Veena Chopra vs Ved Parkash Chopra
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
::1::
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
(135) CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
Date of decision: 18.11.2026
Veena Chopra ...Petitioner
V/s
Ved Prakash Chopra
...Respondent(s)
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JASJIT SINGH BEDI
Present: Ms. Navdeep Kaur, Advocate, (Legal Aid Counsel),
for the petitioner.
JASJIT SINGH BEDI, J. (Oral)
CRM-17399-2026
The application for placing on record the evidence led by the
petitioner (Annexure P-6) is allowed as prayed for subject to all just
exceptions. The same is taken on record.
CRM-M-16820-2026
The prayer in the present petition under Section 528 BNSS
(Section 482 Cr.P.C.) is for quashing of the order dated 21.05.2025
(Annexure P-5) passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Faridabad in CRR
No.458 of 2019 titled as ‘Veena Chopra versus Ved Parkash Chopra’
whereby the order dated 26.07.2019 (Annexure P-3) passed by the Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Faridabad in Criminal Complaint No.COMI-316 of
2017, has been upheld.
2. The brief facts of the case are that the complainant-petitioner
(hereinafter to be known as ‘the petitioner’) filed a private complaint against
SUKHPREET KAUR
2026.11.21 12:13
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
::2::
the respondent-accused (hereinafter known as ‘the respondent’) for offences
under sections 420, 467, 468, 471,120-B and 506 IPC with the averment that
her husband had purchased a part of a property measuring 171 Sq. ft of area
out of 152.32 Sq. Yards property area plus 1st Floor rights of H. No.949
Type II Quarters, Sector-21-C, Housing Board Colony, Faridabad from it's
the then owner the accused for Rs. 2,27,000/- in June 2002, by way of sale
agreement, GPA, SPA, I/Bond, Affidavit, Possession Letter, Will and
Receipt. Out of the above mentioned documents, only GPA was got
registered in New Delhi. It was further alleged that the petitioner had paid
Rs.50,000/- advance to the respondent on 29.03.2003 to purchase remaining
part of property when he wanted to sell entire property. Without returning
the money of the husband of the petitioner and without getting the GPA
cancelled, the respondent on 17.04.2003 entered into an agreement to sell
the entire said property to Rajan son of the petitioner for Rs.10,00,000/- as
total sale consideration and collected Rs.2,00,000/- from him as advance at
the time of agreement. The respondent collected balance Rs. 8,00,000/- from
him by 23.06.2003 i.e. the full amount of sale consideration. The accused
issued receipts in favour of Rajan for Rs.8,00,000/- which included two
receipts of Rs. 3,03,721/ and of Rs. 67,000/- respectively, drawn by cheques
in favour of HDFC on his behalf. Due to some dispute of Rajan with his in-
laws, the custody of his wife was obtained through the orders by N.C.W on
28.06.2003 and due to this reason, the possession of the said entire property
was given by the respondent to the husband of the petitioner with mutual
understanding that sale deed would be executed later on by him. For this
SUKHPREET KAUR
2026.11.21 12:13
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
::3::
purpose, the respondent adjusted about Rs. 8,00,000/-out of Rs. 10,00,000/-
paid by Rajan in favour of the husband of the petitioner and signed the
amendments on the documents mentioned at para 2 above (except receipt) to
read as full property and amount to read as Rs. 10,30,000/-. The original sale
deed of property was also handed over to the husband of petitioner as
security. The respondent vide his letter dated 11.07.2003 had sought
permission to retain 2nd floor rights which proved by itself that he had sold
the entire said property to the husband of the petitioner. Pending execution
of sale deed by the accused, the property was developed into three storey
residential units but due to family problems, Rajan the son of the petitioner
was debarred of all rights of properties sometimes in mid of 2005. After this,
the respondent started cheating to extract more money and grab the property
by way of manipulation as under:-
(A) First of all by misguiding the Registering Authority, he obtained C.T.C
of the then sale deed by giving false reasons as the originals were handed
over to the husband of the petitioner by him and he was fully aware of this.
(B) Secondly vide his letter dated 07.07.2006, the respondent informed that
he never sold the property in question to the husband of the petitioner and
that on the basis of C.T.C, he threatened to sell the said property to some one
else who would throw the luggage by force.
