Evershine Builders Private Limited vs Hiren Jaswant Rajani

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM010370452026

2026:BHC-AS:45706
-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 11018 OF 2026

Evershine Builders Private Limited,
a private limited company incorporated
under the provisions of Companies Act, 1956
and having office at 215, Veena-Beena, Shopping
Centre, Opp Bandra Station, Bandra (W),
Mumbai 400 050. ...Petitioner
Versus
Hiren Jaswant Rajani,
Adult, Indian Inhabitant,
aged 69 years, residing at
Narlibaug, Killa Road, Vasai Road,
Vasai Gaon, Vasai (W), Taluka Vasai,
…Respondent
Dist: Palghar
Mr. Karl Tamboly, with Karan Bhide, Nitesh Ranavat (V.C.), Vedant
Joshi (V.C.) and Dhanashree, i/b Wadia Ghandy & Co, for the
Petitioner.
Ms. Aafreen S Shaikh, i/b Krupali H Rajani, for the Respondent.
ARUN
RAMCHANDRA
SANKPAL
Digitally signed
by ARUN
RAMCHANDRA
SANKPAL
Date: 2026.11.18
20:31:02 +0530
CORAM : N. J. JAMADAR, J.
th
RESERVED ON : 6 OCTOBER 2026
th
PRONOUNCED ON : 18 NOVEMBER 2026
JUDGMENT:
1.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith and, with the consent of
the learned Counsel for the parties, heard finally.
ARS
1/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC
2.
This Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India calls in

rd
question, the legality, propriety and correctness of an order dated 23
April 2026, passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Vasai, in
SCS No. 11 of 2010 whereby the following additional issue has been
framed:
“Whether the entire suit would abate as a whole in view of
abatement of the suit against the some of the defendants on the
ground that, the legal heirs and representatives of deceased
defendants are not brought on record?”
3.
Shorn of superfluities, the background facts can be stated as
under:
3.1 The petitioner-plaintiff instituted a suit for specific performance
of a contract to sell immovable properties bearing Survey No. 55A
(part), Survey No. 26 Hissa No. 1A, Survey No. 25 and Survey No. 58
Hissa No. A/1, admeasuring 47356.87 sq mtrs at village Malonde,
Taluka Vasai, District Thane (“the suit properties”). The plaintiff
asserted that, late Lalitaben Chabildas Rajani, the predecessor-in-title of
the defendants, was the holder of the suit properties. Post negotiation,
the predecessor-in-title of original defendant Nos. 1 to 9 and the
st
plaintiff entered into a Memorandum of Understanding on 1 June
1996, whereby and whereunder the predecessor-in-title of original
defendant Nos. 1 to 9 agreed to sell the suit properties on the terms and
conditions incorporated thereunder, for a consideration to be computed
ARS
2/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

@ Rs.75,000/- per guntha. The plaintiff claimed to have paid a sum of
Rs.24,21,000/- by way of earnest/part consideration.
th
3.2 The plaintiff further asserted that on 26 August 1997, late
Lalitaben alongwith original defendant Nos. 1, 2, 4, 5 and Mrs.
Sudhaben, wife of defendant No.3/1 and mother of defendant Nos. 3/2,
and late Jaswant Rajani, the father of defendant No. 6 to 9, executed an
Agreement for Sale in favour of the plaintiff. Under the said Agreement
for sale, the plaintiff claimed to have parted with further consideration
of Rs.24,21,000/-. Alleging refusal of performance of the contract
st
contained in the aforesaid MoU dated 1 June 1996 and the Agreement
th
for Sale dated 26 August 1997, the plaintiff instituted the suit for
specific performance of the said contract.
th
3.3 On 30 April 2012, the Consent Terms were purportedly executed
between the petitioner and original defendant Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to 9
and thus the dispute, according to the plaintiff, was settled qua
defendant Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to 9.
3.4 In accordance with the Consent Terms, the plaintiff asserts, the
original defendant Nos 1 to 5 and 7 to 9 executed three separate Deeds
st st th
of Conveyance dated 31 December 2011, 31 December 2011 and 25
July 2012, respectively, in respect of the said defendants’ 23/24th
undivided share out of the suit properties in favour of the plaintiff and
Green Court Associates.
ARS
3/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

