Supreme Petrochem Ltd. vs Union Of India And Anr.
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Judgment reserved on: 14.08.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 17.11.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 17.11.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010338782020
+ W.P.(C) 10289/2020
SUPREME PETROCHEM LTD. .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ramesh Singh, Sr. Adv.
along with Mr. Jitender Singh
and Mr. Anshumaan Sahni,
Adv.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Ms. Nidhi Raman, CGSC with
Mr. Anurag Ojha, SSC, Mr.
Dipak Raj, Mr. Aryaman Singh
Chouhan and Mr. Aditya
Chaudhary, Advs.
# CNR No. DLHC010454872022
+ W.P.(C) 16640/2022
CARBORUNDUM UNIVERSAL LIMITED .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ramesh Singh, Sr. Adv.
along with Mr. Jitender Singh
and Mr. Anshumaan Sahni,
Adv.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anurag Ojha, SSC along
with Mr. Dipak Raj, Mr.
Aryaman Singh Chouhan and
Mr. Aditya Chaudhary, Advs.
# CNR No. DLHC010455222022
+ W.P.(C) 16647/2022
GRINDWELL NORTON LIMITED .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ramesh Singh, Sr. Adv.
along with Mr. Jitender Singh
and Mr. Anshumaan Sahni,
Adv.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 1 of 40
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anurag Ojha, SSC along
with Mr. Dipak Raj, Mr.
Aryaman Singh Chouhan and
Mr. Aditya Chaudhary, Advs.
# CNR No. DLHC010474552022
+ W.P.(C) 17186/2022
ASAHI INDIA GLASS LIMITED .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ramesh Singh, Sr. Adv.
along with Mr. Jitender Singh
and Mr. Anshumaan Sahni,
Adv.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anurag Ojha, SSC along
with Mr. Dipak Raj, Mr.
Aryaman Singh Chouhan and
Mr. Aditya Chaudhary, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
J U D G M E N T
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
W.P.(C) 10289/2020
1. The present Petition has been filed by a domestic producer,
challenging the constitutional validity of Section 9A (1) of the
1
Customs Tariff Act, 1975 read with Rule 18 of the Customs Tariff
(Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on
2
Dumped Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995
1
hereinafter referred to as ‗Act of 1975‘
2
hereinafter referred to as ‗Rules of 1995‘
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 2 of 40
[hereinafter referred collectively as ‗impugned provisions‘], on
account of the provisions being ultra vires Article 14 of the
Constitution. The challenge raised by the Petitioner is founded upon
the premise that the impugned provisions confer upon the Respondent
No.1/Central Government (CG) an unfettered, unguided and excessive
discretion.
2. Briefly stated, the Petitioner herein is one among a number of
3
domestic producers engaged in the manufacture of Polystyrene who
approached Respondent No.2/Designated Authority (DA), seeking
imposition of Anti-Dumping Duty (ADD) on imports of the subject
goods, originating in or exported from Iran, Malaysia, Singapore,
Chinese Taipei, UAE and USA.
3. The Respondent No.2, upon conducting an investigation came
4
to conclusion on 12.06.2020 , recording a positive determination of
definitive ADD on the subject goods from subject countries, on the
country and producer wise basis in terms of provisions contained in
Rule 17(1)(b) read with Rule 4(d) of the Rules of 1995. Contrary to
the said recommendation made by Respondent No.2, the Central
Government (CG), by way of its Office Memorandum (OM) dated
5
11.11.2020 , chose not to impose any ADD on the said goods.
4. Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioner has approached this Court
invoking its extra-ordinary jurisdiction, praying for the following
reliefs:
“In view of the above facts and circumstances, the Petitioner most
3
hereinafter referred to as ‗subject good‘
4
hereinafter referred to as ‘Final Finding‘
5
hereinafter referred to as ‗Impugned OM‘
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 3 of 40
respectfully prays that this Hon’ble Court may be pleased to:
(a) Declare that Section 9(A)(1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 and
Rule 18 of the Anti-dumping Rules are ultra vires Article 14 of the
Constitution of India as much as the same grant an unlimited,
unguided and unhinged discretion to Respondent No.1; and/or
(b) Issue a Writ, Order or Direction in the nature of Certiorari,
thereby quashing the O.MF No. 354/88/2020-TRU dated 11.11.2020
issued by Respondent No. 1 and any other order/decision taken by
Respondent No.1, thereby deciding not to implement the
recommendations of Respondent No.2, imposing the anti-dumping
duties, prescribed vide Final Findings No. F.No. 6/10/2019 dated
12.06.2020; and/or
(c) Grant a writ of mandamus or any other writ or order or direction
in the nature thereof directing Respondent No. 1 to implement the
recommendations of Respondent No.2 imposing the anti-dumping
duties prescribed through Final Findings No. F.No. 6/10/2019 dated
12.06.2020; and/or
(d) Pass such other and further orders as this Hon’ble Court may
deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case. ”
5. This Court has heard learned counsel representing the parties at
length and with their able assistance perused the paper book.
6. Before proceeding to examine the arguments advanced by the
parties, we deem it apposite to reproduce the relevant statutory
provisions relied upon during the course of submissions, which are as
follows:
Constitution of India
51. Promotion of international peace and security.— The State shall
endeavour to—
(c) foster respect for international law and treaty obligations in the
dealings of organized peoples with one another:
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
246. Subject-matter of laws made by Parliament and by the
Legislatures of States. —(1) Notwithstanding anything in clauses (2)
and (3), Parliament has exclusive power to make laws with respect to
any of the matters enumerated in List I in the Seventh Schedule (in
this Constitution referred to as the ―Union List‖).
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 4 of 40
(2) Notwithstanding anything in clause (3), Parliament, and, subject to
clause (1), the Legislature of any State also, have power to make laws
with respect to any of the matters enumerated in List III in the Seventh
Schedule (in this Constitution referred to as the ―Concurrent List‖).
(3) Subject to clauses (1) and (2), the Legislature of any State has
exclusive power to make laws for such State or any part thereof with
respect to any of the matters enumerated in List II in the Seventh
Schedule (in this Constitution referred to as the ―State List‖).
(4) Parliament has power to make laws with respect to any matter for
any part of the territory of India not included 2 [in a State]
notwithstanding that such matter is a matter enumerated in the State
List.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
265. Taxes not to be imposed save by authority of law.— No tax
shall be levied or collected except by authority of law.
SEVENTH SCHEDULE
List I—Union List
13. Participation in international conferences, associations and other
bodies and implementing of decisions made thereat.
14. Entering into treaties and agreements with foreign countries and
implementing of treaties, agreements and conventions with foreign
countries.
