Vinay Goel vs Sanjay Kumar And Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
FAO-4847-2019
Vinay Goel . . . . Appellant
Vs.
Sanjay Kumar and Others . . . . Respondents

Reserved on: 12.11.2026
Pronounced on: 16.11.2026
Pronounced fully/operative part: Fully

CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE DEEPAK GUPTA
Argued by:- Mr. D.K. Gupta, Advocate for the appellant.
Mr. Radhe Shyam Sharma, Advocate for
respondent No.4- Insurance Company.

DEEPAK GUPTA, J.
The present appeal has been preferred by the injured claimant
seeking enhancement of compensation awarded by the learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Jalandhar, vide award dated 14.03.2019, whereby
compensation of ₹11,70,336/- has been assessed on account of injuries
sustained by him in a motor vehicular accident dated 28.05.1994.
2. Briefly, on 28.05.1994, at about 6:30 p.m., the appellant was
standing on the kacha portion of the road near Milan Palace, New Jawahar
Nagar, Jalandhar, when Contessa car bearing registration No.PB-08-F-7797,
driven rashly and negligently by respondent No.1 struck him, resulting in
multiple grievous injuries. The appellant, an advocate by profession,
suffered extensive injuries to his right lower limb, including fractures,
vascular damage and subsequent infection. He filed a claim petition under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking compensation from
the driver, owner and insurer of the offending vehicle.
NEETIKA TUTEJA
2026.11.16 17:04
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document.

FAO-4847-2019
3. The learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Jalandhar,
vide award dated 30.07.1999, held that the accident had occurred due to
rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle and awarded
compensation of ₹3,57,674/- along with interest at the rate of 12% per
annum.
4. Dissatisfied with the quantum, the claimant preferred FAO
No.2477 of 2000 before this Court. During pendency of the said appeal, the
appellant underwent further treatment and surgical procedures. Ultimately,
on 29.05.2006, his right leg was amputated above the knee on account of
persistent infection, non-healing wounds and deformity. Accordingly, an
application for leading additional evidence regarding post-award
expenditure and disability was moved.
5. This Court, vide order dated 23.05.2014, permitted additional
evidence to be recorded by the Tribunal. Pursuant thereto, the Tribunal
submitted its report dated 25.02.2015. Subsequently, vide order dated
09.11.2017, the matter was remitted to the Tribunal for fresh decision in the
light of the additional evidence.
6. The Tribunal, vide impugned award dated 14.03.2019, assessed
compensation as under:
Particulars Amount

Compensation under original award dated

₹3,57,674
30.07.1999

Additional expenditure assessed on subsequent

₹7,12,662
treatment, artificial limb and attendant
 
Additional compensation for pain and suffering ₹1,00,000
Total ₹11,70,336
The Tribunal also awarded interest at the rate of 12% per annum from the
date of institution of the claim petition till its realization.
NEETIKA TUTEJA
Page N: 2 of total 9 Pages
2026.11.16 17:04
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document.

FAO-4847-2019
7. Seeking enhancement, learned counsel for the appellant
contends that despite the serious nature of injuries, prolonged treatment
and eventual amputation, the Tribunal has failed to award just
compensation under several permissible heads. It is argued that adequate
compensation has not been awarded towards transportation, replacement
of artificial limb, loss of income during treatment, future loss of earning
capacity, loss of amenities, inconvenience, hardship and mental agony. It is
further submitted that the appellant continued to suffer from oozing
wounds and persistent infection for several years and the additional medical
evidence has not been appreciated in its proper perspective. Reliance has
been placed upon Prahlad Sahai v. HARYANA Road Transport Corporation
and anr., 2026 INSC 396; Mohd. Sabeer vs Regional Manager, UP State
Road Transport Corporation, (2023) AIR (SC) 186; and K.S. Muralidhar v. R.
Subbulakshmi and anr., (2025) AIR (SC) Civil 136.
8. Per contra, learned counsel for the insurance company
supports the impugned award and submits that the Tribunal has considered
the entire evidence, including the additional evidence, and has awarded
compensation under all admissible heads. It is pointed out that the
appellant's income, instead of diminishing, continued to increase after the
accident. He successfully pursued his legal profession and subsequently
served as Presiding Officer of the Debt Recovery Tribunal. Thus, according to
learned counsel, there is no evidence of actual loss of earning capacity
attributable to the disability. It is further argued that several claims relating
to transportation, attendants, professional assistance and future prosthetic
replacement are either unsupported by reliable evidence or are excessive.
9. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and examined the
record, this Court finds that the controversy is confined to the quantum of
compensation. The findings regarding negligence and liability are not under
challenge.
NEETIKA TUTEJA
Page N: 3 of total 9 Pages
2026.11.16 17:04
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document.

FAO-4847-2019
10. It is well settled that compensation under Section 168 of the
Motor Vehicles Act must be just, fair and reasonable. In R.D. Hattangadi v.
M/s Pest Control (India) Pvt. Ltd., (1995) 1 SCC 551, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court explained the distinction between pecuniary and non-pecuniary
damages. The former include actual medical expenses, loss of earnings and
other ascertainable financial losses, whereas the latter encompass pain and
suffering, loss of amenities, inconvenience, hardship and deprivation of the
ordinary pleasures of life. In Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and anr., (2011) 1
SCC 343 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court further explained that the percentage
of permanent physical disability is not necessarily the percentage of loss of
earning capacity, which must be assessed with reference to the nature of
employment and the effect of disability on the claimant's ability to earn.
11. Examining the medical evidence, it is apparent that the
appellant suffered serious injuries to his right lower limb, resulting in
repeated surgical interventions, prolonged hospitalization, infection,
deformity and eventual amputation above the knee. PW7 Dr. R.R. Saggar,
who performed the amputation, categorically established that the appellant
was admitted to Patel Hospital on 28.05.2006 and underwent above-knee
amputation on 29.05.2006. The doctor also explained the persistent non-
healing wounds, deformity and difficulties in walking, which necessitated
amputation.
12. PW8 Dr. Pritpal Singh, Medical Officer proved the disability
certificate Ex.PW8/A, assessing 80% permanent disability in relation to the
amputated limb. The medical evidence establishes the continuing
consequences of the injuries sustained in the accident. The subsequent
amputation cannot, therefore, be treated as an independent or unrelated
occurrence.
13. As regards medical expenses and the artificial limb , the
Tribunal has allowed ₹7,12,662/- towards subsequent expenditure, which
includes ₹38,848/- incurred at Patel Hospital, ₹2,83,500/- towards purchase
NEETIKA TUTEJA
Page N: 4 of total 9 Pages
2026.11.16 17:04
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document.

FAO-4847-2019
of the artificial limb, expenditure on belts and other medical requirements,
and ₹3,24,500/- towards attendant charges. These amounts have been
assessed on the basis of the documentary and oral evidence. There is no
justification for reopening the amounts already allowed merely because the
appellant has claimed substantially higher expenditure.
14. However, the claim for future replacement of the artificial limb
requires separate consideration. PW9 Dinesh Kumar, associated with United
Artificial Limb Centre, Ludhiana, has testified that the artificial limb has a
limited useful life and would require replacement. The fact that the
appellant has undergone above-knee amputation and requires a prosthesis
for mobility is not disputed. The Tribunal has allowed the cost of the
artificial limb already purchased but has not made any separate provision
for its future replacement. The absence of proof of the precise cost of a
future prosthesis does not justify complete denial of compensation under
this head. At the same time, the estimate of ₹10–12 lakh given by PW9
cannot automatically be accepted without reliable evidence regarding the
particular prosthesis required, its specifications and the likely cost of
replacement. A reasonable provision for future replacement is, therefore,
warranted, keeping in view the medical evidence and the nature of the
disability.
15. Coming to loss of income and future earning capacity , the
appellant was admittedly a practising advocate at the time of the accident.
The record shows that he subsequently continued in the legal profession
and was appointed as Presiding Officer of the Debt Recovery Tribunal in
April 2013. In his cross-examination, he acknowledged an increase in his
income over the years. The income-tax returns relied upon by the insurance
company also indicate that his professional income did not suffer any
confirmed permanent diminution attributable to the accident.
16. Undoubtedly, amputation of a lower limb results in substantial
physical disability. Nevertheless, the functional disability of an advocate
NEETIKA TUTEJA
Page N: 5 of total 9 Pages
2026.11.16 17:04
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document.

FAO-4847-2019
cannot be equated with that of a person, whose livelihood depends
predominantly upon physical labour or mobility. The appellant's professional
work principally involved intellectual and legal skills. His subsequent
professional advancement is a relevant circumstance in determining the
actual impact of the disability upon his earning capacity. In the absence of
satisfactory evidence establishing a measurable permanent loss of earning
capacity, this Court finds no justification for applying the multiplier method
merely on the basis of 80% disability of the amputated limb. The claim for
future loss of income, calculated on that percentage, is accordingly declined.
17. Similarly, although the appellant undoubtedly underwent
prolonged treatment and must have faced considerable difficulty in
attending to his professional work, loss of income during the period of
treatment must be established on a reasonable evidentiary basis. The
material produced does not establish the precise loss of professional
earnings for the entire period claimed. The Tribunal has already awarded
₹20,000/- under this head in the original award. In the absence of cogent
evidence establishing a greater actual loss, further enhancement under this
head is not warranted.
18. As regards transportation, assistance and miscellaneous
expenditure , the record establishes that the appellant underwent treatment
at different hospitals and required assistance for mobility. The Tribunal has
already allowed substantial expenditure towards attendant charges and
certain medical requirements. The appellant's additional claims concerning
engagement of an associate advocate, personal assistance, massage and
travel are not supported throughout by sufficiently reliable and independent
evidence to justify reimbursement of the entire amounts claimed. In
particular, expenditure incurred for professional assistance cannot
automatically be treated as loss directly resulting from the accident unless
its necessity and causal connection are established. Nevertheless, the
repeated hospitalization, subsequent amputation and visits to medical
NEETIKA TUTEJA
Page N: 6 of total 9 Pages
2026.11.16 17:04
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document.

FAO-4847-2019
institutions reasonably establish that transportation and incidental
expenditure must have been incurred. The appellant cannot be denied
reasonable compensation merely because every visit is not supported by a
separate receipt.
19. The claim for loss of amenities, inconvenience and hardship
stands on a different footing. The appellant suffered grievous injuries at a
comparatively young age and remained under treatment for several years.
His right leg ultimately had to be amputated above the knee. Even with the
assistance of an artificial limb, he cannot be expected to enjoy the same
degree of physical mobility, comfort and independence as before the
accident. The disability is permanent and its consequences extend
throughout his life.
20. The fact that the appellant continued his profession, secured
employment and earned a higher income does not diminish the physical and
psychological consequences of losing a limb. Professional success cannot be
treated as a substitute for the loss of ordinary amenities of life. The
appellant's inability to walk normally, restrictions on physical activities,
dependence upon a prosthesis, discomfort and inconvenience constitute
distinct non-pecuniary losses which require appropriate compensation.
21. The Tribunal has awarded an additional sum of ₹1,00,000/-
towards pain and suffering but has not separately assessed compensation
for loss of amenities and permanent inconvenience resulting from the
amputation. Pain and suffering arising from treatment and operations are
distinct from the lifelong deprivation of normal physical activities and
enjoyment of life. These heads cannot be merged so as to deny
compensation for the latter. The approach adopted by the Tribunal,
therefore, calls for interference to this limited extent.
22. At the same time, compensation under non-pecuniary heads
cannot be assessed mechanically or with mathematical precision. The
NEETIKA TUTEJA
Page N: 7 of total 9 Pages
2026.11.16 17:04
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document.

FAO-4847-2019
nature of injuries, duration of treatment, permanent consequences, age and
overall circumstances must be considered. The object is to provide
reasonable monetary recompense for the deprivation suffered, without
awarding overlapping amounts for the same injury under different
descriptions.
23. Having regard to the entire evidence, particularly the above-
knee amputation, the continued dependence upon an artificial limb and the
permanent restrictions upon mobility, this Court considers it appropriate to
award an additional sum of ₹1,50,000/- towards loss of amenities of life,
permanent inconvenience and hardship. A further sum of ₹50,000/- is
considered reasonable towards transportation and incidental expenses
incurred during prolonged treatment, over and above the amounts already
allowed. Considering the evidence regarding the limited useful life of the
prosthesis, a lump sum of ₹3,00,000/- is also awarded towards its future
replacement. These amounts are assessed conservatively, having regard to
the evidence and the necessity of avoiding duplication of compensation
already awarded.
24. Accordingly, the appellant is held entitled to the following
enhanced compensation:
Particulars Amount
 
Compensation awarded by the Tribunal ₹11,70,336

Additional transportation and incidental

₹50,000
expenses

Loss of amenities, permanent inconvenience

₹1,50,000
and hardship
 
Future replacement of artificial limb ₹3,00,000

Total reassessed compensation ₹16,70,336
 
Less: Compensation already awarded ₹11,70,336

Enhancement
₹5,00,000
NEETIKA TUTEJA
Page N: 8 of total 9 Pages
2026.11.16 17:04
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document.

FAO-4847-2019
25. Consequently, the appeal is partly allowed. The award dated
14.03.2019 passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Jalandhar, is modified to the extent that the appellant shall be entitled to
total compensation of ₹16,70,336/- instead of ₹11,70,336/-. The additional
amount of ₹2,00,000/- awarded towards transportation, loss of amenities
and hardship shall carry an interest at the rate of 7.5 % per annum from the
date of institution of the claim petition till its realization, as awarded by the
Tribunal. However, the sum of ₹3,00,000/- awarded towards future
replacement of the artificial limb shall carry interest at the rate of 6% per
annum from the date of this judgment till its realization, since it represents
provision for future expenditure.
26. The enhanced compensation, along with applicable interest,
shall be deposited by respondent No.4–insurance company before the
learned Tribunal within eight weeks from the date of receipt of a certified
copy of this order. The amount already paid or deposited shall be duly
adjusted. The remaining terms and conditions of the impugned award shall
remain unchanged.
27. The appeal stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
All pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, stand disposed
of.
(DEEPAK GUPTA)
JUDGE
16.11.2026
Neetika Tuteja
Whether speaking/reasoned? Yes
Whether reportable? Yes
Uploaded on.: 16.11.2026
NEETIKA TUTEJA
Page N: 9 of total 9 Pages
2026.11.16 17:04
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document.