3.5 The dispute, according to the plaintiff, thus survived qua original
defendant No.6-the respondent herein.
3.6 In the intervening period the original defendant No.2 passed
th
away on 6 February 2015. The legal representatives of the deceased-
defendant No.2 were not brought on record during the stipulated
period.
3.7 In the wake of the aforesaid development, it appears that three
applications, came to be filed. First, an application for dismissal of the
suit as abated (Exhibit “126”) preferred by defendant No.6; second, an
application to bring the legal representatives of the deceased defendant
No.2 on record (Exhibit “130”) and third, an application for an
amendment in the plaint to delete the defendant Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to 9,
and prosecute the suit qua defendant No. 6 only by incorporating the
necessary amendment in the plaint (Exhibit “136”).
th
3.8 By an order dated 14 July 2022, the application for dismissal of
the suit as having been abated (Exhibit “126”) was rejected by the
learned Civil Judge. After adverting to the settlement arrived at
between the parties and the execution of the Consent Terms and the
th
Conveyance Deed by the deceased-defendant No.2 on 25 July 2012,
during his lifetime by deceased defendant No.2, the learned Civil Judge
observed that when the deceased-defendant No.2 had performed his
part of the contract, during the lifetime, nothing remained to be
ARS
4/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

answered by the legal representatives of the deceased-defendant No.2
and, therefore, the suit could not be dismissed as having abated despite
the non-impleadment of the legal representatives of the deceased-
defendant No.2, within the stipulated period.
3.9 The application for amendment preferred by the plaintiff (Exhibit
“136”) was allowed by the learned Civil Judge, observing that the
amendment was necessary on account of the subsequent events that
occurred during the pendency of the suit; the plaintiff had no claim
against defendant Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to 9 and the surviving lis was only
between the plaintiff and defendant No. 6. It was noted that defendant
No.6 also instituted a suit, being RCS No. 597 of 2018, against the
plaintiff alone for the partition of the suit properties. It would be
necessary to immediately notice that the said order was not assailed by
defendant No.6. Accordingly, necessary amendment in the plaint has
been carried out to confine the suit to the extent of the share of
defendant No.6.
3.10 The second application preferred by the plaintiff to bring the legal
representatives of deceased-defendant No.2 on record, was also rejected
by the trial Court opining that, the plaintiff had filed an application
seeking an amendment in the plaint so as to delete the original
defendant Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to 9 and restrict the claim to the share of
defendant No. 6 only, and that defendant No. 2 had passed away after
ARS
5/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

the execution of the Conveyance Deed in favour of the plaintiff. No
purpose would be served in bringing the legal representatives of
deceased-defendant No.2 on record.
th
3.11 Defendant No. 6 challenged the order dated 14 July 2022,
whereby the application preferred by him for the dismissal of the suit as
abated came to be rejected, in revision before this Court.
th
3.12 By an order dated 26 November 2025 passed in Civil Revision
Application No. 619 of 2022, the said revision application, came to be
dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to file an application before the
trial Court for framing an additional issues as to whether the entire suit
would abate as a whole in view of the abatement of the suit against
some of the defendants on the ground that the legal representatives of
the deceased-defendant were not brought on record.
3.13 In the intervening period, original defendant No.1 passed away
rd
on 3 March 2022. The legal representatives of deceased-Defendant
No.1 were also not brought on record within the stipulated period of
limitation.
3.14 Availing the aforesaid liberty, defendant No. 6 preferred the
instant application (Exhibit 302) seeking framing of an additional issue
about the abatement of the suit as a whole. The substance of the
st
contention of defendant No. 6 was that the alleged MoU dated 1 June
th
1996 and Agreement for Sale dated 26 August 1997 were executed by
ARS
6/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