Act of 1975
9A. Anti-dumping duty on dumped articles. —(1) Where [any
article is exported by an exporter or producer] from any country or
territory (hereinafter in this section referred to as the exporting
country or territory) to India at less than its normal value, then, upon
the importation of such article into India, the Central Government
may, by notification in the Official Gazette, impose an anti-dumping
duty not exceeding the margin of dumping in relation to such article.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this section,—
(a) ―margin of dumping‖, in relation to an article, means the
difference between its export price and its normal value;
(b) ―export price‖, in relation to an article, means the price of the
article exported from the exporting country or territory and in cases
where there is no export price or where the export price is unreliable
because of association or a compensatory arrangement between the
exporter and the importer or a third party, the export price may be
constructed on the basis of the price at which the imported articles
are first resold to an independent buyer or if the article is not resold
to an independent buyer, or not resold in the condition as imported,
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 5 of 40
on such reasonable basis as may be determined in accordance with
the rules made under sub-section (6);
(c) ―normal value‖, in relation to an article, means—
(i) the comparable price, in the ordinary course of trade, for the like
article when [destined for consumption] in the exporting country or
territory as determined in accordance with the rules made under
sub-section (6); or
(ii) when there are no sales of the like article in the ordinary course
of trade in the domestic market of the exporting country or
territory, or when because of the particular market situation or low
volume of the sales in the domestic market of the exporting country
or territory, such sales do not permit a proper comparison, the
normal value shall be either-
(a) comparable representative price of the like article when
exported from the exporting country or [territory to] an appropriate
third country as determined in accordance with the rules made
under sub-section (6); or
(b) the cost of production of the said article in the country of origin
along with reasonable addition for administrative, selling and
general costs, and for profits, as determined in accordance with the
rules made under sub-section (6):
Provided that in the case of import of the article from a country other
than the country of origin and where the article has been merely
transhipped through the country of export or such article is not
produced in the country of export or there is no comparable price in
the country of export, the normal value shall be determined with
reference to its price in the country of origin.
[(1A) Where the Central Government, on such inquiry as it may
consider necessary, is of the opinion that circumvention of anti-
dumping duty imposed under sub-section (1) has taken place, either
by altering the description or name or composition of the article
subject to such anti-dumping duty or by import of such article in an
unassembled or disassembled form or by changing the country of its
origin or export or in any other manner, whereby the antidumping
duty so imposed is rendered ineffective, it may extend the anti-
dumping duty to such article or an article originating in or exported
from such country, as the case may be [from such date, not earlier
than the date of initiation of the inquiry, as the Central Government
may, by notification in the Official Gazette, specify].]
[(1B) Where the Central Government, on such inquiry as it may
consider necessary, is of the opinion that absorption of anti-dumping
duty imposed under sub-section (1) has taken place whereby the anti-
dumping duty so imposed is rendered ineffective, it may modify such
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 6 of 40
duty to counter the effect of such absorption, from such date, not
earlier than the date of initiation of the inquiry, as the Central
Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, specify.
Explanation. For the purposes of this sub-section, "absorption of anti-
dumping duty" is said to have taken place,-
(a) if there is a decrease in the export price of an article without any
commensurate change in the cost of production of such article or
export price of such article to countries other than India or resale
price in India of such article imported from the exporting country
or territory; or
(b) under such other circumstances as may be provided by rules.]
(2) The Central Government may, pending the determination in
accordance with the provisions of this section and the rules made
thereunder of the normal value and the margin of dumping in relation
to any article, impose on the importation of such article into India an
anti-dumping duty on the basis of a provisional estimate of such value
and margin and if such anti-dumping duty exceeds the margin as so
determined:—
(a) the Central Government shall, having regard to such
determination and as soon as may be after such determination,
reduce such anti-dumping duty; and
(b) refund shall be made of so much of the anti-dumping duty which
has been collected as is in excess of the anti-dumping duty as so
reduced. 1 Provided that if the Central Government, in a review, is of
the opinion that the cessation of such duty is likely to lead to
continuation or recurrence of dumping and injury, it may, from time
to time, extend the
[(2A) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1) and sub-
section (2), a notification issued under sub-section (1) or any anti-
dumping duty imposed under sub-section (2)shall not apply to articles
imported by a hundred per cent. export-oriented undertaking or a unit
in a special economic zone,unless,—
(i) it is specifically made applicable in such notification or to such
undertaking or unit; or
(ii) such article is either cleared as such into the domestic tariff area or
used in the manufacture of any goods that are cleared into the
domestic tariff area, in which case, anti-dumping duty shall be
imposed on that portion of the article so cleared or used, as was
applicable when it was imported into India.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this section,—]
(a) the expression ―hundred per cent. export-oriented undertaking‖
shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in clause (i) of
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 7 of 40
Explanation 2 to sub-section (1) of section 3 of the Central Exise
Act, 1944 (1 of 1944);
(b) the expression ―special economic zone‖ shall have the same
meaning as assigned to it in clause (za) of section 2 of the Special
Economic Zones Act, 2005 (28 of 2005);]
(3) If the Central Government, in respect of the dumped article under
inquiry, is of the opinion that—
(i) there is a history of dumping which caused injury or that the
importer was, or should have been, aware that the exporter practices
dumping and that such dumping would cause injury; and
(ii) the injury is caused by massive dumping of an article imported in
a relatively short time which in the light of the timing and the
volume of imported article dumped and other circumstances is likely
to seriously undermine the remedial effect of the antidumping duty
liable to be levied,
the Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette,
levy anti-dumping duty retrospectively from a date prior to the date of
imposition of anti-dumping duty under sub-section (2) but not beyond
ninety days from the date of notification under that sub-section, and
notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in
force, such duty shall be payable at such rate and from such date as
may be specified in the notification.
(4) The anti-dumping duty chargeable under this section shall be in
addition to any other duty imposed under this Act or any other law for
the time being in force.
(5) The anti-dumping duty imposed under this section shall, unless
revoked earlier, cease to have effect on the expiry of five years from
the date of such imposition:
Provided that if the Central Government, in a review, is of the
opinion that the cessation of such duty is likely to lead to
continuation or recurrence of dumping and injury, it may, from time
to time, extend the period of such imposition for a further period [up
to five years] and such further period shall commence from the date
of order of such extension:
Provided further that where a review initiated before the expiry of
the aforesaid period of five years has not come to a conclusion
before such expiry, the anti-dumping duty may continue to remain in
force pending the outcome of such a review for a further period not
exceeding one year.
[Provided also that if the said duty is revoked temporarily, the period
of such revocation shall not exceed one year at a time.]
(6) The margin of dumping as referred to in sub-section (1) or sub-
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 8 of 40
section (2) shall, from time to time, be ascertained and determined by
the Central Government, after such inquiry as it may consider
necessary and the Central Government may, by notification in the
Official Gazette, make rules for the purposes of this section, and
without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, such rules may
provide for the manner in which articles liable for any anti-dumping
duty under this section may be identified, and for the manner in which
the export price and the normal value of, and the margin of dumping
in relation to, such articles may be determined and for the assessment
and collection of such anti-dumping duty.
[(6A) The margin of dumping in relation to an article, exported by an
exporter or producer, under inquiry under sub-section (6) shall be
determined on the basis of records concerning normal value and
export price maintained, and information provided, by such exporter
or producer: Provided that where an exporter or producer fails to
provide such records or information, the margin of dumping for such
exporter or producer shall be determined on the basis of facts
available.]
(7) Every notification issued under this section shall, as soon as may
be after it is issued, be laid before each House of Parliament.
[(8) The provisions of the Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962) and the
rules and regulations made thereunder, including those relating to the
date for determination of rate of duty, assessment, non-levy, short
levy, refunds, interest, appeals, offences and penalties shall, as far as
may be, apply to the duty chargeable under this section as they apply
in relation to duties leviable under that Act.]
