DR T D DEVEGOWDA vs STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

R
ST
DATED THIS THE 21 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.P.SANDESH

CRIMINAL PETITION NO.6286 OF 2022
C/W
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.7111 OF 2022

IN CRL.P NO.6286/2022:

BETWEEN:

1. DR. T.D. DEVEGOWDA
S/O. LATE SRI. DEVEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
R/O.NO.1285, PADUVANA ROAD,
TH TH
4 CROSS, 4 STAGE, T.K.LAYOUT,
MYSORE-570009.
…PETITIONER

(BY SRI. K. PHANINDRA, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SMT. VAISHALI HEGDE, ADVOCATE)
AND:

1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY JAYALAKSHMIPURAM POLICE, MYSORE,
REPRESENTED BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
BENGALURU-560001.

2. DR. A. KHADAR PASHA
S/O. LATE AHAMAD HUSSAIN,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
FINANCE OFFICER,
KARNATAKA STATE OPEN UNIVERSITY,
MYSORE-570006.
…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. MOHAMMAD AYUB ALI, ADDL. SPP FOR R1;
SRI. M.B. MARGUND, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SMT. KSHAMA NARGUND, ADVOCATE FOR R2)














Digitally signed
by DEVIKA M
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED UNDER SECTION 482
OF CR.P.C PRAYING TO QUASH THE ENTIRE PROCEEDINGS
AND ORDER DATED 31.03.2022 VIDE ANNEXURE-A PASSED BY
THE COURT OF THE I ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND CJM,
MYSURU IN JAYALAKSHMIPURAM P.S., CR.NO.42/2016 FOR
ALLEGED OFFENCES UNDER SECTIONS 406, 409, 149 OF IPC
AND QUASH THE FIR DATED 20.08.2016 IN CR.NO.42/2016
ALONG WITH THE COMPLAINT DATED 19.08.2016 REGISTERED
WITH JAYALAKSHMIPURAM POLICE STATION FOR ALLEGED
OFFENCES UNDER SECTIONS 406, 409, 149 OF IPC VIDE
ANNEXURES-B AND C AND ALL OTHER PROCEEDINGS
PENDING ON THE FILE OF THE COURT OF THE I ADDL. SENIOR
CIVIL JUDGE AND CJM, MYSURU IN SO FAR AS THE
PETITIONER IS CONCERNED.

IN CRL.P NO.7111/2022:

BETWEEN:

1. PROF. DR. K.S. RANGAPPA
S/O LATE SUBBE GOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS,
OCC: EX VICE CHANCELLOR OF KSOU
AND UNIVERSITY OF MYSORE
RESIDING AT NO.227/9,
ND
BOGADI 2 STAGE,
MYSORE-570026.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. DINESHKUMAR RAO K., ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY JAYALAXMIPURAM POLICE STATION,
MYSORE-570006.
REPRESENTED BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
HIGH COURT BUILDINGS
BENGALURU-560001.

2. PROF. KHADER PASHA
S/O LATE AHMED HUSSAIN,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
OCC: THE THEN REGISTRAR,

- 3 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


NOW FINANCE OFFICER,
KARNATAKA STATE OPEN UNIVERSITY,
MUKTHAGANGOTHRI, MYSURU CITY,
KARNATAKA 570006.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. MOHAMMAD AYUB ALI, ADDL. SPP FOR R1;
SRI. M.B.NARGUND, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SMT. KSHAMA NARGUND, ADVOCATE FOR R2)

THIS CRIMINAL PETITION FILED UNDER SECTION 482
OF CR.P.C PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER
DATED 31.03.2022 PASSED BY THE I ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL
JUDGE AND CJM, MYSORE IN CR.NO.42/2016 OF
JAYALAKSHMIPURAM P.S., MYSURU PENDING ON THE FILE
OF THE I ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND CJM, MYSORE
(REGISTERED FOR THE OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTIONS 406, 409 R/W 149 OF IPC.

