D SHEIK DAWOOD vs DEPTT OF POSTS

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1 of 14
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA No. 310/00820 of 2024
.
th
DATED MONDAY, THE 16 DAY OF NOVEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
CORAM :
HON'BLE MS. VEENA KOTHAVALE, MEMBER (J)
BETWEEN
D. Sheik Dawood (age 69)
S/o. Derwish,
9-C/1, Mohamed Ali Street,
Tirunelveli Town,
Tirunelveli District,
PIN-627 006.
(Retd. Postman). ...Applicant
(Advocate: M/s. R. Malaichamy)
Versus
1. Union of India,
Rep. by the Assistant Director General (Pension),
Ministry of Communications,
Department of Posts,
Dak Bhavan, Sansad Marg,
New Delhi-110 001;
2. The Chief Postmaster General,
Tamil Nadu Circle,
Anna Salai,
Chennai-600 002;
3. The Postmaster General,
Southern Region (TN),
Madurai- 625 002;
4, The Superintendent of Post Offices,
Tirunelveli Division,
Tirunelveli-627002. …...Respondents
(Advocate: Mr. M. Kishore Kumar, SPC)
CAV ON : 01.10.2026

2 of 14
O R D E R
(Hon'ble Ms. Veena Kothavale, Member(J)
This Original Application is filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking to set aside the order dated 25.11.2020
st
passed by the 1 respondent and for a direction to the respondents to count the
officiating service rendered by the applicant as provided under Rule 13 of CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972 along with regular service rendered by him in Postman cadre
and cure the shortfall of 4 months & 3 days by invoking Rule 88 of CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972, in so far as GDS are concerned, and pay the pension and the arrears to
him under Old Pension Scheme.
2. Briefly, the facts of the case as stated by the applicant are that he joined the
Postal Department on 08.12.1973 as ED (Extra Departmental) Packer, now re-
designated as Gramin Dak Sevak packer. From the year 1980 to 1998, he was
ordered to officiate in the Group-D vacant posts. From 1999 to 2000, he was
working in the P&T Dispensary as Group-D in the leave/vacant places. Due to ban
th
on recruitment, the 4 respondent did not take any action to fill up the vacant posts
of Group-D and Postman on regular basis. Since, the applicant was eligible for
appointment on seniority basis to the cadre of Group-D, the applicant was offered to
officiate as Group-D cadre in the Tirunelveli Town Sub-Office and hence, he
officiated as Group-D from 01.01.2001 to 30.06.2001. Since Night Chowdikhar post
was vacant at Tirunelveli Town SO, the applicant was ordered to officiate as Night

3 of 14
Chowkidar (Watchman) from 01.07.2001 to 02.10.2002. Since he was the senior
th
most GDS in the 4 respondent Division, he requested to appoint him as Group-D on
permanent basis. The Departmental Selection Committee was convened on
24.06.2002 and the applicant was selected for appointment to the cadre of Postman
th
vide letter dated 27.09.2002 issued by the 4 respondent. The applicant successfully
undergone Postman training from 11.10.2002 to 20.10.2002. Thereafter, he was
posted as Postman at Tirunelveli Town SO on regular basis with effect from
21.10.2002. Thus, the applicant worked continuously as Postman at Tirunelveli
Town SO and retired from service on superannuation on 31.05.2010 afternoon.
3. The applicant further states that as per Rule 13 of CCS (Pension) Rules, the
service rendered in an officiating capacity has to be counted towards qualifying
service for the purpose of grant of pension. Thus, the total service rendered by the
applicant is is 9 years, 4 months & 27 days. As per Rule 49 (3) of the CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972, the minimum qualifying service for getting minimum pension is 9 years
and 9 months. The applicant has rendered regular service in Postman cadre for 7
years, 7 months and 6 days, officiating service in Group D CADRE from 01.01.2001
to 30.06.2001 for 6 months and officiating service as Night Chowkidar from
01.07.2001 to 10.10.2002 for 1 year, 3 months and 10 days. Thus, if the officiating
service is taken into account, the total service of applicant in Group-D/ Postman post
works out to 9 years, 4 months and 27 days. Therefore, he prays that the short fall in