Left with no other option, the petitioner purchased the very said
entire property measuring 152.32 Sq. Yards as per the allotted size of
property by Housing Board, vide sale deed document No. 20464 dated
SUKHPREET KAUR
2026.11.21 12:13
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
::4::
01.03.2007, from the respondent on separate payment of freshly demanded
sale deed consideration amounting Rs.9,46,500/-.
Further for the sale deed also, the respondent cheated the
complainant as vide sale agreement dated 08.02.2007, he agreed to sell the
entire said property for agreed sale consideration Rs. 7,50,000/-only but at
the time of sale deed, he charged and collected Rs. 9,46,500/-as sale
consideration for said property measuring 152.32 Sq. Yards with
construction total having covered area 500 Sq. ft. At the time of handing
over possession of the entire said property, the accused adjusted about
Rs.8,00,000/- out of Rs.10,00,000/- paid by Rajan as sale consideration in
favour of the husband of the petitioner and signed the amendment on I™
sale agreement to read as Rs.10,30,000/- received as sale consideration. The
respondent vide letter dated 07.07.2006 and email dated 07.11.2006
considered only the amount paid to HDFC by Rajan as paid by the husband
of the petitioner and thus, fraudulently considered both of them defaulter in
payment of sale consideration. In his statement given to Police authorities on
24.09.2011, he mentioned that their agreements lapsed due to non-payment.
In this way, he cheated both of them of the entire of their paid up amounts.
Further in order to extort more money and grab the said property, the
respondent forged a sentence of underpayment to the tune of Rs. 4,46,500/-
above the ink signatures of complainant on the 7th page of photocopy of the
sale deed document no.20464 dated 01.03.2007. Contradicting his fake
demand of Rs. 4,46,500/- the respondent vide his statement dated
06.01.2011 to cops, misinformed about the receipt of Rs.2,50,000/- as
SUKHPREET KAUR
2026.11.21 12:13
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
::5::
payment towards sale consideration whereas that amount was paid as loan
repayment. He also misinformed that he received Rs.2,50,000/- on the orders
of the court where as the payment was made on getting notice itself. After
committing this fraud, he filed a civil suit but later on to correct his version
he issued an M.O.U for full ownership of the property in question and No
Dues in favour of the petitioner. But he again backed out on the next date of
hearing. However, the case was dismissed in favour of the petitioner by the
Court. The respondent lodged the complaint with the Commissioner of
Police on flimsy grounds even by assassinating the character of the
petitioner. Investigations conducted by an officer of the rank of Zonal A.C.P
then A.C.P Crime Branch and finally by A.C.P HQ conducted that " It is not
possible that the accused has not received the payments and that the accused
was unaware of cutting before signing the amendments. It was prayed that
the respondent may kindly be summoned and be punished as per law
accordingly.
3. In the preliminary evidence, complainant(Veena Chopra) herself
stepped into the witness box as CW1 and also examined Baldev Krishan as
CW2, Lalit Prasad Chopra as CW3 and Rajan Chopra as CW4 and Surender
Sharma CW5. Thereafter, preliminary evidence was closed by the
complainant. Report under Section 202 Cr.P.C was called vide court order
dated 08.11.2017 and same was filed in the court on 04.12.2018.
4. Based on the evidence led and the report under Section 202
Cr.P.C., the Court Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Faridabad dismissed the
SUKHPREET KAUR
2026.11.21 12:13
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
::6::
complaint vide judgment dated 26.07.2019. Para 10 of the said judgment is
as under:-
“10. First of all, the complainant failed to prove by any
documentary evidence that accused has committed any cheating
or forgery etc of any documents. Complainant examined five
witnesses but none of the witness have tendered even a single
documents in their evidence nor the same were tendered by the
counsel for the complainant or by any of the witness. Therefore,
in the absence of tendering of documentary evidence, the same
cannot be read into evidence as per the Indian Evidence Act.
The allegations of the complainant were regarding cheating
and forgery upon some documents, which have not been
tendered in evidence. Only on the basis of oral testimony,
cheating any forgery upon some documents cannot be accepted.
The complainant failed to prove that accused forged any
document or that he had initially dishonest intention at the time
of making agreement of the suit property with her or with her
husband which is very essential ingredients of the offence of
cheating. Further the report under Section 202 of Cr.P.C also
says that no cognizable offence has been found in the enquiry
rather it was just a family dispute of transfer of money. Hence,
in the absence of the documentary evidence, no prima facie
case is made out against the accused and the complaint is
devoid of any merit and is hereby dismissed. File be consigned
to record room, after due compliance”.
