HEMAMALINI SURESH vs THE SUB REGISTRAR,
- Court
- Madras High Court
WP No. 36287 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on 05.11.2026
Pronounced on 16.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE KRISHNAN RAMASAMY
WP No. 36287 of 2024
AND WMP NO. 33941 OF 2026 & 39168 OF 2024
Hemamalini Suresh
B1-22,Olympia Panache,
33,Rajeev Gandhi Salai, Navalur,
Chennai -600130
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
The Sub Registrar,
Sub Registrar Office,
T.Nagar, Chennai -600017
..Respondent(s)
Prayer:
Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying
for issuance of Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus, calling for the records of the
respondent culminating in issuance of refusal checkslip bearing RFL
No/Thyagaraya Nagar/79/2024 dated 15.11.2024 and quash the same as illegal
and consequently direct the Respondent to receive the sale deed presented by
the Petitioner for the undivided share of the land comprised in Paimash Nos.
384 and 386, O.S.No. 92, Part, Old T.S.No. 6866 pat, town Survey Nos. 4777/1,
4777/2 and 4777/3 Block No. 108A, T.nagar Village and register the same.
[Prayer amended as per the order
dated .11.2026 passed in WMP.No.33940 of
2026]
__________
Page1 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
For Petitioner(s): Mr.K.S.Suresh, for Mr.V.Kuberan
For Respondent(s): Mr.T.Gowthaman, AAG,
Asst. by Mr.Dominic S.David, SGP
Order
This writ petition has been filed challenging the refusal check slip dated
15.11.2024 issued by the respondent and to issue appropriate directions to
register the same.
2. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that in
this case, on 15.11.2024, the petitioner had purchased the undivided share of
land from M/s.Lancor Holding Limited, to an extent of 883.51 sq.ft., out of the
total extent of 7928.50 sq.ft., comprised in T.S.Nos.4777/1, 4777/2 & 4777/3 of
Block No.108A, T Nagar Village, Guindy Taluk, Chennai District. Thereafter,
he engaged the services of the Builder, who is none other than the very same
M/s.Lancor Holding Limited, for construction of building. When the said sale
deed was presented before the respondent for the purpose of registration, the
same was refused by way of impugned refusal check slip for the following two
reasons:
1. Index not entered correctly
2. Others: Mtzk;’ghprPypf;fg;gl;ljpy;’Mtzj;jpy;
__________
Page2 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s brhj;J tptu';fs; ml;ltiz ,uz;oy; Kjy;’fpiua
Mtzk;;’ ml;ltiz cl;gFj;jg;gltpy;iy/ ,uz;lhtJ fpiuahtzj;jpw;F
cz;lhd ml;ltiz cl;gFj;jg;gl;Ls;sJ/’vdnt’,t;thtzk;’gjpt[‘kWjypf;?
fg;gLfpwJ/
3. Further, the respondent had orally informed that in view of the
GO.Ms.No.131 dated 01.12.2023, the registration of undivided share was
dispensed with and thus, the sale deed, presented by the petitioner, will be
registered only based on the composite value.
4. According to the petitioner, once the document is presented for the
purpose of registration, immediately, the duty is cast upon the respondent to
register the said document, after the receipt of the stamp duty and registration
charges, in accordance with law. In the event, if there is any under-valuation or
short payment on stamp duty, etc., the respondent has to refer the matter to the
Authority concerned in terms of Section 47A of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, for
the purpose of re-determination of valuation as well as the registration charges.
Without doing so, merely by citing the aforesaid reasons in the refusal check
slip, the respondent had refused to register the petitioner’s sale deed.
5. As far as the petitioner is concerned, all the relevant documents were
produced before the respondent and a sum of Rs.10,88,486/- towards stamp
duty and a sum of Rs.3,10,998/- towards registration fee was paid by way of
__________
Page3 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
online bank transfer in accordance with law and the same was acknowledged by
the respondent-Department. In spite of the same, the respondent had issued the
impugned refusal check slip to the petitioner, which is not proper.
6. Further, he would submit that the respondent cannot insist the
petitioner for the payment of composite stamp duty and registration fee. He
would also contend that an agreement was entered with the aforesaid builder
(M/s.Lancor Holding Limited), only, for the purpose of construction of building
in the subject land, for which, the petitioner was required to pay the entire cost
of construction along with GST.