THESE PETITIONS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS ON 12.11.2026 THIS DAY, THE COURT
PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.P.SANDESH

CAV ORDER
This Court heard learned senior counsel for petitioner in
Crl.P.No.6286/2022 and learned counsel for petitioner in
Crl.P.No.7111/2022, learned Additional SPP for respondent
No.1 and learned Senior counsel for respondent No.2.
2. This Court heard and reserved the petitions filed by
accused Nos.1 and 2 praying this Court to quash the order
passed by the learned trial Judge as per Annexure-A dated
31.03.2022, wherein having rejected ‘B’ report, ordered for

- 4 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


fresh investigation in respect of Crime No.42/2016. Hence,
these two petitions are taken up together for common
consideration, though both the accused have filed independent
petitions.
2. The factual matrix of case of the prosecution is that
the police registered a case in Crime No.42/2016 against 7
accused persons invoking the offence punishable under
Sections 406, 409 read with Section 149 of IPC based on the
complaint given by Financial Officer of Karnataka State Open
University (‘KSOU’ for short), wherein certain accusations are
made against each of the accused persons. The police having
registered Crime No.42/2016 investigated the matter and filed
‘B’ report stating that there is no material to file the charge
sheet against the accused persons. Hence, complainant has
filed objections by way of protest petition. In the protest
petition, it is contended that the Investigation Officer has
misconceived the entire facts of the case in respect of
transparency in public procurement and hierarchy of
administrative powers in the University set-up. The
complainant-University have stated several reports regarding
the act of accused persons, who are working in different
capacity. It is the main allegation in the complaint that without

- 5 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


making the tenders, have purchased computers and also
necessary furniture. Hence, the Chancellor office made several
correspondence to KSOU regarding illegal acts committed by
the opposite parties. The Chancellor also has appointed one
man committee of Hon'ble Justice Sri K. Bhaktavatsala,
Chairman of Enquiry Committee, who has advised to conduct
the audit within three months. The complainant have referred
several letters issued by the office of the Vice-Chancellor
regarding the enquiry as to the act of opposite parties. Even
the complainant stated that in view of MOU, payment of
mobilization advance of Rs.1 crore to IEM in the end of tenure
of Vice-Chancellor of KSOU without making any tender and the
same is illegal. The MOU has been entered for purchasing the
necessary supply by the IEM and made payment of Rs.1 crore
st
and odd on different dates during the month of 31 October to
November, 2012 and the work order was issued during last
period of working. Even though the complaint has been lodged
to the police, the Investigating Officer has filed ‘B’ report and
the same was rejected and ordered for fresh investigation.
3. The complainant has relied upon several judgments
in their objection statement and prays for rejection of ‘B’ report
and apart from that, examined the complainant himself as

- 6 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


C.W.1 and got marked the documents as Exs.C1 to C35. The
learned Magistrate having recorded his sworn statement and
considering the documents vide impugned order comes to the
conclusion that the Investigating Officer filed ‘B’ report without
verifying original documents and without inquiring the
witnesses. So from 2012-2013 and 2013-14, the officials who
have worked as Vice-Chancellor, Financial Officers and
Registrar have alleged to be done the violation of Government
Rules and also KTPP Act. Hence, the Investigating Officer has to
conduct fresh investigation by securing all the original
documents from the complainant-University in paragraph
No.11.
4. The learned Magistrate also discussed the scope of
Section 202 of Cr.P.C. and comes to the conclusion that as per
the sworn statement of C.W.1 and documents produced by
C.W.1, there are sufficient material to make fresh investigation
by securing original documents and ordered for fresh
investigation.
5. The same is challenged in Crl.P.No.6286/2022 by
accused No.2. The main grounds urged in this petition by
referring the documents Annexures-A to H relied upon the copy

- 7 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


of the order passed by the Trial Court as Annexure-A, copy of
the FIR as Annexure-B, copy of complaint as Annexure-C, copy
of the final report/’B’ report as Annexure-D, copy of the
order/letter issued by the Special Secretary to Governor of
Karnataka to the Vice Chancellor of KSOU as Annexure-E, copy
of the extract of the inquiry report as Annexure-E1, copy of the
audit report issued by Senior Deputy Director, Karnataka State
Audit and Accounts Department as Annexure-F, copy of the
letter dated 22.07.2016 issued by Under Secretary to Governor
as Annexure-G, copy of the objections dated 20.11.2018 filed
by respondent No.2 to Final Report/‘B’ report in respect of
Crime No.42/2016 as Annexure-H and referring these
documents, the petitioner mainly contend in the petition that
passing an order for fresh enquiry vide impugned order dated
31.03.2022 by the learned Magistrate is totally illegal and
contrary to the ratio of law laid down by this Court in the case
of DR. RAVIKUMAR vs. MRS. K.M.C. VASANTHA & ANR.
reported in ILR 2018 KAR 1725 . The counsel also would
vehemently contend that the police have investigated the
matter and filed detailed ‘B’ report. The Court below has not
given any reasons while rejecting the ‘B’ report. But, has totally
relied on self-serving statements of respondent No.2.

