situated
in village Shampura as well as Abheypur Beli @ ₹ 1.65 crore per acre.
The Reference Court has increased market price from ₹ 1.5 crore per acre
to ₹ 1.65 crore per acre. The landowners submitted contemporaneous sale
data disclosing market price. As per contemporaneous sale data, the
market price comes to ₹ 4.94 crore per acre. The market price has not been
determined by the Reference Court as per exemplary sale deeds. The
Court could impose cut, however, could not blindly or mechanically
ignore sale data. The acquired land was very potential. It was surrounded
by Hospitals, residential colonies, marriage palaces and shops. In these
circumstances, it had potential of being used for commercial purposes.
Market price of the land in question may not be determined at par with
market price of land of remaining six villages. The State in September’
2010 declared Collector rate of commercial property @ ₹ 25,000/- per
square yard. It indicates that market price of commercial property even as
per State was more than ₹ 10 crore per acre. As per statement of Gurmukh
Singh, Planning Officer, District Town Planner, Rupnagar (PW-3), master
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-8-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

plan for 2010-2031 has been prepared for the District Ropar. Land of
villages Shampura, Abheypur Beli, Arazi Ropar fall within master plan.
As per statement of Sanjay Kumar, Clerk, Improvement Trust, Rupnagar
(PW-4), land of village Shampura was sanctioned for the scheme known
as Beant Singh Aman Nagar, Ropar and site of SCO was auctioned by
Improvement Trust, Ropar in January’ 2009. These facts collectively
vindicate stand of the landowners that land in question should be
considered as commercial and value be assessed as per commercial rates.

9. Per contra , learned State counsel submits that the Collector
in case of land of village Shampura found that market value up to 40
Karam from Bela Road should be determined @ ₹ 1.50 crore per acre.
Market value of the land situated within 40-80 Karam was determined @
₹ 60 lakh per acre and market price of remaining land was determined @
₹ 45 lakh per acre. The landowners submitted different sale deeds before
the Reference Court. All the sale deeds related to duly constructed houses.
These houses comprised very small pieces of land i.e. less than 200
square yards. Land comprised in exemplar sale deeds was situated 500
meters away from the acquired land. This Court has determined market
value of land of six villages @ ₹ 1,09,68,450/- per acre. It is a case of
linear acquisitions, thus, it would be unjustified to determine market price
of the land in question beyond aforesaid value. Acquired land of villages
Paprala, Chhoti Railon and Rasoolpur was abutting existing 30 meters
road as well as surrounded by multiple residential and commercial
establishments. Site plan produced by the landowners is disclosing that
there was Transport Nagar, Power Colony, Jagat Nagar, Gillco Valley,
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-9-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

Baba Deep Singh Nagar, Gill Hospital, Ajeet Singh Sahibzada Academy
etc. close to acquired land of the aforesaid three villages. Despite
aforesaid facts, market price has been determined @ ₹ 1,09,68,450/-. The
Collector considering the fact that small portion of the acquired land is
close to Bela Road where multiple business/commercial establishments
are located, determined market price @ ₹ 1.5 crore for the land situated up
to 40 Karams. Remaining land was as good as land of other villages, thus,
there was no occasion to give special treatment and assess market price @
₹ 1.50 crore or ₹ 1.65 crore per acre.

10. Heard the arguments and perused the record.

11. Learned counsel for the parties are ad idem that delay in
filing any appeal which is part of present bunch may be condoned.
Accordingly, delay, if any, in any case, stands condoned. It is clarified
that appellants shall not be entitled to interest for the delayed period.

12. Learned counsel for the parties are ad idem that in case of
linear acquisition, uniform rate should be determined where for common
purpose and by one notification, land of different villages is acquired.
They are also in tandem that in case of linear acquisition, uniform rate
may be determined. The Supreme Court recently in Surender Ahuja
(supra) relying upon its previous judgments has reiterated aforesaid
opinion.