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
9C. Appeal . [(1) An appeal against the order of determination or
review thereof shall lie to the Customs, Excise and Service Tax
Appellate Tribunal constituted under section 129 of the Customs Act,
1962 (52 of 1962) (hereinafter referred to as the Appellate Tribunal),
in respect of the existence, degree and effect of-
(i) any subsidy or dumping in relation to import of any article; or
(ii) import of any article into India in such increased quantities and
under such condition so as to cause or threatening to cause serious
injury to domestic industry requiring imposition of safeguard duty in
relation to import of that article.]
[(14) An appeal under sub-section (1) shall be accompanied by a fee
of fifteen thousand rupees.
(IB) Every application made before the Appellate Tribunal,-
(a) in an appeal under sub-section (1), for grant of stay or for
rectification of mistake or for any other purpose; or
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 9 of 40
(b) for restoration of an appeal or an application, shall be accompanied
by a fee of five hundred rupees.]
(2) Every appeal under this section shall be filed within ninety days of
the date of order under appeal: Provided that the Appellate Tribunal
may entertain any appeal after the expiry of the said period of ninety
days, if it is satisfied that the appellant was prevented by sufficient
cause from filing the appeal in time.
(3) The Appellate Tribunal may, after giving the parties to the appeal,
an opportunity of being heard, pass such orders thereon as it thinks fit,
confirming, modifying or annulling the order appealed against.
(4) The provisions of sub-sections (1), (2), (5) and (6) of section 129C
of the Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962) shall apply to the Appellate
Tribunal in the discharge of its functions under this Act as they apply
to it in the discharge of its functions under the Customs Act, 1962 (52
of 1962).
(5) Every appeal under sub-section (1) shall be heard by a Special
Bench constituted by the President of the Appellate Tribunal for
hearing such appeals and such Bench shall consist of the President and
not less than two members and shall include one judicial member and
one technical member.]
Agreement on implementation of Article VI of the General
Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, 1994 (Agreement of 1994)
Article 6
Evidence
6.2 Throughout the anti-dumping investigation all interested parties
shall have a full opportunity for the defence of their interests. To this
end, the authorities shall, on request, provide opportunities for all
interested parties to meet those parties with adverse interests, so that
opposing views may be presented and rebuttal arguments offered.
Provision of such opportunities must take account of the need to
preserve confidentiality and of the convenience to the parties. There
shall be no obligation on any party to attend a meeting, and failure to
do so shall not be prejudicial to that party's case. Interested parties
shall also have the right, on justification, to present other information
orally.
9. The provisions of this Article are not intended to prevent the
authorities of a Party from proceeding expeditiously with regard to
initiating an investigation, reaching preliminary or final findings
whether affirmative or negative, or from applying provisional or final
measures, in accordance with the relevant provisions of this Code.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 10 of 40
Article 9
Imposition and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duties
9.1 The decision whether or not to impose an anti-dumping duty in
cases where all requirements for the imposition have been fulfilled,
and the decision whether the amount of the anti-dumping duty to be
imposed shall be the full margin of dumping or less, are decisions to
be made by the authorities of the importing Member. It is desirable
that the imposition be permissive in the territory of all Members, and
that the duty be less than the margin if such lesser duty would be
adequate to remove the injury to the domestic industry.
9.5 If a product is subject to anti-dumping duties in an importing
Member, the authorities shall promptly carry out a review for the
purpose of determining individual margins of dumping for any
exporters or producers in the exporting country in question who have
not exported the product to the importing Member during the period
of investigation, provided that these exporters or producers can show
that they are not related to any of the exporters or producers in the
exporting country who are subject to the anti-dumping duties on the
product. Such a review shall be initiated and carried out on an
accelerated basis, compared to normal duty assessment and review
proceedings in the importing Member. No anti-dumping duties shall
be levied on imports from such exporters or producers while the
review is being carried out. The authorities may, however, withhold
appraisement and/or request guarantees to ensure that, should such a
review result in a determination of dumping in respect of such
producers or exporters, anti-dumping duties can be levied
retroactively to the date of the initiation of the review.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
Article 12
Public Notice and Explanation of Determinations
12.2 Public notice shall be given of any preliminary or final
determination, whether affirmative or negative, of any decision to
accept an undertaking pursuant to Article 8, of the termination of such
an undertaking, and of the termination of a definitive anti-dumping
duty. Each such notice shall set forth, or otherwise make available
through a separate report, in sufficient detail the findings and
conclusions reached on all issues of fact and law considered material
by the investigating authorities. All such notices and reports shall be
forwarded to the Member or Members the products of which are
subject to such determination or undertaking and to other interested
parties known to have an interest therein.
Rules of 1995
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 11 of 40
4. Duties of the designated authority.-
(1) It shall be the duty of the designated authority in accordance with
these rules –
(d) to recommend to the Central Government -
(i) the amount of anti-dumping duty equal to the margin of dumping
or less, which if levied, would remove the injury to the domestic
industry, after considering the principles laid down in the Annexure
III to these rules; and
(ii) the date of commencement of such duty;
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
6. Principles governing investigations.-
(6) The designated authority may allow an interested party or its
representative to present the information relevant to the investigation
orally but such oral information shall be taken into consideration by
the designated authority only when it is subsequently reproduced in
writing.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
16. Disclosure of information.-
The designated authority shall, before giving its final findings, inform
all interested parties of the essential facts under consideration which
form the basis for its decision.
17. Final findings.-
(1) The designated authority shall, within one year from the date of
initiation of an investigation, determine as to whether or not the article
under investigation is being dumped in India and submit to the Central
Government its final finding-
(a) as to, -
(i) the export price, normal value and the margin of dumping of
the said article;
(ii) whether import of the said article into India, in the case of
imports from specified countries, causes or threatens material
injury to any industry established in India or materially retards the
establishment of any industry in India;
(iii) a causal link, where applicable, between the dumped imports
and injury;
(iv) whether a retrospective levy is called for and if so, the
reasons therefor and date of commencement of such retrospective
levy:
Provided that the Central Government may, in its discretion in
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 12 of 40
special circumstances extend further the aforesaid period of one year
by six months:
Provided further that in those cases where the designated authority
has suspended the investigation on the acceptance of a price
undertaking as provided in rule 15 and subsequently resumes the
same on violation of the terms of the said undertaking, the period for
which investigation was kept under suspension shall not be taken
into account while calculating the period of said one year,
(b) Recommending the amount of duty which, if levied, would
remove the injury where applicable, to the domestic industry after
considering the principles laid down in the Annexure III to rules.
(2) The final finding, if affirmative, shall contain all information on
the matter of facts and law and reasons which have led to the
conclusion and shall also contain information regarding-
(i) the names of the suppliers, or when this is impracticable, the
supplying countries involved;
(ii) a description of the product which is sufficient for customs
purposes;
(iii) the margins of dumping established and a full explanation of
the reasons for the methodology used in the establishment and
comparison of the export price and the normal value;
(iv) Considerations relevant to the injury determination; and
(v) the main reasons leading to the determination.
(3) The designated authority shall determine an individual margin of
dumping for each known exporter or producer concerned of the article
under investigation:
Provided that in cases where the number of exporters, producers,
importers or types of articles involved are so large as to make such
determination impracticable, it may limit its findings either to a
reasonable number of interested parties or articles by using
statistically valid samples based on information available at the
time of selection, or to the largest percentage of the volume of the
exports from the country in question which can reasonably be
investigated, and any selection, of exporters, producers, or types of
articles, made under this proviso shall preferably be made in
consultation with and with the consent of the exporters, producers
or importers concerned:
Provided further that the designated authority shall, determine an
individual margin of dumping for any exporter or producer, though
not selected initially, who submit necessary information in time,
except where the number of exporters or producers are so large that
individual examination would be unduly burdensome and prevent
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 13 of 40
the timely completion of the investigation.
(4) The designated authority shall issue a public notice recording its
final findings.
18. Levy of duty.-
(1) The Central Government may, within three months of the date of
publication of final findings by the designated authority under rule 17,
impose by notification in the Official Gazette, upon importation into
India of the article covered by the final finding, anti-dumping duty not
exceeding the margin of dumping as determined under rule 17.
(2) In cases where the designated authority has selected percentage of
the volume of the exports from a particular country, as referred to sub-
rule (3) of rule 17, any anti-dumping duty applied to imports from
exporters or producers not included in the examination shall not
exceed -
(i) the weighted average margin of dumping established with
respect to the selected exporters or producers or,
(ii) where the liability for payment of anti-dumping duties is
calculated on the basis of a prospective normal value/ the
difference between the weighted average normal value of the
selected exporters or producers and the export prices of exporters
or producers not individually examined:
Provided that the Central Government shall disregard for the purpose
of this sub-rule any zero margin, margins which are less than 2 per
cent expressed as the percentage of export price and margins
established in the circumstances detailed in sub-rule (8) of rule 6.
The Central Government shall apply individual duties to imports
from any exporter or producer not included in the examination who
has provided the necessary information during the course of the
investigation as referred to in the second proviso to sub-rule (3) of
rule 17.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1), where a
domestic industry has been interpreted according to the proviso to
sub-clause (b) of rule 2, a duty shall be levied only after the exporters
have been given opportunity to cease exporting at dumped prices to
the area concerned or otherwise give an undertaking pursuant to rule
15 and such undertaking has not been promptly given and in such
cases duty shall not be levied only on the articles of specific producers
which supply the area in question.
(4) If the final finding of the designated authority is negative that is
contrary to the evidence on whose basis the investigation was
initiated, the Central Government shall, within forty-five days of the
publication of final findings by the designated authority under rule 17,
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 14 of 40
withdraw the provisional duty imposed, if any.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
20. Commencement of duty.-
(1) The anti-dumping duty levied under rule 13 and rule 19 shall take
effect from the date of its publication in the Official Gazette.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1) -
(a) where a provisional duty has been levied and where the
designated authority has recorded a final finding of injury or where
the designated authority has recorded a final finding of threat of
injury and a further finding that the effect of dumped imports in the
absence of provisional duty would have led to injury, the anti-
dumping duty may be levied from the date of imposition of
provisional duty;
(b) in the circumstances referred to in sub-section (3) of section 9A
of the Act, the antidumping duty may be levied retrospectively
from the date commencing ninety days prior to the imposition of
such provisional duty:
Provided that no duty shall be levied retrospectively on imports
entered for home consumption before initiation of the investigation:
Provided further that in the cases of violation of price undertaking
referred to in sub-rule (6) of rule 15, no duty shall be levied
retrospectively on the imports which have entered for home
consumption before the violation of the terms of such undertaking.
Provided also that notwithstanding anything contained in the
foregoing proviso, in case of violation of such undertaking, the
provisional duty shall be deemed to have been levied from the date of
violation of the undertaking or such date as the Central Government
may specify in each case.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER:
7. Learned senior counsel representing the Petitioner has made his
submissions under two distinct heads, which are as follows:
a. challenge to the vires of Rule 4(1)(d) read with Rules 17
and 18(1) of Rules of 1995 (Impugned Rules);
b. challenge to issuance of OM dated 11.11.2020 by
Respondent No.2.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 15 of 40
a. Challenge to the vires of Rule 4(1)(d) read with Rules 17 and
18(1) of the Rules of 1995
8. While raising the challenge against the Impugned Rules, the
following submissions have been made:
8.1 It has been argued that the Impugned Rules supplant the
scheme of Section 9A of the Act of 1975, which when construed in
light of Articles 9.1 and 9.5 of the Agreement of 1994,
contemplates a single, integrated exercise culminating in the
determination and imposition of ADD, and does not provide for a
bifurcated, two-tier structure of recommendation by respondent
No.2, followed by an independent acceptance or rejection by the
CG. In this regard, it is contended that the Respondent No.2, acts on
behalf of the CG and not as an independent agency.
8.2 Further, it has been contended that the Impugned Rules
provide for a unilateral decision-making process, and since the
exercise undertaken by the CG is quasi-judicial in nature and not
legislative, the Impugned OM is subject to the principles of natural
justice and Article 14 of the Constitution. Reference in this regard
has been made to Automative Tyres Manufacturers’ Association v
6
Designated Authority and Reliance Industries v Designated
7
Authority .
8.3 It is argued that the exercise undertaken by the CG is
violative of following principles, namely, ‗ the person who hears
must decide ‘ and ‗ the grant of an effective opportunity of hearing ‘
6
(2011) 2 SCC 258
7
(2006) 10 SCC 368
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 16 of 40
before the final determination. According to the Petitioner, the
aforestated principles, stand reinforced by Articles 6.2, 6.9 and 12.2
of the Agreement of 1994 and Rules 6(6) and 16 of the Rules of
1995, which contemplate oral hearing, exchange of submissions,
disclosure of essential facts and a reasoned statement of findings
and conclusions. On this premise, it has been contended that the
exercise undertaken by CG stands in violation of the treaty
obligations under the World Trade Organization (WTO).
8.4 It has further been contended that, read as a whole, Rule
17 of Rules of 1995, only deals with the recommendatory power
envisaged upon the Respondent No.2, while the final determination
rests with the CG through the requisite Gazette Notification.
Reliance in this regard has been placed upon Saurashtra Chemicals
8
Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. .
b. Challenge to issuance of OM dated 11.11.2020 by Respondent
No.2
9. While raising specific challenge against the Impugned OM, the
following submissions have been made:
9.1 It is contended that the Impugned OM effectively defeats
the Petitioner‘s statutory right of appeal under Section 9C of the
Act of 1975, which lies against the final determination of the CG.
Reference in this regard has been made to the Order of Supreme
Court in Saurashtra Chemicals Ltd. (Supra).
9.2 It is argued that the decision of the CG to not impose
8
(2009) 17 SCC 529
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 17 of 40
ADD, is premised on decline of sufficiency of production of subject
goods, owing to closure of one of the three production companies
dealing with the production of the said goods, thereby affecting the
demand and supply ratio. It is contended that the aforesaid aspect
has already been considered by the Respondent No.2, post which
the recommendation came to be effectuated and as such the reason
of public interest cited by the CG for non-imposition of ADD, is
based on the absence of any material produced thereof. Reference
in this regard has been made to Dai-Ichi Karkaria Ltd. v Union of
9
India and Ors. .
9.3 Against this backdrop, it has been the case of the
Petitioner that although recommendations made by the Respondent
No.2, are not binding upon the CG, yet the latter cannot second
guess such recommendations particularly when the same were
issued on the basis of various factual issues considered thereof.
9.4 Replying to the objection raised by the CG with respect
to the scope of the present Petition, inasmuch as the issuance of
impugned OM is a legislative function, it has been argued that such
exercise in not legislative in nature. According to the Petitioner,
ADD is neither a tax nor a fiscal levy within the meaning of Article
265 of the Constitution, but a financial barrier under the WTO
regime.
9.5 Further, its imposition is argued to be culmination of a
quasi-judicial process undertaken by the Respondent No.2 and
9
(2000) 4 SCC 57
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 18 of 40
acted upon by the CG, with the Gazette Notification serving only as
the instrument of implementation. Reliance has been placed upon
Director General of Trade Remedies & Anr. v. Jindal Saw Ltd. &
10
Anr. , the WTO Panel Report dated 06.11.2018, and Articles 51(c)
and 253 of the Constitution read with Entries 13 and 14 of List I.
9.6 In the alternative, it has been argued that, even assuming
the Impugned OM to be legislative, the same would remain
amenable to judicial review on grounds applicable to administrative
action, the power being exercised pursuant to statutory discretion.
Reliance has been placed upon Indian Express Newspapers
(Bombay) Ltd. v. Union of India and Bennett Coleman & Co. v.
11
Union of India .
10. Per contra , learned counsel representing the Respondents, has
made the following submissions:
10.1 Controverting the arguments raised in respect of scheme
of Section 9A of the Act of 1975, it has been argued that the said
provision is consistent with Article 9.1 of the Agreement of 1994,
which gives the importing Member‘s Authorities, a discretion to
either impose or not impose ADD even where all requirements are
fulfilled and records only that permissive imposition is desirable
and not obligatory. Reliance is placed on C ommr. of Customs v.
12 13
G.M. Exports , and Union of India v. Agricas LLP and Ors. .
10
2022:DGC:2782:DB
11
(1985) 1 SCC 641
12
(2016) 1 SCC 91
13
2020 SCC OnLine SC 675
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 19 of 40
10.2 On the aforesaid premise, it has been argued that the two-
step mechanism adopted thereof, which includes an investigation by
the CG under Rules 6, 7, 16 and 17 of the Rule of 1975, followed
by discretion of CG exercised under Impugned Provisions, does not
derogate from treaty obligations, since Article 9.1 of the Agreement
itself vests the ultimate call on the importing Member‘s authorities,
of which the Respondent No.2 and the CG are integral, harmonious
parts.
10.3 Reference in this regard has been made to the judgment
14
in S&S Enterprise v. Designated Authority and Ors. and
Reliance Industries Ltd. (Supra) , to argue that the purpose of
Section 9A of the Act of 1975 is to remedy unfair trade and
maintain a level playing field, not blanket protectionism, a purpose
presupposing a discretion to weigh domestic-industry interest
against the wider public interest.
10.4 The aforestated discretion is argued to be guided and not
unstructured, inasmuch as it is anchored to public interest. Reliance
15
in this regard is placed on Alembic Ltd. v. Union of India and
16
Eveready Industries Ltd. v. Union of India and Anr. to argue that
the respective High Courts, upheld the exercise of discretionary
power by the CG on grounds of public interest.
10.5 Controverting the arguments with respect to the quasi-
judicial nature of action by the CG, it has been argued that the
14
(2005) 3 SCC 337
15
2013 (291) ELT 327 (Guj.)
16
(2019) SCC OnLine Del 7865
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 20 of 40
issuance of notification pursuant to the recommendation is
legislative/sub-ordinate legislative function. The aforestated, is
sought to be substantiated by referring to Section 9(7) of the Act of
1975, which requires the notification to be placed before the
Parliament. Against this backdrop, it is argued that since the DA
acts for and on behalf of the CG, the quasi-judicial determination at
the first stage and the legislative act of notification at the second
together form a composite scheme, each stage carrying its own
procedural regime.
10.6 It is further argued that since the action of the CG is a
legislative action, it is not subject to natural justice, more so when
Impugned Provisions are silent on any such requirement and the
Petitioner does not dispute a full hearing before the DA.
10.7 On the standard of review, reliance is placed on Sales
Tax Officer v. Shree Durga Oil Mills , Alembic Ltd. (Supra) , and
Kasinka Trading & Anr. v. Union of India & Anr. , for the wide
latitude the Court accords to the executive in economic and fiscal
policy, and its reluctance to interfere with government action taken
bona fide in the public interest.
10.8 It has been argued that if the final findings of Respondent
No.2 is positive with respect to imposition of ADD, the CG is not
bound by such findings, since the same is merely recommendatory
in nature. However, where the Respondent No.2 records a negative
finding, CG cannot impose ADD contrary thereto. In such
eventuality, Rule 18(4) mandates withdrawal of any provisional
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 21 of 40
ADD. Reliance in this regard is placed on Designated Authority v.
17
M/s Andhra Petrochemicals Ltd. .
10.9 Lastly, it has been contended that notwithstanding the
Respondent No.2‘s recommendation, the CG refrained from
imposing any ADD in furtherance thereof, since the domestic
production of subject good was substantially inadequate to meet
demand. It is their case that as per Niti Aayog, the imposition of
ADD would have affected the demand and supply ratio affecting
the growth of downstream user industry, since amongst the three
producers of the subject good, only two are surviving in the market.
Consequently, taking into account the public interest factor, the CG
did not impose any ADD on the subject good.
11. Heard learned counsels representing the parties at length and
with their able assistance perused the paper book and the judgements
relied upon by the parties.
12. Upon consideration the following issues arise for the
determination of this Court:
A. Whether Rule 4(1)(d), Rule 17 and Rule 18(1) of the Rules of
1995, read with Section 9A of the Act of 1975, are ultra vires
Article 9.1 of the Agreement of 1994, and/or Article 14 of the
Constitution?
B. Whether the action of the CG has led to violation of natural
justice?
17
(2020) 10 SCC 209
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 22 of 40
C. Scope of the CG‘s discretion to depart from a positive
recommendation by Respondent No.2.
In re: Issue A
13. The principal contention of the Petitioners, while challenging
the vires of the impugned provisions/rules is premised on the
argument that the said provisions also run contrary to the scheme
envisaged under Article 9.1 of the Agreement of 1994. It is in this
backdrop that we now proceed to examine the Impugned
Provisions/Rules in light of Article 9.1.
14. Upon a plain reading of Article 9.1 of the Agreement of 1994, it
becomes clear that the said provision does not mandate a single,
undivided exercise culminating automatically into the imposition of
ADD wherever dumping, injury and a causal link are established. It
expressly provides discretion to take decision on whether or not to
impose ADD, to the authorities of the importing Member, even in
cases where all requirements for imposition are fulfilled.
15. Further, the usage of the term ‗ desirable ‘, imposes an
understanding that such imposition of ADD is not obligatory, but is
rather, discretionary in nature. Notably, the language provided
thereunder is also not indicative of a single, undivided exercise
culminating automatically in imposition of ADD wherever dumping,
injury and causal link are established. When viewed holistically, it
reflects a deliberate legislative choice to preserve a measure of
discretion even after the substantive pre-requisites for imposing ADD
have been established.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 23 of 40
16. The aforesaid interpretation stands reinforced by the
architecture of Section 9A (1) of the Act of 1975, which empowers the
CG, to impose ADD subject to the statutory ingredients being made
out, and nowhere does it use a language to mean that the CG does not
exercise the power of DD. Thus, the aforestated provision mirrors the
permissive and discretionary formulation under Article 9.1 of the
Agreement of 1994 and as such cannot be said to travel beyond or fall
short of India‘s obligations under the international treaty.
17. The Petitioner has contended that Article 9.1 of the Agreement
of 1994, contemplates only a single-tier exercise, and as such a
bifurcated structure being followed by the CG, namely,
recommendation by DA followed by independent discretionary power
of CG is impermissible. However, in the view of this Court, the
aforestated does not survive scrutiny when the text of the provision is
examined in its proper context.
18. As enumerated hereinabove, Article 9.1 refers broadly to ‗ the
authorities of the importing members ‘ and does not prescribe any
precise institutional arrangement through which the said authority
must discharge its function. Reference in this regard, may be made to
footnote 3 of Article 2.2.1 of the Agreement of 1994, which explicitly
provides that, in the context of the agreement, authorities shall be
interpreted as meaning authorities at an appropriate senior level.
19. Consequently, in absence of any guiding principle envisaged
under the Agreement of 1994 with respect to the process of decision
making, a Member State, cannot be refrained from creating a two-tier
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 24 of 40
domestic structure with respect to the imposition of ADD. It is of
particular significance to note that the functions undertaken by the CG
and Respondent No.2, when viewed cumulatively, does not stand in
contravention of framework governing anti-dumping measures.
Accordingly, the two-tier mechanism adopted under Indian law,
cannot by reasons of its institutional separation be characterised as
violative of or inconsistent with Article 9.1 of the Agreement of 1994.
20. In this regard, reference is also made to the statutory scheme
governing ADD. While Section 9A (1) by way of usage of phrase
‗may‘ vest upon CG a discretionary power to impose ADD, Rule 17
of the Rules of 1995, on the other hand, expressly describes the
conclusion drawn by the Respondent No.2 as recommendatory. The
aforestated distinction created by legislature is deliberate, giving the
final decision-making power of imposition of ADD to the CG, while
Respondent No.2 undertakes the specialised technical examination
and makes the requisite recommendation under Rule 4 of the Rules of
1995 [Ref: M/s Andhra Petrochemicals Ltd. (Supra) ].
21. Viewed in the context of the aforestated, the argument made by
the Petitioner that the discretion provided to CG is unguided so as to
attract Article 14 of the Constitution, does not merit acceptance. The
power so granted is conditioned by Respondent No.2‘s own findings,
the standard of public interest and the purpose of the ADD regime,
which is to remedy unfair trade and maintain a level playing field
without descending into protectionism [Ref: S&S Enterprise (Supra)
and Reliance Industries (Supra) ]. Moreover, as recognised in R.K.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 25 of 40
18
Garg and Ors. v UOI and Ors. , the Courts ordinarily accord greater
latitude to legislative choices in matters of economic regulation,
recognising that such legislation may legitimately employ pragmatic
and broadly drawn standards.
22. Therefore, the statutory scheme when assessed as a whole,
merely implements the principle envisaged under Article 9.1 of the
Agreement of 1994, which grants discretion to the importing Member
to determine whether ADD should be imposed. Following the
aforesaid principle, Act of 1975 implements that discretion through a
structured two-stage process, without offending the Agreement of
1994 or rendering such discretion constitutionally unguided.
23. Accordingly, Impugned Provisions/Rules, cannot be said to be
ultra vires either Article 9.1 of Agreement of 1994 or Article 14 of the
Constitution, rather they establish a coherent institutional framework
in which technical determination and policy discretion operate
sequentially within the same statutory scheme.
In re: Issue B
24. At the outset, we deem it appropriate to note that the present
Petition does not arise on the premise that a notification under Section
9A of the Act of 1975 has been issued by the CG imposing ADD
while acting upon the recommendations of the Respondent No.2,
rather it is premised upon the fact that CG acted in contravention of
such recommendations.
18
MANU/SC/0074/1981
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 26 of 40
25. In this regard, we may note that the Act of 1975 or Rules of
1995, do not prescribe any express procedure to be followed/adopted
by the CG in cases alike, where it rejects a positive recommendation
made by the Respondent No.2. The aforestated distinction assumes
significance while determining the scope of power exercised by the
CG, in order to determine whether the non-imposition of ADD,
attracts the principle of natural justice or not.
26. As enumerated in the preceeding paragraph, the statutory
scheme contemplates two distinct stages, firstly , investigation and
final findings by the Respondent No.2 under Rule 17 of the Rules of
1995 and secondly , discretionary power of the CG to impose ADD. In
this regard, it may be pertinent to highlight that the first ladder of
investigation and final findings under Rule 17, is quasi-judicial in
nature inasmuch as, it requires the Respondent No.2 to adjudicate,
upon notice and hearing, a contest between the domestic industry and
exporters/importers [Ref: Reliance Industries (Supra) ]. Undisputedly,
the Petitioner herein had a full hearing at that stage in compliance with
the prescribed procedure under the Rules of 1975.
27. Following the aforestated, the second ladder of discretionary
power vested upon CG, does not reopen the adjudication made by the
Respondent No.2. The latter‘s findings on dumping, injury, non-
injurious price and causal link, in absence of any prescribed procedure
is not revisited by the CG and as such attains finality on the technical
matrix covered thereunder. However, it is at this stage that one needs
to put to scrutiny the power envisaged under Section 9A (1) of the Act
of 1975.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 27 of 40
28. Before proceeding further, we must highlight that the reliance
placed by the Petitioner upon Reliance Industries Ltd. (Supra) , to
characterise the power under Impugned Provisions as quasi-judicial, is
misplaced and distinguishable on facts. That case arose from a
challenge to the methodology adopted for computing the Non-
Injurious Price where anti-dumping duty had in fact been
recommended and imposed. It did not concern a situation, as in the
present case, where the CG declined to impose the duty despite a final
finding and recommendation by the DA.
29. More significantly, the Supreme Court in Reliance Industries
Ltd. (Supra) was not called upon to determine, as a specific issue, the
nature of the power exercised by the CG under Section 9A of the Act
of 1975. The observation on the quasi-judicial character of the
notification was rendered incidentally, while repelling the Tribunal's
view that such notifications were purely legislative and hence beyond
challenge on the grounds urged; it was not preceded by any
examination of the text, scheme, or object of Section 9A and Rule 18.
Being obiter to a wholly different controversy, that observation cannot
constitute the ratio decidendi on the precise question at hand and does
not bind this Court on the issue now under consideration.