- 8 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


6. The counsel also would vehemently contend that
the Court below has failed to observe and appreciate the fact
that a reading of the complaint dated 19.08.2016 as per
Annexure-C does not make out commission of any offences. In
the complaint, point No.3 was referred with regard to audit
report Annexure-F. Annexure-F clearly reflects that no
irregularities were formed in respect of purchase of computers.
The allegation made against this petitioner is only in respect of
purchase of computers are concerned. The counsel would
vehemently contend that Court below without even considering
the contents of ‘B’ report, Annexure-D, has straight away
permitted the complainant to examine himself as C.W.1 in
support of his allegations and marked the documents Exs.C1 to
C35 and even did not taken any cognizance and without taking
any cognizance permitting to examine the complainant as
C.W.1 is erroneous. The counsel would vehemently contend
that in the complaint, only referred point Nos.3 and 4 of the
audit report. The point No.3 of the audit report relates to the
petitioner herein and point No.4 is not in respect of this
petitioner. Even in respect of point No.4 in the audit report
also, it is very clear that no irregularity in purchase of the
computers as well as other articles. The trial Judge while

- 9 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


passing fresh order for investigation failed to take note of
contents of Annexure-F. Hence, the counsel in his argument
would vehemently contend that it is a fit case to quash the
order passed by the trial Judge.
7. The counsel also would vehemently contend that
ingredients of Section 406 of IPC will not attract, since
complaint does not disclose any of the allegations and audit
report is also in favour of this petitioner, particularly paragraph
No.11 of the order. The counsel also would contend that though
an allegation is made that audit report is not proper, no action
is taken against the Audit and Account Department and there is
no violation. The page Nos.74 and 75 is also very clear that
specific reasoning is given that no violation in purchase of
computers and also stocks are in order. The procedure followed
is correct and while filing the ‘B’ report also taken note of all
these factors into consideration.
8. Learned counsel for the petitioner in
Crl.P.No.7111/2022, who has been arraigned as accused No.1
reiterates the similar grounds in the petition as the learned
Magistrate has no powers to pass order for fresh investigation.
The counsel in his argument would vehemently contend that

- 10 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


the police have investigated the matter and filed the charge
sheet i.e., ‘B’ report under Section 173(2) of Cr.P.C. and the
very direction for fresh investigation is nothing but re-
investigation which is impermissible in law. The counsel also
would vehemently contend that learned Magistrate has
committed an error in proceeding to record the statement of
complainant and the ‘B’ report is otherwise not correct, the
Magistrate himself can enquire into the matter and invoking
Section 202 of Cr.P.C. is only for limited purpose of
investigating the case for the satisfaction of learned Magistrate
to consider the sworn statement/documents submitted by the
complainant and ought to have proceeded either under Section
203 of Cr.P.C. or under Section 204 of Cr.P.C.
9. The counsel would vehemently contend that the
procedure adopted by the learned Magistrate is contrary to law
even as per Section 202 of Cr.P.C., as the same is not
permitted. The learned Magistrate has committed serious error
in recording the sworn statement on the basis of protest
petition without rejecting ‘B’ report and ought to have rejected
the ‘B’ report and then proceeded to record the sworn
statement and the procedure adopted by the learned
Magistrate is also erroneous. The counsel also would

- 11 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


vehemently contend that no investigating agency is empowered
to conduct fresh, de-nova or re-investigation in relation to the
offence which has already been investigated. Further, the
Magistrate has no power to direct re-investigation or fresh
investigation in view of judgment of the Apex Court in VINAY
TYAGI VS. IRSHAD ALI ALIAS DEEPAK AND OTHERS
reported in (2013) 5 SCC 762 . The very approach of the
counsel is erroneous.
10. The counsel also in support of his argument would
vehemently contend that learned Magistrate committed an
error in invoking power under Section 202 of Cr.P.C. and the
same is not permissible. The counsel would vehemently
contend that this petitioner was working as Vice-Chancellor
from 2009-2013 i.e., 11.01.2013 and no payments are made
during this period even in respect of MOU and though, MOU
came into existence in 2012 and payment was made after 2013
and by that time, this petitioner had already served and his
period was over and there is no prima facie material against
this petitioner that he made payment without following the
procedure. The counsel would vehemently contend that due to
enmity, a complaint is filed and when there was no payment