the owners as a single, independent and indivisible transaction in
respect of a single composite and undivided parcel of land and, thus,
the cause of action was one and indivisible. Therefore, as the suit
abated against defendant Nos. 1 and 2, on account of the failure to
bring their legal representatives within the stipulated period, the suit
abated as a whole, as it could not proceed against the surviving
defendants in the absence of the legal representatives of defendant Nos.
1 and 2.
3.15 The plaintiff resisted the application.
3.16 By the impugned order, the learned Civil Judge, was persuaded to
allow the application and frame the additional issue (extracted above).
The learned Civil Judge was of the view that in the backdrop of the
nature of the suit and the transactions that had taken place between the
parties, the additional issue was required to be framed in the interest of
justice and to decide the real controversy between the parties.
3.17 Being aggrieved, the plaintiff has preferred this petition.
3.18 An affidavit in reply has been filed on behalf of the respondent-
now the sole defendant, supporting the impugned order.
4.
I have heard Mr. Karl Tamboly, the learned Counsel for the
petitioner, and Ms. Aafreen Shaikh, the learned Counsel for the
respondent, at some length. With the assistance of the learned Counsel
ARS
7/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

for the parties, I have perused the pleadings, the documents and the
orders that have been passed.
5.
Mr. Karl Tamboly, the learned Counsel for the petitioner,
submitted that the impugned order is in teeth of the fundamental
principles which govern the framing of issues. The question as to
whether the suit would abate as a whole does not necessarily arise out
of the pleadings, as even after the amendment in the plaint the sole
defendant has not raised a contention by way of an additional written
statement that the suit stood abated as a whole.
6.
An issue cannot be framed on the basis of vague statements. To
buttress this submission, Mr. Tamboly, placed reliance on the judgments
1
of the Supreme Court in the cases of Sita Ram Vs Radhabai And Ors,
D. M. Deshpande and Ors Vs Janardhan Kashinath Kadam (Dead) by Lrs
2
and Ors, a decision of the learned Single Judge of this Court in Ramu
3
Shivappa Agalgave and Ors Vs Iaman Kashim Pathan and Ors and a
decision of the Karnataka High Court in Nagarathnamma W/o Late M
Ramaswamy And Daughter in law of Chikkalamma (URUF)
Muniyamma and Ors Vs Gorappa Alias Munivenkatappa S/o Late
4
Kundali Muniyapa and Ors.

1 1967 SCC OnLine SC 27.
2
(1998) 8 SCC 315.

3
1992 SCC OnLine Bom 1.
th

4
Writ Petition No. 47224 of 2016 (GM-CPC), decided on 13 March
2023.
ARS
8/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC
7.
Secondly, Mr. Tamboly would urge that, in the facts of the case at

hand, there was no question of abatement of the suit even qua
defendant Nos. 1 and 2, much less in its entirety. With the execution of
the Consent Terms and Conveyances by the rest of the defendants,
including deceased defendant Nos. 1 and 2, there was no subsisting
cause of action qua those defendants, and, therefore, by no stretch of
imagination could it be said that the right to sue survived against the
legal representative of those defendants. At any rate, Mr. Tamboly
would urge, the plaint came to be amended so as to confine the same to
the subsisting lis between the plaintiff and the sole defendant only. The
order passed by the trial Court permitting the amendment in the plaint
has attained finality. In this view of the matter, there was absolutely no
occasion or propriety in framing the issue of abatement of the suit as a
whole for the purported non-impleadment of the legal representatives
of the deceased defendant Nos. 1 and 2.
8.
Mr. Tamboly made a strenuous effort to drive home the point that
the order passed by this Court permitting withdrawal of the civil
revision application with liberty to file an application to frame an
additional issue could not have been construed as a permission to frame
the additional issue. The trial Court was enjoined to judiciously examine
whether the aforesaid issue really arose for consideration. As the trial
ARS
9/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