7. Further, he has also referred the Clause 5(i) of Schedule I of the Indian
Stamp Act, 1899, wherein it has been stated that in the event, if any person is
engaged for the construction, the stamp duty is required to be paid to the said
construction agreement as one rupee, for every hundred rupees or part thereof,
of the cost of the proposed construction or the value of construction or the
consideration specified in the agreement, whichever is higher.
8. The petitioner is ready and willing to pay the same, in the event of,
entering into the construction agreement. In such case, the construction
agreement will only be a works contract and at any cost, the existence of said
agreement will not be an impediment for the respondent to register the sale deed
__________
Page4 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
for the subject undivided share of land. Hence, he would submit that by citing
the notification in GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023, the respondent cannot insist for
registration of the building, which is proposed to be constructed by the
petitioner, at her cost, after payment of all taxes, including GST.
9. The petitioner, who was not in a position to purchase the larger extent
of land, has purchased a portion of undivided land of the subject land with an
intention to construct a flat therein. Under these circumstances, when the sale
deed was presented for the purpose of registration, the respondent made a
demand to pay the stamp duty on the composite value, as calculated in terms of
GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023, under the pretext that it is beneficial to the purchasers.
According to the petitioner, the said aspect is not acceptable since it is only an
act of imposing higher amount of stamp duty and other registration charges and
passing on the same to the purchaser.
10. Prior to the imposition of composite value, the duty was levied based
on the guideline value and charges paid for the construction agreement. Further,
he would submit that if a person purchases the entire extent of land, in such
case, the stamp duty payable for land would be based on the guideline value
alone and nothing is required to be paid on the construction of building. In that
case, the question of composite value would not arise at all. Therefore, he would
submit that the respondent is showing discrimination towards the petitioner’s
__________
Page5 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
transaction due to the reason that the petitioner is not in a position to purchase
the larger extent of land and construct the building by engaging a contractor
independently.
11. He would also submit that it is the right of the petitioner to purchase
either the superstructure or the land alone. As per the Tamil Nadu Tenancy Act,
the lessor can lease out the land and the lessee can construct the superstructure,
in which case, he can also sell the superstructure alone and the respondent
cannot refuse the same.
12. That apart, the notification in GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023 was issued in
terms of Section 9(1)(a) of the Indian Stamp Act 1899. However, the said
provision is only for purpose of reducing, remiting or compounding duties and
it does not empower the respondent to fix composite value for levying stamp
duty and registration fee in respect of the instruments referred therein. Such
composition of duties would apply only for the instruments, which are referred
in Section 9(1)(b) of the Stamp Act. Therefore, he would submit that without
any authority of law, the aforesaid notification was issued by the Revenue
Department and by citing the said notification, the registration of the
petitioner’s sale deed was refused by the respondent. Hence, he would submit
that the impugned refusal order passed by the respondent is not proper and thus,
he requests this Court to set aside impugned order.
__________
Page6 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
13. Per contra, the learned Additional Advocate General appearing for the
respondent would submit that in the present case, the petitioner has agreed to
purchase an undivided portion, in the form of flat, promoted by M/s.Lancor
Holding Limited, who is a developer and also Power of Attorney of the original
owner of the land. In this regard, a sale deed was executed on 15.11.2024 and
the same was produced before the respondent for the purpose of registration.
However, the respondent had rejected the sale deed vide impugned refusal
check slip dated 15.11.2024 on the ground that the composite duty was not paid
by the petitioner.
14. By referring the GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023, he would submit that in
terms of the said notification, the registration of undivided share of land and
building has been dispensed with and hence, the petitioner is liable to pay the
duties based on the composite value. He would also contend that the said GO
was issued only to benefit the general public.
15. Further, he would submit that individual purchasers buy UDS land
from the land owner and thereafter, they enter into a construction agreement
with the builder to construct the apartment does not hold good. Therefore, the
purchaser of the Flat would come only after the developer starts the
commencement of project. Under these circumstances, the notification was
issued under Section 9 of the Indian Stamp Act vide GO.No.131 of 2023, which
__________
Page7 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
mandates the promoters/land owners/builders to execute a composite sale deed
for undivided share of land and building. The State had introduced the concept
of composite value for the first sale of Apartment/flat/villa/row house/villament
with effect from 01.12.2023 and necessary instructions were issued to the
registering authorities. Therefore, when the petitioner made an attempt to
register the undivided share of land, the same came to be rejected by virtue of
impugned order.
