Manoj Alias Manoj Dodhi vs State Of Punjab
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
1
CRM CRM-M-52220 CRM CRM 52220 52220-2026 52220 2026 2026 2026
243 243 243 243
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT AT AT
CHANDIGARH CHANDIGARH CHANDIGARH CHANDIGARH
CRM CRM-M-52220 CRM CRM 52220 52220-2026 52220 2026 2026 2026
Manoj @ Monu Dodhi
….Petitioner
versus
State of Punjab
….Respondent
Date of decision: Date of decision: November 17 Date of decision: Date of decision: November 17 November 17, 2026 November 17 , 2026 , 2026 , 2026
Date of Uploading: Date of Uploading: November 17 Date of Uploading: Date of Uploading: November 17 November 17, 2026 November 17 , 2026 , 2026 , 2026
CORAM: CORAM: CORAM: CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMEET GOEL HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMEET GOEL HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMEET GOEL HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMEET GOEL
Present: Present:- Present: Present: Mr. Amandeep Singh Rai, Advocate and
Ms. Sunaina Rani, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Anup Singh, AAG Punjab.
SUMEET GOEL SUMEET GOEL, J. (ORAL) SUMEET GOEL SUMEET GOEL , J. (ORAL) , J. (ORAL) , J. (ORAL)
nd
Present 2 petition has been filed under Section 483 of the
Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short ‘BNSS’) seeking grant
of regular bail to the petitioner, in case bearing FIR No.35 dated 07.04.2024,
registered for the offences punishable under Sections 307, 324, 452, 427,
148, 149 of IPC, 1860 (Sections 120-B & 302 of IPC added later on), at
Police Station Dugri, District Ludhiana.
The last regular bail plea preferred by the petitioner was
dismissed as withdrawn, at that stage, vide order dated 10.02.2026 passed in
CRM CRM-M-51180 CRM CRM 51180 51180-2025 51180 2025 2025. 2025
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 17:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment
2
CRM CRM-M-52220 CRM CRM 52220 52220-2026 52220 2026 2026 2026
2. For the sake of ease, relevant factual milieu drawn from the
order dated 28.03.2025 passed by the concerned Sessions Court (whereby
regular bail plea of the petitioner was rejected), reads thus:
“ 5. The FIR was filed based on the statement of Amandeep Kaur, who
was injured. She said that she is a B.Ed. student at Guru Ram Dass
College. On the night of April 6-7, 2024, around 12:30 AM, she was at
home with her uncle Dara Singh, her mother Sarabjit Kaur, and her
grandmother Surjit Kaur. They were all asleep when they heard the sound
of motorcycles in the street. Suddenly, 2-3 boys climbed over the wall and
entered their house. They then opened the main gate from inside, allowing
more people to enter. The attackers were carrying swords, baseball bats,
and other dangerous weapons. They started attacking them with the
intention to kill. Sagar Neutron attacked Amandeep with a sword, injuring
her left-hand little finger, right arm, and head. Monu Dwarik and Monu
Dodhi (the applicant) hit her mother with a sword on her head and arms.
Shubham attacked her grandmother, injuring her left cheek and ribs. Rajiv
Kumar (the applicant), Kuldeep Singh, and Amit attacked her uncle in the
back room, causing injuries to his head and arms. Their house was filled
with screams, and people gathered in the street, but no one helped them.
The attackers also damaged a Splendor motorcycle (PB-10EY-7623)
parked in the house. They were shouting that Navi had helped Rajiv and
Sunny in a fight on March 30, 2024. Due to fear, Navi did not return
home. Amandeep alleged that Sagar is a troublemaker who has been to jail
many times and that the accused often pick fights. She also stated that the
attackers took money, her Oppo F-15 mobile phone with its cover, and
broke her mother's phone. She said the reason for the attack was that the
accused believed her brother Navi had helped Rajiv and Sunny in the
previous fight. ”
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner has iterated that the petitioner
is in custody since 16.09.2024. Learned counsel has further iterated that the
petitioner has been falsely implicated in the instant case. It has been argued
that co-accused of the petitioner, namely, Shubham was attributed the role of
attacking the grandmother (Surjit Kaur) of the complainant causing injuries
to her left cheek and ribs. The grandmother of the complainant later expired.
