M/S MERCURY EXPORTS AND MANUFACTURING PVT LTD AND ANR vs SPECIAL DIRECTOR, EASTERN REGION, ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE AND ORS
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
17.11.2026
Ct. no.10
Sl. No.05
b.r.
WPA 11000 of 2026
M/s. Mercury Exports &
Manufacturing Private Limited & Anr.
Vs.
Special Director, Eastern Region,
Enforcement Directorate & Ors.
Mr. Anurag Roy
Mr. Dhirodatta Chaudhuri
…. For the petitioner
Mr. Arijit Chakraborti
Mr. Debsoumya Basak
Ms. Swati Kumari Singh
…. For the Respondent nos. 1 and 2.
1. The affidavit of service filed in Court, is taken on
record.
2. The present writ petition assails, inter alia, the
legality, validity and the sustainability of the adjudication
order dated 29.10.2025 passed by the respondent no.2,
whereby penalty to the tune of Rs. 75,00,000/- and
Rs.25,00,000/- has been imposed upon the petitioner nos. 1
and 2 respectively, for the period 2007-2009, for belated
realisation of the export proceeds.
3. The facts of the case are in brief are as follows:
i. The petitioner nos. 1 and 2 are engaged for
manufacturing exporting of leather goods/garments with
major thrust in American market.
2
ii. The petitioner no.1 exported goods, inter alia,
during the relevant period 2007-2009, but failed to
realise export proceeds from 28 export bills amounting
to Rs.14,76,78,236/- within the stipulated period. After
investigation by the Enforcement Directorate (E.D.), a
complaint was filed under Section 10 (3) of the Foreign
Export Management Act, 1999 (hereinafter referred to
FEMA Act, 1999 for the sake of brevity and convenience).
iii. Thereafter, a show cause was issued, which
was duly replied to. Thereafter, the respondent no.2
upon considering the reply of the petitioners, passed an
order of adjudication by imposing a penalty of Rs.
75,00,000/- and Rs.25,00,000/- upon the petitioner
no.1 and 2 respectively.
4. The core issue involved in the present writ petition is
whether a penalty can be imposed despite the export
proceeds having been realised and repatriated to India
beyond the period of 9 months from the date of export,
where there was reasonable cause for the delay for realising
the same at a belated stage.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
submits that both petitioner nos. 1 and 2 are 100 percent
export oriented units having only export turnover of
Rs.80,00,0000,00/-. Till 2008 there was no irregularity in
any of the accounts. All the export bills were realized in time.
However, with the onslaught of the global recession, more
particularly in the USA, the export bills could not be realised
3
in time and in 2009-2010, the accounts of the petitioner nos.
1 and 2 turned NPA in both the banks, namely, Federal
Bank and Punjab National Bank.
6. Thereafter, in the year 2023, the petitioner was able
to realize the export proceeds in respect of 32 shipping bills,
on piecemeal basis. Accordingly, the banking authorities also
issued ‘No Due Certificate’ and got the charges vacated from
Registrar of Companies.
7. It is further submitted that the adjudicating
authority, upon considering the entire facts of the case, has
given clean-chit to the petitioners, save and except for the
delay in realisation of the export proceeds. The adjudicating
officer has, however, imposed a penalty of Rs.75,00,000/-
and Rs.25,00,000/- upon the respective petitioners, which is
arbitrary, illegal, and in excess of jurisdiction and in utter
disregard of the principles of natural justice,
8. Despite such realization of the export proceeds, the
penalty imposed upon the petitioners vide order dated
29.10.2025 suffers from unreasonableness, arbitrariness
and is liable to be set aside and quashed.
9. On this score, learned counsel for the petitioner relied
upon a decision reported in 2023 SCC Online CAL 1412 , in
the case of Hooghly Mills Co. Ltd. and Others versus
Union of India and others, the relevant paragraphs nos.18
and 19, are quoted hereunder below:-
“18. In the facts of the present case, the key phrase in
Section 18(3) of the Act of 1993 is „all reasonable steps
4
to receive or recover the payment for the goods‟. In fact,
the key words are „all reasonable steps‟.