16. Further, he would submit that the petitioner herein is trying to evade
the payment of stamp duty for the unit, which was constructed and sold as
composite unit by the promoter/developer. With an intention of protecting the
interest of individual purchasers, the GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023 was issued after
due deliberation. By virtue of the GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023, the concession was
also granted by way of reduction of stamp duty, which will benefit the public at
large. No difficulties were faced by the purchasers while registering the unit
after the issuance of the aforesaid GO and the available data would establish the
same.
17. Further, he referred to his counter and would submit that for all the
above stated reasons, the sale deed, presented by the petitioner was rejected by
the impugned refusal check slip. Therefore, he prays for dismissal of this
petition.
__________
Page8 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
18. I have given due consideration to the submissions made by the
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and the learned Additional
Advocate General appearing on behalf of the respondent and also perused the
entire materials available on record.
19. In the case on hand, the petitioner had purchased the undivided share
of land to an extent of 883.51 sq.ft., out of the total extent of 7928.50 sq.ft. In
this regard, he entered into a sale deed dated 15.11.2024 with M/s.Lancor
Holding Limited, who is a developer and also Power of Attorney of the original
owner of the land. When the said sale deed was presented before the respondent
for registration, the respondent had rejected the sale deed vide impugned refusal
check slip dated 15.11.2024 on the ground that the stamp duty is required to be
paid on the composite value.
20. According to the petitioner, the levy of stamp duty on the composite
value would not arise since the construction of building would commence only
subsequent to the purchase of undivided share, for which they will enter into the
construction agreement with the builder. In this regard, the petitioner is required
to pay the entire amount of construction cost along with GST, as specified in the
construction agreement.
__________
Page9 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
21. While registering the construction agreement, the law mandates the
petitioner to pay stamp duty for the value of the said construction agreement, in
terms of Clause 5(i) of Schedule I of Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and the said
provision is still in force. At this juncture, it would be apposite to extract the
provisions of the said provision, which reads as follows:
5. Agreement or Memorandum of an Agreement-
(a) to (h) …………………
(i) If relating to construction of building One rupee for
every hundred rupees or part thereof of the cost of the
proposed construction or the value of construction or the
consideration specified in the agreement, whichever is higher.
22. A reading of the above would show that at the time of registration of
the construction agreement, the Stamp duty at the rate of 1% of the entire cost
of proposed construction or the value of construction or the consideration as
specified in the agreement, whichever is higher, is required to be paid.
23. When such being the case, since the above provision is still in
existence, the application of the said provision cannot be dispensed with merely
by virtue of issuance of GO.Ms.No.131 dated 01.12.2023. Therefore, the
petitioner is certainly entitled to avail the rights and benefits in terms of the
above provision while registering the building agreement.
__________
Page10 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
24. Further, now the petitioner has entered into the sale deed dated
15.11.2024 only to purchase the undivided portion of land to the extent of
883.51 sq.ft., out of the total extent of 7928.50 sq.ft., of land. The petitioner
would enter into the building/construction agreement only after the registration
of sale deed. As on date, the construction of building was not commenced. In
such case, the question of purchasing the building and payment of stamp duty
on the composite value would not arise.
st
25. The Clause 5(i) of the 1 Schedule of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899,
states that it is mandatory to levy 1% of the total construction cost towards
Stamp duty for availing the service of the builders. That apart, the building is
going to be constructed out the petitioner’s money alone. In the event, if the
petitioner is entering into a construction agreement with the builder, the cost of
construction would be borne by the petitioner along with GST. Thus, the
building would be constructed out of the money paid by the petitioner to the
builder. In such case, the question of purchasing the superstructure by the
petitioner himself will not arise. The payment of GST is the proof for the
petitioner’s payment made to the builder for construction of building.
26. Therefore, it is not fair on the part of the respondent to refuse the
registration of undivided share, on the ground of non-payment of duties based
__________
Page11 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
on the composite value. As stated above, it is the statutory right of the petitioner
to register a property, either as a land or as a building, in which case, the
respondent is bound to register the same and they cannot compel the registration
of property along with the superstructure.
27. As stated by the petitioner, in very many cases, the owners may lease
out the lands without any construction but with the permission to the lessee to
construct the building in the land. In such case, the lessee is entitled to transfer
the property by way of sale of superstructure alone. In those circumstances, the
respondent cannot insist the lessee to register the land along with the building.