4 of 14
qualifying service of about 4 months and 3 days be cured by taking into account 25
years of GDS service rendered by him.
4. In the reply filed by the respondents, they have denied the claim made by the
applicant. It is contended that the applicant was engaged on 08.12.1973 as Extra
Departmental Mail Packer now designated as Gramin Dak Sevak. The applicant
worked in the vacant post of Group D at Tirunelveli Town SO from 09.01.2001 to
30.06.2001 purely on temporary basis and worked as Night Chowkidar at Tirunelveli
Town SO from 01-7-2001 to 02-10-2002 purely on temporary basis. He was engaged
as paid substitute against the leave/ vacant post with the conditions that the
arrangement is purely on temporary basis and it will not confer any right to him to
claim regularization and he has to revert to his GDS post any time. The applicant was
selected for the post of Postman on seniority quota by the DPC held on 24.06.2002
and had undergone Postman training for the period from 11.10.2002 to 20.10.2002.
On completion of his training, he was posted as Postman at Tirunelveli Town SO on
regular basis from 22.10.2002 and he had worked there till the date of his
superannuation on 31.05.2010. Thus, he worked as Departmental regular Postman
from 22.10.2002 to 31.05.2010 only and his qualifying service is 7 years, 7 months
and 6 days. As per Rule 49 (2) of CCS (Pension) Rules 1972, minimum of 10 years'
qualifying service is required for grant of pension. Since the applicant has less than
10 years of qualifying service as regular postman in the Department, he is not eligible

5 of 14
for pension as per the applicable rules.
5. The respondents further state that applicant had earlier filed O.A. No. 1240 of
2012 before this Tribunal for grant of pension and arrears of pension by taking into
account the entire period of his service from 12.07.1971 to 31.12.2005 which was
dismissed on 06.11.2012. The RA No.2 of 2013 filed for reviewing the said order
was also dismissed on 29.06.2015. The applicant filed W.P. No.9475 of 2016 before
the Madras High Court which was dismissed along with similar cases in W.P. No.
27602/2017 and W.P. No.27582/2017 by a common order dated 15.11.2023 by
relying on the earlier decision passed by the Division Bench of that Court in similar
matters in W.P. No.10162, 19881 & 6514 of 2015. Now the applicant has filed this
OA 820/2024 to direct the respondents to count his officiating service along with his
regular service and to cure the shortfall of 4 months & 3 days by considering 25 years
of GDS service by invoking Rule 88 of CCS (Pension) Rules 1972.
6. As per the provisions of Rule 13 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, the qualifying
service of a Government servant commences from date he takes charge of the post to
which he is first appointed either substantively or in an officiating or temporary
capacity provided that officiating or temporary service is followed without
interruption by substantive appointment. The applicant was engaged as substitute
against the leave and vacant post of Group D from time to time with break. Hence

6 of 14
the officiating service rendered by the applicant with break cannot be counted for the
purpose of pension. The applicant had served as regular Postman from 22.10.2002 to
31.05.2010 and his qualifying service is 7 years, 7 months and 6 days only. Hence he
is not eligible for pension under CCS Pension Rule 1972. Moreover, the applicant
has filed this OA with the same prayer to grant pension and has reiterated the
averments made in his earlier OA..No.1240/2012, R.A. No.2/2013, and W.P.
No.9475/2016, all of which were dismissed by the respective courts. Therefore, this
OA is barred under the doctrine of res judicata and prayed for dismissal of this OA.
7. Learned counsel for the applicant argued that the applicant had rendered
service as GDS for nearly about 25 years, and therefore the shortfall of qualifying
service can be cured for grant of pension by invoking Rule 88 of CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1974. Moreover, the applicant is entitled to count the officiating service
rendered by him along with his regular service under the provisions of Rule 13 of
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and therefore, denial of pension to him is unjustified. He
referred to the case of one M R Palaniswamy who had rendered 9 years 3 months
qualifying service and he was granted pension under old pension scheme by this
Tribunal which has attained finality before the Hon'ble Supreme Court and on coming
to know of the said order, he had filed OA 1240 of 2012 which was dismissed by this
Tribunal and Madras High Court. Learned counsel referred to the judgment of the
Apex Court in Civil Appeal No.8497/ 2019 and batch cases wherein, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, considering that many employees are missing pension on account of

7 of 14
marginal short fall in their regular service tenure which deserved sympathetic
consideration for grant of pension, directed the concerned ministry vide its order
dated 08.11.2019 to consider whether the minimum qualifying service rule can be
relaxed in such cases in terms of Rule 88 of the 1972 Rules. Therefore, he urged that
the Postal Department should invoke Rule 88 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 as
directed and grant pension to the applicant under old pension scheme.
8. Learned counsel for the respondent submitted that this OA is barred by
limitation and should be dismissed in limine and relied on the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board Vs T T
Murali Babu [2014(4) SCC 108]. It is also barred by the doctrine of res judicata as
the earlier OA. No.1240/2012 filed by the applicant for pension and arrears of
pension has been dismissed by this Tribunal and the High Court.
9. Learned counsel further submitted that the subject regarding counting of
service rendered as Gramin Dak Sevak to make good the shortfall in minimum
qualifying service of Group-D/ MTS employees for grant of pension has attained
finality before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India vide its order dated 08.11.2019 in
SLP No. 13042/2014. In compliance of the direction of the Apex Court that the
concerned ministry may consider as to whether the minimum qualifying service rule
can be relaxed in terms of Rule 88 of the 1972 Rules, the Postal Service Board has