30. Essentially, the discretionary power conferred under Section 9A
confers upon the CG a function that is closer to policy formulation
than to adjudication. By its very nature, the exercise of such discretion
necessitates consideration of the interests of the public at large, rather
than being confined to the commercial interests of the domestic
industry. The nature and scope of the power, therefore, partake, in
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 28 of 40
substance, of a legislative or quasi-legislative character, particularly
having regard to the facts and circumstances of the present case.
31. In this eventuality, the principle of ― person who hears must
decide ‖, is not attracted in the manner contended by the Petitioner.
Since neither Section 9A (1) of the Act of 1975 nor Rule 18(1) of the
Rules of 1995 prescribe a further oral hearing before the CG. The said
aspect is of assumed significance because when the legislature
intended an oral hearing to be mandatory, it has expressly provided so,
as is evident from insertion of Rule 6(6) of the Rules of 1995, which
allows an interested party to submit the relevant information for
consideration of Respondent No.2 in writing. In absence of any such
statutory requirement, a requirement of a second hearing cannot be
read into the Act of 1975 and Rules of 1995.
32. On the appellate architecture provided under Section 9-C of the
Act of 1975, which confers a right of appeal to CESTAT, the
Petitioners have placed reliance upon Saurashtra Chemicals (Supra),
to argue that the Appeal lies against the final determination made by
the CG. However, such reliance placed by the Petitioner cannot be
accepted inasmuch as this Order arose from the dismissal of special
leave petitions in limine and its precedential weight under Article 141
of the Constitution is doubtful, in as much as an Order passed of this
nature does not amount to declaration of law binding all the Courts
19
[Ref: State of U.P. v. Synthetics Ltd. and U.P. State Road
20
Transport Corporation v Omaditya Verma ].
19
(1991) 4 SCC 139
20
(2005) 4 SCC 424
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 29 of 40
33. In regard to such appellate remedy, it is also necessary to flag a
live uncertainty surrounding this very premise. This Court in W.P.(C)
No.14723/2025 captioned Union of India v Essilorluxottica Asia
Pacific PTE Ltd. and Ors ., in view of the amendments made to
Section 9(C) of the Act of 1975 by way of Section 134 of the Finance
Act, 2023, has been posed with the question as to whether such
amendment has been notified and/or brought into force or not. The
effect of this question lies directly on the lis as to whether the Order of
CG notifying, modifying or not notifying ADD shall be amenable to
the jurisdiction of CESTAT.
34. Thus, the question whether the amended Section 9-C of the Act
of 1975 is presently in force, and consequently whether an appeal
against the CG‘s notification or order lies under that provision,
remains sub judice . It is in this backdrop that we proceed to examine
the Petition on its merits, without resting the outcome on the existence
or otherwise of an alternate statutory remedy.
35. Accordingly, in view of the aforesaid, for present purposes, it
is sufficient to hold that the second stage exercise by the CG is
legislative or quasi-legislative in character and as such it neither
amounts to redetermination of Respondent No.2‘s findings, nor
requires a further oral hearing.
In re: Issue C
36. Before proceeding to examine the present issue, we deem it
appropriate to reproduce the relevant paragraphs of the Final Findings,
forming basis of the present analysis, which are as follows:
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 30 of 40
“61. As regards the fact that injury to domestic industry, if any, is on
account of ban on single use plastics, it is noted from the records that
during the POI, there is no blanket ban on single use plastic in all the
states, and any blanket ban on single-use plastic products might have
similar impact on the imports also. Therefore, the alleged ban has
little relationship with dumping of subject goods, and injury to
domestic industry.
62. With regard to the benefit to the Domestic Industry concerning
imports of raw material at concessional rates, it is noted that the same
has been duly considered in the injury analysis and in the calculation
of NIP. Therefore, contention of the other interested parties has been
appropriately taken into account.
63. As regards the profitability of the Domestic Industry, it is noted
that the Applicants are multi-product companies and to compare
profitability of the companies with profitability of the product under
consideration is incorrect and also not in line with the jurisprudence
available on this subject. Further, the Authority is required to examine
the performance of the Domestic Industry in respect to domestic like
product and not for the company as a whole. Accordingly, the
Authority has analyzed the data for this investigation also. Therefore,
the contention of the other interested parties based on total
profitability of the company is not correct.
64. As regards the issues of no price undercutting, price underselling,
price suppression and depression, it is noted that the same are
addressed in the subsequent paragraphs while making injury analysis.
65. Rule 11 read with Annexure-II of the Rules provides that an injury
determination shall involve examination of factors that may indicate
injury to the domestic industry, ".... taking into account all relevant
facts, including the volume of dumped imports, their effect on prices in
the domestic market for like articles and the consequent effect of such
imports on domestic producers of such articles...." In considering the
effect of the dumped imports on prices, it is considered necessary to
examine whether there has been a significant price undercutting by
the dumped imports as compared with the price of the like article in
India, or whether the effect of such imports is otherwise to depress
prices to a significant degree or prevent price increases, which
otherwise would have occurred, to a significant degree. For the
examination of the impact of the dumped imports on the domestic
industry in India, indices having a bearing on the state of the industry
such as production, capacity utilization, sales volume, stock,
profitability, net sales realization, the magnitude and margin of
dumping, etc. have been considered in accordance with Annexure-II
of the Rules. The Authority has taken note of various submissions of
the domestic industry and the exporters / importers / traders/ users on
injury to the domestic industry and has analyzed the same considering
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 31 of 40
the facts available on record and applicable laws. The injury analysis
made by the Authority hereunder ipso facto addresses the various
submissions made by the interested parties.
II. Volume Effect of Dumped Imports
i. Assessment of Demand
66. For the purpose of the present investigation, demand or apparent
consumption of the subject goods has been defined as the sum of
domestic sales of the Applicants and imports from all sources. The
demand so assessed is given in the table below:
67. It is noted from the above table that the demand of the subject
goods has marginally increased in the POI as compared to the base
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 32 of 40
year.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
79. The details of production and capacity utilization are given in the
table below:
80. It is noted from above table that the Domestic Industry have
sufficient capacity to cater the need of the domestic demand. However,
the capacity utilization has gone down significantly during the injury
period.
c. Market share:
81. The details of imports, domestic sales and the market share of the
domestic industry is as below:
82. From the above, it is noted that:
a. Imports of the subject goods from the subject countries have
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 33 of 40
increased in the POI as compared to the previous years.
b. Market share of the domestic industry has decreased during the
period of investigation over the base year despite a stagnant demand
over the same period. However, during the same period the market
share of the subject goods from subject countries has almost doubled.
d. Productivity:
83. The productivity of the Domestic Industry is given in table below:
84. It is noted from the above table that the productivity in terms of
total production per employee has declined marginally in the POI as
compared to the base year due to lesser laying-off of workforce (100
to 87 indexed) as compared to the comparatively higher decrease in
production (100 to 83 indexed). Ceteris paribus, the productivity of
the domestic industry has not undergone any significant change
during the period of investigation as compared to the base year.
e. Inventories:
85. The inventory of the subject goods is shown in the following table.
86. From the above table, it is noted that the inventory has increased
consistently during the injury period, except a decline during the
POL”
37. Having held that the discretion vested in the CG under Section
9A(1) of the Act of 1975 is, legislative or quasi-legislative in
character, it becomes necessary to examine the standard by which the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 34 of 40
exercise of such discretion falls to be tested, more particularly where
the CG declines to give effect to a positive recommendation of
Respondent No.2.