- 12 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


during his tenure, question of facing criminal case by this
petitioner does not arise.
11. Per contra, learned Senior counsel for respondent
No.2-complainant in his argument would vehemently contend
that this complaint was filed against these two petitioners and
others and the same was registered as Crime No.42/2016 and
allegation is that having purchased the computers, the payment
of mobilization advance of Rs.1 Crore and additional payment
made to IEM agency is in clear violation. The counsel also
would vehemently contend that though learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner in Crl.P.No.7111/2022 would
contend that number of complaints are filed and this Court
already quashed the case in respect of Crime No.53/2019
based on the complaint dated 17.12.2019 and even the same
had reached to the Apex Court and the Apex Court confirmed
the order passed by this Court, but clarified that it is in respect
of subsequent complaint and while dismissing the petition and
confirming the same held that already there was initiation of
proceedings in Crime No.42/2016 and there cannot be second
complaint and the same is subject to result of Crime
No.42/2016. Hence, quashing of other complaint will not come

- 13 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


in the way of this petitioner, since this is the main complaint
filed against both the petitioners.
12. Learned Senior counsel for respondent No.2 also
filed memo along with documents. Earlier, the other accused
persons have also writ petition and mainly brought to notice of
this Court copy of FIR in Crime No.42/2016, copy of FIR in
Crime No.53/2019, copy of FIR in Crime No.54/2019,
complaints which are 4 in number and so also, copy of the
order sheet in Crime No.42/2016. The counsel also mainly
relied upon statement of objections filed in both the cases
referring the documents Annexure-R1 to R24 and particularly,
the counsel brought to notice of this Court accusation made
against both the petitioners and brought to notice of this Court,
paragraph No.11 of the statement of objections and while
referring the audit report Annexure-R8, it is stated that audit
report submitted by the Senior Deputy Director, State Audit
and Accounts in respect of point No.3 there was a reference for
having purchased the computers. The audit team ought to have
examined and reported the lapses in purchase of
computer/furniture in all worth Rs.38,69,836/- Regional
Centres of KSOU established in different District Headquarters
of the State. Instead of doing so, the audit team in collusion

- 14 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


with some officers of the University i.e., accused have reported
regarding purchase of different 30 numbers of computers worth
Rs.10,99,259/-. No dispute that they have purchased 30
computers and the same was also taken note of by the one
man committee of Hon'ble Justice Sri K. Bhaktavatsala and the
audit report is issued favouring the accused persons.
13. The counsel brought to notice of this Court
paragraph No.12, wherein also an allegation is made that
Registrar is the officer next to the Vice-Chancellor of the
University. Administrative Sanctions, work orders, purchase
orders ought to be issued by and in the name of the Registrar,
KSOU, for procurement of goods and services, adhering to the
procurement norms. The same was not done and brought to
notice of this Court paragraph Nos.13, 14 and 15, wherein
made an allegation and so also contend that quotation
procedure was not followed. The Counsel also brought to notice
of this Court paragraph No.22 of the statement of objections
referring the document Annexure-R17, so also paragraph No.29
that purchase of these 30 computers has nothing to do with the
purchase of computers and furniture to the Regional Centres of
the respondent-university. The counsel also brought to notice
of this Court document Annexure-R series, particularly brought

- 15 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


to notice of this Court Annexure-R4, wherein an advice is made
by the Hon’ble Governor and Chancellor that necessary steps
may be taken within a period of one month and communicated
for their perusal.
14. The counsel also brought to notice of this Court
document at Annexure-R9 with regard to mobilization funds in
advance referring the document of KSOU dated 05.04.2016.
The counsel also brought to notice of this Court Annexure-R13
issued by the Registrar dated 19.08.2016, wherein reference is
made with regard to prima facie illegality and irregularity in
point Nos.3 and 4 of the audit report. So also, the document
Annexure-R14 i.e., the complaint given and registered as Crime
No.42/2016. The counsel also would vehemently contend
referring Annexure-R16, earlier when these two petitioners and
others had approached the Court for quashing the FIR, the
same was dismissed. The counsel also contend that the ‘B’
report filed by the Investigating Officer is without perusing the
material on record and reasoning given in column No.17 is also
as against the material. Hence, the counsel would vehemently
contend that specific allegations are made in the audit report
against the petitioners and therefore, they cannot rely upon the
same.