Court has failed to exercise the jurisdiction in consonance with the law,
the impugned order deserves to be quashed and set aside.
9.
Ms. Aafreen Shaikh, the learned Counsel for the respondent,
stoutly countered the submissions canvassed on behalf of the petitioner.
At the outset it was submitted that this Court in exercise of its limited
supervisory jurisdiction need not interfere with a procedural order. By
no standard can it be said that, the impugned order is perverse or
suffers from the vice of patent illegality. In the absence of an apparent
error of law which impairs justice, this Court may not exercise the writ
jurisdiction, submitted Ms Shaikh.
10.
Secondly, Ms. Shaikh urged with tenacity that the aforesaid
additional issue is indispensable to effectively and completely
adjudicate the suit. It was urged that, when admittedly interest of the
original defendants in the suit properties agreed to be sold was joint,
indivisible and undivided, the suit for specific performance cannot
proceed against a few of the co-owners, in the absence of the legal
representatives of the deceased-co-owners. An endeavour was made to
demonstrate that the cause of action was single and indivisible and,
thus, the contract cannot be enforced piecemeal or split up against the
individual co-owners. Resultantly, the failure to implead the legal
representatives of the deceased defendants, entails the consequence of
ARS
10/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

the abatement of the suit as a whole de hors the amendment in the
plaint.
11.
To buttress these submissions, Ms Shaikh placed very strong
reliance on the judgments of the Supreme Court in the cases of State of
5
Punjab Vs Nathu Ram, Sri Chand and Ors Vs M/s Jagdish Pershad
6
Kishan Chand and Ors and Union of India Vs Shree Ram Bohra and
7
Ors.
12.
Ms. Shaikh further submitted that it cannot be said that the lis
between the plaintiff and the deleted defendant Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to 9
has come to an end. The legality and validity of the purported Deeds of
Conveyance in favour of the plaintiff has been put in jeopardy by few of
those defendants by instituting suits and proceedings. Therefore, the
plaintiff cannot draw any mileage from the said fact.
13.
I have given anxious consideration to the submissions canvassed
across the bar. Before adverting to the aforesaid submissions, it is
necessary to keep in view the position of the suit as it obtains today. In
view of the order passed by the learned Civil Judge on the application
st
for amendment (Exhibit “136”) on 31 January 2023, original
defendant Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to 9 stand deleted and the suit is confined
to the share of the sole defendant (original defendant No.6) in the suit

5 AIR 1962 SC 89.
6
AIR 1966 SC 1427.
7
AIR 1965 SC 1531.
ARS
11/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

properties. Thus, only the petitioner and the respondent are the parties
to the suit. It is also not much in dispute that defendant Nos. 1 to 5 and
7 to 9 have executed the Deeds of Conveyance in respect of their
st
aggregate 23/24th share in the suit properties on 31 December 2011
th
and 25 July 2012.
14.
It would be contextually relevant to note that even if
subsequently disputes have arisen between the plaintiff and defendant
Nos.1 to 5 and 7 to 9 and the legality and validity of those Conveyances
is put in contest, that is of no relevance for the purpose of the
determination of the controversy at hand. It is also necessary to note
that defendant Nos. 1 and 2 passed away after the execution of those
Conveyances. Indubitably, no effort was made to bring the legal
rd
representatives of defendant No.1 who passed away on 3 March 2022
on record, whereas the application (Exhibit “130”) filed by the plaintiff
to bring the legal representatives of deceased defendant No.2, albeit
st
belatedly and under protest, came to be rejected by an order dated 31
January 2023.
15.
In the backdrop of the aforesaid facts, the justifiability of the
order framing the aforeextracted additional issue deserves to be
examined.
16.
To explore an answer, it is necessary to appreciate whether in the
facts of the case at hand, the suit would abate qua defendant Nos. 1 and
ARS
12/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