Learned counsel has further iterated that no role whatsoever in the injuries
sustained by the grandmother of the complainant were attributed to the
petitioner. Learned counsel has iterated that there are material contradictions
in the medical record in respect of age of the deceased. Learned counsel has
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 17:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment
3
CRM CRM-M-52220 CRM CRM 52220 52220-2026 52220 2026 2026 2026
iterated that no final or conclusive cause of death report has been placed on
record by the prosecution even after a span of more than 02 years from the
date of death of the grandmother of the complainant. Learned counsel has
further argued that the grandmother of the complainant was in advanced
stage having pre-existing chronic ailments. Learned counsel has argued that
the alleged recovery of kirpan , that too after one day of alleged occurrence,
cannot, by itself, be treated as a conclusive incriminating material
connecting the petitioner with the commission of offence in question.
3.1. Learned counsel has seeks parity with the co-accused, namely,
Keshav, Vanshika Bawa, Aditya Chauhan and Mansh @ Vansh, who have
been granted the concession of regular bail by this Court vide orders dated
20.08.2025 20.08.2025 passed in CRM 20.08.2025 20.08.2025 CRM CRM-M-20984 CRM 20984 20984-2025 20984 2025 2025, dated 28.07.2025 2025 28.07.2025 28.07.2025 passed in 28.07.2025
CRM CRM-M-48458 CRM CRM 48458 48458-2024 48458 2024 2024, dated 11.02 2024 11.02 11.02.2025 11.02 .2025 .2025 passed in CRM .2025 CRM CRM-M-53388 CRM 53388 53388-2024 53388 2024 2024 and 2024
dated 13.12.2024 13.12.2024 passed in CRM CRM-M-61816 61816-2024 2024, respectively.
13.12.2024 13.12.2024 CRM CRM 61816 61816 2024 2024
3.2. Learned counsel has iterated that the challan (upon culmination
of investigation) has already been presented on 01.10.2024. Total 15
prosecution witnesses have been cited, only 02 (in part) have been examined
till date. Learned counsel has, thus, argued that further detention of the
petitioner behind bars would not serve any useful purpose particularly when
culmination of the trial is likely to take long time. On the basis of aforesaid
submissions, the grant of instant petition is entreated for.
4. In oppugnation , learned State counsel has filed reply by way of
an affidavit dated 22.10.2026, which is already on record. Relevant of the
said reply, reads thus:
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 17:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment
4
CRM CRM-M-52220 CRM CRM 52220 52220-2026 52220 2026 2026 2026
“ 50. That it is respectfully submitted that the following particulars
pertaining to the present case are submitted hereunder for the kind
consideration of this Hon’ble Court:
(A) (A) (A) (A) Role of the petitioner ole of the petitioner ole of the petitioner: ole of the petitioner
Petitioner accompanied with co-accused to the
complainant's house during the intervening night of 06/07.04.2024
at about 12:30 a.m., armed with a sword and entered the house
after the gate was opened from inside by his companions. The
petitioner, along with co-accused Monu Dwarika, attacked Sarabjit
Kaur, mother of the complainant, with swords, causing injuries to
her head and arms, while the other assailants attacked Amandeep
Kaur, Dara Singh and Surjit Kaur. The attack arose from the
assailants' grievance that the complainant's brother Navi had
assisted Sunny in the earlier quarrel with Rajiv Kumar. The
petitioner surrendered before the learned Illaqa Magistrate on
16.09.2024 and during police remand, pursuant to his disclosure
statement, got recovered a sword from a vacant plot near LIG
Flats, which was taken into police possession.
(B) (B) (B) (B) Incriminating evidence collected against the petiti Incriminating evidence collected against the petitioner Incriminating evidence collected against the petiti Incriminating evidence collected against the petiti oner oner: oner
i) Statement of the complainant Statement of the complainant: The statement of the Statement of the complainant Statement of the complainant
complainant, forming the basis of FIR No. 35 dated
07.04.2024, specifically names the petitioner as Monu
Dodhi and assigns him an active role in the assault. She
identified the petitioner and Monu Dwarika as the persons
who attacked her mother Sarabjit Kaur with swords on her
head and arms. Her statement places the petitioner inside
the house with the armed assailants during the occurrence.