- 16 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


15. Learned Senior counsel for respondent No.2 in
support of his argument relied upon judgment in NATIONAL
BANK OF OMAN vs. BARAKARA ABDUL AZIZ AND ANOTHER
reported in (2013) 2 SCC 488 and brought to notice of this
Court paragraph Nos.8 and 9, wherein discussion was made
with regard to scope of Section 202 of Cr.P.C. Investigation
under Section 202 Cr.P.C. is different from the investigation
contemplated under Section 156 as it is only for holding the
Magistrate to decide whether or not there is sufficient ground
for him to proceed further. The scope of enquiry under Section
202 Cr.P.C. is therefore, limited to the ascertainment of truth
or falsehood of the allegations made in the complaint on the
materials placed by the complainant before the Court; for the
limited purpose of finding out whether a prima facie case for
issue of process has been made out; and for deciding the
question purely from the point of view of the complainant
without at all adverting to any defence that the accused may
have.
16. The counsel also brought to notice of this Court
order passed by the Division Bench of this Court in
W.P.NO.51930/2019 dated 29.08.2026 , wherein the
challenge was made by the petitioner in Crl.P.No.7111/2022

- 17 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


with regard to set aside the report of One Man Fact Finding
Committee dated 14.10.2015 and this Court dismissed the
same. Hence, matter requires re-consideration, as the learned
Magistrate has not committed any error in passing an order for
further investigation. Though word is used as ‘fresh
investigation’, it is for further investigation.
17. Having heard the respective counsel and also the
principles laid down in the judgments referred supra, the Court
has to examine with regard to scope of ordering for fresh
investigation and also whether there are materials to proceed
against the petitioners in view of accusation made. Hence, the
points that would arise for consideration of this Court are:
(i) Whether the petitioner in Crl.P.No.6286/2022
has made out a ground to quash the
proceedings initiated in Crime No.42/2016 in
setting aside the order passed by the learned
Magistrate vide Annexure-A dated
31.03.2022, wherein fresh investigation is
ordered?
(ii ) Whether the petitioner in Crl.P.No.7111/2022
has made out a ground to quash the
proceedings initiated in Crime No.42/2016 in
setting aside the order passed by the learned

- 18 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


Magistrate vide Annexure-A dated
31.03.2022, wherein fresh investigation is
ordered?
(iii) What order?
Point Nos.(i) and (ii):
18. Both the points are taken up together for
consideration, since the proceedings are initiated against the
petitioners in Crime No.42/2016,.
19. The main allegation in the complaint at Annexure-C
is against both the petitioners along with other accused is that
a letter was addressed to the Police Inspector by the Financial
Officer dated 19.08.2016, wherein it was referred that a letter
was received from the Chancellor's Office that there is a prima
facie illegality and irregularity in point Nos.3 and 4 of the audit
report and based on the same, a crime is registered for the
offence punishable under Sections 406, 409 read with Section
149 of IPC. The learned Senior counsel appearing for
respondent No.2-complainant brought to notice of this Court
that another case in Crime No.53/2019 is also registered and
the same is quashed by this Court and the same is confirmed
by the Apex Court, since already there was a case registered

- 19 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


for the similar offence in Crime No.42/2016 and there cannot
be one more complaint. Hence, the very contention of learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner in Crl.P.No.7111/2022 that
already quashed the proceeding and there cannot be another
proceedings cannot be accepted in respect of this crime is
concerned. However, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner
in Crl.P.No.6286/2022 and learned counsel for the petitioner in
Crl.P.No.7111/2022 would vehemently contend that there
cannot be any fresh investigation and the Magistrate has no
power to pass any order for fresh investigation. Learned Senior
counsel appearing for the petitioner in Crl.P.No.6286/2022
relied upon the judgment in Dr. Ravikumar’s case and so
also, learned counsel for the petitioner in Crl.P.No.7111/2022
relied upon the judgment in of Vinay Tyagi’s case.
20. Having perused the principals laid down in the
judgments referred supra, it is very clear that learned
Magistrate cannot pass any order for fresh investigation. In the
judgment in Vinay Tyagi’s case, the Apex Court categorically
held that the learned Magistrate has no such power to pass
order for fresh investigation, the Magistrate has no jurisdiction
to direct fresh or de novo investigation. But, once the report is
filed, the Magistrate has jurisdiction to accept the report or