2 and, if yes, whether it would also abate as a whole, prima facie.
Evidently, the position would be governed by the provisions contained
in Order XXII Rule 4(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (“the
Code”). It provides that where one of two or more defendants dies and
the right to sue does not survive against the surviving defendant or
defendants alone, the Court, on an application made in that behalf,
shall cause the legal representative of the deceased defendant to be
made a party and shall proceed with the suit. Sub-Rule (3) of Order
XXII of the Code provides that where within the time limited by law no
application is made under sub-rule (1), the suit shall abate as against
the deceased defendant.
17.
Thus, ordinarily, if no application is made to bring the legal
representative of one of the defendants, who has passed away, the suit
abates primarily as against the deceased-defendant, and that it does not
abate necessarily as a whole. However, if the suit is of such a nature
that no relief can be granted against the surviving defendant in the
absence of the legal representatives of the deceased co-defendant, the
failure to bring the legal representatives within the stipulated period of
limitation may entail the consequence of the dismissal of the suit as a
whole.
18.
The crucial words in Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 4 are, “where …. the
right to sue does not survive against the surviving defendant or
ARS
13/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

defendants alone”. These words necessitate an inquiry as to whether the
right to sue survives and, if yes, against whom. The general principle of
law is that all rights of action and all demands whatsoever existing in
favour of or against a person at the time of his death survive to or
8
against his legal representative. (Sri Krishna Singh Vs Mathura Ahir).
19.
In the context of the controversy at hand, the first question that
warrants consideration is whether the right to sue survived against the
legal representatives of deceased defendant Nos. 1 and 2.
20.
The provisions contained in Section 306 of the Indian Succession
Act, 1925, provide a legitimate answer. It reads as under:
“306 Demands and rights of action of or against deceased
survive to and against executor or administrator.—
All demands whatsoever and all rights to prosecute or defend
any action or special proceeding existing in favour of or against a
person at the time of his decease, survive to and against his
executors or administrators; except causes of action for
defamation, assault, as defined in the Indian Penal Code, 1860
(45 of 1860) or other personal injuries not causing the death of
the party; and except also cases where, after the death of the
party, the relief sought could not be enjoyed or granting it would
be nugatory.”
21.
A plain reading of the aforesaid section would indicate that all
demands and rights existing in favour of or against a person at the time
of his decease, survive to and against his executors or administrators;

8
1981 (3) SCC 689.
ARS
14/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

except in cases of personal actions. Thus for the survival of the demands
and rights to and against the executors and legal representatives, the
primary condition is that, those demands and rights must exist in favour
of or against the person at the time of his demise. The right to sue,
therefore, cannot survive in the abstract. In a case where there were no
surviving demands and rights to prosecute or defend any action in
favour of or against a deceased-party, on the date of his demise, nothing
survives to and against the legal representatives. Thus the expression,
“where …. the right to sue does not survive against the surviving
defendant or defendants alone” assumes critical salience. To put it in
other words, if the right to sue does not survive against the legal
representative of the deceased-defendant, the provisions contained in
Rule (4) of Order XXII would not be attracted.
22.
Since the instant case arose out of a contractual obligation,
reference to the provisions contained in Section 37 of the Indian
Contract Act may also become relevant. The second part of Section 37
provides that, promises bind the representatives of the promisors in case
of the death of such promisors before performance, unless a contrary
intention appears from the contract.
23.
In the case at hand, the plaintiff asserts that in view of the
settlement arrived at between the parties, defendant Nos. 1 and 2 had
executed Deeds of Conveyance in respect of their respective shares
ARS
15/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