This was elaborately discussed in the order passed by the Hon’ble Division
Bench in Park view Enterprises vs. State Government of Tamilnadu and
others reported in AIR 1990 Mad 251 and the relevant portion of the said
judgement reads as follows:
93. Yet another plea put forth by the petitioners is that the
Registering Authorities cannot compel production of
agreements which are unconnected with an undivided share
sold in the land which alone is chargeable to duty under article
23 , and that, by summoning construction agreements, they
cannot impose the stamp duty under article 5(i) on such
agreements and insist upon registering them. Undoubtedly, it is
entirely left to the parties either to register or not to register
the instrument. If they do not choose to register the document,
the consequences are spelt out in section 49 of the Registration
__________
Page12 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
Act. Even thereunder, the proviso is to the effect that an
unregistered document affecting immovable property could be
received as evidence of a contract in a suit for specific
performance, or as evidence of part performance for the
purpose of section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, or as
evidence of any collateral transaction not required to be
effected by registered instruments. Therefore, failure to
register a document which is compulsorily registrable
under section 17(1) of the Registration Act disables the
effectiveness of the document only to the extent provided in that
section and not otherwise. It suffers certain handicaps as
in section 35 of the Act. Therefore, on the Registering
Authority under rule 3(3) getting at an agreement which would
come under article 5(i) or even the Collector on coming across
such an agreement when he assesses the market value under
section 47A(2) of a share of land sold under a sale deed cannot
compel the parties to register such agreements. Hence, an
agreement covered by article 5(i) and which is not registered
and proper stamp duty not paid thereon would suffer the
disability as known to law. No provision is made either in the
Stamp Act or in the Registration Act to compel parties to an
instrument to register it.
94 to 96. …………….
97. Therefore, the conclusions arrived at are as follows:
1. The impugned provisions of the Stamp Act and the
Registration Act are valid, though badly drafted.
__________
Page13 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
2. When a sale deed with a clear intention that only a
share in the land is conveyed, and that there is no transfer of
interest between the parties in relation to the building, if any,
found thereon, then the chargeability to stamp duty could be
confined only to the market value of the share of the land and
no other. Article 23 alone will apply.
3. Registering authorities have no power to compel the
parties to such a sale deed to register any agreement entered
into between them for constructing a flat/apartment in the
building, and which would fall under article 5(i).
4. In respect of such of those instruments which fall
under article 23 , article 5(i) cannot be applied as it covers a
different kind of transaction.
5. It is only when the parties to an agreement to construct
a flat/apartment in a building or the whole building as covered
by article 5(i) chooses to present it for registration, the stamp
duty as prescribed thereunder could be demanded, and not
otherwise. Article 47A procedure cannot be followed.
Only article 27 read with section 64 are applicable.
6. It is entirely for the parties either to get an instrument
which falls under article 5(i) to stamp it as prescribed or to
have it registered as required under section 17(1)(f) of the Act.
It is open to them to take the risk of the legal consequences in
not following the provisions of these two enactments.
7. When a sale deed conveying only a share in the land is
produced and the Registering authority has reason to believe
that its market value furnished is not correct, he has no
__________
Page14 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
jurisdiction or authority to hold an enquiry and decide as to
what is the stamp duty payable thereon. Rule 3(3) only enables
him to arrive at a "prima facie" assessment as to whether the
@market value furnished in the sale deed could be relied upon
to proceed with the registration. If he opines that the market
value is not correct, the statutory duty cast upon him is to
register and send it to the Collector to follow the procedure
under section 47A.
8. to 16. ……………………………….”
28. Further, in the event, if any individual is purchasing one ground or ½
ground of land individually and if he engages any contractor for the purpose of
constructing the building therein, certainly, he will not be liable to pay the
registration charges or stamp duty based on the composite value. In this case,
due to the poor financial status, the petitioner is not in a position to purchase the
whole property and put up construction. Therefore, he intended to purchase a
small portion, i.e., 883.51 sq.ft., out of 7928.50 sq.ft., as undivided share of land
and presented the sale deed in respect of the said land. However, the respondent
had refused the same by citing the reason that the petitioner is liable to pay the
stamp duty and registration charges based on the composite value. It is not fair
on the part of the respondent to refuse the registration by citing the aforesaid
ground for a simple reason that it completely discriminates the poor, while the
law is permitting the petitioner to purchase and register the undivided share and
__________
Page15 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
to construct the building through the builder. The said provision of law cannot
be dispensed with by way of any notification.