xx xx xx xx ”
Raising submissions in tandem with the said reply, learned
State counsel has opposed the petition by arguing that the allegations raised
against the petitioner are serious in nature. It has been further submitted that
after conclusion of investigation, challan has been presented and out of total
15 prosecution witnesses, only 02 (in part) have been examined till date;
thus, grant of bail, at this stage, would create a real apprehension that the
petitioner may abscond from the process of justice as also intimidate the
prosecution witnesses. Learned State counsel seeks to place on record the
custody certificate dated 16.11.2026, in the Court today, which is taken on
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 17:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment
5
CRM CRM-M-52220 CRM CRM 52220 52220-2026 52220 2026 2026 2026
record. On the basis of these submissions, the dismissal of the instant
petition is prayed for.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the rival parties and have
perused the available record.
6. The grant of bail falls within the discretionary domain of the
court; however, such discretion must be exercised in a judicious and
principled manner, ensuring it aligns with established legal precedents and is
in the interests of justice. While considering a bail application, the court
must evaluate factors such as the existence of prima facie evidence
implicating the accused, the nature and gravity of the alleged offence, and
the severity of the likely sentence upon conviction. The court must also
assess the likelihood of the accused absconding or evading the due process
of law, the probability of the offence being repeated, and any reasonable
apprehension of the accused tampering with evidence or influencing
witnesses. Additionally, the character, antecedents, financial means, societal
standing, and overall conduct of the accused play a crucial role.
Furthermore, the court must weigh the potential danger of bail undermining
the administration of justice or thwarting its due course. A profitable
reference in this regard is made to the judgment passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court titled as State through C.B.I. vs. Amaramani Tripathi, 2005 State through C.B.I. vs. Amaramani Tripathi, 2005 State through C.B.I. vs. Amaramani Tripathi, 2005 State through C.B.I. vs. Amaramani Tripathi, 2005
AIR Supreme Court 3490, AIR Supreme Court 3490, AIR Supreme Court 3490, AIR Supreme Court 3490, relevant whereof reads as under:
“ 14. It is well settled that the matters to be considered in an application
for bail are (i)whether there is any prima facie or reasonable ground to
believe that the accused had committed the offence; (ii) nature and gravity
of the charge; (iii) severity of the punishment in the event of conviction;
(iv) danger of accused absconding or fleeing if released on bail; (v)
character, behaviour, means, position and standing of the accused;(vi)
likelihood of the offence being repeated; (vii) reasonable apprehension of
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 17:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment
6
CRM CRM-M-52220 CRM CRM 52220 52220-2026 52220 2026 2026 2026
the witnesses being tampered with; and (viii) danger, of course, of justice
being thwarted by grant of bail (see Prahlad Singh Bhati v. NCT, Delhi, Prahlad Singh Bhati v. NCT, Delhi, Prahlad Singh Bhati v. NCT, Delhi, Prahlad Singh Bhati v. NCT, Delhi,
2001(2) RCR (Criminal) 377 (SC) :2001(4) SCC 280 2001(2) RCR (Criminal) 377 (SC) :2001(4) SCC 280 and Gurcharan 2001(2) RCR (Criminal) 377 (SC) :2001(4) SCC 280 2001(2) RCR (Criminal) 377 (SC) :2001(4) SCC 280 Gurcharan Gurcharan Gurcharan
Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), AIR 1978 Supreme Court 179). Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), AIR 1978 Supreme Court 179 Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), AIR 1978 Supreme Court 179 Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), AIR 1978 Supreme Court 179
While a vague allegation that accused may tamper with the evidence or
witnesses may not be a ground to refuse bail, if the accused is of such
character that his mere presence at large would intimidate the witnesses or
if there is material to show that he will use his liberty to subvert justice or
tamper with the evidence, then bail will be refused. We may also refer to
the following principles relating to grant or refusal of bail stated in Kalyan Kalyan Kalyan Kalyan
Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan, 2004(2) RCR (Criminal) 254 (SC) Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan, 2004(2) RCR (Criminal) 254 (SC) Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan, 2004(2) RCR (Criminal) 254 (SC) Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan, 2004(2) RCR (Criminal) 254 (SC)
:2004(7) SCC 528 :2004(7) SCC 528 :"The law in regard to grant or refusal of bail is very :2004(7) SCC 528 :2004(7) SCC 528
well settled. The court granting bail should exercise its discretion in a
judicious manner and not as a matter of course. Though at the stage of
granting bail a detailed examination of evidence and elaborate
documentation of the merit of the case need not be undertaken, there is a
need to indicate in such orders reasons for prima facie concluding why
bail was being granted particularly where the accused is charged of having
committed a serious offence. Any order devoid of such reasons would
suffer from non-application of mind. It is also necessary for the court
granting bail to consider among other circumstances, the following factors
also before granting bail; they are:
a. The nature of accusation and the severity of punishment in case of
conviction and the nature of supporting evidence.