in the suit properties, and thereby performed their part of the contract
in that manner. The plaintiff has amended the plaint to incorporate all
those subsequent developments and confined the suit to the share of the
sole defendant.
24.
In the aforesaid view of the matter, in the considered view of this
Court, right to sue did not survive against the legal representative of
deceased defendant Nos. 1 and 2 and, thus, there was no question of
the abatement of the suit qua those defendant Nos.1 and 2.
25.
Ms. Shaikh would urge that, notwithstanding the amendment in
the plaint consequent to the execution of the Deeds of Conveyances by
the erstwhile co-defendant Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to 9, the failure to bring
the legal representatives of the deceased defendant nos. 1 and 2 entails
the dismissal of the suit as a whole as it cannot proceed against the sole
defendant.
26.
On first principles, since it appears that the suit would not abate
qua deceased defendant Nos. 1 and 2, the edifice of the submission that
the suit would abate as a whole, for the reason of abatement qua
defendant Nos. 1 and 2, gets dismantled. It is true that in a given case if
the right to sue does not survive against the surviving defendants alone
and the suit is of such a nature that no effective decree can be passed
against the surviving defendant alone, the suit may abate as a whole.
ARS
16/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

However, in a case of the present nature the aforesaid principle may not
be attracted.
27.
Neither there is prohibition in law to enter into a Agreement for
Sale of an undivided interest in the property, nor the Court is precluded
from passing a decree for specific performance of the contract, leaving
the purchaser to work out his remedies to seek partition of the
undivided share so purchased. Undoubtedly, it would be in the
discretion of the Court whether to pass a decree for specific
performance of the contract or not.
28.
The decision in the case of State of Punjab (Supra), on which
reliance was placed by Ms. Shaikh, considered the aspect as to whether
the appeal abates as a whole when the appeal abates against one of the
respondents. In the said case, the Supreme Court clarified that when
Order XXII Rule 4 does not provide for the abatement of the appeals
against the co-respondents of the deceased respondent, there can be no
question of abatement of the appeals against them. To say that, the
appeals against them abated in certain circumstances, is not a correct
statement. Of course, the appeals against them cannot proceed in
certain circumstances and have therefore to be dismissed. Such a result
depends on the nature of the relief sought in the appeal. The
observations of the Supreme Court in paragraphs 6, 7 and 8 read as
under:
ARS
17/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

“6. The question whether a Court can deal with such matters
or not, will depend on the facts of each case and therefore no
exhaustive statement can be made about the circumstances
when this is possible or is not possible. It may, however, be
stated that ordinarily the considerations which weigh with the
Court in deciding upon this question are whether the appeal
between the appellants and the respondents other than the
deceased can be said to be properly constituted or can be said to
have all the necessary parties for the decision of the controversy
before the Court. The test to determine this has been described
in diverse forms. Courts will not proceed with an appeal (s)
when the success of the appeal may lead to the Court's coming
to a decision which be in conflict with the decision between the
appellant and the deceased respondent and therefore which
would lead to the Court's passing a decree which will be
contradictory to the decree which had become final with respect
to the same subject matter between the appellant and the
deceased respondent; (b) when the appellant could not have
brought the action for the necessary relief against those
respondents alone who are still before the Court and (c) when
the decree against the surviving respondents, if the appeal
succeeds, be ineffective, that is to say, it could not be
successfully executed.
7. There has been no divergence between the Courts about
the Court's proceeding with the appeal between the respondents
other than the deceased respondent, when the decree in appeal
was not a joint decree in favour of all the respondents. The
abatement of the appeal against the deceased respondent, in
such a case, would make the decree in his favour alone final,
and this can, in no circumstances, have a repercussion, on the
decision of the controversy between the appellant and the other
ARS
18/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

