Mohammad Sabir vs Ramesh Prasad
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 1255
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.13804 OF 2026
MOHAMMAD SABIR APPELLANT
VERSUS
RAMESH PRASAD AND RESPONDENTS
OTHERS
J U D G M E N T
ATUL S. CHANDURKAR, J
1. The appellant seeks further enhancement in the amount of
compensation as awarded to him by the Motor Accident Claims
1
Tribunal, Gwalior and partially enhanced by the learned Single
2
Judge of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Gwalior .
2. The appellant on 24.04.2013 was travelling on his motorcycle
along with his wife Mrs. Rizwana. At about 12.10 p.m., when the
motorcycle was near Kotwali Datia area, it was hit by a truck
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
IRAMNAZ
Date: 2026.11.20
17:00:27 IST
Reason:
1
For short, ‘the Tribunal’
2
For short, ‘the High Court’
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 1 of 13
driven by the first respondent and owned by the second
respondent. The appellant and his wife suffered injuries pursuant
to the aforesaid accident and underwent medical treatment. The
appellant, thereafter, filed Claim Petition No.147/2013 while his
wife filed Claim Petition No.146/2013 before the Tribunal under
3
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 seeking
compensation. The appellant produced a Disability Certificate
indicating that he had suffered permanent disability to his right
leg to the extent of 50%. He further claimed that he was earning
monthly income of ₹ 15,000/- by collecting milk and selling it. He
was aged between 27 years and 30 years when the accident took
place. The Tribunal, after considering the evidence on record, held
that the accident was caused due to rash and negligent driving of
the truck. The appellant had suffered permanent disability to his
right leg to the extent of 50%. On account of the said accident, his
overall disability was considered at 40% since the doctor had
opined that with some treatment, the disability would be reduced.
The Tribunal determined the compensation in the following
manner:
3
For short, ‘the Act of 1988’
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 2 of 13
Sr. No. Particulars Tribunal’s Award
1. Disability 20%
2. Multiplier 17
3. Monthly Income ₹ 4000/-
4. Net Annual Income ₹ 1,63,200/- [4000 x 12 x
17 x 20%]
5. Loss of Earnings ₹ 20,000/-
[4000 x 5]
6. Medical Expenses ₹ 15,930/-
7. Special Diet and
₹ 5000/-
Transportation
8. Pain and Suffering ₹ 25,000/-
9. Atttendant Charges ₹ 4000/-
Total Compensation ₹ 2,33,130/-
Accordingly, an amount of ₹ 2,33,130/- was awarded to the
appellant as compensation with interest @ 7% per annum from
28.06.2013 when the claim petition was filed till the date of actual
payment.
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 3 of 13
3. The appellant, not being satisfied with the compensation as
awarded, filed an appeal under Section 173(1) of the Act of 1988
seeking enhancement in the amount of compensation. The said
proceedings, however, came to be dismissed pursuant to an order
dated 29.04.2015 as the defects in the appeal were not removed
within the stipulated period. Subsequently, by an order dated
26.04.2024, the proceedings were restored subject to payment of
cost of ₹ 1,000/- and a further condition that in case of
enhancement in the amount of compensation, the appellant would
not be entitled for interest for the period when the proceedings
were dismissed and were subsequently restored.
4. The High Court, after considering the material on record,
enhanced the amount of compensation by ₹ 2,00,000/- over and
above the amount awarded by the Tribunal. The appellant, not
being satisfied with the partial enhancement in the amount of
compensation, has filed the present appeal.
5. Mr. N.K. Mody, learned Senior Advocate for the appellant
submitted that the Tribunal as well as the High Court erred in
assessing the income of the appellant @ ₹ 4,000/- per month which
was lower than the minimum wages of an unskilled labourer. A
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 4 of 13
pragmatic approach ought to have been adopted by the Courts
instead of insisting upon strict proof of income earned. He
submitted that the loss of earning capacity of the appellant was
considered on a lower side disregarding the Disability Certificate
issued to the appellant. Considering the nature of disability
suffered by the appellant which was permanent in nature, it was
clear that the appellant’s earning capacity had been seriously
impacted. It was further urged that higher compensation ought to
have been awarded towards future prospects, medical expenses,
attendant charges as well as for the pain and suffering of the
appellant. While the Tribunal awarded meagre compensation, the
High Court enhanced the same only by ₹ 2,00,000/-. Considering
the nature of injuries suffered by the appellant coupled with his
age, a higher amount of compensation ought to have been granted.
It was, thus, submitted that the amount of compensation be
reasonably increased in the facts of the case.