13. Hon’ble Supreme Court in ‘HSIIDC Vs. Pran Sukh & Ors.’,
2010(11) SCC 175 and ‘Ali Mohammad Beigh & Ors. Vs. State of
J&K’, 2017(4) SCC 717 has recognized one rate for the land of multiple
villages where acquisition is by common notification and for the common
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-10-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

purpose. Relevant extracts of the judgment in Ali Mohammad Beigh
(supra) read as:-
“13. When the lands are more or less situated nearby and
when the acquired lands are identical and similar and the
acquisition is for the same purpose, it would not be proper
to discriminate between the land owners unless there are
strong reasons. In Union of India v. Bal Ram and Another
(2010) 5 SCC 747, this Court held that if the purpose of
acquisition is same and when the lands are identical and
similar though lying in different villages, there is no
justification to make any discrimination between the land
owners to pay more to some of the land owners and less
compensation to others. The same was the view taken in
Union of India v. Harinder Pal Singh and Others. (2005)
12 SCC 564, where this Court held as under:-
“15. We have carefully considered the submissions
made on behalf of the respective parties and we see
no justification to interfere with the decision of the
Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High
Court which, in our view, took a pragmatic
approach in fixing the market value of the lands
forming the subject-matter of the acquisition
proceedings at a uniform rate. From the sketch plan
of the area in question, it appears to us that while
the lands in question are situated in five different
villages, they can be consolidated into one single
unit with little to choose between one stretch of
land and another. The entire area is in a stage of
development and the different villages are capable
of being developed in the same manner as the lands
comprised in Kala Ghanu Pur where the market
value of the acquired lands was fixed at a uniform
rate of L 40,000 per acre. The Division Bench of
the Punjab and Haryana High Court discarded the
belting method of valuation having regard to the
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-11-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

local circumstances and features and no cogent
ground has been made out to interfere with the
same.
16. In our view, in the absence of any
contemporaneous document, the market value of
the acquired lands of Village Kala Ghanu Pur
which were acquired at the same time as the lands
in the other five villages was correctly taken to be a
comparative unit for determination of the market
value of the lands comprising the lands forming the
subject-matter of the acquisition proceedings under
consideration........””


14. In the present case, land of 9 villages has been acquired for
the construction of bye-pass road. It is a linear acquisition of multiple
villages by common notification and for common purpose. The Reference
Court has assessed market value of land of two villages i.e. Abheypur
Beli and Shampura @ ₹ 1.65 crore per acre and third village Arazi Ropar
@ ₹63,52,500/- per acre . This Court vide judgment dated 02.02.2026 and
25.09.2026 has determined market price @ ₹ 1,09,68,450/- per acre. In
Bhag Singh (supra) , the Court has determined price of land of six
villages namely Paprala, Chhoti Railon, Rasoolpur, Badi Railon, Bari
Haveli and Gurdaspura. The Court has determined market price relying
upon judgment in Darshan Singh (supra) . In Darshan Singh (supra) ,
the Court has noticed nature of land, exemplar sale deeds and concluded
that area acquired is 35 Kanal 1 Marla and 3 Sarsai and area comprised in
sale instance Ex. A-1 is measuring 975 square yards (1 Kanal 12 Marla)
which cannot be called as small area vis-à-vis area acquired. The Court
has also considered that acquired land has potential to be developed for
residential purposes. Findings recorded in Darshan Singh (supra) read
as:
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-12-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

“12. Upon further examination of sale instance
dated 27.05.2009 (Ex.A-1) it has been found that the kind
of land sold therein was recorded as “Chahi” and “Gair
Mumkin”. Furthermore, the sale deed was registered by
treating the alienation as that of residential parcel with
segment rate of Rs.30,000/- per marla which was
admittedly, the Collector rate for registration of sale deed
of residential parcel of land. In such circumstances, it
becomes evident that the acquired land also had the
potential to be developed for residential purpose. Thus,
accordingly, an appreciation of 9% needs to be awarded in
favour of landowner for the time gap of 9 months from the
date of sale instance dated 27.05.2009 (Ex.A-1) till the
date of notification under Section 4 of the Act in the case in
hand i.e. 03.03.2010.
13. Moreover, in the humble opinion of this Court,
no merit can be found in the submission made on behalf of
the learned State counsel for applying any deduction
towards smallness of area involved in the sale instance
Ex.A-1 especially, when the sale instance Ex.A-1 measures
975 square yards (1 kanal 12 marlas) which cannot be
regarded as a small area viz-a-viz the acquired land which
is merely 35 kanals 1 marla and 3 sirsai. Further, since the
acquisition in the case(s) in hand has been carried out for
the public purpose namely, for construction of Ropar
Bypass and as such, the respondents did not suffer any loss
towards optimum utilization of the area acquired and also
did not incur expenditure towards providing of additional
infrastructural amenities like parks, green belts, roads and
community buildings etc., no cut towards development
costs needs to be imposed. Furthermore, the sale deed
dated 27.05.2009 proved on record by the landowners/
appellants as Ex.A-1 itself has even been relied upon by
the respondents, having produced on record the same as
Ex.R2. On the other hand, the sale deed dated 18.08.2009
produced on record by the respondents as Ex.R3, though
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-13-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