- 20 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


reject the same right at the threshold. In the case on hand, it is
not in dispute that investigation is conducted and ‘B’ report is
filed. While filing the ‘B’ report in respect of purchase of
computers is concerned referring to audit report comes to the
conclusion that there was no such violation. The Apex Court in
this judgment also discussed with regard to investigation can
be ordered in varied forms and at different stages, right at the
initial stage of receiving the FIR or a complaint, the Court can
direct investigation in accordance with the provisions of Section
156(1) in exercise of the powers under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.
Investigation can be of initial investigation, further
investigation, fresh or de novo or re-investigation. It is also
settled law that Cr.P.C. does not contain any provision which
deals with the Court competent to direct fresh investigation,
the situation in which such investigation can be conducted, if at
all, and finally the manner in which the report so obtained shall
be dealt with. But, the Superior Courts have their jurisdiction
under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. or even Article 226 of the
Constitution of India to direct further investigation, fresh or de
novo and even re-investigation and Magistrate has no such
power.

- 21 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


21. This Court would like to rely upon judgment of the
Apex Court in KISHAN LAL vs. DHARMENDRA BAFNA AND
ANOTHER reported in (2009) 7 SCC 685, wherein also at
paragraph No.13 in detail discussed paragraph No.10 of the
judgment of the Apex Court in DEVARAPALLI
LAKSHMINARAYANA REDDY vs. V. NARAYANA REDDY
reported in (1976) 3 SCC 252, wherein discussion was made
as to power of Magistrate under Sections 202, 156, 156(3) and
taking cognizance under Sections 190, wherein it is observed
that Section 202 comes in at a stage when some evidence has
been collected by the Magistrate in proceedings under Chapter
XV, but the same is deemed insufficient to take a decision as to
the next step in the prescribed procedure. In such a situation,
the Magistrate is empowered under Section 202 to direct,
within the limits circumscribed by that Section an investigation
“for the purpose of deciding whether or not there is sufficient
ground for proceeding”. Thus the object of an investigation
under Section 202 is not to initiate a fresh case on police report
but to assist the Magistrate in completing proceedings already
instituted upon a complaint before him.
22. This Court also would like to rely upon judgment of
the Apex Court in CHANDRA BABU ALIAS MOSES vs. STATE

- 22 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


THROUGH INSPECTOR OF POLICE reported in (2015) 8
SCC 774. In this judgment also, the Apex Court held that
Superior Courts alone have the jurisdiction under Section 482
Cr.P.C. or under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to
direct “further investigation”, “fresh” or “de nova” and even
“reinvestigation”. While the Magistrate can only direct further
investigation, the Courts of higher jurisdiction can direct further
investigation, re-investigation or even investigation de novo or
by a different agency, depending on the facts of a given case.
Needless to say, the power of the Magistrate to direct for
further investigation has to be cautiously used.
23. This Court also would like to rely upon judgment of
the Apex Court in VINUBHAI HARIBHAI MALAVIYA AND OTHERS
vs. STATE OF GUJARAT AND ANOTHER reported in (2019) 17
SCC 1 and in this judgment also, detailed discussion was made,
including postponement of issue of process and discussed in
paragraph No.20 scope of Section 173(8) in Cr.P.C. and so also
in paragraph No.24 discussed scope of Section 156(3) and in
paragraph No.26 judgment of Devarapalli
Lakshminarayanareddy’s case was also taken note of and
comes to the conclusion that there cannot be a fresh
investigation by the learned Magistrate.

- 23 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


24. Keeping in view the principles laid down in these
judgments, this Court has to take note of the order impugned
at Annexure-A. The learned Magistrate while passing an order
at paragraph Nos.8 and 9 taken note of the allegations, the ‘B’
report and also MOU and so also, the evidence of complainant
in paragraph No.9. But, in paragraph No.11 while discussing
the same comes to the conclusion that the Investigating Officer
filed the ‘B’ report without verifying the original documents and
without inquiring the witnesses. But, it is observed that from
2012-2013, 2013-2014, the officials, who have worked as Vice-
Chancellor, Financial Officers and Registrar have alleged to
have done the violation of the Government Rules and also KTPP
Act. Hence, the Investigating Officer has to conduct fresh
investigation by securing all the original documents from the
complainant-University. Hence, it is clear that ordered for fresh
investigation which is not permissible. Though, the learned
Magistrate discussed in paragraph No.12 scope of Section 202
of Cr.P.C. is concerned, once again reiterates that it is a case of
fresh investigation and as per sworn statement of C.W.1 and
documents produced by C.W.1, there are sufficient material for
fresh investigation by securing the original documents. Both the
counsel brought to notice of this Court that further observation