29. As stated above, due to poor financial status, the petitioner was able
to purchase 883.51 sq.ft., of land and thus, he joined with similarly placed other
purchasers to share the cost of the construction, so as to minimise the total
building cost. When such being the case, now, the State is trying to extract more
registration charges as well as stamp duty from the petitioner vide
GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023. Thus, the issuance of said GO is nothing but
discrimination against the people, those who are having the poor financial
status.
30. The above aspect can be explained with the following example: If an
individual, who is having good financial status, purchase the entire extent
7928.50 sq.ft., of land under his own name and engages a builder for the
purpose of construction of building by spending crores of rupees, the respondent
would register the same without insisting for the stamp duty and other
registration charges based on the composite value. On the other hand, due to
poor financial condition, the petitioner was not in a position to purchase the
entire extent of 7928.50 sq.ft., of land, instead he had purchased the undivided
share of land, to the extent of 883.51 sq.ft., by joining with other purchasers,
those who are also facing the similar financial issues, and had entered into an
__________
Page16 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
agreement with the builder for the purpose of construction of building, where,
the State is aiming to extract more stamp duty and registration charges, from the
petitioner, in the form of notification in GO.Ms.No.131 dated 01.12.2023,
which was issued contrary to the provisions of Section 9 of the Stamp Act.
Thus, to the aforesaid extent, it is clear that the petitioner faces discrimination in
payment of stamp duty and registration charges, when compared with the rich,
who are able to purchase the entire extent of land and pay less stamp duty and
registration charges.
31. Further, in the counter filed by the respondent, it has been stated as
follows:
“7. I submit that in most of the cases, the builder gets
power of attorney from the land owner and executes sale deed of
apartment using the power of attorney. This being so, the
argument that individual purchasers buy UDS land from the
land owner and thereafter, they enter into a construction
agreement with builder to construct the apartment does not hold
good. I submit that the purchaser of the Flat comes into picture
only after the developer starts commencing the project.
8. I submit that the State Government of Tamil Nadu has
issued a statutory notification under Section 9 of the Indian
Stamp Act, in GO.Ms.No.131 dated 01.12.2023 which mandates
the promoter/landowner/ builder should execute a composite
sale deed for undivided share of the land and building. I submit
that the State has introduced the concept of composite value for
__________
Page17 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
the first sale of Apartment/Flat/Villa/Row house/Villament with
effect from 01.12.2023 and necessary instructions have been
issued to the Registering Authority vide IGR circular
No.15486/C212023-L dated 28.09.2023 & 01.12.2023. The
policy of the State Government to adopt composite value for the
flats/apartments/row houses/villa etc., had been implemented
across the State of Tamil Nadu with effect from 01.12.2023.”
32. The State Government issued a notification under Section 9 of the
Indian Stamp Act, 1899, in GO.Ms.No.131 dated 01.12.2023. However, the
State Government has no authority to issue such an enabling notification for the
purpose of levying duties at composite value with regard to the land and
building in terms of Section 9 of the Act. For ready reference, it would be
apposite to extract the provisions of Section 9, which reads as follows:
9. Power to reduce, remit or compound duties.–
(1) The Government may, by rule or order published in
the Official Gazette,–
(a) reduce or remit, whether prospectively or
retrospectively, in the whole or any part of the territories under
its administration, the duties with which any instruments or
any particular class of instruments, or any of the instruments
belonging to such class, or any instruments when executed by
or in favour of any particular class of persons, or by or in
favour of any members of such class, are chargeable; and
(b) Provided for the composition or consolidation of
duties 1[of policies of insurance and] in the case of issues by
__________
Page18 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
any incorporated company or other body corporate or of
transfers (where there is a single transferee, whether
incorporated or not) of debentures, bonds or other marketable
securities. Or of note of memorandum sent by a broker or
agent to his principal intimating the purchase or sale on
account of such principal.
(2) ………………………..”
33. The above provision states that the Government can issue notification
for the purpose of reducing or remiting the stamp duty for any instruments as
mentioned at Section 9(1)(a), which includes the sale deed. Thus, it is only for
the purpose of reducing or remiting the stamp duty, either prospectively or
retrospectively, and it does not mention anything with regard to empowering the
State Government to issue GO for the purpose of determination of composite
value with regard to the immovable properties and levy the stamp duty and
registration charges thereon.