decree- holders or on the execution of the ultimate decree
between them.
8. The difficulty arises always when there is a joint decree.
Here again, the consensus of opinion is that if the decree is joint
and indivisible, the appeal against the other respondents also
will not be proceeded with and will have to be dismissed as a
result of the abatement of the appeal against the deceased
respondent. Different views exist in the case of joint decrees in
favour of respondents whose rights in the subject matter of the
decree are specified. One view is that in such cases, the
abatement of the appeal against the deceased respondent will
have the result of making the decree affecting his specific
interest to be final and that the decree against the other
respondents can be suitably dealt with by the appellate Court.
We do not consider this view correct. The specification of shares
or of interest of the deceased respondent does not affect the
nature of the decree and the capacity of the joint decree- holder
to execute the entire decree or to resist the attempt of the other
party to interfere with the joint right decreed in his favour. The
abatement of an appeal means not only that the decree between
the appellant, and the deceased respondent has become final,
but also, as a necessary corollary, that the appellate Court
cannot, in any way, modify that decree directly or indirectly. The
reason is plain. It is that in the absence of the legal
representatives of the deceased respondents, the appellate Court
cannot determine anything between the appellant and the legal
representatives which may affect the rights of the legal
representatives under the decree. It is immaterial that the
modification which the Court will do is one to which exception
can or cannot be taken.”
ARS
19/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC
9
29.
In the case of Ram Sarup and Ors Vs Munshi and Ors a

Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court enunciated that where a
decree is a joint and part of the decree has become final, by reason of
abatement, the entire appeal must be held to be abated.
30.
The same principle was reiterated in Sri Chand and Ors (Supra).
It was enunciated that, an appellate Court has no power to proceed
with an appeal and to reverse and vary the decree in favour of all the
plaintiffs or defendants under Order XLI Rule 4 when the decree
proceeds on a ground common to all the plaintiffs or defendants, if all
the plaintiffs or the defendants appeal from the decree and any of them
dies and the appeal abates so far as he is concerned.
31.
In the case of Shahazada Bi And Ors Vs Halimabi (Since dead) by
10
her Lrs, on which reliance was placed by Mr. Tamboly, again in the
context of the abatement of an appeal as a whole on account of
abatement of an appeal against one of the co-respondents, the Supreme
Court enunciated that, the test often adopted in such cases was whether
in the event of the appeal being allowed as against the remaining
respondents there would or would not be two contradictory decrees in
the same suit with respect to the same subject matter.
32.
The aforesaid pronouncements were rendered in a completely
different fact-situation. A case of abatement of an appeal as a whole on
9
AIR 1963 SC 553.

10
(2004) 7 SCC 354.
ARS
20/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC

account of abatement of appeal against one of the parties thereto where
the adjudication of the appeal is fraught with the risk of conflicting
decrees, stands on a completely different footing than a suit where a co-
defendant enters into a settlement with the plaintiff and stands deleted
from the array of the defendants. The indivisibility of the initial cause of
action, does not preclude the Court from proceeding with the suit to the
extent the lis subsists with the surviving defendant. The Court may or
may not pass a decree in favour of the plaintiff. However, the question
of abatement of the suit as a whole may not arise if there was no
abatement in the first place against the co-defendants and the right to
sue did not survive against the legal representatives of the deceased co-
defendant.
33.
This Court was required to delve into the aforesaid aspect rather
elaborately for the reason that, this Court has passed a series of orders
stipulating a time-frame for the disposal of the suit. The framing of the
aforesaid additional issue would further unnecessarily expand the scope
of adjudication and warrant consideration of matters which are not
germane for the determination of the pivotal issue as to whether the
plaintiff is entitled to a decree for specific performance of the contract
qua the share of the sole defendant. At any rate, it must be noted that
the trial Court has also framed the issue of maintainability of the suit in
the present form.
ARS
21/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57

-WP-11018-2026-.DOC
34.
The upshot of the aforesaid consideration is that, the impugned

order of framing the afore-extracted additional issue cannot be
sustained. Hence, the petition deserves to be allowed.
35.
Hence, the following order:
: O R D E R :
(i) Petition stands allowed.
rd
(ii) Impugned order dated 23 April 2026 stands
quashed and set aside.
(iii) The afore-extracted additional issue stands
deleted.
(iv) The trial Court is requested to hear and decide
the suit as expeditiously as possible in conformity with the
directions already issued by this Court.
(v) Rule made absolute to the aforesaid extent.
No costs.
[N. J. JAMADAR, J.]
ARS
22/22
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 20:50:57
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)