- 24 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


is made that as per Section 202 of Cr.P.C., the matter is
referred to the concerned police for further investigation, but
reasoning given by the learned Magistrate is for fresh
investigation which is spelt out in operative portion of the
order, which reads as follows:
“ORDER
The ‘B’ report filed by the investigation officer
is rejected.
Acting under Section 202 of Cr.P.C. the
investigation officer is directed to conduct fresh
investigation by securing all the original documents
from the complainant and file the report.”
25. Having taken note of operative portion also, while
rejecting ‘B’ report, invoking Section 202 of Cr.P.C., the
Investigating Officer is directed to conduct fresh investigation
by securing all the original documents from the complainant
and file the report. Having perused this order, it is very clear
that this direction given by the learned Magistrate is opposed to
the principles laid down in the judgments referred supra by
both the counsels appearing for the petitioners and so also
principles laid down in the judgments referred by this Court.

- 25 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


26. Apart from that, the Court has to take note of the
‘B’ report filed by the Investigating Officer and the same is
based on the audit report, which is marked as Annexure-F to
the petitions and both the petitioners have relied upon the
same and the respondent No.2 relies upon the document at
Annexure-R8 which is also the report filed by the Auditor,
wherein categorical finding is given that there is no such
violation. But, point Nos.3 and 4 referring the Special Secretary
letter as per Annexure-C is clear that there is no violation. The
contention of the petitioner in Crl.P.No.6286/2022 is that the
only allegation against him is that 30 computers are purchased
without following the procedure. But, as per Annexure-F audit
report, clean chit is given. No doubt, a letter is addressed
mentioning point Nos.3 and 4 of the audit report, having
perused point No.3, though a letter is referred in Annexure-R13
which is relied upon by learned Senior counsel appearing for
respondent No.2, in Annexures-R13 and R14, reference is made
that there is illegality, but no such illegality is found out in
Annexure-F in respect of point No.3 is concerned. But, it is
observed that there is a prima facie illegality and irregularity in
point Nos.3 and 4 of the audit report and the said observation
is made as a general observation, but report in respect of point

- 26 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


No.3 is very clear that there is no such violation. Hence, on
merits also, there is no ground to proceed against the
petitioner in Crl. P.No.6286/2022.
27. In respect of other petitioner in Crl.P.No.7111/2022
is concerned, specific accusation is made in respect of point
No.4. No doubt, having perused point No.4, allegations are
made with regard to entering into MOU and payment. But, the
admitted document of audit report at Annexure-F is very clear
that payments are not made during the period of this petitioner
and payments are made subsequently in the month of May,
2013 onwards consequent upon MOU and though MOU came
into existence earlier, but payments are made subsequently.
Hence, there cannot be any violation on the part of the
petitioner. Admittedly, this petitioner term was from 2009 to
January, 2013 and no dispute to that effect as the same is not
disputed by the complainant, though it is not stated in the
grounds of the petition.
28. However, learned Senior counsel appearing for the
complainant brought to notice of this Court statement of
objections filed in Crl.P.No.7111/2022 and particularly,
documents of Annexures-R9(D1), R9(D2) and R9(E), wherein

- 27 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


letter is addressed by the IEM to the Registrar requesting to
release the mobilization amount of Rs.1 Crore to start the
operation of Integrated Web Based System effectively and
smoothly. This amount is to be adjusted against future periodic
payments to be made to the IEM over a period of 3 years in 12
equal installments dated 31.10.2012. The counsel also brought
to notice of this Court letter dated 22.11.2012 and Annexure-
R9G, wherein the office of the Registrar order dated
27.11.2012 is referred with regard to the request to get an
approval. Though counsel brought to notice of this Court that
the approval was given by the Vice Chancellor, but in the
second paragraph, it is mentioned that the said order was
issued on the approval of Chancellor, but not on the approval of
Vice-Chancellor and operative portion also refers the approval
of Chancellor and not Vice-Chancellor, though contend that
approval was given by this petitioner. However, counsel also
brought to notice of this Court issuance of Cheque dated
29.11.2012 i.e., Cheque issued in favour of IEM for an amount
of Rs.1 crore and an endorsement is also given for having
received the Cheque. But, the document placed before the
Court Annexure-R8 and so also, Annexure-F is clear that no
such payment is made during the period of this petitioner. In