6. The first and second respondent, namely the driver and the
owner of the vehicle have not chosen to contest the appeal. The
third respondent, the insurer, was represented by Mr. Sanathana
Bhaarath, learned counsel. He submitted that the Tribunal as well
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 5 of 13
as the High Court considered the evidence on record and
proceeded to award reasonable compensation to the appellant. In
absence of any evidence with regard to the appellant’s income, the
₹
amount of 4,000/- per month as notional income was rightly
taken into consideration. The doctor had opined that with further
treatment, the percentage of disability would be reduced and, thus,
the earning capacity of the appellant was not seriously impacted.
He, therefore, submitted that there was no reason, whatsoever, to
enhance the amount of compensation and the appeal was liable to
be dismissed.
7. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and having
perused the documentary material on record, we are of the
considered opinion that the appellant would be entitled to a higher
amount of compensation than what was awarded by the High
Court. It may be noted that the findings with regard to the first
respondent being responsible for the accident as well as the
liability of the insurer are not under challenge. It is only the aspect
of just compensation that is required to be adjudicated in the
present appeal.
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 6 of 13
8. At the outset, it may be observed that the Tribunal
determined the amount of compensation after analysing the
appellant’s entitlement under various separate heads. The High
Court in appeal enhanced the amount of compensation by an
amount of ₹ 2,00,000/-, however, without indicating the manner in
which it arrived at the said figure.
In our view, the High Court ought to have adverted to each
head under which compensation was awarded by the Tribunal and
then determined whether such grant was just or not. A composite
increase in the amount of compensation without indicating the
basis for the same could be termed as an exercise of guesswork
rather than applying the law laid down in this regard. This Court
4
in Raj Kumar Vs. Ajay Kumar and another has considered this
aspect in detail. In paragraph 5, it has observed as under:
“5. The heads under which compensation is awarded in personal
injury cases are the following :
Pecuniary damages (Special Damages)
(i) Expenses relating to treatment, hospitalization, medicines,
transportation, nourishing food, and miscellaneous
expenditure.
(ii) Loss of earnings (and other gains) which the injured would
have made had he not been injured, comprising :
(a) Loss of earning during the period of treatment;
(b) Loss of future earnings on account of permanent
disability.
4
2010 INSC 703
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 7 of 13
(iii) Future medical expenses.
Non-pecuniary damages (General Damages)
(iv) Damages for pain, suffering and trauma as a consequence of
the injuries.
(v) Loss of amenities (and/or loss of prospects of marriage).
(vi) Loss of expectation of life (shortening of normal longevity).
In routine personal injury cases, compensation will be awarded only
under heads (i), (ii)(a) and (iv). It is only in serious cases of injury,
where there is specific medical evidence corroborating the evidence
of the claimant, that compensation will be granted under any of the
heads (ii)(b), (iii), (v) and (vi) relating to loss of future earnings on
account of permanent disability, future medical expenses, loss of
amenities (and/or loss of prospects of marriage) and loss of
expectation of life. Assessment of pecuniary damages under item (i)
and under item (ii)(a) do not pose much difficulty as they involve
reimbursement of actuals and are easily ascertainable from the
evidence. Award under the head of future medical expenses – item
(iii) — depends upon specific medical evidence regarding need for
further treatment and cost thereof. Assessment of non-pecuniary
damages – items (iv), (v) and (vi) — involves determination of lump
sum amounts with reference to circumstances such as age, nature of
injury/deprivation/disability suffered by the claimant and the effect
thereof on the future life of the claimant.”
The High Court, however, failed to determine just
compensation by undertaking such exercise.
9. We may, thus, determine the amount of just compensation to
which the appellant would be entitled. As per the Disability
Certificate placed on record by the appellant, it was opined that he
had suffered 50% permanent disability to his right leg. According
to the appellant, he was undertaking supply of milk by visiting
various places in the vicinity. From such activity, he was earning
an amount of ₹ 15,000/- per month. His age was stated to be
between 27 years to 30 years as per the medical documents
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 8 of 13
produced by him. The appellant, however, could not place on
record any evidence to indicate his monthly income. The Tribunal
considered a notional amount of ₹ 4,000/- per month as his
monthly income. The High Court, however, did not go into this
aspect. Since there is no evidence on record to indicate the
appellant’s monthly income, the monthly loss of income can be
determined by taking into consideration the minimum wages that
could be drawn by an unskilled worker as per the figures published
by the Office of the Labour Commissioner for the relevant period.