pertained to the same revenue estate of Village Bari Railon
with base price per acre of Rs.48,000,00/-, however, the
same is not relevant for the purpose of determination of
market value of the acquired land in the present case(s) as
the comparative location of its land parcel viz-a-viz the
acquired land has not been established on record.
Accordingly, while relying upon sale instance Ex.A-
1 and by applying appreciation of 9% thereupon for the
time gap of nine months, the market value for the acquired
land as on the date of notification under Section 4 of the
Act is thus determined @ Rs.1,09,68,450/- per acre.”


15. The State vide notification dated 03.03.2010 has acquired 35
Kanal 1 Marla and 3 Sarsai land situated in village Badi Railon whereas
total area acquired is 55.93 acres. The exemplar sale deeds cannot be
mechanically relied upon. It is settled law that sale deeds comprising
different type of land and comprising small area cannot be made basis to
determine market price of a large tract. There is need to rationalize value
declared in small pieces of land. In ‘Lal Chand Versus Union of India
and Another’, 2009(15) SCC 769 , Supreme Court has laid down
principles with respect to application of cut. The Court has appreciated
that land situated in industrial area cannot be at par with commercial.
Land situated in commercial area cannot be at par with residential. Land
situated in residential area cannot be at par with agricultural land.
Unapproved colonies cannot be treated at par with approved colonies. In
case of approved colonies, area ear-marked for different facilities is
always much more than unapproved or unauthorized colonies. The Court
has held:

PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-14-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

“7. On careful consideration, we are of the view that such
allotment rates of plots adopted by Development
Authorities like DDA cannot form the basis for award of
compensation for acquisition of undeveloped lands for
several reasons. Firstly market value has to be determined
with reference to large tracts of undeveloped agricultural
lands in a rural area, whereas the allotment rates of
development authorities are with reference to small plots in
a developed lay out falling within Urbana. Secondly DDA
and other statutory authorities adopt different rates for
plots in the same area with reference to the economic
capacity of the buyer, making it difficult to ascertain the
real market value, whereas market value determination for
acquisitions is uniform and does not depend upon the
economic status of the land loser. Thirdly we are
concerned with market value of freehold land, whereas the
allotment "rates" in the DDA Brochure refer to the initial
premium payable on allotment of plots on leasehold basis.
We may elaborate on these three factors.
8. First factor : The percentage of 'deduction for
development' to be made to arrive at the market value of
large tracts of undeveloped agricultural land (with
potential for development), with reference to the sale price
of small developed plots, varies between 20% to 75% of
the price of such developed plots, the percentage
depending upon the nature of development of the lay out in
which the exemplar plots are situated. The 'deduction for
development' consists of two components. The first is with
reference to the area required to be utilised for
developmental works and the second is the cost of the
development works. For example if a residential layout is
formed by DDA or similar statutory authority, it may
utilise around 40% of the land area in the layout, for
roads, drains, parks, play grounds and civic amenities
(community facilities) etc. The Development Authority will
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-15-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

also incur considerable expenditure for development of
undeveloped land into a developed layout, which includes
the cost of levelling the land, cost of providing roads,
underground drainage and sewage facilities, laying
waterlines, electricity lines and developing parks and civil
amenities, which would be about 35% of the value of the
developed plot. The two factors taken together would be
the 'deduction for development' and can account for as
much as 75% of the cost of the developed plot. On the
other hand, if the residential plot is in an unauthorised
private residential layout, the percentage of 'deduction for
development' may be far less. This is because in an un-
authorized lay outs, usually no land will be set apart for
parks, play grounds and community facilities. Even if any
land is set apart, it is likely to be minimal. The roads and
drains will also be narrower, just adequate for movement
of vehicles. The amount spent on development work would
also be comparatively less and minimal. Thus the
deduction on account of the two factors in respect of plots
in unauthorised layouts, would be only about 20% plus
20% in all 40% as against 75% in regard to DDA plots.
The 'deduction for development' with references to prices
of plots in authorised private residential layouts may range
between 50% to 65% depending upon the standards and
quality of the layout. The position with reference to
industrial layouts will be different. As the industrial plots
will be large (say of the size of one or two acres or more as
contrasted with the size of residential plots measuring 100
sq.m. to 200 sq.m.), and as there will be very limited civic
amenities and no playgrounds, the area to be set apart for
development (for roads, parks, playgrounds and civic
amenities) will be far less; and the cost to be incurred for
development will also be marginally less, with the result
the deduction to be made from the cost of a industrial plot
may range only between 45% to 55% as contrasted from
65 to 75% for residential plots. If the acquired land is in a
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-16-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

semi-developed urban area, and not an undeveloped rural
area, then the deduction for development may be as much
less, that is, as little as 25% to 40%, as some basic
infrastructure will already be available. (Note: The
percentages mentioned above are tentative standards and
subject to proof to the contrary).
9. Therefore the deduction for the 'development factor' to
be made with reference to the price of a small plot in a
developed lay out, to arrive at the cost of undeveloped
land, will be for more than the deduction with reference to
the price of a small plot in an unauthorized private lay out
or an industrial layout. It is also well known that the
development cost incurred by statutory agencies is much
higher than the cost incurred by private developers, having
regard to higher overheads and expenditure. Even among
the layouts formed by DDA, the percentage of land utilised
for roads, civic amenities, parks and play grounds may
vary with reference to the nature of layout - whether it is
residential, residential-cum-commercial or industrial; and
even among residential layouts, the percentage will differ
having regard to the size of the plots, width of the roads,
extent of community facilities, parks and play grounds
provided. Some of the layouts formed by statutory
Development Authorities may have large areas earmarked
for water/sewage treatment plants, water tanks, electrical
sub-stations etc. in addition to the usual areas earmarked
for roads, drains, parks, playgrounds and community/civic
amenities. The purpose of the aforesaid examples is only to
show that the 'deduction for development' factor is a
variable percentage and the range of percentage itself
being very wide from 20% to 75%.
[Emphasis supplied]


PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-17-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters


16. In the case in hand, the landowners cited five sale deeds
before the Reference Court. Tabulated details of aforesaid sale deeds read
as:
Ex. No. Date Vasika No. Village Area Vasika AMT Per/Acre
PW9/A 12/05/2009 357 Shampura 3-6 1090000 47563636.00
PW9/B 28/04/2009 225 Shampura 3-3 1250000 60000000.00
PW9/C 01/06/2009 589 Shampura 3-3 1340000 64320000.00
PW9/D 23/07/2009 1130 Shampura 5-0 1470000 47040000.00
PW9/E 25/09/2009 1723 Shampura 6-2 1100000 28310999.00



17. A perusal of aforesaid sale deeds reveals that all these sale
deeds are comprising area less than 200 square yards. Area comprised in
sale deeds dated 12.05.2009, 28.04.2009 and 01.06.2009 is even less than
100 square yards. Sale deed dated 23.07.2009 is comprising 150 square
yards area and sale deed dated 25.09.2009 is comprising 186.6 square
yards area. It is duly recorded in all the sale deeds that there is
constructed portion e.g. as per sale deed dated 23.07.2009, total area is
150 square yards and constructed area is 112 square yards. Similarly, as
per sale deed dated 25.09.2009, total area involved is 186.6 square yards
and constructed area is 142 square yards. In any case, such a small area
cannot be used for agricultural purposes.
Land in question, as per revenue record is agricultural land.
Part of the land is close to Bela Road which is an internal road of village
Shampura. There is intersection of Bela Road and newly constructed bye-
pass road. There are shops and other commercial/business establishments
abutting the Bela Road. The landowners have pointed out that there was a
marriage palace situated in the acquired land. There is no evidence in the
form of CLU disclosing that marriage palace was constructed with the
approval of Competent Authority. It proves that type of land was
agricultural though small portion of acquired land was close to Bela Road
where commercial activities were carried out.
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-18-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters


18. This Court while adjudicating case of Bhag Singh (supra) as
well as during hearing of present appeals has scrutinized site plan
produced by landowners. A perusal of site plan reveals that the State
acquired aforesaid land to construct bye-pass road. Land of nine villages
was acquired. Acquisition started from Village Paprala and passed
through 08 more villages. Prior to construction of bye-pass, vehicles
leading from Chandigarh/Mohali/Kharar to Nawanshahr/Jalandhar/
Amritsar had to pass through City Ropar. There was problem of traffic
jam as well as unwanted wastage of valuable time and energy. To
overcome aforesaid issues, bye-pass was constructed. As per site plan,
there was already 30 meters road from village Paprala to Village
Abheypur Beli. There was no road from Village Shampura to Bada Phool.
In case where 30 meters road was existing, land was acquired to make it
60 meters road and where there was no existing road, land was acquired
for constructing 60 meters road. As per site plan, Village Paprala, Chhoti
Railon, Rasoolpur are located at Morinda Road and there are multiple
business and commercial establishments close to the acquired land. In
case of aforesaid villages, 30 meter road was already existing, thus, their
location was better than remaining villages. Despite said fact, this Court
has determined compensation @ 1,09,68,450/- per acre. The landowners
₹
herein want that value of their land may be determined at uniform rate,
however, said rate be higher than rate of other villages. Argument of
landowners is contrary to settled principles of law.

19. In view of judgment of Pran Sukh (supra) , Ali Mohammad
Beigh (supra) and Surender Ahuja (supra) , it would be unfair to
determine market value of the villages in question at higher rate than
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-19-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

determined in the other villages. Market price for land of these villages
could be determined more than market price of remaining villages subject
to specific evidence disclosing locational advantages. All the nine villages
whose land was acquired are contagious. Villages Gurdaspura and Bari
Haveli are adjoining to Shampura and Village Railon is adjoining the
Villages Abheypur Beli and Arazi Ropar. It would be discrimination with
landowners of Villages Railon , Gurdaspura and Bari Haveli if market
price of land of Village Abheypur Beli, Arazi Ropar and Shampura is
determined at much more rate than value of their villages.

20. Learned counsel for the landowners have pleaded that land
was acquired to construct bye-pass road, thus, no development cut should
be imposed. Contention of the landowners is mis-conceived because a
large tract of agricultural land cannot be assessed on the basis of small
constructed houses. In the ordinary course, market price should be
assessed as per exemplar sale deeds of same type of land. In the absence
of contemporaneous data, reliance may be placed on a different type of
land subject to correction.

21. Now the matter needs to be examined in the light of Award
passed by the Collector as well as exemplar sale deeds of village
Shampura. As noticed hereinabove, three sale deeds are comprising area
less than 100 square yards. It would not be just and fair to rely upon
aforesaid sale deeds especially when those are related to constructed
houses. There are two sale deeds which are disclosing area more than 100
square yards. Though these two sale deeds like other sale deeds are not
good piece of evidence yet are relied upon to determine market value of
the acquired land because no other reliable evidence is available on
record. Sale deed dated 25.09.2009 is comprising 186.6 square yards area
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-20-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

and disclosing market price @ ₹ 2.83 core per acre. Sale deed dated
23.07.2009 is comprising 150 square yards and disclosing market price @
₹ 4.70 crore per acre. It is also a constructed house. In view of judgment
of Supreme Court in Lal Chand (supra) , cut on account of size as well as
type of land is required to be imposed. If 50% cut is imposed, market
price as per sale deed dated 25.09.2009 would come to ₹ 1.42 crore per
acre and ₹ 2.35 crore per acre as per sale deed dated 23.07.2009. If 50% of
average of both deeds is considered, market price would come to ₹1.87
crore per acre. In case of a constructed house, there is cost of
construction. Cost of construction cannot be less than 50% of total cost
except where land is situated in a posh and upscale residential area. If
cost of construction is deducted, market price of the acquired land would
be less than even ₹1.50 crore per acre which would justify market value
@ ₹1,09,68,450/- per acre determined hereinafter qua land in question.