38. As already noted hereinabove, neither the Act of 1975 nor the
Rules of 1995 prescribe any procedure governing such a departure.
However, this silence cannot be read as placing the discretion of CG
beyond the pale of judicial review altogether, rather, it merely dictates
the character of the review that applies.
39. In the view of this Court, the contention of the Petitioner that no
material was disclosed by the CG prior to exercising its discretion, if
accepted, would amount to importing the language of prejudice
attracting the principle of audi alteram partem, running contrary to the
observations made hereinabove under Issue B.
40. Therefore, since the power exercised by CG has already been
characterized as legislative or quasi legislative in nature, the Court
must examine such character by way of scrutiny applicable to
legislation and economic regulatory measures generally [Ref: Indian
Express (Supra) ], which are as follows:
i. whether the decision falls within the competence
conferred by the parent statute?
ii. whether it is consistent with fundamental rights?
iii. whether it is founded on relevant material bearing a
rational nexus to the conclusion reached?
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 35 of 40
iv. whether extraneous or irrelevant considerations have
entered the decision; and whether it discloses mala fides ?
41. Tested against this standard, we are unable to accept the
Petitioner‘s challenge raised against the Impugned OM, that the
reasoning provided thereunder, has already been considered by the
Respondent No.2. However, this Court is not persuaded by the said
contention. In this regard, at the cost of repetition, it is noted that
Respondent No.2‘s mandate is limited to examining dumping, injury
to the domestic industry, and the causal link between the two.
42. On the contrary, the issues considered by the CG, namely, the
interests of downstream users, the availability of alternative sources of
supply at competitive prices, and the possibility of the domestic
industry becoming a duopoly if competing imports are excluded, are
different from the matters examined by Respondent No. 2. Thus, these
issues, cannot be said to fall within the same inquiry merely because
they may arise from some of the same underlying facts.
43. It may be noted that the reasons cited by the CG to not impose
ADD stems from its claim of public interest. In this regard, a reference
is made to the findings contained under paragraph nos.79 to 86 of the
conclusion, which record that, during the injury period, i.e., April,
2015 to March, 2016, April 2016 to March 2017, April 2017 to
December, 2018, the domestic industry‘s capacity utilisation declined
steadily from an indexed 100 to 83, whereas the domestic industry‘s
share in total demand fell consistently from the base year to the period
of investigation, while the share of the subject countries were nearly
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 36 of 40
doubled. The aforestated trends, as recorded by Respondent No.2
itself, assumed further significance when one of the only three
domestic producers of subject goods, ceased operations following a
fire.
44. This supervening development, read together with the
assessment specifically obtained by the CG from NITI Aayog and
other Government agencies regarding the demand-supply impact of
the proposed duty, a matter falling outside the mandate of Respondent
No.2, furnished the CG with material bearing a rational and direct
nexus to its conclusion not to imposed ADD.
45. We are not unmindful that the Respondent No.2, at paragraph
nos. 90 to 95 read with paragraph nos.61 to 67 of its conclusion,
attributed the decline in the domestic industry‘s capacity utilisation,
market share and profitability to the dumped imports under
investigation, a finding which, on first blush, may appear to sit
uneasily with the CG now invoking a facet of that same decline as a
ground for withholding the recommended remedy. However, on closer
examination, the two inquiries are analytically distinct.
46. While the finding of Respondent No.2 addresses the cause of
the domestic industry‘s deterioration during the period of investigation
for the purpose of establishing injury attributable to dumping, the
assessment by the CG is forward-looking, and addresses whether,
given the supervening and materially different fact of an actual
reduction in the number of operating domestic producers, continued or
increased reliance upon the two remaining producers, unaided by
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 37 of 40
competitively priced imports, would leave the downstream industry
adequately supplied. The historical decline found to be dumping-
induced does not foreclose the CG from independently weighing the
future adequacy of supply in light of the change in domestic
production base, a matter that Respondent No.2 was never called upon
to consider.
47. With respect to the submission that the NITI Aayog assessment
was never disclosed to the Petitioner prior to the decision, we have
already held, at paragraph no.34 above, that disclosure to the affected
party was never the applicable standard at this stage. What falls for
examination is whether such material existed and was, in fact,
rationally applied by the CG, a question which this Court is entitled to
examine on the basis of the record as a whole, including the counter
affidavit filed in the present proceedings, and is not confined to the
four corners of the Impugned OM. Tested thus, the challenge to the
Impugned OM in the present matter fails on merits.
48. Notably, the CG has placed before this Court an explanation
with regard to the demand-supply position and the public-interest
examination undertaken by it. No mala fide , or complete abdication of
the statutory function, has been demonstrated. Therefore, this Court
expresses no view on the eventual outcome of that exercise, the same
being a matter falling squarely within the discretion of CG, which is
entitled to the latitude this Court must accord to matters of economic
21
policy. [ Ref: Balco Employees Union (Regd.) v. Union of India and
R.K. Garg (Supra) ].
21
(2002) 2 SCC 333
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 38 of 40
49. At this stage, it is necessary to observe that the discretion
conferred upon the CG under Section 9A(1) of the Act of 1975 is not
merely adjudicatory in nature, confined to weighing the competing
claims of the domestic industry and the exporters. In declining to
impose ADD despite a positive recommendation, the CG acts as
custodian of the public interest at large and is required to balance the
interests of the domestic industry against those of the downstream user
industry and the consuming public. It is this characterisation of the
CG‘s function that anchors the exercise of discretion under Section
9A(1) of the Act of 1975 within a permissible constitutional and
statutory framework, and reinforces the conclusion already reached in
relation to Issue A above.
CONCLUSION:
50. In view of the foregoing analysis, we do not find any merit
either in the challenge to the vires of the Impugned Provisions/Rules,
or in the challenge to the Impugned OM on merits. The discretion
exercised by the CG under Section 9A(1) of the Act of 1975, being
legislative or quasi-legislative in character and founded on material
bearing a rational nexus with the conclusions reached, does not, on the
facts and for the reasons recorded hereinabove, call for interference by
this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
51. Accordingly, having found no merit, the present Petition is
dismissed.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 39 of 40
W.P.(C) 16640/2022, W.P.(C) 16647/2022 and W.P.(C) 17186/2022
52. Before parting, it may be noted that, on 14.08.2026, along with
the present Petition, the Petitions bearing nos. W.P.(C) 16640/2022,
W.P.(C) 16647/2022 and W.P.(C) 17186/2022, also came to be
reserved for judgment. However, while penning down the present
judgment, we found it necessary and appropriate to adjudicate the
aforesaid Petitions separately, since they do not concern the similar
product, i.e., Polystyrene, which has been the subject matter of the
present Petition.
53. Accordingly, the Registry is directed to list these Petitions
along with W.P.(C) 9754/2026 captioned Indrayani Sales Private Ltd
v. Union of India & Anr. and connected matter, before the Roster
Bench, on the next date of hearing already fixed, i.e., 08.01.2027, for
further action and/or directions.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
NOVEMBER 17, 2026
s.godara/hr
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:01:12
W.P.(C) 10289/2020 & connected matters Page 40 of 40