34. As far as Section 9(1)(b) of the Stamp Act is concerned, the State can
issue notification by providing the composition or consolidation of duties of
policies of insurance and in the case of issues by any incorporated company or
other body corporate of debentures, bonds or other marketable securities.
i) Normally, the life insurance policies will cover two aspects,
i.e., the policy amount is required to be paid in the event of death of the
policy holder and on the other hand, if no death, then it will be paid at
__________
Page19 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
the time of maturity of the policy. Thus, in case of insurance policy,
irrespective of the occurrence of any event (either death or maturity),
the composite value is required to be determined by taking into
consideration of two aspects, i.e., death as well as maturity after the
expiry of term, for the purpose of payment of stamp duty.
ii) In similar way, in the event of issuance of debentures,
bonds and securities by Company, which are all either convertible or
non-convertible. At the option of the purchaser, the said bonds,
debentures and securities can be redeemed or it can be converted into
shares or otherwise. In such situations, instead of charging different
stamp duty, based on the occurrence, the above two transactions of
redemption and conversion are clubbed together and composite value is
fixed for payment of stamp duty and other registration charges.
35. In view of the above, it is clear that the Authorities can levy duties,
based on composite value, only for the instruments specified in Section 9(1)(b)
of the Stamp Act and at any cost, it will not apply for the registration of
documents or deeds or any other instruments mentioned in Section 9(1)(a) of
the Stamp Act. Further, the composite levy cannot be made with force or
compulsion of GO. It must be at the option of the parties concerned.
36. Therefore, in this case, this Court is of the considered view that the
provisions of Section 9 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, does not empower the
State Government to issue any notification for imposition of composite value on
__________
Page20 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
the stamp duties and other registration charges while registering the document
in respect of immovable properties. In such case, it is clear that the
GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023 was issued by the State Government without any
authority and the said GO was issued beyond the scope of Section 9 of the
Indian Stamp Act, 1899. Hence, the provision of Section 9 of the Act is required
to be followed in the present case but not the GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023.
37. For all these reasons, the impugned order passed by the respondent is
liable to be set aside. The respondent is directed to register the petitioner’s sale
deed without insisting for the payment of duties at composite value. Thereafter,
if the respondent have any other reason to believe that there is any under-
valuation or short payment on stamp duty, the matter shall be referred to the
concerned Authorities in terms of Section 47A of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899.
38. In fine, this Court passes the following order:
(i) The impugned order is hereby set aside. The
petitioner is directed to re-present the sale deed dated
15.11.2024, in which case, the respondent shall register the
same and return the document in accordance with law,
forthwith.
__________
Page21 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
(ii) As far as the issuance of notification in
GO.Ms.No.131 dated 01.12.2023 by invoking provisions of
Section 9 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, is concerned, the
same was issued beyond the scope of the Act since
determination of composite value for both the land and
building is not permissible in terms of Section 9(1)(a) of the
Stamp Act.
(iii) As discussed above, the building is going to be
constructed out of the petitioner’s money for which, he is also
liable to pay GST. In such case, if the composite value is
applied, it would amount to mandating the petitioner to
purchase his own building and thus, the GO.Ms.No.131 dated
01.12.2023 cannot be applied to the present case.
(iv) Though the respondent states that GO.Ms.No.131
dated 01.12.2023 was issued only for protecting the interest of
the individual purchaser at less rate of duty, in reality, the small
purchasers, like petitioner, are demanded to pay double the
amount of stamp duty as well as registration charges, which
certainly discriminates them from a person who can
individually purchase the entire extent of land and construct his
own bungalow by availing the service of very same
builder/developer with lesser stamp duty and registration
charges. In such case, no doubt, the respondent is passing on
the benefits only to the rich by virtue of the said GO. On the
other hand, the people, who are going to purchase a single flat,
are forced to pay higher amount of stamp duty as well as
registration charges. Thus, the GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023 is only
__________
Page22 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
pretending to benefit the flat buyers at the reduced rate of duty,
however, in reality, the buyers have been compelled to pay
more amount of stamp duty and registration charges, without
any authority of law.
(v) Any application of provisions of law cannot be
dispensed with by virtue of GO.Ms.No.131 of 2023, which was
issued in contrary to the provisions of Law.
39. With the above directions, this writ petition is disposed of. No cost.
Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petitions are also closed.
16-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
nsa
To
The Sub Registrar,
Sub Registrar Office,
T.Nagar, Chennai -600017
__________
Page23 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )
WP No. 36287 of 2024
KRISHNAN RAMASAMY J.
nsa
WP No. 36287 of 2024
16-11-2026
__________
Page24 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 05:23:15 pm )