The accident in question having occurred on 24.04.2013, the
monthly minimum wages of an unskilled worker during that period
were ₹ 5,270/-. Taking this as the notional monthly income of the
appellant, his annual income would be ₹ 63,240/- ( ₹ 5,270×12). In
the light of the appellant’s age being taken as 30 years, a multiplier
of 17 would be required to be applied.
10. As noted above, the Disability Certificate issued to the
appellant indicates 50% permanent disability to his right leg. In
this regard, it would be necessary to bear in mind the effect of such
disability on the activities of the appellant. Since the appellant
claims to be engaged in the collection and sale of milk by travelling
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 9 of 13
from one place to another, his functional disability after the
accident would be required to be assessed. As a result of the
injuries suffered from the accident, the appellant’s mobility would
definitely be affected. Taking an overall view of the matter and in
the light of the activities undertaken by the appellant, we are of the
view that the appellant’s functional disability ought to be assessed
at 50%. In this regard, reference can be made to the decision of
this Court in Indra Bai vs. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
5
and Another . Accordingly, the net annual income of the appellant
would be ₹ 5,37,540/- ( ₹ 5270×12×17×50%).
11. As regards future prospects of the appellant, calculating the
same at 40% would give a figure of ₹ 2,15,016/-. In this regard, we
may refer to the decision in National Insurance Company
6
Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Others . Thus, the net income of
the appellant can be taken at ₹ 7,52,556/- ( ₹ 5,37,540/- +
₹ 2,15,016/-).
12. As a result of injuries sustained in the accident, the appellant
suffered loss of earnings. The same can be estimated as loss for a
5
2023 INSC 624
6
2017 INSC 1068
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 10 of 13
period of six months. This figure would come to ₹ 31,620/-
( ₹ 5,270×6). An amount of ₹1 5,930/- has been awarded for medical
expenses based on the receipts and vouchers produced by the
appellant. This figure does not deserve any further enhancement.
As regards the amount admissible towards special diet and
transportation of the appellant for the purposes of medical care, a
sum of ₹ 50,000/- can be awarded. A further amount of
₹ 1,00,000/- for the pain and suffering undergone by the appellant
would be admissible. Considering the nature of injuries suffered
by the appellant, he would require the help of an attendant so as
to assist him in his daily chores for some period. An amount of
₹2 5,000/- on this count is granted. After taking into consideration
the enhancement of ₹ 2,00,000/- granted by the High Court, the
appellant would be entitled to a total compensation of ₹ 11,75,106
in the following manner:
Sr. No. Particulars Just Compensation
1. Disability 50%
2. Multiplier 17
3. Monthly Income ₹ 5,270/-
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 11 of 13
4. Net Annual Income ₹ 5,37,540
[5270 x 12 x 17 x 50%]
₹
5. Future Prospects 2,15,016
[40% x 5,37,540]
Net Income ₹ 7,52,556/-
6. Loss of Earnings ₹ 31,620/-
[5270 x 6]
7. Medical Expense ₹ 15,930/-
8. Special Diet and
₹ 50,000/-
Transportation
9. Pain and Suffering ₹ 1,00,000/-
10. Atttendant Charges ₹ 25,000/-
11. Lumpsum Enhancement ₹ 2,00,000/-
Total Compensation ₹ 11,75,106/-
13. Interest @ 7% per annum was granted by the Tribunal on the
amount of compensation. The High Court has maintained the said
rate of interest. The same is found to be reasonable. It is to be
noted that on 26.04.2024, the High Court while restoring the
miscellaneous appeal preferred by the appellant, which had been
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 12 of 13
dismissed for non-compliance of earlier orders, had directed that
in case the amount of compensation was enhanced, the appellant
would not be entitled for interest on that amount for the period
from 29.04.2015 to 26.04.2024. That direction shall continue to
operate.
14. In the light of the aforesaid discussion, it is held that the
appellant is entitled to just compensation of ₹ 11,75,106/- with
interest @ 7% per annum from 28.06.2013 when the claim petition
was filed till realisation. Needless to state that interest is not liable
to be paid on the amount of enhanced compensation for the period
from 29.04.2015 to 26.04.2024. The judgment of the High Court
dated 01.09.2025 in Miscellaneous Appeal No.548 of 2014 stands
modified in the aforesaid terms. The Civil Appeal is, accordingly,
allowed and disposed of. Parties shall bear their own costs.
Pending Interlocutory Application is disposed of.
…...………………………..J.
[ UJJAL BHUYAN ]
.…..………………………..J.
[ATUL S. CHANDURKAR]
NEW DELHI,
NOVEMBER 20, 2026.
Civil Appeal No.13804 of 2026
Page 13 of 13