22. In aforesaid circumstances, market price determined by the
Reference Court @ ₹ 1.65 crore per acre where Collector had determined
@ ₹ 1.5 crore per acre seems justified though Reference Court has granted
10% increase without any basis. At the cost of repetition, it is noticed that
the Collector had determined market rate ₹ 1.5 crore where acquired land
was situated close to Bela Road i.e. road where commercial activities
were going on. He had classified land of village Shampura in three
categories i.e. ‘A’, ‘B’ and ‘C’. As per judgments of the Supreme Court,
uniform rate should be granted for linear acquisition, however, collector
himself has found potential in the part of acquired land, thus, different i.e.
higher rate is justified. Accordingly, market rate of the land is determined
@ ₹ 1.65 core where Collector had determined market rate 1.5 crore per
acre.

PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-21-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters


23. The Reference Court has also determined market price for
land of Village Shampura @ ₹1.50 crore where Collector had determined
@ ₹60 or ₹45 lakh per acre. The Reference Court has simply observed
that as per judicial precedents, uniform rate should be determined. The
aforesaid doctrine is not applicable without examining evidence on
record. It is a case of acquisition of land of 09 villages. As per afore-cited
judgments, uniform rate should be applied qua all the villages where
there is acquisition by common notification and for common purpose.
This Court has assessed market value for land of 06
villages @ ₹1,09,68,450/- per acre and Reference Court had
assessed @ ₹69,72,000/- per acre. Uniform rate has been granted
to 06 villages. Partial land of Village Shampura has been differently
treated by Collector. A different treatment to small piece of land does not
mean that remaining land of the said village be treated at par with
preferential land and not land of other villages. The Collector
determined market price of Category ‘B’ and ‘C’ land of Village
Shampura @ ₹60 and ₹45 lakh per acre respectively. Land of other
villages was assessed @ ₹40 - ₹60 lakh per acre. It is apt to notice
that Collector determined market value for land of Village
Paprala @ ₹60 lakh per acre. Village Paprala was first village whose land
was acquired and it was abutting existing 30 meters road and there were
residential and commercial establishments close to the acquired land.
This Court along with other villages has assessed market value for land of
Village Paprala @ ₹ 1,09,68,450/- per acre. It would be just, fair and
equitable if market price of land of Village Shampura
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-22-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

(Category ‘B’ and ‘C’) is also determined @ ₹ 1,09,68,450/-. Accordingly,
awards of the Reference Court are modified to the extent that market
value for land of Village Shampura is determined @ ₹ 1,09,68,450/-
where Collector had determined ₹ 60 or ₹ 45 lakh per acre. At the cost of
repetition, it is hereby observed that Reference Court increased market
price from ₹ 60 or ₹ 45 lakh to ₹1 .50 crore qua all the landowners and if
cost of construction is considered 50% of total price, market value as per
exemplar sale deeds disclosed hereinabove would not be more than
₹1,09,65,450/- per acre.

24. In the case of land situated in Arazi Ropar and Abheypur
Beli, the Collector had determined market price @ ₹ 40 lakh per acre. The
Reference Court has determined market rate @ ₹ 63.52 lakh per acre with
respect to land situated in Arazi Ropar and ₹ 1.65 crore for the land
situated in Village Abheypur Beli. It is apt to notice that the Reference
Court while deciding references of Village Arazi Ropar has determined
market value @ ₹ 1.65 crore per acre in RFA No.5320 of 2017
(LAC-95-2012) which relates to Village Abheypur Beli. In view of
afore-cited judgments, uniform rate is required to be determined. Uniform
rate does not mean rate equal to rate of land having exceptional
potentiality and locational advantages. In view of findings recorded
hereinabove, uniform rate in the present case means rare which is
determined qua remaining six villages. This court has determined market
price with respect to land of six villages @ ₹ 1,09,68,450/- per acre.
Applying the aforesaid rate, market price of land situated in Arazi Ropar
and Abheypur Beli is hereby determined @ ₹ 1,09,68,450/- per acre. It is
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-23-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

hereby clarified that where the Reference Court has determined market
price @ ₹ 63.52 lakh per acre, it is increased to ₹ 1,09,68,450/- and where
the Reference Court has determined @ ₹ 1.65 or ₹1.50 crore per acre, it is
reduced to ₹ 1,09,68,450/- per acre. The landowners shall be entitled to
statutory benefits including interest on the enhanced amount of
compensation.
Severance Charges:

25. The landowners are claiming that despite raising claim of
severance charges, the Reference Court has not awarded severance
charges. Their unacquired land has been bifurcated into two parts. A
perusal of the impugned award passed by the Reference Court reveals
that Reference Court has not awarded severance charges. The coordinate
bench in Darshan Singh (supra) has awarded severance charges @ 25%
of the market value. This is a bunch of appeals and aforesaid amount
cannot be mechanically granted to each landowner. There is possibility
that area bifurcated from the unacquired area is so small that 25% of the
amount of compensation may be more than total value of the bifurcated
area. This may be understood with an example. A landowner is having
five acres land and four acres are acquired. The remaining area is divided
into two parts i.e. ¾ acre on one side and ¼ acre on the other side. Value
of ¼ acre or even unacquired 1 acre land may be less than 25% of the
compensation. If 25% of the compensation is awarded as severance
charges, it would be apparently bad because it would be in the public
interest if bifurcated ¼ acre or 1 acre land is also acquired. Similarly,
25% of the compensation may be more than total value of the unacquired
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-24-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters

land. The Reference Court is supposed to ascertain area owned and
possessed by the claimants, area vivisected from the unacquired area,
utilization of the land prior to the acquisition and post-acquisition, change
in the value of unacquired land on account of construction of bypass road
because value of unacquired land normally multiplies on account of
construction of national highway/bypass road/link road etc.
It is not possible for this Court to examine record of each
appellant. There may be many appellants/landowners who have not raised
claim of severance charges. They cannot raise said issue at this stage. If
any landowner has raised question of bifurcation of his unacquired land,
his claim needs to be quantified. It is made clear that benefits available
under Section 23(1A) and 23(2) are not available on the severance
charges.

26. This Court finds that without ascertaining afore-stated
factual and legal position, severance charges cannot be determined. In the
normal circumstances, matters are not remanded to the Reference Court,
however, in the present case it is inevitable to remand the matter to the
Reference Court so that factual and legal position with respect to
bifurcation of the unacquired land may be ascertained and severance
charges may be determined. Ordered accordingly. It is made clear that
remand is limited to the determination of severance charges qua those
landowners who had raised claim in the reference petition and led
evidence. The Reference Court would not be required to take additional
evidence unless and until it is inevitable to ascertain the severance
charges.
PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document



-25-
RFA-2262-2017 (O&M) and other connected matters


27. Disposed of in above terms.

28. It is made clear that benefit of aforesaid reduction in market
price would not be applicable where there is no appeal by the State.

29. Before parting with the judgment, I deem it appropriate to
record that during last four months, I have noticed that in most of the
cases, State does not lead requisite evidence before the Reference Court
and as per evidence led by landowners, huge State’s fiscal liability is
created. No effort is made to find out genuineness of sale deeds
comprising small pieces of land and that too executed just few months
before the initiation of acquisition process. A very casual and
lackadaisical approach is adopted by all the officials dealing with the
matters. In the present case appeals have been filed in few cases and no
appeal has been filed where higher amount was awarded. Despite specific
orders of this Court, the State does not produce site plan disclosing
location of the acquired land as well as exemplar sale deeds. A land loser
deserves just and fair compensation, however, cannot be paid exorbitant
amount at the cost of government exchequer. Registry is directed to send
copy of this order to the Chief Secretary and Principal/Additional Chief
Secretary, Law and Justice, State of Punjab.

30. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.


(JAGMOHAN BANSAL)
JUDGE
13.11.2026
Prince Chawla
Whether Speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No

PRINCE CHAWLA
2026.11.17 16:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document