8 of 14
taken decision on 25.09.2020 as under: -
"In view of directions of Apex Court dated 08.11.2019, CCS(Pension)
Rules, 1972, GDS (Conduct & Engagement) Rules, 2011 and
observation of IFW of this Department, the Board after in-depth
deliberation decided that there cannot be a single definition of "undue
hardship" that can be applicable to all cases. Hence, all cases similar
to the cases tagged with the SLP No.13042/2014 and decided by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court vide order dated 08.11.2019, may be taken up
as per Rule 49 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 only where an inbuilt
relaxation of three months has already been provided. No further
relaxation on case-to-case/ en-masse basis will be admissible in terms
of Rule 88 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972".
In the present case, the qualifying service of the applicant being 7 years, 7 months, 6
days only, the applicant is not entitled to pension even after the inbuilt relaxation of 3
months has been provided and no further relaxation will be admissible in terms of
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. Hence prayed for dismissal of the OA.
10. I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel on both sides
and perused the record.
11. It is observed that the matter in issue in this OA is no more res integra and has
already been decided by the Hon'ble Supreme Court vide its judgement dated
08/11/2019 in the case of UOI vs Gandiba Behera  (AIRONLINE 2019 SC 2018)

9 of 14
wherein it has held as under: -
19. Having regard to the provisions of the aforesaid Rules
relating to qualifying service requirement, in our opinion the
services rendered by the respondents as GDS or other Extra-
Departmental Agents cannot be factored in for computing their
qualifying services in regular posts under the postal department on
the question of grant of pension. But we also find many of the
respondents are missing pension on account of marginal shortfall in
their regular service tenure. This should deserve sympathetic
consideration for grant of pension. But we cannot trace our power or
jurisdiction to any legal principle which could permit us to fill up
the shortfall by importing into their service tenure, the period of
work they rendered as GDS or its variants. At the same time, we also
find that in the case of Union of India & Ors. v. The Registrar & Anr.
(supra), though the incumbent therein (being respondent no.2) had
completed nine years and two months of service, the Union of India
had passed orders granting him regular pension. This Court in the
th
order passed on 24 November 2015 had protected his pension
though the appeal of Union of India was allowed.
20. For the reasons we have already discussed, we are of the
opinion that the judgments under appeal cannot be sustained. T here is
no provision under the law on the basis of which any period of the
service rendered by the respondents in the capacity of GDS could be
added to their regular tenure in the postal department for the
purpose of fulfilling the period of qualifying service on the question
of grant of pension.

10 of 14
21. We are also of the opinion that the authorities ought to consider
their cases for exercising the power to relax the mandatory
requirement of qualifying service under the 1972 Rules if they find the
conditions contained in Rule 88 stand fulfilled in any of these cases.
We do not accept the stand of the appellants that just because that
exercise would be prolonged, recourse to Rule 88 ought not to be
taken. The said Rules is not number specific, and if undue hardship is
caused to a large number of employees, all of their cases ought to be
considered. If in the cases of any of the respondents’ pension order
has already been issued, the same shall not be disturbed, as has been
directed in the case of Union of India & Ors. v Registrar & Anr.
(supra). We, accordingly allow these appeals and set aside the
judgments under appeal, subject to the following conditions:-
(i) In the event the Central Government or the postal
department has already issued any order for pension to any of the
respondents, then such pension should not be disturbed. In issuing
this direction, we are following the course which was directed to be
adopted by this Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. v.
Registrar & Anr.(supra).
(ii) In respect of the other respondents, who have not been issued
any order for pension, the concerned ministry may consider as to
whether the minimum qualifying service Rule can be relaxed in
their cases in terms of Rule 88 of the 1972 Rules.".
(Emphasis supplied)
12. Pursuant to the direction as above, and in compliance thereof, the Postal
Service Board has considered the question as to whether the minimum qualifying