5. Thereafter, a revision petition (CRR-458 of 2019) was filed
before the Court of the Additional Sessions Judge, Faridabad and the same
came to be dismissed on 21.05.2025. The relevant extract of the same is as
under:-
SUKHPREET KAUR
2026.11.21 12:13
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
::7::
11. At the stage of issuing process against the accused, Court
has although to see whether prima-facie case is made out or not
and no detailed inquiry and scrutiny of evidence is required.
Otherwise also, it needs mentioning that the Hon’ble Apex
Court in M/s Pepsi Food Ltd. Vs. Special Judicial Magistrate,
1997 (4) RCR (Criminal) 761, held that summoning of an
accused in a criminal case is a serious matter. Criminal law
cannot be set into motion as matter of course. It is not that the
complainant has to bring only two witnesses to support his
allegations in the complaint to have the criminal law set into
motion. The order of the Magistrate summoning the accused
must reflect that he has applied his mind to the facts of the case
and the law applicable thereto. He has to examine the nature of
allegations made in the complaint and the evidence both oral
and documentary in support thereof and that would be sufficient
for the complainant to succeed in bringing charge home to the
accused. Similar to this effect is the law laid down in Arun Jha
& Anr. vs. State of Haryana & Ors, 2006(1) RCR (Criminal)
300. In the instant case, the complainant has not brought on
record any convincing oral and documentary evidence before
the trial court and infact, Learned JMIC, Faridabad,
appreciated the facts in the right perspective and while taking
in to account the same and other relevant material, dismissed
the complaint. Not only this, by following the dictum of law
detailed above, it must be held that present revision petition
deserves dismissal.
12. Thus, at the stage of summoning once a no prima facie case
is made out against the accused persons and the Magistrate is
of the opinion that there is no sufficient ground for proceeding,
he has to dismiss such complaint under Section 203, Cr.P.C. In
the case in hand, the Learned Magistrate after analyzing the
SUKHPREET KAUR
2026.11.21 12:13
I agree to specified
portions of this document
evidence, has rightly arrived at a conclusion that no prima
CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
::8::
facie case under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471,120-B and 506
IPC is made out against the respondent/accused.
13. Therefore, after perusing the material on record and looking
into the facts of the case, it is amply clear that no prima facie
involvement of respondent is established for having committed
the subject offence. Thus, it must be held that the contentions
raised by Learned Counsel for revisionist is not tenable,
accordingly, this court does not find any illegality or perversity
in the impugned dismissal order passed by the Learned trial
Court.
14. As a sequel to above mentioned findings, this court is of the
view that there is no illegality in the impugned order dated
10.07.2019 vide which complaint for summoning the accused
person for commission of offence under sections 420, 467, 468,
471,120-B and 506 IPC of the complainant stands dismissed.
Resultantly, the impugned order stands affirmed and the present
revision petition is hereby dismissed being devoid of any merit.
6. Thereafter, the instant petition has been filed on behalf of the
petitioner challenging the aforementioned judgments dated 26.07.2019
passed by the Trial Court and the judgment dated 21.05.2025 passed by the
Court of the Additional Sessions Judge, Faridabad.
7. The learned legal aid counsel for the petitioner contends that
the impugned judgments dated 26.07.2019 and 21.05.2025 are per se illegal
and passed without application of mind besides being contrary to Section
203 Cr.P.C. There is more than sufficient material on record to adduce that
the respondent had an intention from the very inception to cheat the
petitioner. She, therefore, prays that the impugned judgments be set aside
and the respondent be summoned to face Trial.
SUKHPREET KAUR
2026.11.21 12:13
I agree to specified
portions of this document
CRM-M-16820-2026 (O & M)
::9::
8. I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner.
9. A perusal of the judgments under challenge would reveal that
the petitioner has not been able to produce any forged document in evidence.
There is scant evidence of cheating having been committed by the
respondent with the petitioner and/or her family members. It appears to be a
case of financial dispute within the family of the petitioner and the
respondent as well. No criminality has been established.
10. In view of the above, I find no merit in the present petition and
the same stands dismissed.
11. The pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
November 18, 2026 ( JASJIT SINGH BEDI)
sukhpreet JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
SUKHPREET KAUR
2026.11.21 12:13
I agree to specified
portions of this document