19. Section 18(3) of the Act of 1973 requires an exporter
to take steps to receive or recover the payment of the
goods. The word „steps‟ is qualified with the word
„reasonable‟. Therefore, an exporter is required to take
such steps as are fair, practicable and sensible to
receive or recover the payment for the goods exported.
The words „reasonable steps‟ are preceded by the word
„all‟. The word „all‟ in Section 18(3) of the Act of 1973 is
used as a determiner. Therefore, an exporter is required
to take all fair, practicable and sensible steps to receive
or recover the payment of the exported goods. As to
whether or not, an exporter took all reasonable steps to
receive or recover the payment for the exported goods is
a question of fact which is required to be determined in
each case. At times, mere filing of the suit and
obtaining of decree thereon without taking any further
steps may not be construed to be „all reasonable steps‟
as contemplated under Section 18(3) of the Act of 1973.
However, in a given set of facts filing of a suit and
obtaining a decree thereon may constitute all
reasonable steps within the meaning of Section 18(3) of
the Act of 1973. In a given situation, the quantum of the
balance payment may be such and the importer may be
located at a place where, further steps to enforce a
decree passed by a Civil Court in India at a place
where the importer is situated may not be cost effective.
It may not otherwise be possible to execute the decree
of a Civil Court of India in a foreign country. These
impediments must be factored in to consider as to
whether the steps taken by the exporter to receive or
recover the payment of the goods exported constitutes
„all reasonable steps‟ within the meaning of Section
18(3) of the Act of 1973 or not.”
10. Per contra , Mr. Arijit Chakraborti, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents authorities, vehemently
opposes the contention of the petitioners and submits that
the order passed by the adjudicating authority is appealable
in nature and an alternative statutory remedy is available
before the Appellate Tribunal under Section 19 of the said
FEMA Act, upon deposit of the amount of penalty levied by
the authority within a period of 45 days from the date of
receipt of a copy of the order by the aggrieved person.
5
11. It is further submitted that the order passed by the
adjudicating authority does not suffer from any infirmity
and/or illegality and has been correctly passed by imposing
penalty upon the petitioners for the enormous delay of 15 to
16 years in realising the export proceeds from the foreign
importers.
12. After hearing the rival contentions and upon perusing
the records made available on this record, including the
documents annexed to the writ petition, this court is of the
considered view that the order passed by the respondent
no.2 is an appealable order, and the writ petition cannot be
entertained when there is an efficacious alternative remedy
available to the petitioners, since the moot question involved
herein is with regard to the waiver of the penal amount
imposed by the adjudicating authority. The Appellate
Tribunal is the appropriate forum before whom the
petitioners shall ventilate their grievances for proper and
effective adjudication.
13. In view of the above, the petitioners are directed to
prefer an appeal under Section 19 of the FEMA Act, 1999
within a period of four weeks from date before the Appellate
Tribunal, and shall consider and dispose of the same within
a reasonable period of time preferably within six weeks from
the date of filing the appeal, along with a miscellaneous
application for waiver of the pre-deposit amount as
contemplated under second proviso to Section 19 sub-
section (1) of the said FEMA Act, 1999.
6
14. The Appellate Tribunal shall consider and dispose of
the waiver application within a period of two weeks from the
date of filing the appeal and if the same succeeds, shall
proceed to dispose of the appeal within a period of four
weeks thereafter, on merit, by passing a reasonable and
speaking order in accordance with law upon affording an
opportunity of hearing to the petitioners and communicate
such decision accordingly.
15. However, it is made clear that the Appellate Tribunal
shall take an independent decision in deciding the issue
involved herein without being influenced with the above
observations made herein above. The petitioner shall not
seek unnecessary adjournment before the Appellate
Tribunal.
16. In view of the above, the order dated 29.10.2025 is
hereby quashed and set aside. The delay in filing the appeal
stand condoned. The petitioners are directed to file the
appeal along with the application as directed above.
17. However, it is made clear that the entire proceeding
st
shall be peremptorily completed on or before 31 January,
2027.
18. In the light of the judgment cited above and
considering the merits of the case, this writ petition, WPA
WPA 11000 of 2026 stands disposed of without going into
the merits of the case.
7
19. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be given to the parties upon compliance of all necessary
formalities.
(Smita Das De,J.)