11 of 14
service rule can be relaxed in terms of Rule 88 of the 1972 Rules, and has taken its
decision on 25.09.2020 as under: -
"In view of directions of Apex Court dated 08.11.2019, CCS(Pension)
Rules, 1972, GDS (Conduct & Engagement) Rules, 2011 and
observation of IFW of this Department, the Board after in-depth
deliberation decided that there cannot be a single definition of "undue
hardship" that can be applicable to all cases. Hence, all cases similar
to the cases tagged with the SLP No.13042/2014 and decided by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court vide order dated 08.11.2019, may be taken up
as per Rule 49 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 only where an inbuilt
relaxation of three months has already been provided. No further
relaxation on case-to-case/ en-masse basis will be admissible in terms
of Rule 88 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972".
13. In the case of S. Raman Pillai Vs UOI, the Hon'ble Madras High court vide its
order dated 08.03.2019 in W.P. No 5305 of 2018, held as under: -
"..this court is of the considered view that the Applicant's earlier
service as 'GDS' cannot be treated for any pensionary benefit.
Furthermore, the applicant can only be treated as person having
joined in the service on 26.08.2010 and by no stretch of imagination,
he cannot be characterized as the person having entered into service
before 01.01.2004. Apart from that, the 'Gramin Dak Sevaks' do not
come under the CCS (Pension) Rules, which are applicable only to
'Regular Departmental Staff'.".

12 of 14
14. In the case of Union of India vs The Registrar, the Hon'ble Madras High court
vide its order dated 04/08/2024 in WP 8698 of 2024, held as under: -
"5. This Court is of the considered view that CCS pension Rules
prescribes 10 years of qualifying service for grant of pension.
However, if there is a shortfall of three months, then, it may be
rounded of to one year so as to grant pension under the pension
Rules. However, beyond the permissible limit, as contemplated under
the Rules, the power of relaxation vests with the Government. The
High Court in exercise of the powers of judicial review cannot relax
the service Rules in favour of an individual which would result in
opening a Pandora’s box and unsettle the scheme of pension in the
matter of minimum qualifying services required for grant of pension.
General power of relaxation contemplated under the Statutes and
Rules, are to be exercised sparingly and discretely, if any gross
injustice or miscarriage of justice is established. Even the
Government, while exercising the power of relaxation, is expected to
be cautious and it should not result in unsettling a settled principles
or create a wrong precedent. Exercise of the powers of relaxation
contemplated under the statute by the High Court would fall beyond
the realm of the powers of judicial review. Thus, the Courts are
expected to exercise restraint in exercising the powers of relaxation
contemplated under the Statues and Service Rules.
6. In the present case, admittedly the respondent completed the
qualifying services of 9 years and 4 months and the shortfall of eight
months, if relaxed by the Courts, it will have larger repercussions and
several such similarly placed employees across the country working
in various departments would also claim such relaxations resulting in

13 of 14
causing huge financial burden to the Union of India.".
15. From the above, it is evident that the applicant having served as regular
Postman only from 22/10/2002, and having superannuated on 31/05/2010, has
qualifying service of only 7 years, 7 months, and 6 days for the purpose of pension
and does not fulfill the requirement of law. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has clearly
held in the case of Gandiba Behera (Supra) that no provision exists in law which
allows adding of the period of service rendered as GDS to the regular tenure of
Postman to enable fulfilling of the minimum qualifying service required for pension.
It has also opined that it is outside its power/ jurisdiction to dispense with or relax the
requirements of the statutory rule and that such power vests in the executive under
Rule 88 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.  The Postal Service Board has taken a
decision that inbuilt relaxation of three months has already been provided and no
further relaxation is admissible in terms of Rule 88 of the CCS (Pension) Rules,
1972. The said decision of the Postal Service Board has been relied upon by the
Division Bench of Madras High Court in W.P. No.10162, 19881 & 6514 of 2015 and
dismissed the Writ Petitions. In the recent decision of the Madras High Court in W.P.
No.8698 of 2024 passed on 04/08/2016, it has held that in exercise of the powers of
judicial review, the High Court cannot relax service rules which would result in
opening Pandora's box and unsettle the scheme of pension in the matter of minimum
qualifying service required for grant of pension.

14 of 14
16. In view of the above discussions, I do not find any merit in this OA.
.
Accordingly, it is dismissed with no order as to cost
(Veena Kothavale)
Member(J)
16.11.2026
asvs
Digitally signed by ASAPU
SRINIVASA VIDYASAGAR
Date: 2026.11.20 16:56:23
+05'30'
A.S.V. Sagar
P.S., CAT,
Chennai Bench.