- 28 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


page No.5 of Annexure-R8, it is shown that payments were
made on 04.09.2013, 25.11.2023, 05.02.2014, 02.04.2014,
27.03.2014, 10.10.2014 and 18.05.2015 and all these
payments are subsequent to the period of this petitioner and no
financial misdeeds on the part of the petitioner during his
period and these are payments made after 9 months of his
period was over and complainant also not disputes this
document.
29. When such being the case, there cannot be any
criminal prosecution against the petitioner. The judgment of the
Apex Court in PEPSI FOODS LTD. vs. SPECIAL JUDICIAL
MAGISTRATE reported in (1998) 5 SCC 749 is very clear
that on the face value, if no misdeeds during his period and
the accusation is not found against the petitioner, there cannot
be any criminal prosecution against this petitioner. So also, in
the judgment of the Apex Court in STATE OF HARYANA vs.
BHAJAN LAL reported in 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 , the Apex
Court in paragraph No.102, particularly Guideline Nos. 4, 5 and
7, observed that if complaint does not disclose constituting of
an offence and no ingredient of the offence against the
petitioner, there cannot be any criminal prosecution and

- 29 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


Guideline No.7 is very clear that in order to wreck vengeance, a
criminal prosecution cannot be instituted.
30. The judgment of the Apex Court in Kishan Lal’s
case is very clear that to wreck vengeance for personal
grounds, criminal prosecution cannot be invoked and it is prima
facie clear that no payments are made during his tenure and he
cannot be prosecuted for the same and agreement was also
signed by Registrar and not by this petitioner and mere
entering into an agreement cannot be a basis for prosecution
when there was no payment during his period. Hence, the
petitioner in Crl.P.No.7111/2022 has also made out a ground to
quash the proceedings and also quash the order passed by the
learned Magistrate and learned Magistrate failed to take note of
all these factors into consideration and even order for fresh
investigation and he was not authorized to pass such order for
fresh investigation.
31. Having considered the factual aspects in respect of
accused Nos.1 and 2 and the allegation made in the complaint
and FIR and also taking note of the reasons given by the
Investigating Officer by filing ‘B’ report and so also, the
discussion made by the learned Magistrate, the learned

- 30 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


Magistrate committed an error in ordering for fresh
investigation in view of the principles laid down in the
judgments referred supra by counsels appearing for the
petitioners as well as the judgments relied upon by this Court
The law is also settled that the learned Magistrate cannot pass
an order for fresh investigation and the Magistrate is not having
any such power and only Superior Courts can do the same and
Magistrate is not having jurisdiction to pass impugned order at
Annexure-A and the same is passed without jurisdiction.
32. This Court has also taken note of accusation made
in the complaint in respect of accused No.2 which is in respect
of purchase of 30 computers and Annexure-F is very clear that
no such violation. No doubt, grievances are made by the
complainant that audit report is misleading and even, if it is
considered, the same cannot be a ground to initiate criminal
prosecution and initiation of criminal prosecution is a serious
matter and so also in respect of accused No.1 is concerned,
payments are not made during his period and the same is
made subsequent to his tenure and his tenure was in between
2009 to January, 2013 and payments which are shown in the
audit report is subsequent to his tenure and no prima facie
material against him for having disbursed the amount. Hence,

- 31 -
CRL.P No. 6286 of 2022
C/W CRL.P No. 7111 of 2022


against him also there cannot be any criminal prosecution.
Accordingly, I answer point Nos.(i) and (ii) as ‘negative’.
Point No.(iii):
33. In view of the discussion made above, I pass the
following:
ORDER
(i) Both the criminal petitions are allowed.

(ii) The impugned order passed by the learned
Magistrate at Annexure-A dated 31.03.2022 is set
aside and consequently, the ‘B’ report is accepted
and the proceedings initiated against the petitioners
are dropped.


Sd/-
(H.P.SANDESH)
JUDGE


ST