b. Reasonable apprehension of tampering with the witness or
apprehension of threat to the complainant.
c. Prima facie satisfaction of the court in support of the charge. (see
Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh, 2002(2) RCR (Criminal) 250 Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh, 2002(2) RCR (Crimin Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh, 2002(2) RCR (Crimin Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh, 2002(2) RCR (Crimin al) 250 al) 250 al) 250
(SC) : 2002(3) SCC 598 andPuran v. Ram Bilas, 2001(2) RCR (Criminal) (SC) : 2002(3) SCC 598 andPuran v. Ram Bilas, 2001(2) RCR (Criminal) (SC) : 2002(3) SCC 598 andPuran v. Ram Bilas, 2001(2) RCR (Criminal) (SC) : 2002(3) SCC 598 andPuran v. Ram Bilas, 2001(2) RCR (Criminal)
801 (SC) : 2001(6) SCC 338. 801 (SC) : 2001(6) SCC 338. 801 (SC) : 2001(6) SCC 338. 801 (SC) : 2001(6) SCC 338. ”
7. As per the prosecution case, serious allegations have been
levelled against the petitioner. Perusal of the prosecution case, the material
collected during investigation, the reply filed by the State as also the order
whereby regular bail plea of the petitioner was dismissed by the concerned
Sessions Court, prima facie , reveals that the petitioner allegedly attacked
Sarabjeet Kaur with a sword and caused injuries to her head, right arm and
left arm, which stand corroborated by her medical report. It is further alleged
that co-accused – Rajiv, along with other accused persons, caused injuries to
the complainant’s uncle. Initially, four persons, namely, Amandeep
(complainant), Dara Singh, Sarabjeet Kaur and Surjit Kaur, sustained
injuries in the occurrence. However, Surjit Kaur subsequently succumbed to
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 17:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment
7
CRM CRM-M-52220 CRM CRM 52220 52220-2026 52220 2026 2026 2026
her injuries, resulting in the addition of the charge under Section 302 IPC. It
is further the case of the prosecution that some of the injured had sustained
grievous injuries on vital parts of their bodies, particularly the head.
7.1. Learned counsel for the petitioner has sought the concession of
regular bail on the ground of parity with the co-accused who have already
been granted the said concession by this Court. However, a perusal of the
orders granting bail to the co-accused, when juxtaposed with the role
attributed to the petitioner, reveals that the petitioner has been specifically
assigned the role of attacking the complainant’s mother with a sword,
thereby causing injuries to her head and arms. The role attributed to the
petitioner is, thus, clearly distinguishable from that of the co-accused who
have been granted the concession of bail. Consequently, the petitioner
cannot claim the benefit of the principle of parity in the facts and
circumstances of the present case.
8. Keeping in view the entirety of the factual milieu of the case in
hand; especially the specific role having been attributed to the petitioner, and
the fact that the prosecution witnesses are yet to be examined; this Court is
of the considered view that the petitioner does not deserve the concession of
regular bail at this stage.
9. In view of above ratiocination, it is directed as under:
(i) The instant petition, being devoid of merit, is hereby
dismissed dismissed; dismissed dismissed
(ii) Any observations made and/or submissions noted
hereinabove shall not have any effect on merits of the
case and the investigating agency as also the trial Court
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 17:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment
8
CRM CRM-M-52220 CRM CRM 52220 52220-2026 52220 2026 2026 2026
shall proceed further, in accordance with law, without
being influenced with this order;
(iii) Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed
of.
(SUMEET GOEL SUMEET GOEL SUMEET GOEL) SUMEET GOEL
JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE
November 17 November 17, 2026 November 17 November 17 , 2026 , 2026 , 2026
mahavir
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 17:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment