National Highways Authority Of India vs The Louis Berger Group Inc. Jv With M/S. Cowi A/S

Court
Delhi High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

Judgment reserved on: 24.07.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 03.08.2026


+ O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 & I.A. 17160/2023
NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AUTHORITY OF
INDIA .....Petitioner

Through: Mr. Arun Kumar Varma, Sr.
Adv. with Mr. C. S. Chauhan &
Mr. Kunal, Advs.
Versus

THE LOUIS BERGER GROUP INC. JV WITH M/S.
COWI A/S .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Vadlamani Seshagiri, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN

J U D G M E N T

1. This petition is filed under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short „the Act‟) against the award dated
04.05.2023 of Ld. Arbitral Tribunal (for brevity „the tribunal‟).
2. The relevant facts are that the petitioner/National Highways
Authority of India (NHAI) invited bids for the construction of cable
stayed bridge across river Chambal in Kota, Rajasthan. The Louis
Berger Group Inc., a company incorporated in the USA in joint
venture with M/s COWI A/S, a Danish public limited company
(hereinafter referred as „the respondent‟) was the successful bidder
and was awarded the consultancy work for a price of INR
8,16,30,000/- and USD 24,40,590/- exclusive of escalation and service
tax. The parties executed the consultancy contract on 07.12.2006 (for
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 1 of 17

brevity „the contract‟) for the Design, Construction and Maintenance
of the bridge. The scope of services comprised four phases:
(i) Establishment of code and design, methodology to be adopted,
(ii) Proof checking of design/drawing submitted by the contractor,
(iii) Supervision of construction, and
(iv) Operation and Maintenance (for short „O&M‟)
2.1 The petitioner awarded the civil construction work to a joint
venture of M/s Hyundai Engineering Construction Co. Ltd. &
Gammon India (JV). M/s Syspra, France was appointed as the design
consultant. The respondent commenced performance of obligations on
01.01.2007. During the execution of the project in an accident that
occurred on 24.12.2009, extensive damage was caused to the partly
constructed bridge.
2.2 A Committee of Experts (for short „CoE‟) constituted by the
petitioner to inquire into the incident submitted report dated
07.08.2010. The petitioner decided to retain the respondent and the
civil contractor for completion of the project. The civil contractor vide
communication dated 07.10.2010 submitted a revised timeline for
completion of the construction by 31.10.2013 which was approved by
the petitioner.
2.3 The petitioner issued a show cause notice (for short „SCN‟)
dated 06.12.2010 for debarring the respondent and levy of penalty.
The respondent replied to the SCN on 15.01.2011. The executive
committee considered the matter under Agenda Item no.15 on
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 2 of 17

25.05.2012 and resolved:
“Item No. 15: Consultancy services for design,
construction and maintenance of a Cable Stayed
Bridge across river Chambal on Kota bypass on
NH-76 of East-West Corridor in the State of
Rajasthan Package No. CS (RJ-05): Release of
payment to the consultant M/s LBG-COW (JV) reg.
Decision: The Committee deliberated the agenda
taking into account the decision taken by NHAI to
continue the work through existing civil Contractor by
imposing maximum LD and freezing of price
escalation apropos to the recommendations of expert
committee, who has investigated the cause of collapse
of under construction bridge, and decided to extend the
Consultancy Services commensurate with civil work
subject to acceptance of following conditions by the
Consultant:
(i) The maximum amount of final consultancy cost
should not exceed the original contract value awarded
to the Consultant on the basis of actual man power
deployed at site as per contract and the Consultant
should ensure that all the key personnel proposed in
the contract are deployed at site.
(ii) The price adjustment for the extended consultancy
period should be freezed as on 02.11.2010 i.e. up to
allowable extension of time given to the civil
contractor.
(iii) Consultant should bear all the additional cost
associated with mobilization of requisite additional
technical Expert without any financial implication to
NHAI
(iv) A firm commitment/undertaking should be
obtained from the Consultant for agreement to above
conditions and in case the Consultant do not agree to
above modalities, NHAI should initiate action for
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 3 of 17

termination of consultancy contract and take action for
debarring the Consultant for appropriate period based
on show cause notice already served on the Consultant.
In case of agreement, a supplementary agreement may
be signed.”

2.4 In December, 2011 and March, 2012 the respondent sought
release of the pending payments but the petitioner insisted that the
conditions contained in the decision of the executive committee shall
bind the parties. By letter dated 31.08.2012 the respondent refused to
accept the unilateral conditions imposed by the petitioner. The draft
supplementary agreement forwarded by the petitioner was not
accepted by the respondent.
2.5 In February 2016, the petitioner released part payment for the
period up to July, 2013. The dispute of exchange rate was resolved but
the respondent continued to claim the balance amount including the
escalation component consequent to the delay in completion of the
project. The O&M period was extended up to 31.08.2023 and the
respondent continued to provide O&M services during the extended
period.
2.6 The financial implications of extension of the O&M period
furnished by the respondent were forwarded by the Project
Implementation Unit but were not approved by the Headquarters. By
letter dated 17.07.2019 the petitioner insisted that the respondent
should execute the supplementary agreement and for processing of the
claims, invoices be raised in the prescribed proforma. Pursuant to
communications dated 08.11.2019 and 11.12.2019 the respondent
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 4 of 17

submitted the invoices on 17.01.2020 in the specified format. By
communication dated 21.04.2020 the petitioner approved the
extension of the O&M period but refused to release the pending
payments till execution of the supplementary agreement. The
petitioner also raised a dispute regarding the qualifications and
experience of Sh. Sunil Bohra, the O&M expert appointed by the
respondent.
2.7 The contract between the parties provided for dispute resolution
through arbitration and the respondent invoked arbitration by issuing a
notice dated 26.01.2021 under Section 21 of the Act. The arbitral
proceedings culminated in the impugned award. The claims raised
before the tribunal and the decisions thereon of majority members of
tribunal are tabulated below:


CLAIM DECISION
CLAIM NO. 1


Allowed

Claim towards payment for the
construction period (31.07.2013 to
29.08.2017) of Rs. 5,39,38,987/- & USD
12,74,174.17 along with interest at 6%
p.a. on the local currency component &
LIBOR+1% p.a. on the foreign currency
component

CLAIM NO. 2
(Partly allowed)
USD 60,769/- & Rs.
5,16,82,887/- (after
deducting Rs.
1,07,40,310/-) along with
interest

O&M charges from 29.08.2017 till
September 2021 of Rs. 4,13,05,161/- &
USD 60,769/- along with interest
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 5 of 17

Allowed
CLAIM NO. 3
Costs of arbitration proceedings


Submissions of the Parties
3. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
tribunal erred in not deciding the issue as to whether the respondent
and the civil contractor were responsible for the incident dated
24.12.2009 wherein the partly constructed bridge collapsed. The
submission is that the fixing of responsibility was the core issue
before the tribunal and the non-adjudication thereof is fatal to the
impugned award. Reliance is placed upon the decision of Division
Bench of this court in National Highways Authority of India v. IRB
Pathankot Amritsar Toll Road Ltd., 2023:DHC:4352.
3.1 The argument is that while allowing claim no.2 towards O&M
charges, the tribunal granted relief beyond the prayer. It is canvassed
that although the award was passed on 04.05.2023, payment for
services to be rendered up to November 2023 was also granted. The
tribunal while quantifying the deduction at Rs.1,07,40,310/-, in
violation of the provisions of the Act and the principles of natural
justice relied upon the financial implications of employing Sh. Sunil
Bohra, as O&M expert. The information was received through an e-
mail from learned counsel for the respondent and was not confronted
to the petitioner. The grievance is that the petitioner was denied an
opportunity to defend the case. It is contended that despite quantifying
the financial implication of hiring an expert not possessing the
necessary qualifications and experience, no deduction was made while
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 6 of 17

quantifying the final amount awarded.
3.2 The last contention is that the claims are barred by limitation. It
is submitted that the cause of action arose on 25.05.2012 when the
executive committee imposed the conditions and froze the escalation.
Alternative argument is that even if limitation is computed from
February 2016 when part payment was made, the claim is time barred
as arbitration was invoked after five years.
4. Per contra , the scope of interference under Section 34 of the
Act in an international commercial arbitration is limited. The court
does not sit in appeal over the award and cannot re-appreciate the
evidence or substitute its view for that of the tribunal. Reliance is
placed upon the decisions of Supreme Court in Prakash Atlanta (JV)
v. National Highways Authority of India, 2026 INSC 76, Ramesh
Kumar Jain v. Bharat Aluminium Company Limited (BALCO) ,
2025 INSC 1457, Consolidated Construction Consortium Limited v.
Software Technology Parks of India, (2025) 7 SCC 757 and Parsa
Kente Collieries Limited. v. Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam
Limited, (2019) 7 SCC 236.
4.1 The submission is that the petitioner chose not to take action
pursuant to the SCN and instead continued with the respondent and
the civil contractor. The award is defended stating that the issue of
fixing responsibility for the bridge collapse was not the subject matter
of arbitration and the dispute before the tribunal was confined to the
non-release of payment for the services rendered during the extended
period. The tribunal after a detailed discussion, recorded reasons to
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 7 of 17

support the conclusion arrived at and calls for no interference.
4.2 The awarding of claim no. 2 till the end of consultancy period is
defended by contending that the respondent continued to provide
O&M services till 19.11.2023 and the amount was granted to avoid
further litigation. The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner
that the e-mail relied upon was received at the back of the petitioner is
refuted by stating that the e-mail sent to the tribunal was also marked
to the petitioner. It is further argued that the petitioner vide letter dated
25.01.2024 extended the services of Sh. Sunil Bohra for a further
period of six months. The submission is that the entire claim was not
awarded and the financial implication of Sh. Sunil Bohra was taken
into account while awarding claim no. 2.
4.3 Lastly, it is contended that the cause of action to raise dispute
arose on 21.04.2020 upon rejection of the claim by the petitioner and
the arbitration was invoked on 26.01.2021 well within limitation.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties at length. No other
contention than those noted above was pressed.
Analysis
6. Before proceeding further it would be apposite to quote the
decision of Supreme Court on the scope of interference under Section
34 of the Act in an international commercial arbitration. The relevant
paras of Ssangyong Engineering & Constructions Co. Ltd. v. NHAI,
(2019) 15 SCC 131 are reproduced below:
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 8 of 17

“ 42. Given the fact that the amended Act will now
apply, and that the “patent illegality” ground for
setting aside arbitral awards in international
commercial arbitrations will not apply, it is necessary
to advert to the grounds contained in Sections
34(2)( a )( iii ) and ( iv ) as applicable to the facts of the
present case.

43. Sections 34(2)(a)(iii) and (iv) state as under:

“34. Application for setting aside arbitral
award.—(1)
*
(2) An arbitral award may be set aside by the
court only if—
(a) the party making the application furnishes
proof that—

*
(iii) the party making the application was not
given proper notice of the appointment of an
arbitrator or of the arbitral proceedings or was
otherwise unable to present his case; or

(iv) the arbitral award deals with a dispute not
contemplated by or not falling within the terms
of the submission to arbitration, or it contains
decisions on matters beyond the scope of the
submission to arbitration:

Provided that, if the decisions on matters
submitted to arbitration can be separated from
those not so submitted, only that part of the
arbitral award which contains decisions on
matters not submitted to arbitration may be set
aside; or”

7. In view of the above, the challenge to the impugned award is to
be examined within the parameters of Section 34(2) and Section
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 9 of 17

34(2A) is not applicable.
8. The undisputed facts are that during the construction the partly
built bridge collapsed on 24.12.2009. A CoE appointed by the
petitioner submitted report dated 07.08.2010. A SCN dated
06.12.2010 was issued to the respondent which was responded on
15.01.2011. The executive committee made recommendations on
25.05.2012. The petitioner without complying with the decision of
CoE i.e. execution of a supplementary agreement or acceptance of the
conditions by the respondent, decided to continue to avail the services
of the respondent for completion of the work. Consequent to the delay
caused by the accident, the petitioner extended the time of the project
and the respondent rendered services in all the four phases of the
contract.
9. The issue of fixing responsibility for the breach would have a
fall-out if the supplementary agreement was executed between the
parties or the amended terms and conditions were accepted by the
respondent, but it is not so. The tribunal rightly held that despite
constituting the CoE, issuing the SCN and placing the agenda before
the executive committee, the proceedings were not taken to the logical
end. Neither the work awarded was terminated nor the penalty was
imposed, rather the petitioner got the work completed through the
respondent without any variation in the original terms and conditions
agreed between the parties. The contention that fixing of responsibility
was the core issue is ill-founded.
10. The reliance placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner on
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 10 of 17

NHAI v. IRB Pathankot (supra) is not applicable to the facts of this
case. In that case, the tribunal proceeded to decide the issue of
compensation and extension of the concession period without deciding
whether the material default under the concession agreement was
attributable to the concessionaire. In the present case, the issue of
fixing responsibility was not taken to its logical end by the petitioner
and as a natural consequence the tribunal proceeded to adjudicate the
claim of the respondent as per the original terms and conditions agreed
between the parties.
11. Before proceeding further it would be relevant to reproduce the
portion of the impugned award allowing the claim no.2:
“ Prayer

Claim No. 2 - for the amount of Rs. 4,13,05,161/- &
USD 60,769.00 allegedly due and payable by NHAI to
the LBGC-JV towards the O&M charges in the O&M
period from dt.29.08.2017 to dt.nill.09.2021 together
with interest at 6% per annum on local currency and
Lending Rate (LIBOR or any other rate that has
replaced LIBOR) plus 1% per annum on foreign
currency.

Award

7(xxiii) Concerning Claim No.2, the sub-issue to be
decided is whether Sh. Sunil Bohra was having the
requisite experience, qualification prescribed to be the
Head of Supervision Team pertaining to the O&M. The
correspondences dated 08.09.2020 and 03.12.2020
emanating from the claimant show that because he had
supervised the construction of the Cable Stayed Bridge
the claimant claimed that he had the requisite
experience. The requisite experience required was 'in
similar capacity' i.e. supervision of Operation &
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 11 of 17

Maintenance for at least one Cable Stayed Bridge.
Supervising Construction and supervising Operation &
Maintenance are two different things. The criteria
mentioned in the contract is supervision of O&M.
Merely because he was a part of the O&M from
31.08.2017 would not make him qualified as the
supervisor of the team. This Tribunal cannot dilute the
experience criteria mentioned. The Tribunal concurs
with the stand of the respondent that Mr. Sunil Bohra
could not be deputed as the supervisor of the O&M
Team. The financial implication emailed by Learned
Counsel for the claimant as directed by the Tribunal
vide order dated 11.04.2023 is to the effect that the
sum of INR 1,07,40,310.00 is liable to be deducted
from Claim No.2.

7(xxiv) Accordingly, the Tribunal decides issue No. 1
by awarding for Claim No. 1, INR 5,39,38,987.00 and
US$ 12,74,174.17 to the claimant and against the
respondent payable for the construction period
31.07.2013 to 29.08.2017 together with interest @ 6%
p.a. on local currency and LIBOR rate or any other rate
which may have replaced LIBOR plus 1 % p.a. on the
foreign currency payment. The Tribunal grants claim
No. 2 by awarding USD 60,769.00 till the end of the
consultancy period i.e. 19.11.2023 and INR
5,16,82,887.00 together with interest at the same rate
as for Claim No. 2. This decides issue No. 2 as well.”

12. It is evident from the perusal of the prayer and the award that
relief beyond the prayer made was granted. Even the amount for the
services yet to be rendered was awarded. The contention of the
learned counsel for the respondent that this was done only to avoid
further litigation lacks merit. Relief cannot be granted on an
apprehension and for services yet to be rendered for which no amount
was due on the date of passing of the award. The award to that extent
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 12 of 17

travels beyond the scope of submission to arbitration and falls within
the ambit of Section 34(2)(a)(iv) of the Act which reads as under:-
“ Section 34(2)(a)(iv) —the arbitral award deals with a
dispute not contemplated by or not falling within the
terms of the submission to arbitration, or it contains
decisions on matters beyond the scope of the
submission to arbitration:

Provided that, if the decisions on matters submitted to
arbitration can be separated from those not so
submitted, only that part of the arbitral award which
contains decisions on matters not submitted to
arbitration may be set aside; or”

13. The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner that the
financial implication of employing Sh. Sunil Bohra received behind
the back of the petitioner could not have been relied upon, deserves
acceptance. The tribunal vide order dated 11.04.2023 sought the
financial implication from the respondent and it was furnished to the
tribunal through e-mail. The information before being relied upon was
not confronted to the petitioner thereby denying an opportunity to
rebut or object. Section 18 of the Act reproduced below provides that
the parties shall be treated equally and each party shall be given a full
opportunity to present the case.
“ Section 18. Equal treatment of parties .—The
parties shall be treated with equality and each party
shall be given a full opportunity to present this case.”

14. With the procedure adopted by the tribunal, the petitioner was
denied an opportunity to reasonably defend the case. The Supreme
Court in Ssangyong Engineering & Constructions Co. Ltd., (supra)
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 13 of 17

held that reliance upon material obtained behind the back of a party
without affording an opportunity to rebut it, is a ground available
under Section 34(2)(a)(iii) of the Act to challenge the award. The
relevant para is reproduced below:
“52. Under the rubric of a party being otherwise unable
to present its case, the standard textbooks on the
subject have stated that where materials are taken
behind the back of the parties by the Tribunal, on
which the parties have had no opportunity to comment,
the ground under Section 34(2)(a)(iii) would be made
out.”

15. The tribunal granted relief beyond the prayer by awarding
O&M charges for the period subsequent to the date of the award, i.e.
till 19.11.2023. The relief travels beyond the scope of submission to
arbitration and is contrary to the public policy of India. The relief
granted for claim no.2 is in violation of Section 18 and is liable to be
set aside. The award is unsustainable to that extent.
16. The grievance of the petitioner that the financial implication of
Sh. Sunil Bohra though quantified by the tribunal was not deducted
while awarding the final relief cannot be gone into under Section 34 of
the Act with the limited scope of interference. It is not demonstrated
by the petitioner that while awarding the amount for claim no. 2 the
tribunal failed to give effect to the quantified amount. The court in
proceedings under Section 34 of the Act is not acting as an appellate
authority.
17. The challenge to the claim on the ground of limitation is noted
to be rejected. The grievance of the respondent was not against the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 14 of 17

decision of the executive committee dated 25.05.2012 as the
respondent declined to execute the supplementary agreement and
thereafter no action was taken by the petitioner. Though the petitioner
while extending the contract released only part payment but the
respondent continued to pursue the balance claim. It was only vide
communication dated 21.04.2020 that the petitioner finally rejected
the claim of the respondent and refused to release the remaining
amount till the execution of the supplementary agreement. The
arbitration was invoked on 26.01.2021 within one year of rejection
and the claim is well within time.
18. In an International commercial arbitration, Section 34(2A) is
not applicable but the remaining provisions of Section 34 are
applicable in the full force. The Supreme Court in Gayatri Balasamy
v. ISG Novasoft Technologies Ltd., (2025) 7 SCC 1 held that
severable portions of an award can be set aside provided that the
invalid portion is capable of being severed. The clerical,
computational and typographical errors apparent on the face of the
record can be corrected and post-award interest may be modified in
the circumstances mentioned therein. The relevant paragraphs are
quoted below:
“32. In the present controversy, the proviso to Section
34(2)(a)(iv) is particularly relevant. It states that if the
decisions on matters submitted to arbitration can be
separated from those not submitted, only that part of
the arbitral award which contains decisions on matters
non-submitted may be set aside. The proviso, therefore,
permits courts to sever the non-arbitrable portions of an
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 15 of 17

award from arbitrable ones. This serves a twofold
purpose. First, it aligns with Section 16 of the 1996
Act, which affirms the principle of kompetenz-
kompetenz , that is, the arbitrators' competence to
determine their own jurisdiction. Secondly, it enables
the Court to sever and preserve the “valid” part(s) of
27
the award while setting aside the “invalid” ones.
Indeed, before us, none of the parties have argued that
the Court is not empowered to undertake such a
segregation.
33. We hold that the power conferred under the proviso
to Section 34(2)(a)(iv) is clarificatory in nature. The
authority to sever the “invalid” portion of an arbitral
award from the “valid” portion, while remaining within
the narrow confines of Section 34, is inherent in the
Court's jurisdiction when setting aside an award.
34. To this extent, the doctrine of omne majus continet
in se minus —the greater power includes the lesser—
applies squarely. The authority to set aside an arbitral
award necessarily encompasses the power to set it
aside in part, rather than in its entirety. This
interpretation is practical and pragmatic. It would be
incongruous to hold that power to set aside would only
mean power to set aside the award in its entirety and
not in part. A contrary interpretation would not only be
inconsistent with the statutory framework but may also
result in valid determinations being unnecessarily
nullified.”
(emphasis supplied)

19. Though claim no.1 and claim no.2 arise out of the same contract
but they are not inextricably connected. The award relating to claim
no. 2 is severable. The awarding of claim no.2 for reasons already
recorded is set aside.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 16 of 17

20. The petition is partly allowed. Pending application stands
disposed of.

AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
AUGUST 3, 2026
JK
Reportable:- Yes
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AWANISH
CHANDRA MISHRA
Signing Date:03.08.2026
16:57:04
O.M.P. (COMM) 351/2023 Page 17 of 17