MUKESH MEENA vs NORTHERN RAILWAY

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1


Item No. 34 - Court 3

Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench
New Delhi

OA No. 3517/2024

Reserved on : 03.11.2026
Pronounced on : 18.11.2026

Hon’ble Mrs. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J)
Hon’ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member(A)

Mukesh Meena (ST)
S/o Late Sh. Bhoodhar Singh
Rio A-13, second floor, Dayal Bagh, Faridabad,
Haryana-121 009.
Presently working as Loco Pilot Goods
At Nizamuddin Railway Station
Northen Railway

..Applicant(s)

(By Advocates: Mr. Yogesh Sharma)

Versus

Ministry of Railway (Northen Railway)
Govt. of India
Baroda House, New Delhi
THROUGH ITS SECRETARY
...Respondent(s)
(By Advocate: Mr. U Srivastava with Mr. Anoop Kr.)

















SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA

2


Item No. 34 - Court 3

O R D E R
Hon’ble Mrs. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member(J)
The applicant is aggrieved by the rejection of his
candidature for selection to the post of Chief Loco Inspector on
the ground that he did not fulfil the prescribed qualifying service
of 10 years as Loco Pilot (Goods). The respondents have rejected
his claim by relying upon Railway Board's Circular dated
21.03.2006 (RBE No. 34/2006), restricting the counting of past
service rendered in the previous unit to the length of service of
his immediate senior in the new unit.
2. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the issue
involved in the present O.A. was squarely covered by the
decision of the Principal Bench in Raghubir Singh and Others v.
Union of India, OA No. 1755/2009, decided on 23.11.2009,
which had also been considered and relied upon by the Jabalpur
Bench of this Tribunal in OA No. 772/2016, decided on
29.03.2019.
3. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents relied on the
reply filed by the respondents and submitted that the applicant
had not completed the requisite 5 lakh kilometres of footplate
duties and that, in terms of Railway Board's Circular dated
21.03.2006, the past service rendered in the previous unit could
not be counted beyond the length of service of his immediate
senior in the new unit. It was further submitted that the
applicant's immediate senior had rendered only 7 years and 10
months of service and, therefore, the applicant did not fulfil the
prescribed eligibility condition of 10 years of actual service as
Loco Pilot (Goods).
4. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the documents available on record.
5. We find that the issue regarding counting of past service
rendered in the previous unit for the purpose of determining
eligibility for promotion, notwithstanding transfer on one's own
request and consequent placement at the bottom of seniority,
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA

3


Item No. 34 - Court 3

already stands considered by the Jabalpur Bench of this
Tribunal in OA No. 772/2016, decided on 29.03.2019. After
considering the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Renu Mallick (Smt.) v. Union of India, 1994 (1) SCC 373 and
Union of India v. C.N. Ponnappan, (1996) 1 SCC 524 , as well
as the decision of the Principal Bench in Raghubir Singh
(supra) , the Tribunal held that past service rendered in the
previous unit was liable to be counted for determining eligibility
for promotion. The relevant portion of the said judgment is
reproduced herein below:
“We also find that the said selection was through invitation of
applications from everybody who fulfilled the eligibility criteria. The
selection was on the basis of merit, to be decided by written
examination and screening of service records. Seniority was not the
basis on which promotion was to be done.
14. Therefore, it is clear that the entire service at the old unit is to be
counted while considering eligibility criteria of service for promotion. The
candidature of the applicant in this O.A. cannot be rejected on the
ground of not fulfilling the requirement of qualifying service.
15. Accordingly, the Original Application is allowed. candidature of the
applicant has been rejected for not having minimum qualifying service
are set aside. The respondents are directed to consider the case of the
applicant for promotion through review DPC within a period of 60 days
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. If found fit, he
may be promoted with effect from the same date when others have been
promoted through the said selection process. He would also be entitled
to consequential financial benefits, on which no interest would be
payable. No order as to costs.”
6. In view of the aforesaid decision, we find that the respondents
were not justified in restricting the applicant's past service in the
previous unit by applying the condition contained in Railway
Board's Circular dated 21.03.2006 (RBE No. 34/2006). The
applicant's candidature, therefore, deserves to be reconsidered
by counting his past service in accordance with the aforesaid
decision. Moreover the Circular dated 21.03.2006 (RBE No.
34/2006) already stands quashed by the Jabalpur Bench of the
Tribunal. Respondents continued reliance on the same is
therefore illegal.
7. In view of the above, we see no reason to take a divergent
view. Accordingly, the O.A. is allowed. The impugned
communication dated 22.08.2024 is set aside. The respondents
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA

4


Item No. 34 - Court 3

are directed to consider the applicant's candidature for selection
to the post of Chief Loco Inspector by counting his past service
rendered in the previous unit, in accordance with the
observations made hereinabove, and take a decision through a
review selection process within a period of 60 days from the date
of receipt of a certified copy of this order. If found eligible and fit,
the applicant shall be extended the benefit of selection from the
same date on which other candidates selected through the said
selection process were appointed, along with consequential
benefits. No interest shall be payable on the consequential
financial benefits.
8. The OA is allowed in the aforesaid terms. Pending MAs, if any,
are also disposed of. No costs.


(Dr. Sumeet Jerath) (Harvinder Kaur Oberoi)
Member(A) Member(J)
/ss/
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA